To make any decisions here, Carissa is going to need more information. She can decide to get it from this person because this person is the first person to have guessed that she's the latest Tea God drop, or she can decide to convince this person she's a fraud instead, or kill this person, and get it from a person selected by a process that is not that.
This person seems.....fine? Like she'll kill Carissa for her own benefit but also like she thinks it's pretty unlikely killing Carissa would be for her own benefit.
Probably she should attempt to be far more selective than that, but on the other hand - 7% of the population will want to enslave her and 2% will want to kill her sounds low.
And she doesn't know how long she has before the fire swallows up the planet.
Probably not that long, actually, if it started five years ago and has swallowed a third.
Why would someone be under the impression that being altruistic and kindly-hearted is the best way to become a Hero's Companion????? Who in the universe goes around going "I hope my adventuring companions are altruistic and kindly-hearted?" Maybe a previous Tea God drop just went in really hard on Lawful Good, either for real or in propaganda, and everyone decided that's how the Tea God selects people or something.
She continues to follow, blinking wide-eyed at things that her persona to date would blink wide-eyed at.