« Back
Generated:
Post last updated:
impelling one toward right action
Sheridan transported to the world with a conscience problem
Permalink Mark Unread

Sheridan would consider herself fairly well acquainted with the house she's in. If it had secret passages or the like she'd not found, this wouldn't particularly surprise her, but not needing to risk a beating to walk around means a few days is more than sufficient to establish knowledge of the overt areas.

It does not, of course, require being acquainted with a house to know that purple-blue-black apparently-not-especially-amenable-to-vision whirlpool-like things are not generally present above the kitchen table. 

This one is there when she turns around. It proceeds to swallow her.

 

The place she sees around her when she is no longer swallowed is not one she is acquainted with in the least.

Permalink Mark Unread

And now she's sharing a tiny apartment with a very startled person. The walls are white, one wall has a tall narrow window, if she looks behind herself she'll see that the only door latches from the inside. The whole room is four feet by four feet, made even smaller by the railing along one wall that might be for someone to hold onto for balance. There's a pile of necklaces in one corner and a quilt on the floor. The room's other occupant, when they get over their shock, leaps to their feet glaring murderously and says something very angry in a tonal language.

Permalink Mark Unread

No citizen's card (not odd - plenty of people who didn't have estates didn't wear them at home); the carriage and way-of-speaking doesn't give her a clear indication of stratum. What is he wearing and the like?

She's still in her slave collar, because that's the law and they're risking quite sufficient trouble already; doesn't drop her cover body language when she's in public areas. Gofer-type uniform rather than domestic. Convenient, at the moment.

Something incredibly bizarre and fascinating just occurred and she would of course like nothing better than to attempt to gather more about it, but handling acute problems has the precedence. 

She does not look behind herself. She looks demurely down.

"My apologies, sir."

(Details on the necklace and quilt? Can she see out the window?)

Permalink Mark Unread

The necklaces in the pile are strings of metal beads that seem to be painted, except that the colors change constantly. Several of the beads are the same color or pattern at any given time. Out the window is a five-storey building painted in some kind of abstract foresty design in green and brown. Here and there are balconies whose railings are being used as trellises for grapes and other vines. The person who lives here is wearing loose calf-length pants and a loose sleeveless shirt. No shoes, though there's a pair by the door, but socks.

The apologetic tone seems to mean something to them, because they don't shout any more. They echo the words carefully as if they've never heard them before. Hesitantly they try a question in another language.

Permalink Mark Unread

That is a desirable outcome.

Her brain process does not produce any information or associations on color-changing beads, this architecture style, this clothing style, or either language. Hair style? Scars, calluses, fingernail style, signs of anything on their clothes or skin, and such like? Details of the quilt?

She can further attempt the several languages she is fluent in and then the several more she knows some amount of.

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda's hair is in a ponytail. Nails short, hands not callused at all, clothes apparently undyed. The quilt is made of rejected, streakily dyed dull yellow wool. Or maybe it's just carefully, artfully designed to look like that. The squares and the stitching are vaguely irregular like it's handmade. Sloppily handmade.

Hearing more unfamiliar languages makes Valanda very happy for some reason. He turns around and reaches under the pile of necklaces for a charcoal pencil and a notebook. He opens it to a clean page, draws something that might be a map of an island or continent, then looks at her expectantly.

Permalink Mark Unread

Neat ponytail, messy ponytail? Can she see what it's tied up with? Dirt under nails? Details of the stitching?

Details of the pencil and notebook? Anything else that indicates something else lying under it?

She also looks at the island/continent.

Permalink Mark Unread

Dirty hands, but clean nails. He might be an artist who blends sketches with his fingers. The ponytail may have suffered a little in the last few hours, seems to be tied with string. The quilt is lumpy like it might be hiding things. The stitching was not done with a sewing machine and on closer inspection the thread seems not to have been dyed. The pencil is less a precisely-manufactured art supply and more like a stick of charcoal partly wrapped up to keep it from marking everything. The notebook has a metal spiral binding and the pages aren't white paper. The pages he flipped through on his way to this one were used very efficiently like he was trying to cram as much stuff into as little space as possible.

The continent is almost U-shaped but sort of squarish and thick-bottomed and has an extra bite taken out of it. There's a mountain range. It's not drawn with any great degree of artistry. The smoothness of the coastlines suggests it may have been drawn from a vague memory. The longer the stranger looks at the map, the more pleased Valanda seems about something.

Permalink Mark Unread

Available data continues to not produce many larger associations. The dirt on hands seems to be from the charcoal or the like?

Anything she can tell about what the items under the quilt might be? Anything she can see from the pages given the time she had to see them?

Pleasedness is generally better than not, though it is considerably better if she knows what exactly it is responding to than not.

That is not evoking any islands or continents she recognizes. None of the languages got responses; she shrugs at the map and shakes her head.

Permalink Mark Unread

It sure does seem to be from the charcoal. There are a couple small smudges of the same on the quilt, in fact. It's not obvious what's under the quilt except that the unobviousness means there isn't anything very big and solid. Maybe just more fabric. The pages had obscure diagrams or illustrations or something and cramped writing with no paragraph breaks.

Valanda gestures for her to have a seat if she'd like and starts putting on necklaces from the pile.

Permalink Mark Unread

She sits and takes this opportunity to in fact look around at what had previously been behind her. (Details on latch, door, railing, window, and shoes?)

Permalink Mark Unread

The latch is large and looks like it would be possible for someone without much manual dexterity to operate. The rail is varnished wood and seems to serve no function except to make the room even smaller. The shoes are leather and seem to be wearing out. The window has a shutter, currently open, but no glass.

When Valanda is absurdly blinged out with all his necklaces and three bracelets, where the pile was there's a flat metal rectangle, not apparently color-changing or even unusually-colored at all.

Squatting down in front of her, Valanda speaks softly just to get her attention. He mimes eating. He raises his eyebrows. He gestures at her. Assuming she's as human as she looks and eats with her mouth, which is a big assumption, she should probably understand that as "are you hungry?"

Permalink Mark Unread

As a slave it is prudent to be in the habit of not refusing food when offered, but her recent access to such has been more than sufficient. And there are multiple compelling reasons not to immediately take the food of strangely-and-possibly-not-well-provisioned people in whose closets she unexpectedly appeared. 

She smiles and shakes her head.

Permalink Mark Unread

Nod, smile. He tries asking her if she's thirsty.

Permalink Mark Unread

Smile, headshake. (It would be unfortunate if he were from a culture where her accepting is a necessary social ritual, but by her knowledge and conjecture that would have been more likely to involve an attempt to give her the materials in question, rather than inquire about them.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Nod, again. Valanda gestures for her to stay put. He points to himself, mimes walking away and coming back. Gestures again for her to stay put. Raises his eyebrows as if to ask if this is okay with her.

Permalink Mark Unread

Smile, nod.

Permalink Mark Unread

Excellent. Valanda leaves, shutting the door behind him.

Permalink Mark Unread

Decision factors:

  • She is currently to observation physically able to leave.
  • Arguments for:
    • doing so could potentially enable her to more quickly determine where she is.
    • whether she was transported by someone's intention or not, the local person could have negative intentions with respect to her.
    • if the transportation is secret and this is not desirable, she might have a higher opportunity to expose it.
  • Arguments against:
    • if she was transported by someone's intention, measures of control she was not aware of could be present, such as guards on call.
    • if she was transported sufficiently far away, she might be in violation of some law pertaining to slave behavior, and this would be noticed if she started wandering outside. Attempting to address this with stealth is not likely to be successful on a street she has no familiarity with in full daylight, and considerably likely to bring trouble.
    • Myna is likely to be able to get her out of trouble, but not without unpleasantness in the interim, and not without expenditure.
    • if the transportation is secret and this is desirable, this still raises the chances of exposing it.
    • there could be some reason non-negative reason she was transported here and to this person in particular.
    • there could be a negative reason but she will have more opportunity to learn about it.

Altogether it does not seem a better path-selection to attempt to leave than to stay, so she stays. Nothing in the room appears worth the risk of moving or touching it, so she stays where she is. 

She redirects her brain's central analysis to the transportation itself.

Theorizing without data is not desirable, but she is limited in data. A foundation of possibilities will serve her whether she can acquire more or not. She sorts them out.

  • Those behind it could be the Imperial government, or a different party.
  • This could have been done on purpose or by accident. The Imperial government + on purpose is not likely.
  • 'A different party' heads a large variety. Myna's people + on purpose is not likely. 
  • Different parties have a spectrum of positivity and negativity that cannot be easily collapsed into axes.

As such: the Imperial government or Myna's people, by accident (experiment gone wrong, the like). Some other party, on purpose with some intention, or by accident.

The effect could also be easily reproducible, or not (this can approximate to an axis).

 

That is as far as she is likely to get without further data. She looks around the room for anything she may have overlooked, and for further detail out the window.

Permalink Mark Unread

If she looks down at the street below she will see that there are furry quadrupeds going about their business, most of them wearing strings of the same color-changing beads Valanda has, some of them parasitized by large color-changing leech-like creatures. There are also some snakes, some of which are accompanied by floating bead necklaces. She'll have to watch for a while to see any humanoids.

Permalink Mark Unread

That. Is. Not expected. At all.

She runs a standard diagnostic for whether she is hallucinating; returns 'either no or it is still best path-selection to proceed as though no'.

She proceeds.

It is not completely impossible that the Imperial government or some other group is running a very extensive successful secret experiment in biological engineering. It is not, altogether, very likely. A priori, 'transportation to another world' and similar events are also at the least, not likely. But popular reaction notwithstanding it it quite the opposite of scientific to proclaim occurring events to be impossible. (Color-changing beads, no clear strata, the unfamiliar island - observations move to connections.)

Tabula rasa. If that is the case, she cannot make assumptions about patterns she is accustomed to applying being applicable or true, must observe without expectation. The brain will easily fall into familiar patterns, underproduce the very strange. A bias to keep in mind, and to oppose.

As simpler beginning, she considers her previous reasoning set.

'On purpose' is less likely. There might be some reasons to attempt experimental translocation on a slave not one's own. There are far less to send such one to a different world. The layout of accident possibilities remain possibilities. Additional possibility that it was done from this world, and not hers. That could be on purpose still; she does not know what motivations they might hold. If most anyone in the world had discovered and was aware of another, Myra would have known, and so she would have known. Not certainty. But sufficient probability.

She lacks data about what this world may hold and how to act in it. This current situation at the least appears stable.

She continues to stay.

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda returns after less than an hour, wearing far fewer necklaces and carrying a potted flowering plant, a glass bottle, a pair of gold bracelets, and an iridescent blue-green hummingbird. He greets her warmly in a language she won't understand, sets down the plant, locks the door, and offers her the bracelets. They're close to the right size for her.

Permalink Mark Unread

Details on the items?

If she is in another world, they are unlikely to be familiar with the slavery laws and signifiers from hers. But politeness is still advantageous.

Smile. Headshake.

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda accepts the refusal with all the good grace you don't expect of someone whose plot to magically enslave someone has just been foiled. Everything about how he moves, how he speaks, the expressions he makes all suggest that he's trying to be welcoming and helpful and is very sorry for shouting at her earlier.

The bracelets are very plain and fasten shut rather than being large enough to slip over a hand. The plant has a cluster of drab small flowers surrounded by floral-looking white sepals.

The bird says something in a quiet, high-pitched voice. Valanda uncorks the bottle for the bird to drink from and says something to the bird, then turns back to Sheridan and asks a question.

Permalink Mark Unread

She can think of benevolent reasons to be offered bracelets (a law that all black-haired individuals should wear bracelets, for instance). She can also think of non-benevolent ones. He has not responded in either anger or worry (real or feigned) so that is not the highest priority for further understanding, at the present.

Welcoming affect is generally more positive than not, but can, of course, also be feigned. 

She does not understand the bird (if applicable), or the question.

Permalink Mark Unread

The lack of response isn't helpful. He makes a vague circley gesture in front of his lips and points to her. If he can get her talking, the bird can translate, one way at least, but no magic he knows of can translate silence.

Of course, when he woke up today, he didn't know of any magic that could teleport someone. Who knows what they've learned to do on her undiscovered continent presumably somewhere in the antipodes.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not sure what you mean," she says, which of course is not going to be particularly helpful, but allows her a method to attempt to prompt something else, and to convey tone.

- Unless one of those items is in some manner a communication aid, she corrects her thoughts. (Bias. More effort required.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

The bird says something, Valanda asks a clarifying question, the bird answers.

"I'm sure what you mean," Valanda says, enunciating very carefully.

Permalink Mark Unread

Comprehension of the bird appears, indeed, applicable.

She considers utterances for informational and confirmation-testing usefulness.

"The bird can translate what I say? That is correct, or that is not correct?"

(Can she distinguish words in what they are saying?)

Permalink Mark Unread

More conversation in the foreign language. The bird echoes parts of what Sheridan said, translating individual clauses and sometimes words. Valanda asks a question including the word "bird" and the bird answers.

"The bird can translate, that is correct," Valanda says. "The bird... not can translate what I say? The bird can translate, I'm sure what you mean."

He picks up the notebook he had before and opens it to the page that's half-filled with the map he drew earlier. They're listening in case she spontaneously starts talking about magic but if she doesn't it'll be useful to have pictures to point to to ask.

Permalink Mark Unread

She sets her brain to attempting to memorize word and phrase correspondences. 

That is a very curious translation capability. But certainly useful and exploitable.

"You or the bird will remember the words? If I say many different words, you will remember all of them? Or you will remember some but forget some?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda listens to the translation of that and starts frantically taking notes. "Forget some," he says sheepishly. It's a shame she hasn't said "thank you" yet, he isn't sure how to convey that he wouldn't have thought of that until it was too late otherwise. When he has everything she's said so far transliterated and translated, he points to his notes. "Remember all of them," he says. He pauses, thinking, then tries stringing some words together on his own. "I will forget some but the..." he points to his notes and says a word in Hari "will remember all of them." He smiles and hopes that conveys the idea of gratitude well enough, then turns the page and starts drawing magic symbols to ask her about.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Notebook. Writing. Write, write down. Record."

She considers base useful vocabulary (very different, somewhat unfortunately, from vocabulary foreign language lessons commonly begin with. Can't simply refer to such), as well as questions.

"Is this your house? Yes? No? May I record your language also?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He writes that down on the bottom half of the page with the magic symbols on it. On the facing page he draws a box, divides the box into several smaller boxes, points to one. "This," he says, and then gestures around the room, "yes, but this" he makes a gesture that encompasses the whole box-of-boxes "many house." Maybe she'll guess he means it's an apartment. "Yes, you record!"

Permalink Mark Unread

She guesses.

"Apartment. Apartment complex. I do not have my own paper and pencil. May I borrow some?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes, apartment! Yes, you borrow some." Valanda removes three sheets of paper from the notebook, adds the most recent few words to his list, then hands over the pencil. "My pencil, you borrow, but your paper, you have the paper."

He takes the opportunity to pet the bird perched on his head and thank the bird, but then he pesters Sheridan rather than let her write. "May I have your language," he says and then he says a word in Hari. "Your language, you my apartment." He hates practicing languages he isn't good at yet. This is awful. He does everything he can to seem totally at ease anyway.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you." She can switch between writing and responding fairly effectively. "I'm not sure what you mean. I am speaking Capital."

If there are any remaining signs of not-ease, she will pick up on them.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, he's not very used to hiding things from people who are very used to humans. On the other hand, some of his body language is copied from other species.

"I am speaking Capital," he echoes carefully. It's useful even though it's nothing like an answer to his question. "I speak Hari and Ilan. Hari..." he holds up one finger and counts "one" in Hari, and two fingers and three and so on, and when he's done with all ten he shows one finger again and gives that a word that isn't "one" and then two and gives that a word that isn't "two" and goes through the whole sequence again. One two three four five six seven eight nine ten eleven twelve. "Capital?" he asks.

It's probably too much to hope that Capital uses the same word for "twelve" and "magic" like Hari but the connection between them is obvious enough that given the one he can definitely get to the other. No matter how differently they use it, magic has to be the same everywhere, right?

Permalink Mark Unread

In that case, she picks up on it. Does not have enough data to conclude which of very many potential sources may be causing it; files it away and continues collecting observations.

Listing language names from another world is not a good use of vocabulary. "I also speak several languages." She takes notes, returns the pencil, and goes through the numbers through twenty.

Permalink Mark Unread

He writes down the numbers. He sighs when the bird tells him "twelve" doesn't seem to mean anything else that Sheridan is thinking of.

"Twelve," he says. "One, translate." He points at the bird. "Two, you may not. Three," he points at the flowers. "Four," he mimes holding a baby. He trails off, obviously expecting her to know exactly what he means. This should be comforting in its familiarity once she gets it. It's pretty surprising she hasn't thought to talk about it yet.

Permalink Mark Unread

She could develop guesses, but that would be an incorrect direction for her thoughts, when opportunity to ask is so present. "I'm not sure what you mean."

Permalink Mark Unread

For a moment he looks at her in blank incomprehension.

Then he wonders if maybe she's from such a small population they don't have every kind of magic or a population that doesn't recognize the different kinds as a category or hasn't figured out that inheritance magic does anything yet.

Okay, he doesn't need to talk about magic in general, then. "You, my apartment," he says. "Not" and he mimes flying. "Not" and he mimes walking. He would like to make it as obvious as possible that what he wants to know is how she got here and he is carefully tailoring his body language to suggest this as clearly as possible in the absence of actual words.

Permalink Mark Unread

"You are asking how I arrived here?" That did not appear to be what the number-correspondance was about, thought in retrospect it may have been the intended meaning of "Your language, you my apartment." Given that he switched to the numbers and then returned, it's possible the numbers also had some relation to that in some way. Though it could also be simply switching to another topic when one seems unproductive, and then back.

(He left the correspondence list incomplete, potentially suggesting he thought she could fill in. And he was surprised that she did not understand. That is not enough information for concluding the answer. But contributive.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes! I am asking how you arrived here!" He writes down the words. He is so excited. No one on this continent can teleport. If he gets the one and only teleporter working for him, he can make so much money and buy up as much land as he needs, he can probably even buy state-level sovereignty for as much as he'll be making, if she tells him how in enough detail he can eventually sell that, too, to other force mages at whatever absurd price he wants.

Permalink Mark Unread

If she knew he was thinking this she would consider it unfortunate that she would be about to disappoint him, but she reads people, not minds.

"A light-whirlpool-phenomemon I had never previously heard of appeared over the kitchen table and swallowed me. This is not something that to my knowledge ever happens."

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay, so Valanda just spent most of his savings on a random foreigner who isn't the person who invented teleportation. He still has the random foreigner. He writes down translations of new words and phrases. What can he still get out of this? He still doesn't know for sure that she doesn't know how to do anything they don't know in the Empire.

A light whirlpool is a strange thing to do teleportation, as if an illusion mage and a force mage were working together. If it were intentional, he'd guess the illusion mage had marked the portal or whatever it is, but this sounds like something else. It's possible it's not even magic. Maybe that kind of thing just happens by itself sometimes, very rarely.

"Are you going to sell me?" the bird asks in Hari; Sheridan probably won't understand it all of it but if she's been paying very close attention she might recognize some of the words.

"No," says Valanda. He shakes his head and thinks and then speaks to Sheridan again in Capital. "You... not translate, not..." he points at the flowers again. "I borrow you, you...?" He makes a gesture that if she were familiar with this continent would put her in mind of a caralendar tutor prompting a student to complete a pattern. Maybe she'll pick up enough of his instinctive body language to guess what he's asking. What can she do for him?

Permalink Mark Unread

Her saying that caused him to be sad/disappointed, where before he'd been excited. Some potential answer to that question would have been very positive for him, and it was not the actual one. He saw her appear; if someone appeared in front of someone from her world, they would not be straightforwardly excited when they asked about it. It's an unheard of thing. So it is likely that here in some way it is not.

She has been paying very close attention but she does not know 'sell', which is rather core. 

She is not familiar with this continent. 

"Are you asking what work I can do?" And adds, "Question words. Who, what, where, when, why, how." ('borrow you', that is - possibly indicative. He does not have many words to work with, but that that one came up in association at all remains so.)

Permalink Mark Unread

He writes those all down. He thanks the bird. He praises the bird.

"Thank you. Yes, I'm asking what work you can do." He deliberately acts as welcoming as before. No need to seem like he was only being nice because he wanted her to teleport things for him. There are other kinds of work that could make this investment worth it.

Permalink Mark Unread

She considers what she should say, from the direction of what abilities of hers she can convey as an answer, and what abilities she may or may not want known.

Her central skillset is not very easily expressed as an answer to that question. She doubts that 'taking a beating' is within the desired answer.

"Domestic work. Chemistry and biology. Gathering information. Strategy and strategic advice. I am familiar with security systems where I come from. Some nonstandard computer skills. Experimental procedure. Some games played for money where I come from." She deliberately leaves out, for the moment, physical combat, disguise, what exactly she does with security systems and computers, and that her particular skill and experience with gambling is giving her owner unfair advantages.

Permalink Mark Unread

Notes notes notes. All theoretically useful, nothing Valanda can see a use for at the moment. Most likely to be useful is comparing her continent's inventions against the Empire's.

This is all going to be so frustrating without a shared language. He rereads vocabulary notes. He thinks. "What security systems do you have where you come from?"

Permalink Mark Unread

More preferably she could practice language as well, since she is the one in the location where everyone will not speak hers. But at the moment that trades off against gaining words. She settles for parallel practicing in her head, for now. With no feedback, which is severely suboptimal. But, tradeoffs, such it is. And she is experienced enough in it.

"Alarms. Motion detection. Temperature sensing. Remote monitoring. Sensors on doors and windows. Glass break detectors. Locks of various sorts. Access control." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Write write write. What useful words. That doesn't sound better than what the Empire has. It sounds worse. Locks, sensors. Valanda's walls are unbreakable, the window is unopenable if he doesn't want it to open, the door can be held shut the same as the window if he feels like expending the power and doesn't trust the latch. Whatever glass break detectors are, they don't have them but they probably don't need them. It's possible the other continent just prefers to let would-be thieves in to give them more rope to hang themselves, make sure no one trusts what looks like an opportunity.

"Do you write security systems?" he asks. If he's very lucky, she'll grasp that with his limited vocabulary he's trying to describe spell-design. "And you gather what information? You have what chemistry and biology? What is a computer?" He has a translation for that but the translation was "automated arithmetic system" and he wants the details on her magic abacus design. Maybe he can sell the plans for it to a team of whatever sort of mages it needs. He can give her half the proceeds if he does and recoup some of today's losses.

Permalink Mark Unread

Obviously she does not grasp this at all; understands it as planning/design/programming/setup. 

"No, though I likely could if I needed to. Where I come from, generally information about people, locations, events. I am not sure what descriptions of my level of chemistry and biology you want. I don't have a formal degree."

A very potentially informative question. It's not likely that they simply call them something else; the bird had translated everything else without causing questions. 'Do you not have computers' is obviously not an informative question. 'What technology level are you at' is not likely to be. 

The room does not have a light visible anywhere, nor a lightswitch. Not something she'd found necessarily odd at first, since it looks like a closet (if with a window). But he'd not taken her to a larger room. 

"Do you have electricity?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Good of her to finally say "needed" and "want" and "if" and the like, Valanda's been waiting to hear "if" for a while now. The bird stumbles on "electricity" but eventually "useful lightning" is the tentative translation. From context it sounds like the magic abacus is made of lightning. Valanda draws a picture of a dark cloud and lightning striking from an implied ground up to the cloud. "Electricity?" he asks, pointing to it.

Another strange thing is the lack of elaboration on which parts of security system design she could do if she needed to. If she can design combined spells for several mages on her own, that's a very useful talent. Maybe she's a knowledge mage who used magic to understand how the other types of magic feel to have and use. Or maybe she thinks it's obvious that she's the knowledge mage and handles sensors. If she is, she's very unspecialized. People and places, not, say, translation or noncontagious disease diagnosis. Makes it sound like she's not very good at finding out any particular thing.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Lighting is a form of electricity." And that is probably a no. "Where I am from, a different form of electricity is used to power a lot of technology."

He hasn't answered the chemistry and biology question, so she can't elaborate on that yet. 

Meanwhile, "I'm going to start listing some words that might be useful after things I say. City. Country. Empire. Room. Important. Laws. A little."

Where she comes from she is good at finding out quite a variety of particular things, but she doesn't expect to be anywhere near as much so here, certainly at first. Deduction needs knowledge.

Permalink Mark Unread

It sounds like what her home continent has is not better magic but better nonmagical technology. Which means instead of a one in twelve chance (one in six if he counts the bird) that he can do whatever she can teach, it's certain he can do it. Materials will probably be more expensive than if it were magic, but as long as he turns a profit...

"Thank you! The words are useful! This room is in Thelm Ret. Thelm Ret is a city in Ehima. Ehima is in the Empire." He flips back to the map of the continent. "This is the Empire. This is Thelm Ret. This is Mar Geru. Mar Geru is a city in Har. 'Mar Geru' is Hari, 'Thelm Ret' is a different language. This" on the southeast coast, he points to it "is Anavel Sani City in Anavel Sani. Anavel Sani speaks Ilan, Har speaks Hari. All of the" he hesitates, not completely sure if the word is right "countries speak Hari. Hari is the language in the Empire." He smirks. The bird makes a sound that Sheridan might not recognize as laughter. It's only a little funny even if you get the joke, which Sheridan won't. "...Oh," he says. "I will... not-arrive here, I do not have but I will have" he decides not to bother translating "Hari Ar Sarag Marsaehu, I will arrive here, you will have Sarag Marsaehu. You will not borrow, you will own. If you own, you speak Hari. When you speak Hari, I ask you, electricity, technology, you ask me laws. You here. When you're sure what laws, you may not-arrive here, you may the city, the Empire. If you're not sure what laws, you may here, this room, or... I will say, when I arrive here. You want something?" He mimes food again, in case she's changed her mind about that.

Permalink Mark Unread

He is excited again. 

He is asking about what she can do; he'd said 'borrowing' her (as opposed to asking about her world, or the whirlpool phenomenon, like a scholar-type might, or more about her, or a variety of other topics); he wants to use her for work. He wasn't asking her if she can do specific things; he is less likely to have a project in mind; he wants to make use of her work in general. He gets excited when it seems she might know something new to him, but is not a scholar-type; he likely wants to make use of it too.

Also the distinction between borrowing and owning is important here.

It seems she chose words well.

She does not get the joke, though she notices the smirk. 

She's heard those words. Has to check her paper for 'language' but 'Empire' she just heard. 'Hari is the language of the Empire'. 

"Leave. Province? Food. Thank you very much, I would be glad to learn more of your language, and your laws. "'Hari is the language of the Empire' is an object? How long do you expect to be gone?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Well that question would be easier to answer if he spoke more Capital. He finds the edge of the rectangle of sunlight from the window. He puts his finger on it. He moves his finger. "This leaves, when this arrives here, if not food, I arrive." Shorter than his last errand by a lot. "If food, I arrive here." Still well under an hour. "Yes and no, is and is not an object, when you have you will be sure what I mean. You want food, when I leave?" He's not sure if she was just giving him the word or actually requesting it.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I ate recently, no thank you."

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda asks the bird whether it'd rather stay or go. It stays perched on his head. They leave.

Permalink Mark Unread

She memorized the indicated sunlight location; keeps track of time.

He does not have reason to know she's a slave, and if he'd cared very strongly about her not touching his things he could have expressed as such. She is thoroughly practiced in returning things exactly how she'd found them. This is not sufficient when she might be being monitored by Imperial guards, or with someone who had set up unknown security or would be checking for fingerprints and the like. At this point she will accept the remaining risk.

What is under the blanket? Will the metal rectangle hold anything interesting if she picks it up and looks at it? Did he leave his notebook?

Permalink Mark Unread

The quilt is folded double to fit in the small space. Between the folds there's a change of clean clothes that have been mended several times and might be a little small for Valanda but at one point they were nicer than the ones he's wearing now. There's a wool blanket, or maybe that's a cloak. There's a small half-empty bag of nuts. There's a lump like there might be another notebook and some harder-to-guess things against the floor but for some reason without any visible nails or anything like that the quilt just refuses to be lifted off the floor. He did leave his notebook but it's written in at least two languages that share an alphabet without any warning when he changes between them and the diagrams are not anything familiar except one thing that could be a braid or a DNA helix with the ends circled and labeled for some reason.

The metal rectangle was face-down. The other side is blank except for a carving in the same alphabet as the notebook. It says "The Law Will Find You" if Sheridan could read it. Wait, no, it's not blank, suddenly it starts displaying a silent movie of a big cat levitating. The cat does not look happy about it. A caption scrolls across the screen. The cat seems to be pulled in different directions by unseen hands. It looks even less happy about this. It's ripped apart and dies. The movie is abruptly over and the metal rectangle is just a metal rectangle again.

Permalink Mark Unread

What kind of bag? How is the cloak made?

She does not try harder to pry up the quilt. She explores the way it's stuck on. Smooth seam, or intermittent like if it was nails? Can she see anything at the seam? Is the outline an exactly shape or more freehand?

He was transliterating things she said into the notebook. If it's written with an alphabet, she should be able to figure out a lot of letters from that. If that's enough she will decipher the elements she knows of the carving (the, law, will, you, but not find). The caption probably goes by too fast for her. Based on the 'law' part and the lack of anything else happening, a top conjecture would be 'execution', though other options are very possible. Which would then also mean that in this world it is possible to levitate and manipulate things without contact. (Conversely, if it is a trailer for a movie or similar, it does not necessarily tell her anything about what they can do in reality).

What is the rectangle like? Does it seem to have internal components somewhere? What changes when the displaying starts?

Permalink Mark Unread

Burlap bag. Looks like it's made from a couple scraps that may have been part of ill-fated larger bags at some point. The cloak is a wool square with fasteners on two adjacent corners.

The quilt is stuck as if it were superglued. There's no visible seam. It's not intermittent like nails. It's freehand, in some places it's stuck to the bottom of the wall, in some places it can be peeled up to reveal half an inch of wood floor.

She'll have some difficulty figuring out how to read Hari vowels from Hari-alphabet transliterations of words in a non-tonal language, the way tone is written is unobvious and for that matter Valanda's inconsistent about how to write non-tonal words. And if Capital uses more than five vowels and ten consonants Valanda will have had to improvise spellings.

The rectangle is a metal rectangle. Might be steel. There are small holes in the corners as if it's meant to be easy to tack it up somewhere. It seems to be a sheet of steel. The corners are rounded and it's polished and smooth and unlikely to accidentally cut someone. When it starts displaying things, it starts displaying things. That's about it. The display also isn't obscured by reflections even though in a pinch the metal is polished enough to serve as a mirror.

By the time she's done figuring out as much as she can about the Hari alphabet there won't be very long left before Valanda's expecting to return.

Permalink Mark Unread

Usefully, she also heard him or the bird saying the Hari words, and isn't new to tonal languages.

There are 'theories' one does not usually entertain, but being transported to other worlds by surprise phenomena rather adjusts protocols.

She remembers what he sounded approaching last time and has been listening for that as well as watching the sun, but a buffer is preferred. She returns the last of what she looked at to how she found it; sits and reviews her notes externally (and what she has of the alphabet additionally, internally).

Permalink Mark Unread

She has even more warning this time than last. A voice speaks in Hari. It's not Valanda's voice but there's not another set of footsteps. When he opens the door he hands her another rectangle. This one has sound as well as pictures. There's another big cat, but this one isn't being killed, he's just talking.

"...and that's the end of this episode," he says in Hari, then it goes blank for a second and when it reappears he has a different set of props with him. "Welcome to a new episode of Hari Is The Language Of The Empire. I'm Mahan and I'll be teaching you Hari. I am an agerah. This is a tree. This is a rock..."

And on it goes. Valanda smiles at her but assumes she'll want to listen without him talking over the teacher, so he says nothing to her and is very quiet when he speaks to the bird.

Permalink Mark Unread

She smiles back, because that is social. "Thank you." She watches the rectangle. She pays enough side attention to see if she can catch anything he and the bird say.

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda wants to know if the bird wants to stay with Sheridan or go with Valanda when he has to go to work later; the bird wants to stay with Valanda.

"Do you want a name?" Valanda asks the bird. Hari conveniently doesn't distinguish "name" from "word" so she'll have heard the word before.

"I have one. I'm Iri," says the bird, which surprises Valanda.

"Huh. Iri. Sure. I need you off my hair while I fix it, you mind?"

The bird perches on his shoulder instead while Valanda finger-combs and re-ties his hair.

The show teaches a lot of forest-related vocabulary, starts a new episode in an orchard, teaches farming-related vocabulary. The farmer is another of the kind of talking cat called an agerah, this one named Riha, whose explanation of how he farms is a little beyond the intended audience's comprehension level and makes reference to magic. Episodes are pretty short. If the show was designed to hold interest or make memory easier, it sure wasn't designed to do that for humans. There aren't really signs it was designed to do that at all. Valanda isn't using the pencil at the moment, though, if she has more space left on the three pages he gave her.

Permalink Mark Unread

That is not an ideal design for language acquisition, but it is not an uncommon one. (Perhaps she should tell her host that she can design a better language curriculum). Getting as much as she can out of information provision she does not have convenient access to is a skill she is very practiced at. She is good at conserving writing space. She focuses more on core words, functional words, structure, how expressions are put together, important words, words with broader applications. Takes notes with prioritization of important but not-commonly occurring words. Pays attention to pronunciation. Imagines how she might write words in what she gathered of the alphabet.

It would be more effective to have more space to practice, even internally. If her host is not busy, she will look somewhat up (there's a sequence of mostly specific vocabulary going on) and see if this draws his attention.

(What are the references to magic like?)

Permalink Mark Unread

He's looking out the window. Looking at people isn't inherently rude but it's a little intrusive and she doesn't have anywhere private to go by herself. Iri doesn't care much about rudeness but also doesn't bother to tell Valanda where their guest happens to be looking.

The references to magic will be very unclear at this point. "I'm a green mage," says Riha. "I make plants grow faster and more efficiently and produce bigger fruits. I can roughly triple, sometimes quadruple the yield and ripen fruit earlier in the season than anyone else around here. I'm working on getting a crop in fast enough to have two a year but it might take a different spell to start the trees flowering again in summer. That field over there is owned by a death mage and we trade magic. He kills pests when I get an infestation and I make his strawberries grow bigger and faster. We barter rather than use currency because we're not very liquid out here in the country." The interview ends that episode and the next is set on a different sort of farm, naming things. These are sheep, these are goats. This is wool, this is a fence.

Valanda will just keep politely looking out the window for a while unless she says something.

Permalink Mark Unread

She does not know enough words yet to understand this thoroughly enough to pick up on it.

He does not appear busy and 'how they respond to her interrupting them' is useful information to obtain.

"Excuse me?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda turns away from the window and if Sheridan is seated he'll squat down to keep level with her.

"What do you want?" he asks in Capital, in a tone of voice that suggests it's a lack of familiarity with Sheridan's language and a lack of knowledge about what she might consider rude, rather than any actual resentment, that determined his choice of words.

Meanwhile Mahan tells her that this is a rope and this is a bag and...

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm sorry to bother you. Is there a way to pause this?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"No pause and I need the pencil, I want to write how you say that."

Permalink Mark Unread

She passes him the pencil.

"How long is it?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Um. No, not how long." He's not sure how to explain in Capital and he doesn't think she can understand if he says it straight out but he switches to Hari anyway: "it repeats. Episode one, episode two, episode three, four, five, six, seven, eight... episode one again, then episode two, episode three, four... and it repeats and repeats. Does that make sense?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She catches the repetition in the numbers. 

"It repeats? It's a loop? How long is one repetition?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He puts his finger in the sunlight. He moves his finger over to the east wall. He crosses the room. He traces a line from the west wall to where the sun is now. "That's one day," he says in Hari. "Hari is the Language of the Empire is three days and..." he thinks about it and then traces about two or three hours of sun movement. "And maybe that much. You'll want to watch it again if you have to sleep." He is not looking forward to sleeping in this room with the show going on all night.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Three days and a few hours?" She doesn't understand the rest of what he said.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes, three days and a few hours," Valanda says. He hopes Iri translated "hours" as a familiar unit of time because they measure time the same way and not because the magic can't tell the difference between different measurements of time shorter than a day.

Permalink Mark Unread

Attempting to watch it for three days straight is certainly not an effective learning method. So missing pieces as needed to take other actions only makes sense.

"Could I ask you a few questions? It will make it easier for me to understand."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You may ask."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you.

Do you use magic?" 'Have magic' is more likely to bring on reverse questions about her world, which she would prefer to avoid if possible. This way she can be taken to mean if he personally uses it. And if she is completely mistaken in the supposition, then she will come up with something she meant instead (the translation has been shown to not be perfectly flawless).

Permalink Mark Unread

She's been talking to him this whole time and didn't notice he was a person? How weird. He wonders if they have people who don't have magic on the other continent. How would they even become people without it?

"Yes."

Permalink Mark Unread

That is a rather important thing to know. And now she knows the word as well.

"Might it be possible for me to get some translations directly from the bird? I could gain some core words, and confirm ones I learned."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't care, do what you want," Valanda tells Iri in Hari.

"I don't know how to ask her to pay me," says Iri. "If she even can."

"Iri wants..." Valanda mimes barter, giving with one hand and taking with the other.

Meanwhile Mahan is naming colors. This leaf is green, this cloth is blue.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Compensation? Payment?

What would Iri want as payment?" she doesn't add that she doesn't exactly own anything; this seems apparent.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know what I want," Iri confides in Hari to Valanda.

"Is there anything you wish she would do differently?"

"No and I don't know what she could do for me. I wish I knew more about where she's from. Oh, that's what I want." Iri changes to Capital to try to speak to her. "I want where you come from."

Permalink Mark Unread

That, she supposes, is something she indeed has to offer. "What would you like to know?"

Permalink Mark Unread

If she's familiar with the body language of this species of eusocial bird people, she'll recognize Iri's shrug. If not, well, that's why Valanda echoes it in more human body language.

Permalink Mark Unread

She is not familiar.

She considers this a rather silly way to ask a question, but, such a way it was asked. "I am also from an Empire. I've lived in several locations in it, including the capital city." Not that she'd gotten to see much of it. "As I mentioned, where I am from electricity is used to power a lot of technology. Where I come from, a series of episodes like this would be watched using technology. There is generally a way to pause, or rewind, or move to a different episode." Does this appear to be a kind of information Iri is interested in?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you," says Iri. "You want translations directly?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"As opposed to?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know how to figure out what she wants from me," says Iri, trembling like a scared bird. Iri regrets asking for payment. Iri regrets agreeing to this. Iri regrets existing. Iri regrets literally everything.

"You asked," says Valanda, "might it be possible for you to get some translations directly from the bird. What translations?" He doesn't add that Iri is terrified of her and that he suspects Iri hasn't bothered to remember much vocabulary and doesn't know how to ask for clarification besides repeating things. That's a little beyond him to explain.

Permalink Mark Unread

She notices the body language.

"If I say some words or sentences, can Iri tell me how to say them in Hari?

"Is Iri alright?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Alright, ha, Iri has everything they've ever worked for and nothing they've ever taken for granted and no idea what to do with any of the things they've been told all their life not to want and

also Iri hasn't really been paying attention to which words mean what and can't read Valanda's notes and Valanda's no help either, he just shrugs and now Iri's left the stranger waiting while they think and

"Can Iri tell me how to say them in Hari. Yes. Iri can. Is Iri alright," and Iri translates that into Hari. It's using a concept that's slightly slant of anything Hari has words for but it's close to a couple of different concepts. "Iri ar riuh i erhes au?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri still seems distressed, and unfortunately this is an area where it is rather hard to assist given impeded communication.

"I'm not upset at you in any way, if you are worried about that. I am not asking you to do anything except tell me how to say things I say in Hari. If that is distressing I won't do it either. Is it?" 

She notices the lack of an exact word match. Does she know any of the words within it?

Permalink Mark Unread

Refusing wouldn't be any less distressing and since Iri got payment up front it'd be dangerous to wait and let her decide she's owed something else later. And if Iri does more than they owe that's either dangerous or helpful, you can usually guess which by species but humans are rare and Iri isn't sure if they'll see weakness and press their advantage or if they'll want to be fair and repay Iri for helping.

Iri translates that for Valanda and then answers. "I tell you how to say things you say in Hari."

She might've heard on Hari is the Language of the Empire that it's important to make sure your sheep are "erhes" but it's not a word that's very easy to define by pointing at things. She's likely to recognize "Iri ar" as the same construction that starts "Hari Ar Sarag Marsaehu" and she might recognize "au" as a verbal question mark, if she's been able to tell when Valanda and Iri are asking each other questions and when they're making statements. Or she might recognize it when it shows up in Iri's translation of what she just said, which ends "ar au?" "Riuh" shows up there, too: "ar riuh" is the entire first clause and then it comes up again when in Iri's translation she says if it will make Iri stop being riuh she won't ask for more translations. It's possible she can parse the whole sentence, especially knowing what it's supposed to mean.

Permalink Mark Unread

She can somewhat parse it. Something like 'Is Iri not-upset-at-her/undistressed and __ ?' The first part not in fact being what she meant, if the upset-at is important there. She notes to keep that in mind, but decides not to attempt in-depth investigation, at the moment. Not highest priority, and if it has to do with some cultural difference she will be better set up to understand it once she learns more.

"Thank you. Is there some reassurance or help I could give you that would make anything better? 

Do you have an established signal for 'I am saying this to you' as opposed to 'please translate this'?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri trembles and translates all of that into Hari for Valanda.

"She's trying to tell you she'd rather back down than fight with you," says Valanda.

"Oh," says Iri. Iri thinks hard about how to answer in Capital. "Is reassurance, is better, is all right." They get some help from Valanda figuring out how to answer the other question. "No established signal."

Permalink Mark Unread

By body language xie is at least somewhat in fact reassured, and if she is to attempt more she would want to wait for greater knowledge as well as intimacy level.

(She does not have enough words to understand Valanda's sentence.)

She nods.

And that seems an omission in translator work, but, is as it is. "Would just saying 'translate please' or the like be alright?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"All right."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you. Might I be able to also practice language with you? It might go easier, if I can also say what I meant to say in Capital."

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri doesn't understand what she's asking for and that's terrifying but Valanda did say she's not dangerously inclined toward Iri right now. Iri will just try their best to figure it out.

"Yes. Practice."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you." (Xie's scared again, but the rest of the situation features continue to hold, so, no clear procedure for addressing that. She is not about to do anything unpleasant on purpose and she will watch for information as she is able.)

It would be useful to ask about scheduling - she can schedule herself for learning between the not-video and translation and practice, but it would be of assistance if she knew if either of them had opinions on aspects of her going about that, or planned to ask her to do something else, or head off elsewhere themselves. But at her current level of language it is likely better to start acting and watch for responses and change, rather than try to ask.

She looks back at the not-video for a moment, thinks. Then turns back to Iri "Are these correct? Could you correct me, please, if they are not?" And she produces a few short sentences in Hari. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Correct." Now Iri thinks they understand what she wants. This shouldn't be too hard.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you." And, if no one appears to object to this, she will set herself into alternating between the not-video, sitting silently as she repeats words to herself, asking Iri for translations, and production practice. 

Permalink Mark Unread

They leave her to it for a while but then Valanda gets her attention.

"You might not understand this so I'll translate it afterward. I have to go to work soon but before I do I should show you where to find the bathroom and get water to drink. In Capital, that's... you and I go, you know where, uh..." Valanda makes a vague gesture meant to convey that he can't really explain. "You and I arrive here, I go to do work, you here. Go?" Valanda opens the door.

Permalink Mark Unread

She nods, stands up. "Thank you." Says it in Hari, this time.

Permalink Mark Unread

The hallway is painted in vaguely naturalistic streaky non-patterns of dark green and brown. Light comes from a window at one end of the hall. There are lots of doors and there are stairs.

This floor's bathroom is accessible for at least five different species and not really optimal for any of them. They have soap and running water, though not sinks per se. Valanda demonstrates that the water is drinkable. There doesn't seem to be a way to run it hot.

Valanda is very relieved that they don't run into anyone and leads her back to his room before anyone has a chance to show up and take some kind of offense at her or wonder where she came from.

Permalink Mark Unread

Access to restrooms and water is considerably preferable to absence of the same. "Thank you," she says again.

(Can she see how it seems to be working? Is there plumbing? What is the style of the stairs? What is the hallway floor like?)

Permalink Mark Unread

The plumbing seems to be pretty hidden in the walls. There's nothing that couldn't be strictly mechanical. The stairs are within the range of acceptable heights for a human and there are handrails on both sides. The hallway floor creaks like wood and is covered in soft carpet in dull natural colors. It might have been tie-dyed but that would only explain parts of the design.

Permalink Mark Unread

How does the metalwork look?

"Do I need to unlock and lock the door to go to the hall?" she asks Valanda back in the room.

Permalink Mark Unread

it looks like they use silver for it, is how it looks.

"Unlock the door, go to the hall, arrive here, lock the door." The mechanical lock is a deadbolt. Valanda can lock the door from the outside with magic but doesn't know if Sheridan can.

Permalink Mark Unread

That's certainly something.

So she does not need to lock the door from the outside, and he did not mention anything having to do with magic. (Sheridan cannot). "Thank you."

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah, he's just leaving the whole topic of magic for later when they can talk to each other better.

"I go do work," he says. The bird goes with him. "You lock," he says, pointing to the lock, just before he closes the door.

A new episode of Hari is the Language of the Empire starts.

"...I'm Mahan and I will be teaching you Hari. Today we'll talk about magic. This is Ariu. Ariu is an illusion mage. Ariu will show us illusion magic now." There's a good view of a bare patch of ground between them. And then projected on that patch of ground are twelve symbols. "This is an illusion of magic. We call it that because there are twelve kinds." ("Magic" and "twelve" are the same word in Hari.) "You are watching Hari is the Language of the Empire on an enchanted object. It is enchanted with illusion magic. This is the symbol for illusion magic." He points to it with his tail. "I am a void mage. Using void magic is against the law. Do not use void magic. This is the symbol for void magic."

A snake slithers into view. "This is Agi. Agi is a force mage. This is the symbol for force magic. Agi will do some force magic." Agi levitates. "Agi is levitating by using force magic."

Agi slithers off, to be replaced by another furry creature who does sun magic. The furry creature transmutes elements. The symbol for sun magic looks like a sun.

There are twelve kinds of magic and by the end of the episode not all of them will have been demonstrated but all of them will have been named and their symbols pointed out.

Permalink Mark Unread

She locks the door and watches the not-video.

 

What a rather important episode. (Ah, she had noticed the homophone-(which-turns-out-to-in-fact-be-more-than-that). She does her best at understanding with her current capacity - fortunately this appears to be an episode with higher quantities of simple sentences and repetition and such. Twelve kinds of magic, each does something different. People appear to be identified as types of mages. Void magic is against the law ('illegal', like 'bathroom', and related concepts, are words she'd asked Iri for) but the speaker does not seem to be concerned about identifying himself as a void mage.  

 

(And ah, this appears likely to have been what her host had been attempting to get at with the numbers earlier. She thinks back to that conversation and its pattern. Had he thought she had appeared by (their) magic? ...Had he thought she might have appeared by magic she could do? That might explain the topic-patterns, and the excitement-then-dissapointment.

And - had she, in fact, appeared by their magic? He didn't seem to recognize her description, and the not-video had not shown anything like it, but it is not odd to have advances or experiments not known to everyone and not described in commonly-available educational materials.

Not much she is able to do with such a hypothesis. But she keeps it in mind.)

 

The transmutation explains the silver, she supposes. 

She copies down symbols and brief notes, notes questions.  

(Is the transmutation specifically elements? Has anyone been identified as more than one kind of mage? Has she heard a word that seemed to be not-mage? What were the other kinds? Are enchanted objects mentioned for any other kinds?)

Permalink Mark Unread

The sun mage transmutes elements. A structure mage alters chemical compounds. No one has been identified as two kinds of mage or zero kinds of mage but it is possible that they wouldn't be featured in an episode like this, just to keep it simple. The kinds of magic are force, structure, illusion, sun, death, command, heat, knowledge, void, inheritance, green and defense. The symbols for these are, in order, an arrow, a bunch of circles touching each other, a vague squiggle, the sun, a horizontal line, an empty circle, a rectangle that's half black half white-outlined-in-black, a brain shape with a squiggle on it, a black square, an X, a leaf, an arc over a dot that looks a little like an umbrella.

The episode doesn't demonstrate heat, knowledge, inheritance or green magic. Command magic is demonstrated by pointing out that a gold bracelet was enchanted with it. It is not explained what the bracelet does. It looks like the ones Valanda offered her earlier. One of the mages who appears on the show is wearing four, one on each leg.

The explanations of the kinds of magic not demonstrated lean heavily on presumed familiarity with the twelve symbols. It's not really possible to figure out what all of them do.

...and he's Mahan and welcome to another episode of Hari is the Language of the Empire, today you'll be learning about the bloody wars of conquest that led to the existence of a one-world government! Aren't you so lucky to live in the Empire instead of a nation that isn't the Empire and would definitely be extremely bloodily destroyed. Modern conveniences like a total lack of alternative states sure are grand.

 

Permalink Mark Unread

This appears potentially relevant to the level of pertinency of her chemistry knowledge.

She thinks she can form some conjectures about command magic. (She notices the bracelet similarly).

If she remembers correctly green magic was mentioned in the farming episode (as was... death magic? (This not-video could certainly be structured more conveniently, she lets herself observe. But she is well used to taking knowledge from less than convenient setups)). Heat she can guess at, though she may not be at all correct. Knowledge and inheritance not so much so. Void magic continues unclear. 

(She wonders why sun magic has that name; it seems an odd one out.)

 

She is from an Empire herself, and is long in the habit of not making facial expressions and the like at such pronouncements. She sets herself to paying attention to conquest-relevant vocabulary (and/or seeing if they got some language educational value, into their propaganda episode).

Permalink Mark Unread

Of course the propaganda episode teaches vocabulary. Blood. Death. Fight. War. Cooperate. Peace. Safety. Law enforcement. They show maps of the continent with the polities that used to exist. They compare it to a modern map.

They mention minority languages and where they're spoken. The two biggest minority languages among people who can pronounce Hari are Ilan, spoken in the southeast, and Devin, spoken around the bay in the southwest. There's also Ereli, North Essi and South Essi, but people who speak those can't pronounce Hari. This is okay as long as everyone understands Hari and all the people who can pronounce it speak it. People can also watch Understanding Ereli to learn Ereli.

Isn't it so nice that the Hari Empire allows linguistic diversity to exist. Without them maybe people would go to war and all the speakers of a minority language would die. On the other hand, the Hari Empire also makes it easier for people to understand each other by teaching them all Hari. If you like languages, you like the Hari Empire! If you like transcontinental trade and understanding people from far away, you like the Hari Empire!

There's a little bit of math about the resources diverted to fighting wars and how not doing that leaves more for literally anything else, like inventing more efficient ways to farm or having regular flights from city to city, which couldn't happen if they were at war, now, could it.

It's a long episode and clearly biased but their treatment of the subject is detailed and includes lots of useful vocabulary words. A lot of effort is made to make concepts like "war" clear. An intermediate student would probably be able to understand everything and learn a lot of new words. Parts of it might go over Sheridan's head.

Permalink Mark Unread

Parts of it do go over her head, but she appreciates their effort, detail, and vocabulary words. She also appreciates maps, and copies down quick details.

All other factors being equal she does approve of allowing linguistic diversity, trade, understanding people, and preferences for funding useful things over wars and for lack of genocide. (She of course is perfectly aware of bias being certainly present, and that lack of inclusion in a propaganda episode of elements such as 'war crimes' and 'less bloody alternatives that could have been chosen' and 'oppression' and 'various horrible things the government does and countenances' does not likely reflect the lack of such things in reality.)

What polities used to exist? Is one-world government literal? How about the other continents?

Is 'some people can't pronounce Hari' conveyed in a way she would understand? Are there any examples of speech in the other mentioned languages?

Is the math presented in a way to give her some information on their math notation?

Is the existence of flights conveyed in a way she would understand (for instance with images)?

Permalink Mark Unread

There is no mention of any other continents anywhere in the episode. There is no mention of foreign relations involving anyone from any other continent. No other continents appear on any maps. Small islands near the coast of this continent appear on one map. Information on other polities is limited, there's only any detail on two larger ones, Anavel Sani and Thervigenia, the former now a state and the latter totally lost, and one tiny island one, the Sovereign Republic of Anemone Bay.

There's a sample of North Essi with a Hari translation. It isn't completely obvious that it's not produced by a vocal apparatus that could also pronounce Hari, but it might seem likely just from that sample. It's also mentioned that illusion mages can pronounce Ereli even if they're agerah or caralendri.

The math is all explained verbally, not written.

The existence of regular flights is illustrated with a map and a video of an airport in Mar Geru.

...and he's Mahan and he'll be teaching you Hari, today's lesson is about common materials! This is coal, coal is the sixth element, this is wood, wood's not an element, this is a candle, the candle is on fire, the fire is using vital air, vital air is the eighth element. This is steel, steel can't be made by a sun mage but can be made by a structure mage. This is silver, silver is the forty-seventh element, it can be made by sun mages. Silver's a common material for door handles, taps, things a lot of different people have to touch. This is gold, it's number seventy-nine. This is titanium. This is adamantite, three parts titanium to one part gold. This is platinum, very useful for a few very specific applications that Mahan doesn't go into detail on. This is glass, this is graphite, this is cement. Try to avoid lead. It's not safe to use lead for things people might eat or drink from. It's not safe to make elements that might be radioactive. Don't assume a compound is safe just because the elements it's made of are.

Mahan seems to have no trouble at all getting examples of precious metals to show people and "adamantite" is clearly an everyday word.

Permalink Mark Unread

Totally lost?

Is this use of illusion magic demonstrated or only mentioned?

In that case she will note mathematics vocabulary. What math do they seem to be using?

Anything to indicate the existence of flights/transportation from said airport, or is it just 'bustling people'?

 

Useful vocabulary. (Incredibly useful and fascinating magic; she wonders if they might have made chemistry discoveries quite ahead of her world). She notes their chemistry knowledge. (Anything about coal vs diamond and such like?)

Yes, if one lives in a world where some can transmute elements she imagines that would lead to such a said-trouble-free state of affairs. 

Permalink Mark Unread

The use of illusion magic to speak Ereli isn't demonstrated. The video shows a flight taking off, but unlike a nonmagical plane it takes off by heading straight up for a while first and the video cuts to something else before it starts moving any other direction.

They do have a separate word for graphite and seem to know which things are elements. They're a little sloppy about the purity of their examples of elements, but that might be because Mahan isn't a chemist and this show is about language.

Valanda is gone for hours. It starts to get dark. The show doesn't provide any quizzes or any pauses to let things settle. An average human would probably find it increasingly difficult to make any use of it. If spaced repetition is a concept this world has, there is no evidence of that in the design of the show.

Permalink Mark Unread

Then that will tell her that they do have flight, while not apparently having electricity. Interesting. She makes a note of wanting to know if it uses the force magic, instead.

Is there any indication of what determines the form of an element a sun mage ends up with? Also, of how the transmutation handles amounts? Would a mole of one give a mole of the other, or does it match by total number of subatomic particles, or something else?

That would make sense, given that he went to work.

Is it harder to watch the show in the dark? Are there lights in the apartment?

She has noticed these features of the show; wonders dryly if they might appreciate advice on language education theory. 

She is not an average human, but for all the work various learned memory tricks and practice and the like can do, not in fact a perfect absorption brain unit. She takes breaks (preferably on episodes that seem comparatively less useful) to repeat and review vocabulary, practice production in as much as she can without anyone else present, engage in some limited-space physical activity and brain-restorative operations, get water.

Permalink Mark Unread

Total number of subatomic particles seems to stay constant.

There are no lights in the apartment, but it's still twilight, not night, when Valanda gets back. He knocks.

"It's Valanda," he says in Hari. "Unlock my door."

Permalink Mark Unread

That is fascinating.

 

She unlocks the door.

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri is with him. He locks the door once they're inside.

"Hungry?" he asks. He mimes it for clarity. At this point a human who ate right before she arrived might be hungry. And she might not have.

Permalink Mark Unread

Has she, in any of the episodes she's watched so far, seen people acquiring food and eating it and nothing negative happening as a result (for instance, at a market?)

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah, there was a crowd scene at a market where a lot of foods were named. In the background, some furry creatures ate some fruit. Someone humanoid but not human ate hard-to-see food of indeterminate origin in another crowd scene. Birds like Iri drank nectar straight from flowers in an episode that mentioned them.

Permalink Mark Unread

That is as safe as she has a reasonable likelihood of being. And food is important for proper functioning.

"Yes, thank you."

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda gets a bag of nuts out from under the quilt and offers it to her.

"If you have any questions, I can try to answer them now," he says in Hari. He knows it's absurdly optimistic to expect her to understand but he's tired of Capital and forgot some of it while he was at work.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you." She eats nuts.

She has 'question' and the smaller words, and can conjecture from there.

"If I have questions, you can try to answer?" she checks in Capital (she looks at Iri).

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri translates and otherwise stays silent.

"Yes," says Valanda.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I have many questions. But I think I will not understand many - answers? - now. I will learn more, then say more questions," she says, in halting but clear Hari.

"What are important laws of the Empire? Any I will understand?" This she repeats in Hari and Capital, for practice and clarity respectively.

 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Don't kill any people. Don't hit or eat people you don't own. Don't take any things or people that aren't yours. Don't damage someone else's things. Don't go anywhere you're not allowed to be, like into someone's house or apartment without their welcome. Don't lie about whether someone committed a crime. Don't make anyone leave a public place. Pay your taxes, I'll help you figure out how much, you don't owe any yet. There are some others but they only apply if you own slaves. Those apply everywhere in the Empire. We're in Ehima right now. Ehima also has other laws. Don't use void magic. Don't lie while selling things. Don't cut down any trees you don't own. There are laws about when and where you can fly and what kinds of buildings you can build, but I don't know them because I don't fly or build buildings. There are also some city laws. Maybe I should just get you written copies tomorrow, there are laws I don't think about much."

Permalink Mark Unread

She clarifies or attempts to determine various words she doesn't have or is not sure of.

Was 'slave' in the not-video?

"Void magic is not illegal other places?" (From the not-video she had understood it was).

"Will it teach me reading also?" (the not-video). 

Permalink Mark Unread

There were slaves in the video but she hasn't gotten to the episode about slavery yet. She may not have heard the word. If she doesn't guess a translation Iri won't be able to pluck the Capital word out of thin air.

"Reading Hari is easy. I'll teach you tomorrow. Void magic is illegal other places but it's not illegal under imperial law. There's imperial law. The Hari Empire enforces imperial law. Every state enforces other laws. Every state enforces a law against void magic. There could be a state where it was allowed, but there isn't one."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Understood. Thank you.

What is void magic?

'Slaves'?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you own a person, that person is your slave. Void magic is magic that makes there not be things. It makes empty space. Not empty like air, you can breathe air. Empty like you can't breathe. Empty like nothing. And then not empty because then things rush in to the empty space, but before that it's empty like it would be if you flew above the air."

Permalink Mark Unread

Nod. "Thank you." She marks this important word. "Could I see it, if someone is a slave?"

"Vacuum?" She asks in Capital.

"Why is it illegal?"

And, it is information about their world again that they know that. "Are there people here who fly above the air?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes, vacuum," says Iri.

"Yes, you can see that Iri is my slave." Valanda points out the gold anklets. "And you can see that I'm not." He indicates his own bare wrists. He doesn't mention that he was definitely trying to get her in his thrall with his offer of enchanted bracelets earlier. He doesn't look sorry, either. "Void magic is illegal because it can't be undone. If we make everything void there will be no ground to stand on and no air to breathe and no food to eat. There are no people here who fly above the air. Can you do that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Clarification of a few words as needed. Nod.

She receives the new information about Iri, back-combines it with past information-without-that-context-at-the-time such as how Valanda spoke to xer, and xer wanting payment for answering Sheridan. Not enough general information to draw most conclusions yet, but more is helpful.

She makes conjectures about the connection, with respect to the bracelets, but does not currently comment on it. 

"Do all the bracelets have command magic like in the episode, or are some just for seeing?

Do many people own slaves?" (Given that it seems he does, while living in this apartment.)

"But death magic is not illegal?

I cannot do that. We can make some machines fly above the air, with technology. But we cannot put people in them."

("In space?" she asks in Capital, to get the word.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Turns out there's not a single Hari word for outer space. Iri calls it the void beyond the world.

"You can make a bracelet and not enchant it, but if people see you wearing gold bracelets they'll think you're a slave. Wearing unenchanted bracelets would be a lie, I guess. It's not a very useful lie. It would mean people would think someone was protecting you. And if a slave commits a crime, the owner is the one who gets punished, but if you're just pretending, then people would figure that out when they couldn't find your owner. You would be safer if you were spoken for but you have no reason to trust me on that."

He shrugs and takes the bracelets he tried to trick her into wearing earlier and sticks them to the wall. They stay as if the wall were magnetic.

"Might be better to just take that off the table." And give her one less thing to try doing to him while he sleeps. Which reminds him. "If you don't want me watching you sleep, you can sleep while I'm at work this morning. Lock the door and I can't unlock it from the outside."

He frowns at some of her questions. They seem like very strange sorts of things to be unclear about.

"Yes, lots of people own slaves. Death magic is legal. I'm not sure why you'd want a law against it. The government pays death mages to go around helping sick people, it's good for preventing epidemics. Tell me how you fly above the air, isn't there nothing for your wings to beat against?"

Permalink Mark Unread

(She generally continues attempting to clarify words as needed and switching between Capital and Hari as seems more optimal for being understood and also practicing.)

"Bracelets for slaves are always enchanted?" And, "will there be an episode on slavery?"

"That is very very generous, thank you.

Watching me?" (Does that have a figurative meaning she is not aware of?). "And, you do not sleep?"

"In the Empire where I am from, usually richer people own slaves, and the government owns slaves, and other people do not." 

She definitely does not have the Hari for this, but "it seems that death magic and void magic have the similarity that they can be very useful but also very dangerous. So I was clarifying on the one being illegal while the other is not."

"We do not fly with wings. We -" she thinks if there might be something to compare it to. "How do your flights work? Are they force magic? They cannot fly in space?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"If they weren't enchanted they wouldn't do anything and then the slave could disobey. There will be an episode about slavery, yes. I sleep but I wouldn't expect you to trust me not to wake up and watch you. I'll tolerate you watching me sleep because there aren't any better options. When you've been here and able to work for a couple weeks and know the laws, then I'll help you find a place of your own."

He wonders why rich people and the government want that many slaves. Maybe labor is more useful where she's from.

"Void magic and death magic are different. It's not that void magic is dangerous every time you use it. No one expects someone to use so much void magic that suddenly there's no air to breathe. But if one void mage gets rid of one pound of stuff one day and then the next day another void mage does the same thing and  then the next day another void mage does the same thing..." Valanda spreads his hands. "Death magic isn't like that. New animals are born to replace the dead ones. Nothing replaces what's lost to void magic. Our flights are force magic unless you have wings. I guess a force mage could get to space. It'd be a long trip and they'd have to carry air and the vital air would be turned into poison as they breathed. And it wouldn't get them anything. They could go light a torch from the sun, I guess, I think that would make the torch transmute elements instead of compounds? But sun mages already do that. I guess maybe they could go pry a star out of the edge of the world and carry it home. I'm not sure what stars are. Maybe they're useful somehow."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you. You are very very kind." (And apparently tried to trick her into magical slavery, which suggests a likelihood of ulterior motives, but that is less useful to say.)

"I'm sorry, I do not understand. Does 'watch' mean more than 'look at'? Does to be looked at when you sleep hurt you?"

"Thank you, I understand."

"Torch? Light a torch from the sun? Why would it do that? Edge of the world?

I know what stars are where I am from; maybe they are the same here. How do you learn about the sun and the stars and what is outside the world?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not sure what you're confused about. If we sleep in the same room, one of us could wake up and look at the other, yes. Or one of us could wake up and try to enchant the other. I don't know anything about the sun and stars, I'm not educated. There might be people here who know what stars are. I think a knowledge mage could tell but I've never asked. I'd like to know what you know about stars."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Where I am from, if someone looks at someone else when they are asleep, nothing bad will happen. Here something bad will happen?

You can enchant differently if someone is asleep?

Could you explain about the torch? This is not a torch that is on fire and for giving light?"

Where she is from, the stars are giant balls of gas very very far away. They are made mostly of the first element and the second element. The sun is a star that the planet is closer to and goes around. You could not light a torch from it, because you could not go near it without dying - they burn and are very very hot. Also the world does not have an edge; it is a sphere.

Permalink Mark Unread

"The sun might be that hot, I guess that would explain how it can heat half the world at a time. The sun is made of the first element and turns it into the second element. Uh, I know that the ground that this building is on is a sphere but I don't know how far the void goes or if there's anything after it. You seem to be confused about some things but I'm not sure what you're confused about. It's sometimes easier to hurt a sleeping person, depending on what kind of magic you have and what kind they have. I don't think it's ever harder. Sleeping people don't notice things and can't protect themselves very well. I guess I could kill you whether you're awake or not. Maybe you could do the same to me if you wanted, I don't know. You seem to know more about the sun than me so maybe I'm wrong about what would happen if you lit a torch from it, if you could do that which you say you can't."

Permalink Mark Unread

Nod.

"Yes, you could.

You could blindfold me, or tie me down while you slept, if that would help you?" (she is not especially worried about her vulnerability to him. If he wants to hurt her, it is and has been clearly trivial for him to do so.)

"I don't know if your sun is the same as my sun." (She is still confused about the torch and the different kinds of magic, but it does not look like trying to clarify is achieving anything useful.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"Of course I could, but there's a chance a judge would decide that was assault. I wouldn't know how to help you figure out if our sun is like yours, I never learned any science. What kind of mage are you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

And even if a judge would accept her testimony that she permitted it, she presumes he cannot trust that she would give it.

Inconvenient. (She does not like that he might have to worry about her all night.)

"I do not think I am a mage. You?" (Not very much point to try to keep this secret, she thinks. If it will cause problems, then such it will.)

Permalink Mark Unread

It will definitely cause problems!

Valanda squeaks. He flaps his hands almost like he's trying to fling something away. "No no no no no no no, I thought, I, I thought it was a, a person, I, I, I, Iri did you know it wasn't a person, did you know and not tell me, it's, it's, it looks, it's, no no no no no no no..."

"She's not less of a person than I am," says Iri.

"You're, you're, that's different, thwilit are people, you're not this, you're not an animal, you don't look like you're whole, you, you, no no no no no, it's a, it's, no no no no no, I, I, I talked to it, I talked to it, I thought, I thought..."

Valanda backs up as far away from her as he can. He stares at her straight on for the first time.

"Do you, is there, is there something wrong with just you or, or, or does your entire world just not have any people, there's no, there's no magic, there's no people..."

Permalink Mark Unread

Yes, this is a problem.

She is very much not sure how to attempt to solve this problem.

"I'm very sorry to distress you. Is there - something particular you're worried about? Have people without your kinds of magic caused some kind of problem?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Our kinds? Do you have some other kind of magic?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"We don't use the word magic for anything we have, but I'm not sure what decides what is magic and what is not? Some people in history used to say that rain came by magic, or birds used magic to navigate, or people with a stronger discerning-sense were magic, or people who could do a lot of math in their heads were magic. Yours seems different than that, but I do not know enough about it right now." (This is not how she would by default have talked about this, but he seems very upset and she is very uncertain of what exactly might talk him down.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri translates "discerning-sense" as "knowledge magic specializing in people's health and other personal information" and Valanda's too desperate to be suspicious that Iri might be phrasing it that way deliberately to calm him down.

"Everyone has discerning-sense?" he asks, borrowing the Capital word. "That's, that's something you can do that animals can't? It not like, not like us, we don't all have the same magic. I think maybe it's a translation problem. It's a translation problem, it's Iri's fault, it's, it's, you have a similar word that doesn't mean the same thing, 'magic'" (in Capital) "doesn't mean magic, it's, it's... unexplained things or something, you just all have an, an unusual type of knowledge magic, and it's all the same so you don't need a word for the whole category, that's all, that's all, you're not, not, not some kind of thing that looks like a person and talks like a person and, okay, you're a knowledge mage and you don't have twelve kinds, that explains a lot, you just have one kind of magic but you have it, because you're people, of course you're people."

Valanda takes several deep breaths.

"I'm so sorry."

Permalink Mark Unread

...Sure. 

'Somewhat lying' is not the most stable of solution mechanisms, but Iri seems to be going along with this one, and she has not currently thought of another one, and he was very very upset (and Iri was not, so this is not just an interworld issue). And this could possibly cause some problem if and when more interworld contact occurs - certainly scientists are still studying discernment-scence, but she's not expecting the answer they produce to be 'magic' any more than she's expecting the answer to 'why is there more matter than antimatter' to be 'magic'.

But if contact occurs she predicts plenty of scientists will promptly insist that the local phenomena clearly has a physical explanation somewhere, and if needed she does not think it will do much harm for her to pretend to be the kind of person who would find 'maybe the answer is magic!' to be an appealing hypothesis.

"We have our discerning-sense and animals do not, yes." (This is clearly not the time to discuss that people with impaired discernment-sense are also people, nor any theories on animals).

"Please don't blame Iri - you are correct, where I am from in the current time "magic" (the Capital word) is only used to mean things that do not happen in our world. If I had read a story about your world it would have called your 'magic' (the Hari word) "magic", so I borrowed the world, and Iri translated what I meant. I did not know there were other concerns, or I would have chosen better words. It is entirely my mistake, and I apologize.

We do not have twelve kinds, though some people can do things with discerning-sense that others can't.

We are definitely people, yes. 

It is very alright. It would be odder, I think, if sudden contact between different words never caused such misunderstandings. Even meetings between different cultures in the same world often do. But we are certainly people.

 

You do not have discerning-sense? That must have been difficult for your ancestors."

Permalink Mark Unread

More deep breaths.

"Oh. It sounds like normal magic doesn't happen in your world, so you were right to use that word for it. And Iri knew what you were talking about, so that was right, too. The definition of our word 'magic' is anything that some but not all people of every species and no animals can do. All people can talk in some kind of language, so that's not magic. Animals can walk, so that's not magic. A twelfth of our population could learn to do what your discerning-sense does. I'm not sure if it's more difficult for us not having it but I doubt it's more difficult than not having death magic."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I do not think we have what you have, no. 

That makes sense." What an interesting - and potentially... problem-involving... concept. "Where I am from, we only have one sentient species, so we may not have had the same concerns.

Are there animals here who don't have magic but will try to learn your language and talk to you like a person would?" (Best find out, if there are - dynamics such as that, present.)

"Yes, having death magic sounds like it could have helped our ancestors.

As it is, discerning-sense is what people use to keep from accidentally begetting a child, and to know if someone is carrying a disease before they have outward symptoms, and to help the sick and injured, especially when there is not technology. So we are fortunate to have had it.

Those are the knowledge mages?" (And, has any of the language she's learned or episodes she's watched tell her anything about this world and strata, or gender?) 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Knowledge mages can do all that. We do have talking animals, they're" a species name she won't have heard yet. "They're black birds bigger than Iri, they eat already dead meat and whatever else they can scavenge. They usually just say 'ah! ah!' but you can catch one and teach it to say 'food' or 'water' when it's hungry or thirsty. I don't think they can use sentences but I think they understand the words they say. Do they have those where you're from?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"We have birds that can be taught words and phrases, but no animals that could carry on a conversation the way I have.

Do knowledge mages read strata for you, then? Or do you not use those at all; I did not see signs in the episodes. And how do most people tell the genders of those they interact with, then?" (The language she'd heard didn't seem to have the words or grammar for it, but that they clearly have - Valanda's is as clear to her as anyone's at home would be, and Iri's was clear if not something she'd encountered before. Which, while she would not find the converse surprising either, should not be surprising, for another species.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri attempts translations. "Awareness of your sex" comes across, with caveats. The other thing is harder. Iri spends a while trying to explain what they're getting.

"Thank you, Iri. Okay, no, I think only Iri's species has strata, if we understand what that is. With some species you can tell sex by looking. For instance, caralendri women are larger than caralendri men."

Iri interrupts. "Not sex. Them knowing their sex."

"Oh! You can read minds? But only to tell what someone else believes their sex is? How can you tell the difference between that and being able to tell what sex they are? Are people wrong about that a lot?"

This is such an uncomfortable topic for Valanda. He didn't really need to have to think about someone looking at him and thinking about him being a woman. Looking at him and thinking that's something important to know. Oh, and the mind-reading. That's also bad.

Permalink Mark Unread

The complexity of translation is at least a strong suggestion that something is different. She listens for words she knows and such.

She considers the implications of a society mostly without strata (not, of course, that she is likely to be able to accurately project-imagine. Though fortunately she in this case will not need to.) 

Nod. "That would be a great difference from the Empire I am from, then, if you do not have strata." 

She tries to understand the rest of what he's saying. Since he said 'with some species' it seems to be about the gender part of what she asked rather than the strata part. 'With some species you can tell __ by looking. For instance, caralendri ___ are larger than caralendri ____'. Given the topic she might assume those should be 'gender' and some genders, but given the rest of the phrases that's blatantly nonsensical. As would 'Not __. Them knowing their __' be, in that case.

She attempts to generate possibilities; considers them with models of a world in which people don't have a discerning-sense...

"...People in your world guess people's genders by looking at them? ...That sounds like it would be distressing for a lot of people!" (...Mental shuddering is not to be allocated space in her active mind right now; that space is needed and being used.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Does your society use 'gender' to decide how to treat people? In that case I will pay you one ring if at the end of a month you've acted as if you believe I'm male. Does that sound good? ...Do you understand what I'm offering?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...we use it to decide what pronouns and words and inflections to use when we talk? Hari has seemed not to have those. Is that what you do? ...that also seems as though it would be distressing to many people.

I'm sorry, I don't know a core word, there. You're offering to pay me to act as though I believe you're... something? Is that a gender-category here? ...Have I been using the wrong one for you? I am so very sorry if so. My discerning-sense has been saying you're male, but perhaps it doesn't read accurately given a different world. I'm very sorry; of course I'll change that immediately, if you let me know what I should use." (If this is the case she needs to apologize and such further of course, but confirming the problem is first, there.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri is able to translate that very straightforwardly.

"Your discerning-sense says I'm male," he says in Hari. (Mind-reading! She can read his mind!) "It has to be reading something about my thoughts or my preferences. I'm..." Valanda grimaces and twitches. "I'm not male, I'm..." (Valanda looks like he's just bitten into a lemon and has to stop and steel himself) "...female, you could tell if I undressed, but I want you to keep acting like I'm male. But that's what your discerning-sense can see, isn't it? You have enough people who are wrong about their sex to know you're looking at people's thoughts and you have a word for the thing that's in people's minds instead of their bodies. Because you can read minds. Can you read minds in any other circumstances? Can you see my memories? My favorite foods?"

"What gender am I?" Iri asks.

Permalink Mark Unread

She continues to try to put understanding together from what she can gather. ("minds", "bodies", "wrong about", "undressed", the way he flinches and steels himself...). Form a resultant picture. Appropriately take into account 'if something seems rather inconceivable and a skew line, that can be expected of a different world' and 'it is easy to let too little data and an imagination run away with one', knowing she is likely still affected by both biases.

(Will continue to not be allocating space to personal emotional reactions to the forming picture; that is not what she is doing at the moment.)

 

"If - I am understanding correctly. Your - system - seems very - unfortunately set up, in this regard. And has been - significantly harmful and distressing to you personally, if I am understanding correctly. I'm sorry.

Of course I will keep acting in accordance with your gender.

We - I suppose I would imagine we have some people who are wrong about their gender - people are wrong about all sorts of things, they can be wrong about their favorite color or about if they are in love. It - does not seem often very generally relevant?

I - would have said I do not understand how undressing is relevant, but if I understand correctly your society - guesses gender from what body someone has? Again, I'm very sorry.

...In my society purposely referring to someone as a different gender than they are is understood as psychological torture."

 

"I - do not think I can read minds? I can sometimes understand what people are thinking from their body language and similar, but it helps to have more background social knowledge than I do here. I - do not know anything of your memories or food preferences."

 

"Not something I've run into previously," she says to Iri.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Your 'gender' is something inside your mind? It's... the sex that your mind has?" Valanda uses the Capital word for lack of a Hari word for gender. "Here no one talks about that. My gender is male. Your discerning-sense is correct."

That's all in conveniently short, carefully enunciated sentences so she has a better chance of understanding. He can't quite say everything he wants to that way though.

"What purpose does sorting people by gender serve in your society?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Understood. Is there something you would prefer in my actions, that would be affirming here, as you lack it in language?

I - suppose it is in your mind. Most facts about oneself are, are they not.

I'm not certain exactly what 'sex' means, as you use it? It is about bodies? We have [{word for what might be summarized as 'traits that tend to come up in body dysphoria'}], and [{word for 'can you get pregnant or get people pregnant', generally private}]. And [{'reproductive class'; used to talk about animals and plants and such}]. 

Many people in my world prefer it - they find it psychologically salutary when it is correct, and upsetting when it is not, or when it is not acknowledged and they wish it to be. Some people find it an important feature of partner selection. Some people find it pleasant to sometimes be in groups of those similar. Not everyone has such a preference, or cares. But it is very common."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Sex is the third thing. Sex is" her word for it. "Some people don't care about sex most of the time. Agerah don't care very much. Essi don't care at all. Caralendri care a lot. I think... a lot of male caralendri want to be female. I'm not sure if that's gender. It might be. But they aren't treated like it just because they want to be. Caralendri have to change sex before they can change how people treat them. Does that make sense?"

Permalink Mark Unread

...She supposes if everyone in one's species were [agender in the 'not experiencing gender' way] and no one had [physical dysphoria] it might - make some sense to use ['reproductive class'] for people? Though clearly there is not a good reason to extend that to people who had those things. Perhaps there was some past power dynamic among species that was responsible for the phenomenon? (Continuation of suppressing shudders and the like.)

"I think so. I'm - very sorry about your society.

Change sex? Is that like [{word for something like ''transition'-related physical change-making things}]."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes. It's that. Caralendri do that. No one else here does that. Where you're from, people change sex?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Not like caralendri," says Iri. "On purpose, not by accident. I think they cut off breasts."

Valanda blinks.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I do not know what caralendri do. We have technology to change some [{'traits that tend to come up in body dysphoria' word}]. Not currently enough to do everything people can want - we cannot currently cause a body to produce different gametes, or let someone become able to carry a pregnancy. Further advances are worked on, and hoped for. But we have various forms of surgery, and can change our hormone balances, and such things."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You cannot cause a body to produce different gametes." Turns out Hari has a word for gametes, who knew. "You cannot cause someone to be able to carry a pregnancy. You can cause your 'hormone balance' to change." If Hari has a word for hormones it's not one Iri and Valanda know. "We cannot cause someone to be able to carry a pregnancy. We cannot cause a body to produce different gametes. We cannot cause a 'hormone balance' to change. Caralendri don't cause it. The body produces different gametes. They can carry a pregnancy. The 'hormone balance' changes. No person causes it." Shrug. "Tell me more about causing these things tomorrow. I have to go to work in the morning. I'm going to sleep now. I'm going to lock the door in a way you can't unlock. If you want to go sleep in the hallway, leave now. Otherwise the door doesn't open till morning."

Permalink Mark Unread

Acknowledging of the new information.

 

If she's worried someone will assault her or the like, the hallway clearly gives more people the opportunity. If she's worried he'll assault her, being in the hallway is not actually particularly likely to protect her.

"I would prefer to stay here, if that's alright?" May she make a final trip to the restroom and such?

Permalink Mark Unread

She can do that.

"If I left it so you could open it, a force mage could open it from the outside," he says.

Permalink Mark Unread

That is useful to know. (She says so.)

"Is that a common problem?"

 

Is anyone else in the bathroom? Does it have stalls or the like?

Permalink Mark Unread

"No, because it's hard to do and illegal."

There's more than one! None of them are human. None of them try to talk to her. It has curtains that reach from almost the ceiling all the way down to the floor.

Permalink Mark Unread

She can observe herself to have manifested a desire to hide behind a curtain when undressing. That - will need to be dealt with. Cannot really be dealt with right now, and there's not benefit to potentially causing trouble for herself without need. She hides behind a curtain.

Permalink Mark Unread

No one seems to think there's anything unusual about wanting to hide behind a curtain.

As soon as she gets back Valanda locks the door and curls up on the floor to sleep.

Permalink Mark Unread

Will it bother him if she watches the not-video some more? Can she do that in the dark?

Permalink Mark Unread

It's not like she can make it stop playing. In the dark it's weird, too visible for the amount of ambient light but it doesn't work as well at illuminating things around it as it should for how bright it is.

Aaaaaand he's Mahan and he'll be teaching Hari! This episode is about the water cycle. There is a cloud up there. This is water. This is the ocean. This is a river. This is a river delta. The episode is filmed while flying, she can get a good bird's-eye view of part of the continent. It makes pointing at a whole river more convenient. Water evaporates, it goes up, it goes from the ocean to the cloud. Then there is rain, the water goes down, it goes to the river. Then the river goes to the ocean...

Permalink Mark Unread

She wonders idly if they planed some of these episodes by taking submissions.

She continues with learning strategies.

Then, careful to give her host his space as best as she can given what is available, she also sleeps.

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda gets up very early. He makes sure she's also awake and lets her know he's leaving. Iri goes with him.

The show is still playing. The next episode is about formal logic.

Permalink Mark Unread

She wakes up when he does.

She plans to sleep more at some point, but vocabulary for formal logic is of interest. She listens.

Permalink Mark Unread

Then she can learn how they say because, therefore, imply, premise, conclusion...

The second half of the episode seems to be about probability.

The next episode is about... she won't have heard the name of the subject in Hari before, but it's another one with diagrams.

Permalink Mark Unread

Useful words.

She'll listen to that one too.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's about game theory. It's also propaganda. This is the prisoner's dilemma! It works like this! The government's job is to force everyone to cooperate! It's true that if not for the government you could kill or eat or kill and then eat your neighbors but actually they would probably beat you to it and you'd be sad. And dead. And tasty.

This is a stag hunt. This is cake-cutting. This is chicken. The Hari names might be different than she's used to but if she's familiar with the concepts they're pretty similar.

Completely absent: any mention of altruism in experimental results. Maybe they just didn't think it was interesting to talk about? It's kind of a long episode even without any speculation about that.

Permalink Mark Unread

Useful episode.

She's familiar with the concepts, and as attentive to localizations as she can be given her vocabulary level.

Lack of discussion of altruism will not actually be something she finds unusual, given where she herself first learned the concepts - it is not as though her parents sold her into slavery for being a Protector because it was high status.

But it is notable to her that this is the approach in an educational dissemination apparently made generally available. As well as that game theory is included in it to begin with (and used as a propaganda tool, apparently, here.) (Back home, of course, game theory is certainly curriculumized for Alphas, but not generally otherwise.)

Permalink Mark Unread

The next episode is about slavery. Some people can't just participate freely in society because they keep breaking laws or don't understand the law. Such people need to be enslaved or else their neighbors are in danger. You can only become a slave after committing certain crimes, usually more than once, or being too disabled to understand the law or being born. Not being born to enslaved parents, just being born.

Slavery can be enforced by using command magic. Oh look it's the bracelets. Command magic can keep people from doing things but not make people do things.

Make sure you don't free any slaves who aren't allowed to be free! If you buy a criminal you can't just dump them where they could commit more crimes. If you have a disabled child you don't want to take care of don't worry, you can get help getting rid of them!

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah, good. She pays attention.

...She sees. That - certainly explains the ability of a common person to own a slave. And likely connects to the explanation of slavery Valanda had given being 'responsibility' focused as it was.

 

Is it said how one frees a slave? Is it said how people generally stop being slaves, given the 'born' form?

 

Charming. (...do people in general in this world tend psychologically/sociologically Alpha-like?)

 

She files information as informative about the world, and about people and situations she may encounter. As well as into the 'problems of the world she is aware of' category.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's mentioned that you're allowed to free them if they're able to follow the law. There's no more detail than that.

People in general in this world show few signs of being held back by moral concerns. The slavery episode, for instance, includes no rhetoric about it being for the slaves' own good.

The sky brightens. There are some simpler episodes where Mahan just points to things and names them. Some of them overlap with previous episodes. It's hours before Valanda comes back.

Permalink Mark Unread

She would not expect such rhetoric particularly, but she will notice the pattern.

Such episodes, and overlap, are useful.

She watches episodes, and practices vocabulary, and practices putting together communication. She takes breaks for cognitive reasons as well as for exercise, water, and restroom use (she uses the curtain). She continues, for now, to avoid being out of the apartment except when necessary.

Permalink Mark Unread

Eventually he does come back with a platter of dried fruits and bag of nuts. He sits down and sets them down in front of him.

"Have some if you're hungry," he says. He has some of the fruit. "How's your Hari now?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She is hungry, and has some fruit and nuts. (Her caloric and nutritional needs are really not being sufficiently met, but she is used to that kind of thing and is not planning on commenting on it without further information, yet.)

Her Hari is improving. She can demonstrate. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"That's great progress, you're very fast. I think we can try asking you some questions." At least she won't have to answer in Hari, they have Iri. "Tell me what you know about biology."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you.

Could I first ask you about some laws?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes, ask."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You listed things that were illegal, yesterday.

In my country some other things are illegal - it is illegal to try to overthrow or undermine the government, and to say negative things about important people connected to the government. And there are laws about - social hierarchy, and behavior. Do you have those?"

Permalink Mark Unread

That seems far beyond her language skills but okay if she wants to try to talk about it now. He tries to explain in short declarative sentences with smallish words.

"You can take over the government by convincing people to vote for you. It is illegal to try to take over the government by killing the people in charge. It is illegal not to follow the law. It is illegal not to pay taxes. You can tell people you don't like the government. If we understand 'social hierarchy' you mean what caralendri and thwilit do. The government does not care about that. Iri says 'behavior' means things you do. All our laws are about things you do. I'm not sure I understand your questions correctly."

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, it's rather important to know.

"Vote?

I don't know what caralendri and thwilit do. In my country, if I write a paper that says someone in the government is - terrible and incompetent, I can be arrested. If I go to someone of a higher strata and insult them or am rude to them, I can be arrested."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Voting is... if the Imperial Chief Justice dies, who will be Imperial Chief Justice? Seihra says 'I would be good at it' and Ariu says 'I would be better' and Seihra tells people why she would be the best and Ariu tells people why he would be the best. Then free people say 'I want Seihra' or 'I want Ariu' or both. Then we count how many people want Seihra. We count how many people want Ariu. If more people want Ariu then Ariu is the new Imperial Chief Justice. That is voting. Voting is saying you want Ariu or Seihra.

"It is not illegal to be rude. It's dangerous but it's not illegal."

He's not sure how to explain caralendri. If she spoke Ilan and he felt like spending even more money on her he'd get her a soap opera to watch and figure it out herself. But she doesn't and he doesn't.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Ah, I see.

We do not do that for the government.

What decides who can say 'I want to do that, vote for me'?

It is dangerous because the person you are rude to might attack you? Is that legal for them to do?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"It is not legal to attack people but they might be rude to you. They might not want to buy from you or sell to you. They might illegally attack you.

"Saying 'I want to do that, vote for me' is called running for office. The answer depends on the office. It's different for the Imperial Chief Justice than it is for the Governor of Anavel Sani. For every office you have to be free."

Permalink Mark Unread

Understood.

"How do people become free?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Their owners choose to free them. There's a little paperwork, not much. Or sometimes they're free if their owners die."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I heard in the slavery episode it's different if they're a criminal?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes. It's illegal to free someone who can't follow the law. I don't know if you're legally allowed to be free here, that's one reason I don't want you going places and talking to people. You could break a law by accident. I don't know if I would be in trouble if you did."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Why would you be in trouble?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I didn't tell anyone that you're here and don't know how to follow our laws. I didn't enslave you, either."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Is there a law that you should?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't think there are laws about what to do if someone from another universe gets accidentally teleported to your apartment. I think someone will decide what the laws about that should be after they find out about you. I think it's less likely they'll decide I did anything wrong if you follow our laws."

Permalink Mark Unread

Nod.

"I want to learn your laws and how to act.

The episode said you can only become a slave after committing certain crimes, usually more than once, or being too disabled to understand the law or being born - is that not entirely the case, then?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's if you can't follow the law. If you're too young to. If you can't understand it for some reason. If no one taught you. Even if there's no reason, if you just clearly don't do it and no one is sure why. Those are just... examples of how you'd tell, I think. And some people are executed instead, for the same crimes, it depends on whether they think it's possible to control you. They'd kill me, for instance."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm sorry. Why?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Because they can't use command magic on me. I'm warded."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You are - defense?"

And - it would be incorrect to do this lightly, and unideal to have her current limits on information sources. But she does have the not-video, which would be hard to fake, and has not been lying as far as she can ascertain. If he wishes her harm he can do her harm. He should not be harmed by her, that is not acceptable.

"If it is so much safer for you, and possibly the law, and you will promise to free me again when I am better oriented, you can go ahead and put those on me."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You want me to say I'll free you? Is that right? Why?" Maybe there's some additional magic that she didn't realize was magic in her world, something to make promises binding somehow?

Permalink Mark Unread

She considers whether or not to tell him. Certainly not that she reads lies well; he'd be more careful about it then, if he tried, and she'd have less information. Something partial, maybe.

"If you'd said something like 'why would you need me to promise, don't you trust me' that would be suspicious, and that would be useful information, then.

If there's a way to sign a contract I'd certainly prefer it but I can easily imagine possibilities where that would be impossible or cause too much trouble."

 

Permalink Mark Unread

He has no idea whether, in the case where they decide she shouldn't be allowed to be free in the Hari Empire, contracts with her would be valid.

He's pretty tempted but this seems like an obvious trap. He's not sure what kind of trap it is exactly but it's definitely some kind of trap. A really confusing one that might involve otherworldly magic he's not familiar with.

"I don't have to do that if you stay here and read the laws when I bring you a copy."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I would not want to stay here forever, but I can certainly stay until I have learned enough, and would very much want to read the laws.

You have been very generous to me, and I certainly would not want your life to be in danger over me."

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, now he gets it, she cares about fairness like an agerah.

"I'll be back soon. I'm going to bring you laws to read."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you."

Permalink Mark Unread

It's a while before he's back. When he returns he has another pair of metal things. They're both a lot larger than the one for Hari Ar Sarag Marsaehu. But for what they are they're surprisingly small. They show live feeds of documents but it might not be obvious they're live feeds because they're just sitting there. The titles are Hari Imperial Law and Ehima State Law. Each one has a color-changing circle with a hole in it in one corner.

Ehima State Law is double-sided and written in small writing but it's a pretty unwieldy size even so, maybe two square feet.

"Ask me if you don't understand," says Valanda.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you.

I can't read yet."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh, right, I said I'd teach you." He sighs and sits down. He opens his notebook. He writes some symbols. He points to each one and makes a sound. It's not a hard alphabet as alphabets go and he doesn't seem to be explaining a dozen ways to pronounce each letter.

Permalink Mark Unread

She knows some of them, but she's not going to give sign of it, given how she obtained the knowledge. She pays attention. She has a good memory and very good sight-cipher-reading (which this in some sense amounts to). Is he including the tones and such?

Permalink Mark Unread

Yep, he shows her how each vowel is written for each tone. The system might not be obvious but it's consistent and easy to remember.

Permalink Mark Unread

She doesn't expect orthographies to be generally derivable from first principles. She continues to pay attention. Can she make her own copy of the alphabet?

Permalink Mark Unread

He lends her his pencil for it and examines her writing to see if she's doing it right.

Permalink Mark Unread

Letters, letters. No letter combinations doing something different? If there are she should note those.

Permalink Mark Unread

None that he mentions.

Iri, meanwhile, watches the whole lesson.

Permalink Mark Unread

Whenever he feels he's covered what needs to be covered, she can start attempting to make her way through the laws.

Permalink Mark Unread

The imperial laws should be mostly familiar to her by now. Turns out there aren't very many of them. The language is very precise and detailed. Punishments for first, second and third offenses are listed. They sometimes differ by species but in general they're pretty lenient for an empire with no concept of morality and no qualms about ripping people apart to make an example of them. Fines are the first resort for most things.

Ehima has a lot more laws about a wider variety of things. Making any false statement in the course of advertising any product is punishable by a fine, for instance. There are state taxes, too. Her lack of familiarity with these laws will probably leave her confused by the legal language.

Permalink Mark Unread

She's going to be confused by legal language a lot, that is a fairly predictable consequence of having started learning the language yesterday.

She makes use of Valanda's offer and asks as needed.

Are there in fact no sedition laws? What are punishments between 'fines' and 'execution'? Can she get any information on torture use from this? What happens if someone cannot afford a fine?

Permalink Mark Unread

It's not illegal in itself but Ehima has some state laws that could stretch to cover sedition if judges were motivated to interpret them that way. Imperial law has no restrictions on speech but a lot of the actions someone interested in overthrowing them might want to take are otherwise illegal.

Besides fines and execution there are classes about the importance of the law and how to meet your needs without breaking it. Command magic can be used just to keep someone from being violent. Ehima sometimes exiles immigrants but not natives. No one seems to be sentenced to torture but it isn't specified how people condemned to death should be killed and it certainly doesn't say it should be humane or gentle. There is no information on how the courts determine guilt but it doesn't say they don't torture suspects. It doesn't say what happens to people who can't afford fines, either.

Permalink Mark Unread

What kinds of laws and actions?

She blinks somewhat at "classes about the importance of the law and how to meet your needs without breaking it". (If she ends up back in her world, maybe Myra can find a way to import that.)

That seems like an omission. She asks Valanda about the fines. Also about the legal process.

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's not always the same thing. There's judicial discretion and sometimes if your victim is alive they can have some influence. The way we know who's guilty is by using knowledge magic. Sometimes we can watch what happened."

Permalink Mark Unread

What kind of variety of things can happen?

That is a useful thing to be able to do.

Permalink Mark Unread

"You can be enslaved or killed. You can just pay as much as you have. You can pay some and then pay more later."

Permalink Mark Unread

Nod.

Law reading.

Anything else likely relevant to her? Anything she expects to have a difficult time following?

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, theft is illegal even if the property you're stealing is a person and they asked you to, for one thing.

Permalink Mark Unread

This is not in the least surprising.

Anything particularly complicated? Are there in fact no laws about appropriate social behavior toward one's 'betters' and so on?

Also, while she is reading, what are the laws on how one may treat one's slaves?

Permalink Mark Unread

There are in fact no laws on either of those things! Sort of. The fine for freeing someone who can't follow the law is higher if the reason they can't is because of your actions, for instance because you hit them on the head until they were too brain-damaged to understand what's against the law.

There might be more complexity hidden in other documents these ones reference, like the one defining adequate safety precautions in building design. Immigration and forest use are both kind of complicated but not likely to be relevant to Sheridan unless she decides to move away somewhere.

Permalink Mark Unread

Charming.

 

If she decides to design a building, immigrate, or use a forest, she will research accordingly.

Permalink Mark Unread

He has to leave again in the afternoon.

There's an episode on the names of different professions. This caralendar is a farmer, he grows apples. This human is a butcher, she sells meat. This essi is a professional defense mage who makes wood buildings fireproof. This caralendar fishes. This agerah is a tutor who teaches people to read.

Magic seems to make a lot of things easier. The farmer can sit down and use magic to make his apples pull themselves off the trees, for instance. But magic seems to be the biggest source of labor-saving inventions: they don't seem to have tractors or chemical fertilizers.

Valanda doesn't have time to answer more questions before bed. He doesn't bring dinner.

Permalink Mark Unread

From all these 'this is', does she have a general derived understanding of what all the species are and what they're called?

Can she gather anything on how this works with who has what jobs (obviously they can't be doing it by strata) and how people obtain them? And how this relates to what magic they have?

 

This is going to become a problem, and probably indicates an underlying one. Three options seem to occur: 1) he needs less food than her, and has not realized she needs more. 2) he is eating while away and not bringing her enough for some reason he has. 3) he is also not eating enough.

Can she noting anything that would point to one of those? Does he seem hungry/show signs people do when hungry? Conversely, does he show signs of having eaten while away? (How about Iri?)

Permalink Mark Unread

She should probably be able to name the species of people in any crowd scenes she sees, if she remembers everything she's learned. The big cats are agerah, the other furry creatures are beluli, the humanoids are caralendri, the birds are thwilit, the snakes are essi, the parasitic worms are ereli.  There doesn't seem to be any information about certain species doing certain jobs. There are some obvious inferences she could make about non-force mage essi and thwilit.

He does look a little thin but not enough so to be sure he's not eating well. He seems annoyed but it's hard to be sure if that's because he's hungry, because he's sharing space with a stranger, because he spent so much of his savings recently, because he's spent so much of his free time answering her questions...

Iri doesn't eat the same foods and might be eating while they're out.

Permalink Mark Unread

She has a good memory. (Parasitic worms?)

Any observations she can make about people in some jobs seeming more well off than others, having apprentices or children with them...?

 

She will attempt more active inquiries in the morning.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's a little hard to tell who's how well-off in a society where different things are hard to get. There are sometimes children in crowd scenes. All of them have bracelets. Some are working. Whether they're the children of the people they're working for isn't always clear except in the case of one human child carrying things for a snake.

Permalink Mark Unread

She might still expect things like more worn clothes to correspond with less wealth? What kind of differences in personal adornment and such do people display? In body language?

Permalink Mark Unread

She might find that the number of coin necklaces someone is wearing is a more obvious clue, except that people clearly don't go out visibly wearing all of their money.

There's an agerah who seems to have dyed his fur dark blue and a belul who's dyed hers glossy black, but most people don't have dyed fur. Most bracelets are gold but some are other metals. Some people have necklaces that aren't coins and don't resemble the bracelets. An essi slave, awkwardly wearing a bracelet like a belt, has an intricate design painted on his head.

Or there could just be naturally blue fur and natural variation in essi patterns. It's hard to say.

Permalink Mark Unread

Hard to say is to be expected, from having just arrived in a different world. She'll keep collecting. (She doesn't like the feeling of it, like missing a sense, almost. But that is hardly the important thing.)

(Citizen's cards appear to not be used here, meanwhile.)

 

She works on Hari and sleeps, again.

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda wakes up and wakes her up early again.

His stomach growls audibly. That could just mean he's going to get breakfast out. Maybe.

Permalink Mark Unread

She wakes up when he does without needing to be woken.

If he has a moment of attention for her, she's wondering if there's maybe some kind of work she could do, to pay him back somewhat for his generosity, and possibly for more food? Some kind of piecework she could do from here maybe, if she still should not go out?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Can you make anything? Can you repair anything?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She can, but she isn't sure what kinds of things that she can do need doing in this world, since it's so different, and she images if she tries to guess she'll come up with things that do not and therefore sound silly. As two examples, she can sew and embroider by hand, and she thinks she would make a fairly good calculator.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Can you make shirts and pants that humans can wear? Like these?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Probably not near as quickly as someone who's done it for a while, but given a pattern and materials she'd expect so. (Of reasons she expected it to be useful to be able to impersonate different strata, this was not one, but that hardly means she can't use the skills.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"I might be able to market that. Anything else you can do? Can you spin wool?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Theoretically, but not very well, and it's been a while since she's practiced; her sewing and embroidery are much better. She can knit and crochet - worse than sewing, still much better than spinning. (Do they have crochet?) She can do a few other threadcrafts and expects she could pick up more if needed. She expects she can pick up many sorts of small labor-intensive handtasks. She can repair various things from her world, but expects things to be different here.

Do they have calculators? (The job, not the technology; she assumes they do not have that.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"I can ask around and see if anyone needs a lot of computation done. If they do I can show you how to write numbers. Anyway, I'll let you know if I know more when I get back, I need to leave now."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you."

She goes back to Hari. She pays attention to various details. Does this world appear to have plastic? Synthetic fabrics? The printing press?

Permalink Mark Unread

Probably none of those but it sure is hard to tell what materials things that might be under illusions are made of. The printing press seems to be an almost definite no. Things in general look handmade.

Permalink Mark Unread

Then when Valanda returns she'll suggest copying writing as another task she might be able to do.

And eventually potentially see about selling formulas.

Permalink Mark Unread

He's in a bad mood when he gets back but it doesn't seem to be directed at her. He's carrying some papers.

"Someone needs help calculating tides," he says. "Tides are when the ocean gets bigger and smaller. More information in here." He hands over the papers. They include one blank one but it won't be enough space. "Ready to learn how to write numbers?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes, thank you.

Are you alright?"

Permalink Mark Unread

How about if he just completely ignores that question. Certain letters double as numbers, isn't that neat. Here's one, two, three, six, twelve, a hundred forty-four. If you want to write seven you write six and then one. Sixteen is twelve three one. Here's a plus sign, here's a minus sign, here's times and divided by.

"If there isn't anything then you leave a space. Some people put bars on either side of it like this or a circle around it like this to show you left it blank on purpose because there's nothing."

If she's still attentive he'll explain the calendar.

Permalink Mark Unread

Do they seem to be using something like base-12, then? And not have place value?

She's attentive. She asks about other important symbols (parentheses? equals? variable conventions? decimal (possilbly not decimal, here) points/fractions? negative numbers? trigonometric functions?)

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, Valanda doesn't seem to be familiar with place value or parentheses or functions. Whether that's because they haven't been invented yet is unclear.

"Those are good questions."

He takes his remaining savings and walks out.

Permalink Mark Unread

Different math system and lack of conveniences will slow her down (she could convert to the system she's accustomed to, but they may want to see her calculations) but if he left her the pencil she'll get to work on the tide calculations.

(Does observing Iri get her any more possible information on what the problem might be?)

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri is afraid but not shrinking away from Valanda.

After an hour they come back with an agerah. Valanda doesn't even try to invite him in. The agerah rests in the hall and sticks just his head in the door.

"I'm Saiu. I teach math. May I use the wall with the window for visual aids?"

"Yes, do that," says Valanda.

"How much do you know now?" Saiu asks Sheridan.

Permalink Mark Unread

...It would have been convenient if he had told her about this plan first, so that she could prepare and ask relevant questions. But this is how it is.

With no direction, she goes for her Iota body language.

Considers the risks, but she needs to know, and it had been said the Empire is multilingual, and most people cannot recognize every language that exists on hearing it.

She will ask Valanda in Capital (and as few and simple words as possible) if she should lie or tell the truth.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not sure what you mean," he says in Capital. In Hari: "ask him your math questions."

Permalink Mark Unread

Maybe his cognitive functions are being affected by hunger.

"I'm sorry," she says politely to Saiu.

He has suggested that if she's found out about the wrong way he might get executed. And she thinks she might manage survival at this point, if he throws her out in anger.

It is very likely, she says to Valanda (in Capital), that she knows some math this world does not, does math in some different ways from this world, and so on. If she is truthful about her knowledge, Saiu might notice this. If this is the point, she can do that. Otherwise, she needs to try to pretend otherwise.

Permalink Mark Unread

"She's hesitant to ask how to write some things because she isn't sure if her ideas are new and doesn't want you to steal the credit. Can we work out a deal where you don't tell anyone what she says?"

"Twenty-four rings."

"I don't have that many. Three?"

They work out a deal. Valanda pays extra. He is even less happy than before.

Permalink Mark Unread

This really seems to be defeating the purpose. Not much she can think to do about it right now.

Could Valanda say 'truth' in Capital (which she will just said, so he doesn't have to already remember) if she should tell the truth about the math she knows?

Permalink Mark Unread

If she says that whole phrase he'll tell her to tell the truth about the math, very heavy emphasis.

Permalink Mark Unread

She says the whole phrase.

Understood (not that she was planning differently, with respect to not telling other truths).

Truth it is.

She's not sure how they divide up subjects here, she says to Saiu. She uses a somewhat different math-writing system. It goes by tens and has place value and a symbol for 0. Here are some things she doesn't know how to write in this system (she repeats the ones from before, if she knows the words from asking Valanda, and paraphrases otherwise). She knows adding and subtracting and multiplying and dividing numbers, and working with math and shapes, and working with variables and functions, and the math having to do with triangles, and some other things also. (She does not know how to say 'arithmetic' or 'geometry' or 'algebra' or 'trigonometry' and asking for translations is probably suspicious). (She purposely limits the list for now - she is still not entirely sure Valanda understands potential situations, here, and it is more possible to say more than to unsay.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Saiu can guess some of what she means.

Variables are represented by whatever squiggle you happen to feel like making. He demonstrates with illusions on the wall. There's a straightforward equivalent to parentheses. There's a way to write fractions and negative numbers.

Math having to do with triangles? He knows some math having to do with triangles. Did she know the angles add up to a straight line? Isn't that neat. He's not really sure what math having to do with triangles she's thinking of but he's very interested in possibly meeting her again later when her Hari is better to ask her about her decimal system.

Permalink Mark Unread

She did know that, it is very neat. Other shapes have similar things but triangles have other neat things.

She is working on her Hari!

Symbols for say sine (she paraphrases)? Exponents? Square roots etc? Logarithms? Infinity? Factorials? Permutations and combinations? Pi? (She paraphrases a lot). How do they write very large and very small numbers? (this is also relevant to her curiousity about mages, though she doesn't mention this.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Saiu is pretty impressed that she came up with these ideas independently. There are conventions for writing some of them but others don't seem to be formalized the way she's used to. The ratio of a circle's circumference to its radius is approximately six and forty-one hundred-forty-fourths but it doesn't have a special name or symbol.

Permalink Mark Unread

Math is very interesting.

She will ask him various other things. Are there things he thinks are important she may not have thought of? In between, she will try to acquire more world information. How much math do most people know? What kinds of things do people usually learn more math for? Where do new math ideas usually come from?

Permalink Mark Unread

Educated people can do arithmetic, at least, but Saiu's not sure what else people learn if they don't care about the subject. Saiu can't really understand needing a reason besides how great math is to learn math. Math ideas come from people noticing things! Two hundred years ago a caralendar noticed that a cone has a third the volume of a cylinder with the same base and height. More recently a different caralendar came up with a trick for quickly finding all the primes up to a certain number.

If she wants to learn things systematically he can recommend a book! Just a ring for the recommendation! Valanda winces and scowls.

Permalink Mark Unread

Math is great, but some people also want to use it for jobs. Do people usually do their own accounts? Does the government hire people to do math and figure out things like taxes? Do people learn math to build things?

Interesting! (She wants to ask if it is a coincidence that both were caralendri, but is wary of the topic without knowing more, and does not ask.)

She politely declines the recommendation.

What math is he usually hired to teach people?

Permalink Mark Unread

Saiu does his own accounts. Math is used for taxes and building things and timekeeping and other things. So far this year he's taught four young agerah to do arithmetic but last year he had more interesting work, someone wanted to know how to draw regular polygons.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, does he teach the timekeeping, she would like to know more about that.

Oh?

Permalink Mark Unread

He talks about timekeeping for a while.

Eventually he's spent as long at this as Valanda paid for.

Permalink Mark Unread

She pays attention. She thanks him.

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda closes and locks the door. He stares out the window for a while.

Permalink Mark Unread

She won't disturb him. (She'll review math notes.) (Any Alpha instincts toward 'why on earth did you do that' and the like that weren't taken care of by being a Protector, practicing for and years of slavery more or less did for.)

(It does occur to her that if he decides to hit her lack of discerning sense is an additional factor that would make that a more dangerous proposition. She strategizes for how to attempt to handle that.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"You eat when you finish your tide table. And so do I."

He leaves. Iri stays.

Permalink Mark Unread

Does Iri by any chance know what's wrong? (And be at liberty to say?)

(Also, does Iri by chance know if the tide-table-orderers want to see her calculations?)

Permalink Mark Unread

"Lost his job. Ariu doesn't think defense magic is the right kind and wants to try some other kind now. I don't know if they want to see your calculations."

Permalink Mark Unread

That would certainly be a reason for a bad mood.

She thanks Iri for the information. Ariu? Also, does Iri by chance know why he suddenly decided to hire Saiu?

She will continue to assume they do, then, and write out the calculations in the local system, though she can still speed up the process by mental arithmetic whose answer she then writes down.

Permalink Mark Unread

Aaaaaa. Iri is not an authority on anything. Aaaaaaaaaaaa!

Iri guesses.

"You couldn't do the work you're supposed to without knowing more math."

Permalink Mark Unread

She can tell Iri is anxious, but not specifically about what. Produces some guesses.

Offers reassurance that she won't be annoyed by not-100%-correct information, that she is asking to have more information than she does otherwise not to make final conclusions from only that, and she won't be annoyed if Iri doesn't want to answer.

She's still curious about Ariu, if there is anything Iri could tell her.

She suspects from nonverbals she's getting better at this to be a guess and not knowledge. She thanks Iri anyway. ('Did it maybe occur to him to ask me first' is not a useful question to ask Iri, and she won't).

Permalink Mark Unread

"Ariu wants to be immortal. I don't know anything else. Is there anything else I can do for you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She sees, thank you.

Does xie know where Valanda went? Does xie know anything more than Sheridan does about behavior advice given the mood?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Probably looking for work. I don't know."

Permalink Mark Unread

Sheridan thanks her again. She works on tide calculations.

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda comes back with some honey for Iri and a list of unsolved problems that rich eccentric math enthusiasts have offered prizes for solving. They can make rent if Sheridan can square a circle or calculate two pi to the nearest sixty-one billion nine hundred seventeen million three hundred sixty four thousand two hundred twenty-fourth.

"If none of those seem easier than the tide chart just keep working on that."

Permalink Mark Unread

Squaring a circle has actually been proven to be impossible, if that is of interest to the enthusiast. She has to do a calculation to figure out which place that corresponds to, but does know pi to more places than that and can convert the relevant truncation back.

 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'll take them the really precise number tomorrow if you'll write it down for me. If it's impossible to square a circle you probably need to prove that. How much paper will you need for the proof?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She can write it down. If the enthusiast will pay more for more precision than that, she knows more, too.

She can look at how much space she needs to write with the charcoal and give him an estimate, but that would be in her system and this involves more concepts about which she's not sure how they get represented locally, or if they in fact have local analogues. She can more simply give the reason, and its logic, if that helps at all? (The 'if such-and-such is the case, then it would be impossible' was also a much later idea than the question itself, in her world.)

She can propose a few more ideas to sell (more specific than things like 'the idea of place value', though that is also available, if he knows a market.) The volume and/or surface area of a few other shapes, since that was mentioned? A few others that seems like possibilities, given the information she has?

Also if there is someone who would pay to have some numbers multiplied quickly, who doesn't need converted calculations, and this is not something they already have tools for, she can do that? (Adding quickly can be done just fine with an abacus, she knows).

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'll look into all of that tomorrow while I'm out." He hesitates, about to say something else, but then he doesn't.

He rests. He doesn't seem very interested in talking right now.

Permalink Mark Unread

She won't bother him.

She'll convert and double the relevant amount of pi and write it out on its own bit of paper and work on tide tables and Hari. (She hasn't brought up other things she could potentially sell yet, because risking overwhelment seems suboptimal, and he responded unpredictably and not very well to her introducing the math area. But she's keeping some chemical formulas and such in mind.)

Permalink Mark Unread

The next day he leaves for a while. When he comes back mid-morning he has more coins than he left with but not as many as he's spent since her arrival.

"There's someone who's interested in an explanation of your system for writing numbers. I don't think the price is very good but I don't know enough about math to be sure or get you a better one. They're checking your work on the very precise number and they'll pay when they've decided you're right. They won't cheat us, they can't get away with it."

Permalink Mark Unread

(Does he seem to have any food?)

That's fine - as she understands they need the money; a lot depends on place value, so people knowing it might help sell other things; and getting it from her might make people more interested in other contributions she might have.

(Can't get away with?)

Permalink Mark Unread

He doesn't seem to have brought any food.

"We have a scryable verbal contract and witnesses. If you think your Hari's good enough to write an explanation of place value, do that and I'll take it over when I go check that they're satisfied with your other thing."

Permalink Mark Unread

She thinks she can manage, examples do most of the work anyway.

She writes up an explanation with examples, base-10 in the system she knows and a sample base-12, one using letters for the lacking symbols and one using the magic signs since they have the number correspondence anyway. She'll check it with Valanda before she'll give it to him to bring over.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I like that system. Have you ever used one more like ours?"

Permalink Mark Unread

It is really incredibly useful.

Various parts of her world have in the past, yes - the place value system is an invention like anything else.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Why did you change to using place value?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, it is very useful. With a basic set of symbols you can easily and quickly represent numbers up to very large (and down to very small) ones. It makes operations much easier. (There's an additional system for even larger and smaller numbers). You can see how it makes addition and subtraction easier if you've used an abacus. With multiplication and division you gain even more.

Permalink Mark Unread

Eventually he leaves again. When he comes back he brings a lot more money that he doesn't show any sign of meaning to give her and some raw meat chunks that he encourages her to share with him. He seems much happier now.

Permalink Mark Unread

She is not particularly expecting to be given money. She will be irritated if she gets food poisoning or something but she is not a picky eater, nor possessed of much of a disgust reaction. Food is appreciated.

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you get the tide table done in less than a month and we don't have any emergencies we'll be fine now, I have enough time to find another job but I might have to move back to Anavel Sani to do it. Do you think you can manage that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

If whoever gave him the tables/people here generally think this amount can be done in less than a month at a reasonable pace, then she is fairly certain she can do it in less than a month. She also continues to have reserves of ideas to sell.

...having enough to eat is better for math doing, and if there's more she could do to make that more possible she would both want to and it would be advantageous to the larger goal.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh. Yeah, I guess food is important. I'll get more tomorrow. Anything else you need?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She'll need more paper as she works. She would work faster with a better writing utensil (and possibly surface) but she understands if that's not available. It would be useful if she could work on this parallely to learning how to start going out and such so that she can both improve and do that.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'll bring more paper tomorrow. Study more Hari and I can show you around the neighborhood... soon, maybe."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you."

And she will work on tables and on Hari.

Permalink Mark Unread

The next day he brings back apples and honey in the mid-morning and a little more money.

"If I showed you around today, what would you do?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Follow him, look at things, listen to things. First ask him for some advice on how to behave, carry herself, respond to things that might happen, etc.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Good. You should stay quiet and avoid looking at people too much. If you do look at someone don't look them dead-on in the eyes. If you look someone in the eye by accident blink or look away. It's probably safer if you don't talk to people. Any other questions?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Is one of her body languages better than others? She's guessing Omega or Iota, but is one clearly better (she can demonstrate them)? What does looking people in the eye mean (she won't do it.) What does she do if someone starts talking to her? What other kinds of things might happen she should be prepared to respond to?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Not a lot of people are familiar with human body language. If someone is, I don't think either of those is the safest thing you could do. Maybe something like..." He demonstrates. He seems to think she'll be safer looking more confident. "Looking someone in the eye means you're spoiling for a fight or think you can do what you want to them. If someone talks to you it depends on what they're saying but I'll try to handle that if it comes up. Probably nothing will happen."

Permalink Mark Unread

The ones she knows come out of strata, so it might be different from humans in this world.

Interesting. She watches and adapts and puts together a better one given-information and demonstrates it so he can give her feedback.

Understood. Thank you.

Permalink Mark Unread

He declares it good enough.

"Want to go now?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She does.

Permalink Mark Unread

Then they can go.

There are elevators. How they function is not immediately obvious. The ground floor lobby has a different color scheme entirely than the hallway on their floor.

And just down the street is a market with several open-air stalls and room for more in a big open square surrounded by buildings some of which might be businesses. Someone is transmuting elements. Someone is sharpening knives. Someone is selling meat and blood. Someone is selling nuts and dried fruit, someone is selling fresh fruit, someone is selling honey. An agerah offers to dye their hair or skin or clothing with her magic. Valanda ignores her completely.

Permalink Mark Unread

She keeps the body language he'd said was fine. She looks around, attentive not to look anyone in the eye or at anyone in particular too much.

(Do they seem to have bread and similar products? Vegetables?)

Permalink Mark Unread

Doesn't look like they have anything like that.

"This is where I buy groceries," says Valanda. He keeps walking. They pass what might be a very large park.

Permalink Mark Unread

Huh. (Had she seen any of those in the not-video?) Also, anyone selling alcohol and the like?

Nod.

What kind of park?

 

Permalink Mark Unread

There doesn't seem to be anyone with alcohol on display at a stall at that particular market. She might've seen vegetables for sale in a not-video scene in some other city with more humanoids.

The park is wooded. The trees suggest a temperate biome, maybe on the lucky side of a mountain range. The streets do slope but between tall buildings and tall trees it's a little hard to see far enough to confirm that.

The next place Valanda wants her to see is a building designed to give the illusion of being larger than it is and make visitors feel small.

"That's a government building," Valanda says. "It's where I got Hari Ar Sarag Marsaehu."

Permalink Mark Unread

But no bread and similar products at all. Interesting.

She'll wait to ask questions until they return.

She has a fairly good sense for slope.

She observes the architectural - choices.

Nod.

(Who else is around on the streets? What are they like?)

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Most people around here are furry quadrupeds. A couple people have other people latched on and drinking their blood right there in public. An entire flock of Iri's species flies by. A human also flies by, apparently by magic.

"This wasn't a disaster! Want to get something to eat on our way back?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Observing, observing. Do any people seem richer than others, more confident than others, like they're given more respect than others... Anything corresponding to jobs/positions/familiar status/etc?

Yes, thank you.

Permalink Mark Unread

Some people wear the symbol for a type of magic. What this correlates with is unclear. Some of those people are free and some are not, the flying human is one of them but the others aren't human, it's not that common a choice but she'll see more than a couple. The person transmuting elements is wearing the sun magic symbol. Free people look more dominant but there don't seem to be strata per se. One of the agerah in the park has what seem to be kittens with her.

"What kind of food would you like?" Valanda asks when they get back to the market.

Permalink Mark Unread

Any more confirmation or refutation for the obvious hypothesis that it correlates with having that magic? Or, if what is unclear is who wears one and who doesn't, for hypotheses that it might refer to education, or accreditation, or work?

She's already aware of the lack of strata, and looks for what they perhaps do have.

Cooked meat and fruit might be a good choice out of what she has seen, if this is a reasonable option? (What appears available at the market does seem to be sufficient explanation for what exactly he'd been bringing back.)

Permalink Mark Unread

It seems like it could correlate with having that magic. Nothing obviously refutes any of those hypotheses.

"...Oh, of course you'd do that. You want the fruit cooked too?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Of course she'd do that?

Either is fine, if one is easier or cheaper or such.

Permalink Mark Unread

And here is where they can buy fresh fruit. There's apples, peaches, a few kinds of berries.

"What kind do you like?" Valanda asks her.

Permalink Mark Unread

She is not picky, but she had apples this morning, so, something else? Berries are probably good. (She thinks about nutritional needs.)

Permalink Mark Unread

He gets a couple different kinds so she can try them and see what she likes best. The seller removes the wards keeping them fresh before handing them over. Valanda eats his half quickly before they move on to the next stall.

"Well, now do you know what you like?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you."

She's really just not very discerning. She can pick food mostly based on nutritional needs and cost.

Permalink Mark Unread

"How about meat, do you care what kind of meat we get?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She would prefer cooked, if possible? (She's mostly thinking of digestibility, familiarity, and it making less of a mess. When they return she needs to ask if death magic or other wards are used to prevent food poisoning.) (She's still unsure what he meant by 'of course you'd do that', and says so). But she can adjust if needed.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'll explain when we get home."

Since she doesn't seem to have a preference he gets the pork. The butcher seems to have an arrangement with the fruit seller to handle wards on the meat. It's raw but Valanda visits a nearby building where a human jeweler wearing the heat mage symbol on a necklace agrees to cook their meat for them with magic.

Permalink Mark Unread

She does not have a preference.

Can she figure out which magic does the food wards?

"Thank you."

Permalink Mark Unread

That mage isn't wearing a symbol and the wards don't seem to do anything visible.

"Is this the kind of thing you're used to eating?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Not really, actually, but if he wants to know more she should probably tell him at home.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, that's where they're going.

Permalink Mark Unread

She keeps looking around. Are all the species she knows represented? How do different ones behave? What are the buildings like from outside? (Do they have yards, say?) Are the streets paved? Do they have sewers? How clear or dirty are they?

Permalink Mark Unread

They are but some are pretty uncommon here. They don't have individual garden plots in front of every building but there's a lot of vertical gardening and at least one large park. The streets are paved with setts. There is no sign of feces anywhere, if she wants to infer facts about their sewer system from that. The streets don't seem to have been cleaned today but they're not dirty enough to suggest they aren't cleaned ever. The outsides of buildings are often painted in dark natural colors, mostly browns and greens. Lots of people have balconies, it might be that not everyone has windows and it's impossible to see in the windows that do exist.

What seems to be the local version of an airplane passes overhead before they're back inside.

Permalink Mark Unread

What do the buildings seem to be made of? The balconies?

Oh? What does it look like?

Permalink Mark Unread

Some of them seem to be stone on the lower floors and wood on the upper ones. The plane doesn't have wings, it seems to just float.

Valanda seems relieved when they get back to his apartment.

Permalink Mark Unread

Makes sense, with the force magic.

 

Well, hopefully it was just tension and not anything that happened. Does he do anything aside from seeming?

Permalink Mark Unread

He shuts the door and sits down.

"You asked me earlier why I said of course you'd cook all your meat. I just remembered you didn't have death magic and needed to for safety. We do that here if there's no death mage but it's not necessary otherwise. Anyway, did you get what you need? Will there be any problems with you eating what's available?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah, yes, that is a reason people in her world cook meat. She is glad to hear that is not going to be a problem here even if she eats the raw meat.

She did get some experience in being out and about, which is good to have, thank you.

Nutrition is unfortunately not a subject she's very well versed in, but if humans here tend to be fine, she will probably be fine.

(Out of curiosity, do they have grains/bread? Why the lack of vegetables?)

Permalink Mark Unread

"You can get grains down south in Anavel Sani. If you want vegetables here we can go gather some. I wouldn't know if humans tend to be fine or not, I don't know that many."

Permalink Mark Unread

Vegetables are not farmed? And, is the difference-by-location due to species distribution? Is there a similar location-difference in dairy products?

Well, he is human?

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's due to species distribution, yes, caralendri eat grains and agerah don't. I'm human but I haven't lived here very long, I came from the south. I've met my parents but not many other humans. Only some species make milk, yes, essi and thwilit and ereli and anemones don't make milk."

Permalink Mark Unread

Understood.

Interesting. Do adults here sometimes drink other sentient adults' milk? She meant to refer to dairy from animals though.

Anemones?

Permalink Mark Unread

"...There are a lot of niche fetishes in the world and I'm sure I haven't seen all of them, but I've never heard of any adult drinking milk from any person or animal. Anemones are a species of people, you won't have seen much about them on Hari is the Language of the Empire, they live in the water and don't talk."

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, how do they communicate?

Interesting. In her world it is common to drink animal milk, from kept animals, similarly to how it's common to keep animals and slaughter them for meat, and it is not considered a fetish. It's also used to make other food products. (Drinking milk from people if one is not a baby would probably be considered a fetish, though.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"They don't communicate. They can't be told what the law is so they're all slaves. You probably won't meet any. I've never heard of anyone drinking animal milk but I guess it could be food. How do you get it out of the animals?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah, but they use magic, so it's known they're not animals? Whose slaves are they? (She continues to keep any other opinions to herself.)

She doesn't actually know much about that either. It's called milking and she thinks it's something like such-and-such. (If it's not done here she wouldn't recommend just trying it; in her world people whose ancestors didn't adapt to drinking milk tend to have it make them sick.)

Do they eat animal eggs here?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know, most people that own anemones live on the west coast and I've never been there. Some people can eat eggs, I've had them before."

Permalink Mark Unread

That reminds her of a somewhat unrelated question.

"If a slave has a child, who does the child belong to?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"The slave's owner. Is it different where you're from?"

Permalink Mark Unread

That probably accounts for most of anemone-'distribution', then, she thinks. Still wonders about the rest of it, as well as how they did it originally. (Continues to keep opinions to herself.)

 

Depends on strata. For Iotas and Omegas it's like that; children of slave Betas are free. Slave Alphas aren't generally having children.

Permalink Mark Unread

"That sounds complicated. Is there any benefit to doing it that way?"

Permalink Mark Unread

That's certainly not a direction she's ever thought of it from.

 

It's not really about benefit; it's a - status thing. You can't be a Beta and born a slave. Similarly only Iotas and Omegas can be sold into slavery by their families.

Permalink Mark Unread

"How many of each of your strata are there?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Across the world it varies. (In general a lot of societal things she's been telling him are about the Empire she's from in specific). Different cultures did different things with strata.

In the Empire there are relatively few Alphas, more Betas than that, then more Iotas than that. There used to be then more Omegas but the numbers have changed some in more recent history. She doesn't remember what they are in relation to Iotas now.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Why are the alphas so powerful?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Historical reasons. In the areas where the Empire originated, they took power as monarchs and nobility centuries ago and held on. The Empire started by conquering its neighbors, who had similar structures, and that remains the structure and the system in the Empire.

This is actually the reason there's fewer of them too - there was a lot of killing each other, during that era.

In the Empire it is said that Alphas are suited to taking power and to wielding it. The former isn't without basis, but it's not an inevitability thing - cultures around the world have done different things, as she said.

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Your empire doesn't rule the world? That must be horrible. The Hari Empire rules the world, you don't have to worry here."

Permalink Mark Unread

? (horrible? worry?)

Permalink Mark Unread

"Because you have to pay high taxes so your government can fight a lot of wars, that must be horrible. You don't have to worry that there will be a war here, we never have those."

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah. Yes, wars are pretty horrible.

They don't have uprisings and things?

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's happened but the empire always wins and everyone knows the empire will win."

Permalink Mark Unread

Understood.

 

...she also thinks the Hari Empire has some better qualities than the Empire she is from.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm glad. What do you like here?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She likes things like caring about linguistic diversity and money saved by not having wars. It not being illegal to criticize the government. The lack of the system used with strata. Voting sounds potentially good. Things like publishing the laws for everyone to see and providing some language learning facilitation.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I like those things too. Do you miss anything about your empire?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She thinks what she misses and what she thinks are good qualities are different questions.

She misses some technological conveniences, and knowing things about people and things she looks at. And some people.

She does think not enslaving all children is a good quality. And not doing suspicious-implication things with disabled children, not that where she's from gets so much credit on that one.

Permalink Mark Unread

"What do you do with children instead of slavery?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She's not sure exactly what he's asking about. (This is certainly an interesting formulation/direction to think about it in, she thinks.)

Children are raised by their parents by default, but sometimes by other people, who have responsibility and (this seems likely to be relevant, given context) certain legal rights over them. They're supposed to get an education at the right age and such. When they reach the age of majority they are adults.

Is there an age of majority here? Does anything happen when a child reaches it?

Does she understand correctly that children here belong-as-slaves to their parents? To both (all?) of them, or somehow else?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Children here belong to their mothers. It's illegal to free them because they can't understand the law. There's an age of majority, you're allowed to free your children after that but don't have to. Do you mean that people are automatically free when they become adults? So they need to learn the law before then? Do I understand right?"

Permalink Mark Unread

What's the age of majority here? (In the Empire she is from it's 17.)

People in the Empire she is from are born free. There's rights parents or guardians have over children but it's not the same as for a slave. Once someone reaches the age of majority parents/guardians no longer have said rights over them.

The approach to law is less all-at-once than it sounds like it is here? While how much and how one will be held to account for it does depend on age (and some other factors), children under the age of majority can still be arrested and punished for breaking laws.

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's the same age for us. How is slavery different than the rights parents have over children in your world?"

Permalink Mark Unread

If you compare them - different scope, different aim? Theoretically at least the point of parental rights over children is getting those children raised to be part of society and such. Slavery's not like that. You can't sell your children to other people for money (unless you're an Iota or Omega and sell them into slavery). You have some legal obligations toward children you have. There's legal constraints on punishment and other treatment of children there isn't on slaves.

If a slave says no to their master and the master doesn't have the resources to punish them enough the government will - help.

As some elements.

 

What happens if an under-17 breaks the law here?

Permalink Mark Unread

"If someone you own breaks the law you can be punished for that. In your home, if an Alpha has a child they can't raise to follow the law, what happens? Do they have to kill them?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Punished how? What if you have a child who keeps breaking the law and you don't think you can keep them from it?

Theoretically, you're not supposed to murder your children. In practice, Alphas in fact will often get away with this, if they do it.

Also in practice, what happens is often that the family covers for the child, pays their fines, etc, maybe tries various ways to improve their behavior. Then when they grow up they either figure out how to stay out of that kind of trouble, or the family keeps covering for them, or they figure out how to cover for themselves, or they eventually end up dead or in the slave Alpha 'route'. (The bar for the slave Alpha 'route' is also considerably lower if the government already doesn't like where you come from very much, or you're less in favor.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Here you just kill them... why aren't you supposed to do that? Do you need more people?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Can a parent kill their child whenever they want, here?

Well, you're generally not supposed to kill people, unless they get arrested and sentenced to death in which case the government does it.

Permalink Mark Unread

"You can do what you want to things you own. You're not supposed to kill free people but there's no reason you can't destroy your own property. Why can't you do that where you're from?"

Permalink Mark Unread

As noted, in the Empire she comes from children are not owned, they are free people who are children.

The law on killing slaves is odd in some sense. It's not properly legal to outright kill your slave. If a slave happens to die as a result of your treatment, this is fine. If this happens an absolutely absurd amount, the government might get involved.

The reason for this is that if your slaves know you might just randomly come up and kill them, they end up with more incentive to stop listening to you and revolt, or something like that, and then the government will have to go deal with that.

(The other reason, she thinks, is that Alphas who like murdering for fun are very likely to end up causing trouble, and this way there's a legal means to cut them off earlier.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"Right, you don't have command magic, I guess you have a harder time keeping your slaves under control. We have command magic so it matters less what slaves want. Well. Here you can buy someone just to kill them if you want."

Permalink Mark Unread

They do not. And the Hari Empire doesn't have Alphas.

How does command magic work? She understands that you can stop people from doing things but not make them do things, but what are the details?

Permalink Mark Unread

"You can't use it to stop someone from going limp and not doing anything. Command magic can't make someone move, that's force magic. You can use it to make someone go limp. You can use it to make just one muscle go limp. You can use it to make just one muscle go limp only some of the time under specific circumstances. You can prevent any action but some are tricky to specify precisely."

Permalink Mark Unread

How is it directed? Spoken word? Intention? Does it always work by muscles that way? Does it only work on the body, or the mind too? Can you try to literal-genie at it?

Permalink Mark Unread

"It only works on your body, not your mind. Command mages just think what they want but bracelets are enchanted differently."

It takes a while to translate that last concept but eventually they figure it out. "Yeah, that's how magic works, it doesn't know what you want, just what you tell it to do."

Permalink Mark Unread

How are they enchanted?

Also, that reminds her, she was wondering what wearing a magic symbol as she saw people doing symbolizes.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not one of the kinds of mage that work on the bracelets.

"Wearing those symbols shows interest in doing the kind of low-skill work that anyone with that magic can do. Someone wearing the illusion symbol will make your hair another color, someone with the defense symbol will make your bag indestructible. It's not all working mages, it's... when you think 'I need to hire a defense mage, any defense mage' or 'I need to hire any heat mage' they want you to ask them. My magic research job was a job doing magic but it wasn't something a twelfth of the population would be equally qualified for. I'll probably start wearing a defense symbol soon if I don't find anything else to do."

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, he bought some bracelets, and Iri is wearing some, how would he have interfaced with them? Are they usually the same, or are there different options?

Ah, that makes sense. That is a useful thing to have established.

How does being able to do magic work? If he makes something indestructible, is it indestructible against anything? Can someone make it destructible again?

Permalink Mark Unread

"These I'd talk to, that's the most popular interface. There's others too. If I make something indestructible I can make it destructible later but I can't undo some other defense mage's wards. How indestructible it is depends on what you do."

Permalink Mark Unread

If a mage makes something indestructible and dies, will it be like that forever?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah, sometimes that happens, it's dangerous. There's some indestructible mud buildings from hundreds of years ago that no one can retrofit with plumbing or anything."

Permalink Mark Unread

...that sounds like it would be a problem, yes.

"How indestructible it is depends on what you do"?

Permalink Mark Unread

"For instance, I can make it so something can't break or bend. That's what those mud buildings are like. But you wouldn't want me to do that to your clothes, if you want indestructible clothes you still want to fold them. I can make fireproof paper that you can tear. Things like that. Magic does what you ask, not what you want, I don't just get to ask it to make everything I want to protect immune to exactly the things I want it protected from if I can't specify what those things are."

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah, understood. She was imagining 'how indestructible' as how much force it would withstand; is that not a factor?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Nope! I could turn you into a statue and you'd stay that way forever, even if people hit you with hammers. Diamond hammers. That's why those indestructible buildings are such a problem."

Permalink Mark Unread

Aspects of her innate psychology suggest this is an oblique threat/power show. She doesn't necessarily disagree, but it has been and continues to be the case that he can hurt her if he wants to regardless, so she does not consider this of high importance.

 

She was thinking more explosions than diamond hammers. Though maybe if they have force magic they can just test forces directly? (She is not sure how that works.) And ah, she was wondering if the indestructibility can be used on people.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not sure what you mean about testing forces directly. I think it's possible to make people immune to injury but I don't know how. If you just make someone indestructible the obvious way that turns them into a statue."

Permalink Mark Unread

'How much force can something withstand before it breaks in a certain way' is a common engineering question in her world. Like 'how much weight can you hang from this rope before it snaps', or 'how much weight can you put on top of this block before it crumbles', or 'how hard can you hit something', and so on. She's not sure how force magic works, but if it was the case that a force mage could apply various amounts of force to something directly, they could do that rather than just hanging weights off it (or using machines to apply force, etc.)

...is someone turned into a statue still alive?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know about engineering. Someone turned into a statue is just paused, if the mage who did it wants to they can break the enchantment."

Permalink Mark Unread

...that certainly has implications.

 

In general, how does being a mage and doing magic work, in terms of what you are able to do and what it's like and how you become able to do more?

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's probably similar to your discerning sense. You have to intend exactly what you want and you become able to do more by understanding the world more."

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, that's really interesting.

Is intending effortfull? Do you have to do it for some amount of time? Do you get feedback about whether or not it is working?

Permalink Mark Unread

"It takes effort. It takes time but not much time. You can usually tell if it worked, if you want to make something indestructible you can try hitting it, if you want to make something hot you can touch it and see if it's hot."

Permalink Mark Unread

Does time vary based on any factors? Ah, so you don't get feedback as a direct sense, you have to check?

Permalink Mark Unread

"It depends on how complicated it is, you don't want to go too fast and make mistakes. I... don't think I could be wrong about whether I'd used magic."

Iri almost says something to that but doesn't.

Permalink Mark Unread

She is curious what Iri didn't say but won't likely distress xer by asking.

Make mistakes?

Permalink Mark Unread

Conveniently he gets to hear her actual words and know what she means.

"If I need some cloth to fold but not tear and I forget and make it stiff that's a mistake. If I don't know that it needs to be able to fold that's also a mistake. If I'm sloppy about what I'm aiming at I could ward the wrong thing and that would be a mistake."

Permalink Mark Unread

Like if he wanted to ward a belt buckle and instead thought of the whole belt, for instance?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah, like that. It's particularly hard to get command magic right because you're not just up against an object, you're up against a person who'll try to find any way to defy you."

Permalink Mark Unread

That makes sense. In her world one runs into that kind of looking for loopholes vs trying to shore up against loopholes in some forms of rules and contracts, though of course there's no command magic involved.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yup that sounds like contracts.

Iri is very interested in that topic and very quiet.

Permalink Mark Unread

Unfortunately as noted neither discerning-sense nor other talents she has allow mind-reading.

 

And meanwhile - she got distracted by very interesting topics, but she is also very interested in feedback about how she did with respect to the going-out? 

Permalink Mark Unread

"No one died! It went fine. It's when you start talking to people that things might go wrong. That doesn't have to happen for a while yet, as long as I can buy food. ...Which I can't if you don't get back to work."

Permalink Mark Unread

Aspects of her innate psychology, apparently noticing themselves outside the scope of accustomed circumstances in which she is used to enforcing their behavior, think he has no business giving her oblique orders like that and she should do something about it. She continues to not consider them useful to the situation.

 

Well, she'd like to start trying as soon as it's feasible, or preparing to try if there's something that could and should be done for that first; it's clearly something she needs to get to being able to do.

But yes, work is important. 

Tide tables.

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda goes out again. Iri stays behind.

"Can I help?" Iri asks.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, she was going to start looking for a chance to talk to Iri without Valanda around.

"What with?"

and,

"Can I help you? Are you all right? Can you tell me what commands you're under?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Why is Iri suddenly terrified? Who knows! Iri's sure not saying!

"...I just thought you might want help with your work... but I don't know much about it... I'm not mad at you."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm sorry, I didn't mean to suddenly scare you. It's fine. I don't think you're angry at me and I'm not angry at you either.

I want to help you if there's ways I can do that, and I don't know enough about your situation. But it certainly makes sense if you don't trust me or feel like telling me about it."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you trust anyone?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Depends on what the word's used to mean? She trusts some people different amounts of conditionally/with different sorts of some-things-and-not-others. They're all back in her world though. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think I want that. I want to partly trust people. It seems... better that way."

Permalink Mark Unread

Major aspect of trust, she thinks, is knowing what you can expect of people. So she can trust a particular friend of hers to not decide to betray her for personal gain, but not to not do some stupid things. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you."

Iri considers saying something else but then doesn't. Iri looks out the window instead.

Permalink Mark Unread

"May I ask where you're from?" (If questions continue to be terrifying she'll stop asking them, but she'd like to make some attempts before doing so.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"I used to live in the woods near here. With my... siblings. Where are you from?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Close to the Imperial capital, originally. Then a variety of places. Siblings?

Permalink Mark Unread

"We're thwilit."

She'll have seen thwilit on the not-a-TV depicted as groups that act as one. The law treats the colony as the basic unit of thwilit that can be responsible for its actions. The laws dealing with thwilit acting alone exist but are clearly an afterthought.

Permalink Mark Unread

(Interesting. Was it discussed how that works in practice, say with lawbreaking? And how the children-slavery works for them?)

Permalink Mark Unread

Yup, they treat an entire colony as responsible for any wrongdoing by one member. There's different punishments for lone individuals, too, for the same crimes.

There aren't any laws about young thwilit in particular.

Iri keeps looking out the window being quiet and uncomfortable.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Did they sell you? Or something happened to the colony?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I wanted to leave. They thought they might be in trouble if I ever did anything wrong if they just let me go. And then they didn't let me change my mind."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm very sorry.

How old are you?"

(Did the not-video have anything about mechanisms for thwilit to separate out? Is this because xie was underage, or a general issue? Did anything mention when thwilit come of age?)

Permalink Mark Unread

Nothing mentions when thwilit come of age.

"You first. How old are you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She doesn't mind answering that.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm four."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Is that underage, for thwilit?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"There's no law about when we're adults. It wouldn't make any sense for us, we're not like humans."

Permalink Mark Unread

How does that work with the underage and slavery thing?

Permalink Mark Unread

"You really don't know anything about us, do you? I'm not really a person so it doesn't matter how old I am."

Permalink Mark Unread

She knows exactly as much as was in the not-video, plus what Valanda has told her, which Iri will have heard. How does it work for thwilit?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I haven't been here the whole time, remember? I've only seen part of it. And we, uh..." Is that the bird equivalent of a shrug? It might be! Iri doesn't narrate what their body language means. "One person is one human or one agerah or one belul or all the birds that live together and work together and have children together. Thwilit make choices together. Like choices about whether to break laws."

Permalink Mark Unread

Most things she learns to draw conclusions on are not narrated.

 

Sorry. She should not have just assumed Iri knows the not-video contents. If there are episodes with more about thwilit specifically, they're not ones she's currently seen.

So rather than being birth-based, a colony can just sell a member if they want, but there isn't a slave/free internal distinction otherwise?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not mad at you. Yeah, it's like that. Some birds aren't... used for making decisions as much... but it's not the same."

Permalink Mark Unread

Understood.

She's sorry that happened to xer, that sounds awful.

(And, now that they're talking, she'll try asking again -)

Is there anything Sheridan might be able to do to help xer? Is xie alright right now? Would xie be able to tell Sheridan what commands xie's under?

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri's not as terrified as the last time she asked.

"I don't think I should tell you that. Is there anything I can do to help you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Ok. That's fine. (That's actually very suspicious in at least some way, though there's a few to choose from. She keeps that part to herself.)

 

Information about Valanda that it would be good to have and she lacks would be useful. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri trembles.

"I don't know him, I don't know what you know, I, I..." Deep breath. Pause. "Maybe if you have specific questions."

Permalink Mark Unread

She's sorry to be scaring Iri. If it helps at all, she's not angry at xer and is very unlikely to become so. Is there anything else she could do to scare xer less?

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I'll let you know if I think of anything you can do for me. I can answer more questions if you want."

Permalink Mark Unread

She'd be glad to know that.

She'd like to ask a somewhat oddly-formed question, can she try that?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Sure."

Permalink Mark Unread

If there's something having to do with Valanda where xie is under commands that involve keeping it from Sheridan, please don't respond right now until Sheridan says something again. If not, say something.

(She not sure if this ought to work or not - doesn't have a definite good enough understanding of command magic, at the moment. And she's certainly not guaranteed a true answer. But it's enough to be worth a try.)

Permalink Mark Unread

(aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa)

"I don't know of anything Valanda is planning that would hurt you. But I wouldn't know if he were."

Permalink Mark Unread

That wasn't the question, which among 'Iri saying something = there is not something' vs 'Iri saying something = there is but Iri for whatever reason doesn't want to let Sheridan know that' puts weight toward the latter. The nonverbals also do so.

 

That's fine, she's not expecting Iri to know that.

If there's anything about Valanda xie's under commands to keep it from Sheridan, and it involves Valanda hurting anyone else who is not guilty of hurting someone or trying to hurt someone first, Iri included in the 'anyone else', please don't respond right now. If not, say something.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know of anyone who's never hurt anyone. I don't know what Valanda's plans are."

Permalink Mark Unread

(Deflection, continues to be possibly suspicious.)

What kinds of things is xie thinking of with 'hurt'?

And that's fine, she's not expecting Iri to know that either.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Hurting people is, um... biting them, stealing from them, locking them up someplace by themselves... getting to a shop first and buying the thing they wanted, getting them to hire you and then doing a bad job... I'm not sure what hurts other species. Am I forgetting anything you wanted to know about?"

Permalink Mark Unread

So which of those things has Valanda been doing?

Permalink Mark Unread

"He's probably bought things other people wanted. I don't know what else. I'm just guessing, I don't know him. Why do you want to know?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, if Valanda is going around, say, locking random innocent people up, and he asks Sheridan to help him with some unspecified thing, she may not want to help him, since he might use that to lock more people up, and Sheridan's not a fan of that.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Why not?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Because people don't like that sort of thing happening to them and it's not good for their wellbeing and flourishing.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Are you worried he'll do that to you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, not unworried, but at the moment she's certainly more worried he'll do it to someone else. If he wanted to do her harm he's had a lot of opportunities he doesn't seem to have made use of, so she has some reason to believe he's less interested. She has no such evidence at all for other people.

Permalink Mark Unread

"We're the only ones he could do that to. Otherwise it's illegal."

Permalink Mark Unread

People do and plan to do illegal things sometimes; he could potentially buy more slaves; and Iri is in fact of concern here.

Permalink Mark Unread

"He can't afford more slaves, he's not stupid enough to break the law... and I'm... not worried."

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh? (With respect to the not worried.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"You're not worried either."

Permalink Mark Unread

Given what she said earlier, is that meant to mean that Valanda hasn't hurt xer despite opportunities (xer being his slave being opportunity)?

Permalink Mark Unread

"He hasn't hurt me yet."

Permalink Mark Unread

She's glad to hear that. If he starts or it seems he's going to Sheridan would like to help if she can.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'll remember that. Do you, um... have any other questions?"

Permalink Mark Unread

If there's any commands xie's under xie thinks Valanda won't tell Sheridan about if asked, please don't respond right now until Sheridan says something again. If not, say something.

Permalink Mark Unread

"How would I know what Valanda would tell you? I've only known him a few days."

Permalink Mark Unread

For some things it might be more obvious than for others, but that makes sense, she's not expecting Iri to know. Why doesn't xie think xie should tell Sheridan the commands?

Permalink Mark Unread

"How much will you pay for the answer?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, she doesn't have any money; is there any other kind of payment Iri wants?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm still deciding whether I can trust you to pay me back later if I ask you to owe me for it."

Permalink Mark Unread

That makes sense. She would, not that she expects saying that to raise trust, but she doesn't think it's a good idea for her to promise people money right now when she doesn't have certain prospects of getting any.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh, um... do you want me to stop distracting you? So you can make money doing your work."

Permalink Mark Unread

No, it's fine, the conversation is useful and Sheridan is participating in it and could stop.

And, she's not necessarily expecting to receive any of the money as money.

Permalink Mark Unread

"He can't keep you if you'd rather leave. You could just walk away."

Permalink Mark Unread

She could. Not doing so seems a better bet toward her continued survival, for the moment. And she'd like to help Valanda more in return for his help to her, if it is in fact safe to do so.

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's probably safer than going away. But you could. That might be part of why it's safe."

Permalink Mark Unread

She's certainly keeping it in mind.

That would make sense.

She'd also like to help Iri, as noted, if possible.

 

Why does Iri keep being so scared around the subjects?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Wouldn't you be scared?"

Permalink Mark Unread

...not necessarily but she has an odd psychology, she wasn't mainly scared when she was being imprisoned and tortured by her government either. (Iri had traded for information before, and she's been asking most of the questions here, and it might be useful to have that known about her while being safer than disclosing the slavery part of her background.)

But she could be scared-or-suchlike because she thought her owner would hurt her for saying something, or because she thought the person she was talking to would hurt her with some particular provocation, or because she was generally in an unsafe and uncertain situation and unknown factors were more so, or if something was happening that to her signaled 'scary' for some reason of her past or psychology...

Permalink Mark Unread

Is that trembling? That's a really different kind of trembling than before. Iri doesn't comment on any of what she says but that is definitely some kind of reaction.

"I could try to teach you my other native language. I'm not sure if you could hear all of it or say any of it but I could try. If you want."

Permalink Mark Unread

Thank you, and she would certainly be interested, but she thinks she ideally needs to focus on Hari right now. Is there a reason Iri is offering?

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Because of what you said." Birdly shrug. "I can answer Hari questions too."

Permalink Mark Unread

If xie was - offering a vulnerability for a vulnerability, then, thank you. Sheridan recognizes it. Was that it?

(There's not really a good way to outright ask either 'or was it a diversion xie thought Sheridan would be diverted by' or 'or was it an oblique attempt to set up a secret code').

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah, you could call it that."

Permalink Mark Unread

Iotas have a word for acknowledging that kind of thing. She says that one.

And - xie could have been trying to deflect, but could have just thought the offering-in-return was more important.

So -  is Iri scared for some of the reasons Sheridan said, or some other reasons, or?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not sure what it's safe to tell you."

Permalink Mark Unread

Of course. Sheridan apologizes.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Iri is just going to be over here by the flowers being quiet and scared unless Sheridan talks to them again.

Permalink Mark Unread

Speaking of safe, is it alright to ask Iri questions when Valanda is around, or should Sheridan avoid that?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think it's safe but I guess it makes sense not to. Since I could be wrong. It's probably safe."

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, Iri's the one it might not be safe for, so Sheridan will do as xie prefers.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh, I thought you meant for you! It's probably safe for me too."

Permalink Mark Unread

So, is xie alright with Sheridan doing it, or should Sheridan refrain and wait till they're alone again?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Unless you have more reason than I do to think it's dangerous I don't think you need to wait. You keep asking about things he knows anyway."

Permalink Mark Unread

Alright. Thank you.

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda's shirt has the defense magic symbol on it when he gets back. He doesn't bring back any more money but he does bring some honey for Iri and a peach for Sheridan.

The next couple of days he leaves early and gets back late without coming home in the middle of the day. He brings Sheridan fruit and meat in the evenings and lets her work and study.

Permalink Mark Unread

She works and studies (and distributes food as possible to make more meals and eats and such).

If there's a time that seems open for doing so, she'll ask him some more questions.

If he leaves her and Iri alone again she'll ask Iri about Iri's magic.

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda's not very available for a couple of days but Iri stays home once.

"I'm a knowledge mage. What would you like to know about that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah! She'd been wondering what enabled the translation. She is very interested in knowing more about knowledge magic. What is it like? How does it work?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I ask the world what I want to know and then I know it. It's hard because the world doesn't know how I think so I have to ask in ways that it can understand. And I have to know what I want to know. If I ask whether the room I'm in is shielded from other knowledge mages and whether there are any spells the shield let in, the world doesn't know I want to know about the force mage hiding behind some boxes listening in."

Permalink Mark Unread

...That sounds incredibly powerful. Are there other limits? What ways of asking does the world understand? 

Ah, that makes sense. Well-definedness seems a common feature of the magic here?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Any illusion mage can block me, it's not that powerful. Most places have some kind of illusion on them. There's one here, if I went out of the room I couldn't use magic to find out anything about you unless you went with me."

Permalink Mark Unread

Block xer? There's an illusion on here?

Permalink Mark Unread

"There's an illusion on this room so I can't see in from the outside. There's a different illusion on the building so I can't see in the building from the outside either. I think most places have them. People don't like it if other people can just start watching them at any moment."

Permalink Mark Unread

Seems reasonable. How does an illusion do that? Could xie find out things that don't depend on vision?

('Spells the shield let in'?)

Permalink Mark Unread

"You could do an illusion that was just visual but this one isn't. I don't know how it works, I'm not that kind of mage. I know you can let someone put a spell on a room so they can see what's going on inside but then keep anyone else from doing the same thing."

Permalink Mark Unread

Wow.

Can xie get knowledge that doesn't depend on knowing about the person right now, like 'what did Valanda buy at market yesterday'? Can xie get scientific knowledge? Can defense magic protect against knowledge magic, or is it specifically illusion magic that does that?

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri does some magic before answering. "I can see a lot of the market. I could spend a whole day watching Valanda at the market yesterday if you want to know what he bought. You want another knowledge mage that's studied science more to get you scientific knowledge, I could try but I don't know enough to know what to ask. Defense magic doesn't do anything about knowledge magic."

Permalink Mark Unread

So xie has to watch, xie doesn't get the information directly?

Would someone else telling xer about the science questions help?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Someone could get it directly but I don't know how to tell the world what 'bought' means. If they knew how to ask questions the right way that might help."

Permalink Mark Unread

Understood. 

What is the right way to ask questions like? How does xie do the translation? Why does it only work in one direction?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I know how to tell what you mean but I can't make you know things. I'm not sure how to describe the right way to ask questions. It's... really precise and doesn't make assumptions. I don't know, you can try a question and see if I can figure out how to get the answer."

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah (that explains why it seems xie can explain things that don't actually have straightforward expressions for them in Hari). Is 'how to say such-and-such in Capital' not a question xie can ask?

And - she considers good questions for this, as distinct from questions about things she might want to know, or science she is interested in. 

How far is this planet from its sun? Right now, maybe, if that's easier than 'on average'. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Squeak! Shiver. "...It's really far. Um, I had to make some changes to the question, you have to define whether you're measuring from the close side or the far side or in the middle... anyway it's about ninety-four million three hundred thousand one hundred twelve miles away right now. Using the middles. ...And it's getting farther away."

Permalink Mark Unread

...is this alarming? She's sorry to alarm Iri.

That makes sense about the question, she sees.

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you could see how far away it was you'd be alarmed too! It's really far!"

Permalink Mark Unread

She doesn't think she would be - it is true she has not literally seen it, only numbers and models, but she doesn't think that would make the difference. But it would likely be much more alarming if you weren't used to it, and it might make the difference for someone else.

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "Maybe. Let me know if you have more questions."

Permalink Mark Unread

She does. Also a metaquestion. 

Her world has a lot of science and technology it looks like this world doesn't, that maybe some people here could benefit from. One constraint is that she doesn't remember everything that would be useful. Is it possible knowledge magic could help fill some of it in?

 

(If this works the way she currently understands it does, knowledge magic would be of limited help in making discoveries, because you couldn't specify the question. But she can certainly specify questions).

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not sure. Give me an example question and I'll try."

Permalink Mark Unread

She'll ask a simple thing she knows, as a starting experiment.

What's the chemical makeup of water? (That's a non-specified question, and she is is ready to give specificity as needed if Iri tells her what is needed.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's made of two of the smallest element and one of the, um, eighth. Is that what you wanted to know?"

Permalink Mark Unread

!

What is bonded/connected to what, among the atoms?

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Not clear enough, try another way?"

Permalink Mark Unread

What isn't clear enough/what was the difference between the two questions? She still not sure what exactly the requirements are.

Permalink Mark Unread

"The first time I knew what an element was so I filled in what was missing. This time I guess I don't know something. How do they bond?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah. 

She explains various things about bonding. 

Permalink Mark Unread

They retry periodically as they understand better.

"Both of the little ones with the bigger one. I think. Why is it useful to know that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

One form of technology her world has as a result of it being invented is chemical compounds that are useful for various things. There are some of them where she knows they exist, but doesn't remember their specific chemical structure.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I can try to figure them out but I have to know what they are first."

Permalink Mark Unread

What kind of know what they are? 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Like if you want to know which element is metal, you could mean more than one. If you want to know the structure of something that tastes good, lots of things taste good. I can do 'what's the structure of that thing over there?' or 'what's the structure of that thing that was right outside the door yesterday at dawn?' but not 'what's the structure of the thing I want to know the structure of?' You can try asking some questions and see if I can find what you want."

Permalink Mark Unread

...Glucose? She can talk about what glucose is, there's some in her body right now... (This is another one she knows, but the check is for being able to specify.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Once she mentions honey Iri narrows it down to two monosaccharides and then checks which ones are where inside Sheridan. Iri gives the molecular formula and a vague description of the shape.

Permalink Mark Unread

She's not sure how most kinds of magic work - could a structure mage work from that?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not a structure mage. I think so."

Permalink Mark Unread

Understood. Thank you very much.

Are knowledge mages not able to do their magic on math? Like for the person who wanted the pi calculation.

Permalink Mark Unread

"That's not the kind of thing it works on."

Permalink Mark Unread

Does xie know what the division is?

Permalink Mark Unread

"...You can use magic to figure out where something is but not where it'll be tomorrow. You can use magic to figure out the structure of something you've seen but not something you've never seen. You can measure things but not answer division problems. Does that make sense?"

Permalink Mark Unread

...Something like, there needs to be a 'present' 'anchor'?

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "Maybe. I don't know."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you."

(That is a severe limit, but she was expecting to only have what she can pull out of her head so it's still a gain.)

 

And - she's been asking Iri a lot of questions; is there anything Iri might want to know from her?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you ever plan to leave here and stop working for Valanda?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She doesn't consider herself to be working for Valanda per se, but that's not particularly the point. She doesn't have certain plans right now, nor does she feel she can make particularly long term plans. Lots of dependencies. If Valanda turns out to be the kind of person she can work with, she is more likely to keep working with him. If Valanda turns out to have strongly unfavorable qualities, she is more likely to leave. And so on.

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you leave Valanda while we could still be useful to each other..." Iri doesn't quite know how to finish the question.

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri is definitely another important factor. She would not want to leave Iri unless Iri prefers her to, and if Valanda turns out to have strongly unfavorable qualities she wouldn't just abandon Iri to him.

Permalink Mark Unread

"What kind of unfavorable qualities?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Wanting to hurt people for fun or for his own gain, that sort of thing. She can work with some amount of that but it's a cost. It's also much harder to work with people if they'd be trying to work against her. Likewise with respect to amount. Sometimes it's worth it, sometimes it's not. Again, she wouldn't abandon Iri though.

Permalink Mark Unread

"You mean any people? What's the problem if he wants to hurt some people?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Sometimes hurting people comes up as part of a plan to do something else that needs doing, like rescuing someone they kidnapped or stopping them from doing something else that's a problem or dealing with something they did first or were involved in. But that wouldn't be 'for fun or his own gain'. If he gets a job as an executioner or something like that, that's also different, it's not like someone else wouldn't do it if he didn't. Otherwise generally yes. Why, does Iri think there's an exception Sheridan hasn't thought of?

Well, people usually don't want to be hurt, so when they feel that way she doesn't like it happening to them either. Unless it's a punishment for a crime where she agrees that should be the punishment for the crime, or something like that.

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri doesn't have many more questions.

Eventually Valanda has time to talk if she wants.

Permalink Mark Unread

Good, because she certainly does.

She thinks she needs to practice going out more, that being an important thing to be able to do.

Also, could she ask him some more questions about the world that the not-video is leaving her unclear on?

Permalink Mark Unread

"What're your questions?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She's still interesting to understand more about command magic. What kinds of commands do people usually put on bracelets? Are there default ones and do people usually add more? Can they also be removed? For instance, what kind of commands are/has he put on Iri's?

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's longer and more complicated than this but usually it's don't break any laws, don't try to take the bracelets off, don't hurt your owner. People add more if they want to. You can remove a command on its own or the bracelets. You should ask Iri that." He notices Iri's reaction. "Uh, no, never mind, you shouldn't ask Iri."

Permalink Mark Unread

Will 'don't break any laws' work even if the person doesn't understand the laws? Do you have to remember all the commands yourself to remove them, or can you find out from bracelets what commands are on them? Does it have to be bracelets or is that just a social convention?

(She notices the deflection. (If there was something he didn't want her to know, 'ask Iri' could seem unsuspicious and even desirable if he thought she wouldn't think of 'he might have told Iri not to say'). She notices Iri's reaction (can she notice anything more detailed about it?). ...the last part, given the two together, is odd. She is not sure what to make of it.

Of course if he hadn't done anything, 'ask Iri' might be a genuine 'Iri should decide if to tell you', and the last part might also be genuine, and Iri's reaction to these questions of course she's seen before, though she's still unsure of the reason...

So if he has done something, why that last reaction - perhaps he thinks she is not a very suspicious person, and thus that she will be more well inclined toward 'if Iri is distressed, I will show I am concerned' than she will be suspicious at a complete denial of the information.

And if he has not done anything to disapprove of, why is Iri afraid of the questions.))

Permalink Mark Unread

"That's a summary, not the actual commands, it can't figure out what's against the law on its own. It does work even if you don't understand the orders you're under. It's a little tricky to remove orders you've forgotten you gave. There are other shapes that could work but bracelets are the most convenient."

Permalink Mark Unread

Tricky but it can be done?

Wearing the bracelets is why the command magic works on the specific person? Is it the surrounding a part of them specifically, or the skin contact, or something else? Could it be done in another way, like putting command magic on walls to affect everyone in a room?

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I'm not a command mage, I don't know if you could do that. It, um. It would be illegal, probably."

Permalink Mark Unread

(She really does not approve of this world's apparent 'I'm not an X mage so I don't know how that works' social convention. And by probable extension, educational system.)

That is good to know.

She doesn't suppose there's some sort of 'magic 101' material she could read, to get such information in a more targeted form than the not-video supplies? Would also allow her to practice reading.

Permalink Mark Unread

"You could hire the people who teach magic and tell them you're a different kind of mage and just curious but even if they try their best I'm not sure you'll learn anything."

Permalink Mark Unread

She thinks she would - she's learned things from him about defense magic, for instance. She'll keep that in mind for if she gets some money, thank you.

Speaking of learning things - practice going out?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah, okay. Are you making progress on the tide table?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She is. She can report on said progress if he wants.

Also can try to suggest some more ideas for more short-term money-acquisition, if that is needed or desirable.

Permalink Mark Unread

"What are your ideas?"

Permalink Mark Unread

A few ideas: If anyone is interested in some other interesting numbers aside from 2pi she knows some other ones. Given a place value system, she knows much faster ways to do multiplication and division of longer numbers, and some tools that can speed it up. Depending on what tools they already have, possibly some tools for other math. She's not sure about the state of their medicine aside from the usefulness of death magic, but may be able to make some suggestions. She's not clear on how exactly structure mages work but there are some materials she might be able to tell them about.

Permalink Mark Unread

"What are the materials useful for?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Depends on the materials. Does he know what a structure mage would need to produce a material?

Permalink Mark Unread

"A sufficiently precise description and the elements it's made of. I don't know more precisely than that, I'm not educated," says Valanda.

Iri interrupts. "The thing I told you water was made of, before. That kind of description would work."

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah, thank you.

(So, anything whose structure she knows and anything she actually has on her for Iri to read it off.)

She doesn't know what materials they already have. Do they have rubber? Polyester? Other plastics? Polyester is used for fabrics with some desirable qualities, and there are many kinds of plastic and she won't be able to come up with all of them but it is lightweight and shapeable and waterproof and can be used for containers to keep food fresher and safety devices and minor pleasing items and a large variety of other things (she can list more). Latex? Nitrile?

(Not materials, but by the way do they have pencils? Erasers?) How are they on adhesives? (or do they not need them because of defense magic?) Pain medication?

Permalink Mark Unread

They have none of those materials!

"We have lots of different writing implements, some that work like you're talking about. Pain medication might be useful but do you know if yours work for more than just humans?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, if he thinks someone might pay them to change that, that is something they can try. Possibly starting with more minor things and such. She is not sure how distribution can be expected to work in this world. She is interested in both 'people in this world gain access to useful materials' and 'they acquire money they need', and if these can be combined sometimes that seems a positive outcome.

(She notes 'better writing implement' as something to acquire with money.)

The pain medication she has isn't strong enough for things like surgery, but is often good for some other pains. She does not know enough about the biology of other species here to even hazard a guess about that.

Permalink Mark Unread

"We can probably sell the information to a structure mage. What can your materials do that we can't do already?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She's not sure what exactly they can do already. Presumably defense magic means they already have very good waterproofing, but rubber is still good for things like impact absorption and plastic is lightweight. Polyester, again, is used for fabrics, which has some qualities she doesn't think relate to any of the kinds of magic.

The thing she already has in nitrile and latex are gloves, which they probably don't need for health related procedures because of death magic but are also good for dirty work and for handling some chemicals that are not safe to touch. Latex is also used for condoms, for people who aren't allergic to it; she doesn't know what they're using for those right now. Rubber and some plastics also become more important for electricity, but that's a larger project.

Permalink Mark Unread

"How much more are they worth given electricity? And how much will electricity be worth?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She really does not know how to estimate that, especially given everything she still doesn't know about this world. Though the applications won't necessarily be obvious, if that's what he's worried about.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm wondering if it would be better for us to sell the idea of electricity first."

Permalink Mark Unread

They can do that if he wants. She was considering the benefits of potentially selling something simpler earlier on, but he knows this world far better than her.

Would people be willing to accept a non-exclusive sale? With things this potentially socially major, she doesn't think it would be right to do exclusive. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Not right how?"

Permalink Mark Unread

It means too much pressure on the initial sale, trying to find someone who'd use it to full potential, and trying to price that well when whoever they're selling to won't have much to go on. And it not being used to full potential would be a very large loss, so.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah, I don't want to leave money on the table either. Can you create some kind of prototype without giving anyone else enough information to copy it? And can you list all the uses for it that you know of?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Yes to the last one. She can probably manage a very basic miniature generator if she had the materials; she's less sure about anything that actually uses it. Could probably do a model telegraph? Without giving anyone else the information to copy it would be harder.

Also, does he think anyone might be interested in gloves? And what is the state of the art on condoms?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Gloves could be useful, or something similar for people without hands.

"We don't use the thing you're describing. Death magic can end a pregnancy or cure a disease. I think some defense mages know how to keep people from getting getting pregnant, but I don't. Anavel Sani has a lot of laws that are supposed to keep disease from spreading, all kinds of disease, including the sexual kind. People still get sick but usually they don't spread it around much, it's usually just a few people at a time and the state makes sure they're quarantined and treated. If you can do better than that Anavel Sani will want to make it available. Even if your invention wouldn't sell well they might subsidize it. We'd have to move south to deal with them, you'd run into people who don't speak Hari. Might be worth it. Is it the kind of thing they'll want?"

Permalink Mark Unread

A convenience of the gloves is that she has them in that form already, though adjustment for those without hands would be needed.

Ah, she sees. She'd been imagining the disease issue was basically solved by death magic, but hadn't thought through the use for abortions. She doesn't know enough about that government. At home, people use condoms for disease risk, and also for if they want to have sex that can result in pregnancy when a relevant partner if fertile (it is more effective in avoiding undesired pregnancies to not do that to begin with, but some people do for various reasons.)

...But people here don't have discerning-sense, does that mean they can't read fertility? 

Permalink Mark Unread

"It depends on the species. Some people are only fertile part of the year, some people are only fertile at the right age, of course no one can have kids with another species... At home how much does it cost to have as many condoms as you want for a year?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Do humans here work the same way as humans in her world, with respect to that?

She's not an ideal person to ask about prices but she attempts to make an estimate and transmit it through comparing food prices.

Permalink Mark Unread

"People will want them at that price but not enough that it's our best way to make money. How hard would it be to make electricity do something that can't be done with magic?"

Permalink Mark Unread

The price might not match - in her world they're made in factories and shipped across the Empire - but, understood.

She's still not sure all of what magic does - it clearly does a lot. The problem with electricity is that it does do a lot (if possibly less that is not already being done, here), but a lot of the uses are very effort front-loaded. Which is part of the reason she's trying to think of other things.

Permalink Mark Unread

"It might not be a bad idea for us to just sell a structure mage information about rubber and suggest some applications. You think of as many applications as you can and I'll try to figure out who'll be most interested."

Permalink Mark Unread

Alright. Rubber, or nitrile, or latex, to start? Reminder about desirable treatment of 'intellectual property'. Possibly an approach would be to say whoever they sell to gets to be the only person to sell or use the information for some particular length of time, but she's still allowed to utilize it for her own use?

Permalink Mark Unread

"How would you use it yourself? You're not a structure mage."

Permalink Mark Unread

Use it as in use the information, for instance to have someone make something she needs for her.

(She apologizes, she does not know fairly much anything about how intellectual properly works here.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know much about it either and I don't know how to find out. If I find a possible buyer I'll try to get them to suggest something."

Permalink Mark Unread

Would there be laws on it listed like the laws he showed her? Would someone at the government building know? And at the least he did mention contracts earlier.

Such a person might have motivation to not give entirely good information, but it would be some information, so. Seems reasonable to ask.

If there's some way to market this, she supposes she could also try working as a very limited knowledge mage who can tell people if they're fertile or pregnant or some ways they're sick or not. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"There's a market for that. All mages are limited, you can't learn everything before you die. Which kinds of sickness can you detect?"

Permalink Mark Unread

So in humans the two major factors are how far along it is and how long she spends with a person. She can generally get more detail by spending more time around them (it doesn't have to be quality time or anything of the sort). A thing she's generally less likely to be able to do is to sort out a variety of bacterial and viral infection from each other, though here that seems like it might be less of a problem.

But - she's actually fairly good at this; she's quite good at using discerning sense and she happened to get a chance to practice this. Things she can discern include various cancers, various hormonal disorders and such, a variety of 'such and such organ is not operating exactly correctly' (diabetes, for example), infections. Internal injuries. 

She's not sure how much will carry over to non-humans, as well as not knowing if they even have the same illnesses (though there's some things she would at least expect to be similar enough). If there's some kind of opportunity for her to walk through a hospital or the like, she can try to see about it. Especially if he knows anything about other species' illnesses and can tell her.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Depending on how long it takes you to tell, it would be really useful if you warned people about distemper and white death before they have symptoms. Those mostly affect beluli, agerah and essi. But I don't know how to get you access to a lot of sick people to learn from. If I knew how to arrange that it'd be a decent job for you when you run out of things to 'invent'."

Permalink Mark Unread

How long is the period between getting it and symptoms? Is it developing without symptoms during that time? She doesn't know what distemper is. Is white death tuberculosis? 

Alright, she will keep that in mind. And work on paying attention to people when they practice going out; see what she can read.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know how long it takes for symptoms to show. Distemper's awful, they cough and vomit and have fits and diarrhea and sometimes die. White death is a fungus that grows on reptiles and kills them."

Permalink Mark Unread

Is distemper viral or bacterial or something else?

Alright, she does not know either of those in that case. If there's a way she can see any sick people she can see what her discerning sense might give her about it?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know which of those it is. Iri?"

"I don't know, I'd need to know someone who had them."

"But there might be a way to get you information about sick people. It'd be conspicuous but I might be able to think of something."

Permalink Mark Unread

Probably not worth doing something conspicuous right now?

Does this world have hospitals and such? Or doctors whose office they could hang around outside?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah, but people will definitely notice us hanging around. It'd be kind of rude, we could pay patients but..."

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah, understood. No doctors offices near something it would makes sense to be near? Or hospitals that might need someone for a day job?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Maybe. If I knew more about medicine maybe I'd know of jobs that don't need death or structure or force magic."

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, what's the force magic used for?

In the hospital she was in some menial jobs were cleaning and fetching and carrying; she doesn't know how the hospitals here work though. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"They use force magic to move things that you can't easily grab onto and move around another way. You know, like if someone decides to use something unusual as a dildo and it gets stuck. Or sometimes they can get to someone who's choking fast enough to save them. Or people that can't cough well enough and are dying of it. Anyway, I can look into nonmagic jobs that would let you get close to sick people, just because I don't know about them doesn't mean there aren't any. I need to find a new job anyway."

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah, understood. Useful.

And, not very time critical, she thinks, but that sounds like a plan. And meanwhile she can start paying more attention to that particular area when they go out.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Finish the tide table first. And then rubber."

Permalink Mark Unread

(Alpha instincts continue to not give useful input.)

Of course.

She'd like to practice going out parallel to working on the tide table, though. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda offers her a few coins. "When you want you can go out. Buy yourself something if you want. Don't draw attention and don't do anything stupid. Don't let anyone overcharge you, don't fall for any scams, don't forget to work on the tide table."

Permalink Mark Unread

She thanks him on all counts. (It's obviously more useful to go out with him at this point in time; feedback and all that pedagogical value. But it's not something she's going to push on. And she's handled picking up customs and the like herself before, if not in another world. And having money is also very useful).

She will absolutely be careful and conservative. What kinds of things might draw attention/be stupid? How would she know if people are overcharging her? What are scams and signs of scams to watch out for?

She will not. In fact, varying activities is likely to be beneficial to her productivity. 

(Soon enough she expects she'll be used to this particular dynamic of managing/not taking not-useful advice from her Alpha instincts, as she got with the dynamics of slavery.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"Don't buy things you don't know how to assess the quality of, I guess. Don't agree to any deals where you pay now and maybe get something later. Don't buy things you can get for free. Don't buy things from someone who's breaking a law and don't trust anyone who says they can keep you from getting caught if you break a law for them. Don't give away anything you could sell. Don't interact with people if you don't have to."

Permalink Mark Unread

Understood. Just to clarify, what kinds of people breaking laws might be trying to sell something to her? And, what can be gotten for free?

Permalink Mark Unread

"People might try to sell you stolen goods. And you can read the laws for free and learn Hari for free and there are some diseases you can sometimes get treated for free, especially in a city like this."

Permalink Mark Unread

Understood. Is there a way to tell if goods being sold are stolen?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do business in public places without illusions. And buy things from people who have other customers."

Permalink Mark Unread

Thank you. Without illusions?

Permalink Mark Unread

"One reason for doing business outside is so people can scry it. It's a way to show that you have nothing to hide. There's reasons to run a business from inside a building and some of them are legitimate, but if you don't know enough to tell, just avoiding hidden business is a way to show that you don't think you're doing anything bad. You won't always be able to tell but most knowledge mages will know and if they're avoiding someone then other people will notice and usually avoid them too. And there are legitimate businesses that aren't very popular but if you can't tell..."

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, interesting!

Ah, without the knowledge mage blocking illusions?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah, guess that wouldn't be obvious, don't avoid a shopkeeper just for having blue fur or anything."

Permalink Mark Unread

She was thinking of some sort of decorative illusions on the surroundings, though she doesn't know if those are discernible from not-illusions. She's still not sure how the knowledge mage blocking illusions work, exactly.

Understood, thank you.

Permalink Mark Unread

"The important thing is whether the business is scryable. Doesn't matter if ten feet of ground around the stall are illusioned to look like you're floating in the starry void beyond the world, it just matters if a knowledge mage can hear you say 'yeah I'll take twelve of those for eight rings' and see you hand over your rings and get what you're buying."

Permalink Mark Unread

That makes sense. (And she already understood that part just fine, but she's not saying that.)

Does he know how the knowledge mage blocking illusions work?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not an illusion mage or a knowledge mage. Iri?"

"I'm not an illusion mage, I just know what they look like."

Permalink Mark Unread

They look like something?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah, to me they look like blind spots, like a spot of... nothing... in the middle of everything. Just when I use magic to see them, they don't look like anything to my eyes."

Permalink Mark Unread

Understood.

Speaking of magic, what should she do with the door if she goes out?

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Don't stay out long and come back fast, I guess. Maybe don't get into a routine, if people don't know when you'll get back that's better."

Permalink Mark Unread

Understood.

She thanks him again.  

Oh, can she get a map somewhere, of what's around here? If not, could he draw her one?

Permalink Mark Unread

He draws her a map of Thelm Ret and its surroundings from memory. It's not a very good map. It may not even be accurate. It's almost certainly not to scale. He marks east and west.

Permalink Mark Unread

She would not expect to-scale maps when drawn by random people, nor entirely accurate ones. She thanks him. Carrying a map draws attention; she memorizes it.

And the next time she is left alone, she goes out.

Permalink Mark Unread

There is the same city as last time she went out.

Permalink Mark Unread

Some information she needs:

-General locations and arrangements of things. Are there more and less expensive areas? Other kinds of orientation information?

-Can she successfully wander around without running into trouble?

-How expensive is food?

-Is anyone hiring for menial labor, and if so how does it pay?

-If she needed to find things like 'people who might pay her for math' and 'people she might sell technology to' on her own, can she figure out how she would do that?

Permalink Mark Unread

There's an illusion mage with a notice board who charges a fee to add someone's ad to it for a period of time. There are a handful up right now.

Nesa - erel - freelance medical structure mage - I have treated hair loss, fatigue - kept a human with diabetes alive 2 years - find me at home at the brown building on Chestnut Street, 2nd floor, apartment 2

 

Want to learn Lexori? Isava the belul teaches it. Find me at the market or in the woods, I have free time to teach in the late morning and evening

 

Hari-Devin translation by Hanu the agerah - find me at market most mornings, in my house at the corner of Chestnut and Rain most noons. Telvik Haryi yo Devini, ager Hanuvi - segithet en karthani serverasan, niswi eni etyi Chestnut yo Rain detverasan.

She doesn't seem to have run into trouble yet.

Someone negotiates with the thwilit to visit them and pick up four pounds of honey for ninety rings.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ad boards and medical structure mages are of interest. She notes down Nesa's information. (She doesn't know a few of the words, including 'diabetes'; she notes those down too.)

How much is food in the sense of food she can go eat? How much money does she have from Valanda right now? Do people seem to be getting drinking water from anywhere (aside from within the apartments)? Public restrooms? It would be easier to tell at night but are there people who seem to sleep in the streets around?

Permalink Mark Unread

There definitely aren't any people currently asleep in the streets visible right now from where she's standing.

There's no public water fountain near the market. If there are public restrooms they're not visible from the street. She has sixteen rings: two fours, three twos, two ones. She could get some apples or a couple ounces of pecans.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yes, but 'people who sleep in the streets' is a thing one can notice without actually seeing them sleeping at that precise moment.

She isn't planning on doing that. Though, since she's not sure if Valanda will want the money back if she doesn't spend it - anyone selling better writing utensils, and can she afford them?

Permalink Mark Unread

If she steps into the stationery store she'll find there are lots of inventions available if she'd like to use her paws to write! This thing is so easy to grip with paws! This kit for fingerpainting probably works just as well with fingers. This kit for tail-tip painting might just be a novelty. Available in the genre of human-hand-sized pencils: a few charcoal sticks tucked in a corner.

Permalink Mark Unread

If there are people going in and out of the stationery store, she will step in.

Ah, so that's the problem. Well, a charcoal stick is already available at the moment. She leaves and keeps looking around.

What other kinds of stores rather than market-things are there?

Permalink Mark Unread

A smith, a library, a publicly funded outpatient clinic that's always open. A nice sit-down restaurant for people who want to sit on the floor and eat trail mix. Someone is selling blankets, pillows, bolts of fabric, things that are arguably clothing, curtains.

Permalink Mark Unread

Is the library free or does it charge?

Can she learn anything more about the outpatient clinic?

Permalink Mark Unread

The library charges.

The clinic has a death mage on duty at all times. Treatment is free for rabies, distemper, caralendar pox, white death, a couple of other highly contagious diseases. A structure mage is on duty from noon to eight in the evening, appointments preferred but an attempt will be made to find time for walk-ins.

Permalink Mark Unread

Useful to know. Does it note what kinds of thing the structure mage does?

Charges to walk in or to read or to borrow or?

Permalink Mark Unread

Doesn't say what the structure mage does. It does say the clinic can offer "nonmagical expert advice" but doesn't explain what that is either.

The library charges to read and charges more to borrow.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, if they don't charge to walk in and look around she'll do that.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's a small library. It's brighter than a lot of nearby shops. They've clearly invented the codex but more than nine tenths of the library books are scrolls.

A small bookshelf has codices titled Three-Dimensional Geometry; Native Plants of Anavel Sani and Southern Rasa; Milocri and Seihra-Gara: Eyewitnesses of the Middle Warring States Period, 144 - 90 Before Unification; Twelve Twelves: Surprising Tips For All Twelve; and Architecture for Caralendri and Beluli.

There are a few dozen scrolls with titles like Known Dietary Needs of Eight Peoples; Twelve Jobs You Can Do as a Non-Force Mage Who Can't Walk or Fly; Architecture for Essi; Efficient Farming Techniques; World Almanac 432; World Almanac 433; How Government Works; Prehistoric Ehima; Rain, Sun, and Other Influences on Agriculture in Ehima.

Every single book is in Hari.

Permalink Mark Unread

How are the books made, hand-copied or something else?

Is the Twelves one about magic, from what she can see without reading?

How much is reading?

Permalink Mark Unread

The writing might be illusioned onto the pages.

It's probably about magic.

She can afford maybe a quarter of an hour of reading anything they have, if she haggles the price down as far as it goes and spends everything she has.

Permalink Mark Unread

She'll go look around some more and if she hasn't found anything more useful to buy she'll come back and take it.

Back outside. So - sectors and areas of town? More and less expensive areas? Also, can she spot any law enforcement? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Zoning's fairly mixed. A number of buildings have businesses on their lower floors and residences above. There are apartments around the market and on the way to the airport.

No one is obviously law enforcement.

Permalink Mark Unread

She's not going too far today, so she'll try to figure out more about different areas another day.

Meanwhile, how do people in the street tend to treat each other? Can she see a lot of slaves? How do they act? How common are injuries? How violent do people get with slaves in public?

Permalink Mark Unread

People tend to ignore each other if they're not obviously together or doing business. Looks like at least four out of five people are free, but not nine out of ten. A lot of the slaves seem to be working.

There are visibly injured people, most of them slaves. It's not a majority of slaves but it's definitely a significant minority. Less than half of people she sees have visible scars but there are certainly some who do. Someone drags a slave who seems to be refusing to go somewhere. Nothing more violent than that happens while she watches but the slave being dragged has some claw marks. Injuries and scars are unevenly distributed: it's noticeable how many people have either a lot or none at all, more often none.

Permalink Mark Unread

And how about if they are together or doing business? What kinds of work are the slaves doing? (What kinds of work are people in general doing, aside from selling things?)

Uh-hm.

Permalink Mark Unread

Some people are discussing things or haggling or asking questions about goods and services for sale. Some people are carrying things for other people. The people having things carried for them are disproportionately likely to be snakes.

There's an illusion mage changing the color of people's fur or belongings. There's someone talking to the illusion mage with the noticeboard about listing street cleaning dates for the sake of people who are forgetful or new in town.

She could infer things about what else people do. Someone, several someones, made Hari is the Language of the Empire. Someone is farming all the food for sale. There must be people construction workers and plumbers and smiths, but there aren't electricians or computer programmers.

Permalink Mark Unread

What kinds of things do they ask (that she can overhear without seeming to spy, and understand)? What kinds of things are people carrying?

Any indication of how they get their street cleaning done? Also, can she tell who's talking to the mage about it; is it a government official, an altruistic civilian...

Indeed. But at the moment she's looking at what she can see. Menial labor? Anyone hiring for it?

Permalink Mark Unread

They ask if food for sale has had a death mage see to it already. They ask about businesses' open hours. They ask about people's credentials and training. They ask all kinds of things.

People are carrying rings, groceries, that kind of thing, mostly.

There is no evidence that anything is being done by altruistic civilians.

A snake tries to talk to her in a language that isn't Hari, but she may not recognize this as a job offer if she doesn't speak North Essi.

Permalink Mark Unread

Credentials and training? (What kinds get mentioned? What kinds seem desirable?) What kinds of hours do businesses tend to have? How do people seem to be keeping time?

Well, it wasn't that likely people would describe the street cleaning. What are the dates, so she can just look then? And, what can help her identify this person as government? Do they do anything else?

"I'm sorry, I only speak Hari," she says, in what seems to be a neutral polite tone from what she's been overhearing.

Permalink Mark Unread

There are twenty-four hours in a day and there seem to be things in the genre of sundials. Businesses that rely on being open during their customers' free time have more variable hours but a lot of people seem to work on the same schedule as Valanda, a few hours in the morning and a few in the evening.

The notice, which says it's there by order of the mayor's office, says it'll next happen in a few days.

Illusion letters appear that spell out CARRY THINGS FOR ME AND I TEACH YOU TO UNDERSTAND SOME THINGS ESSI SAY? in Hari.

Permalink Mark Unread

Good to know. She notes to herself to ask Valanda if they have better clocks. (Maybe knowledge mages fill in?) Also if she can remember anything about clock-making, in case.

She notes that too.

That seems like something it would be useful to try. Possibly would have been better to wait, but she can't assume she'll always get offers. What things, and where, and for how long, she asks. (Good to be clear with these things.)

Permalink Mark Unread

His groceries and anything else he happens to want to buy or sell or transport. Where he wants them, definitely not outside the city at any rate. Probably not for more than a couple hours.

Permalink Mark Unread

She will carry things she is safely able to carry, places where it is safe for her to go, for a couple of hours or less, and that is agreeable to her.

(Valanda may have a different opinion on if she should try this, but she needs information, and in fact information on what happens if Valanda doesn't like something she does is also rather important.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Then she can end up carrying things to places. A couple hours ends up being an overestimate, he doesn't need her that long.

He teaches her to recognize some words in North Essi. Yes, no, the numbers one through twelve, here, there, rings, deal.

Permalink Mark Unread

Useful. Any new to her places? What are they like?

Permalink Mark Unread

He wants some things taken back to his apartment in a different building. It's a lot like Valanda's, but one of the floors has lower ceilings, paler colors and more windows.

Permalink Mark Unread

She observes and so on.

Permalink Mark Unread

The snake doesn't want anything else from her.

Permalink Mark Unread

Given the time that took, she'll go back to Valanda's apartment rather than the library.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Learn any Hari while you were out?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She did. Here's some words she picked up from so to speak immersion. Also some she didn't know the meanings of, including 'diabetes'.

Permalink Mark Unread

Turns out Valanda doesn't know that one either.

Iri does! "It's a disease where, um, food is poison because something's wrong with one of your organs?"

Permalink Mark Unread

There's more than one of those, does Iri have any specifics?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think you go blind and die?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She tries out some Capital words for diseases. (Not the kind of thing she wants to be uncertain of, here.)

Permalink Mark Unread

And now Iri knows what those Capital words mean!

Which would be really helpful if they knew a lot of Hari disease names. They can rule out some of them but not single out one of them as definitely right.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, unless knowledge magic can help that sounds as far as they can go with present resources.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm sorry. Should I go, um, try to figure it out somehow?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri has nothing to be sorry for. It's probably not that important right now?

In something else she's wondering if they know - do they know the approximate demographics of the different species of this world? She understands it's different in different places.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think more people are agerah than anything else but less than half of people are agerah. Beluli are the next most common, I think. Then caralendri. And humans are rarest."

Permalink Mark Unread

How rare? And about how does it vary among different places?

Permalink Mark Unread

"There might be somewhere between 6912 and 8640 humans in the Hari Empire. I think there are more agerah north of the mountains and more caralendri south of them."

Permalink Mark Unread

Well.

Does he know why there are so few humans? Have their always been? 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think there used to be two or three times as many?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh?

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I don't have siblings, I think that's why there aren't very many humans."

Permalink Mark Unread

Her Alpha and Protector instincts together have decided to take this time to tell her that this is an unsafe number and she should clearly do something about this. She puts them away appropriately.

Are they having fertility or pregnancy or infant mortality problems of some sort, or social problems, or do people just not tend to want many children?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think my parents wanted more children before they saw how I turned out."

Permalink Mark Unread

He seems to have turned out perfectly well; is there something they found objectionable? And, is this a common experience?

Permalink Mark Unread

"What a question! And what did your parents think of you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

At some point she will need to make decisions about what story she can tell here. In the meanwhile,

They didn't particularly like her, and then something they didn't like about her became something that could embarrass them, and then they got rid of her and she hadn't seen them since she was fifteen. She was the second child, though.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah, well, my parents had their regrettable baby first. Anyway, I don't think all humans even have relationships with other humans, lots of people are happy with caralendri or something."

Permalink Mark Unread

Sympathy to him.

Ah, she sees. It must be harder to find suitable humans with such small numbers, too. And they don't mind the lack of children?

Permalink Mark Unread

"You can buy baby beluli, they're adorable."

Permalink Mark Unread

...She sees.

What does one do with them when they grow older?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Same things you do with human children!"

Permalink Mark Unread

Those being?

Permalink Mark Unread

"You can free them or use them as slaves or kill them."

Permalink Mark Unread

She sees.

 

In somewhat closer matters - now that she is somewhat better acquainted with things, she has been wondering what sorts of plans he may have, with regards to her and such.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'll let you stay here while you pay me back for all the help I've given you."

Permalink Mark Unread

She considers possible responses to this. (Alpha instincts continue unhelpfulness.)

She appreciates his help very much, thank you. If that is in fact what he wants she can certainly do that.

If he actually wants something else it would be convenient if he perhaps told her so.

(He obviously wants something else, by that phrasing and nonverbals, but she won't push harder for the moment.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"I've given you a lot. I want you to make it worth my while to have taken you in and let you see me sleep and fed you and taught you Hari. Otherwise I won't help you in the future. You can't do this with innovative uses of magic like I expected but if you can do it with arithmetic and useful technology and scientific information I'll call that good enough."

Permalink Mark Unread

She continues to appreciate it.

Alright. Does he have some personal goals in life she could perhaps help with, or is he simply thinking of monetary payment?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I want to rule a city somewhere with all the humans in the world."

Permalink Mark Unread

...Well that certainly answers her question.

Would he mind telling her more about that?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Then I can make laws that I like better than the ones here."

Permalink Mark Unread

What sorts of laws?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you actually think you can help with that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

She considers and decides this is a situation in which to take the honesty risk.

If he thinks the present setup is less than good for humans and wants a better one and they have sufficient agreement on what that might look like, then yes, she can. If he likes exercising unpleasant power over people then she - well, can't, probably, but also won't.

Permalink Mark Unread

"What do you mean, exercising unpleasant power over people?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Having people arrested for insulting him, picking random attractive people he likes and having them dragged by guards to his bedchambers, requiring people to do anything he orders on pain of torture, that sort of thing and its variants.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not going to commit assault or keep people out of public places, I would get fined. If I want to have someone dragged somewhere, I'll buy a slave. I don't see why you keep thinking governments should make insulting them illegal, that's pointless and stupid. Obviously I'll require people to do what I say, that's what it means to be in charge of someplace, but I won't tell anyone to break any imperial laws because I'd get in trouble for that."

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah, have a city in that sense.

Does he think he is going to be buying slaves and having them dragged around?

She does not think they should, she thinks that the ones she is used to does, and that many people who want to govern like it that way.

That is not in fact what it means to be in charge. It is quite possible to be in charge, in the sense of making social laws and various decisions, and not to require everyone to obey your personal orders, in the sense of 'paint my walls right now' or 'give me that object in your living room'.

What did he think she might mean?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I wasn't sure what you meant, that's why I asked. I don't want any more slaves right now, I'm even considering getting rid of Iri eventually. Yes, I expect I'd make clear laws and not randomly demand that people paint my walls, that would make people want to live somewhere more predictable. Do you think I'd be the kind of ruler you'd refuse to help?"

Permalink Mark Unread

...Getting rid of in what sense?

She does not currently have enough information on what kind of ruler to think he'd be, which is why she's trying to get more of it. If the city is to be populated voluntarily that makes is significantly more likely he'd be the kind of ruler she'd help become one.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I couldn't just kidnap people for my city, that's illegal. I might sell Iri at some point, maybe, or maybe I'll decide not to. What else do you need to know?"

Permalink Mark Unread

If he means to sell, and she can acquire enough money to buy, she would appreciate it if he would allow her to do that. She can express this appreciation tangibly as applicable.

 

Why is he interested in this? What kinds of laws is he thinking of? What does he think will attract humans to move to his city?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Imagine waking up in a room designed for human comfort, going to buy food and having meat and fruit and vegetables available at the same market, wanting to get laid and being able to find another human, being able to find enough other humans to choose, having cheaper housing because you don't have to accommodate any agerah, having the door handles at a comfortable height for a human to use, having everything designed for you. I want that."

Permalink Mark Unread

That certainly makes sense.

And laws?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I haven't decided yet. I think since humans free their children at pretty high rates I should maybe require people not to hit them on the head a lot while their brains are growing. And since we take the longest to grow up there's so much time to teach human children things, maybe we can have more educated people."

Permalink Mark Unread

...yes that sounds like a good law.

Oh, humans take the longest to grow up?

And, yes, this sounds like the sort of venture she'd want to help with. And thinks she can - she'd been considering what to use any resources she might be able to acquire for, aside from repayment, and this would be a effective answer, and she has lived (exclusively, in fact) in cities designed for humans and such, and would predict that she knows things that would be useful.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Well, maybe I can use you if I ever make enough to get my city. I'd need to make up all the money I've spent on you and then some, though." Sigh. He looks out the window and doesn't do anything regrettable. "...Yeah, humans take the longest, our age of majority is seventeen, it's twelve for caralendri and they take the next-longest."

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah, she hadn't realized. What about everyone else?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Four or so for beluli and agerah and seven months for essi and ereli."

Permalink Mark Unread

Understood. (Well then.)

How do the life spans compare?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Uh. Beluli don't live as long as humans, ereli don't live as long as beluli, essi don't live as long as ereli, thwilit can live forever but the individual birds don't, anemones can just live forever, agerah live longer than humans and caralendri live longer than agerah."

Permalink Mark Unread

About how long do humans live here? And what about individual birds?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Humans usually live to be more than sixty and usually not ninety. Thwilit, uh... I'm not sure."

"Four or sixteen or twenty-four," says Iri. "Depending on who you're talking about."

Permalink Mark Unread

That's a fairly good lifespan. Especially considering the circumstances.

Oh?

Permalink Mark Unread

Iri explains but the explanation hinges on three very important words that she's heard one of before but not the other two. The one she's heard is what Valanda called Iri's gender.

Permalink Mark Unread

She asks about those. (Which lifespan does the one Iri goes with correspond to?)

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, one of them lays eggs and lives more than twenty years, one of them fathers eggs and lives about four years, and Iri does useful things and might live to be about sixteen.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh. Are thwilit like bees?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think so."

Permalink Mark Unread

She sees. (She doesn't say anything about the lifespan, because condolences seem like they might be misplaced, and it is not as thought she expects to be able to do anything about it.)

 

Alright, so if this is what Valanda wants, does he want to be making a plan together and such?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I can't rule anywhere right now, I need to buy land. Which I can't do because I don't have enough saved up."

Permalink Mark Unread

Makes sense.

Have the place value system buyers gotten back to him yet? She has some useful things you can use once you have that she could try selling to them. And are they going to be spreading it around? She has some calculation aids some people might like. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I've put off agreeing to some things while doing some market research, now that you have something you're doing already, but I'm planning to talk to them again tomorrow."

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah, good, that's the part he is fairly certainly more qualified to do than she is and she has been aware of her lack.

If at some point they need to advertise she can beat people in a public speed math contest, if one can be arranged?

What other kinds of market research is he doing? Would he be able to conduct some about nitrile and latex gloves? She thinks that is another good and low hanging candidate for her to sell.

Permalink Mark Unread

"That's a good idea, I'll look into both of those things."

Permalink Mark Unread

Excellent.

It is quite beneficial, in several senses, to have a plan in existence. She would have had an improvement in tide table/Hari performance regardless, due to the outing (she can push her psychology around to a much greater extent than at all standard, but it does remain her psychology), but with this it increases further. 

She works on tide tables and Hari.

Permalink Mark Unread

He talks to people and asks her how long she expects it'll take to explain place value, someone wants to schedule a lecture for a handful of mathematicians about it.

Permalink Mark Unread

That seems a desirable idea.

Not that long to explain, but perhaps they'll want to attempt using it with her available for questions?

How are presentations done here; in her world they have chalkboards or whiteboards to write on, or slides to project.

Permalink Mark Unread

"You should be able to borrow chalk but I'll ask."

Permalink Mark Unread

And a surface to write on? (She's seen the illusion mage teacher he hired her, of course, but she's not an illusion mage.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm sure the answer is yes but I'll ask anyway."

Permalink Mark Unread

How soon might this be happening, so she can plan?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Might be able to work out a time five days from now when all the relevant people would have the time and be in town."

Permalink Mark Unread

Alright. She will plan for that. 

She adds planning the lecture to her schedule of the day.

She goes out on her own again.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's another ordinary day of various sociopathic talking cats and such going about their business.

Permalink Mark Unread

She hasn't actually fully gathered the 'sociopathic' yet; it's the sort of thing harder to entirely realize from materials meant for people used to this world. And her origins do not overly help.

If Valanda didn't take the money he gave her back, she heads for the library.

Permalink Mark Unread

He didn't do that.

There is the library, same place as before, with its scrolls and codices.

Permalink Mark Unread

She'd like to pay for reading time. She'll haggle to get the most out of her money.

Permalink Mark Unread

She can get about a quarter of an hour.

Permalink Mark Unread

Starting with quick look at Twelve Jobs You Can Do.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's written on the assumption that the reader has very limited physical abilities and no ability to use magic to compensate. The tone is matter-of-fact. There is no mention of taking charity, even as a thing to avoid. 

Accommodations can be made for medical death and structure mages, though being able to make house calls is an advantage. It's not unheard of to get elected to an important position in state or imperial government while disabled, though it is unheard of for essi and ereli. For essi who can travel easily under their own power, there are jobs available for most kinds of mage: painting buildings, investigating crimes, encouraging crops, transmuting elements, keeping food safe, fireproofing buildings, all kinds of things. For people with the necessary dexterity, there's smithing, carpentry, pottery, weaving. It has ever happened that someone made a living publishing books or mathematical proofs.

Turns out there are actually more than twelve options total, but some of them rely on being the right kind of mage or having skills or body parts someone in the target audience is unusually likely not to have.

Permalink Mark Unread

Do they seem to have wheelchairs? (Would the streets allow the use?)

Permalink Mark Unread

The streets are flat and hard and wide enough and a lot of the nearby buildings have street-level entrances. The pavement is in good repair in most areas, too: there are some chipped tiles but there are no trees ripping it up with their roots or anything.

There's a mention in the book of renting or buying something that, in context, is probably exactly the same kind of thing that would be used to take a big unwieldy load of fruit to market. It doesn't say it explicitly but she can infer that it's probably nothing self-propelled.

Permalink Mark Unread

She notes this.

And the Surprising Tips For All Twelve book?

Permalink Mark Unread

Mildly counterintuitive tips for every kind of magic. Did you know if you make the same amounts of water and metal the same temperature the metal will cool less other stuff than the water before the temperatures equalize. Did you know that isotopes are a thing. Did you know that even though you can't use knowledge magic to translate written material you can use it to translate the act of writing something down, and you can pastwatch for the moment something was written and translate from that. And so on.

Permalink Mark Unread

That's very interesting. 

Can she use this to get any hints of what the magic forms she's still unclear on do?

Permalink Mark Unread

Maybe! The writer seems to have thought that inheritance mages would find it useful to know that some genes regulate the expression of other genes... but doesn't bother to explain what a gene is.

Permalink Mark Unread

She can probably guess from context.

Does she have time to look at any of the other magic types before her time's up?

Permalink Mark Unread

She can read a little more but not a lot.

Looks like most of the useful tips for mages are facts about the world around them rather than about their own magic.

Permalink Mark Unread

What do the ones she has time for say?

Permalink Mark Unread

One of them points out that selectively encouraging everything that isn't a weed is effectively the same thing as stunting weed growth, since the other plants will steal their water and block their sun.

A lot of these tips might be hard to understand and reading in a second language is pretty slow. She doesn't have the time, or the ability if she had the time, to understand everything.

Permalink Mark Unread

She approves of this thinking.

She didn't particularly expect otherwise. More, and other books, will have to await another opportunity. She returns her reading material and leaves the library again.

And, she'd like to attempt to continue gaining information about the city and society. Does the map she's seen suggest in any way how large the city is? (Does anywhere in the market or elsewhere she's seen have a better map up?)

Permalink Mark Unread

She's seen aerial views of cities on Hari Is The Language Of The Empire, if this one is typical it's not all that big. She could probably see the whole thing on foot in one day. There aren't any better maps on display. It's possible there are some for sale somewhere.

Permalink Mark Unread

Useful.

Well, for today she's out of money. Does the map she saw give any idea of where wealthier vs poor areas might be?

Permalink Mark Unread

She could guess based on where people would want to live relative to the things marked but otherwise no.

Permalink Mark Unread

What things are marked?

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda marked his apartment, the market, the government buildings, a forest, some mountains, a river.

Permalink Mark Unread

About how close are the apartment and market to the center vs the edge of town? Also, how does the city seem to be arranged? Some kind of organized layout or not?

Permalink Mark Unread

It's a little hard to tell those things from this map. The city edge isn't marked and neither are most streets.

From what she's seen wandering around, it's an organic, unplanned city.

Permalink Mark Unread

She will attempt walking toward the center of the city, and see what she can observe.

Permalink Mark Unread

A small, historic district of buildings dating back to before the empire. They seem to be used mostly by businesses rather than for residences.

Permalink Mark Unread

What kind of businesses? What distinguishes the historic district?

Permalink Mark Unread

Businesses that don't mind the limitations of the architecture which does not, for example, include indoor plumbing. The walls rise straight up instead of each floor being a little bigger than the one below. There are more single-story buildings in this district than the entire rest of the city combined, which is to say three.

Permalink Mark Unread

And what businesses are those?

Any change in what people are around here as compared to the market?

Permalink Mark Unread

There's a smith and a tailor and some others.

There's an agerah buying a new hat and a caralendar getting a knife. A few agerah and a belul wander through the area without stopping to do any shopping.

Permalink Mark Unread

What are the prices like compared to the area near the market?

Also, while she's here, what are the smith and tailor like? (The businesses, not the people.)

Can she use whatever she's seen in the not-video so far to hypothesize anything about the caralendar?

Permalink Mark Unread

Prices don't differ by a lot. Slightly lower.

The caralendri all seem to be herbivorous humanoids.

The smith is a caralendar whose process seems to involve hitting glowing metal with a hammer. He seems to be a heat mage who can heat and cool metal on his own without fire or water. The tailor is an agerah force mage who can sew two seams at once with magic and has no trouble threading needles.

Permalink Mark Unread

Useful.

Are they both working on their own?

What kinds of things do they make?

Permalink Mark Unread

The smith has a boy with him, watching but not touching anything right now. The two of them talk a little in Ilan.

The tailor makes a wide variety of garments that are not all designed for humanoids. Most of them are more decorative than functional, for definitions of decorative that include... modesty? It might be modesty. Hard to tell with the information she has.

Permalink Mark Unread

She doesn't know Ilan, though maybe she can tell a bit of what it sounds like compared to Hari?

Signs of mistreatment on the (presumably slave) boy?

Permalink Mark Unread

The boy sure is a slave but it's not clear that he's being mistreated. He has scratches that are pretty consistent with falling onto pavement or running around in the woods and would be a little unusual for the results of corporal punishment. He seems relaxed and interested in the work and asks questions.

Ilan seems to have five or six phonemes Hari doesn't but no tones. It's not immediately possible to recognize any words as probably cognates.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well that's a good thing in as much as she can rely on momentary observations.

She notes what she can of the sounds in case she suddenly needs to fake an accent for some reason.

Can she tell what is on the upper stories of the buildings?

Permalink Mark Unread

There are signs in front of some of the entrances!

One has a weaver and one has a carver who sells little wooden statues. One has a couple of apartments for rent. One has empty space for rent by the hour. One conspicuously doesn't say what its top floor has.

Permalink Mark Unread

Can she go look in on the weaver and carver? Is there information on the apartments and empty space? What are the prices like?

Permalink Mark Unread

Not the weaver, but she can see the front part of the carver's cramped, dim little shop. A curtain divides the front from the back. The carver is a belul who's missing part of his tail. If she gets too near any of the things on display he eyes her suspiciously. He has a knife in easy reach but it's almost certainly for wood, not flesh.

It doesnt actually list a price. She could inquire.

Permalink Mark Unread

She has no intention of stealing woodcarvings and can act accordingly.

She doesn't currently know how people here feel about inquiring without intent to buy; she'll avoid it for now.

And, attempting a new direction. 

Permalink Mark Unread

She finds a quiet neighborhood without many people out doing things. It seems mostly residential.

Permalink Mark Unread

Different in any ways from other residential places?

Apparent economic level relative to other places she's seen?

Permalink Mark Unread

Less intermingled with businesses.

It's kind of hard to say. Might not be very different than other places she's seen so far.

Permalink Mark Unread

Not where she is interested in being at the moment, in that case. 

Walking more. If she notices places getting nicer, or alternatively less nice, or the corresponding things about people in the streets, she'll head father in the relevant direction.

Permalink Mark Unread

If she goes all the way through this neighborhood she'll end up right at the fence around someone's orchard at the edge of town. There's no convenient gate right here, though. If she follows the fence a while keeping the city to one side of her she'll find a pathway out and a handful of shops and more housing.

Some of the housing here charges by the hour or the day instead of by the month. Might be hotels of some kind?

Permalink Mark Unread

She is not planning on trespassing. 

Useful to know. What kind of shops are here?

Permalink Mark Unread

At this entrance to town she could buy seeds or an almanac or an enchanted scarecrow. If she could pay for any of them.

Permalink Mark Unread

Enchanted scarecrow?

Permalink Mark Unread

It doesn't just stand still for the birds to perch on! It moves! It's a little bit dangerous to birds! Comes in three models, so you can replace them when the birds learn to get past them.

Another option also for sale is for just killing specific species that get into a certain area.

Permalink Mark Unread

Is the former force magic? (She is guessing the latter is death magic). 

Permalink Mark Unread

It's a combination of magics, actually. There's knowledge magic involved, but that might not be obvious to Sheridan. And illusion.

Permalink Mark Unread

(Is that information being made available somehow?)

It is indeed not obvious to her; she does not currently know that knowledge magic can be put on an object. She looks if there is any other information on the scarecrow.

Permalink Mark Unread

(She might make some inferences based on what it does.)

Someone is manning that shop at the moment! She might ask when he's done selling a belul a book.

Permalink Mark Unread

(How so?)

Has she seen other people asking people manning stores things without buying anything?

Permalink Mark Unread

(Well, it moves, it changes colors, it reacts to its environment...)

It has ever happened.

Permalink Mark Unread

So, force magic and illusion magic. (She does not make the knowledge magic inference yet.)

Did it happen in a way that suggests she can safely try it?

Permalink Mark Unread

Nobody got eaten?

It's plausible that everyone else who tried it was at least seriously considering buying. Most of them did buy at least one other thing while they were out.

Permalink Mark Unread

She's fairly confident she won't be eaten; she's more worried about someone getting angry she's not buying, wanting her to pay for the earlier questions, and calling lawkeepers on her when she cannot.

Alright, she will avoid that for the moment then. And, she hasn't found what she was looking for, but she's been out for a while; she heads back.

Permalink Mark Unread

Valanda's out when she gets back but Iri can let her in.

Permalink Mark Unread

Might Iri have the time and willingness to answer some questions?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Sure."

Permalink Mark Unread

She thinks she understands most of the types of magic, but what does inheritance magic actually entail?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Inside people and animals and plants there's a long string. It's too small to see. It's not all the same, different parts are different somehow. If a part of the string is wrong, you can get sick. For me, part of the string says what color my feathers are. If it was wrong I might be white instead. Inheritance magic is for seeing the string and changing it."

Permalink Mark Unread

...in living people?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes."

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

...what is their current state of the art on doing things with that? 

Permalink Mark Unread

"We don't know what most of the parts of the strings do. We know some. I'm not sure what the ones we know are. I know we got rid of some diseases."

Permalink Mark Unread

Understood. Thank you. 

This actually relates to her next question. She saw in a book a suggestion to do translation of written work with knowledge magic by looking back at when it was written. Is that kind of thing something Iri can do?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Maybe. It depends. Do you have one in mind?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Could she do it for things Sheridan did in her world, or does it only work here?

Permalink Mark Unread

There's a pause. "It only works here."

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, that is a shame, but nothing for it. 

(She wishes she'd studied more genetics, but nothing for that either.)

Next question, unrelated - she got the idea that some mages can make enchanted objects. Can all mages actually do that? Are there limits?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Not everyone learns how. Everyone could."

Permalink Mark Unread

Can objects do the same thing as a mage but only predetermined ones, or something else? What kinds of things do objects of the various magics do? 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I... guess so? They can do things like... control slaves. And play illusion shows. You can have windows that kill mites and flies if they go through." Vague shrug that she might be good enough at reading thwilit body language to recognize. "There are a lot of kinds of enchanted things."

Permalink Mark Unread

Knowledge magic enchanted things? Inheritance magic enchanted things?

Permalink Mark Unread

"There's knowledge magic in some of the slave bracelets. I don't know what kinds of things inheritance mages enchant."

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh?

And, how does knowledge mage enchantment work? It looks like when xie does knowledge magic, xie gets the information in xer mind. Where does the information 'go', if it's an enchanted object?

Permalink Mark Unread

"It goes in the spell. And then the other mage can make their part of the spell only do something if the knowledge part of it is a certain way. I don't know more details, I've never worked with other mages or enchanted anything."

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah, understood. So it can only interact with other spells?

Permalink Mark Unread

"It doesn't do anything to any spells. It's like putting up a sign, the sign doesn't interact with people."

Permalink Mark Unread

But other spells can read it? Would that also allow another mage to read it more directly? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "I don't know, I don't enchant things."

Permalink Mark Unread

She thanks Iri. She studies Hari and works on tide tables and the lecture.

What kinds of further things has she learned about this world through the not-video?