Select,
Apologies for the lack of a proper salutation, but your name did not make it down to the Mendevian line, and I only hope my barely-existent attempt at an address was enough to identify you at all.
I've heard some rather fascinating rumors about your existence. Whatever of them is true, if you're a new Iomedean in one of the Chelish forts, you deserve a welcome from more of Her Church than I imagine you can find there. I expect you wrote Lastwall, as did I for confirmed information about you, but I hear they're endlessly busy. How is your fort doing? How are you doing, with all the changes? It must be immensely complicated. Is there anything you need that a stranger on the neighboring border might possibly be of help with?
The Goddess be with you,
Ser Marcus Aemine
Pensive nod.
"Yes, that's the problem with trying to figure out what the right thing to do would've been in Infernal Cheliax. In most places, if someone asks me what they should've done, I can say 'Here's the obvious Lawful Good choice, it'd probably make your life better or at least not much worse, and you could've thought of it if you had stopped to think, or possibly you knew what it was already.' In Cheliax, it's... 'Here's the obvious Good choice, which you could've maybe thought of but which would've absolutely gotten you killed, or some more complicated Good choices that might not get you killed but still very probably would, and that you would've had a hard time succeeding at and that you probably couldn't have thought of in the first place, and here are maybe some options that are less Good but might at least be reasonable to try.' The whole country was a trap."
"Very deliberately, yes. I believe I already mentioned that I am taking as an article of faith that there was something I could and should have done."
"I agree that there was. I'm just not certain how to, hmm, how to think about which things you could've done or at least attempted, when the first question is whether it would've been possible for you, as you were then, to think of them in the first place."
"I could have died in that basement or done it myself rather than be His, most obviously, but I would have expected to go to Hell. In the Eighth Act - he makes Axis. I don't think it says anywhere in the book that anyone is ever morally required to, not risk unjust Malediction, but just be damned in the normal way, just for being Evil - obligated to die in the process of doing not enough."
"It seems clear to me that people are sometimes morally obligated to die rather than be forced into some great evil, even if they're Evil themselves. It is a loss to the cause of Good for anyone to be damned, but... if someone says 'Maledict these ten people or we'll kill you', it seems obvious what the right choice is. I may be missing some theological point about whether it's required, but it's obvious that it's what you should do, nonetheless."
"But the lesson of the Eighth Act is that a choice like this can and often will in itself keep you from damnation. I don't know that it always works that way, but I do not think you would have gone to Hell."
"Well, if we're imagining you doing the morally correct thing with your earlier life, it'd be a rather bizarre and convoluted exercise to imagine you doing it for some unrelated reasons."
"Convoluted, certainly, but I do think it's worth doing, even if some parts are too hard to reason through."
"What do you mean, about not having found a conscience? I'd think not wanting to torture people would count."
A slightly disbelieving frown. "What an extremely Chelish thing to say. I feel inclined to suspect that this is just... because it's the only framing of that thought allowed an Asmodean cleric. But maybe I'm wrong."
"...there are a few acceptable reasons to dislike it?" Blai offers. "At least in an immediate contingent sense. You can say you hate the noise and this is understandable so long as you aren't of sufficient circle for a Silence or need to be able to hear what the subject says, for example."
"Right, but having a conscience surely isn't an acceptable reason, so I can imagine you convincing yourself you don't. You seem... a deeply strange person, and apparently you aren't in the habit of paying attention to half your feelings, so if you had a conscience I'm not entirely sure you would've noticed."
"Indeed. So, hmm, why do you do anything? Most people, when not driven by a conscience, just want pleasant lives, and you're clearly not doing that. Or they want to achieve some personal goal that matters to them for whatever reason, but I don't get the impression you're doing that, either."
"Knowing the general idea will suffice. Prestidigitation."
A minute later, there's a chess set, board and blacks and whites.
Blai advances a white pawn two squares.
"Why did the pawn do that?"
He stares at the Prestidigitation, but they have more important questions right now.
"... Even now, that's what it's like for you?"
"Very much so, yes." And it might be useful to talk about that, too, later, but first: "What is it that's different?"
He reads it, in case there's a detail he forgot, and looks at him searchingly. "And why does this matter?"