This post has the following content warnings:
This post's authors also have general content warnings that might apply to the current post.
Accept our Terms of Service
Our Terms of Service have recently changed! Please read and agree to the Terms of Service and the Privacy Policy
Marcus visits Blai's fort
+ Show First Post
Total: 1490
Posts Per Page:
Permalink

"Hmm, what-- actually no, back up first, can you tell me what I explained wrong the first time around?"

Permalink

"'Hurt someone' is really vague."

Permalink

"Ah. Well, I really need to figure out how to explain that one. It's... the main definition of Good, is helping people and not hurting them, or making their lives better and not worse, including in small ways that don't matter very much on their own but add up because there's a lot of them. If I just say 'without being an asshole' instead of 'without hurting people', is that going to make more sense?"

Permalink

"Maybe, if that's what you mean, but I'm not sure it is."

Permalink

"Yeah, that's the other problem, I'm not sure either. It's... close, probably? In the end I'm not going to manage to fully explain what Good is in one conversation, and will have to call something good enough, but I don't know if that one's it."

Permalink

"When you say hurting people I mostly think of things where you'd want to catch a channel if you could. Including if it's in the rules to do it even with the new handbook. When you say being an asshole I think mostly about that time Tall Oller - who isn't here any more - skipped spots Prestidigitating people so they had to make a fuss about their balls itching, out loud, to complain about him."

Permalink

"Ohh. Yeah, I mean-- some of both, but more the second thing. Hitting people when you haven't got a Good reason, like that the Lastwall rules say so. Prestidigitating people badly, or giving them cold stew not because you need to save on firewood but just because you feel like making their day a little worse. Mocking them, not in the fun way where everyone's laughing even if they're a little embarrassed, but in the way where they feel like an idiot and avoid you afterward – unless you were doing that on purpose because you want them to avoid you because they were being an asshole first, then it's fine... Demanding sex from someone when you covered their shift because they were sick and you know they don't want to but maybe they don't have any other options. Demanding all their raisins when it might make their teeth fall out, too. Cheating at cards to get all their raisins. Threatening them into doing any sort of thing they don't want, when it's not that their job is to do it and it's not that they were being an asshole first and you just want them to leave you alone."

Permalink

"I'd've thought cheating at cards was more a Chaos thing. Doing it to get the raisins is Evil but doing it to see if you can get away with it is Chaos maybe?"

Permalink

"Yeah, exactly so! And if you're cheating to get someone more raisins because you're worried their teeth are gonna fall out, that's Chaotic Good. And if you're not cheating at all, but, I don't know, goading them into playing you while they're drunk and definitely gonna lose, and taking all their raisins that way, that's still Evil but not Chaotic, right."

Permalink

"You should post a chart of the alignments in terms of card games."

Permalink

"Should I really?"  He's not sure if that's a serious suggestion or one of the other ones.

Permalink

"It wouldn't hurt. People'd talk about it because it was silly and anyone really curious could pretend to be talking about it because it's silly."

Permalink

"Huh. That does sound worth doing. How are we gonna distinguish Lawful from Neutral in card games, though..."

Permalink

"Shouldn't you know?"

Permalink

"I'm thinking about it! I'm not sure you can get a whole lot of Law in card games, they're just not a very Lawful thing to be doing... Although they do have rules..."

 

He pulls out a piece of paper, puts it against the wall and starts scribbling things. "What do you think? I'm not sure if this is all exactly right, but that should be fine if we want people to talk about it..."

 

LG: Winning all of someone's raisins at cards without doing anything underhanded and then giving them all back and telling them they should do less gambling. Giving them a bunch extra if they promise to eat half of what they get from now on so their teeth don't fall out. NG: Playing a normal card game where everyone's having fun, and making sure to stop if people are losing too many raisins or are going to be late for their shift or anything. Figuring out what games they'd enjoy more or be better at and teaching them those. Separately giving everyone some raisins at the end. CG: Cheating at cards so someone ends up with a bunch of your raisins so their teeth don't fall out. Noticing that someone's cheating and cheating them back for fun instead of calling them on it.
LN: Winning a bunch of everyone's raisins at cards without doing anything at all underhanded, if you're doing it just because you want raisins. Pointing it out whenever someone makes a mistake even if it was in your favor. Pointing it out when people are cheating. TN: Talking someone into a card game because you're bored, and playing a normal game but they're not having much fun. Not cheating but not pointing out people's mistakes either. CN: Cheating at cards just to see if you could. Making up weird card games that don't make any sense or that change the rules all the time.
LE: Noticing that someone doesn't understand one of the rules right and winning all their raisins by only telling them at the end that the thing they were trying to do doesn't work that way. Winning all of their raisins the normal way because you want to be an asshole to them specifically, especially if you could've won more raisins off more people but instead you wanted one person to lose really badly. NE: Goading someone into playing cards with you when they're drunk and will definitely lose, and taking all their raisins that way. Getting into a bunch of annoying arguments at the card table when it doesn't even get you anything. Pushing the table and spilling everyone's drinks. CE: Cheating at cards to get all of someone's raisins. Accusing people of cheating when you know they aren't. Messing up the game when it's not going your way.
Permalink

"Well, it looks a bit like Good people had better be ready to lose all their teeth or take up solitaire but perhaps that’s intentional."

Permalink

"Mm, it is Good to give people things at your own expense, if they need them more or if you just feel like it. Though it probably shouldn't be all your raisins, and it's not the only sort of thing that's Good. But it's also Good if everyone's just having fun or learning something useful and you're not losing any raisins about it – I tried to put some of those in there, but I should add a couple more, and maybe make it clearer that all the examples are separate and you don't have to be doing all the things from any given square?"

 

The first row accumulates some edits accordingly:

LG: Winning all of someone's raisins at cards without doing anything underhanded and then giving them all back and telling them they should do less gambling. Teaching them to play better so they stop losing all their raisins to other people. Giving them some extra if they promise to eat half of what they get from now on so all their teeth don't fall out. NG: Playing a normal card game where everyone's having fun, and making sure to stop if people are losing too many raisins or are going to be late for their shift or anything. Figuring out what games they'd enjoy more or be better at and teaching them those. Separately giving everyone some of your extra raisins at the end, but keeping enough that your teeth don't fall out either. CG: Cheating at cards so someone ends up with a bunch of your extra raisins so their teeth don't fall out. Noticing that someone's cheating and cheating them back for fun instead of calling them on it – you can get some of their raisins that way, just not so many that they get sick. Pretending to make mistakes just because it's funny.

 

Permalink

"Chaotic Good afterlife is the one where you get drunk and go on hikes forever but you don't have to be a bunny?"

Permalink

"That's the one!"  Grin.  "Elysium. Everyone just gets to do whatever they want, but they're all Good and maybe the plane's doing something on top of that, so it generally doesn't end up that what someone wants makes someone else miserable, it's just people having fun, together or separately."

Permalink

"And Neutral Good is bunnies, and Lawful Good is the eternal war against all our old friends, and Lawful Neutral is just a really big city, and the Boneyard is what it sounds like, and the Chaotic Neutral one is..."

Permalink

"Lawful Good also has the Summerlands, which are farming but without all the parts that suck. And probably other parts I don't know about, too – that one's Erastil's, but there's a lot of other gods, I don't even know all of them, and I'd bet a bunch of them are doing their own thing.  Neutral Good is bunnies and so on and also a lot of lawyers!  Some of whom are probably bunnies.  I'm not very clear on the Chaotic Neutral one, but I think everything just changes on you all the time so you never have an idea what's going to happen next, but, y'know, it's mostly not torture or anything."

Permalink

"Uh-huh. You should do a chart of that too. I'm a wizard and have read more books than most people."

Permalink

"I will, thank you! Maybe I should ask someone to assign me a different wall for all this, the notice board's getting rather swamped..."

Permalink

"A bit, yeah. I'm not sure we have any more cork but who knows."

Permalink

"You can't Prestidigitate things to walls or something? With the icky spiderweb stuff?"

Total: 1490
Posts Per Page: