Pies is all John can see from a distance, one for each of them. They're smaller than regular pies (they couldn't eat a normal sized pie on their own, even if they were splitting one, especially not after all John has eaten already), and their tops are glossy and well-browned and... decorated? There's something on top of the pies, at least. But John can't get a clear view, at least not until the plate and dish with pie inside settle in front of him, and the house starts pouring Rosy more wine (red this time, not that it matters, he's not having any), but he isn't really paying attention to that because he's staring at the work of art in front of him.
The pie is just as glossy and well-browned as he saw from a distance, but on top is a decoration of what is clearly a the head of a deer, from the side, antlers and all, as though cut out from an impossibly detailed cookie cutter and placed on top before it was baked. But it couldn't have been just a cookie cutter, because somehow this deer head has depth, not just width. It's not as though the entire head is 3D, that would be impossible (potentially, he wouldn't have thought this possible until he saw it), but it has enough depth to convey the size and shape it's trying to convey: the antler nearer to him is slightly thicker and thus appears closer to him than the other one, the ear lifts gently to a point, the neck itself has a subtle curve to it... and all of it is done by varying the thickness of the pie crust, or... something, John has no idea how it could possibly have been done. And there are other cutouts, as well, all with their own depth: a ring of leaves around the outer edge of the pie, arranged artfully, partly overlapping the crust.
John stares. "I... I'm not sure I can bring myself to cut into this," he says. "I almost want to take a picture of it." He squints. Would that be allowed? Would it be ok? If a picture was found, would it break the veil laws? (Technically he has other important veil-law breaking pictures on his phone, but... still.) He should probably ask. "Can... could I, actually?"