Do you and everybody else with prophecies ever get together and pool everything you know in case you have something one of them can use?
I was not at all sure this would work until I tried it. I am not sure you'll be able to tell him either. And fate is - sticky, it endures for ten thousand years after people who aren't in the plan start appearing - I am worried that sharing it somehow precipitates it, I am worried that sharing it somehow fails to prevent it - I am not at all sure I'm approaching this rightly. But I ended up concluding that he was unlikely to do anything much worse.
Kib has many thoughts on this subject but he is not planning to share them with Melkor.
I suppose that's reasonable. Although if I do turn out to be a reliable prophecy transmission mechanism in general that seems like too good an exploit to turn down.
If they're going to happen unless somebody in particular knows about it, and nobody but me can tell them? shrugs Kib. I mean, yes, I can see why you'd want to know I was an acceptable waypoint for information of that nature, but it sounds like the worst case scenario is that cities will be shredded and soil will be poisoned, which is already slated to happen, so...
I'm not calling for needless carelessness, I'm saying this looks like an occasion for some modest risk-taking.
Might depend on the phrasing. Would it work if I gave you a sentence in the common?
Oh, good point. ...But it would in the general case? That's interesting. Uh, I know enough Quenya to assemble "I swear I said the truth today", if you need a more limited time frame or something I will need to look stuff up.
Thennnn my Quenya is not actually good enough, that's not airtight and if I'm going to go try to tell Maitimo that he cuts his way through swaths of people for unclear reasons I'd like to have it airtight.