I like him too. He seems - competent to think about things, if the orcs are gearing up for war I'd expect him to notice....maybe it's just that their farmers are all shaped very conciliatory and their nobles are much closer to normal, that'd be a perfectly reasonable way to define people if -
She has some kind of ideological objection she's having a hard time articulating, it feels that it would've been an injustice to her to make her like the Elves they met in the city and at the debate and on the road just because they didn't need that many people who were capable of suspicion, but really it's hard to say what the injustice would've been, assuming the leadership was competent, and you objectively don't need ideological creativity from your magic item makers and might reasonably prefer to design them with no curiosity at all for anything but magic -
- sounds like the orcs don't get an afterlife, because they're not allowed in Valinor...