"We don't have to live in the same city as them?" Kib says. "Keeping it hush-hush is directly correlated with their ability to get divine favors and political whatnots - and also the whole breeding thing means they have these complicated social structures around that and those structures would go haywire with the information and this would also be bad."
"I will take keeping it secret very seriously. But I would have trouble - not putting the pieces together, as it were. I do however do inscrutable well, I'm told. Just not directly lying."
"I haven't had to directly lie to anybody," Kib says, "people don't ask, not unless they already know way too much. Inscrutable should be fine, especially if you are better than I am at restraining the impulse to sarcasm. The redhead is Maitimo, other one's Findekáno. They are both important in Valinor for breeding-related-social-structure reasons and Maitimo in particular also for reasons of overwhelming talent."
"What sort of, breeding related social structures are there? I'm - having trouble picturing them."
"Well, mercifully, unlike animals they only reproduce on purpose. So that's a significant thing, deciding to create a person, and it also comes with responsibility for the new person's upbringing - also it is I think invariably married couples co-creating children because Elves do marriage weirdly - anyway, they have strong slightly confusing social ties between parents and children, and co-children of the same parents, and to difficult-to-track extents with anybody else you can draw a line to on a map of marriages and child-creatings? They're important because they are both the children of different children of the king. It's weird."
"I'm getting sort of used to it? But yeah it's complicated as all get out."
"Wonderful. Well. I suppose whether or not I get the chance to get used to it depends on what we decide to do. It sounds like Maitimo and Findekáno should be involved in this conversation? Unless you'd rather they weren't, or...?"
"We can invite them in. Even odds they've actually been able to hear this entire exchange actually, Elves have really good hearing surpassed only by their stupidly good vision. Iiii should have told you that earlier, sorry." Kib goes to lean out the door and motion Elves in.
"No, it's fine, I'm sure I would have remembered to mention it if anything really sensitive came up. So, Aydanci, this is Maitimo, that's Findekáno, and, uh, this is Aydanci."
"A pleasure to meet you both, as well." And now he does not know what to say! 'You have good taste in at least one boyfriend'? There is no way he could possibly say that, ever.
Kib waves everybody in. And plops on a sofa. First, so it's everybody else's job to decide who sits next to him.
To the elves: "... So. What are your thoughts on -" Handwave. "Everything?"
The Elves look at each other. "There are a lot of cultural differences between our peoples," Maitimo says after a while, "but among Elves marriage is - it takes precedence over everything. And if Kib didn't want that I'd be inclined to ignore it but Kib is obviously hoping you'll embrace him as your long lost love and spend the next several days doing nothing but kissing him and telling him how perfect he is, so it seems like we should enable that, and later compose sad songs that we cannot sing in public- that's the general Elf fallback -"
"I am quite happy to embrace Kib as my long lost love after some adjustment," he says, with kissing and compliments both, "but I'm - unfortunately quite familiar with having someone I love torn from me out of nowhere. If perhaps under very different circumstances. I don't particularly want to inflict it on the - both? was my understanding? - of you for no other crime than having good taste. The world's cruel enough without adding to it because it's tidier."
"I, yes? That sounds lovely? None of that 'compromising on stuff because reasons' unpleasantness, marvelous."
"Well, that was remarkably easy. I feel accomplished."
"I guess? Uh, how likely do you think it is the Valar will go 'okay they can be married one of them was a girl at the time'?"