The Valar think that you are supposed to verify people have done things before you kill them, but they can ask Eru if it's really important.

Eru is sort of the last person Elspeth would ask about questions of morality. If they want his timeline input it's probably fine, though, he does not have a timeline related deficit of which she is aware.

Eru declines to comment on whether Sauron has done anything worthy of death yet. 

Yeah they'll ask a Thuringwethil just to be clear on stuff in the event that he hasn't done anything horrible to the planet he's on so far.

The Valar cannot be of further assistance unless they happen to think of a way to act in Warp efficiently!

Well, Elspeth appreciates their help with keeping Melkor firmly in place.

She goes and reports to the network.

So what is he in fact up to-

Well, maybe there's something published on the subject in the last couple decades.

(Thuringwethil gets a visit and a question.)

"Oh, hey, princess."

"Hey. Sauron-related question."

"One of them loose?"

"How'd you guess."

"Little bird told me."

"Anyway, yeah, one's loose, we're sort of academically curious how evil he is at this point, when does that start?"

"...he was at least apprised of everything that went on in Utumno. It wasn't, like, his thing - orcs were Melkor's passion project - but he, like, had a go at seeing if you could get Elves to have half-Maiar children, that kind of thing..."

"...did that fail in spite of Lúthien as proof of concept or are some running around?"

"Can't get the Elves not to abort, I think? I was not involved, because the fuck."

"Congratulations. Why couldn't they abort when it was orcs?"

"That's a normal pregnancy, you just make the mother forget."

"Ah. Anyway. Thanks."

"Yeah. Have fun."

"This one's not looking like much fun but we'll try."

"Need help? On anything except deciding if you can murder with abandon?"

"You any good at murdering with abandon?"