Next Post »
« Previous Post
+ Show First Post
Total: 2874
Posts Per Page:
Permalink

"Turn every space that your magic can reach into Valinor, but with improvements?"

Permalink

"Why not?"

Permalink

"Some of the Eldar didn't agree to come here. I'm not sure how they'd feel if we went and spruced up their homeland. I know even less about the peoples of distant lands. I am sure there are some who'd want to first ask Eru's counsel, too, though -" he waves a hand - "we might not be interpreting Eru correctly, if I do say so myself."

Permalink

"Well, Valinor in a general sense, not necessarily in any specific aesthetic or politics or layout or anything. If there's somebody who objects to arbitrary plants being edible or the eventual availability of launderers or not having to keep everybody you know within arm's reach all the time lest something eat them I'd love to hear their arguments."

Permalink

He laughs again. As Maiar go he's quite good at it. "You'll hear no arguments for that at this table."

Permalink

"Didn't think so!"

Permalink

"CanI send you research notes occasionally? I would like to work on figuring out whether your magic has access to some kind of interpreter that allows it to do the same things we're doing with much less precise control, and if the answer is that it does, and we know the fundamental results that we're trying to achieve, your project would be one of understanding the function of the interpreter and possibly how it was created. I do not particularly expect this to work, but I think it's worth examining."

Permalink

"Um, I'll look at the notes, sure, although based on that description I'm not particularly optimistic..."

Permalink

"It'd be odd for a magical system to run in this world which we don't know anything about. It really ought to be somehow a derivation of principles we do know, though I'm not sure this is particularly how."

Permalink

"Would it be less weird if I were the only person who could cast spells?"

Permalink

"Yes. Then I'd assume you were tapping somehow on the way the rules worked on your home plane."

Permalink

"...Maybe everybody is. Which would be a heck of an exploit, since in my home plane science isn't allowed and we've been doing a lot of science to magic."

Permalink

"It seems odd that whatever prohibits science wouldn't still apply, if the magic is somehow drawing from your universe. But I don't think I really understand how science can be disallowed in the first place."

Permalink

"My universe has a lot of power structures that don't form a sensible hierarchy with each other. 'The universe' is what we call the thing that prohibits science, and it does it by, well, being the universe - it can make science unrewarding at best and counterproductive or lethal at worst. Here, it's not the universe and doesn't have being the universe privileges; but wizardry might run on something else that doesn't answer directly to the universe, at least outside its jurisdiction."

Permalink

"If we're able to draw on the magic of your world, I wonder what that does to the fated history of ours."

Permalink


"Fated history?"
Permalink

"When we were tasked with making Arda we saw a vision of what it was and would be. A vision of tremendous detail, down to the contents of books that will not be written for many Ages. You didn't feature in the vision, and your world's magic certainly didn't." He smiles. "It's very exciting."

Permalink

"Oh. Huh. So what was going to happen?"

Permalink

"We are eventually going to pardon Melkor, in exchange for his aid on a task no other could attempt, and the immediate aftermath of that attempt is unknown to us because mercy and a second chance cannot be granted with full knowledge. Many Years after that new lights will rise above Arda and new races will be born to it, and they will war, but through tragedy and horror some of the Elves will meet them and aid them, as will I, and eventually they will multiply and fill the whole world save Valinor, and have great and terrible kings and build great and terrible things."

Permalink


"I have mixed feelings about this fated history."
Permalink

"Me too," he says.

Permalink

"So how long have I got to fix it?"

Permalink

"Melkor's pardon is inevitable unless you happen to find the means to break oaths; the problem that only he can fix is that there are people sworn to him who have orders right now to do harm, and he can resolve it by telling them they are free to go live their lives, and we must attempt to aid them. Melkor's pardon may be for the good anyway; we can pledge ourselves to better courses. The arrival of Men is not for three hundred Years. That seems enough time for you to be quite a disruptive force."

Permalink

"Cool."

Permalink

"How do you want the history of Arda to go?"

Total: 2874
Posts Per Page: