Select,
Apologies for the lack of a proper salutation, but your name did not make it down to the Mendevian line, and I only hope my barely-existent attempt at an address was enough to identify you at all.
I've heard some rather fascinating rumors about your existence. Whatever of them is true, if you're a new Iomedean in one of the Chelish forts, you deserve a welcome from more of Her Church than I imagine you can find there. I expect you wrote Lastwall, as did I for confirmed information about you, but I hear they're endlessly busy. How is your fort doing? How are you doing, with all the changes? It must be immensely complicated. Is there anything you need that a stranger on the neighboring border might possibly be of help with?
The Goddess be with you,
Ser Marcus Aemine
"Sometimes they do a whole story that features somebody dying gorily as a plot point, and it's real. Very thrilling but they usually can't be relied on to say their lines."
"That's horrifying. ...Uh, excuse me for a minute, I should just go fix that one."
...have parties,
go to the theatre, travel, have adventures.
⤷ I've been informed Chelish theatre involves murder. I did not mean that one!
He's back pretty soon.
"I should really fix that entire answer, but probably after we've had the whole conversation, or else I'll spend half the morning running back and forth," rueful smile.
"Crossed out theatre and put a little arrow with 'I've been informed Chelish theatre involves murder. I did not mean that one!' ...Should I have added 'murder is Evil' for clarity..."
"No but you maybe should've clarified if executions are, what with how the commander did some not long ago."
"Executions are not Evil and if they were they wouldn't be in the Lastwall handbook! If he'd done something that obviously Evil in his official capacity I would've told him to do a public announcement!" He feels so, so bad at knowing what is obvious to these people. "It is Evil to make executions more painful and terrifying than they have to be, and separately more complicatedly almost always Evil to enjoy them. I probably can't fit all that in the margin without it getting too scribbly to be readable."
"I do think the blood opera was usually a double duty execution, not a murder. I guess maybe they'd buy a slave if they ran out of prisoners?"
"Still Evil to do an execution that way. Unless you found a really weird Shelynite who was into it, probably? And might not be necessarily Evil to watch, depending, but I wouldn't advise people to risk having it as their fun hobby."
"I'm imagining someone who was going to be executed anyway and wanted it to at least happen as art. If they were an actor and really liked it, probably. I don't think it's Evil to let someone pick a strange and more painful execution method if they genuinely prefer it and you're not doing it to fuck with them, although it'd be a weird enough situation that I wouldn't expect Lastwall to risk it."
"Oh! Yeah, sorry. Different things are obvious to me, but that's not really an excuse, I just need to get better at this."
"For all we know Shelynites have a spell to make it painless and so they're great at putting on showy executions!"
"Not that I've ever heard of!"
"...Anyway, what else was there... Oh, hymns, do I have any idea if Asmodean hymns are Evil? If they count as a prayer they are. Humming one isn't going to be by itself, just if it really bothers someone or pushes them back into their Evil habits or something like that, but I expect half the things people do here do that anyway so I wouldn't personally worry about it. If the melody's good someone should just make up different lyrics, really. ...But yeah, see, even songs are complicated." Sigh.
"Hmm, so obviously you can pray in your thoughts without making any sounds at all and nobody can stop you, right. So you could be praying anyway, but humming isn't going to make it prayer, you'd have to be thinking the prayer separately. And even with words I'm pretty sure you have to mean them and not just be saying them – it's not like the sound means anything to the gods, they're reading your intentions, and if you don't have any then they aren't there to read, it's just kind of hard to keep saying a thing and not mean it at least a little..."
"You have to be really definitely just thinking about lunch, but yeah! Like... if you said a prayer and had a Tian Xian repeat it and they had no idea what any of the words were, that can't count. Which means it might not count when a three-year-old says it, come to think of it..."
"You realize that this is sorta adding up to 'many Chelish people never did much evil stuff, but they had feelings, which is of course unforgivable'."
"So, that's... a good part true, honestly. To be clear, I don't think any of it's unforgivable, I think you should all go to Nirvana or Axis or somewhere, Nirvana thinks you should all go to Nirvana and Pharasma can go fuck Herself for not letting you--" There is something to this cussing concept, when you're angry and want to be very clear about it.
She gets a sigh and a faint smile back.
"I don't know if it's mostly feelings, but it is, as far as I can tell, that at least in this fort you're mostly just normal people who got screwed over by the Evil money and the having to whip each other in school and probably another dozen things like that, that did hurt someone but that I'd have trouble calling your fault."