Blai was not prepped appropriately for the monsters of Menador either magically or educationally, and when his mace swings for this one's face it goes straight through, and then so does the rest of him.
Well, that pattern-matches to Ustalav, but really this is confusing enough as an eventuality that it could be Arcadia and he certainly wouldn't know. He casts Guidance on himself and tries to spend it on resisting an illusion, which is either not there or stronger than his save, and then he trudges for the farmhouse on the grounds that terrible haunted shelter might be better than no shelter and he won't know till he tries.
"Almost certainly. With the aim of delaying our return, most likely, so prepare for an ambush before we're in sight of the city - no, everybody, don't pause, keep moving -"
This is a bizarre thing to shout in a terrible accent across an enormous distance and also explains nothing! Someone Teleport-capable could conceivably have landed off course on their way to Canorate, someone Plane Shift capable likewise, but there is no reason for there to be a third circle cleric in the wasteland out here, and also the light - which is, according to Dayi, Bellene's familiar, a holy symbol held aloft by a man jogging in their general direction - is a ...sword...which isn't any god she's heard of.
Well, shouting across vast distances probably doesn't pose much risk. Their location is already known to the enemy. And she already has Clarion Call up herself, since they're out of the city. "THE CONCERN IS NOT THAT YOU WOULD NOT BE WORTH RESCUING IF IT WERE SAFE BUT THAT IT IS ALMOST CERTAINLY A TRAP OR AT BEST AN EFFORT TO DELAY US" she shouts back. "IF YOU CAN CATCH UP WE'LL ACCEPT YOUR SURRENDER. IF YOU CLAIM TO SERVE AN ALLIED GOD I'LL SEND A HORSE." And probably lose the horse, but in principled if he were a third circle cleric of an allied god gone astray in a teleportation accident it'd be worth the horse many times over.
Because there is no god by that name on this planet and you are clearly not speaking Taldane through a translation spell or you'd be speaking it better, but she probably should not give the enemy advice on how to convince her of things.
"Send him a horse."
"Probably. But - no number of horses will save us. Only a miracle will." She has lowered her voice. You can't just go around telling everybody that only a miracle will save them, though she really thinks that ideally you would be able to tell them that and they would be able to consider the matter soberly and still do their work.