native Fëanorian Amentans
+ Show First Post
Total: 6302
Posts Per Page:
Permalink

"I think credits are mostly set with consideration for the right questions and not decided by the most profitable price point - notice how they're doing a tier for poor purples now - but if the economists come out with a paper arguing we're setting them badly I can't say I'd be shocked."

Permalink

Isama glances expectantly at Kantil.

Permalink

"There probably shouldn't be red credits anymore -"

Permalink

"That one's an investment in public safety."

Permalink

"And there're the eugenicist arguments but you've said what you think of doing irreversible things because the academics say so."

Permalink

"So I have. We're eugenicist relative to Voa, I do mean to look at who seems better off in ten years as a result."

Permalink

"I talked to a Voan expat who says there's less crime when everybody has a couple kids at home to worry about, but I dunno if he had statistics."

Permalink

"People with kids definitely commit less crime but most criminals are young - four to six- and it's pretty rare to start that early these days, people want a bit more of a financial cushion."

Permalink

"Farm purples blow their savings on a kid as soon as they have it or their grandparents front them the cash," says Isama.

Permalink

"Prefer to have them young?"

Permalink

"Yep. More help around the farm, see more generations of great-grandkids."

Permalink

"Someone could probably win an election with a 'first kid free' platform, even if you raised taxes to make up the revenue deficit. Split the difference between the Voan way and ours."

Permalink

"So why hasn't anybody?" asks Isama.

Permalink

"I mean, you could probably win even more promising two kids free, and maybe even more than that promising three kids free. At some point it's irresponsible, and at any point it's very hard to reverse. And you can't do a small pilot somewhere, everyone'd move there."

Permalink

"The effects on the dating market are really something. Women just barely in my tax bracket want to date anywhere else."

Permalink

"You could do first kid cheaper. Tax credit or something that covers around half the cost of your first child credit, that's more reversible than a full switch - and definitely by all means fix the thing with the brackets where people have incentive to be poorer -"

Permalink

" - that might go somewhere, I could suggest it. Instead of brackets you could maybe scale the credit."

Permalink

"Like how?" Isama asks.

Permalink

"If two people are married and neither of them have a prior child, they get a tax credit towards their first one which comes to half the cost of a credit plus an extra thousand ni for every two thousand by which their income is below thirty thousand a year -"

Permalink

"That's a fifty percent marginal tax rate and it's not the only social program that phases out around thirty thousand a year - you get healthcare help below that line, too -"

Permalink

"I can give someone rough desiderata and get a formula out of that."

Permalink

"Yet another secret tax on people who cry when they look at forms," says Isama.

Permalink

"There can be a calculator online - how much do you earn? This is how much a credit will cost you - but yeah, 'free' plays better. It's just also irreversible and impossible to check empirically before you do it everywhere and exacerbates income inequality and so on."

Permalink

"'How much do you earn' is a messy question all by itself," insists Isama.

Permalink

"Is it? Blues complain about fronting capital gains and inflation deductions and double-counting investment income and so on but we can afford accountants, if you have one or two jobs which mail you paychecks I would expect it to be easier."

Total: 6302
Posts Per Page: