Accept our Terms of Service
Our Terms of Service have recently changed! Please read and agree to the Terms of Service and the Privacy Policy
you should meet original flavour Lucia
+ Show First Post
Total: 114
Posts Per Page:
Permalink

What ought a paladin do? 

Permalink

...You know, sometimes there are people who are literally impossible to stop, so nobody tries. They're too powerful and they have too many allies and they've built up too many defences, so they just get to kill and torture and steal with impunity because everyone is too afraid to fight back. And there are some people who will try to fight back anyway, because we can't not, because we can't live with ourselves if we don't.

Sometimes there are people who aren't worth saving, because they're afflicted with some horrible disease that would be far too expensive to find the cure to, or they're being oppressed in some far-distant land and the mountains are impassable, or they are jailed and tortured in the dungeons of some incredibly dangerous enemy who nobody has ever escaped from, or they're just too far gone into their own evil to be redeemed. And there are some people who will try to save them anyway, because against all possible evidence and with absolutely no reason, they believe that everyone can be saved - because they can't abide a world where everyone isn't. 

Sometimes there are situations with absolutely no hope, where you have to choose between succumbing to some horror and doing something awful in order to defeat it, and there are so many different enemies on all sides and so many threats and everything is so expensive and difficult that it is impossible to imagine victory without doing something horribly morally wrong. And there are some people who will die trying, die looking for that way out where nobody at all has to die, because throughout history there have been thousands and thousands of evil people who did evil things while proclaiming that they only did it because they really had to - and they didn't have to, they just needed an excuse. And someone ought to test the question of whether they could have avoided doing evil if they'd just put a little effort in, and sometimes nobody will test that question unless there's people who make a habit of testing it every time regardless of how heroic they have to be.

Sometimes there are paths of light that are too straight and narrow for any human being to possibly walk, and some people try anyway because we would rather take one single step towards perfection than a thousand in any other direction. Because - the world should know what it looks like, when someone is trying to be really truly good. Even if we only succeed in one single tiny fragment of purity, so that there is some room somewhere in some castle where for a day or a week it was a space entirely free of evil.... a place should exist somewhere outside of Heaven that is entirely free of evil, so that people know what that looks like, so they have some example to strive for and some proof that it is worth it.

The people who die trying to do these impossible things are called paladins.

And if paladins proclaim their - our - existence throughout the world loudly enough, then not one single person will ever die without hope, not one single person ever has to go to their doom knowing they have not a single friend in the world, not one single land will ever believe that their ruler cannot possibly be overthrown. Because there is always a chance. A paladin will try. Perhaps the paladin will die. Perhaps there will be a blaze of holy inspiring light and they will do the thing that others refuse to do.

Sometimes paladins die. And other times we are right.

And people like to call us foolish when we die, and call us heroic when we don't die, but I think what they should say is that - whether it is true or false that it is possible to do what we are attempting to do and live, they are glad somebody is asking the question.

Permalink

That is very beautiful and I picked you because you think truly beautiful and good things and I am glad you are trying, but you are still wrong. 

Paladins ought to defeat every evil, save everyone, solve every problem, and walk the straight and narrow path without tiring.

Questions should not exist that you do not know the answer to. You can give your life to answer a question, if it would be a greater sin to leave it unanswered, but it is also a sin to not know the answer in the first place.

Permalink

I should just.... already know the truth that I can't beat that lich and try not to lie to myself about it? 

Permalink

I didn't say that. 

Permalink

Because if I'm very very good and very very lucky I can beat a lich? 

Permalink

If you were perfect you could. 

Permalink

I don't know what to do about the situation where I don't know, because I'm not perfect, but saying I'm not perfect is just making excuses for the sin of not defeating the lich yet, but I don't know how to become perfect and.... I don't know how to respond to that. 

Permalink

I really don't know how to respond to that. 

Permalink

But paladins ought to do good. 

Permalink

You're learning. 

Permalink

So instead of sitting on a mountaintop and whining I'm going to go and do good, right now.

Permalink

Lucia ascends the mountaintop effortlessly, in shining chainmail, a bright silver blade at her side. When she reaches the summit she tosses her helmet at the foot of the altar angrily. "You are not fucking fair." 

Permalink

"I read all the holy stuff the other villagers wrote down from you and it's - gorgeous. The poetry. You gave them actual guidance. You loved them! You sent so many people to help them-"

Lucy knows she doesn't have to talk out loud but she's angry and shouting helps. 

Permalink

Are you sad that I don't give you verses about how beautiful goodness is? You know how beautiful goodness is. 

Permalink

"After every single death I have witnessed I have wanted someone to hold my damned hand! I - yes I wanted that. I wanted to know the hymns!" 

Permalink

I have limited resources, you know. Limited ability to be in the world, when I'm elsewhere. 

I am chasing down demons on the fifth moon of a planet you've never even heard of. I am trying to ease the suffering of a woman dying of the plague in Calimport. I am negotiating with Mystra to try and convince her not to allow the creation of a powerful magic object that would trap people in time-dilated torture chambers. I am practically rewriting the stars to try and change the fate of another of my paladins. I am providing a voice of conscience to a young wizard in Cormanthor. 

I can talk to you far more easily here than anywhere else. And even here I'm sending you just enough of my intelligence to barely hold down a conversation. I'm borrowing your own moral compass for a fair bit of the work here. 

Permalink

I did tell you that you weren't special. Sorry. I do love you. 

Permalink

"You're.... reflecting my own moral compass back at me?" 

Permalink

There is a holy spark in you which pushes you towards the good. You naturally feel it. You burn with the need to heal the sick, tear down the strength of evil, protect the innocent, love your fellow people, cultivate the beautiful and seek out the good in everything.

The only thing you have ever needed from me is a little push. And raw magic. I have given you raw magic and you have done very, very well with it. 

Though not perfectly. 

Permalink

"If you were perfect you would manage all those other things you're doing and come down here and have a goddamn conversation with me!" 

Permalink

Yes. I would. 

Permalink

"If you were remotely perfect you would tell me how to overthrow the king!" 

Total: 114
Posts Per Page: