Oh, I didn't say he was ineffective. Just, he seems to have already decided she was in the way.
Malicious miscellaneous gossip, principally aimed at Lúthien. Lúthien and I wound up having a very sharp conversation about homosexuality. At one point I implied that I was ditching her "princess sleepover" plan to go find a girl to sleep with but I've run out of known amenables.
You can't - I am familiar with the comments being unpleasant, but you can't pick a fight over it every time, it's what all of us are told - by the gods themselves - from a very young age. Compassionate people will be compassionate about believing it's abhorrent and self-destructive behavior, but no one, not even Fëanor, seems to have, without personal inclination prompting them, thought their way right out of believing it.
I picked a fight because I was disappointed in Lúthien and angry at Galadriel, and it was the thing I could most readily complain about in the whole miserable list with a minimum of sounding confirmatory.
Loki has an eidetic memory; she recites the list verbatim.
Maedhros may have already done, but assuming more effort can be applied without canceling out...
Won't. But I would be incredibly pissed off at them if they threatened you with nukes. That is not why I let them have nukes.
Yes, I'm just pointing out that they have reasons besides his oath and the possibility that you'd do something other than fold encouraging them to avoid it.
Well, sometimes they get away with it if all I am is annoyed. People who I'm annoyed with and threaten populations I like, though, those have a terrible track record.
I am not nearly as paranoid about my cousins as I'm sure I must come off whenever we speak - it's my job to have plans for even unlikely things, if they're the sort of thing that can effectively be planned for - but if I were him and wanted to pull this off, I'd do it while you were a day into accelerated cognition, communicate his terms to no one but my father and tell my father that he'd demand an oath from anyone who was told about the threat, and then once he got his surrender and his oaths spend eight weeks designing a different story about the reconciliation.
Might work, until I gave everybody free will and the secrecy oaths snapped.