Matirin does not want to go tell Alloran that he is going to argue that the Andalites should not execute Mhalir, but he is pretty sure that he ought to do it. He thinks about it intermittently over the next few days; it feels like there ought to be a framing that would go over - not well, but tolerably, that won't inspire Alloran to try to kill him on the spot at least. It's much less fun than spending time with Leareth but - he's talked Leareth into coming to his homeworld with him, he'll have plenty of time for that.
He goes over to see Alloran a week later. Alloran is playing with the foals in the Companion's Field. He looks much better. This almost makes him want to change his mind about not executing Mhalir even though that's very stupid.
They exchange pleasantries.
<I want to go home and do some politics> he says, eventually.
<I am not surprised> Alloran says neutrally.
<Cayaldwin is close to figuring out a version of morph that permits demorphing into a nearby anchor, and that doesn't have a nothlit risk. At that point morph becomes a one-step cure to aging and most illness and disability. I think we ought to share it on Earth.>
<It went so well last time.>
<If Seerow had shared morph it would have gone well, actually! I don't think we should give the humans starships and I think it was stupid of Seerow to give the Yeerks that. We should have kept them contained to the one planet and pointed our technological innovations at making that more palatable. We have lost a great deal because Seerow empowered the ones who wanted to enslave everybody.>
<Which is all of them. Some of them required some brief soothing in very vague terms about how once the universe had ceased to resist they could cease to enslave people.>
<I know. I think we have more resources now, to retaliate if humans try something similar. We don't have to give them Gifts. And when our own warriors are all routinely trained with Gifts no enemy can stand against us.>
<Maybe.>
<Visser Three has been helping Cayaldwin with the research. I know what you will tell me about this.>
Tail-lash. <I don't know what his aim is but you are foolish to trust him at all and Cayaldwin is - behaving much like a traitor to our people.>
<Don't say that again.>
<I spoke carefully> Alloran says, watching him.
<I think I do know what Visser Three wants. He hopes to, by saving hundreds of millions of lives on Earth and elsewhere through new discoveries, persuade Andalites that Yeerks can be valuable. And he hopes that we'll spare him, in the trials that are commencing soon.>
<That will never happen.>
<Nothing he does now can make right what he did during the war. And it does not change that he is the kind of person who did it.>
<If you have encouraged him in the impression that you will spare him ->
<I am not sure whether I have or not. I certainly have not tried to, but I am conflicted, and I imagine he has sensed that.>
<There are few arenas in which I would question your judgment> Alloran says stiffly.
But this is, obviously, one of them. <I hate him> Matirin says. He's not sure whether it's true. <If I could kill him twenty years ago I would gladly give my life for that. If I could kill him six months ago, though, I would not do that. It would have been uglier, without his aid.>
<Now it is over and you can kill him.>
<Now it is over and I could kill him, or wait until he's invented a very nearly perfect generalizable cure for deaths by illness and aging and kill him then, and I think the second one is better than the first one, in a way that implies I shouldn't do the first.>
<Can Cayaldwin not do it without him?>
<I don't know. It would take him longer. Mhalir had sunk several decades into research along similar lines.>
<Using my head.>
<Yes.>
<He is stupid, on his own.>
<I know.>
<The only part of him that isn't stolen is the desire to enslave and torture people.>
<I do not, actually, think that's true. He had convinced himself that the only way to save his people was to destroy ours. It was a lie, and it speaks poorly of him that he convinced himself of it, but I think he would not be working on morph adjustments if he only wished to enslave people. And I think he would not have surrendered. He could still have gotten himself off the planet, with what he learned from Leareth, and reverse-engineered the adjustment that permitted morphing Gifts, and then had both Gifts and Leareth's knowledge of how to use them.>
Tail-lash.
<It is beside the point anyway. If it serves our people for him to die, then he should die, no matter how friendly he is; his actions certainly warrant it and we should decide at this point for us, not for him.>
<I am glad we agree on that.>
<That said it is not obvious to me that it serves us to kill him. I think it probably doesn't. He keeps his people in check. His inventions are useful. Leareth wants him alive. I think it is likely that I will argue that his sentence should be commuted. That he should be a nothlit in some other form, maybe.>
<No.>
<I think that you deserve better.>
<I don't - know quite what to say to that.>
<I am going to do what I judge best but I think - it will be very unfair to you, if I judge it best for the world to go on having him in it. I think you deserve better. I am sorry, that I am doing you this harm.>
<It is not, in fact, best for the world to go on having him in it.>
<If it were, would you care?>
<It - couldn't be best for a world at peace to go on having something like him in it. If there were a specific emergency with a defined duration - but we haven't won, if he still exists.>
Matirin shakes his tail ambivalently.
<If it were him who'd killed your father, your brothers ->
<I killed one of my brothers> Matirin says. <I am planning to go on living, about it.>
They look at each other for a long time. Then Alloran turns and trots away.
<It went about as well as I could have expected> Matirin says to Leareth when he gets back.