Plane shift can drop you up to five hundred miles from your intended destination.
This time they land in some woods, at sunset, near a remarkably flat and smooth path that looks like a lava flow or something.
"You can try it. If you get evil and you attack him I will punch you, you should not assume whatever you get is relevant to his current conduct."
So he casts the spell. Looks around the room, blinks rapidly. His hands move at his side a bit. He does not attack anyone. "Huh. Thank you."
"..." He points at Faith. "Chaotic neutral." Alex. "Chaotic neutral." Father Michael. "Lawful evil." Angel. "Chaotic evil." Karen. "Neutral good... are you, uh, confident in the company you're keeping -"
"Okay." He nods at Dennis. "I can't read him, or your dog, but that's normal, people who don't have a lot of magical power are typically hard to detect."
"Do we know what this system judges people on? I don't know if I speak this much nerd."
"Lawfulness is about your willingness to hold yourself to rules - your society's rules, or your god's rules, or the code of an organization you've committed yourself to. Goodness is about your willingness to make sacrifices to help other people, mostly, though there are some details that are important."
"Well, fine, I'll take chaotic neutral, then. - why do you ping evil? The priest, I mean, it's pretty obvious why Angel pings evil."
"Oh, okay. Aren't they all. Guess we shouldn't keep these guys waiting through it."
"A long time ago I made a magically binding commitment the execution of which ended up requiring murdering a lot of people."
" - I mean, I dunno if he'd ping evil. But we have just determined that he sends a lot of people to Hell, so."
"That is not actually evil. - sending good people to Hell is evil, but sending bad people to Hell is neutral."