She listens, fascinated.
"That sounds closer to the Valar and Maiar - I don't know the full tale, but..."
"In the quiet before Song, the first Voice spoke, and from his Voice came the dance of Music, but it was a harsh, controlled music. The world spun out as an illusion, made of order and stability, utterly sterile. Fifteen Powers were sung into being, and they Sung alongside the First to make the world envisioned before them, and they were given their charges - things like wind, and dreams, and youth - and they sang in perfect harmony. But one of the fifteen sang alone - in disharmony. He destroyed what the others made stable, and poisoned what they made beautiful."
"Eventually they finished the world and filled it with all manner of creatures - but only those that could live in harmony. Melkor, the trouble-maker, set their world on fire, again and again, destroying their work."
"A great war raged for eons between Melkor, who was mightiest, and the other Powers. Eventually, the Powers won through trickery and imprisoned Melkor. But then the Powers discovered Elves, who had awakened unknown to them on the battlefield - the Powers stole some of the elves away, and took them to a certain small continent where they made court, and left the rest of the world - including those elves who had hidden from the Powers - to develop on its own in the dark. Sometime after this the dwarves woke beneath the mountains and began to make their civilizations."
"The elves and Powers and Maiar - lesser servants of the Powers - prospered in their fenced land, but then Melkor convinced the Powers he was redeemed to their perspective. They set him free, and he convinced the elves there to fight each other, and he destroyed the last of their lights, and he stole their greatest treasures and fled to the continent the Powers had abandoned. The Powers refused to go after him this time, so the elves fought him alone. The Powers did then make the Sun and the Moon out of the lights Melkor had destroyed - the world'd been lit by glowing trees before, I think - but didn't do much otherwise."
"When the Sun rose, Men woke up. The alliances of elves and dwarves and men challenged Melkor for a few centuries, so Melkor made the dragons to be his mightiest fighters. Eventually an elven princess - who was also a Maia's daughter - fell in love with a human, and her father said they could only wed if they stole a gem from Melkor's crown. They did, and then their... I think granddaughter or great-granddaughter? Eventually brought it to the Powers, after Melkor had nearly finished destroying everyone on the continent. It was apparently one of the treasures Melkor'd stolen? And she convinced the Powers to fight against Melkor again, which they did, and they won - sinking a continent in the process - and then threw Melkor out of the world."
"We never had anyone appointed by the Powers to rule in their stead, though. Dunno they had good priorities, so I dunno it'd be good if they had - things're only interesting 'cause of Melkor, pretty much."