Love songs communicate love, they don't induce it. But they communicate it very intensely and viscerally, and if someone is not sufficiently familiar - the difference between the Maiar and us is as large as the difference between us and Men, and we're overwhelmed - overwritten, even - should they desire to overwhelm us. I do think Melian wronged Elu, though not intentionally.
Well that's horrifying and I'm glad I was introduced to osanwë by benign persons.
...Depends a whole lot on what strategy they took with me. Wouldn't've had my nonremovable suicide method figured out.
I mean, if I were introduced to a Balrog at some point I'd have figured it out, but if Morgoth decided to go straight for the heavy mindfuckery no guarantee that would happen soon enough.
As a rule I think they do conventional torture first. I always thought it was considerate of them; if you get sent back and all you can say is 'he gave me hallucinations' no one will understand, but they can look at scars and missing limbs and missing - and then you don't have to explain the really bad parts, you can let the things that weren't really so bad cover for them -
- I actually don't know how unpleasant I'd find being conventionally tortured, what with the ability to heal myself multiple times a second if that's what I need to be doing. Uh, should I apologize about your scars...?
Okay. I originally considered making an option in the spell to leave scars in case I ever acquired some battle injury that would definitely scar and I was witnessed doing it, but I didn't, it just seemed like a stupid feature for a healing spell.
...I'd say 'that's good' but 'able' is not the standard I actually apply when assigning goodness to family hugs.
On the subverbal level, or are you planning to tell them you think they're real, too?
How do you case-by-case that? They'll talk to each other.