Accept our Terms of Service
Our Terms of Service have recently changed! Please read and agree to the Terms of Service and the Privacy Policy
native Fëanorian Amentans
+ Show First Post
Total: 6302
Posts Per Page:
Permalink

"He wants to dance. I bet nobody wants to be a cop."

Permalink

"If there were police officers ex-reds trusted maybe they'd report things more readily. On the other hand they might be stuck avoiding the appearance of impropriety so I suppose it might not help much." He scowls. "Criminal justice reform is going to be such a nightmare but it's terribly overdue."

Permalink

"There's some understanding of incentive structures," says Shasali, "apart from the hideous blind spot around reds."

Permalink

"It's pretty easy to push through any kind of fix that's an improvement to the incentives, if you've got those."

Permalink

"Well, all the ex-reds have picked castes now. Maybe a yellow office could filter complaints and supervise handling of them."

Permalink

"Could make that work, yeah, if greys didn't feel like it was a usurpation of their field. The reforms I'd want to make aren't really to the incentives, they're to - predictability and fairness and smaller differentials in treatment by caste."

Permalink

Nod.

Permalink

"Why's it hard?"

Permalink

"Uh, everyone likes the judges to have enough discretion to make things go away, there's a lot of evidence that swift handling of things has a better deterrent effect than anything else, so any change that makes things take longer isn't on the table, and people get attached to their special privileges and don't want them extended to other castes - why are there different methods of execution by caste? Literally just so we can feel special."

Permalink

Lots of hmmming.

Permalink

"Do you like the work, Shasali?"

Permalink

"I do, yes. I'd like it less if someone wanted me to have someone killed for extrajudicial reasons but so far that has not happened."

Permalink

"Honestly there are enough laws that if you want someone killed you can usually find a judicial reason!"

Permalink

"I don't think most people have committed capital crimes, and what I meant was if someone called me insisting, on the basis of extrajudicial motives, that I have someone executed."

Permalink

"Yes, that's reasonable. You shouldn't really get too many of those calls, I might've arranged a couple when the resources were sorely needed but that kind of thing doesn't happen constantly."

Permalink

"I don't get them frequently, no. I got someone in person the other day asking for his pregnant wife's case to be put off but he couldn't pull together what it would have taken to let that slide - she was able to identify a more interesting culprit, though, so I could take it down a couple notches from capital."

Permalink

"I'm surprised judges aren't swamped with people pleading on behalf of their relatives - I suppose if they don't expect it to work -"

Permalink

"I could have had my secretary turn him away. Would have, if I'd been busier - ultimately wouldn't have made a difference, even if I was influenced by her being pregnant it was clearly visible."

Permalink

"We could have some kind of allowance for pregnancy, it probably wouldn't be a strong bad incentive because I think most people wouldn't buy a child credit and get pregnant just to delay their execution for something they anticipate being arrested for."

Permalink

"Maybe if there's obviously a way to provide for the child even after the sentence is imposed. I suppose 'give them up for adoption' is a way."

Permalink

"The lists for that are very long! We sat on one for ten years before realizing we'd have to arrange things ourselves. Could default to adoption and let surviving parents make a showing that they can still provide for the child."

Permalink

"I assume it's longer for blue. Congratulations on the arrangement, by the way."

Permalink

"Thank you. We are very excited."

Permalink

"Do you have names picked out?"

Permalink

"Boy and a girl. Alatana and Notelle."

Total: 6302
Posts Per Page: