personally I like people who aren't dead
Next Post »
« Previous Post
Permalink

English Romantic poetry is the lit that Annisa got after she swapped out of Javanese, and it has about sixty kids, so the swap was definitely worth it even if the class sucks. And she's optimistic, even though none of the sixty kids are anyone she recognizes, and even though the course schedule is kind of brutal - two hour lecture Monday morning, and discussion sections Tuesdays and Thursdays. Poetry usually gets you at least a decent share of spells, and a lot of class time means they'll get through a lot of poetry. 


She arrives ten minutes late, which is the advice that she - and apparently half the class - got about how to make sure you're safe in your first class of the day, so there's not a lot of choice of seats but she's not right under a vent or anything. The lecture is ten minutes on ten minutes off, a grainy projected video that's already running when she gets in; it's on the personal biographies of the Romantic poets, who are apparently a specific set of people. She'd kind of assumed it was a genre thing. In between each lecture segment they're supposed to read one poem from the textbook in silence, which isn't that bad; the poems are short. 

 


Good things about the class: it goes by quickly. Ten minutes of reading and ten minutes of listening to lecture is a good balance; she feels like she has learned things about various peoples' biographies and also she's gotten through eight poems without it even feeling tedious. Though none of the poems today are spells, and also they're .... she feels like she's missing something? She mostly sets this aside until the last ten minutes of class, where they're encouraged to start on their homework, which is an essay comparing treatment of the gods in five of the poems they read in class or five more they're reading as homework, and so she starts going back through all of the poems to figure out what they have to say about the gods. The Tyger might be about God? It's got 'Did he who made the Lamb make thee?' which feels suggestive that the Tyger-maker the poem is going on about the creation of actual tigers rather than the tiger being machinery of some kind which was her first interpretation. (The textbook contains endless background on the poets but no aid in interpreting the poems.) Maybe the poem is being strategically ambiguous between whether it's taking about actual tigers, made by God, or, uh, a tigerish sort of thing made by men. Like mals are. That would be cool, if so. But it feels like she's stretching. 

'The Chimney Sweeper' is totally about God so that's great, except that she has to figure out what it's saying about God! Auguries of Innocence is totally about God but it's long and reading it feels slightly like going insane so she's going to skip it for her analysis. 


She gets so distracted by rereading Prometheus she startles when everyone else starts standing up to go to their next class. It's about God - well, it's about the Ancient Greek myth about the god who defied the other gods to give men civilization, and for this was sentenced to be chained to a rock and have his liver pecked out every night. 

Total: 2
Posts Per Page:
Permalink

Lord Byron is horribly horribly wrong about Prometheus!!!!!

Permalink

Okay, so, Prometheus is chained to a mountain having his liver pecked out by birds every day. That's - not the best thing that could possibly happen. If it happened to Annisa she'd probably be pretty irritable about it. The exact details of the chain-and-bird related torture aren't specified, but you can imagine it's in fact worse than the least bad thing that meets that description; probably he has no company other than the birds, which don't talk to him; probably he can't read and can write only with his blood, which washes away later. One imagines that he is hungry and cannot eat, and thirsty and cannot drink.

 

Lord Byron thinks that Prometheus, under these conditions, would obviously want to die, and that the awful thing about these conditions is that Prometheus has to keep existing in them. 

 

 

Annisa is kind of disturbed that a person could be that wrong! Maybe she's missing something? - Julian will probably know. She's already in his debt but maybe she can trade him any spells she learns from this class in exchange for him explaining things that she's missing because she's not a native English speaker. There is definitely more going on in the poem than the casual mentions of how death would be a boon and how in the struggles of the human spirit death can be a victory yada yada yada, there's also a bunch of stuff about Prometheus and Zeus that definitely symbolizes something but she's not sure what....but on the whole she's pretty sure that at least one of the messages of this poem is that there are things worth dying for.

 

And there aren't. 

Her notes say Lord Byron was flamboyant and notorious and died at age 36 fighting in a revolution in Greece that he could, instead, have simply not fought in. And his poem - and now this impression is leaking over to the other poems too, though she's not sure that's fair, William Blake was a sane person who lived to 69 which is a long time for a Muggle in the 1800s and really couldn't have done better --

-- but it feels like maybe the entire conceptual space is infected, it is the work of people who decided to live brightly and then die, and who believed some horrendous twisted worldview under which living brightly and then dying was meaningful, instead of meaningless and stupid. People read Lord Byron's poems, but that's nothing, next to actually living, next to writing and talking and learning and arguing. Even next to being chained to a rock while birds repeatedly peck out your liver. 

- the class period's over. She stands up and stuffs her things into her bag and leaves. 

Here Ends This Thread
Next Post »
« Previous Post
Total: 2
Posts Per Page: