"If it'll look consistent to the people it needs to look that way to, all right."
Loki dismisses the silence in time for the other orcs to hear the fiction. I'd like him too if he didn't stress me out. "If your fellow orcs sworn to the highest Melkor will trust you, then so will I," she says.
Loki looks at the other orcs of the new batch and raises an eyebrow at them.
"Thank you," Loki softly illusions in the ear of the skeptic orc, and then she distributes names to those who want names. Does skeptic orc want a name? Already have one?
"I really wouldn't mind if you wanted to keep your old name," says a quiet illusion again, and she suggests, "Tyr?"
And she turns to Macalaurë. "In other news, Maitimo is alive, healed, and under the impression that these facts are further hallucinations engineered by the Enemy."
"The smoke over Angband was gone, so I scouted it again. Some of the prisoners are kept outdoors, chained to a cliff; only two were alive. I didn't know who they were, but I could get them out, so I did; one - Maitimo identified him to me as Rodyn later but doesn't know where he's from - ran off, whereas Maitimo I hauled a fair ways in this direction before he was willing to have enough of a conversation to express that he'd rather not hallucinate a family reunion. I've taught him to fly; he thinks it would be computationally expensive to simulate a whole continent so he's looking around from the air until the next scheduled rendezvous. I don't think it'll do the trick itself."
"After I left here last time. I did not know who I had, he wouldn't tell me; there are certainly more prisoners inside and many more outside were dead than alive - so I went to the Nolofinwëans to identify the people rather than interrupt the festival for what was more likely to have been a false alarm. He's - he liked flying. I think I had him happy for thirty seconds, learning to fly, before he remembered that I'm supposed to be some Maia servant of the Enemy who's trying to trick him so as to extract information."
"I don't know where he is right now, because I taught him to fly. He doesn't want me to tell you where he is going to be, either, but I'll meet him in a few days and can relay counterarguments. How are you planning to convince him?"
"You can't fake technological advancement. There are things it would take me five hundred years to figure out, and if Maitimo learns them he can be confident that five hundred years have passed. He's not technically inclined but I'd expect him to be able to understand them once they're explained to him. It may take a thousand years but, as I said, probably not an age, for him to conclude that the enemy isn't that patient."
"Oh! I could speed that up, you hadn't invented movable type yet - it'll all have to be things building on principles he remembers from before his capture, though, nothing with electricity or obscure physics or based partly on magic he thinks I made up... but I could explain, I don't know, steam engines, I don't think you have those? But this only convinces him that he's not being time-dilated quite as drastically as he could be, not necessarily that there isn't some extremely long game in play."
"By the time we've shown him technology that is obviously sufficient to best Moringotto with," Fëanor says, "it would be surprising to conclude that the war is still proceeding in a manner that would make whatever Moringotto'd originally intended hundreds of years ago when he started this trial valuable."
"I suppose. But this does sound like it might take a long time even if I come up with fifty things on the order of 'steam engine' that I can explain from memory so there's the question of the meanwhile; he's willing to live with people he doesn't know, would find the converted orcs uncomfortable neighbors, I'm going to sound out the Dwarves but think most local Quendi would turn away a rescued prisoner."