The meeting itself begins with a discussion on the topic "Are there more lost threats waiting to reappear?" Zohls, a celestial deity of investigation and truth, some axiomites, and Asmodeus collectively present the case that the chance of something in the Rhoswen incident's reference class occurring without advanced notice in the absence of interference well before the point of incursion is below 1%. They then note that the Celestial who'd received reports which would have allowed for advance notice of the issue was killed by daemons (servants of the Horsemen) in between learning of the issue and reporting it.
This and other evidence of daemonic interference prompts a topic change to "What Charon is up to". Charon and his colleagues claim that the attack on Heaven that disrupted the report that could have prevented the Rhoswen incident was unrelated, and that Szuriel had only sent an Obcisidaemon to lurk in the Verduran Forest (the site of the Rhoswen incident) due to some vague prophecies of war and attempted genocide.
The Horsemen then question Griffie and eir coworkers (the "Resolute Reclaimers") on the incident. (Details on the negotiation over questioning details can be found in Appendix 3 part A of the report.) Ultimately, while the Horsemen are permitted to interview the Reclaimers face-to-face, the Reclaimers are permitted to have four deities of their choice accompany them, and select Aiyuna, Immonhiel, Torag, and Magrim.
Szuriel asks aggressive questions to confirm that a war and a potential genocide occurred in the Verduran Forest, which is approximately confirmed by Reclaimer testimony. Griffith takes the tactic of refusing to speculate on any event ey did not directly observe and otherwise attempting to answer questions with precise honesty. During the testimony, it becomes clear that an Obcisidaemon is formed by fusing the deaths of victims and perpetrators of genocide. The Reclaimers call it suspicious that the Obcisidaemon only targeted an information-containing noncombatant, Kenchlo, which Charon said occurred because it recognized Kenchlo as having received illegal aging reduction, with the Obcisidaemon merely enforcing the lawful penalty for such. Charon also explains the forced aging of a number of other individuals as having been an implementation of the lawful penalty for forcible as opposed to consensual aging reduction, while attempting to make jabs at Griffith over the Erlonnians' currently-unimplemented death sentences.
Charon then prompts the Reclaimers to summarize their understanding of the Rhoswen incident, while accusing them of lying. The Reclaimers make various claims about the historic nature of the death-related Aiquzall faction, and point out that being attacked by a team of daemons oriented towards destruction of their information on death in old Aiquzall is extremely suspicious. Szuriel repeatedly attempts to provoke the Reclaimers into unconstructive rage, portraying them as willing to lie in court to weaken the Horsemen, et cetera, with statements illustrating her nature as a goddess of war crimes.
Subsequent witnesses receive less hostile interviews and outline a broad summary of the incident: The warnings never transmitted to Heaven were on an obelisk with mysteriously flickering wards. A mad druid unknowingly modified himself to be able to penetrate the seal on Rhoswen's realm when prompted by a dishonest book received at an estate sale, and subsequently penetrated the seal and was manipulated into partially releasing her, cutting off the Verduran Forest and surrounding areas from contact with other planes. The Reclaimers retrieved the wardstones, brought them into Rhoswen's realm, and resealed her, returning with books, the mad druid, Kenchlo, paintings, Rhoswen's captives who had been polymorphed into birds, and less relevant goods. While contact with other planes still was not reestablished, a massive team of daemons ambushed the group, and the Reclaimers coordinated the partially-successful effort to fight them off, summoning a Jubjub Bird in the process. (This is noted in the report with some dismay, as the Jubjub Bird testified at the meeting, subjecting all attendees to its supernaturally loud screech.) Eventually, contact with other planes was restored.
Given testimony at the meeting, the Erlonn Leshies (Griffith's family) are given a 50 year reprieve from lifespan enforcement, and the bird-shaped polymorph victims are exempt from further retroactive aging.
The non-Reclaimer witnesses, Rhoswen-related risks, and issues with pre-historic data are discussed before the meeting ends.