And Rúmil goes to meet his alt. Writes a letter in advance, actually, sets a time.
"Hello," he says when the other Rúmil opens the door. "I think it might be a good idea to just start by telling the whole story? This was in 1179, I don't know how much the timelines had diverged by that point but Miriel was dying, Finwë was a mess, and Fëanáro was racing around being miserable, and that's when Bella dropped on us."
And he tells everything from that point forward. "So," he concludes, "if it were me I'd be curious what tampering the Enemy had done. If you're similarly curious I can vouch for Bella's trustworthiness. That's the whole of it, really."
"Around here people don't trust the dimension-jumpers much. The Enemy'd stopped hurting people, you know."
"Yeah, it sounds like they've been in lots of high stakes situations and made varyingly bad decisions. I'm not speaking to the trustworthiness of the dimension-jumpers in general. Bella I vouch for."
"You like her?"
"She's going to do a lovely job ruling this planet we've patched together."
"And so you jumped ships? How'd Finwë feel about that?"
"I am looking after his son. That is the most important thing I can do for him."
"I am curious what tampering the Enemy did, but I do not like or trust the dimension-jumpers. It's like the Valar all over, you know, coming in and seeing people who in their eyes should be different people, immediately punishing and tampering and getting terribly offended and making decisions in a blind panic."
"...I can see how they'd have left that impression, yeah."
"And then wanting us to act all friendly and grateful and corrected and cooperative -"
"It does seem like it might have been better if someone else'd made contact, someone who was less personally invested in the King's character."
"The King's excellent at his job. If I'd been crafted to make Arda worse I would have expected he'd be less so, instead of being equally competent but only instrumentally good. It's hurting our world now, of course, but it didn't hurt us until interdimensional contact happened and the Enemy couldn't have anticipated that."
"Maybe the Enemy likes evil to exist separately from wanting his opponents to be incompetent."
"Maybe."
"Do you talk to the King?"
"Of course."
"Of course," he murmurs. "Did he ask you to talk to me?"
"I asked him about it. He said that if one acted like it was a Vala, only with different preferences about how to perform deference, it was perfectly safe to be around you."
"What a ringing endorsement. He might be biased, you know -"
"Yes, he is. At first he thought they'd deliberately calculated how best to torture him without losing face, but I talked him around because I did not think that was a very reasonable read on them."
"Torture him?"
"Show up, demonstrate astonishing capacity for meddling with people on every level including with their very souls, 'accidentally' use this to set the Enemy loose again - do you have any idea what it was like to learn he was free - announce that the King is fundamentally an error and Should Not Be, kidnap his consort, give him ten years to make sure the world doesn't fall apart when they execute him - they left and he swore not to be too terrified to be functional and then set to dismantling our people, because what else do you do when gods decide you shouldn't exist and give you the courtesy of a few years to offer yourselves up with some semblance of dignity?"
"His consort, did you know -"
"I knew."
He shakes his head. "I do not think they're planning to kill him."
"Just keep the threat close to hand?"
"I imagine they do not conduct themselves like this towards people who aren't horrifyingly evil."
"Most of the thousands of years of mistreatment we have endured has been in the name of making us not evil and therefore deserving of not being mistreated."
"Have the interdimensional visitors actually mistreated you, aside from being appalled at the King?"
"And setting the Enemy free -"
"That was an accident - they probably didn't even set him free, just prompt him to leave - and they're looking for him, it's how they found us -"
"Forgive us for not taking your word for it."
"Are there other respects in which they have mistreated you."
"I don't know, because I don't know what they could have done for our world if they considered us worthy of it, or what this 'untampering' entails, but you can imagine we are reluctant to try it!"
"My understanding is that they are doing everything they can which doesn't make you more dangerous."
"Teaching people to read makes them more dangerous."
"They are also doing some things that make you more dangerous, just not all such things." A long pause. "...do you mind if I share this conversation with Bella?"
"Go ahead."
"Let me know if you end up getting curious about the tampering."
"Can you teach me magic?"
"No. I'm sorry."
"The teleport - no one could ever hurt you again -"
"I might be able to get you a suicide trigger if you want, I can ask."
"Will it help if I beg ."
"No, no, that - that's not the point -"
"With the other jumpers I could at least tell myself they did not understand what they were denying me, what they were denying everyone who'd been in the Enemy's hands -"
"I understand. And magic is too powerful and too flexible and you have been so edited by the Enemy you are a completely different person."
"So if I assent to yet another round of correction, from your Bella -"
"If you were you, no Enemy tampering, of course I'd teach you magic. But she wouldn't want you to feel coerced."
"Then I think you may have boxed yourself in a little. Of course I feel coerced."
"I understand."
And he goes home.