A practitioner and Elves in Arda
+ Show First Post
Total: 2130
Posts Per Page:
Permalink

Sigh.

 

Tempted to take him up on the offer to let us read his mind.

Permalink

There's nothing–  currently urgent, is there? That bad?

Permalink

There's a war!

Permalink

I mean anything they know that we need to that'd be worth the extreme. The war is there either way.

If it even worked. He could swear he's not hiding any thoughts and get away with having sworn not to think about something, or similar.

Permalink

That's straightforward to work around. I don't know if there's anything we need to coordinate on that desperately, the transaction friction seems costly but I am only seeing half of it, I don't know if they'd tell us everything we need to know, I don't know how much better off we'd be if we could work with them on the name-calling and the karma plan...

Permalink

Me neither. First one would be a function of how many practitioners they have and the second is less predictable.

Maybe if we absolutely had to coordinate something. Absent that, I've been trying to stay away from magic like this and using it when there seems to be a good reason is– not that.

Permalink

Hmm?

Permalink

When it goes wrong it can go very wrong. She debates sending a memory and doesn't. This is read-only, at least, but unrestricted access to someone's brain is really extreme.

There can always be some emergency big enough, but right now it's more like convenience.

Permalink

I'm not sure it is. We're not telling them about major, important operations, they're not telling us, they'd apparently speculated that the Enemy might take the continent down with him and not shared that...

Permalink

They shared it once destroying Angband was on the table. The rest I'll agree.

Permalink

And if we'd seen an opening to destroy Angband and there wasn't time to run it by them -

Permalink

They were probably relying on their spying to know if we had anything that could do it given a chance. Not exactly reassuring.

Permalink

No, it really isn't.  Sigh. 

Permalink

No. 


We can at least wait until there's something more concrete depending on it.

Permalink

Yes.

Permalink

For now we can at least scale up what we're doing. I'm worried it might take armies of full-time practitioners.

Permalink

Well, we can get up to ten thousand pretty easily, past there will be a challenge.

Permalink

Ten– easily? Wow.

And we've already got enough to irritate him; maybe this isn't that much of a problem.

Permalink

Not easily, but 'within a year and without anyone going hungry', yes.

Permalink

Oh. Well, a Year is still pretty fast for shifting ten percent of the population.

Permalink

We are here to fight a war; the means might be unconventional but we were expecting to be diverting lots of resources to the cause of war-fighting.

Permalink

I do keep forgetting to think of it as an army as much as a country. That makes this less surprising.

Permalink

Do you want to ask about a library, if it is going to be a year?

Permalink

 

 

Yes. There is a high enough chance a randomly chosen Vala will do it, right?

Permalink

A high enough chance to be worth petitioning them? Normally I'd say 'yes, definitely worth the try' but with the Doom I am less certain.

Total: 2130
Posts Per Page: