"For escaped prisoners of Angband. They're - a bit of a wreck, you know, and also everyone else is frightened of them, and we have healing but it doesn't do anything about that, and the idea was to make the memories less vivid and stop the panic attacks and help them work around missing memories and so forth, but then the King adopted the policy about none of them in Doriath and so I dropped work on it."
"Well, I only know where to find one of those but I imagine there are likely more."
"I wonder what would happen if I stuck that song in Angband."
"Well, I probably shouldn't actually do it for the same reason I shouldn't make the whole place silent, but yes, until the Enemy did something about it I certainly could. I'd probably want to put it in a silence baffle, get quite far away, and dismiss the baffle from a distance."
"I tested with Melian; if she doesn't want an illusion of mine in place in Doriath, she can shut it down and it takes concentration to oppose her. The benefit I'd want from the silence would need the illusion effortlessly sustained to achieve, and it would also draw attention I probably can't handle."
"I'm generally uncomfortable with mind-affecting magic and I do have to listen to each song myself at least once to copy it; the one for escaped prisoners is an exception since not applying mind affecting magic to them seems to do them so few favors. There might be demand for the others - I don't know how many composers you have who can make magic songs or how long they take."
The song for children was learned before we found Elu and Melian, when we'd be trying to stay quiet to flee from orcs and your other choice was to strangle them. It doesn't have an effect on people over five."
"Ooh, I probably can't take advantage of that since I don't actually have osanwë but that's cool."
"It seems sheer luck that illusory songs work, it could have gone the other way."
"Mother says she'll talk with you now," Lúthien says. "Sorry, that is not the answer I was expecting and I thought you two'd have time to copy useful songs or suggest ideas for them first...she sounds very worried about you, by the way, I ended up promising her you were all right even though I'm not sure if that's even true."
"I'm fine, just shaken up," Loki says, and she grabs a last handful of nuts and eats them as she heads to the throne room.
"Thank you," says Loki, inclining her head politely, although wow does she ever have mixed feelings about random demigods addressing her as "daughter".