This post has the following content warnings:
Accept our Terms of Service
Our Terms of Service have recently changed! Please read and agree to the Terms of Service and the Privacy Policy
Traumatized sci-fi soldier in Hearthkeeper's Refuge
+ Show First Post
Total: 147
Posts Per Page:
Permalink

"Given the nature of who ends up here, there are plenty of people who will understand that, I think. Not everyone, but. Quite a few."

"That's the other important thing you should understand about the refuge's culture. All the cats were born here—they're the only species with a self-sustaining population—as were a few of the humans, but everyone else got here because they had something to get away from. That includes a wide variety of different things, and they affect everyone differently, but we've all been shaped by whatever made us come here, one way or another. This place is a second chance for us, and usually, with time, people heal."

"As will you, I think. There's no war here, and survival is easy. You'll have to figure out what you want your life to look like without those things. But whatever you choose, I think it will be a great improvement."

Alaïs nods firmly.

Permalink

 

"It's fairly obvious to me that I have to choose engineering?" He doesn't sound thrilled. Nor resigned, really.

Permalink

"I have some nine thousand books in my head, many of them about war and many of the rest about engineering and technology. Or the intersection thereof with war. I couldn't make it at scholarship level but those slots are - ridiculously competitive, I'm not stupid. And there isn't much industry here that I can see."

Permalink

"Well, if you haven't been to the workshops, you wouldn't have seen it, but we do have some. And I'm not one of the engineering people, but I'm pretty sure they aren't being held back much by a lack of books."

Permalink

"You didn't actually answer his question."

Permalink

"I'll need to see the workshops soon. And, I did answer. I have an advantage at it that would be wasted if I were selfish enough to do something else. I'd be productive in one, I'm sure. I'd contribute to the society as an engineer."

Permalink

"You said some facts related to the question. That's not the same as answering the question."

Permalink

"He didn't exactly answer the question I asked, no. But based on the way he said what he said, I was able to infer some things about his answer. Sometimes people don't say things directly, because they consider them obvious. Or because they find them embarassing, but I don't think Fiadh is embarrassed about this."

Permalink

"Okay."

"Fiadh, why do you want to contribute to society?"

Permalink

Artemis tends to be rather tactless, but if Fiadh doesn't seem uncomfortable, he'll let her lead the conversation for a while and see where it goes. Sometimes the naïveté of youth can help cut to the heart of a matter.

Permalink

(Kaspar and Alaïs are still eating, their mouths busy, but they seem interested.)

Permalink

"If people do not contribute to society there is no society and we all die in the cold, jealously guarding our flints and twigs. I suppose we accomplished this goal of coordination with shame and fear and shouting at those who are labelled 'lazy' or 'useless'."

Permalink

"But Levron just told you a few minutes ago that survival is easy. If people don't contribute to society, no one dies. I guess anyone who doesn't contribute to society gets a boring funeral urn, but that's not that bad. But probably no one will make them afraid or ashamed or shout at them. And if anyone does you can ask the Hearthkeeper to make them leave you alone."

Permalink

"Then nothing will ever get done or better... The internalized expectations maybe difficult to remove, even if they- And I'm not yet convinced of it- Even if they are unwarranted here."

Permalink

"If you care about getting something done, it makes sense to want to do it. I'm not sure what that has to do with contributing to society."

Permalink

Something is bothering him; He's missing something. He's not sure what, though.

"Because specializations are more efficient than everyone learning everything?"

Permalink

"No."

This is confusing. Levron, help?

Permalink

"If someone does something because they really care about that specific thing getting done, it may or may not contribute to society for them to do so. And if it does, it wouldn't make sense to say they're doing it because it contributes to society. That would be kind of like saying I went for a walk in the flower garden this afternoon because I wanted to get my shoes dirty. I went for a walk because I wanted to go for a walk, to get some fresh air and smell the flowers and relax. My shoes getting dirty was an inevitable part of me doing what I wanted, but it wasn't the thing I wanted."

"But I think you're talking about things getting done or things getting better in general."

Permalink

 

 

"...Well, I suppose literally not needing to do anything to survive except not annoy someone sufficiently for them to try to kill you means that... Wait, not even that, the Lady of the house."

He sighs.

Permalink

"Do you want to contribute to society because you want to get things done and make things better in general?"

Permalink

"Yes! Maybe! I want - things to do, things that are productive, I don't want to fall into patterns of laziness. I did my best! I always did my best. Or usually, at the very least. But some are more capable than others. I want to contribute to society because everything I ever learned says that those who do not excel in their contributions are wretched and contemptible and I don't want to be wretched and contempted."

Total: 147
Posts Per Page: