If there were a magical girl who got it and she was sitting with a girl who was making up her mind?

The fluffs don't actually outright lie that I've caught them at, but that's probably not why, since except me they should usually know ahead of time if anybody nearby has lie detection.

Huh. Do you have ideas of why?

Not really. Some weird alien taboo, maybe, they definitely understand that not all communication will help them get what they want but they just don't lie, except by implication or omission.

And what happens if you directly ask them where they're from and why they want to help magical girls fight witches and stuff?

They're from another planet, they think puella magi are very important and did you know that without them keeping witches in check they'd eventually overwhelm the whole human population - they're not good at pretending to have emotions exactly but they're good at saying things that would imply them if you didn't know better -

Frustrating. And I suppose you can't wish for more information about them?

Haven't tried it. I guess we could go visit Raine again next loop.

Yup.

Wish it was timed so I could find her before Kyubey does. Maybe eventually we can find a potential like that.

Kyubey wins them over? 

I wish I'd thought to check what Raine was thinking when she attacked us.

Would've been handy. And yeah. It's so cute and fluffy and it grants wishes, it barely needs to do anything else...

I'm kind of impressed Raine waits so many days to think it over.

Yeah. I'm not sure how much of it's ethical qualms and how much of it is thinking she might wish for something different entirely.

You say that like you have something specific in mind?

I've never managed to perturb things gently enough that she does wish for something else of her own devising, but she was considering the usual - million bucks, checked to see if she had the potentiation to do world hunger, that sort of thing.

World hunger?

Some people don't have enough food. Pinches humans a bit sooner than it would you.

How much potential do you need to fix that one?

Not sure it's doable at all by wish, at least the way the fluffs ration. Too nonlocal and long-term.

The one I talked to was thinking that making me Queen of England might be too hard because it might involve mind-controlling billions of people.

Yeah, a lot of people know who the Queen of England currently in fact is. Probably easier to put you in charge of Liechtenstein and even then it'd be a big wish.

I'm already a princess, even if no mind control were involved it's not what I'd be tempted to wish for. 

Yeah. Although now I sort of wonder if a puella magi has ever taken control of Liechtenstein.

I wonder if one could wish for a list of all wishes that've been granted.