Vanyel has explained your grievances with the local gods and some, to me, seem legitimate.
What.
...Maybe it shouldn't be as surprising as it is. If anything, it would be less surprising in the bizarre scenario where this is a ruse of Vanyel's design. Vanyel himself has some sympathy for Leareth's grievances, if not for his chosen response to them.
And if it's really someone from another world... Well, it depends what 'Iomedae' is like as a person, doesn't it. But - it might be easier for a true outsider, someone seeing the world with fresh eyes, to look at the actions of the Velgarth gods and see their cost in human suffering.
In the interests of honesty I must disclose that I am a selected follower of the god Aroden in my own world
Which is the first claim that very definitely doesn't read like a story designed to elicit Leareth's sympathy and curiosity, and convince him that 'Iomedae' is someone who he should highly prioritize trying to work with. Does that make it more likely that the story is, instead, just the truth? ...He's not sure. There are still too many moving pieces.
part of an institution by which the gods select specific people who are then highly trusted and highly reliable, and given positions of authority accordingly. This system is like the heralds in some respects, but were Aroden to renounce me I would be only an ordinary amount of grieved by this, I can renounce Him if I cease to believe that serving Him is the best path for me to achieve the goals I believe I share with Him
Fascinating. And...back to feeling like a claim shaped to be convincing to Leareth personally, maybe? - Sort of, at least. The particular extent to which it's both oddly detailed and very underspecified doesn't feel like something Vanyel would have come up with.
and I can fight the gods if it seems like a good idea (which it does, for some gods and some fights).
What.
- why is that as shocking as it is? It doesn't not fit, with either scenario, and yet. It still leaves him off-balance, metaphorically dizzy with it.