This suddenly became a lot more personal than a pre-Jump Earth literature class. Well. It already was rather personal, but - a bathtub being compared to an ocean. Both are wet. One's a lot deeper than the other.
She is tempted to say, 'That is not what I meant, that point was very clear, you did not have to belabor it' - but no. That - would not help at all right now. That would just be petty. What does one do when someone shows one their soul? She doesn't know the answer.
First step: breathe. Collect your thoughts. Okay? All settled? Good, now to work.
...
She has no idea what the fuck to do. Not a damned clue. She can think of a few points of comparison, and even more things that are - in something of the same vein of pain she can't fix, but doesn't have the eloquence in her to say them without potentially hurting him.
'I am a woman from a society that treats them as chattel,' 'I understand that few will think of me as I am an instead in terms of who I marry and how I raise our children,' 'I am desperately trying to not drown in the ocean of propaganda surrounding my home planet and Beta Colony, I am confused and lost and barely know who I am,' 'I am so very small and everything I want to do is so much larger than I am, I don't know how I'll even begin,' 'Sometimes I feel as if I've already failed, that I'm doomed to it, that there is nothing I can do and no one cares what I have to say,' 'Sometimes I just think I'm not good enough, and never will be.'
And none of these are exactly the same sorts of problems as he has, she doesn't know what it's like to be him. She probably never will. Her problems are - smaller, less grave, in comparison to his, at least as far as she can tell. But - damn it, they're both being assailed by shitty things about life and their society, why the fuck should they look at one another and say, 'Your experiences of pain and confusion differ from mine, get out, do not try to reach out to understand and be understood.'
She doesn't have a speech written by Shakespeare in front of her to cram her feelings into. Maybe there is one, but she hasn't read it yet. She makes a note to read more Shakespeare, to maybe have a reply to situations like these. Because she still doesn't. And she can't even figure out a way to cram her own feelings into something that isn't horribly out of place and sounding like she doesn't care about his problems. She feels hopelessly out of her depth with a rock tied to her foot and the inability to swim.
But she does kind of dearly want to hug him.
"Miles," she asks, voice soft. "Would you like a hug?"
Wait, he's trying to be less depressing. Say something else, Miles.
"It's better on Beta Colony, at least here the pity and disdain mostly only comes up when I mention what planet I'm from. And there are no alleys to get beaten up in."
No not that. God what's wrong with him. He covers his face with his hands.
She's tempted to hug him without permission but she doesn't know him well enough to guess how that would go. She doesn't.
"How do I help," she asks, a little desperately. "There's - I'm - I feel like there's nothing I can say that won't make things hurt more, I - I've known you for four days and I'd personally tell any asshole that looked at you with disdain to take a jump to hell? Because fuck those guys? I think Barrayar is getting better, even if it's, taking a while to get around to it? I get the pity and disdain from Betans too? I. Would definitely hug you, if you wanted me to, but I don't know if that would help or hurt more so I haven't been." Pause. "... We can possibly take a break from Shakespeare, trash talk Betans together?"
"I don't—I—why do you care?! Why do—why does—what is the point of trying to help me when I'm just a fucking mutie anyway and no amount of trash-talking Betans is going to change that," he says, raw-voiced and miserable, hunching down in his seat.
"I - I - why the fuck shouldn't I care, huh? Why the fuck shouldn't I look at Barrayar, look at the fucking Nexus and say, 'This should be better, what is happening here should not happen, I want to help, I want people to stop hurting'?! You do not get to, to, opt yourself out, I see you as fucking valuable and if I can fucking help you, you can bet your entire fucking fortune that I will raise hell to try! Every! Single! Time!"
By the end of this tirade her voice has raised to a point where she's almost shouting. She looks like she would like to continue, but she catches herself and takes a deep breath.
"The point," she says, in a more even tone, "is that you are already so much more than a, a - you are more than what other people see you as."
He has to sit very still for a moment and focus on breathing evenly to keep himself from bursting into tears.
Maybe that was a bit - strong. That was probably a bit strong. She - can't bring herself to regret it, it's too close to home, too much of her soul bared to him to try to take it back. Maybe something to cushion the words a bit, but wanting to take any of that back - no, she can't.
"... Offer for a hug's still open, anytime you'd like it."
"I... I don't..." He trails off, exhales shakily—looks up at her with a flash of a wry, haunted smile. "Uh, in case you were wondering, it's not my usual practice to unload all my private griefs on the third conversation with a new acquaintance. You just. Caught me at a bad time, let's say."
"Darn, I was waiting in rapt anticipation for what conversation four would be like," says Yvette, dry. "... But no, seriously, you seemed to need it, and if I can help -" She shrugs, looking amused. "I think you've heard my opinion there. Happy to be of service."
"I want you to know that I deeply appreciate and admire your commitment to making the world a better place," he says, his voice soft but intense. "I—when I'm being my best self, when I live up to my own ideals, I feel very similarly."
She smiles a tiny slightly shy smile, and inspects her hands because she cannot meet that gaze right now.
"Well, thank you. I uh. Am glad that it's not just me that wants to save the galaxy."
"But sometimes... it just isn't in me to believe I can be helped, or that I should be. It's—I guess it really does come back to what I was trying to say about poor Richard. About... feeling like something in the fundamental nature of my physical and spiritual being is corrupt, broken, impure." He pauses a moment, then adds, "I judge my odds of reducing Frank to tears pretty high if I can just manage to get that out onto a vidscreen in a comprehensible essay format."
"Reducing him to tears is important, I see." Pause, a complicated expression. "And I don't think you're - corrupt, broken, or impure. I realize that probably doesn't help, but." She waves a hand awkwardly.
"It... I don't know," he sighs. "It's... better than nothing? That sounds so inadequate, and any way I can think of to try to make it sound more positive fails catastrophically at that task. Um. It's better than nothing and I swear that's actually meaningful?"
"I will take you at your word," she agrees. Pause. "So, want to be friends, only other Barrayaran at this school?"
He looks her in the face again with a broad, friendly, genuine smile that only carries a little pain around the edges.
"Yes, I will absolutely be your friend, Yvette Vorlaine."
"Hey, I had to be sure! Good, I have someone to trash talk Betans with, that's important."
"Unfortunately lacking in participants on Beta Colony itself. Pity, there are so many Betans to trash talk."
"Do we want to start trash talking Betans right now?" she wonders. "Because we can!"
"God help me, there are some Betans I would dearly love to trash-talk, but so far I have avoided literally crying on you and I'd like to keep that up," he snorts.
"You are allowed to cry on me," says Yvette. "I'm insoluble in water, promise."