Select,
Apologies for the lack of a proper salutation, but your name did not make it down to the Mendevian line, and I only hope my barely-existent attempt at an address was enough to identify you at all.
I've heard some rather fascinating rumors about your existence. Whatever of them is true, if you're a new Iomedean in one of the Chelish forts, you deserve a welcome from more of Her Church than I imagine you can find there. I expect you wrote Lastwall, as did I for confirmed information about you, but I hear they're endlessly busy. How is your fort doing? How are you doing, with all the changes? It must be immensely complicated. Is there anything you need that a stranger on the neighboring border might possibly be of help with?
The Goddess be with you,
Ser Marcus Aemine
"Even if you protect somebody from every other consequence of telling you they have feelings you cannot protect them from feeling dumb when they do it."
"I think eventually you may have to brave feeling dumb, to get all this figured out."
Headtilt. "Are you? That's a relief. Here I thought I might be risking myself to a bad influence."
"I take my job very seriously. Anyway, you can probably get some feelings out of people if you just acknowledge they're so bloody obvious that they'd have to be some kind of alien not to feel that way and then most people won't contradict you."
"Huh, all right."
"D'you think me going around having obvious feelings all the time is helping any, or am I too much of a strange foreigner to even count as an example?"
"Ah well. At least I'm the sort of strange where you'll talk to me even without being specifically assigned."
Soft huff of a laugh. "Yes."
"So, were any of my other note answers particularly bad? Or I can try to remember the thing I said yesterday."
"Oh good. Yesterday's thing, then. You said the Select wasn't a very helpful example of not being Evil because it mostly sounded like needing to be a completely different person, and I tried to figure out why you couldn't try to act like him even if you weren't the same inside, and said something like... That he does it by not having a personal life, and if you do want one then that doesn't tell you how to do it without hurting people?"
"That sounds like it has most of the same words in it. But today we have established that acting like him wouldn’t even do the trick if the feelings weren’t there."
"Mm, no, that's not really true. It's not quite about feelings, it's about motivation, about what you're trying to do. It doesn't actually matter, or at least not very much, if you feel sad every time you hurt someone, it just matters if you're trying not to. If you did the things he did for some bizarre Chelish reasons by complete coincidence, that wouldn't count; if you do them because you want to be Neutral, it will."
"You want to think about that one for a minute and see if you come up with a clarification like you do for most things you say?"
"Oh no, am I doing it wrong again? All right, let me try..."
No, he still can't tell what thing he left disastrously unclear this time. He can try just being clearer about everything? "It matters why you're doing things, not really what feelings you're having while you do them. You don't need to be a different person with different feelings – you can decide that you're going to act like that person, and if the reason is Good, it'll count for Good. So, if you decide you want to act like the Select because you want to be Good or at least Neutral, doing it will shift your alignment; if you're acting like him because you, I don't know, want to impersonate him for some unrelated plot, it might still shift your alignment some based on the actions, but not nearly as much. I don't know that acting like him is the thing I'd recommend, but for anything else you might do it works the same way, that it's the reason and not the feelings that matter."
"Not about most things, no. But if you're deliberately deciding to do something differently, at least that should be, and it's easier than deciding to do something and have the right feelings about it."
"Not very much. It makes a little extra difference, because if they can tell then probably you're giving them a Good example and scaring them less and so on, and those are Good too. But the main effect will be just the same."
"I think I don’t scare most people much. But it’s 'cause I’m quick and don’t have to. A stupid person is going to try this and be too stupid to cope with it and to see that coming in the first place."