He did give what looked like a practical reason rather than an arbitrary social one.

Yeah, I know. But still. You want it, so you should have it. 

I love you.

I love you too. 

We could just get married before we go home, I dont' care how much anyone'd sputter at me...

Is this a terrible idea? Possibly. But--she has so much time, now, and she's sure she can figure something out to get her the rest of the way in the time she has, and he's so amazing and--

Yes.

Idaia I have decided you are the person I want to spend the ages of Arda with, will you?

Yes, absolutely.

This seems to call for more kissing.

How observant of him.

I love you.

I love you too.

It's - it's not 'oh, I can't resist' though I want you very badly, it's that I want to be married to you, I want everyone to see it in my eyes, I want to wake up next to you for tall the ages of the world.

I want that too--I want to scream from every mountaintop in the world what an amazing person you are--I want to put all my dreams somewhere you and only you can see them--

I probably want kids someday but am okay with it being a faraway day.

I definitely want kids someday and I'm really not picky on the timing.

They're going to be royalty. I'm really sorry about that.

I'll cope, somehow.

No royal wedding party, though. We shall just march into Tirion and I will say 'it wasn't an accident' and my family'll be delighted to meet you.

I would've wanted some kind of party back home but that was, you know, when I had people to invite.

I'm so sorry.

I know. I love you.

The custom is to give each other rings. Just so you can be on the lookout for materials.

Ooh, noted.

He has no regrets about this life choice.

Regrets are for life choices that aren't awesome.