"They're shiny? There's three? You acquire them at some point and wear them in a crown and it's very fetching and then when everything is dark for unclear reasons they could be used to restore light to the world and you don't turn them over for the purpose. They were a recurring theme in the subsequent unpleasant warfare."
Blink. "Uh, I suppose that might help, if you have an alternative. Presumably you originally had other reasons to make them besides immortalizing humans?"
"I'm not sure how anybody's going to live anywhere short of evacuating to my world while the world is all dark if they - hm, no, one of the later visions was in what looked like daylight, but I don't know how that was accomplished -"
I could make them impossible for anyone to wield or benefit from without my leave."
"That might work. Don't know enough to say for sure. The visions didn't show anyone using them as anything other than shiny rocks."
"Might work, don't know. If I could give you a complete prescription for how to steer around all the everything I would definitely have brought it all neatly indexed," Kib sighs.
"It's in the very early stages of consideration," Fëanáro says. "Is it possible you killed all those people to get it back because it was needed to save many many more people?"
"I am really good at solving problems like that without swords, and don't seem to have been particularly effectual with them," he says. "I cannot imagine I'd try that."
"Silmarils don't explain what happened to you before that, either," Kib says to Maitimo.
"But you could hear Nerdanel's dream, couldn't you? Even without me as a waypoint."
"...it didn't seem conspicuous that its subject could not hear her if she told him about it?"
"There are a lot of features of the nature of the Eldar that cannot truly work the way we're told they work. Marriage comes to mind. I think prophecy might be the same. I am sure it does something but I don't believe it does what everyone says, and if it does and there's nothing to be done about it, then it's best completely ignored."
"Well, here I am, a thing to be done about it. - What's dodgy about how marriage is supposed to work besides it being really weird-sounding to a human?"
"Yeah, I thought my dreams were fake until they taught me a language and you only had secondhand anything, I get it."