"Oh, so it's, just, like, magnetism or something," says Person4, steam evaporating. "Sorry, I've done a lot of research into the kinds of things people have attributed to 'magic'."
"Well," says N-w-d-s decisively, "given everything else about this situation that makes it unlikely you're part of some classified operation that has access to nonpublic teleportation and telekinesis tech - at least for the practical deception-penetrating purposes of this helpless little cult - I think that pretty well proves you're from another world, which goes a long way toward making you look honest and in good faith here. Asic, Pel, if y'all agree, I think y'all will be fine to lower y'all's weapons for now. We can start taking rolling shifts, me and Kwaiets" he glances at Person4 "first." Pel does lower his gun. Asic, from behind Toy-Mun, grimaces in Toy-Mun's direction.
"You said you were armed, earlier," says Asic. "Sorry, but could you show us what with?"
Table-sitter blinks. "He's . . . got a sword?"
"A what?"
"The giant double-sided knife? You know, what people used for close-range threats before guns?"
"That can't be what he meant!"
(Kwaiets mutters something about agreeing but at least knowing what a sword is.)