Any fine subtleties of the Chelish authors are going to be completely wasted on Keltham due to his absolute incredulity at this whole library section.
On the first random page Keltham opened to, the author was saying what some 'Duke' (high-level Government official) was thinking while ordering the east gates to be sealed, which, like, what, how would the historian know what somebody was thinking, at best you get somebody else's autobiographical account of what they claim they were thinking, and then the writer is supposed to say that what was observed was the claim, and mark separately any inferences from the observation, because one distinguishes observations from inferences.
This. This is supposed to be an expository educational history book. This is supposedly in the nonfiction section. What did the author think they were doing. This isn't reasoning, this is ink somebody spilled on a page and it happened to come out looking like words and everybody was so amazed at the coincidence they decided to reprint it.
There are no probability distributions on this page. There are no numbers on this page. There are no distinct premises and conclusions anywhere on this page. This page contains more fallacies than it contains distinct words.
Keltham puts back the book. Maybe it was just written by a three-year-old. Yeah, Keltham already knows that it wasn't written by a three-year-old, it was written by somebody from a lower-intelligence world; but maybe the next book will have been written by a member of the cognitive elite wearing an intelligence headband.
The next random page in the next random book is written like a school parody of how you would critique somebody else's faction, if it had never occurred to the writer that anybody in the audience might think that the other faction would have a different story. Like. The author doesn't even try to explain what the other faction thought they were thinking. The other faction is just supposed to be running around being Wrong because they are the Wrong Faction.
Okay, so, Keltham is just going to adopt the rule of not believing anything that a Golarion author seems to explicitly be saying or even calling attention to, and is going to flip through random pages only trying to infer the world that gave birth to these parodies of argument and exposition. Just looking for things that the author seemed to assume away as politically nonvalent obvious uncontroversial truths, the equivalent of mentioning that the sky is blue when that's not a focus of political attention.
To the extent Keltham supposes that this class of inference is reliable, it does seem to be confirmed that a place called Cheliax exists.
Some other points that Keltham is able to pick up on:
- People had higher tech seven thousand years ago. What? What happened? Some kind of infohazard thing that required all the tech to be buried? But if that was true, why are they digging it up again? When dath ilan ran into the Past Infohazard they went to a lot of trouble to mothball all the old cities, nobody sane would just wander in and start looking at them without knowing why they'd been hidden.
- You get to be a really powerful wizard by killing monsters rather than by deliberate practice. Why.
- Governance as Keltham knows it does not exist. Prediction markets do not exist. Delegates, Electors, Legislators, and Tribunes do not exist. Nobody seems to be talking about anything that looks like an obvious preference-aggregation mechanism. Choices get attributed to people and it is at no point obvious why anyone would listen to those people.
- People fight giant destructive battles, and it does not occur to any author to remark or explain on how multi-agent-optimal this is not. It doesn't seem to be a remarkable fact when it gets mentioned in passing.
- It looks sort of like... factions have sharp territorial boundaries, and there's a thing where you kill the person at the top of the faction and the people inside the faction all switch sides to the other faction that killed them; which, what why would anybody do that. Why, of all the things to successfully coordinate on, would people coordinate on that? Keltham is really missing something here about individual incentives.
- This entire planet is so on mind-altering drugs Keltham doesn't even just what what what
By the time Keltham reaches anything about Zon-Kuthon, he catches a glimpse of an infohazardous page, winces, and just shuts the book. He may eventually have to work out what is true and what is Drugs; but whatever that was, it is probably not the most important thing for him to deal with right now. In fact, maybe he should move on from the political history shelf entirely.
So is there a section of this library about "Magic: How Does It Even No Seriously What The Fuck Golarion"?