I don't know if we handle grief badly because we were born to Aman and don't know how to handle it, or if it's something more fundamental. Everyone I know has been absolutely shattered. Some people die of grief. They lose someone on the ice - a child was the worst, almost no one survived losing a child - and they stopped wanting a body, their soul sort of rejects it. It's a startlingly violent death, for being entirely internally inflicted."
"Even people born in harder places have a first loss. Although if the surrounding culture doesn't know how to cope either that could make it worse."
"In a sort of general sense, yes, but I'm not sure we physically can die of grief except via refusing to eat or something like that."
"No, it's not like that, it's not voluntary. It is mediated by the mind, but not the conscious mind; one could desire to keep living but die of grief, if it gets overwhelming enough. The Valar can prevent it. As can the Enemy or all his prisoners would choose the escape of death. We probably could too, if we knew how."
"I didn't think it was voluntary. It's just not something that happens to us."
"It could be. Although since we don't do the thing where the mind directly mediates the body I'm not sure the mechanism was ever in place."
"Much. Asgard is, not quite isolationist, but definitely not cosmopolitan; there are many realms we just ignore that I can't tell you much about but they number in the thousands."
"I suspect it would amount to no good if I just flew to Valinor and attempted to talk to the Valar about how bad they are at their jobs. But it would be very satisfying, if only briefly."
"And then I would cease to exist and the half a thing of the one and a half nice things I have heard about the Valar would be downgraded to a third of a nice thing. Not worth it. They are not good enough at their jobs to get better at them in any way I can help them with."
"Fëanor has a lovely story about one of them taking his third son out to discover something he was talented at; and it seems possible that going to Mandos instead of being obliterated as a conscious being altogether is better even if he's flagrantly abusing the ability to preserve people in this way. And if they killed me they would not be being careful to obey any systematic principle opposed to annihilation; it would just be something they do most of the time, maybe, probably, badly."
"Eru's bad at their job too, but I don't think they have a clear enough location that I can even form a coherent daydream about flying over to tell them so. Anyway, the Valar wouldn't check to make sure I was one of Eru's, would they? They would see a transgression and lash out like angry toddlers without thinking about the possibility that there could be consequences they couldn't account for, or whether punishing me would accomplish anything worth the attention they'd spend to do it for my development or theirs or the cowed obedience of the bystanders!"
"They don't think like that. They don't do things because they'll have good results, they do things because those things are deserved. You're actually the only person I've ever met who doesn't talk that way. They would punish you because you had done something that warranted punishment, not because they expected it to make anything better."