Select,
Apologies for the lack of a proper salutation, but your name did not make it down to the Mendevian line, and I only hope my barely-existent attempt at an address was enough to identify you at all.
I've heard some rather fascinating rumors about your existence. Whatever of them is true, if you're a new Iomedean in one of the Chelish forts, you deserve a welcome from more of Her Church than I imagine you can find there. I expect you wrote Lastwall, as did I for confirmed information about you, but I hear they're endlessly busy. How is your fort doing? How are you doing, with all the changes? It must be immensely complicated. Is there anything you need that a stranger on the neighboring border might possibly be of help with?
The Goddess be with you,
Ser Marcus Aemine
"Then I am sorry for it, again. And... I should hear what it is that they do, to make Neutral people worse, though I don't expect it to be a pleasant conversation for either of us."
"There were classes, but - most of it was oriented around weekends in the basement, with no sleep, nothing to eat, and no water until someone could make it."
"What, just-- when did that start, what was it they were trying to make you do, I assume there must have been classes about... whatever all this was trying to push you toward... Surely you cannot just torture people and get clerics out of it..."
"I missed two nights in a row once, but I think I went to sleep before noon after?..."
"And you had water, I expect. It is possible to get - very delirious, in this way. It is conducive to a sincere prayer to Asmodeus acknowledging His control over the situation and promising service for respite. Some students can get clericed without it, some people want it enough in the right way to resonate with Him before ever being subject to this practice, but I think it is not typical. Everyone in my cohort went downstairs at least once. There was some jockeying about who was expected to be closest, trying to curry favor with those people to be promised water when they managed it, and that too is part of the theologically appropriate hierarchical structure... To answer your question it did not start until we had some of the basic classes under our belts so we would know more straightforwardly than the lay Asmodean what we were driving at, because there is a fair bit of obfuscation that served for the typical member of the population but would not do for aligning a cleric."
"I did have water, and was I suppose fairly delirious anyway, just not enough to be useless for simple physical work. But it's-- obviously different, when you're choosing to do that and know you can stop, and when nobody's using it to push your mind into some unnatural shape."
"So they just... make you miserable and helpless, and make it true that Asmodeus's favor is the only thing that can make it stop... and believing that thoroughly enough is most of what you need to be the right shape for Him?"
"It serves. Of course the ones who could fit themselves to Him without such techniques were spared them."
"But it doesn't sound as if there were many. Because it's not just an Evil faith, it's one people need to be... broken in some way or another... to sincerely follow."
"What are the obfuscations, that other people believe but clerics cannot?"
"People are - were - permitted many minor heresies such as that Hell is pleasanter for the faithful, or that they'll be reunited with anyone they might have had in mind to see again. - clerics do sometimes believe the first one, only specifically for clerics, but it's not actually orthodox."
"...Ah. And so if someone was angling for seminary, they were still likely to learn it wasn't what they hoped for, and have to be forced into continuing."
"... I notice that none of this seems Evil on your part, exactly. Though I suppose it wouldn't matter if you were neutral to start with, as I'm guessing you would've been – that's still a valid cleric alignment, and they have plenty of time after to make you worse. Unless just the... social environment... was doing enough of that."
"If I were guessing here it might have been Evil to enter a situation where I would be predictably made worse rather than resist this against whatever coercions might have been brought to bear if I hadn't gone when told."
"It would've been Good to refuse, certainly, but I think only slightly Evil to just go along with it. It's usually Neutral to just go along with things. ...My point is mostly that I have yet to hear the parts where you were predictably made worse, rather than just being hurt. So I can't think about that very usefully, although I have no doubt it happened."
"But first, again, and I'm going to keep saying these things unless you wish me to stop: that was a horrible wrong done to you, and should've never happened to anyone, and you didn't deserve it. Not that I think you don't know that, but it often still helps to hear it."
"Helps people believe it, and believe that others think so. Like you said, often you can theoretically know something but still not feel, or make decisions, as if it's true."
"...And now you're going to ask me how you would be expected to act differently if you believed those things," he thinks he's starting to get the idea of how these conversations go, "and in truth I don't think you would, so maybe it doesn't matter so much, for you. You can consider it an example of how spiritual counseling is usually done."
"I was actually going to point out that whenever you say anything that you reasonably ought to know if it were the case it only makes sense to believe it."
"Well, yes. That is something of the point of me. Did it make some difference, then, that I said it?"
"Mostly it makes it salient that - you see, I would already have said that I did not particularly deserve it, if you asked, but if you bring it up then there’s probably something more to it than that fact, only I don’t know what."
"There is, to most people, but it's... a feeling, and I'm not sure how to usefully explain it. People who've gone through something awful will assume that there was something wrong with them from the start, to make it happen, and that's usually not how it works. People will think the gods wouldn't have let it happen, if they didn't deserve it somehow, and that's definitely not how it works. Or people will think that everyone else must be assuming they deserved it, even if they themselves disagree, and they will make... more informed decisions about how to interact with others... if they're told it's not true. Not that I can speak for everyone, of course, but another useful thing about me is that I can speak for many people."
"Though of course it does matter, what happened afterward. I... think we might as well keep going, but I won't blame you if you'd rather not."