Crystal's boss, Silver Rose, is currently in a meeting with an author to discuss edits to its* unpublished manuscript. She checks her phone when she gets the alert, nods to herself, and continues the meeting. This is important, but there's no need to be discourteous about it.
Once she and the author have agreed on the appropriate edits, she opens the shortlist.
She sighs. Of course Crystal has sent her too many books. This is going to be a headache.
She retires to her private office, a small, cozy space with an overstuffed armchair, a small desk, and a pile of blankets,** makes herself comfortable in the chair, puts on her headphones with some light trance music, and places her laptop on her lap.
Let's go through this shortlist more seriously and cut. Is anything obviously dubious?
#9 is noted as awkward. Cut. She wants to avoid anything potentially politically incendiary - she cuts everything with the "Controversial" tag, despite the possibility for sales. Too high a downside risk. Once the alien cultures are more seriously approached then it'll be safe to publish things like that. Let's have a look at the ones that aren't books next - two interactive fiction, three series. These ones are larger commitments. #8 from Iie*a is a series and not an obvious winner - cut. The other two, from Homerealm and Antfolk, she'll keep in contention. #2 and #11 are up for consideration now... Neither is an obvious cut candidate. Alright, let's look at the nonfiction then, since it's a bit out of their wheelhouse. She can see why Crystal recommended all of these, they're strong and unique... But the textbook on Motherbeasts from the Periverse, #15, is an animal-raising textbook, no matter the fact that it's about magic, and the number of people on Heart who willingly handle animals other than cats is very low. It probably wouldn't recoup the costs of the license. It can be cut.
Alright, let's go by genre now and look at which areas are crowded. Erotica first, that's a crowded market and anything that hopes to succeed in it will have to be top-quality.
Fully half of her list has erotica elements. Sounds about right. Let's look at this carefully.
There are two works of erotica from the Grapeverse - the S&M novel and the interactive fiction. Then there are three from Homerealm - the erotic cosplayer's autobiography, the transition literature Light Novel series, and the hard-magic political thriller. One from Planet - their interactive-fiction trading sim. Two from Hearthome - the Ecstatic devotional literature and the sex sports comedy. Lastly there's the hard-hitting abuse novel from Basilland.
On a closer examination, the two pieces of interactive fiction and the abuse novel don't really fall into the "Erotica" genre even if they have erotica elements - they're not centered on the sex, they just feature it as a natural extension of their themes. She'll set those aside for the moment and come back to them later. So in the primarily-erotica genre they have the grapeverse S&M novel, the three pieces from Homerealm, and the two pieces from Hearthome. All of these are high-quality and competitive in the modern market, but she can't have half of her alien novels be erotica - she estimates she can publish maybe ten alien pieces, a dozen if she really stretches and works hard hours. So something is going to have to go.
What here is the most obvious winner? That would be the Ecstatic devotional literature. Contact with an alien religion with common values will be a big seller. Alright, so she'll publish that one. She can afford to do one or two more in this category... The first runner-up looks like it's the erotic cosplayer's biography on the strength of its gimmick. It's also nonfiction so that gives some breadth in the space.
Competing for the third and final slot, that leaves the series of transition-literature light novels and the political thriller from Homerealm, the S&M novel from the Grapeverse, and the hilarious sex sports novel from Hearthome. The obvious losers here are the political thriller and the sex sports novel - neither is really primarily erotica. She might come back to them later on the strength of their other qualities, but they don't get an erotica slot.
That leaves the Grapeverse S&M novel and the transition literature Light Novel series. Neither of them are perfect. The S&M novel has a weird obsession with architecture, and the series is, well, a series. If she wants to go for breadth of worlds published, that argues for the S&M novel, since Homerealm already has the erotic cosplayer's biography on the stack, but if she wants to go for writing quality then that argues for the transition erotica.
Quality first. She has to publish things she can stand by one hundred percent, and the Grapeverse novel just doesn't hit that criteria for her. The Light Novel series gets a slot, and the Grapeverse S&M novel is cut.
Alright, looking at the remaining unsettleds, there's a bunch of relatively dark or serious books. Let's put them up against each other as well. We have the heartrending Iie*a poetry anthology, the dysfunctional family drama from the same world, and then two books from Basilland - the villain-protagonist morality play and the realistic abuse story.
It's pretty clear that the poetry anthology has to be published, practically as a moral duty for her. It'll sell, and if it doesn't it's still worth having tried. It'll probably win awards. Overall it'll be excellent for her company's reputation.
#7, the alien family drama from Iie*a, and #24, the realistic abuse drama from Basilland, are clearly up against each other - they're so similar in themes that it'd be silly to publish them both at the same time. She would say that the realistic abuse drama wins, here. #7 is cut, and the abuse novel... goes back on the pile to consider. It might be a little controversial. But it says something very important...
She sighs, and looks at the two remaining books in the category. The villain protagonist book is morally complex as well and quite thought-provoking; it can stay for now, but it's not an obvious publish. Same to the disability-handling antfolk series. ... Actually, she's already committed to publishing one series, so that's a slight strike against the antfolk series. But it's not quite fatal. She'll come back to it.
Let's look at the books she hasn't touched yet and see if there are any clear winners. There are six left. Olam-uncontacted-biography, Planet-Terraforming-Adventures, Planet-Vocational-Literature, Periverse-Children's-Book, Periverse-Prism, Piecemeal-Mystery-Cult-Coming-Of-Age. The uncontacted-biography is a clear winner; it gets moved to the publish list. So does the Periverse Prism - it's just such a strong look at an unexpected confluence with an alien culture.
The remainder get sorted in with the leftover books from earlier. There are nine candidates left and four-to-six slots remaining. She needs to cut at least three.
Looking at the tags on her books to publish, it seems like she already has two fantasy novels. That's a strike against anything remaining that's fantasy - the Periverse children's literature, the Planet trading video game, and the Antfolk series. The antfolk series already has a strike against it because she's already publishing a series, so it falls off the bottom.
There are three works under consideration from Planet - two pieces of devotional literature, and the trading video game. She wants to publish a diverse set of books, so let's only keep one of those three. The book about transportation and the video game are clearly weaker than the terraforming novel at this stage - they're both cut. She'll publish the terraforming novel as representational of the world. Similarly, Basilland has two pieces; the abuse novel is clearly stronger than the villain-protagonist one, so it wins and the villain-protagonist one is cut.
There are three works remaining under consideration - the Grapeverse interactive fiction, the Piecemeal Mystery-Cult novel, and the Periverse children's mystery. Ideally she should only negotiate for two. The Periverse already has a work on her publishing list, so that cuts the children's mystery (which is also fantasy anyway.)
Her final list for negotiation looks like this:
2. Grapeverse [Interactive Fiction, Branching Storyline, Erotica, Choose Your Morality, Relationship-Building]
Small-scale interactive fiction where you befriend or abuse a magical statue. Optional sex scenes. Very sweet and realistically portrayed.
3. Homerealm [Nonfiction, Autobiography, Strong Gimmick (Video Game Walkthrough), Cosplay, Alien Culture, Erotica]
Autobiography of an erotic cosplayer, styled as a video game strategy guide. Exceedingly clever; features both visual and written erotica. Hot.
4. Homerealm [Light Novel, Series, Science Fantasy, Erotica, Transition Literature]
Genius biohackers work for the flowering of all trans women into beautiful, free, sexual beings. Heavy on erotica; each LN is readable in a single sitting.
6. Iie*a [Poetry, Anthology, Autobiography, Tragedy, Value of Life, Shirasanmi]
Poetic autobiography of an alien child with a terminal disease. Unpolished, but heartrendingly sad.
10. Planet [Hard Science Fiction, Character Drama, Strong Characters, Vocational Literature, Terraforming]
Terraforming team has slice-of-life adventures developing an ecosystem. Heavy on scientific detail. Likely to sell well in Eravia.
13. Hearthome [Devotional Literature, Alien Religion, Erotica, Ecstatic]
Alien devotional literature that's clearly from an ecstatic sect. Consists of a series of dialogues with a (implied) Great Reflection.
18. Periverse [Prism, Fantasy, Alien Aliens, Alien Culture, Not Devotional]
Several alternate-universe versions of the same people come into conflict over magic. Alien genre of personality-examination literature eerily imitates Heart devotional art.
19. Piecemeal [Historical Fiction, Alien Culture, Alien Religion, Mystery Cult, Coming-of-Age]
Teenager is inducted into a mystery cult that changes his life for the better. Features strong alien culture; will need cultural notes.
21. Olam [Nonfiction, Memoir, Alien Culture, Culture Clash]
Woman raised in an uncontacted tribe records her introduction to Hadarite culture. Strong, unique perspective on an alien culture.
24. Basiland [Relationship Drama, Realistic Abuse, Dark, Happy Ending, Soft Science Fiction, Dark Erotica]
Woman is abused by her girlfriend, gradually comes to realize she's being mistreated and moves out. Dubiously consensual erotica scenes, but very realistic in its handling.
She checks over her list, decides she agrees with her own decisions, and goes to start making phone calls.
*It's nonbinary.
**Having office blankets is just standard, on Heart.