There are a lot of people in the audience! Well, a lot for here, anyway, not a lot in any objective sense-- there's Mapicc and PlanetLord and Spoke and Baconwaffles and Rekrap and Poafa and three new people, Terrain (a humanoid with a distinctly strange face) and Mr. Cube (whose head is, in fact, a multicolored cube) and Vitalasy (a cloaked being whose face is obscured but whose eyes glow, with fox ears and tail poking out from under the cloak). People are bad at staying in their seats; they run around almost constantly, no matter how much Roshambo tries to convince them to stay still in their seats for just a few minutes.
Roshambo lays out the evidence. The first piece of evidence: the formation of the cleanup crew. The second piece of evidence: the first watch, where Poafa didn't see anyone but it was still petrified the next day. The third piece of evidence: the boat, rebuilt according to the schematic, which Poafa and no one else has. (Poafa disputes this, saying that it's not actually built according to the schematic; Roshambo amends his sentence, saying that it's close.) The fourth piece of evidence: Mapicc, Roshambo, PlanetLord, and Poafa all have off-server commitments during the day on most days; at the most recent petrification, the boat was rebuilt during that time, but Poafa didn't show up to his off-server commitments. (Poafa confirms this; he was sick.) The fifth piece of evidence: Poafa setting off the skulk trap at the pig. For the sixth piece of evidence, Roshambo invites Planetlord to take the stage; Planetlord gives an account of Poafa freezing up and panicking this morning when Planetlord gave him information that made the most recent clue not make much sense. It's weaker evidence but it's still suggestive. Ditto the sixth piece of evidence, which is a comparison of Poafa's build style with the strange tentacle-like growths that extend from the petrified builds.
The seventh piece of evidence is their main one: the obsidian count discrepancy, from 358 down to 250.
Poafa wants to present counterpoints; Roshambo cedes the stage to him.
Poafa says that he can screenshare right now; it's 253 now, up by three over the past day, which isn't enough to build the boat. He's pretty sure he never claimed to have more than that? But he can't prove that. The reason he created the cleanup crew is because even before Medusa, spawn was awful--there was a giant obsidian prison! there were pigs and skulk everywhere! He can show the recordings of when he stood watch for ten hours and nothing happened. (Mapicc points out that he could just turn off the recording before petrifying things.) He has personally mined 7,000 obsidian. He mined most of the courthouse, most of the pig, most of the boat. (Roshambo points out that this is a great way, if he was Medusa, to never run out of obsidian.) He starts dropping stacks of obsidian as an illustration. He is insulted and upset that he's spent the most time out of anyone here other than maybe Drizzt on cleaning this up and everyone thinks he did it. (Vitalasy tries to drop an anvil on him, which he easily dodges.)
Roshambo says that Poafa's still the main suspect and it's time to commence the plan. All at once, Poafa's pearling away, and Roshambo and Planetlord are pearling towards him. Poafa keeps yelling that it's not him. Roshambo gets a hit on him, and then another, and another, and Poafa's dead.
Zam says Poafa's not at his spawn point. Poafa says he respawned, he moved his spawn point because he thought this might happen. He keeps saying the same thing: it's not him. He didn't do this. They're all assholes for killing him over a false accusation.
More accusations start flying. Planet thinks Poafa would've admitted to it by now if it was him, that he's not a good enough liar for this, especially since they don't know where he is anymore and he has less to gain from lying now than he did when he was about to get killed--maybe it's Vitalasy? Vitalasy claims to have 0 obsidian placed but then refuses to screenshare it or send a screenshot. Bacon thinks that's kind of sus, actually. Ro thinks the most sus is still Poafa and they should at least ban him from spawn for a while to see what happens. But if Medusa is here, or has an ally here, which is almost everyone, they could always stop while Poafa's gone to make it seem like him. Vitalasy thinks Ro is suspicious, actually. Zam wants to kill Vitalasy just in case. Mapicc initially disagrees but then says maybe they should kill Vitalasy unless he screenshares his obsidian count. Planetlord kills Vitalasy and then gives him the heart back. Ro says that this has accomplished nothing and they're back to almost square one; the evidence still points to Poafa, but his reaction seemed genuine. A new person, a polar bear named Woogie, shows up and says it was the NPPP; Zam and Bacon say it's definitely not Spoke but it could be Parrot. Planet and Vitalasy still suspect Parrot. Spoke vehemently denies everything and says that if they knew what Parrot was doing then they would know that he couldn't be involved. Roshambo says he knows what Parrot's doing and it's a good alibi but Parrot could be lying or have an accomplice. Mapicc and Roshambo say they're not going to figure it out like this; did they get anything from this? Bacon says that it's less certain to be Poafa than they thought, and Vitalasy is more suspicious than they thought. It's not much. They're approximately back to square one. Poafa asks if he can come back to spawn and they reluctantly agree, although Ro's keeping the heart until Poafa's confirmed innocent.
Planet says he has a plan but he doesn't want to announce it to everyone. He'll tell Perseus later.