At the End of All Things Elves in Revelation
+ Show First Post
Total: 4302
Posts Per Page:
Permalink

"I wasn't there at the time either, mind. Beren'll have a better picture than me of how Dior ended up ruling Doriath -"

       "The Dwarves killed Elu," Beren says, "over the Silmaril, and then they sacked the city and took it and were marching northeast with it - I think Melkor intended them to bring it back to him - and we ambushed them and took it back -"

        "Christ." one of Morwen's kids says.

        "You should have seen Menegroth after they'd sacked it, children chopped up into pieces -"

        "So the magic rock and they deserved each other, sounds like."

        "We didn't want it in Melkor's hands, Lúthien could keep our people safe with it, do what her mother had done -"

        "Did that work?"

        "Yes. For the rest of her life, but then we died - it burned her out, she hadn't been expecting that, she was mortal now and using herself like that burned right through her, and it was up to Dior, and -"

"And the Fëanorians sacked the city, killed nearly everyone who was left," Elladan says. "Your granddaughter was smuggled out with the Silmaril, she was three -"

Permalink

(Cam is following along in his ciphered notes.)

Permalink

"She grew up in Sirion. The survivors of the fall of Gondolin and Nargothrond gathered there too. They voyaged west, as often as they could, planning to get a petition to the Valar somehow and get help. The ships rarely made it back. She got married. She had children. Her husband was out trying to reach Valinor. The Fëanorians learned where the Silmaril was, attacked again, killed almost everybody, again - adopted my father and his twin brother, raised them in their last remaining fortress -"

        "Why?" Morwen's other daughter asks.

"I really don't know. Possibly they thought adopting children would improve morale - possibly wanted hostages - they were insane, by then, you know -"

       "Yes, that much I'd gathered."

"My father loved them."

       "Kids do that," Beren says. 

"Yes. So when Sirion was sacked Elwing threw herself into the sea with the Silmaril around her neck, meaning to keep it from them, and Ulmo pitied her and turned her into a seagull, and the winds swept her into Eärendil's ship, where she returned to human form. And with the Silmaril to guide them they did find Valinor, and Elwing walked among the Teleri and inspired them to help, and Eärendil brought his petition to the Valar and was heeded, and then they came to help."

       "So if we hadn't had a Silmaril -"

"I don't know. I really don't."

Permalink

Cam really does not think his input here would be valued. If anybody wants to ask what Elvis had to say about it they can ask.

Permalink

They don't ask. "So the Valar won, and then -"

     "And then the Fëanorians attacked the victorious host for their Silmarils back, slaughtered their way through the camp in the dead of night, prepared to die fighting their way out, only Eönwë, the leader of the host of the Valar, Manwë's herald, a Maia - he was so tired of the whole bloody thing, he told them to just take them. And they did, and ran off with them, and that's the last anyone saw of them though the reasonably-accurate rumor, as I understand it, is that Maedhros took a Silmaril and threw himself into a fiery chasm and that Maglor threw his into the sea and then wandered it singing for the rest of time."

      "Except now they're back," Andreth says.

"They are. I checked in on them, we've been emailing."

     "If demons can make Silmarils -"

"Then I was going to kill them all," Elladan says. "Demons can't."

Permalink

"Which is good, because I would have been in a pickle."

Permalink

"Oh?" Beren asks.

Permalink

"They summoned a random demon, to check. It was me. I agreed to see if I could make Silmarils, and locate the extant ones, for a couple phone calls. If I could make them they were either going to convince me to not do that any more or keep me. There was mindreading involved, about which I was not best pleased when I found out. Fortunately I could not make Silmarils. Later I investigated the languages and once on my current summon I hassled them for an explanation."

Permalink

"Reputation back in the day was intense, oddly sincere, charming when it suited them, and utterly ruthless."

Permalink

"Sounds about right. I get along with them."

Permalink

"It's been thirty thousand years," Morwen says again, quite firmly. "I'm sympathetic to the back-and-forth over Hitler and Stalin and Mao being free and clear but I've yet to see any calls to bring Leopold II to justice and I think that speaks well of humans -"

       "It says we sleep through our history classes," one of her daughters mutter.

"Better that than mistake them for the present."

      "Dior and the babies aren't coming back," Beren says. "It's thirty thousand years they could have been alive."

      Andreth hugs him. "I can't imagine finding out like this how your children died. I'm so sorry."

 

Permalink

This is probably not the time to break out the "speaking as a murder victim" line.

Permalink

"My father wrote about the War of Wrath, if any of you would like to read it. It's mostly not personal details but it has some." 

        "I'd like that," Beren says. "He's in Valinor?"

"He is."

       "Is he happy?"

"I think he has a lot of regrets and lives with them comfortably enough."

       "Do the rings that make you like a Vala still work?" asks Morwen's daughter.

Elladan looks at his hand consideringly. "They do very little. I suppose I could ask permission to wave a Silmaril at this one."

Permalink

"They work fast," agrees Cam.

Permalink

Several people present shudder. "It's never worth it," Beren says.

      "They might feel they have some claim on the ring," Andreth says.

Permalink

"They haven't brought it up, if they do."

Permalink

He gets a couple exasperated glances that are probably best parsed as 'yep, charming when it suits them, that sure is the people who stabbed the kids'.

 

"If I had it I could make it impossible for outsiders to find Imladris," Elladan says. "And if they had it they could do the same for their castle, which means everyone can sleep free of nightmares about Silmaril thieves - any day now someone's going to publish an English translation of the whole history and some idiot teenager is going to have a run at it -"

       "I resemble that remark," Beren says.

Permalink

"If you have a way to let them safely bounce off Valinor and fly away to the Dwarf afterlife, please, share away, it's just there's all those Valar in the way."

Permalink

"By reputation those are dense, reactive, and well-intentioned only to the extent that good results need hardly ever flow from those good intentions."

Permalink

"Yes, that is my impression also. I'm paying a rotation of security fairies to make sure no random idiots go splashing their way into the twisty to go hassle them lest they mistake random idiots for Humans In General."

Permalink

Sigh. "Thank you for looking into that."

Permalink

"You're welcome."

Permalink

He gets books for people who are interested in books.

Permalink

Cam can make copies if people want copies.

Permalink

They'd be delighted.

Total: 4302
Posts Per Page: