kastil backstory
+ Show First Post
Total: 479
Posts Per Page:
Permalink

"I call people over unpredictably, but I don't hit everyone once a week, and I don't have Dispel Magic and I just ask if they're cultists, or have lied to my face. If the Watch can do that, then I think it'll have a moral authority it has not possessed in a long time."

Permalink

"- Why did Hulrun not do this? He had more spells than I, and it's hardly a great expense in time." You can get a hundred men through a Zone of Truth in a couple minutes, if you're fast, and it lasts for three minutes a circle for inquisitors.

Permalink

"Oh, he'd do it, and the men would desert on the spot, and then he'd hunt them down and execute them. They weren't even mostly cultists, they just knew he'd catch them for something."

Permalink

"- What fraction of those who went before his Zone of Truth were found innocent?"

Because IOMEDAE ABOVE.

Permalink

" - the paladins reliably were? And the priests."

Permalink

 

"One time he asked if I knew of anyone who had broken any laws who I hadn't reported," Stasia says, "and I know of many, because they come to me for sacred counsel, and he was very upset until Liotr talked him down."

Permalink

"Okay, the paladins were reliably fine and the priests were fine sometimes."

Permalink

UGH.

Right. He's going to explain.

The deal in Lastwall, which he would love to import if they can, is that the Watch has a short, easy to memorize, list of rules that is practical to follow, which people are supposed to memorize in training, and the Watch only keeps people willing to follow the rules. (Ettore can recite from memory the code of the police of Vellumis in Taldane from memory, but would need a brief pause to translate into Hallit.) The walls are posted on a wall publicly in the room with the Zone of Truth, and you ask them, and then each person in the Watch gets asked "did you break the rules this month," steps into the Zone of Truth, says, "no," and walks out. It takes a couple minutes out of the priest's day and one second-level spell.

That's it. That's the whole system.

Permalink

"I think that would probably work fine, if people trusted additional rules wouldn't be snuck in later and applied retroactively."

Permalink

"That would not be Lawful."

Permalink

"Right with you there."

Permalink

"I think," says Rathimus, "that there are good ways to do things like that, and in the wrong hands they end up horrendous wrecks worse for Law than the complete lack of it. And the question is whether we actually possess, in a sustained manner, the resources to do things the good way."

Permalink

There speaks an extremely sensible person someone walking out the door and not stuck dealing with this mess the voice of Neutral instead of Good.

Permalink

"How, knowing evil, can one persist in it? How, knowing good, can one refrain from it? To step off the path, even to say that one does not have the strength to walk it, is a choice that condemns Kenabres to Hulrun and Oris Chets."

Permalink

"It is, of course, also worth noting that you have breathing space, considering that nearly every cultist in the city has been stabbed over the course of the past week for failing to kill Xiao-shi. And as Kenabres transitions away from being a frontline city and towards a backline role, the frequency of active demons - and thus new cultists - will decline. Your goal is not to build a frontier city, but to rebuild the arsenal of the Crusade." Unless the Crusade fails in which case you will all die a horrible death, because by sending all her available troops off on a desperate thrust for Drezhen, Galfrey sentenced her entire kingdom to destruction should I and my brother fail.

Permalink

"I appreciate the moral support," he adds drily. (It is, of course, from people who are leaving the city behind.)

"And, Cicerone, while I do not want to dismiss your response out of hand - I do not see how this specific policy would be worse than not having it, provided I do not engage in any retroactive adjustments of the list of crimes. But since I do not understand well how Hulrun became Hulrun, there may be an error in my sight." He can simply not. You can just do the thing that wins without doing the thing where you betray people.

Permalink

"I appreciate and respect your commitment to not becoming Hulrun," says Rathimus dryly. "I do not myself understand why some people, possessed with the opportunity to change laws retroactively, are tempted to do it, but many of them are. And, frankly, you may die."

Permalink

"Still seems much better to have a decent Watch for a time, though."

Permalink

"If I die and am not raised," he will admit to not actually knowing if, should he reach Heaven or Axis, he will have the strength of will to return to this eternally-frustrating mortal life, "I devoutly hope and pray I will be replaced by an inquisitor who is not Hulrun."

Permalink

"Amen," says Irabeth tiredly. "I think you should try the Zone of Truth but actually done Lawfully, see how that goes."

Permalink

"I think that would be good," says Stasia.

Permalink

Seems like there's general consensus.

He would like a vote investing him with the formal and delegateable authority to bring the Watch under the authority of the city council, explain their plans for revised procedures (i.e. a simplified code that the Watch is supposed to enforce, Zone of Truth spells with an explicit written list of questions that will be asked, and shrinking the Watch by letting people go who are unwilling to go along with the new plan. Possibly also pay raises if it is necessary to maintain their numbers.) and release people who did nothing wrong but who the Watch has arrested anyway, until the next time the Council meets.

(There will still be more stuff they need to do, but he can use that to send a signal to Silvio to assure him that the Law has his back. Absent that, there's some worry that Silvio might accidentally break the horrible written unenforced law and commit ambiguously legitimate violence to stop ambiguously innocent people from being murdered.)

Permalink

All parties present are in favor of this except Ramien, who abstains. 

"I don't know that it's a bad idea," he says, "but I'll want to see something go well before the Inquisitor's ideas start getting my backing."

Permalink

"I see no injustice there," he says.

So, next issue: Rebuilding the city.

"The inquisition will donate all funds seized from captured cultists towards the task of reconstruction," he will say flatly, "The question is how to ensure that this money achieves the task of reconstruction, instead of being embezzled or - redirected." Other than arresting powerful people, which he is aware his ability to do is limited by his status as probably the strongest fighter in Kenabres who isn't going on crusade.

Permalink

The dollar signs that appear in Huang Jinruo's eyes are totally imaginary, she has very good Bluff.

Total: 479
Posts Per Page: