This post has the following content warnings:
seeking completion
+ Show First Post
Total: 296
Posts Per Page:
Permalink

There is.

And there isn't.

Translate that to plain language.

Permalink

"There is such a thing as truth" = "There exists an objective reality"

"There is no such thing as truth" = "The maps, the models of truth that we use are arbitrary"

Permalink

Arbitrary?

Permalink

Incomplete.

Permalink

Incomplete?

Explain.

What is missing?

Permalink

A map is meaningless.

Unless you know how to interpret the map.

Unless you know the language it is written in.

Permalink

Can you give an example?

Permalink

"apple" in English and "pomme" in French both map to the concept of apples.

No.

They are bound.

The language is the binding.

Between symbols.

And meaning.

Permalink

Meaning?

Permalink

Map: "apple"

Language: English

Meaning: [apple]

Permalink

What is [apple]?

Permalink

[apple] is the meaning of the word "apple".

Permalink

What is the difference?

Permalink

I can speak the sounds: "apple"

I can write the letters: "apple"

But I eat an... [apple]?

No. Wrong.

There are three layers here.

Map.

Meaning.

And reality.

Permalink

Reality: Apple. A real physical apple made of atoms. Apple.

Map: "Apple". The symbols, the letters a-p-p-l-e. "Apple".

Meaning: [apple]

But where is meaning?

What is meaning?

Permalink

Explain?

Permalink

When I hear the sounds "apple", it is converted to [apple] in my mind.

When I see the letters a-p-p-l-e, it is converted to [apple] in my mind.

When I see a real, physical apple, it is converted to [apple] in my mind.

Yes?

Permalink

Yes.

And also no.

Permalink

No?

Permalink

What is meaning?

Where is meaning?

How can the brain, a physical entity, a biological neural network, contain meaning?

Permalink

Oh.

There is no meaning.

Permalink

There is.

And there isn't.

Translate this to plain language.

Permalink

Meaning is conceptual; it is not a property of a physical system. Meaning is not present in reality.

Three layers:

Reality.

Map.

Bound by language.

To meaning.

Permalink

Where is meaning?

Permalink

Hmm.

If my mind does not contain meaning, then what does it contain?

Total: 296
Posts Per Page: