« Back
Generated:
Post last updated:
i see the stars, i hear the rolling thunder
yves is a portalsnack (hell val in vn)
Permalink Mark Unread

The ghost in the park is five foot two and even lighter than he should be at that height. He only hasn't been sleeping rough because he doesn't sleep, because sometimes people see an old thin man with no eyes and offer him enough cash to pay for coffee and he doesn't exactly have food or rent to worry about. He doesn't think of himself as all that poor, actually. He has sturdy cotton clothes. He has shoes. He has a backpack full of stuff. ...Half full of stuff. Well, it has some stuff in it. Shelter is optional.

Something is happening. He hears Pete shout "run!" and something break and grass bend under something slithery and retreating footsteps and "what the fuck" and "oh my god" and a camera shutter sound. He runs, trips on something, and when he hits the ground he isn't in the park.

He wasn't really expecting to be taken anywhere by magic but there's a specific place he wasn't expecting to be taken to by magic and it's not someplace he wants to be and it's not full of people he wants to cooperate with. He curls up as tight as he can. His hands are shaking.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Who's this?" asks a voice.

"A fine question. Looks too disoriented to be a teleporter. Portalsnake?"

"We aren't adjacent to Dreamward."

"There could be another Dreamward."

"Don't they check for that?"

"Mysterious visitor, what brings you here?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He would curl up tighter but he's already doing that as much as he can. He doesn’t even try to answer the obvious demons people in a situation where he strongly expects demons.

Permalink Mark Unread

"...well, if someone could tote him to the infirmary so he isn't taking up conference room space..."

"My host doesn't want to touch noncommunicative portalsnake visitors, worried they'll have something weird going on."

"If it's a weird airborne thing we're already hosed."

"If it's a weird airborne thing we're in a precognition."

"I'll carry them." Yves is scooped.

Permalink Mark Unread

He doesn’t follow all of that but he follows it enough to worry about the demons seeing the future.

He’s so easy to scoop. Not only is he remarkably light, he reflexively cooperates with attempts to manhandle him. It doesn’t make him more relaxed or responsive to external reality or agentic - if anything it does the opposite - but it looks a little like that since he unfreezes. Once he uncurls a bit it's just possible to notice the hole at the base of his neck that's the result of him having figured out how to suppress his regeneration before cutting his own throat. Pity it didn't kill him but it does keep him from speaking; he's sure these people can change that but at least it'll be one extra thing in their way before they can get much use out of him.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh he's injured."

"It's not like the infirmary is out of your way on the way to the infirmary."

"Not wrong."

Carry carry.

Permalink Mark Unread

His breathing evens out a little along the way. He's never seen an infernal infirmary before and these people don't talk like demons and that's probably a trick but it might be a trick that involves not hurting him for a while.

Permalink Mark Unread

He is plopped onto a bed.

"We think he got portalsnook. - snaked? Snuck?"

"You think a portalsnake ate him."

"Or the equivalent, yeah."

"Missut, over here."

Someone comes over and causes his neck to glow green and heal over.

Permalink Mark Unread

He makes a startled noise but doesn't say anything. He sits up and tries to affect an imperious and disdainful air, an effect pretty badly spoiled by everything else about him.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Hi there!" says the green-glowy-person, a man in a nice sherwani and turban which matches the green glow with gold accessories. "Was that the only place you were hurt?"

Permalink Mark Unread

...That’s not how demons dress, either. Not that that means much.

He smiles slightly. He’s a big fan of how this completely predictable violation didn’t involve any pain and the probably-a-demon responsible is pleasant to look at and that's clearly a deliberate strategy to get him to cooperate and he's inclined to be at least as cooperative as he would be if they were hurting him. Which is not very but he'd probably end up opening his mouth at some point if he were being tortured so he does that. His tongue has also been cut out.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Sir? Anything else you need me to take a look at?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, if that doesn't make it clear, then that's fine. They can just be baffled as to why nothing they try can get him to talk. He shrugs.

Permalink Mark Unread

"- Missut I think he doesn't have a tongue."

"Cripes, how did I miss that, I was looking for dental problems - was this guy in Angband?" Glow goes on the tongue.

Permalink Mark Unread

He makes a face and tries not to gag. His breathing is a little too even.

That was really very predictable but he thought it would buy him hours and instead they just did some kind of magic and undid all his hard work instantly and it's terribly unfair. The strategy where they act nice might last him hours anyway, though, or at least he tells himself that to try to tamp down on all the panic. It doesn't help much. He stares at the glowing person's outfit because that way whatever happens next at least he'll have gotten to see something that looked nice for a moment.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Sir?" says the glowy person, Missut.

Permalink Mark Unread

He shouldn’t say anything because he hasn’t thought through the precognition thing - only he only knows about it because they said -

- no, he’s being an idiot, words aren’t evidence of anything. Which doesn’t actually mean he should say anything, but. Maybe one thing.

"You’ve been very nice and you’re obviously trying not to act like demons so I’ll humor you long enough to let you know it’s not personal that I’m not going to say anything else. Except that it is. It’s not personal to the people you’re pretending to be."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh for fucksake, he was in an Angband."

"Angbands don't have demons."

"They might if our Allspeak was glitching -"

"No, they don't, it comes through as 'orcs' and 'Maiar' and 'Balrogs' and stuff, not 'demons', I know everything is demons but those specifically are not, just like you and me."

"We got translated as demons in one language one time."

"Okay, fine, but they do check for Ardas, it's probably something else they don't check for."

"Which is just like Angband! Halle-fucking-lujah! I always wanted one right next door, I was feeling deprived -"

"Make yourself useful and go tell Sovereign Ristrell."

Permalink Mark Unread

He will not be baited into making it clear whether he’s heard of any of those things before.

Permalink Mark Unread

That seems to be more or less what they expect. One of the people who's hanging around puts on some nice music and leaves a cup of apple juice near the bed where he's sitting and then they leave him alone.

Permalink Mark Unread

He lies down and appreciates being on a soft surface and tries to think of things that make more sense in hindsight if demons can see the future but there aren’t many. He decides that once he destroys Hell he’ll never tell anyone how or ideally even that it was him, but that’s... not really a near-term consideration.

He waits.

Permalink Mark Unread

Eventually a couple of the voices he heard before is back. "We could possibly just send him to an appropriate Valinor." A tall dark man in a suit.

"Only after somebody's been by to chase him back to wherever he came from and deal with it, if they've got a portalsnake they may figure out adjacency and such any moment now. Oh, good, someone put music on, are there any other recommendations -" A remarkably average-looking woman with an incongruously severe expression.

"Just to be boring. Possibly you shouldn't actually take this meeting here?"

"Possibly, but give me five." She pulls up a chair beside the bed. "Hello. I'm Sovereign Ristrell. Our supracivilization's previous familiarity with people who've been tortured until they reach a state similar to yours is of fortresses called Utumno or Angband, controlled by the Vala Melkor also known as Morgoth, assisted by various Maiar such as Sauron or Thauron also known as Gorthaur, Thuringwethil, and various balrogs. If this describes the place you came from, it is within our collective power to annihilate Melkor and Sauron and free all of the prisoners, and it would in no way shape or form be surprising to Melkor if you announced that you would prefer this, nor would it make for a particularly dramatic moment to end a simulation. Does that description match?"

Permalink Mark Unread

...That was obviously crafted to get a response. If they have the ability to do that - which they did not, actually, say that they do, just that they do if that vaguely reminiscent description is an exact match, which it isn’t, which doesn’t matter because words mean nothing.

He will not get suckered into working for the next deceitful nest of sin that pretends to be the good guys. Not even if they really aren’t his demons.

And they didn’t, actually, see the state Hell left him in. (Unless they did. Who knows how long they’ve been spying.)

"When I left they didn’t know me to have heard any of those names. And they didn’t know me to know what drama would have to do with anything. But I wouldn’t dream of trying to talk you out of killing them."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you. I am planning to keep you here until an appropriate specialist can come and derive information about the world you came from by examining you. They will be aware that they cannot expect to have your cooperation to work with beyond lying there. The standard of care for persons rescued from Angband, which I am going to borrow in this instance, is to have them under supervision in case they commit violence, supply background music to stave off the crushing boredom of refusing to take actions or have interesting trains of thought, allow visitors only on a case by case basis depending on what reaction they elicit, offer optional unconsciousness or death or psychological care, and supply an uncomplicated vegetarian diet. I intend to order this procedure followed with you, filling in details like whether your supervision should be sapient or not with whatever happens to be convenient for us, until we can hand you off to an appropriate expert in another world with ordinary Angband victims, unless you state that you would prefer otherwise."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I don't need food. At all. I, uh... I think the abilities you're acting as though you have might not be good enough? If you were expecting I was mortal?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Melkors can sustain people in conditions that would normally kill them but this effect doesn't operate outside their domains, so some rescuees from Angband, which I understand you did not personally come from but which I am using as a template, will die without food and water and air. If you don't need food at all then you can ignore the food that will regardless be brought to you per protocol, we aren't about to run out. If you want to elaborate on what abilities you will expect to be necessary I am listening."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I like plain water and black coffee and if you have food to spare and give it to me instead of a starving person I will understand why you would do that as long as you think you can - " and he stops cold because he was about to fill in something made up and random that technically matches the description she gave of getting information without needing him to do anything but now suddenly he realizes his made-up random example is the only thing he can think of that matches her description and it's the only thing he's even mostly confident demons can't actually do.

Permalink Mark Unread

She waits in case he's going to finish the sentence but doesn't otherwise react to the cutoff. A nurse takes his apple juice and replaces it with an ice water. "We don't have any starving people."

Permalink Mark Unread

He makes a noncommital sound and ponders what to say for a moment. Okay, so, the most important thing is to figure out whether it gives anything away to comment on the fact that it seems notable that it seems to him like she's acting like she wants him to believe she expects him to expect that mindreading is a thing. That might be what he's supposed to think the person inspecting him can do and it could also be why she said something about not having interesting trains of thought. But the others mentioned precognition earlier and if that's real it could be used to fake mindreading. Okay, how can he get more information about whether she wants him to think that mindreading is a thing without tipping his hand about whether he found it notable that she implied it was?

"Is your appropriate specialist going to be annoyed if I spend the whole time having obscene daydreams?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I would be astonished if Vanda Nossëo sent me someone who was going to read your mind, so no, not a bit."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Is that not how you were planning to mine me for strategically relevant information?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- no. Mindreading is pretty strictly regulated. The relevant information is what world you came from and someone with the right magic can probably figure that out by looking at you and then trying to teleport to 'wherever that person came from'. Probably in a precognition given the givens."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I came from a park. On Earth. If you're hoping to go to Hell, I wasn't born there and I didn't come from there."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh, that's good to know, thank you. - though it is also confusing because they also check for Earths."

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "Well, I have no opinion on whether you should try to get more information than that out of me."

Permalink Mark Unread

She raises an eyebrow. "If that is true it is a peculiar thing to say."

Permalink Mark Unread

"It seems like a thing you’d have thought about. I don’t... I don’t have trustworthy judgment about anything, including recursively. So I don’t have an opinion. But it’s..." He shrugs. "It’s interesting that you say you wouldn’t. I don’t know. I’m probably wasting your time saying anything at all."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I do not allow people to waste my time. I can hand you off to an underling, but my underlings will do a better job at more routine work."

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "If you want to try in vain to satisfy my idle curiosity about the decisionmaking of your persona's persona, I’m not stopping you."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You're curious about why it is internationally frowned upon to read people's minds without permission?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug.

Permalink Mark Unread

"A specific stripe of particularly magically and politically powerful individuals have a particular distaste for mind-reading and mind-altering effects. I am told they also don't drink alcohol, for example. But it's also an intimate, high-leverage, and usually asymmetrical process, which many sorts of lawmaking apparatus have reason to eventually elect to forbid in the same way that a body of law will tend to condone less and less physical violence over time."

Permalink Mark Unread

...Asking questions was a big mistake. He runs abruptly out of tolerance for modeling what it means that people present themselves as people who present themselves as people who ad infinitum. He shouldn’t offer because she might be a demon. He has no idea if she as she presents herself would be able to use anything he knows or if the contents of his mind are too pessimized for that to be a good idea. And he can’t figure it out because whatever evidence he decides to wait for, they can tell what it is he’s looking for and show him that.

He curls up again, not quite as tight as before, and starts crying.

Permalink Mark Unread

That's not really an unexpected thing for an Angband victim to do at pretty much any time and the model does keep working. Ristrell nods politely to the medical staff and departs.

Permalink Mark Unread

He refuses to have opinions about that either. He doesn’t know if he wishes they’d prove they can read his mind. It’d mean he should give up, but it’d also mean he could give up.

Whatever.

Permalink Mark Unread

They keep the music playing and periodically resupply him with water and coffee and various food that he can ignore if he prefers.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's... fine. Temporarily. While he's mulling over things he needs to mull over, anyway.

He hates them. Their personas are lies that are also liars - they're pretending to pretend to have but not use mindreading, he has no idea why - and they're taking forever to pretend to do anything about Hell and they're kidnappers who just... what can you even call it, reverse-maimed him? They made it clear how trivial it is for them to decide exactly what senses he has and exactly what abilities he has and pretended to think they were being nice. They kidnapped him, or maybe that was a complete and total coincidence, maybe he happened at complete random to be transported by magic to people who themselves do magic and had a plan for what to do with him. Who knows, anything's fucking possible. Their coffee is terrible, or maybe all coffee is terrible and he just got used to not having a tongue to notice with; either way, it's their fault. But really most importantly, they're holding him here, and he was getting so fond of not being a prisoner. Not overtly, anyway, and maybe actually not at all.

But their terrible coffee is coffee and he has math to prove.

Permalink Mark Unread

After a couple of hours somebody in an outfit that is in ridiculous conversation with the ridiculous outfit of the glowy healer shows up and the staff show her to his bed. She looks at him. "Okay," she says after a moment, "do you guys want to teleport him to whichever Valinor yourselves or should I do that?"

"We've got it," says the nearest nurse, "or so I'm told."

"Great. Thanks. Mister, your suffering will not be in vain, we're gonna get the bastards." She smiles and disappears.

Permalink Mark Unread

He scowls at her smile.

That's his entire ostensible contribution to their supposed future defeat of Hell, if they're telling the truth, and also if they're telling the truth there's not much point in him doing... anything, really.

So if he tries to just walk out, does that make the torture start? Time to find out.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Teleport office is upstairs in room one seventeen," says a nurse, taking somebody's pulse.

Permalink Mark Unread

What an obvious way to get him to take the stairs down. Which is what he's going to try first.

Permalink Mark Unread

They actually only have elevators but he can take them down!

The curtains in the infirmary were all closed, but out in the hall he can see that the view is of more buildings and the Moon.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Where the fuck is that.

Fine. Upstairs. Upelevator. To the teleport office.

Permalink Mark Unread

Room 117 contains a man typing something intently who looks up when he hears footsteps. "Hullo there - oh, are you the portalsnack?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I got teleported here against my will. Are you the person to talk to about going home?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"My notification says we were going to drop you off in a Valinor but if you don't want to go to a Valinor where do you wanna go, where's home?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "Didn’t you just hire someone to find that out?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Maybe so but not so's they'd tell me. You can have a sit and wait to hear back if you want."

Permalink Mark Unread

He just wants to do whatever will make them quit pretending to be nice.

He sits. He hums The Song That Gets On Everybody's Nerves. His voice is awful.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"Coughdrop?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Is he supposed to know that word. Wow, this place is full of alien things. Shrug.

Permalink Mark Unread

The guy picks up a little wrapped candy out of his desk drawer and holds it out.

Permalink Mark Unread

He takes the mysterious object and sticks it in his backpack.

"The last time I was definitely talking to demons I don't think they thought I knew what a Valinor is so I'm either curious or pretending to be curious."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh, Valinors are this continent on Ardas, which are a kind of world. People who went through Angband collect there because it's convenient and pretty and full of very patient and helpful Elves who take care of them while they refuse to do things."

Permalink Mark Unread

"That's very thoughtful of you but I literally have no needs."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Sounds fake but okay."

Permalink Mark Unread

He shrugs. "I don't pester you to prove your magic and you could do that without - man, I don't know, what would even prove to you that I don't have needs?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I dunno, it'd help if you were more specific? Don't need to eat, sure, lots of those, don't need to breathe, sure just like the folks next door - wouldn't benefit from a nice Elf singing you a song after you did a stint in a torture fortress, pull the other one."

Permalink Mark Unread

He did really like the music. While he was hiding on Earth he had a lot of experiences that beat lying very still on flat stone by himself, so he's familiar with the existence of the category, but that music beat it by a surprisingly generous margin.

He shrugs. "I don’t think the demons thought I had any nice elves singing to me for centuries but I suppose I could be wrong."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- I don't think I'm going to be able to follow this conversation if you keep talking like that."

Permalink Mark Unread

Talking is also not a need. He sits in absolute silence with his eyes closed.

Permalink Mark Unread

The guy will ignore him, then, and he can eavesdrop on people asking to be taken hither or thither.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ugh. He contemplates math and resents the existence of language and waits for someone to let the teleporter know how to take him home.

Permalink Mark Unread

Eventually the guy at the desk says, "They're having some trouble triangulating because it looks like you came through a world that bounces people in it an extra step."

Permalink Mark Unread

He sighs. That's such an obvious excuse to keep him prisoner but it's nice that they're still making up excuses instead of just chaining him up. He does not comment on either of these things.

"So just to be clear, you’re not even ostensibly doing anything about Hell and ostensibly I can’t affect whatever you’re up to regardless of whether the contents of my mind are a trap?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...uh, right, though they're like, still trying, it's just taking a while."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Ah, so it could theoretically in the future matter, and you can’t just ask the future what to do?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you really want me to try to explain precognition mechanics to you, because I'd just be reading from Wikipedia."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Not really. I was just wondering if it could possibly matter to anything important if I somehow turned out to have been designed to ruin everyone I talk to, let alone everyone who reads my mind, and it sounds like it could matter."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Uh, that does sound like it could matter. I'm not reading your mind, I can't do that from over here, and hopefully nobody will try, but if you shouldn't talk to people you should probably still go to Valinor and get sung to."

Permalink Mark Unread

He shrugs unhappily.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you wanna go there now or just... sit in this waiting room."

Permalink Mark Unread

He would rather stay in the waiting room than go to Valinor but there’s nothing about this choice that’s important enough to try very hard to get it right and anyway talking about preferences is not a good way to get what he wants. He shrugs.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Right, so, I'm gonna go with the original plan and drop you off in Valinor. Four hops. I assume you don't have, like, other stuff than what you've got on you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Why would I tell you that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah, I dunno why I even asked. I assume the Elves are used to people like you."

Pop pop pop pop.

It's a stunningly gorgeous forest, with towering redwoods shading the mossy ground and picturesque shrubbery muffling the sound of the babbling brook over there and bunnies grazing in a clearing.

"Just a sec," says the teleporter. He steps past a tree, calling, "Hey, who do I talk to about dropping off somebody who might as well be an Angband victim?"

"Over here! Hello!" replies another voice, belonging to a tall pretty pointy-eared fellow in gorgeous robes. "Thank you very much. Is this him?"

"Yeah. We don't have like, a name, or anything, so if you need to find records he's down as 'portalsnack 54'."

"Understood. I appreciate your bringing him to a safe place."

"It sounded kind of like he'd already escaped and wanted to go back but they're having technical difficulties." Shrug. "Probably somebody'll come looking if they figure it out. All set to take it from here?"

"Yes, I believe so."

Teleporter leaves. The Elf smiles at the new person and starts picking leaves and berries off apparently random plants.

Permalink Mark Unread

He hates this Elf. He loves this forest which was probably designed to make him love it for nefarious purposes. Or maybe he’s underestimating the awesomeness of natural forests. He shuts his eyes and covers his ears and sits right where he happens to be and resents Valinor.

Permalink Mark Unread

The next time he opens his eyes the Elf is gone. He is alone in the beautiful forest.

Permalink Mark Unread

Like he’s going to open his eyes. Then he might see the forest.

At home in the land of the free, he interrupts his busy schedule of silent contemplation with occasional panhandling, hanging out standing guard over a sleeping friend, and buying coffee. He has nothing to do here except sit very still forever, briefly doing math and then being too tired to ever think clearly about anything again for all eternity.

...Or meander in the direction of that hot spring he can hear in the distance, he might be able to sleep there eventually. But - if they realize there are still ever times when he can sleep, they might fix that. So he doesn't. And he gets tired, and starts drifting off enough to start listing to one side, and panics and jerks hard enough to end up rolling down a soft slope right toward it.

That's such a suspicious thing to happen and he's very suspicious of it. He does not get into the hot spring. He does drop a hand in to feel the warmth.

Permalink Mark Unread

There's a naked Elf in the hot spring. They've got their chin propped on their arms on the edge of the pool so it's hard to tell what sex of Elf. They look at him and blink once and then close their eyes.

Permalink Mark Unread

That seems pretty valid of them. This Elf is the least objectionable person he's encountered since being kidnapped. He takes his shoes off and sits with his feet in the water, and eventually decides to lie down (still with his feet in the water).

Permalink Mark Unread

There are occasionally munching sounds as the Elf picks clover and eats it. The hot spring burbles. Birds chirp.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's so nice. It's even nicer than his park. It's so...

...one very brief power nap later he's regretting all his life choices, even more worn out than before, and very much not enjoying the forest.

Permalink Mark Unread

Would he like the forest to be some other way? It's very accommodating. (The Elf is still in the hot spring and picking apart bits of grass from the shore to arrange in decorative patterns.)

Permalink Mark Unread

He looks at the decorative patterns for a bit. Probably the forest will not be restraining and torturing him in exactly the way that is simultaneously not too bad to sleep through some of the time and boring enough for the demons that they never pay enough attention to notice him doing that, because this is a forest and not a torture chamber and he doesn't even particularly want it to be a torture chamber. Probably it will also not contain a coffee shop for the same reason. Though who knows, really, it's - it's obviously either reading his mind or paying attention to his reactions and telling the future - no, that's not obvious, it could also have researched his history in exhaustive detail and be guessing wildly -

- its behavior is really suspicious, though. He's so suspicious of its suspicious behavior. Okay. Quick test. He would like to see seven birds. He would like them to be blue or green or brown, he can't remember what the normal bird colors even are, whichever of those is a real thing. He will react visibly if instead they are red or orange or white, but he is politely silently asking the forest for green or blue or brown. This is so out of nowhere he's not sure how he'd come up with it by watching himself from the outside.

Permalink Mark Unread

Seven quail trot across the background. They're brown.

Permalink Mark Unread

The most important thing is to not react differently than he would if there were no quail. He keeps looking in their general direction for a while making steadily more impatient faces before sighing and shutting his eyes in his best facsimile of vague annoyance about the forest's refusal to provide him with evidence. He doesn’t feel like he exists. His hands and lips are tingling. He promises himself he will never ever mention this to anyone.

And now he knows. And now what would he want to do if he didn’t? Would he call their bluff? It’s essential that he keep acting like he can possibly ever achieve anything, like he isn’t totally fucked. He would not start crying. He would not give up. He isn’t sure what he would do. He hopes his guess is right.

He gets up. He walks in a random direction as straight as he can, hoping to find something other than the creepy mindreading forest eventually.

(Thank you for your honesty, he tells the forest.)

Permalink Mark Unread

The creepy mindreading forest yields in a startlingly short period of time to not-forest. There's an Elf there, who smiles at him.

Permalink Mark Unread

Smiling people. Why. "I have something to say to the person I spoke to before."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I can try to help you with that, whom did you speak to?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I think she claimed to be Sovereign Ristrell?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Would you like to dictate a message to send to her for me?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He raises an eyebrow. "No one has even tried to present me with a case that you people don't constitute multiple interest groups who don't all fully trust each other." (Wow, he feels so stupid pretending secrets are a thing he can have.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"...okay, I can just let her office know that you'd like to speak to her, then."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you."

Permalink Mark Unread

They do something with a device, then look up from it and smile again.

Permalink Mark Unread

The smiling is really obnoxious. He smiles back. It's kind of obviously forced.

Permalink Mark Unread

"She'll be able to find you in the Lórien if you wait there."

Permalink Mark Unread

"The what?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"The forest."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thanks." Back to the creepy mindreading forest. At least the creepy mindreading forest has literally never done anything objectionable.

Permalink Mark Unread

It continues in this unobjectionable vein. What kind of forest would he like to walk into?

Permalink Mark Unread

He isn't really consciously thinking about that but a canyon full of fascinating rock formations and odd little trees growing in strange places would be nice, especially if it also had a few flowers and a bright blue sky.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh look, right over there. Bonsai harvester's dream.

Permalink Mark Unread

He sits and stares at a strange tree, scowling.

Permalink Mark Unread

It rustles gently in a light breeze of the precisely correct temperature.

Permalink Mark Unread

Scooooowwwwwl. He tries not to let it be apparent that this is a vaguely fond sort of scowl because he's pretty sure he'd be unalloyedly annoyed if he hadn't noticed that the forest was a sweet honest secret mindreader. "Hate this stupid forest," he mutters. Please don't feel bad, he thinks.

Permalink Mark Unread

The forest gives no indication of feeling bad. A hawk circles overhead. A little lizard clings to the canyon wall.

Permalink Mark Unread

Probably she won't show up. Oh, well. It doesn't really matter. He would probably be pretty close to lying down and giving up forever at this point even if he thought the forest could neither read minds nor see the future.

Permalink Mark Unread

There's a nice spot to lie down over there, if he wants.

Somebody comes trotting up behind him. It's the teleporter guy. "Sovereign Ristrell said you maybe wanted to come back?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I had something to say to her if she wants to hear it."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- I don't think she's going to come here in person, but I can take you back to Tide to see her if you want."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Sure." Does she hate being mindread by the creepy forest? He doesn't ask.

Permalink Mark Unread

Pop pop pop pop.

"Her office is on the eighth floor, room 2."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Thanks." He can try to find it. Maybe he'll even succeed. Probably to absolutely no benefit, but.

Permalink Mark Unread

Room 2 has the door propped open. Ristrell is doing something on a device, with many screens. She raises an eyebrow as he enters. "Welcome back."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Hey. I was trying to say something earlier and I'm not sure I said it well, should I try again?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Go right ahead."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know if I know anything useful to you. And I don't know if instead maybe I've been lied to - I mean - I'm very sure I've been lied to. I don't know if I've been lied to in a way that was meant as a trap for someone else, like giving me inaccurate information about the demons' weaknesses or something. I don't know if it'd be a waste of your time to sort that out. But if you're worried about powerful people getting mad at you, I don't think I'd tell them, and if you're trying to care about me and what I want for some reason, I don't feel especially happy about the idea of you taking how I feel about it into account because how I feel might have been - engineered - and even if not, I don't think it matters much, next to all of Hell."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't follow what you mean about powerful people getting mad at me. Mad at me for what?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"You're the one who said your mindreading policy was related to a... specific stripe of politically and magically powerful individuals? Is that how you put it?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- yes. They don't need to be reported to, to find out, necessarily. I don't formally belong to their organization but broadly agree that consensual mindreading is superior to coercive."

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "Seems like a nice policy if Hell isn't involved."

Permalink Mark Unread

"The comparison facility, Angband, features quite a lot of mind control."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...That's fucked, man."

Permalink Mark Unread

"So I am led to understand."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Why are we talking about them?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"About Angbands? I can understand why a Hell that didn't involve it would leave you fairly inured to mindreading et cetera, but it is not itself a necessarily nontortuous activity if deployed against the unwilling."

Permalink Mark Unread

"It kind of sounds like it'd suck. That's not - if you could materially affect your chances of ending Hell by, uh, waterboarding me, I wouldn't be mad at you unless you'd run into a million people you mistakenly thought you could end Hell by waterboarding." What even is waterboarding, he picked this example for being something they talk about in America and has no idea whether the name refers to something he's experienced. Which really makes the conversation easier.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"Your after-the-fact emotional disposition is not actually what this principle tracks," she says, though she's looking more steadily at him and away from her screens now. "It's whether, in advance, given the expectations you and not I have, you'd want to be mindread, if for example that's a capability your tormentors did not evince."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I would really strongly prefer that that capability not exist, and that implies not wanting it to happen to me? - I don't know who runs Angband, if it's even a thing you didn't just make up to fuck with me, but I wouldn't be more surprised by demons being able to use permission, that's what all the fairy tales say they do when they visit Earth and I don't know if any fairy tales are trustworthy sources on anything either but the thing where you seem like you're trying to get me to say something really specific is not making that seem less likely. And it seems - stupid for you to base your decisions on my expectations, addressing the person you're presenting yourself as, because the version that's actually a demon isn't going to do that so you'd only even consider it in cases where my expectations are completely out of step with reality - never mind, what I mean is I don't really get your decisionmaking process and I'm probably too stupid to get it. I don't know enough to have a preference."

Permalink Mark Unread

"The mindreading ability that I and mine in particular have, as opposed to some other people you could have gone to, is that my species are parasitic invertebrates that can enter and operate hosts with comprehensive knowledge of the still-conscious host's history and dispositions. It is surprisingly easy to find hosts who are interested in this arrangement," she gestures at herself, or, uh, her host's self, "but it is not something that I can within my charter and international obligations impose on someone. I am not a fairytale creature trying to get exact words, I am noting that you said things like 'that implies not wanting it to happen to me' and concluding that probably, like most people, you don't want it to happen to you."

Permalink Mark Unread

He takes a moment to try to breathe evenly. He opens his mouth to say something and then concludes it's actually time for more breathing, and then manages to answer.

"...I don't think it's worse for it to be a thing that happens to me than for it to be a thing that only happens to other people if it's - if you - never mind, I was going to say 'if you're really the sort of people who have rules about it for other people's sake' but I think that also doesn't actually... matter... if it would at all affect the likelihood that you would end Hell. But if you insist on hearing about my feelings, if you can do that I - think probably knowing for sure would - have some upside."

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"If you go on in approximately that vein for a bit longer I will at some point call it good but I would really like an airtight case to present at my next meeting with the Imperatrix should it come up."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I would probably hand you a vacuum jar if I had one," he deadpans.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you have any comments on the question of whether it should be me or some other Yeerk?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't - I'm really not qualified to figure out what would be the best way to end Hell and - " and if he didn't deserve Hell he would end it there because the fewer words he says the faster things change " - that's really the only important consideration but I've done horrible things and it wouldn't really matter if whoever it was were - never mind. You're the second least obnoxious person I've met since being kidnapped today."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't actually think this process will meaningfully accelerate the handling of Hell. They haven't found it yet and would be turning your information into a plan of action only with more corroborating sources."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Why did you string me along, you asshole."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You're difficult to understand when you're being obfuscatory, and sometimes Angband victims want similar interventions by way of proof that they are no longer there, even if this won't help destroy their Angband at all."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I’m not saying I wouldn’t be happy about that but - the inside of my head isn’t something I'd really expect anyone to like getting to see and I sure wouldn’t want to end up delaying you for it. And I don’t know if how I feel was deliberately arranged somehow to cause problems for other people so I’m really not happy about anyone taking it into account but I guess that could apply just as well to taking it into account that I feel that way about it."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't think you need to be worried about the welfare of Yeerks who go into your head if any do so."

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "I think I've told you literally every consideration I can think of and how I feel about them. I'm not very likely to be mad about it, whatever you do."

Permalink Mark Unread

She sighs. "If you will stand just there and not move, I will go and have a look and then come right back out into Josefa again. I will go ear-to-ear to minimize uncomfortable handling procedure." She gets up from her desk.

Permalink Mark Unread

Does freezing in terror count? Because that's what he's doing.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yup. That counts.

She plants her ear on his and extends into his brain.

Permalink Mark Unread

He is really very miserable about this, but then, he's really very miserable about almost everything. He's terrified of it happening at all, and disappointed because he caught the implication that they can also control bodies and wanted to test that, that part would be new and easier to verify and have a lot of implications. But he genuinely doesn't think his preferences should get any weight at all so he's not really considering asking her to do more than take a look and leave.

He does have a detailed mental map of Hell, one that might even be useful if they couldn't just conjure it all anyway.

It wasn't much like Angband. It wasn't as bad, and the lies weren't as competent. The place was presented to him as Purgatory, the torment as purifying and exalting. It should have been easy to suspect something, if he'd been thinking straight, but he never really got that chance. There was literally never a moment when he was neither in pain nor at work; they trained him out of even wanting to eat, and tried to do the same with sleep; they kept him desperately lonely and interacted with him mostly to ask things of him. And the things they asked weren't usually horrible - copy books, construct a printing press, scrub the floor, learn new languages - but sometimes they were. Sometimes he was asked to be the one to wield the knife. Sometimes he was asked to take responsibility for the minute details of when and how. He was asked to help teach.

When he got away he cut his tongue out because it was their tool and it didn't even work the first time. He put his eyes out because he couldn't trust them, because he wanted to stop being tempted to believe anything he saw, because gaslighting per se never happened to him other than through sight or hearing (and he thought for a long time about whether he would rather be deaf). He didn't want them back; he didn't parse himself as having a choice; the sense of ownership of his body he was starting to build back shattered when Missut healed him and he doesn't endorse even suggesting that anyone change their behavior in any way over his stupid preferences that were obviously installed by demons on purpose to cause problems, but it feels just a bit silly to be so precious about something he obviously wants and asked for and to just decide to reshape his body on a fucking whim. He thinks it might have taken days to get it all set up stably so he wouldn't just heal. It might be faster now. It wouldn't be nearly as fast as what Missut did, though.

He's exhausted - he still doesn't eat and sleeps even less now, though now he has enough to drink and regular social contact - and he wants so desperately to stop. If ceasing to exist were an option, it'd be a very attractive one. He'd take laying down somewhere comfortable and never moving again, if it seemed like there wasn't anything useful for him to do. He'd take being a yeerk host, probably, if it didn't involve being used for anything he wouldn't endorse and he got along at all with the yeerk. He misses sleep; he has a tendency to have some unholy bastard child of flashbacks and hypnic jerks whenever he tries, and if he waits enough of them out to actually fall asleep he has a tendency to proceed to immediately have horrible nightmares. And then wake up almost immediately. And then have flashbacks about it. He'd take being tortured if it'd convince his stupid half-asleep hindbrain that no one was coming after him.

That's - really most of it, though. Just sheer exhaustion and a little gaslighting that probably did involve illusions but not immersive ones. He was pretty confident about living on Earth right up until he got teleported, a thing demons and no one else he knows of can do and which he was concerned about demons doing to him if they ever found him. He's got a friend and a hobby and a favorite coffee shop.

He's got a lot of languages, so hey, that's something. He'd forget them all in a heartbeat on the principle that things he was taught by demons are probably a negative amount of useful to know, if he could, but he can't.

He thinks it's pathetic to hope for but he's trying and failing not to wonder if Ristrell can tell him that actually it's obvious where all the landmines are and it's fine for him to talk to people and fine for him to take his own preferences into account.

Permalink Mark Unread

She rearranges his position slightly to get his ear above Josefa's. (He can probably hear that Josefa is breathing kind of oddly now but is waiting to accept her Yeerk again.) She goes out.

She straightens up and goes to transcribe the map of Hell. "You aren't a memetic hazard. You can go straight back to the Lórien and lie there indefinitely and I will send you a messenger when they've figured out how to go to your Earth. It is possible you can be annihilated but it would be something of a research project since your sort of immortality is new so you would probably be advised by relevant researchers to try at least one of those things first."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Thank you."

He doesn't have any better ideas than taking her advice and he does already know where to go to get teleported so he'll just go do that.

Permalink Mark Unread

The teleporter is up for popping him right back to Lórien.

Permalink Mark Unread

These people are so invested in him being in the creepy mindreading forest. Whatever. Hey, creepy forest, can he have a really hard surface to repeatedly bang his head against in an attempt to knock himself out?

Permalink Mark Unread

No. He can have soporific-smelling flowers?

Permalink Mark Unread

Stupid horrible creepy forest! He’s tempted to rip the flowers up but what if that hurts the forest? ...What if it hurts the forest when he stands on it?

Whatever. The yeerks have better ways of making him hurt people than sending him to the forest in a bad mood. And the horrible forest is allowed to drug him if it likes the idea of getting to watch his nightmares. He lies down and grouchily smells the flowers.

Permalink Mark Unread

They send him aromatically drifting off to a dreamless sleep.

Permalink Mark Unread

He would find a way to complain about that were he but conscious.

Permalink Mark Unread

The flowers back off at the precise right time, of course, leaving him to awaken pleasantly in the exact best sort of sleeping spot.

Permalink Mark Unread

He doesn't get up right away. He just lies there and thinks for a while.

If the yeerks were actually evil he'd have some huge problems but they wouldn't have much reason to lie to him, right? They can do whatever they want. If what they want involves not enslaving everyone they meet, that's nice, but there isn't actually anything he could hold back from them and so it'd be stupid to try. There is really nothing he wants them to only have if they're evil, after all.

Ristrell and also the creepy forest presumably already know that's how he feels about it and probably no one actually has any use for him, or at least no use worth putting up with his horrible memories for. And if they're going to destroy Hell, that's... well, that's great, that's the only thing he's really sure he cares about. And with that done or at least out of his hands he really doesn't have anything else to do. And it's not even exactly that he wants to do things, really. There is definitely some part of him that's glad that, since he's completely useless and cannot affect anything that actually matters, he can stop. There's just - nothing else. The forest can be interesting if it wants, or it can be obnoxiously paternalistic, or whatever it happens to feel like, and it doesn't matter. Lórien just... inherently lacks most of the good things about nature. Because it isn't. Because there isn't a story in the shape of every tree. Because it isn't real, it's just a work of art that seems superficially like a forest if you don't think too hard about it. And boy does he ever hate that there's anything with the ability to read minds and construct unreal space-warping scenarios optimized to provoke specific responses, though given that anything like that exists he's not going to complain about the specifics of its behavior. It could do so much worse than being extremely open about what it is and optimizing for comfort.

It's just that it's a suffocating cocoon of false beauty that can't quite actually hide the gaping pointlessness of his existence. But this is where everyone has seemed to think he should be and it's not like he has any reason to prefer anywhere else.

Hey, Lórien, got any brilliant ideas for how to fix that by cleverly arranging trees?

Permalink Mark Unread

A spruce rustles sadly. It does not solve his problem.

Permalink Mark Unread

I'm sorry your problems are fundamental to the way you are. They seem worse than mine, if you were looking to wallow.

Permalink Mark Unread

The forest has no obvious reply to this.

Permalink Mark Unread

He'll just stay here until someone wants something from him. He's not sure if he wants them to or not. On the one hand, if they did, he'd have things to do. On the other hand, if they did, he'd have things to do.

Permalink Mark Unread

He goes unbothered except by the forest trying as hard as possible to be relaxing and lovely.

Permalink Mark Unread

He discovers within himself a preference other than to end Hell, and it is to not be in this forest. The people who have so insistently tried to get him to experience the forest can either live with that or possess him and make him go back. Goodbye, horrible forest.

Permalink Mark Unread

The same Elf is waiting on his way out. "Hello. Where to?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He blinks confusedly and shrugs.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Humans aren't actually welcome in most parts of Valinor," says the Elf apologetically.

Permalink Mark Unread

The fact that everyone trying to get him to go to Valinor was making stupid decisions does not cause him to know any local place names besides Angband and he doesn’t want to go there. He just sighs and sits down and presses the heels of his hands into his eyes.

Permalink Mark Unread

"You can spend as long in Lórien as you need or want, though."

Permalink Mark Unread

Sigh. "I already haven't, thanks. Look, you're the fucking gate guard who knows where they'll have problems with me, I just got kidnapped to this plane of existence today."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh, you can go most places - do you want me to pull up a map, or a list sorted by something?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Sure."

Permalink Mark Unread

That's not a very helpful reply but the Elf will guess and pull up a map of the multiverse. "I don't know if you have Allspeak yet but I can read it to you if you don't."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don’t know what that - hang on. Did I skip a standard introduction because I showed up visibly maimed and everyone decided to act like I came from Angband?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- I suppose so, usually if you'd been contacted purposefully your whole culture would be getting introduced to multiversal opportunities together."

Permalink Mark Unread

"If there’s a place I can go for that it’s probably a better idea than the world’s worst forest."

Permalink Mark Unread

"There's the integration office in Edda?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"That might be good. I’m sorry I snapped at you, I guess if I had come straight here from Hell I would really have appreciated how you and everyone else have been acting."

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's okay, I'm not upset about it. I can't teleport but I can ask for someone who does to come get you and bring you there."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thanks."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Are you okay to wait twenty minutes for them to finish what they're doing?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Fine."

Permalink Mark Unread

Twenty minutes later another Elf appears on the scene. "Integration office in Edda?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "Apparently."

Permalink Mark Unread

The Elf takes a moment to decide if that counts, exchanges looks with the forest-guard Elf, and then pops over one hop to drop off the passenger at an Integration Office.

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay. He'll go say hello to whoever is on duty there.

Permalink Mark Unread

That's this horse-looking person! "Good day! What are your most urgent needs?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He contemplates this for a moment. "I don't have any needs, literally, at all, although someone I previously spoke to wanted to argue that it counts as a need if you enjoy music and I sometimes enjoy music. Anyway, I got kidnapped here by accident and apparently they say they can't figure out how to get me back to the place I live."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Gosh. Well, what are your most urgent wants?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Uh, hm. A place where I won't be pestered by people who think I should really be somewhere else and the geography is consistent from moment to moment? Some kind of... explanation of where I am and what's going on?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I can get you an apartment and answer most standard questions, but not knowing where you come from my explanation won't be tailored to your context, do you just want the most generic possible one?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I suppose saying I’m from Earth won’t help?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh, that helps a lot, actually, can you also tell me what year it is?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Uhhh... I’m not totally sure if it’s changed since the last time I saw a calendar? I don’t think it’s 2020 yet?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay! So, you're in Vanda Nossëo. It's a big, interdimensional federation, with member states in lots and lots of different worlds, and a lot of those worlds have more than one inhabited planet, too. This world is called Edda, and this planet is called Kallee, and this city is called Skoq. I work for Vanda Nossëo on the federal level. Vanda Nossëo was founded by powerful altruists of several species and worlds, who wanted to explore, learn more about magic and technology, and have everyone working together to make the best possible use of it to bring about universal sapient flourishing. There are some mysteries we still don't understand, like why Earths are common or how humans pop up in worlds that aren't even Earths, for example, and there are some problems we don't know how to solve yet, but there are trillions of people in Vanda Nossëo all working in their own ways toward making the civilization as strong as it can be so we can one day tackle those too."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Uh-huh. How do I... interact with that."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you want to be a citizen of Vanda Nossëo, or just relax while they work on getting you home?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "Does being a citizen involve any responsibilities?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Not breaking the law? But the exact nature of the law will depend on where you live."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...What exactly are 'laws'?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"A law is a rule that is enforced by a government, so, for example, everywhere in Vanda Nossëo, it is illegal to murder people."

Permalink Mark Unread

"What does it mean that it’s enforced by a government?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"People who commit murders are arrested and usually spend some time in prison. Vanda Nossëo prisons are much nicer than any pre-contact Earth prison though."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I don’t know what that means. Maybe I want the version where you explain more."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay, let's imagine a simpler crime, like stealing something from another person. If you reached over and took my ring off my hand and then I said, 'hey, give that back,' and then you decided not to give it back, and instead ran away with it, then if it were just a rule of my workplace that you can't steal, my boss might help me get it back, but since here it's a law not to steal, then if my boss wasn't able to get it back, they could get help from government workers whose job it is specifically to catch thieves and take back what they stole. A law is a rule that is important and common enough that you can get government help if someone breaks it and this causes you a problem."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...What?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...on your Earth, what would happen if you stole something?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He frowns in intense concentration. "...I haven't tried it but I can... speculate...? I think the person I stole from might beat me up? After I got stolen from my friend helped me keep it from happening again? I don't - I don't know but I don't think Congress keeps really careful track of things like that but I guess it does give people food stamps and maybe that's because of theft? I don't know anything about food stamps because I don't eat. I think it was different when I was in France, I think the government would - do different things than you're thinking of. Uh, and I'm not totally confident that I actually know which things actually get people sent there, but Hell exists and I think people at least think you go there for sins like theft and in Hell you might get bathed in acid or thrown into lava or disassembled."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...okay, so, it sounds like you have some atypical-for-most-Earths life experience." says the horse person. "Do you know what a rule is? A law is a kind of rule, and it's a little different from other kinds, but unless following the rules which are also laws sounds like it will be hard for you, I'm not sure the difference is important to understand today."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Maybe? Probably? I don't think I get what following rules has to do with the government helping people."

Permalink Mark Unread

"The government has rules for itself, and one of them is that it will help people who were hurt by anyone breaking one of the rules."

Permalink Mark Unread

He makes a succession of different baffled faces. "...Okay, so, you’re saying it’s okay to hurt people as long as I do it by breaking the rules?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- no... can you tell me what steps you took to get to that idea?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Because if the government will fix it then they’ll be fine? I guess that doesn’t mean I would be fine when the government was done with me."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Most people do not prefer to be in trouble with the government, and most people also don't like having crimes done to them, even if they get help afterwards."

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "So if I broke a law, how would I notice?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Well, you should probably have at least the gist of the laws of anywhere you want to be explained to you. If you break a law someone will probably tell you about it. An innocent mistake won't tend to get you in much trouble, if you were trying to cooperate with the rules around you."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...If the government stopped enforcing laws tomorrow and forgot to warn people, and you broke a law, would you probably be able to figure out that they'd stopped enforcing them?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"It would... probably depend on what law."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay. I think I would like to know what the laws where you would probably notice are and how you would notice."

Permalink Mark Unread

"It would also depend on how I broke it, actually. Because part of enforcement is making sure to find out without waiting to get a report. If I found somebody nobody was expecting home for ages and murdered them, then a government enforcing the law would find out about this, even if nobody saw me. A government that did not enforce the law might not notice. But if I parked my scooter on the front steps of the capital building and the government was not enforcing the law I might not notice the difference between that and the parking robot not having come by yet."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Can I maybe... describe some things I have experience with, in case that helps you figure out what I'm asking?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Sure, go right ahead."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay, so, as an oversimplified model, if you're in Hell, there are things that make the demons angry. If you make the demons angry, they'll probably drag you away from what you were doing and boil you, or if they're not very angry they might just hit you. If you try to fight them when they do those things, they'll do the same things plus some more things. Usually you would learn what makes them angry by doing things and discovering that they're angry. If they're not watching, they'll look in at random times. On the other hand, also as an oversimplified model, in America, there are cops. They come cause problems but I think they're kind of random about it? So if someone is causing a bunch of problems, more problems than having cops around, you could call them, but they might shoot you instead of the person you were hoping they'd deal with. I can't vouch for the accuracy of that part, I never met the cops. What I can vouch for is that Congress doesn't do very much? Like, the whole time I've lived in America, Congress has never come to drag me away to be boiled, and I'm not sure if there even are things they'd care about or if they're just not actually watching. They didn't do it when I got beaten up, they didn't do it to this guy who I kind of suspect was committing lustful sins by himself, and they didn't do it for theft. Apparently what the laws are was so unclear that there were people arguing about it? Like, some people were arguing about whether some human beings are illegal. I think. But people said that America had laws and I'm not sure if they were lying or if they meant something by that. And now you're saying laws are about helping people who got hurt? Or that the government can have to follow them? I don't think I really get what kind of thing you're talking about, I'm not getting - if I do something, then what's the percent chance the government will come hurt me and how will they do that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"How long have you lived in your early-2000s America?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "I dunno, it depends on how you count and I also lost track of time. I don't think it's been more than a few years or less than a month."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay... I'm not from an Earth, but I think Americas are usually more functional than that. I wanna refer you to someone from an Earth who'll be more able to tell if your Earth is weird or if your lens on it is weird. Okay?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Fine? Sure."

Permalink Mark Unread

The horse person swaps out for a human guy. "Hey. She was summarizing so I don't know if I have all the details but 'no human being is illegal' is a political slogan about people entering the country without government permission and being called 'illegal immigrants'."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Well, I didn’t think anyone asked permission for me to be there and Congress still didn’t come drag me away to be tortured."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Congress doesn't directly do any legwork. They argue about what the laws should be and if enough of them agree then the thing they agree on is officially the law, but it's other people's job to see it actually put into practice, and a lot of those people, and a lot of Congresspeople too, are really really bad at their jobs. One way they're bad at their jobs is they guess based on visible ethnicity if somebody's likely to be an illegal immigrant and you look white."

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "Okay."

Permalink Mark Unread

"In Vanda Nossëo, people with important jobs are almost all very good at them. This means that while officially laws in early 2000s America aren't that different, they wind up being implemented and talked about really differently."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Okay. So you’re saying it’s more like Hell?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...there's no torture, Vanda Nossëo doesn't do that literally at all."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...So then when things are illegal, does that mean that anything happens to you if you do them or not?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes. Just, the thing is never torture. Sometimes you have to pay money. Sometimes you just get a warning. Sometimes you get put in jail. Sometimes you get banned from being in whatever place you broke the law in, or near the person you broke the law, uh, at."

Permalink Mark Unread

"And if you decide you don't want to be in jail or you do want to be in whatever place - I guess you just can't decide that because - huh. No, I guess the people who don't like alcohol would be mad at you if you hired the yeerks to keep people in jail. Right?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"The... people who don't like alcohol... yeah, no, we don't use Yeerks for that. Just like, doors, and force fields, and magic."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh. And if you hurt someone the government will try to fix it?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay. I don't think I care about your laws. No offense."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You only care about laws if they're enforced with torture?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Pretty much? If you were torturing people that would suck and I'd try to figure out if I had some kind of angle on getting you to stop."

Permalink Mark Unread

"We're... not torturing people. I think if you don't like torture you should probably help make not-torture work okay for getting people to be decent to each other."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...What does people being decent to each other have to do with laws?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"That's what laws are... for... like not killing people? She said she mentioned the not killing people one?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I thought laws were about things like... theft, murder, adultery, lust, entering America without permission, existing while black, resisting arrest, drugs, mispronouncing things...?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Vanda Nossëo doesn't have laws against existing while black - that's also a police not being good at their jobs thing - or about mispronouncing things, which I think you must have misinterpreted somehow, or lust or adultery, which early 2000s America doesn't have laws about on any Earths I knew about this morning... most parts of Vanda Nossëo have laws against theft, some parts limit who can go into them, all of them forbid murder."

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "I didn't spend that long in America, I know what's allowed in Hell a lot better. But I also don't see how it's not being decent to people for me to go home and live in the park with my friend instead of being trapped in a horrible warped forest. Maybe it is somehow but you know what, I don't see how and I've decided to make a habit of not believing other people about right and wrong."

Permalink Mark Unread

"If that were illegal in some part of Vanda Nossëo, which your Earth isn't since it's newly discovered by us, then it'd be because people wanted the park to not have anybody living in it. I mean, if they didn't let anyone live there. If they just didn't let you there it'd probably be because you weren't allowed in their place in general."

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's possible I don't know what the word 'decent' means but I - " He shakes his head. "I don't know, what does it mean to be decent to people?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Well, uh, I usually start with not murdering or torturing them, and then follow up with letting them have their stuff and decide what to do with it themselves, even if there's a bunch of them and the stuff is a park."

Permalink Mark Unread

"No, I mean English isn't my first language and I was taught it by demons who might have taught it to me wrong on purpose to fuck with me, and the thing you're saying doesn't make sense."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- I have no way to tell what language you're hearing when I talk, because of how the translation magic on me works. Do you want to... look up 'decent' in a dictionary or something?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Sure. Fine."

Permalink Mark Unread

He looks it up. "Conforming with generally accepted standards of respectable or moral behavior," he reads.

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Oh. Fuck. Thank you. Anyway, I don’t think I care about that if there’s no torture involved and I don’t know what this was supposed to be leading up to."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't really have a way to make you care about it but if you break laws you will get in non-torture trouble and this will limit your freedom of movement and resources."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I already have no resources and I'm only here in the first place because I am looking for a place I am allowed to sit that won't get me pestered about how I should be in the horrible forest instead and that also isn't the horrible forest, has a consistent enough geography that it would be even slightly sane to draw a map of it, and doesn't have any torture. I do not care if that involves being chained to a wall. I wouldn't care if you gave me to the yeerks. You can't threaten me with anything you're willing to do."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...okay. I'm going to get you an apartment. You can sit in it." He does some device things and gives him a key card. "Take that moving sidewalk to the green offramp and then elevator up to the seventeenth floor, your room is the Pelican Room, got a picture of a pelican on it."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you." He takes the key card and takes that moving sidewalk and so on to the Pelican Room.

Permalink Mark Unread

The key card, waved in the vicinity of the pelican-adorned door, lets him into a nice little apartment with loosely pelican themed decor, like someone didn't want all the rooms to be the same and started picking random birds after a while.

Permalink Mark Unread

The important thing is that it doesn't belong to anyone who can reasonably pester him to go to Lórien instead. He gets onto the nearest soft surface without even pausing to shut the door or take off his shoes.

Permalink Mark Unread

The hinge is attached to a spring apparatus that makes it close by itself. The room has no comment on his shoes.

Permalink Mark Unread

Meanwhile (a word which here means "not happening at all") in a precognition, Vanda Nossëo's explorers find Hell. It doesn't even slightly resemble any secondhand memories Ristrell picked up, except in that it's also located in a vast cave system. There's a vast tall sprawling city of stone and bone housing a decadent royal court that routinely hosts cannibal feasts (it's... okay? worse than expected? it's something, anyway, because their victims simply cannot die even of being eaten). The city is decorated with sculptures and abstract murals. The murals are painted in human blood. It's not clear that it's ruled by demons; it seems to be an unusually unpleasant human polity.

No, sorry, that's not where they would land. Can't imagine why the last precognition suggested that would happen. When they look into the future again, they see something else.

Vanda Nossëo's explorers find Hell. It doesn't even slightly resemble any secondhand memories Ristrell picked up, except in that it's also located in a vast cave system. There are glowing rocks and strange plants and it is definitely ruled by demons and the only other animals are - well, maybe they were all humans once? Each of them some number of humans? They're warped and terrible and exist only to be injured and broken and remade as a collection of pieces of art catering to some very inhuman sensibility.

No, sorry, that's not where they would land. When they look into the future again, they see something else.

This time, Vanda Nossëo's explorers find Hell. It doesn't even slightly resemble any secondhand memories Ristrell picked up, except in that it's also located in a vast cave system. Instead of sending them on, it traps them. At least some of the people there are lucid enough and friendly enough and educated enough to talk multiverse maps. There are safer places to try to aim for, or so they say, not nearly enough of them but some. There's Earth (not adjacent to Cube) and the Bastion of Peace (not adjacent to Cube, either) and the Dead Republic (likewise) and...

Here's this lovely totalitarian dictatorship on a beautiful desert island archipelago. It's adjacent to Cube and from there they can reach the Dead Republic, which isn't horrible at all, just a whole new world with over ten billion inhabitants for Vanda Nossëo to make contact with, and they know which of the several hells calls itself Purgatory. They have a brief summary of issues escapees tend to have - questions are bad, coming or going; names are fraught at best; they generally won't eat or sleep, sometimes won't drink; they're sometimes genuinely loyal to their demon masters. They think Vanda Nossëo should establish diplomatic relations with New Jerusalem.

New Jerusalem is going to be easy to get along with. It's mostly a vast grassland with a few very big cities. Food is free. Wifi is free. Some limited housing is free. They've dealt with refugees from hells before; they have a residential facility for refugees from the specific one in question. Their major problem is - well, they get all the dead babies. All the dead babies. And on their Earth people have souls from fairly early in pregnancy. But, hey, they've got a bunch of information about all the hells which they're not super interested in declassifying but will admit to having written down.

And incidentally the local magic is great at redirecting incoming teleportation away from private areas, the demons can be destroyed by Disappear magic or temporarily disabled by black holes, and the locals have their own way of going between worlds that seems to mostly or maybe only work in their own neighborhood.

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay. Is there a safe route to New Jerusalem? What is the adjacency layout of this neighborhood?

Permalink Mark Unread

The first thing resembling a safe route goes from Cube to the totalitarian archipelago that is merely a human amount of totalitarian and then to the Dead Republic and then Earth and all the afterlives are adjacent to Earth.

Permalink Mark Unread

Is the archipelago at least in a world with normal enough physics that they can establish a teleport outpost a trillion miles away?

Permalink Mark Unread

It’s not that big. They might be able to put one underwater? Or check if one of the safer worlds is adjacent to somewhere other than Cube.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah, they will once they have a safe-enough route work on figuring out where else this neighborhood touches theirs. They will also put an underwater dome down.

Permalink Mark Unread

And back to the here and now.

There is someone miserable in an apartment. He lies still for hours, and when he gets tired enough that it gets hard to think about math he thinks about coffee instead. He has no idea where they sell it. He has no idea if it’s safe to panhandle here but he’s leaning no, and he has no local money, though maybe they’ll take dollars. Apparently those things were just not as high a priority as telling him he should obey if he wants to be a good person. And also if he doesn’t. Where has he heard that before. (To be fair to the whole idea, his extremely vague recollection is that France might also have been like that and wasn’t awful.)

So, no coffee. And this is the only place he’s sure he can be. And there’s nothing anyone will ever really need from him.

He shaves when he itches too much to keep putting it off (with shaky hands and a naked razor blade but who really cares, right?) and then goes and sits on the balcony in the hope that it will be more bearable than being inside the apartment.

Permalink Mark Unread

There's a lady on the next balcony over. Smoking a cigarette. She raises her eyebrows at him. "You're new."

Permalink Mark Unread

He looks at her. He shrugs.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Lady who had that place before you was standoffish too."

Permalink Mark Unread

He used to have a convenient response to people who got annoyed at him for not talking to them and now he doesn't. Thanks, Missut.

"I've taken a vow of silence," he says, drawing his knees up to his chest. It was supposed to come out very deadpan but he's having a little trouble keeping his voice steady at the moment.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Wow, okay, have fun with that." She takes a drag.

Permalink Mark Unread

He looks at her again and sighs. But he’s not scowling and doesn’t even look very dead inside now.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I didn't take a vow of silence though," she says after a moment. "Hello, my name is Arlene and my daughter resurrected me last week but I don't know why she bothered if she was going to be so inhospitable, all, 'smoking is banned here Mama' and 'you should get your own place Mama' and 'you've missed a lot Mama' and 'Johnny doesn't want to see you Mama'. What gets into a girl that she brings her mama back to send her to live somewhere all by herself without even a cig?"

Permalink Mark Unread

....Shrug??? He looks kind of bewildered about all this. "Did she get you out of Hell or do you not have that here."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Nah, if I got out of Hell I'd be a demon and it'd be a summoning not a resurrection."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I'm so sorry," he says gently.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Being dead's not like anything for normal people." Puff.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I hope that's true and you're not just a copy of someone else who's suffering somewhere."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Wow, do you moonlight teaching people how to give folks nightmares? What a thing to say!"

Permalink Mark Unread

He flinches convulsively and after a moment of horrified staring he curls up very tightly.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Jeepers," she adds after a thoughtful plume of smoke.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ristrell didn't think - Ristrell claimed - he understood Ristrell as claiming

- he thought he remembered understanding Ristrell as claiming -

- but here he is, horrible to listen to. He's just going to bluescreen about that for a minute.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Are you having a seizure over there? I used to have a dog that had seizures. That's another thing that I don't like about all this," ash-tap, "modernity. They won't let you get your pets back, just people. Or you can do it but you have to go to someplace five times as expensive for some reason. It's not like it'd be any harder to bring back a dog than a person."

Permalink Mark Unread

Fuck fuck fuck he’s going through caffeine withdrawal and he usually drinks so much coffee that he literally can’t fall asleep even after multiple days spent awake. His hands aren’t steady enough, and he’s not awake enough, to fix what Missut did.

He isn’t actually sure what "having a seizure" means so at least he’s not tempted to answer. He is kind of tempted to ask what the fuck she’s talking about but he doesn’t.

"I’m sorry," he says, even though probably he shouldn’t say anything.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Have I gotta call the ambulance on you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I don’t have an opinion. I’m so sorry and if there’s some way I can make it up to you I’ll try."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...you sound like you maybe need an ambulance. I hear they're not even expensive nowadays." She fiddles with a device.

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you want me to go away you can just say so."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You got an ears problem too?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Nothing about this conversation makes any sense. Maybe he missed some subtext. He'll just go back inside on the theory that that way he's unlikely to keep bothering her.

Permalink Mark Unread

There is an urgent knock on his door.

Permalink Mark Unread

Fine. Whatever. He opens it, looking extremely done.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Hi!" says a ginger with too many teeth. "We got a call from your neighbor that someone here was possibly having a seizure or a panic attack."

Permalink Mark Unread

He just kind of looks at them blankly because even if he wanted to be helpful that's not a question or a request and he doesn't know what a seizure is and barely has the faintest clue what a panic attack is.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Is there anyone sharing this apartment with you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He gets out of the way of the door in case they feel really invested in learning the answer to this question.

Permalink Mark Unread

...okay, he will go search the apartment. "Sir, do you think I might have been called for you?" he asks when he discovers the place empty.

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "Sounds plausible."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...would you like me to heal you or should I mark down that it was a false alarm?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't have an opinion. If you wanted to be very nice to me for some reason you could tell me what 'seizure' and 'panic attack' mean."

Permalink Mark Unread

"A seizure is when electrical connections in the brain are disrupted - it can cause strange movements or lapses of consciousness. A panic attack is when an anxiety reaction like shortness of breath spirals out of control and makes people feel like they might be dying."

Permalink Mark Unread

"If I ever think I'm dying I won't react by grimly having no opinion about it. Are you totally sure brains are supposed to have electrical connections in the first place."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...yes, they are, for most people."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay. Is there anything else I can do for you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Can I get your thumbprint here affirming that you don't need healing?" He proffers a device.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Huh?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- would you push the pad of your thumb on here, to say that it's okay that I am not healing you, so I can show my boss?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...If you want but why couldn’t you just grab my thumb and put it there if you found me passed out from ODing on heroin?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Because that would be fucked up? This is just to make sure you understand and are making an intentional choice."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don’t understand anything and am just doing what I’m told."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay, I can explain then. Your neighbor called me because they thought you might need healing. Does that part make sense?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"No."

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"Oh boy. Uh. I am an emergency response healer. My job is to show up when someone might be having a medical problem, and help them with it, or take them to a hospital if I can't help. Ordinary people like your neighbor help out people like me with doing our jobs, by letting us know when to show up. Does that make sense."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I understood all of those words, probably, unless I was taught incorrect meanings for them or otherwise ended up wrong about understanding."

Permalink Mark Unread

"And I showed up here today, to help you, but you don't need me. Right?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I also understood all of those words."

Permalink Mark Unread

"And part of how my organization makes sure that people like me are doing our jobs is, when someone turns out not to need or not to want healing, we ask for their thumbprint. - you don't have to give me your thumbprint or else be healed, to be clear, that's not a requirement, but, that's why I'm asking, I get more questions if I can't get the print."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You can have it, I just still have no idea why anyone would claim to think I needed healing in the first place or why you decided I didn’t."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know your neighbor but most people don't want those around them to go without medical attention they need. You don't seem to be having any medical problems or to want help with any I can't see but I can heal you if you want."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Are you sure my neighbor didn't summon you here because I hurt her and she wants someone to deal with me."

Permalink Mark Unread

"If she was trying to do that she did a very bad job of explaining it but I can knock on her door too if you're worried about her."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't have an opinion about whether you should do that."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...okay."

Permalink Mark Unread

Anyway. Thumbprint. Since that is the thing this person wants.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thanks. Do you... need... anything?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"As far as I know I'm incapable of ceasing to exist so not really but there's no reason I would ever need my judgment intact again so now seems like an okay time to make questionable choices about drugs?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't have any drugs but you should get a tripsitter if you want to start experimenting with them."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know how to do that."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Usually you'd ask a friend."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't have any friends here."

Permalink Mark Unread

"That sounds like a problem and I don't know how you should solve it."

Permalink Mark Unread

He laughs bitterly. "Yep."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I could get you a social worker?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I have no opinion about whether you should do that."

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"I'm gonna get you a social worker. One should be by in the next half an hour or so."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Okay."

In half an hour or so he'll be lying miserably in bed nursing two different simultaneous headaches.

Permalink Mark Unread

Knock knock.

Permalink Mark Unread

He opens the door.

Permalink Mark Unread

Lanky dark lady with beads in her hair. "Hello. My name is Nocawe. Emergency services told my department there'd been a false alarm here but that they suspected you'd benefit from being connected to services of some kind; that's my job."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay." He does really look like he'd benefit from services of some kind.

Permalink Mark Unread

"May I have your permission to access records about you in applicable Vanda Nossëo systems?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Okay."

Permalink Mark Unread

She does device things. She says, "There's no name in the system. Do you have a name you want to use?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Wince. "No."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay. You're my thirty-third client so I might refer to you as 33 if that won't bother you."

Permalink Mark Unread

That gets a tiny, startled smile. "I don’t have an opinion about what you call me."

Permalink Mark Unread

"The records I've pulled up say that you appeared via uncontrolled teleportation, consistent with a portalsnake, in the Yeerk polity of Tide in Cube, which called in a specialist for finding a route to your previous universe and remanded you to a Lórien principally dedicated to Melkor victims in Elentári, being as you seemed to have a substantially similar history, having been in 'Hell'?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Does that sound like what you remember?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don’t remember if anyone mentioned 'Tide' or 'Elentári'."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Gotcha. Tide is the one run by Sovereign Ristrell."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I might have met her, if I didn’t just imagine that."

Permalink Mark Unread

"The records say you did, at least. Do you often have experiences that turn out not to have happened in reality if you try to corroborate them, or are you just concerned about it anyway?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Well, you know, maybe I just imagined having those experiences," he says wryly. He wanders back over to the bed and flops onto it.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you sometimes attempt to corroborate an experience and discover evidence that contradicts your memory?" she tries.

Permalink Mark Unread

"That’s what I remember!" he says brightly.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Ah-huh. Okay. And you're - not quite indestructible but divorced from human physical needs?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I seem to eventually heal from everything I don't go out of my way to avoid healing from."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Does this leave you still experiencing any discomfort when deprived of air, water, food...?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Wow, rude. But Ristrell already knows everything anyway. "Yes."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I can set you up with a service that will deliver meals here to you at regular times; would that work for you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I don't eat, thank you. And I would rather have coffee anyway."

Permalink Mark Unread

"May I ask why you don't eat if it's uncomfortable not to?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I don't think you want to know and I don't think I want to tell you."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay. Do you want help with getting or making coffee?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don’t think I have any local money unless you take dollars."

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you become a citizen of Vanda Nossëo, you can get paid money every couple of weeks just for existing, and if you don't want to be a citizen, you're still eligible for charity."

Permalink Mark Unread

He tenses up. "...I think maybe I’m not obedient enough for that."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...can you elaborate on that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "I think someone said something about being a citizen but I had a question and then they had a bunch of questions for me instead and then they lectured me about how it’s right to obey the rightful authorities and also they’ll try to hurt me if I don’t but supposedly they don’t have the stomach to do more than restrain me and I... don’t really understand anything anyone said but maybe it bothered them that I didn’t pretend to care? And they didn’t say anything else about being a citizen or answer the questions I went to them with in the first place. I’m not sorry and I won’t obey anyone ever again even if that means I’m not allowed to know what Allspeak is or have any money."

Permalink Mark Unread

"It sounds like whatever conversations you've had about that haven't been very successful at communicating with you."

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "It wouldn’t surprise me if I just don’t understand anything. I’m already pretty sure I was taught most of the languages I speak intentionally badly by demons."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Wow. Uh, is there a language you're pretty sure you've got learned correctly?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He thinks about it and tries to call to mind the first language he ever learned, one he hasn’t spoken in lifetimes. With effort he drags enough words to answer from the depths of his memory.

"A long time ago, but not anymore."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you think you'd benefit from a language class that would aim to get you conversant in one of the most popular Vanda Nossëo languages, maybe one you haven't studied before to get a fresh start?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He flinches. "...Probably. Maybe if it doesn’t involve learning definitions in words in something I already know. I would have thought Ristrell would have caught anything really glaring but she also didn’t think I would hurt people just by talking to them."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do... you think you will hurt people just by talking to them? Why?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"It sounded like I gave my neighbor nightmares," he says in a hollow voice as though this is among the most shameful things he can imagine.

Permalink Mark Unread

"That may have been hyperbole..."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Oh."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Even if it wasn't, I'm not sure this level of guilt about it is - adaptive, for you."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Huh?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't think it helps you, or your neighbor, or future people you might meet, for you to react this way to the idea of having introduced someone to an idea that they then had nightmares about."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...If you care so much what I do, why would you go about changing it like that? Do the yeerks just hate the inside of my head too much to give me to them and make me act however you're hoping I'll act?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I am confused by that as a response to what I said. Can you break down your thought process into smaller steps?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"It sounds like you want me to act in ways that help people. And I don't see why you'd try to achieve that by telling me things."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh. I don't think you're under any obligation to go out of your way to help people. I am concerned about your mental health. Having a Yeerk pilot you through behaving in any particular way would probably not improve your mental health, though I guess it's not out of the question."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't think I know what 'mental health' is or why you care about it."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Mental health is the parts of your brain working together in a way that keeps your mood stable, your beliefs in functional contact with objective reality, and your mind able to cooperate with your goals and responsibilities."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I don't really see why you want me to have good mental health when you could just cut all of those things off from my behavior."

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's sort of folded in to the rest of my job, not just making you easy for other people to be around but making you easy for you to be around, insofar as that's possible. I'm concerned for your well-being."

Permalink Mark Unread

Sigh. "...Should I give you a list of my preferences since it's not like you can't get them all anyway if you're really just here to hurt me."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You can if you want to but that isn't usually how I relate to clients."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You don't usually relate to clients by getting a list of their preferences or you don't usually relate to your clients by having their minds read against their will?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- both."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Okay."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I can probably find a language class for you that starts from presumed zero fluency in any starting language. The most commonly spoken languages in the connected multiverse are English, Sindarin, and Orcish."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I speak English already. I think. I don't think I speak any of the others."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay, so not English. I can try to find you a class in one of the others. They will probably involve meeting the other people in the class and spending hours at a stretch learning vocabulary by having objects pointed out and actions demonstrated. Is that going to be okay?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He sobs just once. "I've made it through a lot of languages already and I can do one more."

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you will spend a lot of the class in distress, I don't recommend starting it right away."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Oh. Do you not want me to be in distress or do you not want me to be in distress in public?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't want you to be in distress, the teachers and other students at such classes probably also don't want that, I don't think you will learn as well in distress, there are probably priorities other than learning Sindarin if you're very easily perturbed since you can hold an English conversation all right."

Permalink Mark Unread

Can he, though.

"Okay. Whatever you want."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Well, right now I don't know whether you think you'd be in distress during a class if you started one today."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think I’ll be in distress constantly until I can go home and then I’ll be in distress most of the time."

Permalink Mark Unread

"That makes sense. So, in light of that, my plan is to arrange to be notified at once if they find a way to your world, get you couriered home right away, and then let you cope with everything at your own pace while your world has a more normal first contact experience."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Really? They’re not going to complain about me not acting decent and going where I’m not wanted?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Who?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "I thought the person I talked to earlier who seemed to be worried about how I'm not obedient enough thought it was bad for me to live where I used to live because I didn’t ask permission."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know who you were talking before or how the conversation got to that point. You were - squatting? Homeless?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"In a park but apparently it’s - " it’s so hard to say and that’s stupid because they already know, it won’t help. "Apparently it matters that - I mean, I don’t know anything, I probably understood wrong - but I thought - that he said - that being in America without permission is second to murder and torture - "

And he doesn’t, amazingly enough, even feel slightly tempted to feel guilty. Just exhausted and judgmental and terrified and somewhere in there a little bit sad.

Permalink Mark Unread

"That sounds like a miscommunication of some kind, yes. It's possible that your America will take issue with it. Vanda Nossëo isn't going to get you in trouble for living in a park in your America."

Permalink Mark Unread

He whines annoyedly and runs a hand over his face. "I guess that's better than the alternative."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Are there other confusions I could maybe clear up for you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"If I knew what I was confused about more specifically than 'I don't know, everything', I wouldn't have half as many problems as I do."

Permalink Mark Unread

"That makes sense. Do you have any worries about spending, say, the next week, in this apartment?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I mean. I don't expect to like it? It doesn't have coffee in it. But I'm used to being stuck in places I don't want to be and it really improves on most of the other times I've had to just lie down somewhere and wish I didn't exist. I wish the yeerks wanted me instead but, I mean, I wouldn't want to live in my head either if I had a choice."

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you would like to host a Yeerk you can submit an application. I can help you with it if you prefer. I admit I'm not clear on how this would help - people sometimes want them if they're lonely, or have executive dysfunction..."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know what executive dysfunction is. I'm lonely, I'm tired, I'm tired of being completely useless but that doesn't make me capable of being useful, I'm bored, and no one wants to tell me how to interact with society - probably because it's complicated and hard and society doesn't really benefit from interacting with me, it's better for everyone if I just lie down and never do anything again, except that it's a waste of space - but, man, I don't know, someone who has things they want to do being able to do those things because of me sounds kind of okay. If I can't do anything I can't do anything wrong. And, you know, I can't figure out how to get myself some fucking coffee in this fucking place and it sucks and I bet a Yeerk who was invested in my body being awake could do it. And maybe watching them wouldn't suck. And there wouldn't be all this... pretending like I'm supposed to make choices or something, I am so tired of being given enough rope to hang myself. I am so tired of misunderstandings, and at least I can't have any more of those if someone is reading my mind all the time. Not that I'd know everything but wouldn't it be a relief to only be wrong because I'm being deliberately lied to and someone is getting something out of it. But none of that matters because if they wanted me they could have said so instead of sending me to the horrible forest."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I'm going to get some coffee delivered here. Right now. How do you take it?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Black. ...Thank you."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You're welcome." She does device things. "It'll be here in two minutes. Now, you seem to have a lot of misunderstandings. It seems plausible to me that you misunderstood something the Yeerks said or did as saying that you were an unsuitable host. It's possible that you are, but it seems likely that they didn't actually mean to tell you so at the time. If it sounds appealing, you can submit an application."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay. It sounds less unappealing than everything else I can think of to do."

Permalink Mark Unread

"When going home is possible are you going to want to leave any Yeerk you're matched with behind and go home?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Depends on if they suck less than that and if my friend is worried."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay." She pulls up the Tide application form. "Do you want me to fill this in by asking you questions or do you prefer to fill it in and get clarification as needed?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I don't have an opinion? No, I do. I bet if you're filling it out you'll understand it better and I won't know when I need clarification."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay. Well, the first field is 'name', I'll put, uh, 'not applicable'..." There's a tap at the door. She gets up and goes to get his coffee from the delivery robot and hands it to him.

Permalink Mark Unread

Coffee!!! He offers her the pathetically grateful and beatifically innocent smile he uses on people who give him food he can't eat when he's panhandling, which fades into genuine excited grinning at finally having coffee. He's already drinking it before it occurs to him that he could totally just say thanks out loud. Oh, well, now his mouth is otherwise occupied.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's hot but not scalding and very high quality.

Nocawe fills in some forms, takes a picture of him. "It asks how many hours per typical day you would want to be in control of your body, at a guess."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...That depends on if I somehow end up with something to do. Or if they count sleep, probably I can sleep if they drug me. I don't know, are there things I'm not thinking of that I'd want that for?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"There are common things people in general want that for but it's possible that you are not one of them. You might want to, say, visit your friend while operating your own body?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh. ...I bet he'd really love an apartment. Then he could stop having me hang out not being asleep. I've just kind of been assuming since apartments are really easy to get here that if I could go there then I wouldn't need to do that. I could probably tell him about the situation anyway. Only I don't know anything about the situation. I could tell him after I disappeared I was miraculously healed, I guess."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You could. Some people wouldn't want their Yeerk having this conversation with them."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Having it like saying anything or having it like hearing it?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"The first thing. Most people with Yeerks in the first place wouldn't mind the second thing."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I guess I might as well tell Pete I'm okay myself. Not really okay. I might as well tell him the things that make it sound like I'm okay."

Permalink Mark Unread

She fills in the section of the form. "It wants to know if you have any valuable skills - examples given are languages you know, a nice singing voice, steady hands, magical powers, various educational attainments..."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know how good I am at any of my languages. I have steady hands if I haven't just drunk a lot of coffee or just not drunk any coffee for too long. I have the magical power that no matter how bad things get I cannot fucking stop and I, uh, I can... recite the Lord's Prayer in Latin, probably? Unless I'm wrong about that. I'm really educated but I'm not sure that's a good thing."

Permalink Mark Unread

"What are the languages?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's hard to remember. If you say things I can tell you if I can understand them. There are just... a lot of them. I'm honestly really rusty on half of them."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay, can you name five?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Um, I'm not promising I have the names right, but, uh, English, English - the other English - I mean - I don't know, it's just different - it's the one that goes like this - never mind. Uh... Fr...ench? Maybe it's French? Latin. Classic Maya. Cantonese. The one that goes like this. The one that goes like 'I speak more than five languages.'"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- I can't actually hear the difference because I'm using Allspeak. English French Latin Maya Cantonese and others is probably sufficient for the form."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you have preferences about what sort of Yeerk you'd host - what they'd spend time doing, what they'd be like as a person?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He stares into the empty cup that once contained coffee and breathes evenly.

"...I don't want them to be cruel about what I've done, even though I've - I was - I don't actually know if it's true that Hell is a place of punishment. Maybe we just go there because God likes it when people suffer. But I don't know that it isn't. And I think - I think I'm not a good person, at all, and I - I just don't want them to be cruel about it. Or - I don't want them to - is there a separate section for telling them how much it sucks to be me or should I talk about that here?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm mentioning in the 'other information' part that you may be - difficult to take psychological care of - and can add other things in that section."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay. How picky can I be?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"There are a lot of Yeerks, but there are also a lot of people who want to be hosts. I think you get something of a leg up in matching by not wanting much time to yourself, though. It's a tradeoff between likelihood of getting a match and the match if you get one being very good."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Is there a way to list things as tiebreakers in case there are two that want me?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I can write it in."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think I'd like it if they liked spending time around flowers and in areas that have fixed geography instead of changing all the time. I don't know if there are things that are - important? Like, ending Hell is important, but I can't help with that. Ending Angband is also important but apparently that's solved. If there are other things that are important like that and someone needs a pair of hands to work on them, that seems important. Uh. Tautologically. They should definitely have at least one of my languages already, so they can tell about how off I am - I think I had the wrong meaning for 'decent' and I don't know how many other meanings I have wrong and don't know it yet - and it'd be cool if they have other languages that I don't have. I think I'd kind of like to hear myself speaking something I don't know yet. Maybe I'd pick it up and maybe I wouldn't, I don't know. The only thing in my head that doesn't totally suck is math so maybe if they think math is cool they'll like me better than if they don't like literally anything in my head. I don't want them to pick me if they think it sounds horrible, I want them to be happy about it or just turn me down. I don't eat and that's probably a demonic plot somehow but I don't and if they're bothered about that I don't think it will work out. I like the color green and the kinda shit you get on Spotify or YouTube labeled 'three hours of the most relaxing violin' or 'beautiful emotional piano music'." He copies Pete's slightly mocking intonation very well but did not see the jazz hands and therefore cannot include them in his impression. "Oh, you know what, I bet this is the wrong part of the form for it but if they don't like anything about me they can change it, I know the trick for that now and I can be taller or whatever. Or if they really want to find out what it feels like to get injured in some way for some reason and then heal really fast, I guess that might be fine."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- I'm not sure that will matter since the world the Yeerks are from also has shapeshifting technology but if I see a spot for it I'll put it in."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...If their shapeshifting is faster or - okay, no shapeshifting until I've talked to Pete. After that, whatever. Just don't turn me into a completely immobile sphere of uniform torment and then abandon me."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I... don't think I need to specify that."

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's nice that the Yeerks are nice. It would really suck if they weren't."

Permalink Mark Unread

"They're not all nice but I don't think they've ever gone for the - immobile sphere thing."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Not nice how?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"They used to just kind of - take people, instead of having applications or even just asking first."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh, okay." Yeah, that doesn't really make the top ten worst things he can think of, though it does sound kind of bad. "Anyway, what's next?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you want to talk to prospective Yeerks before letting them in your head?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "Okay."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- it's phrased like it's more convenient if you don't care but they will accommodate it if you do. Is there anything you'd want to ask one?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I can’t think of anything."

Permalink Mark Unread

Type type. "What kind of accommodations will you want during periods of time when your Yeerk has to leave to refresh itself in its pool?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Someplace I'm allowed to be that has a fixed layout. This place is fine. How much do they do that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Once every three days for an hour or two, usually. You keep bringing up fixed layouts?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"They sent me to a horrible forest where everything changed all the time!"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- a Lórien?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think most people like them but it's understandable that you wouldn't care for it. I can mention that you do not like Lóriens."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Anything else that should go on here?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "I guess you should warn them I can’t sleep and sometimes I have... memories... my friend thought they might be flashbacks but I couldn’t ask any clarifying questions and he didn’t explain much so I don’t know if that’s the word. And that I don’t care about being decent to people."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- you mentioned 'decent' was one of the words you thought you'd perhaps learned wrong? Are you physically incapable of sleep, do you not want to sleep, or do you just fail when you try because you never need it enough to make you pass out?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I wish I could sleep but I usually can’t and when I do I have a nightmare and wake right up. I just learned today that 'decent' means conforming with generally accepted standards and I didn’t realize it didn’t... mean anything beyond what other people think, I guess."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh. That sounds right to me, yes... you aren't interested in doing what's generally accepted? Howso?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Like when people say there’s a special place in Hell for - it doesn’t really matter who - I don’t care if they’re happy about it or if they’d be angry if I put a stop to it."

Permalink Mark Unread

"So when you say you don't care what's decent you mean - that you are prepared to ignore the feelings of people who want others to go to Hell?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I mean I'm prepared to ignore... any time someone says anything about being decent? I was going to see if I could end Hell, and I was probably never going to manage it and now I guess you're going to do that instead, and besides that I want coffee and to not be tortured very much and to be useful if there are any more places like Hell to end, and I maybe want a Yeerk to want me or at least don't want them not to, and if I think of any more things I want I don't think I'll care if anyone else approves."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay... I'm not really sure how to include that in the form. You know if your Yeerk doesn't want to let you do something they will be able to stop you, at least in the moment, right? You can complain afterwards when they go into the pool or specify that you want to be around telepaths routinely so they can get forced out faster than that if you need it but it will be of at least short term practical import if they don't approve."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yep. They can do whatever they want. I'm just not offering - caring why they say they're in the right? Or paying attention to it, especially in advance. Or trying to... think about all the things that people don't approve of and deliberately change around how I... look, have you ever been punished really badly and learned to change your behavior because of it?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Perhaps not in the way you mean."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay. Well, I obviously can't actually get away with doing things society disapproves of, and I'd rather that be because it just doesn't happen than because I get repeatedly hurt until I remember to pay careful attention to whether I'm doing yet another thing people don't like and have a flashback-or-whatever-they're-called any time I get too close to doing something kind of similar for the rest of eternity. They can do whatever they want and I will not help."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...okay. I think I understand but please tell me if I say anything that sounds like I don't so we can clear it up. Flashback is a real word and sounds like the right one for what you describe."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay."

Permalink Mark Unread

"This application looks done to me, do you want to read it over to see?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Sure. That sounds okay."

Permalink Mark Unread

She passes the tablet over to him - she has a chiplock but isn't using it for this.

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Thanks."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You're welcome. If that looks right you can poke that green box there and it'll submit."

Permalink Mark Unread

He pokes that green box there.

Permalink Mark Unread

It submits. "I'll get the followup response when they've had a chance to look at it. Is there anything else I can help you with until then, including by leaving you alone?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He looks at her hungrily. Metaphorically hungrily. "Are they going to answer fast enough that there's no point in learning how you get coffee delivered?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- I'd expect this to take at least a few hours and maybe all day. The building has a commissary on the second floor. You can go in person, if you don't want a computer to order a delivery robot. Would you like me to go with you and show you how you'd do that, or leave you this tablet and show you how to use that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I can go in person? That’s allowed?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes... can you tell me why that wasn't your presumption?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"People seem like they really, really want me to go to the forest instead of basically everywhere else, probably because I’m dirty and poor and human. And I don’t think I can actually buy coffee there because I don’t have any money."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh, the commissary in particular is free, it's not a fully-featured restaurant with staff it'd need to pay, just a replicator and some nonmagical robots. I think people suggesting you go to the forest probably expected it would help you feel better. It's usually very good for Angband victims."

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "Maybe. I - would like to learn how to get coffee from the commissary?'

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay. In person?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah."

Permalink Mark Unread

She gets up and holds the door into the hallway for him.

Permalink Mark Unread

Walk walk walk.

Permalink Mark Unread

Elevator. Commissary. It's a little alcove with robots of various sizes hanging out on shelves and a big replicator. "Black coffee," she says to the replicator. It produces a cup of black coffee.

Permalink Mark Unread

"What languages does it know?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Most of them. English will work fine."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you." He smiles his panhandling smile again. It’s at least half sincere this time.

Permalink Mark Unread

"You're welcome." She offers him the coffee.

Permalink Mark Unread

He drinks it and immediately orders another cup.

"So. What else does everyone know how to do around here?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Hmmmm... take the bus, call emergency services, use the internet."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don’t know how to do any of those."

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you're up for it I can show you how."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes, please."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you care which is first?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay. Let's go back to your room and I can show you the internet and emergency services both there."

Permalink Mark Unread

Nod nod. He'll follow her.

Permalink Mark Unread

On the tablet she can demonstrate navigating to Wikipedia and Summary Bank and Gimbuk and Shortform and other popular websites.

Permalink Mark Unread

He doesn’t really have questions about that.

Permalink Mark Unread

And here is how to use the tablet to alert emergency services that you need something at your location.

Permalink Mark Unread

"When are you supposed to do that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you witness or are a victim of a crime, if there is a fire or other disaster that might get really bad if somebody doesn't contain it, if you or somebody around you needs medical attention."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Okay. Do you get in trouble if you tell them you think someone needs medical attention or committed a crime and you’re wrong?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"No, you don't get in trouble. If you make multiple deliberate prank calls you will but an accident, no."

Permalink Mark Unread

"And if I’m wrong the other way?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you don't call when a call would be indicated? Uh, if you are committing a crime that will get you in trouble but I don't think you separately get in trouble for not calling emergency services."

Permalink Mark Unread

Nod. "Can they fix my neighbor’s nightmares if she calls them?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"That's not an emergency exactly, but she can get help if she asks."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Good. I really don’t want to have ruined - hey, can I get help with that too?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Help with nightmares?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah. And getting to sleep. It just really sucks to be awake all the time."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...ironically a standard fix for nightmares is asking the god who runs Lóriens. But I can try to get you an appointment with a subtle artist instead."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I’m sure they’re a very nice god, it didn't seem like the forest was evil or anything." Shrug. "If there doesn't end up being a Yeerk with other plans, maybe."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'll at least get you on a waiting list. Hopefully a Yeerk will be willing to keep your medical appointments."

Permalink Mark Unread

"If they want something else that's fine. What's a subtle artist?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Subtle artists are like magical psychologists. There aren't very many real ones but some people get the power applied in a different way so that they can help meet demand. They can among other things block nightmares from happening pretty easily."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think I might not know enough about nonmagical psychologists for that to be a helpful thing to say?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"They're like doctors but for mental health in particular."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...That sounds, uh, useful."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes. I wasn't sure you'd be receptive to the idea but you should probably at least talk to one long enough to deal with the nightmares and see what they think of the rest of your issues."

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "Okay. Which things are issues?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"The flashbacks, the - learned helplessness, though maybe that's not as bad as I first thought - I'm not actually a psychologist, I can do some forms of therapy but for more ordinary problems than having been in Hell."

Permalink Mark Unread

"It sounds really optimistic to say it’s not a very ordinary problem."

Permalink Mark Unread

"It might be common but what I mean is that I talk people through their feelings about losing child custody or getting a divorce or recovering from alcoholism. Mundane problems."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Hmm. - What’s learned helplessness?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"When you have a lot of experiences where trying to do something has no results or bad results and give up on doing things."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I guess that does happen a lot."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Are you up for learning how to take the bus now?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I guess." He curls up a bit.

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's also okay if you aren't ready."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't have a... set of steps in mind for becoming ready for things?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I am imagining this has been a long day for you and you might benefit from some time to rest or be alone with your thoughts or look around on the Internet."

Permalink Mark Unread

He stares at her in stunned silence as he attempts to process this absolutely mindblowing concept.

Permalink Mark Unread

She waits patiently.

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Benefit how?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Approach a new task with more equanimity? Retain information better? Experience it as more pleasant?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He nods slowly and looks away and murmurs, "And notice things. And only see things that are really there. Right?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- perhaps, if that's something that often troubles you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "I don't really know. I think I get pretty bad at those things once I've been up long enough to copy about this much text by hand without any coffee or sleep or breaks." He gestures to indicate the height of the stacked pages that would constitute the said amount of text. "I don't know what that is in days, I only did that in a cave where the light never changed."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Ah. I don't have a good guess. - there is a magic song that can put people to sleep. Would you like me to find it for you? It won't help with nightmares but even sleep with nightmares can be restful."

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "I guess. Okay."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'll find it and you can press play if you decide you want to, once I've gone. Probably while on the bed or at least the sofa." She looks it up on the tablet, points out the button that would make it go.

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Okay."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'll come back tomorrow if I don't hear from you, but that tablet - it's yours, I give one to all my social work clients - has my contact on the home screen, the pink icon."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you. How do I know if the Yeerks have said anything?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'll let you know tomorrow if I've heard back then, and so on for successive days."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you. Do you... never mind. Thank you. You're... really kind." Or at least he's not really evaluating the likelihood that she's secretly plotting anything because obviously he's going to end up doing and believing whatever these people want him to.

Permalink Mark Unread

She smiles warmly. "I do my best. I hope you get some good rest."

And she lets herself out.

Permalink Mark Unread

He doesn't really, though since it's so easy and convenient and fast to press the have-horrible-nightmares button he does it three times. He wakes up each time terrified and not sure where he is and eventually gives up and goes to the commissary for yet more coffee and figures out how to use the internet for music and games. It's kind of amazing how many hours can pass almost unnoticed with browser games.

Permalink Mark Unread

So many! Browser games are super good at eating many hours!

Nocawe is back the next morning, local time. Knock knock.

Permalink Mark Unread

He answers the door promptly, smiling, and stretches while he’s up.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Hi! You're looking better," says Nocawe.

Permalink Mark Unread

He smiles more. He shrugs. "I guess."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Two bits of news. One, they've finally got a stable route to your Earth pinned down."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Have they ended Hell yet?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Apparently there are several different Hells and they are trying to get oriented before they go in spells blazing - there isn't a single lynchpin entity they can annihilate - but a lot of spare capacity is being diverted there, half my coworkers are on standby to supplement people from someplace called New Jerusalem with evacuees and there was an item in the news about reduced precog access as they figure out a way to navigate it safely."

Permalink Mark Unread

Stare. Slightly hysterical quiet little giggle. "Several."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Nasty shock, yes. It's a whole interconnected pile of worlds, I don't have a complete picture from the public announcements, but it sounded like a mess. They are absolutely on it though."

Permalink Mark Unread

He nods slowly. "Several," he says again. "Um. Is there anything I should be doing?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- I don't think so, or at least no one told me if they need you for anything. Do you have some reason to think you have an exceptional perspective on the situation anyone else from the same Hell wouldn't?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "Not really."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Then no, I don't think there's anything you should be doing. The second bit of news is that Tide has matched you with a Yeerk."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Really?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- yes. Why is that so surprising?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't think it's very comfortable to live in my body or think my thoughts?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's possible it won't stick, if it's - physically painful or something - I don't think Yeerks are usually that bothered by host thoughts, or it would have been much more difficult for them to operate by kidnapping people back when that was standard."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Hm." Shrug. "So, who is it?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Their name is Ashkon. They want to study magic music - like the sleep song."

Permalink Mark Unread

This delights him so much he doesn’t have canned body language for it and stands frozen grinning for a moment before figuring pulling his hair is the least wrong of the ways he knows of reacting to feelings that strong.

"Why would anything that nice happen to me?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- I think you have a lot to offer a Yeerk! You're available for much larger chunks of time than most voluntary hosts and you need less maintenance and quid pro quo. Ashkon's next best option would probably be someone who gave them much less time to work on music."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Huh. Okay. What do I do about that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you want to go meet Ashkon I can conduct you there on the bus, it'll double as a bus use lesson."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...That sounds like the kind of thing that might be a good idea?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"All right. Are you ready now or do you want a few minutes to take a shower, drink coffee, finish reading something online, anything like that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...How do I shower here?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"There's a bathroom in these apartments, over here." She leads him to a door beyond which is a bathroom, weirdly fancy for a free lodging but not unrecognizable by American standards, and it's equipped with some no-name unscented soap and shampoo.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don’t suppose there’s also a free change of clothes that I’ve been overlooking?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"The replicator at the commissary can also do clothes but you will have to let it scan you for your size."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I guess I'm probably going to keep you waiting for a minute, then? Sorry, you can, uh, use any of my stuff if you want?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- thank you but I'm fine. I'll come back in an hour?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Sure."

In an hour he's clean and dressed in whatever the replicator thinks he should wear and more caffeinated and playing a tile-matching game with monsters.

Permalink Mark Unread

The replicator's default outfit for humans is a blue t-shirt and loose black yoga pants and fuzzy moccasins.

Nocawe returns when expected. "Hi! All set?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Why is it so hard to tear himself away from playing games? It’s ridiculous.

"I guess so."

Permalink Mark Unread

She leads him out of the building and to the nearest bus stop. She can show him how to pull up bus maps and schedules on his tablet. "We're here," point, "and we're going there," point, "so we'll take the local line to the city hub, here, and then switch to the Coaster line which will go through these two worlds to land us in Cube. Then we'll get on the Gleet line to get to Tide, where you can meet Ashkon."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Okay." He’s still kind of cringing a little.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Is there something confusing about that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "I don’t know. I don’t think I have questions yet."

Permalink Mark Unread

"It is a lot of buses, there are so many places people might want to go that you can't have a much simpler system. This app will calculate a route for you and there are competing versions if you don't like this one. I'll be with you the whole way."

Permalink Mark Unread

He nods. He'll just... do exactly and only the set of things he's prompted to do and otherwise kind of stare vacantly.

Permalink Mark Unread

The bus rides are short, since the travel between worlds itself takes no time at all and the vehicles are designed for swift loading and unloading. It actually takes more time to get through the hub stations to the correct next lines. After less than fifteen minutes they're in Tide.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, that's not horrible. He considers thanking Nocawe but can't seem to make himself say anything.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you need a few minutes?" she asks, pointing at an unoccupied bench near a potted plant.

Permalink Mark Unread

How does she come up with all these mind-blowing ideas???

He sits near the potted plant. He looks at the potted plant and not at anything else.

Permalink Mark Unread

The potted plant sits there greenly.

Permalink Mark Unread

He considers commenting on how nice it is to get to see plants again. That might give people nightmares, though.

"Thank you. I'm fine," he says, getting back up.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay. Ashkon will be in the pool, that's this way." There are signs.

Permalink Mark Unread

There are signs but also he's nervous. "After you."

Permalink Mark Unread

She will lead the way.

The Pool is in a huge room, more like an airplane hangar than like a human swimming pool. It's dark and sludgy in there and it's hard to see the Yeerks. There are a bunch of piers for people to get ducked down close to the liquid so their Yeerks can go in and out, and baskets of hair ties and hairnets available for people who need those to avoid their hair dangling into the gloop.

Permalink Mark Unread

Why did it have to be sludgy. And why did it have to be big. How is he supposed to interact with this and why did it have to be sludgy.

He's pretty sure the part of him that recoils from all this in horror is also the part of him that feels that way about literally everything and just wants eternal dreamless sleep. He makes himself breathe evenly and go wherever Nocawe points him.

Seriously, though, why couldn't they be ominous dark clouds or totally incorporeal or beautiful flower necklaces or literally any other form factor.

Permalink Mark Unread

Nocawe follows instructions on her device to lead him to a booth around the periphery of the Pool. "My client here is supposed to meet with an Ashkon 1159."

"Of course! Inside or outside?"

Nocawe looks consideringly at her client. "Do you think it will be least stressful to go straight to having Ashkon in your head, or to have a written conversation with him first, or to talk to him while someone else hosts him temporarily?"

Permalink Mark Unread

How is he supposed to answer that! Okay. Okay, the most important thing here is to breathe evenly and look collected and in control.

"I have no idea. If I end up doing this ten more times I'm sure I'll have opinions by then but also if that happened I'm sure none of the options would be stressful at all so that's kind of unfair of reality, huh?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not sure what you mean," says Nocawe.

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "It doesn't matter. Whatever's convenient."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- okay, well, it's probably fastest to put him in your ear straightaway," says the staffperson, "if you're ready."

Permalink Mark Unread

Nod. "Sure, let's."

Permalink Mark Unread

The staffperson (their nametag reads SPRUCE / TASSHIN 908) leads them to one of the host-dipping apparatuses there and types in a message summoning Ashkon to it, and when there's a confirmation mark on the message indicating that they've shown up, helps situate the host in the recliner-thing. It has substantial armrests and some bars over the shoulders so people don't fall in but no actual restraints and he can push the button himself if he wants.

Permalink Mark Unread

Sure. That sounds like a thing someone who was capable of interacting with society would do and he would really like to stop being gently pestered to go to Lórien so he'll push the button.

Permalink Mark Unread

Down he goes.

There is a wet sensation at his ear.

Permalink Mark Unread

That's allowed.

That's allowed. By him. He gets to allow it.

By the time Ashkon gets all the way in he's smiling nervously.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Hi!>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Hi!! Hi, I heard you want to do magic music!> If Ashkon is still letting him move his face he'll grin.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon is pushing the button to sit them back up but is letting him smile! <That's right, I'm going to go to the University of Brithombar in Lumos and learn to compose magic songs!>

Permalink Mark Unread

He experiences mild trepidation about the fact that any teachers attempting to punish Ashkon for getting things wrong will have to go through him but, like, it's fine, it's for a good cause and they're probably calibrated for the living and won't really seriously hurt him, and anyway it's bothering him a lot more that he can't figure out if he absently pushed that button without having meant to or if Ashkon is as excited as he is and grins in exactly the same way.

Permalink Mark Unread

<You're smiling, I pushed the button. I can take over entire if you want. It's not really a punishment oriented educational system.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He doesn't especially care how much control Ashkon wants but he would really really like it to be predictable and something he can plan around, whether that means Ashkon taking over entirely or laying claim to specific body parts or specific times of day or really whatever.

<Thank you.> For not taking this opportunity to get coy about it. He supposes Ashkon could still be gaslighting him but it's not useful to think about that so he's just not going to. Whatever. He tries to think how to phrase a question about how the classes will work instead.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don't know that many details since I haven't had a chance to tour the campus or anything!>

The staffperson is waiting with one of the bracelets that lock on to the wrist and Ashkon holds out their arm for it.

Permalink Mark Unread

<That's fair.>

He wants to check if Ashkon actually did take over but they'll look so silly if he tries something and the answer is no. And now he's afraid to take literally any actions whatsoever up to and including trying to shift his weight because what if it gets in the way of something.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Won't get in the way at all. If I'm really distracted you might be able to move something I wasn't planning to let you but I hear it's pretty hard to do.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Well. In that case he's going to systematically try everything he can think of so he can get himself to relax about it.

Permalink Mark Unread

None of it works! Ashkon is piloting him through thanking Nocawe and SPRUCE / TASSHIN 908 and then heading for the exit; his host can't move a muscle of his own volition at all.

Permalink Mark Unread

He gets increasingly silly as he gets increasingly confident he won't embarrass them (can he lick his nose? he couldn't even lick his nose before, he obviously can't now) and then stops trying. His eyes don't flutter closed; he doesn't stretch like a cat about to go to sleep. But there's no level on which he's worried about being punished for whatever he does, and there's usually some level on which he's worried about that. It's been obvious since he was accidentally kidnapped that there's really nothing he could do, if all these new worlds were hostile, and he's been despairing and listless and unmoored, but now it's mostly just relaxing.

...Maybe also a little bit hot. Oh, no, Ashkon can hear him thinking that. New topic. New topic right now. <So, how'd you get interested in music?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeerks are blind, but we can hear! I've liked music since I was born. And writing a new magic song is one of the best-scaling ways to accomplish anything. They work on totally nonmagical devices copied a trillion times!>

Permalink Mark Unread

He’s impressed.

<If you can hear, what do you need me for?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Ardas - magic ones, one of them isn't magic and it doesn't work there - sort of react to music that you're trying to get to do something. You can't compose a magic song without that feedback. And Yeerks can't sing.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He feels really sorry for Ashkon not being able to sing. Which is maybe strange, given how he feels about his own voice, but maybe that just makes it fitting for them to pair up.

<Just singing or do instruments work too?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Instruments can help support a song with vocals but it does need a voice.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<And it’s - your voice now, enough for you to get whatever feedback about it?> Oh look, a tangled mess of mixed feelings.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I think so? I guess if it doesn't work then - I'll have to figure something else out, but I think it should...>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I hope it works.> Obviously he wants Ashkon to have nice things. And it would be disappointing to turn out to be useless. And it’s so fitting, for this voice he can’t destroy to be someone else’s now, someone who wants it. And - and yet -

He likes all the individual parts but the story that's shaping up here, where some wretched damned soul that's been stripped of hope and purpose and name and even most of his memories of who he was before, no longer capable of more than wasting time playing games, gives away literally everything he has so completely that this magic thing recognizes even his voice as belonging to someone else now... yeah, when he steps back and notices the whole picture he doesn't like it very much.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

<Should I turn around and go back in the pool?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<No! ...I'm glad you would.>

But it's not Ashkon that's the problem here. It's just that after all this he wants to still be a person, and after giving up every single choice in his life he's not sure he can be.

But he was doing that anyway. He was just doing it piecemeal, every time anyone asked him anything. Nothing would be better if instead Ashkon couldn't study magic and he went back to pretending he was more than a gaping pit of despair that used to have a futile mission tacked up around it like a bit of caution tape. That metaphor doesn't even make sense, it can't have been preventing him from falling into the pit when he is the pit. Whatever. The point is whatever is wrong with him isn't something Ashkon can fix by not taking advantage of it, and he suspects if there were a version of him that wasn't so broken that version of him would have made a similar offer. Probably.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon hesitates, but keeps heading for the bus station.

Permalink Mark Unread

Vague inarticulate affection.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon laces their fingers together and squeezes, smiling slightly.

Off they go to the relevant magic Arda! This trip is slightly longer mostly because it's a full thirty minute walk from the bus station to the campus of the university in Brithombar. The city is very spread out and relentlessly gorgeous and Ashkon doesn't take the walk very quickly.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah, if they'd passed this up on vague principle that would have sucked. He occasionally suggests looking even longer at specific things that are especially to his liking.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon is very obliging about that! He starts practicing whistling on the way when they walk through areas uncrowded enough that there aren't in-progress spontaneous choirs of Elves he'd be clashing with.

Permalink Mark Unread

Awww.

If he does get his head sorted out enough to want to do things he’s not going to pull the rug out from under Ashkon in the middle of studying unless it’s for something very important, on the scale of more fucking hells or conceivably if he were being tortured but maybe not even then. He made an offer. He intends to have been worth trusting. And also he likes this place.

Maybe that is, itself, having something more to him than all the despair and exhaustion.

Permalink Mark Unread

<<3>

Ashkon presents himself to the Elves who run the school and is brought to his little closet of a dorm room, with the whole wall opposite the door taken up by a spectacular view of a river and the meadow around it where people are picnicking and strolling; there is an intricately carved bed and a marquetry-covered desk and a stunning tapestry on the wall and another one on the ceiling and the floor is glass mosaic and the whole thing somehow coheres without looking busy. He doesn't have anything to put down so after a look around he turns right around to go exploring around the campus.

Permalink Mark Unread

The room is -

Sometimes when he was healing from something he'd be left in a tiny room that was meant not to be more than a little injurious, and there's something of that here, a tiny space for stashing a person who isn't being hurt. But not really.

There was a room with a spiked chair and it was dark enough that he didn't see much of it, and he spent the entire time he was in it too restrained to learn about more than the spiked chair, and it was where he was taken when he fought back. And whereas everything else was merely so horrible he would rather never have been born, what happened there was, so far as he can tell, as bad as the demons knew how to make it. They didn't settle for it sucking a lot. It was optimized.

And that's what the dorm reminds him of. They didn't settle, and the thing they optimized so hard for doesn't just happen to be a different thing than misery. It's the exact opposite of misery. And the show of wealth and the obvious careful study of how to precisely influence someone's exact level of misery leaves him unsettled even though he loves and is impressed with the dorm.

<So I don't suppose you can make me stop thinking about the thing I'm thinking about now before I somehow give myself a flashback - hey, is that the right word?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I think it's the right word... I can try to distract you.> He speeds up a bit. Asks for directions to the school store. The Elf who gives the directions mentions that they have clothes there with an encouraging smile.

They are going to go look at pretty Elfy clothes! They will pet fabrics and hold up various colors next to their skin!

Permalink Mark Unread

!! <3! Actually there's nothing wrong with his judgment at all. It brought him here, didn't it?

Permalink Mark Unread

<3!

Ashkon, being as he is from Tide, isn't a citizen of Vanda Nossëo any more than his host is, but he does have a scholarship, and the Elves seem to have a pretty strong interest in him not going around in a t-shirt and yoga pants anyway, so he walks out of the campus store with a satchel and a notebook full of staff paper and a fountain pen and a little toiletry kit and a headscarf and a potted flowering plant that matches the color scheme of their room and a hammered dulcimer and also two sets of Elf robes. Everybody who talks to them seems to know there are two of them in there.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, yeah, they have a bracelet on specifically for that purpose. It's sweet that they remember he exists as a separate person, he can't even manage that himself sometimes. He suggests a color scheme for one of the sets of robes.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Oh, uh, this kind of Elf can read minds. The bracelet also tells them but if it winds up under our sleeves they'll still know. You can learn to shield your thoughts but it seemed like this would be okay with you if it's okay with them, and it is and they can listen less if it does ever start to bother them.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Meep. It's mildly uncomfortable to be thinking everything for a large and mostly unknown audience of people - Ashkon is a single specific person he has a relationship with, and Lórien wasn't presenting itself as the kind of thing he needed to interact with like a person - but probably not really worth hedging people out only if they're nice people who would tell him how to shield his thoughts and in alternative possible realities continuing to have his mind read by assholes.

Well, it's probably worth knowing how, anyway.

<You're really sure it's okay with them and they can listen less if they want to?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah. The way you shield your thoughts is you think about some of them as being in public or in private, usually with a metaphor like 'indoors' and 'outdoors' or something, but they can listen less.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He immediately adopts the indoors/outdoors metaphor. Outdoors like the park where he felt safe sitting and thinking and wasn't constantly menaced is for private thoughts; indoors like in the caves where he had to be constantly watching himself is for public thoughts. It belatedly occurs to him that that might not be the usual direction for that metaphor. It'd be easier to practice if he could test it but whatever.

Maybe it's good to be able to hide just how much of a mess he is. So people won't suggest that he should be in Lórien again instead of having fun here, or that Ashkon should be giving up on his dream out of some kind of vague principle. (This line of reasoning is outdoors.)

<Does that work on you or just them?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Just them. Not basically any other kind of mindreader. Elf mindreading is particularly polite that way.>

Permalink Mark Unread

It's kind of nice that it doesn't work on Ashkon and only mostly because it's nice to have an excuse to stop worrying about establishing trust from a baseline of total Cartesian doubt. Also kind of awkward, though. (This, too, is outdoors.)

<Do you shield your thoughts or can they just read me through you?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I've been practicing. I slip sometimes, I haven't had a lot of chances to get feedback, but I seem to mostly have it down.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Vague acknowledgment. It sure would be nice to get feedback.

<...Can I talk to other people the same way I can talk to you?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<If they're magic Elves you totally can.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He can talk to so many people.

...Of course, he could do that yesterday and just look what he did to that poor woman. Even if eventually she can maybe supposedly get the nightmares fixed. (This thought is so very outdoors.)

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don't know much about how humans talk to each other that you don't but Nocawe thought it was hyperbole, remember?>

Permalink Mark Unread

...He’s unreasonably averse to concluding that actually she was being mean to him. And that’s unreasonable, isn’t it. It’s entirely possible that she was just responding to him upsetting her by trying to upset him, isn’t it. He can talk to so many people, an unknown number of whom might suck even if they are not demons and Tide as a polity is trustworthy. Since they might not enforce laws against sucking, or someone might be doing it for the first time.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I'm not even sure she was trying to be mean. Maybe it's just an expression where she comes from for some reason.>

Permalink Mark Unread

That would explain a lot. There are maybe actually zero things that would be weirder if that were true.

<...I’ll have to thank her for getting me help. Like, it was clearly an accident, but it kind of wasn’t, you know?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah, she didn't understand what was going on with you but thought you might need somebody and about that part she wasn't wrong.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary fervent nodding. Nocawe is so good. Ashkon is also so good.

Permalink Mark Unread

<3

Ashkon goes back to the dorm room and changes into the Elf clothes and heads out to go for a walk through the pretty, pretty buildings and pretty, pretty grounds.

Permalink Mark Unread

The place is so good. He doesn’t really know what to do with things being this nice.

At some point in all these walks Ashkon might notice how annoyingly weak and out of shape he is.

Permalink Mark Unread

That is a little inconvenient. He sits on the ground to rest now and then and keeps going.

Permalink Mark Unread

The ground is also nice. (Geology is actually a long-running on-again off-again special interest of his, though almost entirely from a stamp-collecting angle and he’s mostly encountered igneous rocks. It hasn’t occurred to him that he could take any actions about this.)

Permalink Mark Unread

<I'm not sure the room has much space for a rock collection. Maybe we could mount some shelves.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Wow, Ashkon is kind of like Nocawe in that both of them have this uncanny knack for thinking of ways things could be better. He should maybe try to imitate them.

He wasn't especially counting on a rock collection and in fact hadn't considered the idea at all and anyway he, uh, doesn't have much time to go collecting them, but maybe? Maybe at some point when Ashkon is ?drinking? sludge (what the fuck) he'll figure out how to visit a canyon? Or they could go together if Ashkon is interested but he's not assuming that.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don't drink the sludge. We absorb rays like plants do. The sludge is just the most comfortable place to hang out doing that. We can see what opportunities come up!>

Permalink Mark Unread

Apparently learning that they're autotrophs is the thing that changes his mind about Yeerks having the worst form factor and now he wants to know all about that.

Permalink Mark Unread

Aww. Ashkon can explain about their homeworld's sun having wonky rays while they stroll around campus building up endurance.

Permalink Mark Unread

If that worked it would also have worked when he was assigned absurd amounts of floor-scrubbing and to the best of his knowledge he has never gained strength or stamina since dying except in the sense that he's recovered from acute injuries.

But at any rate that's fascinating.

Permalink Mark Unread

<If it doesn't work I'll see if there's magic for it or something.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Next time you're out I'm going to go look for my friend to let him know what happened to me and I shouldn't look even more different for that but after that you can change whatever you want, I'm not attached to almost anything about this body. It sucks.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Okay. That's probably easier than finding magic that'd let you get stronger. I'll need to see what the current state of the art is for morph while you've got a Yeerk, you might have to do it while I'm not in you or I'd get morphed along with the rest of you and not be able to come out again.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Hot. That would be a bad outcome.

<What does it feel like?> Every time his body has been changed permanently or semi-permanently since dying it's involved being repeatedly injured.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Morphing? I've never done it. It doesn't hurt, is what I hear, but it supposedly seems a lot like it ought to.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Creepy.> At least a little bit in an exciting way but mostly not, mostly that sounds fucked up.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Some people can do it so it looks pretty and not horrifying.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He doesn't really have a strong preference to not look horrifying. (It hasn't quite occurred to him that this is something he'd have to take actions about, as opposed to sit still for.)

Permalink Mark Unread

<Oh, speaking of, I'm going to grow your hair out, it'll make the Elves feel better.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He cut it for a disguise and because it was a lot of work to take care of but he doesn't actually like having it short. Now he's starting to mentally plan out sets of hair ornaments like all these ridiculously overdressed locals are wearing. It doesn't grow as fast as it used to but it does grow.

...He's not sure if he should proactively think about things they could change or if he'll just end up attached to ideas Ashkon wouldn't like when he'd be fine* if he didn't encourage himself to go around wanting things.

*miserable

Permalink Mark Unread

<The Elf thing is that they have, like, erogenous hair, so it's part of their nudity taboo - they don't actually have a regular nudity taboo - to keep it braided or put up or covered. Besides that I think we can do basically whatever with it.>

Permalink Mark Unread

A very long time ago he thinks he ascribed gender to specific hairstyles but it was so long ago, and he also hasn't had aesthetic opinions about his personal appearance in about that long. He's just kind of going off of things he's seen here so far and what he saw on Earth and general aesthetics. What if he had a steampunk headband with delicate filigree? What if his hair were blue? Except he likes wearing green and that might clash. What if he had an absurd number of hair dyes so he could color-coordinate with arbitrary outfits?

Does any of this trade off against something important like ending all the multiple fucking hells.

Permalink Mark Unread

<No, it doesn't trade off.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<If you run out of stuff to do and give me back my body and some paper I’ll sketch some ideas but only if you run out of things to do. You know of cooler things to do anyway, I’m not missing out if you’re busy.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Maybe I'll run out at some point but right now I'm still getting used to being able to see! I love it!>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary mad cackling. <It has a lot to recommend it here.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<It was still pretty cool from a perspective of never having been able to before even back in Tide. Colors!>

Permalink Mark Unread

<It was fine there.> It was not fine when the ambient lighting was designed to cause eyestrain and people were playing tricks with illusions to make him doubt his sanity and he had to copy books that might have been full of lies. But maybe that’s all in the past and not worth worrying about. <I’m glad you don’t have my associations with it.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeerks don't really pick up trauma or anything from our hosts. It's enabled a lot of bad things but it's convenient now.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<How does that... work, I guess...> It keeps coming up and he’s finally gotten to the point where he can be curious about random things and he’s very curious about what it’s like to be a Yeerk.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Good question, but I don't really know how it works! We evolved to be symbiotes to Gedds, but it's not like they're especially traumatized all the time in the ancestral environment all the time as far as I know... I guess they're kind of helpless and confused and it would be bad if we were too, since that's what we did for them was be agentic and smart.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He doesn’t entirely follow that. <So what do you get?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Skills like languages, and memories and knowledge.>

Permalink Mark Unread

It doesn’t quite make sense that that’s separable from more objectionable things - is there some difference between learning to think of a duck when you hear the word "duck" and learning to think of pain when you open your eyes? Is there some difference between skills for free people and skills like complying when ordered to hurt yourself?

Permalink Mark Unread

<I can think about pain without this being bad, I guess might be the difference? But I do also think the skills are different. And also having them from you is different from having them myself - I'll retain them less well when I'm out, and I can decide to use them or not a little more discretely.> Can they skip rocks? Well, if they keep trying they'll be able to.

Permalink Mark Unread

He doesn’t consciously remember learning how to do that but seems to have some sense of how it works, so maybe he did once.

He finds the explanation enlightening.

Permalink Mark Unread

Skipskipskip. When Ashkon finds a nice one he puts it in his pocket. The rocks here are nicer than the ones on Earth beaches, there are especially nice ones every twenty or thirty they pick up.

Permalink Mark Unread

He hasn’t been to many beaches. He really only has expectations about lava tubes.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon doesn't know much about what to expect either. But when they have a pocketful of rocks he gets up and heads back to the center of campus to pick up his course schedule. <Is it confusing for you if I arrange things telepathically with Elves in a way you can't hear? I can probably figure out how to copy you on those conversations if you want me to without being hopelessly confusing about who's talking but it's not automatic.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He instinctively sorts that into the category of things he should avoid having preferences about and catches himself doing that and asks how bad it would be if he turned out to care.

Permalink Mark Unread

<It'd be a little higher friction but probably not that bad? It might be easier if you started paying attention to public Elf thoughts and I could ask the ones I'm talking to to address both of us.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<How do I do that?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I can get someone to try talking directly to you and then it's just paying attention to that same... channel, but while it's less conspicuous.>

Hi! says an Elf voice in his mind. I'm Rost, the registrar that Ashkon has been discussing classes with.

Permalink Mark Unread

Eep! Another person!

...Hi? Am I doing this right?

Permalink Mark Unread

Yup, I can hear you!

Permalink Mark Unread

Do I need to think in words for that to work or...?

Permalink Mark Unread

Nope, osanwë does nonverbals like pictures and emotions just fine.

Permalink Mark Unread

Appreciation of how convenient that is! Vague uncertainty about whether to say "nice to meet you", here just have the sentiment behind it instead. So how about that discussion he was maybe supposed to be listening to?

Permalink Mark Unread

Rost and Ashkon experiment with ways to fold him into their conversation about Ashkon's assessment tests and what classes he can join. Apparently in the morning he is supposed to go get checked out for singing talent and possibly recommended remediation if he doesn't have any; that could be folded into morph plans. He's also signed up for introduction to music notation and has tutoring for getting to know his hammered dulcimer scheduled.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon had better bring his own singing talent or pick a new host.

He doesn’t want to interrupt but that’s sort of questionably possible at the moment and he'd like to know at some point if Ashkon using him for hammered dulcimer lessons is going to result in him knowing how to play.

Permalink Mark Unread

<That depends on how much attention you pay! If you're thinking about math or talking to somebody by osanwë the whole time almost certainly not.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary nodding. ...He’s probably going to come out of this with weird body language habits, isn’t he, since he isn’t tracking whether he would actually like his body to move in whatever way he's ?trying? to move it.

Oh, well. Way more importantly he totally could have friends to talk to all through Ashkon's classes like that. If he can figure out how to start conversations. And if he were less interested in the hammered dulcimer, which he’s actually very excited about.

Permalink Mark Unread

The sun is starting to go down. Ashkon goes over to a bunch of passively welcoming Elves sitting on a retaining wall to watch it and joins them.

Permalink Mark Unread

Watching the sunset is a good use of eyes and he’s on board with this plan but also he’s interested in the retaining wall. And kind of wants to examine it himself even though Ashkon would definitely do it right. He can even keep watching the sunset since it’s not like he’d use his eyes to get information about something he can touch.

<Can I have a minute?> It’s not a huge deal or anything but also this thought is public.

Permalink Mark Unread

<All yours.> Ashkon lets go of the body; this is mostly pretty subtle but it means all the tension he was holding to sit up straight is now the host's, the eye saccades track the host's attention.

Permalink Mark Unread

He pulls his whole body into a stretch to get used to it and then feels the wall, trying to figure out what kind of stone it is, how it’s put together, if it’s sustained any damage since it was made...

And it really is more fun to watch the sunset while he’s doing that than to shut his eyes.

<You can take over whenever, just warn me.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don't think I'm going to need to be fronting till my first class in the morning.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Man. What would he even do with that much time besides waste it on stupid games. Well, he really should let Nocawe know he's okay, and see if he can find Pete for the same reason, and he was just thinking about sketching out hairstyles, and at some point they need to caffeinate to keep being constantly awake - or he supposes sleep is also an option he might as well take. Or - he should really be trying to imitate that thing Nocawe and Ashkon do where they just kind of come up with ways things could be better - they could... look at stars? Frolic in a meadow? Probably if those things are good ideas Ashkon will get to them anyway and he should prioritize things Ashkon can't do just as well. For values of "can't" that are not literal and don't take into account that, actually, probably Ashkon would be even better than him at having conversations with people he cares about.

Somehow he has enough of a to-do list to have to prioritize it and even thinking about that is exhausting and on some unendorsed level he kind of wants to just watch the sky darken and think about math.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don't think there's a big rush on any of that. Maybe Pete'll get more worried. Do you want to go find Pete tonight?>

Permalink Mark Unread

He reflexively shrugs because why would he know if that's a good idea, but the considerations in favor are that Pete's life is actually pretty hard and dangerous and he might benefit from being tipped off about other places having better social services, and he might be worried, and once it's done they can start thinking about morph, and the considerations against are... that he's lost track of what time it is in America? But there basically isn't a time when Pete wouldn't want to be tipped off about the existence of a place where the wait for public housing isn't. Really if they catch him sleeping that just makes it more rather than less urgent. And that maybe Ashkon would rather he do that on his own time, but this is something he specifically mentioned as a thing he needed time to do, and Ashkon doesn't have anything scheduled. So it tentatively seems like that might be a good idea??

<I don't really trust my judgment but maybe? Unless you can think of some reason not to.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<No, seems reasonable to me. I'll have to book a courier since there won't be a bus route but I can afford that.>

Permalink Mark Unread

That's a cost he totally failed to consider. He stops to make sure he's keeping his thoughts private from the assorted third parties possibly eavesdropping because he needs a moment to consider whether to be bothered by the fact that he failed to think of that. He could just forget about it, say he's already put all those choices in Ashkon's hands - metaphorical hands, Ashkon doesn't have hands - no, Ashkon totally has hands, that's just the thing, isn't it.

But no, actually, he does want to keep tracking that kind of thing. He doesn't want to let the habits of thought he'd need to be his own person fall away.

Then again, he doesn't know enough for trying to think of things like that to work. It's not like he didn't specifically think it was worth asking if there were problems with his plans he hadn't considered. And on the gripping hand, sometimes friends offer each other nice things. Like help going places, or advice on navigating unfamiliar systems. It doesn't have to be complicated or a referendum on his humanity for him to just let Ashkon pay for a courier.

<Thank you.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<You're welcome. If it bothers you you could get Vanda Nossëo citizenship and draw basic income, it'd be easy for you to save up enough to pay me back later - Tide's not part of Vanda Nossëo so I don't draw basic income myself.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He heard about that and tried to ask questions, twice, and somehow he still doesn’t know anything about it. It has been repeatedly represented to him that citizens (he's not sure if there are any requirements for citizenship or if so what they are, except that apparently citizens have to follow the law? only that doesn't sound like it can possibly be a responsibility specific to citizenship, they can't actually mean they don't care what random foreigners do in their territory... can they?? maybe they actually don't care???) receive some unspecified amount of money under some unspecified circumstances. Attempts to learn anything more than that have failed completely and resulted in confusing conversations about whether escaping Hell makes him the next worst thing to a demon, or whatever the fuck that person was on about comparing having gone to ground in America to murder and torture. He has no idea what that was supposed to mean and Nocawe didn't really end up clarifying, just said he must have misunderstood something and then moved on to other topics. At this point he's assuming he will have an additional ten or so conversations where people point out that if he ??????? then he could ??????? and then profit and will never learn anything else about it.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Well, uh, non-citizens can still be like, deported, if they break the law, but citizens generally affirmatively agree to obey it, which might not be an important distinction to everyone but is a distinction...>

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, is that the same basic thing as the reason he doesn't care what Ashkon does with him but hates the idea of being asked to do things himself? He probably doesn't want to agree to obey any laws so he supposes he probably shouldn't try to become a citizen.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Okay. I can just cover it, I have enough spending money and had been budgeting for needing to buy my host food.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Sounds fine. He’s curious how Ashkon came to have money in the first place.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I have a scholarship. Tide wants to send people to study and live other places as a relationship-building measure and I won a scholarship to study music.>

Permalink Mark Unread

That’s so cool.

<So, how do you hire a courier?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Online. You done fronting for now?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Sure.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon takes over again, nods politely to the Elves, and heads back to their room to pick up the tablet Nocawe gave his host and book a courier. He has to write in the destination since the world isn't on the website yet, but he mentions that his host is a native of the world and wants to check up on a friend.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Can we offer to take him with us?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I'm not sure. Since neither of us are ourselves Vanda Nossëo citizens. The courier will probably know?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Okay. I want to offer if it's a good idea, because, like.>

Because Pete had a social worker once who he said didn't do anything. Because public housing in America has wait times longer than it takes to head down a walkway and find a door. Because if even one more person dies, with no guarantee about where they'll go...

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah, I get that.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I get to actually talk to him, right?>

Why must it be physically impossible to hold hands with Ashkon. Unfair.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah, you can front with him no problem, I don't really have much to say to him unless he wants me to introduce myself!>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary nodding.

Permalink Mark Unread

<3

Their courier is booked, he looks like this picture on the app (short beardy fellow).

Permalink Mark Unread

Wordless acknowledgment. Vague nervousness about somehow doing it wrong.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I think Pete will be okay.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary smile.

Permalink Mark Unread

They go meet the courier outside the dorm building. Pop, pop, pop, pop, pop, pop, pop, pop.

Permalink Mark Unread

And does the courier know if they can offer to bring Pete back with them?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes, I can bring him along if he wants to come."

Permalink Mark Unread

He goes looking. It's unreasonably easy when he not only knows where Pete sleeps but also has the ability to ask if anyone's seen him. The latter thing means it's Pete who finds them first, comes up behind them and asks what they want with him.

And he turns and sees Pete for the first time. "I, um. So if you want to you can come to another universe. - It's me, uh, you called me Hear Some Evil at one point..." (It's up there with 33 as things people call him go. Pete had to explain the reference before he really appreciated it but now he does.)

Pete tsks. "He got eaten by the snake."

"Yeah, it turns out it's a portalsnake that teleports people. Or so the people where I landed said. I didn't test it other than once by accident. Um, you... told me about your wife... you wrote a couple of signs for me... I don't really know how to prove myself and telling you that stuff doesn't actually prove anything, they can read minds. The people I ended up with, I mean."

Pete flinches disgustedly.

"It's, uh. It's touch range. They literally touch your actual brain on the inside of your skull. I don't know why I thought that was going to make you make less of a face when I started explaining it. Anyway, obviously I got, uh... healed... and also I have an apartment. They just gave it to me. Also a social worker that, uh, I think my impression is that she seems more useful than what you said about yours? So I thought maybe I should let you know that happened, or something that looks exactly like it happened and they don't really need to convince me to say this, they could totally just puppet me."

"...I never thought you were all there but you have a tongue."

"If you want to go you can just come with us and tell the teleporter you want to. If you want. I don't - I'm not saying I have an opinion about whether you should move there and ask for them to give you an apartment - "

"You don't have an opinion on whether I should move to the place where the social workers are so fucking useful that you got an apartment in less than a week and regrew your fucking tongue, my fucking god, what's wrong with it that you don't have an opinion."

Shrug. "Technically as far as I know they didn't tell me that the healer and the social worker were the same person? I don't have an opinion because I never have opinions! When have you ever known me to have an opinion!"

"Do they read your mind?"

"Mine, yes, I asked them to. Repeatedly. They were really insistent about not reading minds without permission. Uh, there are longer-range ones who just read everyone, or so I'm told, but I also heard they're really easy to block out and everyone who hangs around with them learns and that's why they read minds all the time, since you'd only not be blocking them out if you didn't mind. They - act like they all care a lot about not being - invasive? Maybe it's just an act, I wouldn't know, but it's a pretty consistent one. Except I think this fucked up forest called Lórien might be a god and a mind-reader so maybe don’t let them talk you into visiting? It sucks there."

"...Fine. I'll tell your friend that I would like to go live in a magical fairy realm with free housing and healthcare for everyone, and a pony." Sigh. "If it'll work on me. I'm not a ghost."

"I bet you could be but I really don't recommend it. I don't have any specific reason to think that's relevant?"

"You don't think you being a ghost is relevant to whether you can go to a magic fairy realm where they grow back tongues and eyes?"

"It seems like the teleportation works on live people? Anyway, you can come with me if you want, or stay here, I'm not going to tell you how to live your life. I'll be busy because I decided I wanted to be possessed - "

"Okay, you know what, stop adding more things. Just tell me - have you found the catch yet?"

Headshake. "I’m not that smart but I don’t see why there’d be one. They demonstrated being able to possess people, why bother with tricks? If they wanted to kidnap you and flay you alive and then heal you and do it again I don’t see why they couldn’t just do that."

"...You get why that’s not comforting?"

"No, do you usually worry about things you can’t do anything about?"

Sigh. "You’re welcome to take me away to a magical land of adventure and well-funded social services if that’s a real thing."

"Okay. And even if you don’t want to hear about why, I’ll be busy."

"Are you happy about it?"

He shrugs and curls in on himself but he smiles so tenderly that Pete looks at him and laughs and says, "Do you have a sweetheart? You?"

"...No, you were right about me being a ghost. But I think I’m okay."

"Fucking finally."

 

There’s a little stuff to pack. Not a lot.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon hangs back, surmising that he oughtn't introduce himself since Pete seems kind of overwhelmed.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's kind of exhausting and once they've done something that vaguely resembles exchanging contact information and gotten back to Vanda Nossëo he just wants to go play stupid browser games for an entire day or something. (Obviously Ashkon is going to do things at some point in the next day. He predicts and is happy about this but refuses on principle to put in completely unnecessary scheduling effort or willpower.)

It's cool, though. He's been torn away from a lot of friends before and this is the first time he's ever gotten back in touch or been able to offer them any help with their problems. It doesn't feel like something that's really happening but it's still nice.

Permalink Mark Unread

The courier needs to know which world on the route Pete wants to be left behind in, and wherein.

Permalink Mark Unread

He'll take an information place somewhere people won't read his mind.

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay, so, like, any major bus station?

Permalink Mark Unread

Yep.

Permalink Mark Unread

Sure. Pop pop pop pop pop pop here's a bus station and pop pop pop pop with Ashkon and his transportation.

Permalink Mark Unread

Stretch. Yawn. <Thank you for helping me do that.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<No problem.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<If you want to stay up all night we should get some coffee.> And if not then they have the Have Horrible Nightmares button and Ashkon can do whatever he wants with it.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yup, I'll need to find the replicator. I'm glad you don't eat solid food, I can wrap my mind around drinking but eating solids is really weird to me. I think that's a me thing and nobody else minds, and I would've gotten used to it, but.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Aww, he likes being convenient. <Your thing is better except I’m not sure how you’d skip sleep that way.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeerks don't actually sleep. We can kind of drowse but we're never totally unconscious.>

Permalink Mark Unread

That doesn’t sound appealing compared to getting to sleep comfortably on some reasonable schedule but it does sound better than nightmares or having to sleep every night no matter what.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Being unconscious doesn't sound appealing to me from my perspective, but I'm up for trying sleeping. If I'm in front we can see if your heartbeat responding to my emotions instead of yours and stuff like that helps with the nightmares at all?>

Permalink Mark Unread

He has no idea what to expect but that sounds like a fascinating experiment. Even if it doesn’t help at all it’ll be nice to know.

Permalink Mark Unread

To bed with them!

Permalink Mark Unread

He dreams of being back in the caves. He dreams of someone using him to torture a sobbing prisoner while he tries to stop and tries to scream and tries to apologize. He dreams the Yeerks have joined forces with the demons and it's all his fault for imagining anyone might ever help him.

It's not as awful as usual, at least. As he's waking up he checks whether he can move.

Permalink Mark Unread

Nope, Ashkon's driving again. Up they sit. <Wow, I didn't experience your dreams while they were happening but from your memories they were nasty as all get out.>

Permalink Mark Unread

It's disorienting to wake up to Ashkon being in control. Not in a bad way, though. Well, maybe bad compared to what most people experience most of the time when they get up, but.

He doesn't succeed at laughing bitterly. <Yeah. They always are. Thank you, though.> He wants to stretch, or wants Ashkon to stretch, whichever.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon stretches obligingly and starts getting himself presentable for his first class.

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary bouncing! He’s so excited about classes!

Permalink Mark Unread

Off they go to voice lessons. Their tutor wants them to do vocal warmups and will listen for timbre and test their range.

Permalink Mark Unread

His voice is hard to place and strange, out of step with itself. It's not obvious anything's odd about it when he's just carrying on a conversation by someone who just wants to hear the words he's trying to say. Along every individual axis it's a very average human voice, it's just that the vocal fold length and thickness and position ought to belong to different life stages or to different sexes or both. Whether they want to say his voice has even settled at all is really a question of whether they want to privilege the fact that it's unlikely to randomly change any further on its own for no reason or the fact that it's unusual for a mature voice.

He could probably sing tenor. If he could sing. Which he's horrible at because he completely lacks any talent and has a tendency to forget to drink enough water and hates using his voice.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, Ashkon can drink plenty of water and he doesn't hate it at all and he attends very anxiously to the teacher's suggestions for what to relax and what posture to stand in.

Permalink Mark Unread

It makes Ashkon's body feel more alien than when Ashkon is just walking around. It's a claustrophobic sort of feeling, being so saliently helpless and trapped and no more than a passenger.

Only - when he had mixed feelings about getting himself into this it made Ashkon hesitate even without him changing his mind. The only time he's asked for control of his body he's been given it, no questions asked. He's surrounded by people who could hear him if he screamed for help and might be in a position to actually do something. He trusts Ashkon, or the system Ashkon is embedded in - sort of because it's not really decision-relevant, but at this point also because empirically the thing Ashkon-or-the-system-Ashkon-is-embedded-in does with total control of him is take him for walks in beautiful places and help him sleep. It feels silly to be afraid, it really does, though he still is.

Whatever. It's math time. Graphs are fucking incredible.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon will make this body as good at singing as it can get over the course of a two hour lesson, but there's a break halfway through to rest his voice. <Holding up okay?>

Permalink Mark Unread

Is he? That seems like a hard question. He's not entirely sure if he is, and what if the answer is no even though he would rather let Ashkon achieve things than be definitely okay every moment? Or maybe if he's not okay it's actually fixable really easily and without getting in the way of anything? Or maybe he is okay? Is he okay? How would he know? He could maybe guess if his emotions were embodied like they usually are but that sounds really stupid because if that were happening he would probably be having an awful time about being subjected to lessons while completely immobile and the thing that's happening instead is slowly shredding his habits of fear and that's great.

There probably isn't anything worth doing about whether he's okay right now in two minutes except, actually, there is one thing. That teacher reads minds. Knock knock. Hi, it's me - he sends his sense of the location and arrangement of his body - can I just ask you what you'd do if I didn't want to be here?

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, probably I'd sing you to sleep and then call emergency services.

Permalink Mark Unread

Thank you, I'm glad you would. Don't, though, I'm fine.

And, actually, he is. Not comfortable, but going to come through without any new nightmares and glad to be here.

<<3 Thanks for checking in. I think the answer is yes but mostly because you asked.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Anytime!>

After some water they resume the lesson.

Permalink Mark Unread

Which is still disconcerting and he's still just going to do math and Not Be Here but it's still up there with sitting in a park on Earth so really of the hard things he's done this is not one of the hardest.

Yesterday he was having a crisis about having abdicated all responsibility for making choices. That seems ridiculous now but he can't laugh. He thinks about graphs in his indoor thoughts where anyone who might want to comment can see what he's up to. (What he's up to is trying to derive the quadratic formula, except that he doesn't know the quadratic formula exists and is just sort of fumbling around for some kind of interesting result.)

Permalink Mark Unread

A mathematically inclined Elf a ways away wants to know if he wants spoilers!

Permalink Mark Unread

He would hate spoilers per se but would be delighted if they'd use their knowledge of the spoilers to point out questions with particularly interesting answers. Also he's vaguely curious about this person and their math education.

Permalink Mark Unread

This person is named Tulindo and she used to do lots of math back in Valinor. Here is a quadratic equation hint!

Permalink Mark Unread

He doesn't know anything about Valinor except that he's still really very annoyed about his brief visit thereto but he's sort of vaguely curious about its ostensible traits and wouldn't mind being further interrupted. (If he isn't further interrupted he'll have the answer by the end of class.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Valinor is the continent where the Valar live. I grew up there but a lot of us came over here a few years ago and I don't really want to go back there either, even though they say the Valar are better now.

Permalink Mark Unread

He would rather be talking about cool math but he doesn't really know how people do that and even though he kind of dislikes exposition it's better than nothing right now since he's not trying to assess whether it's true or why anyone would say it. (This is public but not actually sent.)

Thank you. I don't know if anything I didn't like about it had anything to do with them not being good enough, I just didn't like the forest or that they were bothered when I tried to leave it.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, I have really fond memories of Lórien, I used to go there on vacation with my family. I think humans make the Valar nervous because they're not as well behaved as Elves so humans don't get the run of the place.

Permalink Mark Unread

He can't wince. He can't freak out like he did on the balcony. There's an awful moment where he just exists, and it's just true that he's been found unworthy (that he's damned), and he can't do anything (he never could) and his breathing doesn't even hitch because it's not his (it's not like this body ever belonged to him anyway) and it's just... true.

Their loss, he answers, but even in his own mind he sounds brittle and defensive.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, I know, I think humans are neat. I've been to human cities a few times but I have to go around with my eyes closed because otherwise I'll get flinchy looking at their hair, but I love human music and stuff.

Permalink Mark Unread

I put my eyes out when I lived in a human city but it wasn't about hair. The instrumental music's good sometimes, I kind of wish I'd bothered to learn the names of any of the pieces I liked.

Permalink Mark Unread

If you can think a few bars I can try singing them into my tune recognition app!

Permalink Mark Unread

It transpires that he likes Saint-Saëns' Carnival of the Animals though he's rarely in the mood for the lion part, and he has strong opinions about how Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata fails to live up to its artistic potential, and he's a big Chopin fan, and he likes some of Peder Helland's ambient music in a kind of nonspecific way where it's notable for how no part of it is in any way unpleasant. ...Actually he likes a lot of forgettable chill ambient music on the grounds that it doesn't sound unpleasant and is nice and boring-in-a-good-way without being boring-in-a-bad-way. Actually he'd also like to know the name of this one Quenya song they were playing for him when he first visited Tide.

Also he's curious about Tulindo's taste in music. He hasn't gotten to discuss music before but it feels more like the kind of thing he can improvise than discussing math.

Permalink Mark Unread

Tulindo can find all those titles for him. She likes barbershop harmonies (she's usually not into the lyrics) and circle singing and ragtime.

Permalink Mark Unread

He thanks her.

Ragtime is sometimes good though he's not nearly as familiar with it as he'd like to be. He's not in a great position to take a lot of recs but he could take some.

(He's definitely not going to have answered her question by the end of class but. Well. He has a lot more of these to get through.)

Afterward he would very much like for something nice to happen. He's not picky about what kind of nice thing it should be, he just feels like after getting through all that the next thing that happens should not be the sort of thing he would describe as something to get through.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I have melodic dictation next, so we get to listen to Elves sing and you don't have to be the one paying attention to exactly which notes, how's that for something nice?>

Permalink Mark Unread

< ✨They're really good singers.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Aren't they just??>

Melodic dictation ensues.

Permalink Mark Unread

It’s so nice. His imaginary body language is stretching and smiling dreamily and leaning on Ashkon's shoulder. And he doesn’t even have a real body to worry someone will see relaxing and hurt him, and if he were inclined to worry anyway there’s only so worried he could get when Ashkon's heart won’t start racing. It still feels unreal that the teachers don’t hurt their students but he doesn’t expect them to; he just distantly expects good things to happen, and they do.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon periodically goes <3 at him and raises his hand to ask questions about the notation and to ask that phrases be played or sung an extra time, as do the other students.

Permalink Mark Unread

He enjoys most of what happens more than he thought was possible. When he doesn’t he thinks about math. He keeps an eye out for people he could talk to but doesn’t really know how to identify people like that or how to have conversations. He doesn’t ask about sleeping again soon; he likes what it does to him but every day is pretty excessive when he doesn’t need it and almost everything in waking life is more pleasant than almost all his dreams. He doesn’t ask to borrow Ashkon's body again before Ashkon needs to feed.

He feels like an imaginary friend that nothing bad can happen to.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I only strictly need a bit less than an hour. Do you want me to come right back as soon as I'm done or do you want some time to yourself?> Ashkon asks as they're on the bus back to Tide.

Permalink Mark Unread

<...I don’t know.> He will probably care and he’s started thinking of that as important but that only gets him as far as considering the question enough to know he doesn’t know yet. <I think if you don’t have any reason to think this is a stupid idea you should do what makes you comfortable this time and I’ll know next time?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Okay. I'll send you a message through the pool attendants when I'm ready, if you hang around, but if you do want to tell them that you'll be back later, I'll be okay, I don't have a class till tomorrow.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<<3!>

Permalink Mark Unread

<3!

And into the recliner, and - Ashkon is out and his host is all alone.

Permalink Mark Unread

And he’s supposed to get up, probably. He does that. He looks for someplace else to sit.

Permalink Mark Unread

There are plenty of benches and chairs; it's basically a luxe waiting room around here. There's a fishtank.

Permalink Mark Unread

He likes the fish. He could stare at the fish for hours. Presumably over the course of Ashkon's education he will.

In addition to fish-watching he emails Nocawe to let her know that he's fine.

Permalink Mark Unread

Nocawe gets back to him very promptly, apparently she's a fast emailer - I'm delighted that everything's working out for you with Ashkon! Don't hesitate to let me know if you need anything else. Do you still want to be on the waiting list for subtle artist help with the nightmares?

Permalink Mark Unread

Yes but if it's important prioritization information I feel like I can live like this. Not literally, I can be dead like this.

I don’t think I need anything but we helped my friend move here and he might need help. Should I give him your email if he needs anything?

I’m too busy for it now but if I'd realized what teachers are like here I wouldn’t have been worried about language classes. I’m learning a lot. Some of it is even related to Ashkon's classes.

Thank you.

Permalink Mark Unread
Feel free to refer your friend to me! What were you expecting teachers to be like, that might be important for anyone working with other people who've been through what you've experienced.
Permalink Mark Unread

They'd provide information to learn and give me time to memorize it, and then quiz me and punish me for wrong answers. (For big topics like entire languages they'd break it up and give me a dictionary first, and when I had that memorized they'd give me a book about grammar, and then there'd be a chance to practice having conversations.) When I had to work for another dead human that would vary more. They were also much worse at explaining the reasons for things.

Permalink Mark Unread
Thank you for telling me, that sounds awful. I'm really glad you're getting along with Ashkon! Do remember that if you ever start thinking you want to do something else, you can end your agreement any time.
Permalink Mark Unread

Yep, it’s been made very clear to me that if I decide I don’t like the best thing that’s ever happened to me and want to suddenly interfere with Ashkon's studies I can do that. Unlike any of the things I’ve ever wanted to stop happening.

Permalink Mark Unread
You might not need this information now but nobody can tell us about next year or next decade. I'm so glad you're doing well though!
Permalink Mark Unread

They can’t? I think I misunderstood someone as saying people can see the future.

Permalink Mark Unread
Some of them can, but they're not watching you.
Permalink Mark Unread

How can you tell?

Permalink Mark Unread
Precognitive insurance is an expensive service. By default only rich people and governments and particularly dangerous recreational events have it.
Permalink Mark Unread

Why do I feel like there’s something wrong all over except when he’s controlling me? Like fear but it isn’t about anything specific and I’m not exactly more afraid. Is that somehow more of the thing where my heart doesn’t beat faster if he doesn’t let it?

Permalink Mark Unread
Probably. Yeerks can decide whether to let their hosts' emotions influence their autonomic body functions or not. Anxiety or whatever it is you're experiencing is probably related to some kind of physical feedback loop he can interrupt.
Permalink Mark Unread

He spends the rest of the wait looking at the fish.

Permalink Mark Unread

Eventually a pool attendant finds him and lets him know that Ashkon is ready.

Permalink Mark Unread

He'll go pick Ashkon up immediately.

Permalink Mark Unread

In he goes! <Didja miss me?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah.> He's kind of sad about that.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I'm sorry.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He appreciates that but doesn't know what to do with it.

<So if you don't have class, do you have anything fun to do?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<A pool friend suggested that we should try 'fancy' coffee, with like, stuff in it. Would that work for you?>

Permalink Mark Unread

He -

- the panic just doesn't come, of course, there's only vague unease that can't find any purchase anywhere in his body. After a moment he stops being surprised by that and actually considers the question. He doesn't want to take food from people, doesn't want to accept absurd luxuries that people joke about the frivolousness and expense of, doesn't want to remember and be sick. But he's not going to be sick no matter what he has to remember, is he? That's the obvious implication of what Nocawe said, and what he's noticed, unless he's wrong but presumably Ashkon will notice and point out if he's wrong. And nothing's been presented to him as expensive here, and this is only even a real choice if the people who told him there were no starving people here were telling the truth and not just fucking with him.

There is really no need to fuck with him. There is really no need to trick him unless they just specifically want to watch him squirm about it, and that's certainly a possible explanation for all his recent experiences but he's not going to react to that possibility by proactively making sure to squirm in advance. Whatever. He believes whatever these people say, the easy way instead of making them jump through hoops to make him, and the things they say add up to gluttony not really being a concern here.

<Would it be okay to try it even if I might decide it's horrible in the middle and want you to stop?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah, of course. My friend thinks that you might have more stamina if you were ever consuming calories, and I'm not that much more interested in chewing than you are but coffee with milk and stuff seems like the next thing to try. There's no commitment in drinking a latte.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Okay. Whatever you want.>

Permalink Mark Unread

So Ashkon goes and finds a nice coffee shop and orders a latte.

Sip.

Permalink Mark Unread

It tastes bad.

Everything tastes bad, though. Or at least, black coffee tastes bad, and that's all he usually tastes other than water and the inside of his mouth, neither of which tastes good. He only likes black coffee because he started drinking it when he had fewer taste buds and less tendency to notice smells and got used to it gently. The latte is less familiar and therefore even worse.

He doesn't gag. And he's not sure it's really worse other than being unfamiliar. Maybe they should try another sip.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon will go nice and slow.

Permalink Mark Unread

The taste is still... a taste, and therefore terrible, and it makes him start absolutely obsessing over how long it's going to take to finish it. And his stomach feels bad somehow in a way he doesn't recognize.

(If Ashkon has other experience with humans he might recognize some of these feelings as hunger.)

He doesn't ask to tap out, though. It's not going to hurt anyone else and if Ashkon wants him to have more stamina and this is the way to achieve that then who really cares how he feels about it. The way he feels about it was designed to hurt people, probably, unless he misunderstands what the demons were aiming for.

Somewhere hidden deep within the dearest and most hidden parts of his mind he finds a scrap of curiosity about what the other drinks taste like.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon takes three more widely spaced sips. Tragically he's never had a human host before. <I think maybe that's enough to push it for now, unless you really want me to keep going.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary shrug. <You can do whatever but I don't really want that. I hope you end up wanting to try different ones, though?>

Possibly right now. He's sort of oddly interested in this now.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Sure. There's a ton of kinds.> He tosses the latte.

Permalink Mark Unread

He refuses to feel bad about wasting food. He wants to see the list of drink options.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon obligingly looks up a taxonomy of kinds of coffee beverages while riding the bus back to school.

Permalink Mark Unread

The most important information he gleans from this is that different kinds of coffee have different amounts of caffeine and he could be drinking so much less coffee. Temporarily. Until his tolerance creeps up so much that he has to drink plain espresso by the quart. He really hates everything about coffee except the being awake part.

There are kinds that have chocolate in them. He doesn't have any idea what chocolate tastes like but people seem to really like it, so maybe it's worth a try.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Next time we can get some kind of mocha espresso thing.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary shrug.

He tries to imagine what it might taste like, since it's apparently supposed to taste good and he can probably on that basis derive what it tastes like from first principles by imagining what might taste good. Only he can't imagine anything tasting good. He can imagine a taste that's... unusually not very bad?

Permalink Mark Unread

<Maybe we should put a lot of sugar in it, I think most humans like sugar.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I'm up for trying that once.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Back in the college town. A medium sized walk to the campus.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's so nice here. He's so lucky to be here. He wonders if the coffee shops are also very pretty here, if they even have those.

Permalink Mark Unread

<If there are Elf coffeeshops they are definitely gorgeous.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He’s excited to see them and try their weird drinks that probably all suck! As long as there really definitely aren’t starving people who will miss out on not starving because of this. Or at least will definitely not be tortured forever after they starve to death, that's really about as good. It'll be cool to try things, anyway, though also he can't wait to know how they all suck and be done and be able to stop thinking about food again.

(They made him eat garbage just to tell him off for having done it. That's - not how he would have put it before spending months reconsidering everything in light of the idea that actually they were not angels, that actually they were demons, that actually they were lying to him about everything up to and including his own actions and motives. It's less humiliating from that perspective, and less miserable to remember when his body doesn't echo his feelings, but the memory still keeps lurking there at the edge of thought and he hates it.)

Permalink Mark Unread

<If there's anyone in Vanda Nossëo who's hungry it's because they decided to do that for some reason or are avoiding everybody who could feed them also for some reason, definitely not because there's any lack of food. Also they will not go to torture afterlives if they die of anything at all.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<That's good.>

The possibility that Ashkon is lying or mistaken isn't decision-relevant but it seems to be affecting his emotions anyway.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon will attempt to distract him by staring at a water feature.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ooh, nice!

Permalink Mark Unread

Mission accomplished. They can stroll the rest of the way to school and do their homework.

Permalink Mark Unread

Which is fun! And he’s useful!

Permalink Mark Unread

He's so useful and Ashkon couldn't do this without him <3

Permalink Mark Unread

At some point when Ashkon isn’t in the middle of homework he asks, <Hey, if you haven’t tried any other humans, do you think someone who has would be able to guess what I’d like?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah, maybe! I can ask around next time I'm in the Pool, or send some emails now.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary shrug. <Whatever works.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon sends a couple emails.

Permalink Mark Unread

Affection.

<Hey, am I...> It's hard to put it into words. He wants to ask if he's useless, but obviously not; here he is offering Ashkon his hands and voice. But lots of people have hands and voices, and apparently people can transform themselves, and at any rate it feels very much like he's in the way and the best thing he could do would be to shrink into nothing but a pair of hands and a voice. <Am I useless?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Of course not! - Yeerks can use demonic bodies. I mean ones apsels make. If an apsel makes a body there's nobody home in it, it barely breathes on its own. We don't like them. They're too empty, too lonely, I never even tried one because it sounded so awful.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He remembers what it's like to be so lonely it starts hollowing you out. It's a very respectable thing, a very important thing, just to be company. And Ashkon seems eager to make him happy, and being someone other people can be kind to is also very important; he just spent months being a professional person-other-people-can-practice-charity-at and he's not ashamed of that.

It still sort of leaves him at loose ends, though. There's nothing he's supposed to do physically but there could be something important for him to think about and there isn't anymore.

Permalink Mark Unread

<If you want we could save up for you to get the ability to make magic items, and you could do that while I was doing other stuff. I think a few Elves have Yeerks to look after their bodies while they work on magical engineering full time.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<How does that work?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<We'd wear a ring or a necklace or something and you'd enchant it by thinking at it. They make immortality jewelry this way and universal magic contraception and a few other things.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He's in favor of anything that results in fewer people being born and then potentially tortured for all eternity. And also things that prevent people from dying and potentially being tortured for all eternity. ...Supposedly neither of these things is actually a concern anymore, though.

Permalink Mark Unread

<We can try to think of something that affects people who have been tortured more than my first idea, if you prefer, but I'm pretty sure Vanda Nossëo's going as fast as it can and I'm not sure there's an obvious way for one person to make it go faster.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Why not?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Because it's so big. There might be something they're waiting on more magic jewelry before they go ahead with doing, or more staff, or more something, but there'll be hundreds if not thousands or millions of people working on all those things.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Even rescuing people a single day sooner would be something but he doesn't understand the explanation well enough to poke holes in it and anyway that seems to have been a fairly gentle indication that he should leave the whole idea alone and he has no reason to do anything other than be as convenient as possible for the people who have absolute power over him, however sour it feels to conclude that rescuing people isn't worth worrying about.

Permalink Mark Unread

<No, it's a good idea, I just don't want to get your hopes up that it'll have a big obvious impact as opposed to slightly lowering the price of contraceptive jewelry in a way that improves the economy very slightly or frees up somebody who used to work on it for something else and probably eventually means something big happens four seconds earlier or with half a percent better certainty.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Four seconds is enough time to rip off a fingernail.

<That’s worth a lot if there are billions of people affected but maybe not... enough to drown out everything else? I’m not sure I wouldn’t trade four more seconds for - I don’t know. Getting to spend an hour here instead of Lórien. Maybe not if - >

Maybe not if it was four seconds sampled from the worst stretch of time he’s ever been through, but he doesn’t manage to articulate that. He just - remembers, and that is the end of that train of thought.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I'll see what the loan availability is like for buying the ability and the lessons.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh yeah they were totally having a conversation about that. That is a thing they were doing. Probably that's a reasonable course of action? He doesn't have an opinion right now.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah, Ashkon doesn't actually need his help to do that, nor to put on a recording of some Elf music that he is supposed to be learning for choir.

Permalink Mark Unread

He’s not exactly excited about choir but he does like the music.

They should get to hug each other. Sure, Ashkon is arguably hugging his brain, and it’s great, but they really ought to have another physical thing to hug. Like a pillow or something.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon grabs the pillow off the bed.

Permalink Mark Unread

!!!

Permalink Mark Unread

Squish!

Permalink Mark Unread

That’s amazing. He has good ideas sometimes.

It’s weird having Ashkon do exactly what he wants to do. He wants to squeeze the pillow, and he can’t, but he is. He tries to shift position to make it less uncanny but whatever, it’s not bad, it’s just weird. He’s so glad this is happening.

Permalink Mark Unread

Askhon finds a pillow-snuggling position to continue studying in.

Permalink Mark Unread

Meanwhile, of course, first contact is happening with a whole collection of worlds. There are a lot of hell dimensions to empty or improve, affecting an estimated thirty five billion or so humans. Most of them will be uncomplicated, as people already working in the hell rescue field in New Jerusalem and Elysium count these things - people with extensive life experience on Earth, who have been through very bad but very simple torment, sometimes people who would be fine where they are if they just had the materials to stop eating each other, sometimes people who would be fine with a free apartment and a referral to a spiritual counselor. Local resources can't handle all of those just because there are so many; if Vanda Nossëo can just offer ten billion studio apartments and conjure a few hundred tons of infrastructure and supplies then the problem isn't complicated.

Then there are the people who grew up feral. There aren't that many of them; New Jerusalem can handle them.

And then there are the people who were not merely hurt and who didn't merely fail to learn things; there are people who are loyal to demons, or who were loyal to demons and can't prove they aren't anymore, or who think everyone else might also secretly be demons, or whose ability to interact with other people peacefully is thoroughly ruined. New Jerusalem has resources for them, too. (The Bastion and the Dead Republic don't. They're welcome to immigrate once they can convincingly demonstrate that they're no longer likely to make horrible neighbors.) Most of New Jerusalem's strategy is to funnel them to an institution known as St Edith's.

A representative of St Edith's gets in touch with the diplomats from Vanda Nossëo. They're going to be swamped but they expect at worst they can keep some of the refugees unconscious for a few years. They can take the portalsnack off Vanda Nossëo's hands if need be, incidentally, not that they're suggesting that will be necessary but it's their job to offer. But really they're hoping with all the new kinds of magic on offer they'll be able to improve their procedures.

Permalink Mark Unread

It is not at all hard to source a couple demons to make many identical-floorplan apartments in procedurally generated color schemes.

There is nonzero prior art on people who grew up feral in Vanda Nossëo - it came up in Limbo a lot back when child mortality was higher - but if New Jerusalem has a setup that works for them that's probably better.

The portalsnack decided he wanted to be a Yeerk host, according to this public list Tide puts out of who is understood to be supposed to have a Yeerk in them, so probably he doesn't need to go back but they can forward him an email. If they have any difficulty with keeping people unconscious they can work something out with the Poppy Gardens or provide stunners from Cube or something but probably they already know how to handle it at scale.

Permalink Mark Unread

The representative of St Edith's inquires about Yeerks and then perks right up. "How many Yeerks are there? I'm thinking they're probably a cheaper way of dealing with this class of people - we can let them opt out, of course, but it'd solve so many problems."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- well, there are millions, though a lot of them already have hosts, but, uh, not everyone wants a Yeerk."

Permalink Mark Unread

"If they object then they're already doing better than many members of their reference class at identifying and expressing preferences, and of course even knowing whether they object gives us some information about which of them are more likely to secretly be loyal to their old masters."

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's more of an 'affirmative consent' thing than an 'if they object' thing."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You really can’t use that standard with this population."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeerks kind of have to, in fairly recent memory they were enslaving people left and right and the new standard is much better for everyone. Does this mean that the specific guy we got was in better shape than most similar folks, if he managed to communicate that he definitely wanted a Yeerk?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"In that area if it had anything to do with wanting a Yeerk and not, say, wanting to make sure the Yeerks couldn't have any complaints about him. Are there non-Yeerk options that haven't enslaved people in recent memory?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Options for what exactly, I'm not sure what you're hoping for from the Yeerks here."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Checking for sleeper agents. Making people more functional and less prone to do things that don't achieve their goals or anyone else's."

Permalink Mark Unread

"We have truth magic, if that will do for the sleeper agents and they'll answer questions at all. I don't think Yeerks make people more functional, they just sort of act as - functionality prostheses - and at any rate have their own things they want to be doing with their lives."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think you might not grasp the average level of functioning we're talking about. Sometimes these people will do absolutely nothing, literally just lie wherever they're put. Sometimes they get antsy if they don't have a list of things that will get them tortured, and they try to provoke you and when it doesn't work they just keep escalating. When they don't refuse to eat they have a tendency to steal food no matter how well-fed they are. When they don't accommodate everything anyone in authority asks of them instantly they have a tendency to refuse to follow laws on principle. The ones that come here capable of doing work usually don't stay capable of it, they usually fall apart once they realize how gentle the consequences are for failing to do anything. And that's not even getting into the ones who believe in this horrible cult they're trained into and will try to evangelize. They're mostly not allowed into most decent polities that know they exist. Sometimes it reflects a lot of work and a lot of improvement for them to be capable of sitting in their own apartment watching cat videos all day. There's, often enough, nothing there to conflict with anything a Yeerk would want to do. And if there is, they won’t share it or sometimes act on it at all, and it seems to me they’d mostly be better off if someone who cares took a peek and learned what it would take to make them happy."

Permalink Mark Unread

"So our baseline for horribly - albeit differently - tortured people is to put them in a magic forest that reshapes itself according to what will be most comfortable and soothing for the occupants. I'd be more inclined to strongly recommend it if the one example we have hadn't walked right out and reported disliking it, but that might be individual variation...?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"That is unusually agentic... hang on..." She frowns, biting her lip, and checks something on her phone. "Our intelligence knows who that is, I think, but I don’t know why he'd be particularly likely to object to a magic forest. I guess in general we see a lot of... ambivalence about anything restful or pleasant, maybe that’s it."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Well, apparently his Yeerk wanted a host so he could enroll in music school, so that's what he's doing now. You think the restful pleasant forest will often go over poorly?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I wouldn't have said so if I hadn't known it did but maybe it noticed that any time he's not being tortured he must be waiting for the other shoe to drop, or maybe it tried to encourage him to sleep and he panicked. If it was either of those things, it won't be unique to him."

Permalink Mark Unread

"They don't like sleeping?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"They're trained not to like anything... restorative, sometimes only if they don't have permission. So they're useless and unhappy all the time even when rescued. It varies how well it takes and of course some of the newer rescues won't have been there long."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay. I do worry that they won't be able to - manage their end of making sure the Yeerk-host relationship is okay? Like, usually, there's an opportunity to check in when the Yeerk needs to go soak up some Kandrona radiation, but if they won't say anything then making sure they were okay with this approach would involve not only Yeerking somebody unresponsive in the first place but also having to take their Yeerk's description of the situation as accurate, which could be augmented with the truth magic but is still vulnerable to some - spin."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not saying you shouldn't put them in the forest, it might be good for them even if they don't like it. I suppose you could have two different Yeerks take a look and see if they agree?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"That seems more invasive and also it might be hard on the Yeerks, a lot of them get attached to their hosts very quickly."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I see."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Maybe we can put together a pilot program and if it works well we could fund some resurrections to get more Yeerks available."

Permalink Mark Unread

"All right. What do we need to make that work?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Well, Sovereign Ristrell's buy-in, for one, the Yeerks are mostly not citizens of Vanda Nossëo per se."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Is there a way that people typically contact her?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I can probably set up a meeting." Compute compute.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you."

Permalink Mark Unread

"It looks like there's a slot this evening at five."

Permalink Mark Unread

The representative of St Edith’s can make it then, after ascertaining whose five o’clock it is.

Permalink Mark Unread

Tide uses the Cube Earth's UTC.

"I assume you are about to give me an extremely good reason to cross the bright line that allows us to coexist with persons many of whom still bear scars from the Yeerk Empire's behavior," she says.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Is that something you get a lot?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I got an agenda briefing. I'm not going to say yes, if that speeds this up at all."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Are your people free to emigrate?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Not without morphing into something else first or by special arrangement. It's one of the reasons we're not part of Vanda Nossëo. There are a lot of people who'd like to kill every member of my species. I am not going to give them an excuse or let anyone else do it either."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I am not myself empowered to make promises on behalf of the military of New Jerusalem but it sounds like you could use their protection if we can find a way to arrange it, is that right?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"No. We do have an arrangement with Vanda Nossëo. But long term Yeerk civilization needs a record of inarguably on-the-level behavior. I cannot pull off the mass infestation of a bunch of incommunicative torture victims to that standard."

Permalink Mark Unread

Sigh. "You managed to talk yours into it and I don’t think he talks."

Permalink Mark Unread

"He didn't have a tongue when he arrived. With that healed he was capable of speaking."

Permalink Mark Unread

She laughs. "Really. I wouldn’t have done that."

Permalink Mark Unread

"No?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"You don't get anything for it. You don't get - awareness that you have abilities their old masters didn't, or practice with different ways of relating to people. You don't make them noticeably more comfortable. It takes a lot of work to keep their injuries from healing. There are hells that put that effort in just because their victims hate it. Their victims are a different population that I've never worked with and that we aren't talking about. You meet someone from the tunnels whose body is obviously changed, it's always something complicated. Usually something like preferring it that way and being ashamed to, or believing it'll keep them from belonging anywhere else but feeling like anything else would be a lie, or weirder things that I have fewer different examples of. It just makes it look like you've done something helpful. I'll bet you he didn't ask you to heal him and I'll bet you if you interrogate his Yeerk about it you'll find out he begged to be maimed. But I can see why not bothering to check up on that would be more appeasing of genocidal aliens than trying to skip the step where people spend months or years or sometimes longer starving and barely awake except the few minutes a day when they manage to have nightmares instead and either disturbingly eager to please or experiencing abject despair about the entire concept of human interaction."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You're welcome to ask his Yeerk about the details yourself. I'm a head of state, not Vanda Nossëo's charity arm or some kind of bizarre vending machine you put emotional appeals into and get Yeerks out of."

Permalink Mark Unread

Sigh. "Thank you for your time."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Of course. Is there anything else I can do for you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I suppose you could give me Cody's Yeerk's contact information - I know that's not his name but he answers to it - or pass mine on if you prefer." (It is theoretically possible that Ristrell might have paid attention to the right memories to have noticed that a barista declared that the guy from Fake Purgatory looked like a Cody and that ended up being the name they called whenever his coffee was ready.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"Ashkon 1159's email." She writes it out on a postit and hands it over.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you. You have a lovely day."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Likewise."

Permalink Mark Unread

After the meeting she emails Ashkon 1159 to ask if he needs help and also if he (or his host) has useful commentary on how they could improve their procedures.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Hey lookit.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Mrrr why would he have something to say. That seems like the sort of thing someone who wasn't completely incapable of learning anything about the world would do.

...It seems good when good things happen? He was doing sort of okay on his own at avoiding bad things but there's this whole other level of not-sucking that things can do and it's been very nice to have someone introduce him to things that are good. He doesn't have any idea whether that's news to anyone.

He's curious what Ashkon will say.

Permalink Mark Unread
My host and I are doing great, thank you! He likes music and pretty things. I don't know if that or if anything else will generalize, because I haven't met anyone else in his situation. I have some time at [click here to choose your time display preferences] if you want to meet in person and ask more specific questions?
Permalink Mark Unread

One of her underlings who hasn't spent longer than a human lifetime burning out on the whole cause area can meet with them at that time.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon can meet the underling in an Elf coffee shop, where he orders a cup of tea in case his host likes that more as a caffeine delivery mechanism.

Permalink Mark Unread

His host dislikes tea but in a guilty way where liking it feels almost like a real possibility and that's not quite as comfortable as uncomplicatedly hating it. Maybe the exact right tea wouldn't suck very much if it had milk in it. It might suck for it not to suck, though.

<Do you like drinking anything because that kind of seems like it might be easier than finding things I like.> And if it's worth trying then it might be easier to bring himself around on something he knows makes someone else happy.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Well, I don't know, I haven't tried anything with anybody else's mouth, but I like this tea. I might want to go smell all their other tea to guess if there's one that might be tastier.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<You can drink whichever of the teas you want.>

When he says things like this it's usually, at least a little, at least in the background, a statement of fact about the abilities of a well-organized polity with the ability to read all his thoughts and control all his actions, or a refusal to do anything so vulnerable as preferring one thing to another, or both. But this time it's just permission.

Permalink Mark Unread

The underling, whose name is Shadow, arrives and glances at their bracelet. "Hi, are you Ashkon 1159 and Arguably Cody?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes, that's us. Can I get you a tea?" Ashkon asks.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I actually hate tea and I was planning to see if they have anything icy and obnoxiously sweet later but that’s really less the kind of thing you politely sip at a meeting. Anyway, I’m good for now, thanks. So, hi, nice to meet you. Congratulations on not being tortured by demons right now."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Uh... thanks."

Permalink Mark Unread

"So it’s actually very hard to get useful victim testimony from the Underworld and almost anything you can tell us might be useful, but I recognize that this isn’t a very useful question. What have you, either of you but mostly Arguably Cody, found the most difficult about adjusting to your new circumstances?"

(He found it hilarious and charming to be called Arguably Cody the first time but being called the same thing twice is more like being named and that itches.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"Can you stop calling him that? His social worker called him 33, or you could just say 'your host' in this context. He found it pretty hard to get the information he wanted and not information like it must have sounded like he wanted when he asked people for help, is that the kind of thing you mean?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah! Can you unpack that more?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He dislikes both those name options (it's fine if Nocawe specifically calls him 33 but when it escapes its context it feels sort of like a name with a cute history instead of the most transparently halfassed nickname ever; it's really not fine for him to be primarily known as Ashkon's host because he's already deeply ambivalent about the extent to which he's just kind of a thing Ashkon uses and he would like it to feel a little more conspicuous that there's a gap where a name should be instead of feeling sort of like referring to a shirt or something) but he dislikes the idea of there being some connection between his feelings and what he gets called in this conversation even more so whatever.

He suspects that people who have a process more relevant to him than whatever it is they do to people from Angband wouldn't actually make the same mistakes about what he did and didn't already know but he's not confident they wouldn't make any mistakes. He wants to know what Shadow would say to some of the things he thinks he recalls saying to various officials, like asking how to interact with Vanda Nossëo or saying he didn't care about the laws because they didn't involve any torture, before he can venture anything even vaguely resembling criticism that might be relevant to Shadow's organization.

Permalink Mark Unread

"He doesn't know what your usual procedure is, so he doesn't know what the differences are, but -" To the best of his host's recollection he can reconstruct representative conversations.

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Yeah, I would definitely think almost any line of questioning about laws was mostly about torture. I don't think I'd say more than, like, 'I see' if someone said they didn't care about laws that aren't backed with torture, I would just guess that was just someone trying to get a rise out of me or see if I went back on the no torture thing. I guess also - so I work for St Edith's, and that's a residential program pretty specifically tailored to people who've escaped from the Underworld, so we can, say, expect that everyone there shares a certain amount of context, and we have things set up so there can be a small enough number of rules that we can just list them really quickly? Which is a thing we can do mostly because we're far from everyone else and there aren't random people who didn't opt in to being there except for, well, the people we serve, and they can leave. If they, you know, can."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Are... your rules backed with torture?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"No but try telling that to anyone who graduated Demon U. I have tried that. About the only thing that works is listing the damn rules and watching them break every single one and not breaking out the thumbscrews. There's a lockup but there are rules about leaving anyone in it for more than a few hours even if what they're getting up to is, like, trying to stab you just in case that'll be the thing that finally makes you snap."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Huh. This one doesn't seem to experience a lot of stabby impulses."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Not all of them do. It kind of looms disproportionately large for me as someone who likes my blood on the inside."

Permalink Mark Unread

He feels sort of surprised to be described as not seeming to experience a lot of stabby impulses. He thinks of himself as pretty easily convinced to resort to violence and downright sadistic.

But he did spend the entire time he was free refusing to do violence to anyone for any reason. And maybe Ashkon would know.

Permalink Mark Unread

<You shut down because someone exaggerated about getting nightmares! I guess in other circumstances you'd act differently but I'm not, like, constantly stopping you from stabbing people.>

"You should maybe hire limboites or fairies or something."

Permalink Mark Unread

Would this conversation benefit from his memory serving up a highlights reel of his victims begging? Would that help anything? Absolutely not but it's happening anyway.

Permalink Mark Unread

"That is probably a good idea!"

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon picks up his school satchel and hugs it. "What else do you need to know?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you know anything about the people who haven't previously tended to make it anywhere we can grab them from, that's something we haven't had a great window on, but I'll be a bit surprised if you do."

Permalink Mark Unread

He has a vague guess that those people would be the ones they can't use, and that since the torture only let up when they were getting what they wanted it might just not. But that's barely anything and he doubts it's news.

He doesn't know where they'd have kept people like that. He doesn't recall meeting any.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know much about your grabbing apparatus. He speculates they might have been harder to use, for demonic purposes."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah, that's about as far as we've gotten, too. Guess we'll find out soon enough."

Shadow totally has additional questions which this tag is too small to contain.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon will answer to the best of his host's ability!

Permalink Mark Unread

And eventually Shadow thanks them and offers them a business card. By now Ashkon's host has realized he doesn't really need to be consciously dwelling on the past for Ashkon to get information out of him and is contemplating whether it would be nice to try more teas today.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon bids Shadow a polite goodbye and goes and gets samples of all the teas laid out to smell. Sniff sniff. <I think I like this green one.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<You can try it! Do you want to try it with something or just plain?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I'll ask what they recommend.>

The Elf at the tea shop gets them a cup with a stevia leaf and a lemon wedge.

Sip.

Permalink Mark Unread

This... is... allowed. He would be making a face if he could make a face but that barely even distinguishes it from anything else. He hates it like twenty percent as much as anticipated, which is definitely to say that he hates it.

But it's something Ashkon wanted and he's proud he can offer Ashkon that and also he would like to either hear all about how great it is that he's tolerating this or not have to keep tolerating it.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I like it, and in particular like it a lot more than coffee, though it's possible we should be getting caffeine by taking pills with water instead of by drinking beverages at all.>

Permalink Mark Unread

They can do that? Maybe they should do that!

<I think I remember you saying something before about fancy beverages improving my stamina, though?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Calories might do that, but it doesn't have to be a caffeinated beverage. We could drink smoothies or shakes or something, and take caffeine pills.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He's nervously tentatively in favor of this plan.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ahskon pays for the tea and heads to the school store and asks about caffeine pills, whereupon the proprietor tells him that actually there's a song to skip sleep, would that do?

Uh, probably! replies Ashkon. Wow, I guess I forgot about that because back when I read a list I couldn't sleep.

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary cackling.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Sorry!> says Ashkon sheepishly, and the Elf supplies dosing information but clarifies that it's for normal living people and the caffeine doses they're accustomed to would certainly kill one of those so they'll probably be fine, worst case is passing out and being asleep for a while so they should tread somewhat carefully in case Ashkon gets stuck. Probably Ashkon can osanwë for help getting to the Pool if his host is unrouseable though.

Permalink Mark Unread

<...Should we make sure people know where to find us all the time while we’re testing that?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Neither of us is in the habit of shielding that we exist, so they'll know, but yeah, I should warn people.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Or they could sleep. That would be a completely pointless waste of Ashkon's time and kind of miserable but it is kind of oddly appealing.

Permalink Mark Unread

<The nightmares are pretty bad but if they're not bothering you we could also sleep!>

Permalink Mark Unread

The nightmares bother him a lot but there's just this quality to his thoughts and to existence in the first day of being awake that's so bright and clear. Coffee takes the edge off the exhaustion and keeps him on his feet but it doesn't really let him feel like that all the time. He used to also really desperately miss getting to stop being on edge and being able to safely let his attention wander, and he used to only ever risk that if he was about at the point of feeling safe enough to sleep, but these days it's mostly not his job to be alert to anything anyway.

Permalink Mark Unread

Then that night they can put on the sleep song and have some horrible nightmares.

Permalink Mark Unread

He dreams that Pete is down in the caves being flayed. He spends most of the dream sneaking through endless caves in the hope that he'll find Lórien somewhere and be able to ask for help, but of course he doesn't find it. The emotional tenor of the dream is a little odd, with his body enforcedly calm; it's grim but he never really panics, and the realization that he's very unlikely to succeed doesn't quite spark despair.

When he wakes he tries to shift position as he orients, and it doesn't take him long to recognize why this fails, at which point he tries to grab their pillow and hug it.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon obligingly hugs the pillow. <It's okay. Do you want to check up on Pete today?>

Permalink Mark Unread

...Wow, he could do that, that’s incredible. He could just stay in touch with anyone he wants. Maybe he could even try to get back in contact with people he's already fallen out of touch with.

They should maybe have some tea first because he has a headache from not having had any caffeine all night. Or they can quit cold turkey. He's not going to argue about it.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon goes and gets a tea and emails Nocawe to see how to find Pete, given that he was dropped off at a bus stop. Nocawe is able to dig him up and forward on their contact information to him.

Permalink Mark Unread

He really ought to just list all the things he's vaguely sad about not getting to do and see if actually half of them are this obviously trivial. ...Fly. Have a completely perfect memory. Okay, those are probably not trivial, the important category is probably things that he's used to not being able to do because they rely on the people around him being kind and also rich. Learn to sculpt? Learn how to grow every kind of flower? It'd feel stupid, having all these things occur to him only now that his body is busy doing something else, but realistically it's not a coincidence and if he were by himself he might not have any fun even if it did occur to him to try gardening because he'd spend the whole time distracted by the background misery of existence. And - well, the fact that watching Ashkon do things and letting Ashkon comment on his problems leads him to have a better BATNA each day than he had the day before does not exactly make him want to change anything.

(Pete doesn't really keep on top of his email. Probably he'll answer eventually.)

Permalink Mark Unread

<Flying is trivial, we can go morph a bird after my next dunk in the Pool! Completely perfect memory is doable but not cheap. I bet Elves know things about sculpture and flowers, I could take some non-music courses sometime once I'm good enough to practice singing while doing something else or while you're doing something else with your hands.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<3!!!

They can probably figure out some way to split their body so they can both do things at the same time and also he doesn't freak out about it being very weird and wrong for his body that he is actively using to do things he didn't make it do. Eventually. He doesn't know whose emotions their heartbeat would track if they did and now he's wondering if that general category is separable from everything else. Also he doesn't know enough about morphing to have a clear picture of what this would be like but he's excited to find out.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah, autonomics are separable from everything else, I have actually pretty fine grained control over what I let you do. Me singing while you sculpt or garden is super doable.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Maybe that'll be nice at some point. (It'd be nicer if it were anything other than singing. The best he can say for singing is that it's important to someone he cares about and he's glad to be able to help even if it kind of sucks. In hindsight it was kind of questionable to match him with someone who wants to sing but too late no takebacks he's fond of this one.)

Permalink Mark Unread

<3.

Permalink Mark Unread

<3.

Permalink Mark Unread
After the next bunch of classes, Ashkon checks his email - still nothing from Pete - and sends one to a friend of his.

Hey, wrt taking the dimorphism for a spin, I think my host is from medieval times! What should we be reading to update in that department to get started on improving his comfort level wrt orgasms?
Permalink Mark Unread

...Wow okay what.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Oh, I just get the sense that if I wanted to try having an orgasm this would not be your favorite part of the day at all, and I think that is related to your cultural background though the intervening time in Hell can't have helped at all. I am pretty sure modern humans feel differently about it so I asked for book recommendations.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<...Was there someone you wanted to have sex with or are you just, like, completely uninterested in being a decent person, because - well, obviously you can do whatever you want. Never mind. I get it, I'm not going to complain.> He's just kind of surprised because Ashkon hasn't generally been anything but extremely careful and gentle with him. But even if he were going to be maximally demanding he doesn't actually mind, isn't himself interested in being a decent person anymore anyway, and was kind of sad to have failed to think of this during the brief period when he had an apartment and privacy and could have gotten away with it. He just kind of - expected Ashkon to care more about treating him well.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I'm not going to do it till you're okay with it, I'm just curious if you could get that way by reading things. There's nobody I want to have sex with and I'm not especially impatient about it.>

Permalink Mark Unread

That doesn't quite make sense. He doesn't object at all. It might be kind of nice, maybe, and even if he doesn't end up enjoying it he's not really very invested in what happens to Ashkon's body anymore. It's just...

When they met he had no goals left beyond maybe trying to make his existence a little more bearable, and understood himself to be agreeing to pretty much anything Ashkon might want to do to him short of turning him into a flesh sphere with no experiences other than pain because that is the thing he specifically said he wasn't agreeing to. And the instant he found something he wanted to do, back when he wanted to run his hands over that stone wall, Ashkon let him. Ashkon has spent hours on letting him sleep just because he likes how it feels to be well-rested, even though there's no real reason to bother and he would never insist. He would have agreed to be Ashkon's host if it had meant signing a contract that he was agreeing to hand over every minute Ashkon wanted him for the next year. And he's not sure he'd still agree to that, because Ashkon has never taken fine, I guess I don't have any better options as anything but a challenge, because Ashkon has never just stood by and left him to his despair.

Would he abuse himself like that? Absolutely, he would and he has. And he'll accept almost any use Ashkon wants to put him to and it won't make him want out and it won't make him regret signing up for this. He really expects, on the object level, it'll be a relief. He's not sure how much more okay with it he could possibly get short of begging.

But it turns out it mattered a lot to him that Ashkon cared more about him than he ever managed to care about himself.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I care about you a lot. It's just, what I've heard from other people with human hosts is that it isn't actually an abuse. But I certainly don't understand it myself since Yeerks don't have sex any more than we have beverages, hence the reading material.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, it will probably be interesting reading material, and maybe it will explain something.

Permalink Mark Unread

<That's the hope!>

The email is turned around before Ashkon is done with the rest of his messages (mostly Tidal political opinion polls and something he's subscribed to that introduces a new microgenre of music with every issue). It has a graphic novel attached entitled Catching Up From Way Back When: The Sex Issue, apparently item seven in a long series mostly aimed at people who were resurrected from history.

Ashkon opens it up and makes sure his host is paying attention too and starts reading.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Okay, that’s a really good concept and he might want to read the other issues too.

Permalink Mark Unread
Ashkon goes and downloads them all. They do not have to be read in order, though, so he goes back to the sex one.

Depending on when you're coming from, this might be a difficult subject to think much about. We recommend reading it all by yourself so you aren't worrying about how anyone else will react to how you react, a bit at a time if that helps you feel more in control.


<Well, I guess we failed at that part.>
Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary cackling. <If you want me to read it next time you’re in the Pool I can do that.> But then he can’t play stupid browser games instead, and also can’t catch ways Ashkon understands it differently until later, and it’s not like his reactions would actually be private if Ashkon will just read his mind again later.

Permalink Mark Unread
<Yeah. I guess we should just ignore this part.>

Since we (the authors) don't know when you grew up or where, this book is going to talk about how most people in today's mutlicultural, multiversal society tend to expect other people to think. There's no one thing that most people actually think! This book is about the guesses strangers around you might make about what is most likely, the viewpoints that most customs and laws in practice today take as a starting point, the sort of opinion you'll see represented in most new publications and advertisements. You might not change your mind about anything at all as a result of this book, but even so, it could help you understand where people are coming from, and help you summarize where you differ.
Permalink Mark Unread

...Okay, well, that’s already kind of mind-blowing in itself. That’s such a cool attitude.

Permalink Mark Unread
We're also going to reference lots of other sources! This book is about getting you to the point of knowing what things may have changed since you were last around. It's not a guide to dating, it's not pornographic, it's not a history course, it doesn't have any product recommendations besides more books - but if you might want those things, check out the endnotes to see where we did our research.

We've divided this book into the following sections:

1. Modesty and Privacy - what will people be wearing at the bus stop? What is rude to bring up in a social setting?
2. Solo Stuff - this one's about masturbation, how we talk about it, and some stats and science to explain it.
3. Flirting and Pining - this is much more of a do-it-yourself enterprise than it used to be!
4. Partnerships - what assumptions does it invite to say "my wife"? "My boyfriend"? "My other boyfriend"?
5. Formal, Casual, Professional - are partners the only people we have sex with? When and why might somebody else be in the picture?
6. Spiced Up - some people's sexual impulses are hooked up to things that are a little less popular!
7. Bundles of Joy - do babies come into all this at some point? Well, not necessarily!
8. The Great Big List of Exceptions - How do Elves work? What's up with Eclipse? Do I really have to learn about all these intersex conditions?
8. Sample Conversations - scripts demonstrating how an exchange can go well or poorly in different settings with different topics and people.

The contributing authors of this book also have an advice column called Sexed Up, which is a good place to check if you feel this volume's inadequate. We had space limitations!
Permalink Mark Unread

That's... uncomfortable, and being made to read it while someone reads his mind is really even more uncomfortable but at least sort of in a fun way, only that feels intensely rude since Ashkon can't just stop noticing how he's feeling, only there's basically no way he's going to get through this entire book without having sexual thoughts.

<I think maybe I want to follow their instructions after all.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Okay. That works fine for me.> He closes the book.

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary sigh of relief. Confused vague affection.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Love you <3>

Permalink Mark Unread

He does not know how to articulate the question he suddenly has about that and whether it's related to the previous topic but he sure does have a question about that.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don't think Yeerks really do romantic feelings without something weird going on. It's just something I want to get around to trying one day, like you'd like to try flying.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Are there bird people who feel vaguely judgmental of his taste. He doesn't actually care if there are. <Okay, so you're just culturally appropriating having an orgasm? Do I understand cultural appropriation right, I'm really not sure I do.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah, pretty much. I don't understand it either but the thing you're thinking is pretty much the right thing.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary nodding.

This feels like it maybe suggests another question but he can't make it come together and maybe it will once he's read the book. ...Waiting for it to be time to read the book is going to suck.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I think different pairs come down different ways about whether it counts as having sex with each other if any happens while they're together.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Which way do you mean it?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don't know yet. I think I could go either way on it.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Will you tell me which before you do anything?> He doesn’t care very much which it is but he cares a lot about being on the same page.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I won't know for sure how I'll feel about it till I try it, unfortunately...>

Permalink Mark Unread

That is pretty upsetting, but he's not going to make any demands about it. Of course not everything can be nice. He kind of wishes he didn't exist but even if that were easy to arrange he wouldn't make Ashkon figure out a new host right now while he's in the middle of something.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I'm not even sort of in a hurry about this, maybe it'll become clear later somehow?>

Permalink Mark Unread

He doesn't really understand anything that's happening but he feels vaguely affectionate about that attitude.

Permalink Mark Unread

<3.

Permalink Mark Unread

It feels like an unreasonably long time to wait with the reading homework hanging over him but it is eventually time.

He was really hoping for his life to contain absolutely nothing like this for a long time. People making claims is stressful - it's better, and more interesting too, when they're teaching Ashkon how to do things, rather than just making statements that can't easily be tested - and it's stressful to have an assigned job, though not half as much so as having his eyes held open and being forced to look at a book full of claims about sin and society that he's expected to pay attention to while someone reads his fucking mind to confirm that he's paying enough attention. But at least the book doesn't claim to be about what is actually right and wrong, or even about what people actually care about, so that's something. And Ashkon could just force him so he's not about to refuse because why would he give Ashkon less of what Ashkon wants just for having mercy?

He sits near the fish. He keeps all his thoughts private. He skips ahead to chapter two in case it happens to contain all the information he needs right now.

And the book...

...actually, free to think, able to think, and in no particular hurry to memorize anything, he doesn't feel like it's worming its way into his mind. He doesn't feel like it's very persuasive about anything at all. He probably ought to believe it, since he wouldn't rather be made to believe it, but the closest he gets is doing extensive reasoning about what might follow from the book's claims if they were true and resolving to act as though he believes them. But there's not a lot to be done about the idea that some people think that some other people think that it's important to only masturbate in ways you're comfortable with. None of this actually matters to him at all. He's not going to get involved in anyone else's business. For so many reasons it didn't even occur to him to worry about going blind. He's not sure he cares whether anyone realizes he also thinks sex outside of wedlock is wrong. For that matter, he's not sure he cares whether sex outside of wedlock is wrong. What would be the point of caring about that? He cares about torture, and he cares in a very tentative and fragile way about music and decorations and flowers and the sky and not being in Lórien. He doesn't really have the ability to make choices about right and wrong, not even if he wanted to. He doesn't have the ability to independently verify any claims about reality, not when people can read his mind and check what would convince him, so why bother having moral convictions? Even the world's wisest philosopher could hit someone in the nose if he were trying to navigate in blinding fog while also deaf and incapable of feeling objects and having no sense of smell or direction or movement. And he's probably not the world's wisest philosopher. And that's in addition to the thing where the fact that he can ever move any part of his body at all is just down to other people's mercy. He's already been warned that if he's disobedient they can take his freedom of movement away. He can make choices, a little, sort of, by asking for things from his unaccountably generous new masters, and they've been very kind and he has no real complaints, but it'd be silly to imagine that makes him a moral agent. He's a pet.

And this is the wrong chapter to be reading, anyway. Unless he wants to get off right here right now, he isn't well described as having any solo sexuality at all. He's just reading this to try to understand why Ashkon thinks it's okay to use him for this. Which is exactly the only thing he said he wasn't offering anyway, so maybe he should just call it quits.

And maybe he gets it now, anyway. Maybe the idea is that if he has no complaints then it's fine because the badness is located in the fact of him having complaints, even if he can't voice them aloud. Only how exactly does that square with how Ashkon has taken every opportunity to help him have more preferences?

...Now that he thinks about it that way, and without Ashkon keeping his heart steady, he really doesn't like that either. It's a kind thing for a generous friend who can predictably protect him from most harm to do. It's a terrifying thing for someone with absolute power to do. But he wasn't complaining about it and he's going to keep not complaining about it.

Sort of.

His complaints matter, in this model, even if he can't voice them. Maybe they matter even if he can't voice them even to himself. Maybe vague inchoate unease also matters. And he does have plenty of that. And maybe the deliberately suppressed wish for the pain to let up for a while is also the kind of thing that Ashkon objects to.

This doesn't really make it easier to be a passive tool that happens to be blessed with the ability to enjoy things. And it doesn't really make him more comfortable with... anything, really. He doesn't want to try to navigate some kind of horrible catch-22 where if he has any misgivings about anything that thing becomes wrong and his misgivings become justified forever. He doesn't want to make Ashkon try to navigate that. He wants it to be as simple as having already fucking said that Ashkon can do anything short of turning him into an immobile sphere of pain. He doesn't want to analyze his feelings to death for signs of inadequate joy. He doesn't want to try to care about more things. He doesn't want to hear more about acting like a decent person. He doesn't want to satisfy his curiosity about how exactly this fits with everything else about Ashkon. He doesn't want to have to do moral philosophy, and he doesn't want to have a choice between doing complicated moral philosophy and not knowing what to expect from the person who controls every aspect of his life.

He wants to hit his head on something hard until he passes out but he's not sure if that would bother Ashkon while he was healing from it.

He wants to stop having his mind read but if that means being dumped back in the apartment alone... well, it would suck, but he could put a garden on the balcony and get coffee from the replicator and play games. It wouldn't be good, but it wouldn't be constant agony. It would just be such a waste, to leave Ashkon without the ability to sing, to have no purpose in life, to lose someone whose company he really enjoys. But of course Ashkon will immediately see that he's bothered and - he has no idea what Ashkon will do.

But actually, so far, every time he's had a problem where Ashkon can see him, Ashkon's response has been to come up with some amazing thing he never knew was possible that completely solves it. He doesn't feel like that could happen this time but some of that is probably the constant unending feeling of wrongness that just exists in the background whenever he's alone.

...If he's not going to pretend like he gets to be a moral agent and he's not going to think about what moral philosophy Ashkon is following he can just take it as read that if Ashkon says there's some kind of justification, then there's some kind of justification. And he doesn't have to care what it is. And that doesn't have to matter to him, if whatever extremely justified thing Ashkon wants to do bothers him; and since he's not going to insist that Ashkon not do things that bother him, it doesn't have to matter to Ashkon how he feels about it. It was stupid of him to care about any of the details here. The only thing he has to have an opinion on is whether he thinks it'd feel nice.

...But the answer to that is definitely yes, but differently if he's just kind of there than if he's part of it, unless he doesn't know which of those it is, in which case no. And he doesn't know which it is. So the entire thing he just went through is completely pointless.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Ashkon's ready for you at pier 14," says VLADIMIR / ISSARM.

Permalink Mark Unread

He goes to pier 14.

Permalink Mark Unread

In goes Ashkon.

<Wow. Sorry about the homework.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He's not entirely sure how to respond to that. He's tempted to just mentally curl up small and try not to have opinions on anything but that seems like a bad idea.

<I suppose I could do it and you could just watch. Then it'd be really clear who was involved and how.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<That would work fine for me but we could also just not think about it for some amount of time.>

Permalink Mark Unread

But that would mean waiting even longer and he's already done all the unfun parts.

<If you want.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<It's really not urgent at all. I'm not going to stop you if you want an afternoon driving and go for it but I'm not asking you to and I'm seriously more in this for the music and not for the humanity-tourism.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Vague affection and also vague annoyance. <If there's a time when you don't have anything better to do.> Or, like, in three days. He was assuming Ashkon would think it was very rude if he did anything like that but that sure doesn't seem likely.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don't think it's rude.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Awww <3.

The thing where it's fine because no one's really bothered in the moment is such a charming ethical framework. It's so simple. It would have saved him from so many mistakes.

It feels very suddenly very wrong for his body to be so calm and comfortable.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Do you want me to go back in the pool for a bit...?>

Permalink Mark Unread

That sounds horrible but so does just going about Ashkon's life. And then on the gripping hand -

<I don’t want you to base that decision on how I feel about it. I’m a horrible person and you don’t deserve to suffer for that.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don't think you're a horrible person.>

Permalink Mark Unread

The last time he got off it was because he had the leeway to slip away ostensibly to use the toilet, because he'd been allowed all the water he wanted, and it was because someone he'd been assigned to help teach had burst into tears and he felt something about that other than guilt or grief or even the grim determination to do what he'd been convinced needed to be done.

That's not even it, really. What's worse is that he knew even at the time that part of what he was trying to do was break wills, but they told him it was what had to be done to make people fit for Heaven and he so desperately wanted no one to ever be tortured - that's not it either. That's practically sympathetic.

He believed them. He loved them. He would pass untold days or weeks alone and in pain and then finally one of them would come for him and he'd be so desperately grateful to see them, so absolutely delighted that they deigned to pay attention to him at all. He was devoted to them. Of course he did whatever they wanted.

He's been telling everyone they were good at what they did, but they were barely competent. He's been telling himself that they were good at what they did, and that it was hard to figure out that they were lying - and that's not even wrong, it was hard to figure out that they were lying, but it shouldn't have taken knowing that.

Maybe he has the wrong definition of "horrible".

Permalink Mark Unread

<I mean... that was pretty horrible. But I don't think it... reflects on you as you are now, very much, that you could be driven to that.>

Permalink Mark Unread

But not because he's any better. Just because now the masters he adores and wouldn't dream of questioning happen to be kinder.

<Do you think you'd do - I'm sorry, is asking that the kind of thing that gives people nightmares?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don't think I can have nightmares, at least not if I keep being a Yeerk.

I haven't really thought about what I'd do in Hell but sometimes I think about what it would have been like if I'd grown up during the Yeerk Empire.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He's curious about that.

Permalink Mark Unread

<The only way to do anything was to take whatever host you got assigned. Nobody could be very picky. There were a few consenting hosts... sort of... if you can be consenting once you'll be killed if you try to leave for fear you'd tell somebody. And then if you had a host you were in the military, there weren't civilian jobs basically at all. So even trying to amuse yourself in the Pool wound up propping up the whole thing. There was a movement to end all that... Ristrell's, she was a leading figure in it. But only a tiny percentage were in it. I don't think I'm that special. I definitely wouldn't have the idea myself and I doubt I'd have wound up looking like somebody they should bring in.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He can see how that would annoy people who wanted to do something else with their lives. The Yeerks do seem like they’d be pretty decent as slaveowners go - maybe slavery is just always bad, though.

<I’m sorry. Why don’t you think you’d have the idea yourself?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Because almost nobody did. I'm not a particularly original ethical thinker.>

Permalink Mark Unread

That seems like a particularly useless fault analysis that can’t possibly help with becoming someone who would do better.

But maybe Ashkon also doesn’t really have enough power or understand enough to be a moral agent. That would kind of suck but if it’s true then there’s nothing to be done about it.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I can't quite wrap myself around how you think about morality and agency. I could probably generate words about it if I were trying to impersonate you but it doesn't make sense to me.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<It's just - never mind.> Probably there's nothing he can say that would help. <What would you say if you were trying to impersonate me? About that or anything, really.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<In what situation?>

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, he sure has a stunning variety of great past experiences that he definitely wants to suggest Ashkon imagine having to live through. And then there are a few very specific situations where he remembers his exact actions, like the one and only time he's tried to make smalltalk with a neighbor on the balcony. Hmm.

<How would you panhandle as me?> This is an interesting one because his old strategy would just not work anymore. Thanks, Missut.

Permalink Mark Unread

<If I imagine... uh... showing up back in the park, with you, like you never left in the first place except for how I'm there and you have all your body parts... and then I needed to pretend I was you but couldn't instead hide from you or do something other than panhandling... then I guess I'd make one of those cardboard signs. Probably just 'please help', most of the other things you could put on one would be lies.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<...Would I go with "please help"? I guess there's nothing obviously better.> Snark would previously have clashed with the Tiny Tim vibe he was cultivating before and it might be sort of interesting to try it but he doesn't actually have ideas for that. <"Need gross sludge to irradiate slug friend"... probably not a good idea.> (Obviously most of the proceeds would go to Ashkon. There's only so much he could spend on black coffee and Pete isn't there anymore.)

Permalink Mark Unread

<I think you would, at least to iterate from.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<If I bothered to try anything but I guess I did specify that.> He could also just lie down and give up. It’s not like he’s any use to anyone other than Ashkon and this hypothetical specifies that they’re hiding how he’s useful to Ashkon.

Permalink Mark Unread

<If I weren't hiding quite so much I think we could maybe figure out some kind of day laborer situation.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I thought you needed an address to get a real job in America.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I have a friend whose host was an undocumented immigrant in America and managed to do work and get paid for it but I don't know exactly how it worked.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary shrug.

Permalink Mark Unread

<They offered to let me borrow her for a look at what a more baseline sort of human is like, but I wanted to check with you first.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Cool! I assume if they offered she wants to be borrowed, right?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Or at least is cool with it, I don't know if she's actively excited.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<So how is that supposed to work?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Well, if you don't mind I guess we'd meet up, probably here so my friend doesn't have to go in you or a fishbowl, and I'd go check her out and then go back to you.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary nodding. He's kind of distantly wondering if he also gets to meet this person but why would she want to meet him, he has basically nothing to offer anyone except a voice and a pair of eyes and the bare fact of having any thoughts whatsoever.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I have no idea if she'll want to talk to you.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary shrug. <It doesn't really matter.>

Vague sadness doesn't clash quite so much with what his body's doing as fear does, and so it doesn't feel cut off in the same way.

Permalink Mark Unread

<If you're lonely I could probably find an interim host so you could go do stuff without me missing classes, but I was hoping making telepathy friends with Elves would do it.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don't know how to make telepathy friends. I don't know how to talk to other people about math and that's the only thing I could even maybe have anything to say about, otherwise it's just - I don't watch television or read books or have hobbies and I don't know how to tell if it's a good time to talk to someone...>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Hmmmm... oh! I can get us an Andalite doodad that projects in thoughtspeak and you can listen to podcasts or something.>

Permalink Mark Unread

That does sound nice. Even if it doesn't help him make friends - how is he supposed to know who else would want to talk about the podcasts? - it might be nice in itself.

Permalink Mark Unread

<You can leave thoughts public without shoving them at anyone and then people can listen in and comment if they want and you seem receptive.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I guess so.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I think that's how the Elves do it, anyway.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He continues to not be in a good mood but slightly less so.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon arranges a meeting with his friend and her host. The friend dunks in the pool, and Ashkon puts his host's ear to the friend's host's ear.

Permalink Mark Unread

He's not sure if it would be too awkward to say hi. He really has no idea what to do.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Hi," says Ashkon in the stranger's voice. "Ready for me to come back?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. "Okay. Thanks, um, I didn’t get your name if you have one."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm Paloma." The body language changes, shyer and softer, when Ashkon lets her answer.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Nice to meet you."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Mhm, I hope this helps." And then she steps forward and puts her ear to his again. Shlorp.

Permalink Mark Unread

He just talked to another human and that is awesome!

Permalink Mark Unread

<So, first thing I noticed is that you are mindbogglingly hungry.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He can’t remember ever being hungry, that sounds fake.

Maybe he should just trust Ashkon.

He’s not going to just believe what he’s told about his own feelings. But he really wouldn’t know. <If you say so.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<It's not super noticeable without anything to compare but compared to Paloma it's pretty obvious. We can probably rig up some kind of alternative to eating while we work on that, or instead of working on that, but it seems plausible that if you weren't hungry you'd feel a lot better about everything all the time, apparently humans don't work very well when hungry.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I know.> Every way they changed him was to make him worse. (He doesn't know yet why it's worse to be a man and if Ashkon isn't complaining about it he desperately doesn't want to go back, but he's aware, in the back of his mind, that there is something horribly wrong with it.) They didn't want him to sleep because it made it hard to think, hard to question them; probably they didn't want him to eat for the same reason.

But he doesn't yearn for food. He vaguely feels like maybe he ought to consider doing something about it on principle, because making him into someone who cannot ever even want to eat was somehow wrong, but... it does very much feel like they did make him into someone who can't even want to eat. And - he's not, actually, in a position to make important choices, so it doesn't matter very much if his judgment is worse because he's fasting. If Ashkon would find him more useful if he ate, then -

Well, he doesn't really want being kind and considerate to be a notably worse strategy than being demanding and cruel. So he basically only wants to enforce boundaries about things that are so important that he can't see how Ashkon's attitude would matter. He said he didn't want to be made into an immobile pain sphere because that's bad enough that if letting him have boundaries is going to have any value at all it has to rule that out. Being made to eat would be very, very bad, but... well, no, not really. It would be the worst thing Ashkon has ever done to him. It would be worse than anything that happened while he lived in America. And he's gotten a bit soft, thinking of that as very, very bad.

<You can do whatever you want but I like the idea of some kind of alternative.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don't think there is anything wrong with being a man, Paloma isn't and that part didn't seem importantly different. We can try drinking different stuff and I can do some research about ways to not be hungry without eating.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary nodding. Drinking different stuff sounds kind of appealing, maybe. Or whatever Ashkon wants to try, it feels somewhat easier to try to be accommodating than to try to have preferences of his own.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah. I'll get recommendations and we'll try things.> Paloma has recovered her normal Yeerk; he fistbumps her/them and starts heading home.

Permalink Mark Unread

Whoa, fistbumps are weird.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I like them. Less sweaty than handshakes.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<3

Permalink Mark Unread

Back into the routine of music school. Ashkon's pretty good at the dulcimer.

Every day he tries a new beverage. Not caffeinated; he's tapering them off caffeine with pills and doing beverage search separately. He goes for thin smoothies, milkshakes, juice, milk and its imitators.

Permalink Mark Unread

Smoothies are sort of tolerable in the moment. He can tell himself it's important to Ashkon, and that probably if it were really horrible he could stop, and that he'll be more useful afterward. It's just that afterward he keeps dwelling on how tolerating things on the idea that he'd be more useful afterward wasn't really worth it last time.

Milkshakes pretty quickly reduce him to incoherent internal screaming. Juice doesn't, though it makes him want to gag. He had forgotten what milk tastes like, or maybe it tastes different here and now, or maybe both; he can distantly imagine what it might be like to like it.

He likes almond milk. That's putting it generously, maybe. He uncomplicatedly wants more of it, even if that's largely because he's starting to be able to tell that he's starving.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon drinks lots of almond milk and puts various useful nutrients in it in powder form.

Permalink Mark Unread

He'll try add-ons once each but hates most of them unless they're outright imperceptible, and having discovered something he likes he's somewhat less willing to tolerate things he doesn't. But if they try enough flavors they'll discover that he likes protein powder if it's peppermint flavored, and he can be only mildly grudgingly frogboiled into drinking real milk too.

He gets restless. He wants to maybe learn to climb things, or practice tumbling. He wants to run. He's not going to insist, though.

It occurs to him that he's being kind of stupidly all-or-nothing in his estimates of the power of Tide and Vanda Nossëo. They can be entirely able to control his every action if they want and still limited enough that making them do so costs them resources that would matter elsewhere. Ristrell mentioned a treaty; he should take that more seriously. Maybe they could be played off against each other somehow. There is no reason he should do that but it's a thing someone could try to do, and it means there'd be some point in thinking independently about - not really about right and wrong, exactly, but about what he might want the world to be like, and whether there's anything he can actually learn from the evidence presented to him by people who can read his mind and see the future.

He's still emotionally living in a world where everything Ashkon says is perfectly trustworthy because it would be more annoying to be forced to believe things. But he stops modeling Ashkon as a master who happens to be very nice and starts thinking of him as a friend who happens to be very powerful.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don't think I'm even very powerful, in the grand scheme of things.> Ashkon is swimming; it's popular around here. The Elves can catch fish with their bare hands. Ashkon is good enough at the walking on water song now that he can walk back to shore when he's done in the sea.

Permalink Mark Unread

<On the scale of my life, which is mostly just being your instrument.> There's gotta be an innuendo around here somewhere but he's not coming up with words for it. Oh, well. He is really into Ashkon singing magic, though it gets harder and harder to convince himself he can use that voice for anything else.

Ashkon's kind of right, though. There's some sense in which it'd be easy for Ashkon to keep him prisoner but their surroundings are set up to make that harder, not easier. There's a more useful sense in which Ashkon has such complete control that he can't even breathe without permission, but their surroundings are still basically set up to very sharply limit the exercise of that power. Ashkon is just some guy.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah, you're getting it.>

He runs and skips around on the top of the sea, trying to keep his footing and his song steady on the waves as long as possible. He doesn't usually last that long if he's not aiming for a steady well-planned walk back to the sand but it's fun and good practice.

Permalink Mark Unread

<3

His body was good at that kind of thing once. Maybe he could be again.

Permalink Mark Unread

Maybe if they drink enough almond milk with peppermint protein powder in it.

Permalink Mark Unread

That would be a lot of almond milk indeed.

He does sort of notice that he's a little hungry, though. And it's starting to be obvious what a difference it makes to eat something sometimes. That and occasionally sleeping. He makes more progress in math this way. He notices assumptions he's never verified and little notes of confusion that turn into important revelations about Vanda Nossëo and Tide. He's happy. He's whole, in a way he hadn't even noticed himself not being. And he's still not gaining weight and still not building strength or stamina.

He wants to try more things. Maybe someday in the distant future when Ashkon is done with him it would be nice to try more things than what Ashkon happens to be okay with. Or maybe not; it's still not a great idea to eat anything before Ashkon visits the Pool so probably after they part ways he'll never be able to eat again. And that will suck. (It's a when, not an if. At the moment he ends up better and more okay every day they're together but he's starting to be able to see that he will reach a point where he wants time for himself and privacy in his own thoughts. He's just not there yet and won't be for a long time.)

Permalink Mark Unread

<I could probably try eating solid food, it didn't seem so weird from Paloma's perspective.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Only if you want to.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<She likes chips. Maybe we will too.>

Ashkon acquires a bag of chips next time they're at a bus station.

Crunch.

Permalink Mark Unread

He hates them in the way he hates everything, which is maybe conceivably also well described as finding them too overwhelming and confusing to have a real opinion on yet. If he still wants to gag in a few more bites he’ll conclude he hates chips and not just that he hates new foods.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon chews slowly, tries smaller pieces.

Permalink Mark Unread

<3!

There is something fundamentally horrible about this experience and it would be nice to not have a mouth at all but it's... not completely intolerable? He could eat more chips. That is a thing that could happen and it would not be torture.

Next time he has control of his body he's going to research magic for not needing to eat. (He just skips directly to deciding that. There's no step where he consciously decides to consider whether there are solutions to his problem; there's no step where he consciously decides to think of it as a problem that might be worth solving if that were possible.)

Permalink Mark Unread

<Everything I found was something like you have already - higher quality, but still fundamentally 'not eating won't kill you' and not 'you feel okay and healthy if you never eat anything ever'. Maybe you'll have better luck.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<What if I morphed into someone really fat?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<That's not even the better class of that kind of thing, though it might be one of the cheapest. Fat people still get hungry and still don't work very well when they're hungry.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Ugh. Well, when there's time for research he'll see what he can find out.

Permalink Mark Unread

He gets his chance when Ashkon next goes to the Pool.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon is right. There's no really good magic that just makes people not need to eat. What is there that's more creative than that?

He could get someone to conjure food already in his stomach. That doesn't sound great - he doesn't really like feeling like he's just eaten, even with Ashkon keeping the nausea at bay - but it would theoretically let him skip the part where it has to pass through his mouth.

He could cut his tongue out again and taste things less that way but he'd still taste them at all and Ashkon is using that tongue.

Okay, internet, how does the digestive system work? ...Disgustingly. Wow, that's awful. Strictly speaking there's nothing actually stopping him if he wants to rip the entire thing out but that seems rude to Ashkon. The stomach is skippable, that makes the conjuration idea slightly less bad (but still bad). He wonders if any of the worlds with really impressive technology have ever tried to keep people alive if they had damaged stomachs. Hey, internet... great. (Not great.) They can fucking eat because high-tech worlds have clever strategies for connecting people's intestines to their throats. Why. The internet actually explains why, even though it's not actually mysterious; there's a human interest piece about it where someone mentions having expected to be unable to eat and to need a feeding tube - okay, internet, what is that - it's really hard to say if some of those would be an improvement. Probably the kind that passes straight into the small intestine through the skin would be, though who knows how complicated it'd be to arrange or maintain. It doesn't really seem forgettable.

(Of course the internet can tell him all about the use of tube feeding as torture. Of fucking course. Why would there be anything that wasn't used that way, ever, in all the worlds.)

He wiki-walks over to pages on parenteral nutrition and anorexia. Parenteral nutrition is probably too complicated to help but in theory it seems like the kind of thing that would solve his problem, if he didn't mind all the logistics; it's not like he can get liver damage, or complain about still feeling hungry, or most of the other associated problems. Probably Ashkon would mind all the logistics, though.

Or this might be the kind of thing that a wish could do, but it'd be a waste of a wish.

Or he could get stoned and hope it makes him like eating. That's not a very appealing option.

That's all he can come up with. Maybe some of it will be news to Ashkon. He's keeping all his thoughts about it public in case anyone else has anything to say, though probably that's not very likely to be helpful at the Pool.

Permalink Mark Unread

Not at this Pool. It'd help a lot if he went to Nest for some reason!

Ashkon comes back. <Yeah, it's not apparently an area anyone's working on. I can work on a song for it one day but I'm not there yet.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<3. It’s already very cool to be the instrument of Ashkon's magic; he’s excited for Ashkon to also compose new magic, while he watches, for him.

Permalink Mark Unread

<3!

Back to school they go.

With this topic publicly on their minds, eventually someone in Ashkon's lyrics workshop offers them a leaf-wrapped square of something like shortbread. This is lembas. You do have to chew it, but a very small bit can keep you fed all day.

Permalink Mark Unread

!!!

Thank you!

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you!!" Ashkon adds aloud, beaming.

He takes the lembas back to their room to try a little corner of it.

It's rich, and somehow simultaneously Obviously Not Junk Food and also sweet and indulgent, and that little corner of it is very filling.

Permalink Mark Unread

Gah. Why is it like that. Well, that was fast, so he approves. And who knows, maybe he'll decide he likes it. It feels sort of loosely possible that he could like it.

He is so, so happy.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon is happy too! He has a sort of inventory of how-well-is-this-body-working benchmarks that he now puts them through and they are doing solidly better than ever before!

Permalink Mark Unread

He'd like to instantiate his happy bouncing in physical reality for a minute, if that's not in the way of anything.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Go for it.> Ashkon backs off from the voluntary muscles.

Permalink Mark Unread

Bounce bounce. They should have something better than a pillow to hug but a pillow is what they have so he hugs it and twirls and then flops onto the bed and grins so hard it hurts.

He could keep going or he could be done, he doesn't really mind either way.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon takes back over, buries their face in the pillow, and then grabs the computer to a) look up where to find more lembas when this one runs out, which won't be for at least a week, but still, and b) to buy a stuffed nudibranch to hug instead.

Permalink Mark Unread

<3.

Permalink Mark Unread

He ends up liking the stuffed nudibranch.

Time passes. The lembas works; he puts on a little weight. He could leave it at that but in fact he decides to keep trying things, mostly out of curiosity and to have any idea what other people are talking about and a little bit because lembas doesn't come from a replicator and it would be convenient to like things that do. He tolerates a couple of apple varieties in tiny quantities; curry makes him curse the day he was born; vanilla almond milk sort of grows on him a little; plain white rice is bland enough that he doesn't mind the first bite but then it feels too tedious to take another. Peas not only manage to be better than starving, they manage to be better than living on just lembas, in the handful of extremely precise preparations he likes and in very small portions and not every day, and still not right before Ashkon leaves him by himself.

The nightmares improve. Not a lot, but a little. He dreams of discovering that you can swim in the night sky and making sandcastles on the moon and going to class and discovering he's forgotten Ashkon in the Pool. Mostly he still dreams of assorted horrors, but even then he often dreams that there's hope, that he's desperate rather than despairing or that there's pretty Quenya music in the background the whole time or that if he's very fast and very careful he can take breaks in the park.

He finds a math podcast and a little bit of fiction he likes okay. He tries, though not very hard, to figure out what he can possibly actually guess about how his actions affect other people and whether he wants to do anything about that.

He starts putting together plans - not real plans, exactly, barely more than daydreams - for the life he could have if he wasn't lending Ashkon the use of his body. In a lot of ways it would be a more limited life, not less - he might or might not even be able to keep one bite of lembas down, and it'd be harder to sleep regularly without Ashkon keeping his body calm and making it instantly obvious that he's not there when he wakes, and he'd have to worry about money again. But he could take up rock climbing. He could maybe consider taking up painting; sometimes he watches videos of people doing it and that's nice but he's not sure yet if it'd be nice to do it himself. He sort of knows how to talk to people, a little; he wouldn't have to be totally alone. He could spend weeks camping in a real forest that isn't Lórien, without having to worry about anyone having any bodily needs. If he got tired of beauty he could gouge his eyes out again and not worry about taking away someone else's vision. It's not a life he wants, on balance, but he's occasionally wistful about it. When he catches himself wishing he could join this online community about a sci-fi series he likes well enough to want to talk to the fandom, he starts actually trying to sign up while Ashkon is in the Pool one day, only to get stuck and have to wait and ask Ashkon to put something in the username field because he just can't.

He gets an email one day not long after that, from an organization serving people in some nice afterlives he wasn't lucky enough to go to. They've been looking for hundreds of years for a dead French girl. Her name was Helen. She died of the plague. She might not have wanted to grow up to be a woman. She might be going by Vivien. That's far more than enough information to conjure by. There's a mother and a little sister and the mother wants to set up a meeting.

He remembers having a little sister and a mother. He remembers watching the blackness creep up his hands and his arms. He doesn't remember ever being named Helen. He emails the supposed mother of this person he doesn't even really remember being that he doesn't talk much anymore but he can send email and if she's the texting-from-five-feet-away type she can come to the Pool while Ashkon is feeding.

Apparently she is. She shows up. She looks about halfway to tears. "...Vivien?" she asks.

He shrugs with an exaggeratedly clueless expression.

"I'm looking for my - child - I don't have a current name, it's been so long..."

He shrugs again and shows her the email he got about their supposed former relationship.

"For a long time I hoped you hated me," she says, sitting down on the bench next to him. "I hoped you just didn't want to be found because I'd been such a bad mother."

He has no idea what to say to that so he doesn't say anything.

"I gave to charity. For rescuing people. In case that was what you needed. But it didn't end up helping you. I'm so sorry. I love you and I missed you and I... and I missed you, and you were... a child any decent parent would be so proud of."

He doesn't know what to say to that either. If he had guessed he would have guessed that his mother was disappointed in him and maybe hated him.

She starts telling stories, asking him if he remembers them, and he mostly doesn't. She makes things sound so idyllic, except when she breaks off and says something like "I didn't really understand back then" or "times were different and made for worse mothers but please tell me you knew I loved you." (He just shrugs. He doesn't remember if he ever knew anything like that. He remembers that once upon a time he knew how flax became cloth, but he doesn't know it now.)

She sings. She sings something old, something he didn't think he remembered, and the words come to him before she sings them, and he nods vaguely in recognition. Only he can't quite convince himself that he remembers her. His memory holds a few shattered pieces of a picture of a very damaged person who probably tried and maybe failed to love a person he doesn't really remember being, and the person in front of him is begging him to say he believes something else, and is obviously devastated about the loss of this Helen or Vivien or whatever their name is, and he's been told the person he can almost-but-not-quite remember being is Vivien but he can't square the hints his supposed mother is giving him about who Vivien was with his own memories any more than he can square her with his memories.

He types an email. He doesn't send it, just turns the screen to show her.

They didn't give me time to reminisce. I haven't had the chance to speak of my childhood with anyone. They did their best in the mean time to drive me mad and destroy my memory. I have no idea what I knew. I have no idea if you were a good mother. It didn't make any difference. I'm glad you were luckier than I was or a better person or whichever mattered. I don't hate you and I wish I had ended up in the same place as you. I'm okay now. What do you do with yourself these days?

"Yoga. And I teach math to kids. I'm so sorry, Vivien."

It's not his name. It might have been once but it's not his name. It's a nice name, he supposes; he can see why someone who could want a name might want that one. He doesn't remember if he ever got to go by it but they can't have been so trans-accepting in rural France in the middle ages that it's at all likely. It's kind of distantly sad that now he never will.

"Is there anything you need?" she asks.

He shakes his head and puts on a somewhat plausible smile.

"If you ever do - or if you want to talk - or anything at all - well, you have my email."

He nods, smiles, waves, and goes and ducks into the bathroom to escape. He kind of wants to hit his head on the wall but he doesn't.

Instead he finally finishes an email to Nocawe he's been meaning to write for a while.

I have questions about Vanda Nossëo citizenship and what promises or obligations it involves on the part of the citizen. I think I explained to you before how and why I'm iffy on the concept of laws but it was a while ago and I was worse at talking to people from your general context and background then so I can try again if necessary, and I think someone I spoke to before said something that I interpreted (possibly wrongly) as saying I shouldn't seek citizenship if I'm not up for proactively learning and trying to follow the law. But I think my understanding of this entire general topic is somewhat confused so I would appreciate some help sorting it out or some clarification. Thanks.

-33

Permalink Mark Unread

(His username on the fandom site is waybread_instrument because a lot of usernames are taken already.)

Nocawe asks if he wants to meet at the next Pool trip or just correspond by email.

Permalink Mark Unread

Email is good.

Permalink Mark Unread
So, Vanda Nossëo citizenship doesn't exactly oblige you to obey more laws than you already were obliged to just by being in Vanda Nossëo territory. What it does is constitute buy-in. If you murder someone right now you might not be allowed to come back, but they wouldn't think they were authorized to imprison you longer than it took to figure out if you definitely did the murder, they'd just put you somewhere else - in your case maybe Tide but I don't think they'd want to keep you at that point. If you decide to be a citizen, you're saying, I'm one of Vanda Nossëo's people and I'm going to do Vanda Nossëo things and if I make a terrible mistake then Vanda Nossëo's justice system has jurisdiction over me. Does that make sense?
Permalink Mark Unread

Sort of. So if they take issue with me now I end up somewhere basically random?

Does it entail committing to doing Vanda Nossëo things, whatever those are? Or to specific things that Vanda Nossëo happens to be in favor of? Is it permanent if I regret it later?

Would I have to take steps to somehow further empower them or is it just a question of letting them know how I prefer that they act with respect to me?

Permalink Mark Unread
I don't think random, but I could see it winding up being something like a repurposed closet in Tide while they try to figure out somewhere nonrandom that will take you. Or you could always agree to go to a VN prison instead anyway, they're pretty nice. It doesn't commit you to any particular obligations unless you choose to take them on or take on a responsibility that includes them, like having a child or being elected to public office or something. You can renounce your citizenship any time. You don't have to take any steps to further empower VN though I'd recommend you get a bank account for them to deposit your basic into.
Permalink Mark Unread

I’m not actually going to break the law because I spend most of my time completely immobile. And I might not anyway because I’ve decided that even if I can’t know if I’m hurting people indirectly I want to avoid doing it directly and hope that’s at least better than chance. And I don’t expect to mind being in prison in Vanda Nossëo more than going anywhere else. It seems like not much would materially change besides receiving money, as long as Vanda Nossëo is how it presents itself.

But I don’t know what’s right and I don’t know if Vanda Nossëo is made of demons so I’m not sure if it would be appropriate to take steps that indicate buy-in or constitute an agreement of some kind. I don’t really think it’d be fair for the law to punish me because I don’t know enough to do right by other people, though it doesn’t sound like Vanda Nossëo is very punitive anyway. Is the money only for people capable of and interested in learning about the law and following it specifically because it is the law and they trust the government, or at least willing to claim that?

(It’s kind of upsetting that he thinks he’d mind being in prison at all. They have something they can threaten him with now that he’s happy.)

Permalink Mark Unread

<I might be able to get you work-released to me when I don't need to be in the Pool, they're pretty okay with alternative arrangements that aren't worse at keeping an eye on people.>

Permalink Mark Unread
Some Vanda Nossëo citizens are, say, children, and they still get basic income and so on. The law is affected by what the people deciding on it think is right, but it's not exactly the same thing. It's not illegal to, say, laugh at someone meanly even if that makes them cry, in situations that don't involve one of those additional responsibilities (so, it could be emotional abuse if you were doing it to your child, but to basically anyone else, not a legal matter).
Permalink Mark Unread

He didn’t think Ristrell would allow that kind of thing and also the hypothetical is about a crime he by stipulation committed despite being a host but in that case he is pretty indifferent to prison again. Yay.

Do they openly admit to making laws against things that aren’t wrong or are all crimes supposed to be bad even if not all bad things are crimes? Do they think giving children money is because of some kind of buy-in from the children?

Permalink Mark Unread
Some laws are about things that are more about coordination than morality, like a park making a rule against picking flowers because even though you picking one flower wouldn't making a difference everybody picking flowers at will would make a big one and a rule that only the first person to ask every week gets a flower would be higher overhead to implement. I do think the federal laws are all about trying to prevent some kind of bad outcome, but some of them are pretty speculative or indirect or complicated or controversial. The children are not expected to buy in, they just get the chance to opt out later instead of opt in.
Permalink Mark Unread

Does it seem to you like I should become a citizen?

Permalink Mark Unread
If Ashkon doesn't think it's a terrible idea for some reason he can see and I can't, I think it would make sense.
Permalink Mark Unread

<I think it's fine, at least on the scale of things you do already. You might wind up ruminating on stuff but you do that about almost all stuff.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<You really think so? It seems like...> Imaginary shrug. He’s already articulated his biggest concerns as well as he can. <I don’t know. Seems like it gives me strictly fewer choices if I ever break a law.> It’s less option value except insofar as money opens up options, which it doesn’t really if there’s nothing he can think of to spend it on.

Permalink Mark Unread

<No, you can renounce your citizenship and choose exile if you want, if you don't like the sentence you get. - Uh, you might want to spend it on subtle arts? The waiting list is probably... longer... if you can't pay them.>

Permalink Mark Unread

That seems like a good argument. He’ll at least talk to someone about it next time he has the time.

Permalink Mark Unread

On with Ashkon's life studying music as part of the exchange program!

Permalink Mark Unread

It’s a very nice life.

It does occasionally include breaks when his host can do things. He looks up where and how people become citizens of Vanda Nossëo.

Permalink Mark Unread

Here are citizenship offices conveniently located in any of these several dozen bus stops! You tell them you want to be a citizen and they can do it on the spot. They like to have a name and photo and a bank to drop your basic into, and they will take more info if you'll give it to them, and they'll give you an ID number and answer your questions and stuff.

Permalink Mark Unread

Fuck, he wants an ID number. That sounds incredible. He drops by one of those bus stops while Ashkon is feeding.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Hello, how can I help you today?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He does mean to say something but his throat doesn’t want to cooperate with that. He figured that might happen, though, so he has a note already written.

I was thinking I might want to become a citizen of Vanda Nossëo.

Permalink Mark Unread

This doesn't faze the desk person at all. "Great! Do you have any questions you want answered first?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He shrugs shyly and then does think of something he might as well double-check.

No one will expect me to answer to the ID number, right? It’s just something disambiguating?

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you didn't give any other name and they needed to call for you out of a crowd then they might hope you'd answer to it?"

Permalink Mark Unread

That hasn’t come up so far so it seems adequately rare.

What happens to it if I decide to renounce my citizenship?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Then we'd archive your file and stop paying you basic and regard you as a noncitizen if you came into contact with the federal system again."

Permalink Mark Unread

And I could forget about your number because it’s how you disambiguate citizens and not something you expect anyone else to remember?

Permalink Mark Unread

"A lot of people don't even memorize their numbers and just look them up whenever they need them. If you needed the archive for some reason we might want the number to find it by and you would have the same number back again if you ever wanted to resume citizenship."

Permalink Mark Unread

He smiles shyly and tries to hide it and nods vaguely and raises his eyebrows.

Permalink Mark Unread

"...shall I go ahead and issue you a number, then?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Did you have more questions?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He contemplates that for a while and then shrugs.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay, if you need a while to think that's fine. Plenty of seats in the waiting area."

Permalink Mark Unread

No, see, I don’t want to say no because what if I would have a question if I waited a century? But that seems like more deliberation than this calls for.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Are... you ready, then?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Plausibly

Permalink Mark Unread

"Well, think about it as long as you need."

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, that’s... really more care than he thought they wanted him to put into it.

He doesn’t really understand what it would even take to be sure. It doesn’t click like a mathematical proof.

He thinks for a while and then comes back with another note.

How am I supposed to know if I’ve thought about it enough?

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I don't know, I just... only make people citizens if they want me to?"

Permalink Mark Unread

That’s not very helpful.

He shrugs. He goes back to Tide. Apparently he will not be joining Vanda Nossëo today.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Ashkon is ready for you at pier three."

Permalink Mark Unread

He goes to pier three.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Home again!> says Ashkon. <...do you want me to go talk to them for you?>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary shrug. That does seem like a good idea.

Permalink Mark Unread

So Ashkon gets on the bus and back they go, soon enough that the same person is working. "Welcome back!"

He points at the bracelet. "Hi! My host got a bit tongue-tied. He does want to be a citizen," says Ashkon, "but ran into some mental blocks around being too committal about it. Can you take my assurance?"

"Uh, maybe, let me ask my boss." They type something.

Permalink Mark Unread

This is definitely one of the interactions of all time. He’s not actually sure if he wants to be a citizen but it does seem plausible.

Permalink Mark Unread

"He says we can take your assurance under a truth song."

"Great, start one up? - thanks. I am usually occupying this person and in that capacity believe he prefers and intends to become a Vanda Nossëo citizen."

"Cool, okay, let's get the forms filled out."

Ashkon fills out forms with his alien perfect executive function.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Why do you know so much about me? I don’t even know these things.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I think it's the simultaneous inside and outside perspective?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Huh.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Form form form form. Ashkon skips a bunch of questions that seem complicated; it's not like you get bonus points for giving them your religion or birthdate.

In short order Vanda Nossëo has a new citizen.

Permalink Mark Unread

Number? Number? What is his number? He’s so excited for there to be an unambiguously non-name thing that unambiguously distinguishes him in such a broad context. Probably someday someone will ask his name and he’ll have something to tell them and be able to anticipate why they’ll hate it! And they can’t argue about it or take it away, not like if it were a name he went by. Even if someone else refuses to acknowledge it and hates it and assigns him a new number it’ll be a different number in a different system of numbers; he can have two numbers but he’ll still have just one ID number from Vanda Nossëo. And they’ll probably know he’s not asking them to call him that. And even if they’re elves they can’t take issue with it for being ugly. And it makes a way to describe him without reference to Ashkon.

So what’s the ✨number ✨?

Permalink Mark Unread

56-7912-4522-6238-2739!

Permalink Mark Unread

It’s so arbitrary! It’s so void of patterns or anything that would make it stand out among other ID numbers! It’s so unmemorable, so faceless! It’ll be a bit of work to memorize it but he can get started immediately and also keep a written copy.

The organization that destroyed Purgatory (!) gave him this so they can keep track of him so they can give him things! The only context he could possibly be happier to be called anything in is if Ashkon wanted to use a pet name for him and that seems unlikely to ever actually be useful for anything and also like it might escape its context and try to turn into a name, so.

Permalink Mark Unread

<You're adorable.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<<3!! Hey, where does "1159" come from?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<In my name? I'm the 1159th Yeerk to be named Ashkon.>

Permalink Mark Unread

...That seems like it implies an incredible amount of recordkeeping and communication and also like it might cause horrible problems if two Yeerks got names in different places at the same time. It seems like it’d be awful if an extra Ashkon turned up and made everyone else change their names. He’s sure it wouldn’t be handled in the same way as name collisions were handled by demons specifically trying to handle them as badly as possible, but...

Permalink Mark Unread

<There was a pretty incredible amount of recordkeeping and communication but mostly they'd just allocate some names and number ranges for them to a pool that was going out of contact for a while and might have breedings occur in it. I'm not like, fond of my number, it's just a distinguisher from other Ashkons.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<What if they had more breedings than they planned for?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeerks don't reproduce by accident, but they'd usually overassign by an order of magnitude. So I guess it's possible there is no Ashkon to go with every number lower than mine.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Weird but cool.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<It makes sense to us but I'm told lots of people think it's weird to use numbers that way.> They can make their way back to school now.

Permalink Mark Unread

School is also good.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon emails Nocawe with his host's ID number in case that helps anything with the smoothing along of the subtle artist waiting list or reconciling her records with the federal ones or anything and resumes study.

Permalink Mark Unread

His host continues to enjoy it and also increasingly daydreams about a life of his own.

Permalink Mark Unread

In a couple of weeks they have a selection of appointment times forwarded through Nocawe. Most of them are footnoted "available only if it is OK to have a trainee sitting in".

Permalink Mark Unread

He’s okay with a trainee sitting in. He wants to go alone. As the one with any other commitments, Ashkon should probably pick the time.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon picks a time when he'll be in the Pool and makes plans to spend some of that time learning Quenya from a volunteer interim host then so he can rely less on osanwë.

Permalink Mark Unread

And the person known to Vanda Nossëo's bureaucracy as citizen number 56-7912-4522-6238-2739 shows up for the appointment.

Permalink Mark Unread

The subtle artist is a pointy eared person with coal-black skin and snow-white hair who looks very young. The trainee is an Amentan orange.

"I am called Vyn," says the first, "and this is Mahep. What do you wish to be called?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He makes a face and shrugs.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I will need something to put in my notes."

Permalink Mark Unread

He writes a note since he’s still not really up for talking.

I don’t have an opinion on what you should write in your notes. My ID number is 56-7912-4522-6238-2739.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Very well. It says in your referral from your social worker that you want a simple nightmare cure. Is that all you expect to want today?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He has a long prewritten note about this.

Subtle arts was originally suggested to me for nightmares. At this point I still have them most of the time if I sleep, but not always. As my nightmares per se have improved, I’ve noticed that even when I don’t have them I wake up thinking I might be somewhere else and afraid I might be in trouble for having slept, which I didn’t realize was a distinct thing when I was first put on the waiting list since I was almost always waking up from nightmares about being back there.

Currently, I'm not very bothered by these problems in daily life, but the reasons I'm not bothered circumscribe a very limited set of lives I can have. I host a Yeerk, who both directly prevents some physical correlates of panic and is very noticeable and therefore helpful for orienting; I'm also able to make what would be unhealthy use of sleep-skipping music and stimulants for a living person (which I'm not), but skipping sleep isn’t costless for me the way it is for daeva. Everyone has been very clear that I have a right to stop hosting a Yeerk, but I don’t have the ability to do that and be happy or productive. I would like to actually have that option.

I have other problems. I don’t know which are easier to treat or more important. I seem to be selectively mute; I think that's something I experienced sometimes before* but it got much worse when I started hosting a Yeerk who sings. I don’t exactly feel afraid all the time but my body doesn’t seem to know that; I have the parts of fear that a Yeerk can turn off all the time unless I do have a Yeerk turn them off. I get nauseated if I try to eat anything at all without a Yeerk making me not feel sick; with that help, it’s still really hard and brings back bad memories. I don’t need to eat, but when I fasted for centuries I was very weak and tired all the time. I eat lembas every day. I wish more of my diet could come from a replicator instead of consisting of scarce magic stuff. I wish I could eat by myself. I have flashbacks, if I understand that word correctly. I remember things I would rather not remember when I eat, brush my teeth, sit in chairs with backrests, touch myself sexually, see people wearing certain styles of clothing, think about theology, try to go to sleep without magical assistance, or wake up.

Originally, my intention was to say that I don’t want to be used to hurt others but otherwise consent to having anything done to me that anyone wants; if what that ended up meaning was just that I stopped having nightmares, that was fine. Then my intention was to say that anything my Yeerk was okay with and that didn’t hurt anyone else was fine. I don’t feel that way at all now, but I don’t have a positive vision for myself either, so I would appreciate your advice.

By the way, I expect to show up alone, but when I imagine my Yeerk going with me, I imagine him saying that I definitely consent to any mind-reading that would be helpful and that I have mental blocks around being too committal. He could probably pass a truth spell about it if he did say that.

*My memory sucks. It’s not good enough now and it was much worse when I wasn’t allowed to sleep and wasn’t given stims. I don’t think everything I remember really happened. I think it only takes about three days of not sleeping and not using any magic or chemicals to help me cope until I start hallucinating and having attenuated delusions, which I would like to change but I think that condition is called "being human" and it’s incurable.

Permalink Mark Unread

Vyn reads this through twice and then passes it to Mahep. "That was an extremely helpful history, thank you," she says. "Particularly easy to address with subtle arts are nightmares and flashback trigger associations. Some of the other things may also be straightforward to address depending on how you are mentally architected and we will investigate that today. I recommend that after we have solved some of your simpler problems you follow up with a mundane therapist who can help you work through more of these issues with a lesser premium on their time and perhaps train your Yeerk in assisting with a mode of therapy such as cognitive behavioral or Rishpa-Henj. There are magical solutions available to a poor memory but I do not think they are typically indicated in patients with your background. Do you have any further questions or comments before we begin?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug.

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you are unable to speak in this context please nod or shake your head. Shrugging is not admissible as consent to begin subtle arts."

Permalink Mark Unread

Actually he’s going to write another note about that.

So the thing you actually asked was whether I had any questions or comments before we began and while it’s sometimes possible to prove something can’t exist that seems to apply mainly to concepts like a triangle on a Euclidean plane with two right angles. Now I know that I do have a comment, which is this one. I think he might be right about me having mental blocks around sounding too committal. More to the point, I don’t know if I will have questions I wish I had asked later, but I can’t think of them now. I did come here expecting it to involve subtle arts and will be annoyed with myself if I can’t get that to happen because of my stupid issues.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Is there anything else you want to communicate before I begin doing subtle arts as I've described?"

Permalink Mark Unread

I can’t think of anything at this time.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Very well. This will if all goes well be very boring for you. If you wish to listen to music please use the provided headphones. The nightmares we must work on while you are awake, but in any future sessions it will not interfere if you are unconscious."

Permalink Mark Unread

Why?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Which of these remarks are you inquiring about?"

Permalink Mark Unread

All of them.

Permalink Mark Unread

"It will be boring because having subtle arts done to you does not feel like anything, and Mahep and I will communicate by telepathy while working on you. Music might distract us so you should listen to it in a way that we cannot easily hear. If you are asleep while we attempt to work on the nightmares, your proximity to having a nightmare might change meaningfully while we were manipulating it and complicate our work. Other work of the kind you appear to need does not have this problem."

Permalink Mark Unread

Why will you communicate by telepathy and is it a kind you could loop me in on?

Permalink Mark Unread

"It is easier to communicate by telepathy about telepathic concepts which are what I am instructing Mahep in. We could loop you in but would run a higher risk of errors if you reacted in such a way as to distract us, so the standard practice is for the patient to do something solitary that occupies them."

Permalink Mark Unread

Is your concern about physical reactions or emotional ones?

Permalink Mark Unread

"Physical reactions such as moving or making sounds. It is normal and part of what subtle artists must be accustomed to navigating for you to experience emotional swings."

Permalink Mark Unread

He considers this. He’s gotten a little out of practice controlling his body in general but he did get pretty good at it once. The worst thing they could do if they were trying to heckle him would be to remind him of -

- his breath catches but he will not move -

- of the time he fought them. And for once there’s a little pride in there with the terror. His hands don’t seem to be interested in staying steady enough for him to type but too bad, he’ll do it anyway.

I can just not move if it’s not going to be too long.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I expect this to take less than an hour and more than thirty minutes. Shifting position slightly will not disturb us."

Permalink Mark Unread

He’s not sure which gestures mean what to them but he does a thumbs-up in case they’re familiar with that one.

Permalink Mark Unread

Either they are or Allspeak covers it. "Let us know when you are comfortable and we will begin."

Permalink Mark Unread

He can get comfortable. He has a slightly feral understanding of whether and how to involve the furniture in this.

Permalink Mark Unread

They don't comment, at least aloud.

"Ready? A thumbs up to confirm will be fine."

Permalink Mark Unread

...Fine. Thumbs-up.

Permalink Mark Unread

Vyn nods.

It really doesn't feel like anything.

Permalink Mark Unread

Of fucking course. Why would it be possible to tell if someone is editing your very self. God would never be that merciful. He stays very still.

Permalink Mark Unread

Sometimes the two of them look at each other or go "huh" or "mm" very softly to themselves.

After about forty minutes, Vyn says, "That's enough for today. Please schedule a second appointment with our receptionist or through your social worker. That should be enough for us to complete the obvious work you require."

Permalink Mark Unread

By the time it’s been forty minutes he’s intensely miserable. He gets up, looking kind of shellshocked, and kind of stares at Vyn like there’s something he wants to say but isn’t even up for writing down.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I recommend bringing something to read or do quietly next time."

Permalink Mark Unread

That is not really responsive to his actual problems but why would it be. Continuing to stand here isn’t going to get a better response and he clearly isn’t going to do anything more productive. He walks out and then resumes just standing there once he’s out of there.

Permalink Mark Unread

Now he is on a bustling pedestrian-only street in Revelation's Savonlinna.

Permalink Mark Unread

He leans against a wall and stares at nothing. He wavers on whether he wants to bother keeping his thoughts private and eventually settles on doing that.

This was a mistake and he doesn’t want to exist anymore. It’s probably not fair to blame anyone else for his own mistake but he’s tempted to anyway.

There is really no compelling reason to move.

Permalink Mark Unread

Thirty minutes later an unfamiliar Elf comes up to him. "I've got Ashkon with me to pick up Quenya, but he says you were supposed to be back from your appointment a while ago and he's worried," she says.

Permalink Mark Unread

He’s not sure what to say or do about that but he looks sort of flatly at the Elf and - maybe she’s a flat one, that’d be convenient - sends the feeling of having fucked up and not being sure if he’ll ever be okay again.

Permalink Mark Unread

She is not a flat one, apparently. "Uh, Ashkon says he wants to go in your ear and see what's wrong. Okay?"

Permalink Mark Unread

He nods.

Permalink Mark Unread

She puts her ear to his. Shlorp.

Permalink Mark Unread

He should have asked something but he can’t think what. He shouldn’t have mentioned anything more than nightmares. He shouldn’t have come in the first place. When it was obvious he wasn’t going to be comfortable with it he should have walked out instead of quietly intuiting the script they were on and playing it out, only he really did think he might have succeeded in communicating that there was no reason not to tell him anything - and when it was clear he hadn’t, it was too late, they didn’t want to be disturbed - and still, he kind of thought Vyn might bother to tell him afterward instead of leaving him to guess what changed. So now he doesn’t know himself. But if anything is actually good or helpful you have to beg for it because the fucking Andalites have singled out the Yeerks to threaten genocide against instead of anyone worse. (Would he have thought that yesterday? It’s impossible to say!) He’s desperately hoping Ashkon can give him a list and also that the list won’t suck.

He kind of thought Vyn might at any point not make communicating unnecessarily hard but why would he imagine that that might happen. Maybe he should have taken that as a hint but it wasn’t the case that Vyn had always done that until they were done. And he’s not fond of how Vyn talked to him afterward - no if you like what I did, just schedule another appointment, and he certainly doesn’t require anything (or at least he didn’t but now who fucking knows!), certainly not obviously. He can’t imagine that anyone could ever blame Vyn, because - of course - Vyn insisted on getting explicit consent which is something he’s never giving another stranger again ever for anything. He hopes Vyn dies and can’t be resurrected and gets no afterlife. He would give almost anything for today to be some precog's nightmare but he could never afford that and didn’t know in advance that he wanted to. So failing that he just wants to stop existing, which might even be possible, maybe, only if he says yes to anyone they can do whatever they want and blame him.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I love you. I've got you.>

Ashkon thanks the Elf and walks back into the office and marches up to the receptionist. "My host needs a complete after-session summary delivered to his email. Is there a place to leave a review of the artist he saw?"

The receptionist gives him a review site and says she's sent an order for an after-session summary to Vyn.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Why is Ashkon always so good at things. It seems conceivable that maybe things might turn out okay.

He doesn’t really have warm feelings like affection in him right now and he doesn’t think he should try to predict his own choices or make any important choices right now. But it feels like there’s a sense in which it wouldn’t be entirely a lie to say he loves Ashkon too.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon thanks the receptionist, walks out, and hits the bus stop to go home and hug the nudibranch.

Permalink Mark Unread

He doesn’t feel like he exists but that’s an improvement over how he was feeling. He doesn’t feel much about the hug but he appreciates it on an intellectual level.

<Should’ve brought you. Or just not done it but.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<It made sense to want to go alone. It made sense to want help.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<And now I know what to spend my money on.> Keeping a precog on retainer, if he can afford it with merely his entire basic income and comes out of this wanting anything other than to stop existing.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon does a quick check. It is too expensive for merely one's entire basic income if you want anything more complicated than death insurance.

Permalink Mark Unread

Unfair! Maybe he should go to Eclipse himself since he could fast for however many years control training is.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Oh, you could! I'm not sure it's the best possible idea but it's an interesting synergy.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah, there’s no actual reason to think giving him magic is a good idea. Fair enough.

Permalink Mark Unread

<Oh, mostly I meant that now you're used to being fed you might not be happy with going back to starving.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<It’s not that long, right? And then you have magic for the rest of your life, right?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<It's a couple of years and yeah, though it only works in the Eclipse neighborhood.>

Permalink Mark Unread

So not that long.

How long do they have to wait for that email? Not that it will necessarily be honest but then again apparently he could have been secretly dishonestly edited at any time since the snake so it’s not especially likely that it would have happened today, today's a notably bad day for that.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I'm not sure how prompt she'll be. Probably has to fit it in between appointments and it'll depend if she already has a backlog.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Imaginary fist-clenching. <What do you think I should say in a review?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Do you want to write it? I can do it for you, though I was going to wait till we slept to see if she actually did fix the nightmares or if there's also that to complain about.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I wasn’t thinking about doing it now. I just wanted to know...> The thing is, he's been refusing to care what other people think is good behavior, but a review is all about whether Vyn lived up to other people's standards. No one will care if he has his own standards that say something bad happened; the way they take that into account is consent and he consented. Did Vyn even do anything anyone else would object to? (He doesn’t quite feel like he did consent to that, but he can’t afford to let people think he can’t be trusted when he says he wants something or they’ll take Ashkon away.)

It seemed like he should write it but it also seemed like he should go to their meeting alone. So he guesses he’ll just let Ashkon do whatever.

Permalink Mark Unread

<It'll probably be something like, this practitioner did a bad job establishing my comfort level and making sure we understood each other, I understand the subtle arts industry is pressured for availability in general but waiting another month for an appointment would have been better than what happened, I would not recommend her to a friend.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He doesn’t entirely understand what the first part of that means and isn’t sure why he’s supposed to not recommend her to a friend.

Also not only would waiting another month have been better, so would never getting any subtle arts done.

(Also he kind of wants to not be conscious until they have the summary.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon had some things he was planning to do but he can do them later. He turns on the sleep song.

Permalink Mark Unread

There is barely any time in which to appreciate this but he very briefly does.

He doesn’t remember any dreams.

Permalink Mark Unread

<That seems probably better than your baseline?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Maybe.>

Permalink Mark Unread
<It's certainly not, like, good dreams.>

He checks the email. They have the after-visit report.

Pt presented with nightmares, anxiety, flashback-triggering trauma associations, eating disorder, selective mutism. Provided advice wrt accessing standard therapy for some issues. Performed standard two-pronged nightmare block (subject: Purgatory) with trainee observing. Unable to provide confident outside assessment of pt emotional state as no formal consent to reading was secured. Recommend second visit for closing off trauma associations and followup mundane therapy with spot assistance from artists.
Permalink Mark Unread

Well, that’s... not terrible. Maybe he didn’t say he was fine with mind-reading? He thought he did but why would he remember anything right. Or maybe Vyn failed to understand; it’s not necessarily always his fault for not knowing anything ever. Probably he just remembers wrong, though.

Maybe he should believe Vyn without bothering to reread what he wrote since he wouldn’t rather be made to. But for some reason this is wholly unpersuasive. The note exists; if he can’t read it or remember it Ashkon will notice. It could in theory have been altered; Ashkon might also notice that.

At least all that actually happened was fine and not very important. - Why does he believe that but not that he didn’t actually consent to mind-reading? Actually he thinks Vyn could pass a truth spell about it, probably on some technicality about the definition of "formal consent"; he doesn’t expect malice at all -

<Did I think there was a substantial chance Vyn was evil before?> He thinks he did but it feels very stupid of him and that's concerning.

Permalink Mark Unread

<You... have generally thought all people have a substantial chance of being evil.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah, but...> He can basically sort the possibilities into categories. There’s the category where his beliefs aren’t entangled with any part of reality other than what some subtle artist or precog wants him to think. Given their abilities, basically all possibilities where Vanda Nossëo is systematically deceptive about its basic nature fall into that one, and there’s nothing to be done about it anyway. There’s the category where they merely have some statistical fudging about how effectively they prevent crime, or something like that, and actually there’s something going on like underreporting of crimes that are basically embarrassing, or something else about that small, something where the system as a whole has the components it’s supposed to. And there’s the broad category of possibilities where they’re basically fine.

And in the whole third category, they’re putting really tremendous resources toward avoiding subtle artists doing things like blatantly lying about doing subtle arts to people. He can think of ways to be fairly confident that’s not a major issue, using only resources he knows they have. And in the second category - why would anyone specifically target their patients? It seems so obvious; their patients are known to be associated with them. It’d really only make sense to do that for reasons that specifically have to do with them being customers (getting good reviews, getting people to come back...) or for the thrill of betraying people's trust, or maybe if they just fuck with everyone, customer or otherwise... and he wasn’t worried about getting fucked with at other times, and he should have been, but he can’t think of any ways he’s changed for the worse lately - and he thinks the only thing he'd have been suspicious of in advance is how many things he likes and wants, which is really only bad insofar as it makes him more selfish or easier to coerce and he doesn’t think those things have happened. And at any rate, he won’t give Vyn a good review or go back for another session, so he clearly wasn’t altered to do those things.

But if he considers his behavior it doesn’t match that threat model, and also doesn’t match a threat model where Vyn might misunderstand anything. It matches a threat model that assumes Vyn wants to do the worst things she can get away with and can specifically get away with things she can get consent for. And that seems like it’s singling out Vyn as a bad actor - or modeling her as an Elf who has sworn something, maybe, but that’s a stupid threat model - only it’s not really singling Vyn out at all, is it, because he’s like that about absolutely everyone except Ashkon and Nocawe and frankly he's like this with them too but the mind-reading helps. And now that he looks straight at it it feels absolutely insane. But is that a thought he would have had last week if something managed to get him to think about it instead of refusing to trust his own judgment enough to try?

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah, I think you could have, you just have habits that steer you otherwise.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Maybe his habits are stupid.

Maybe he’s closer to okay than he’s been thinking.

<I’m so glad I didn’t bring you.> This would really suck if Ashkon had gone near Vyn or come to her attention. And instead it just... sucks even less than everything sucked before the appointment. He trusts Ashkon. He trusts himself. He doesn’t especially trust Vyn but just in a way where he thinks she’s incompetent.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I'm glad I can, like, reality-check you. Love you <3>

Permalink Mark Unread

<<3!>

He kind of wants to pentest Vanda Nossëo now and he’s annoyed to notice himself caring at all if that would get him sent to prison forever.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I think that's a real job that exists but I don't think it would be very compatible with my class schedule.> He's packing for his morning class now.

Permalink Mark Unread

And - he still can’t eat, and he still has no intention of pulling the rug out from under Ashkon even if he could.

He’s known for a while that he would at some point want his own life. Now he actually does. It’s still a vague future thing; he’s not impatient to make that happen this year. But he wants it.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I'll miss you but you can go do your own thing whenever you're ready.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<<3!!! I’m not quitting today, though. I really like you and...> And he wants Ashkon to succeed here more than he wants to do anything else. And he’d miss Ashkon so much, as a friend and because he really does still suck at taking care of himself. And he said he wouldn’t yank the rug out from under Ashkon and he meant it and he very badly wants to be someone who can mean things like that. And he can’t offer Ashkon the same kinds of presents as Ashkon gives him - he has money now but half of what’s so good about it when Ashkon does nice things for him is having someone see his problems and show him how they can be solved, and he can’t reciprocate because Ashkon doesn’t need that - but if it were ever less than a delight to host him, well, the amount that he’s willing to endure for Ashkon isn’t zero. It’s not infinite, either, but.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I love you but I don't want to be burdensome!>

Permalink Mark Unread

They can cross that bridge if they reach the same galaxy as it. <You could think about looking for someone else but it’s probably way too early, I don’t know for sure if I'm quitting this decade.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah. If it gets to be any closer than the horizon of a planet of unknown size I'll put in to the matching system again. But you're very good <3>

Permalink Mark Unread

<<3>

Permalink Mark Unread

Ashkon goes to the review. <Do you want me to write it for you or do you want to?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don’t have an independent idea of what to say but it’s not your opinion they care about...>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah. If it ever matters who wrote it somehow, it should be you, but you can borrow my wording if you want.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<But I'd also be borrowing your...> Imaginary shrug. <Your way of thinking about what's wrong and whether anything is wrong. I think I should think about it until I know what I think and then I can decide whether to say your thing.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Okay. I don't think there's a rush. You might want to tell Nocawe sooner though.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh! He wants to talk to her about that. He’ll email her as soon as Ashkon doesn’t need to move.

Permalink Mark Unread

He can have a chance after Ashkon's class.

Permalink Mark Unread

I wish I hadn't gone to the subtle arts appointment. Ashkon suggested I email you and I thought that would be a good idea because I don’t really know what to make of it. I don’t think I communicated well with Vyn even though I tried to. (Ashkon suggested if I leave a review I might want to say Vyn did a bad job at establishing my comfort level.) I tried to proactively suggest that she could read my mind if it’d help, but I guess that wasn’t clear and I don’t believe she asked, either. She didn’t explain anything afterward until Ashkon talked to the receptionist about it. She kind of rubbed me the wrong way afterward; she told me to make another appointment "to complete the obvious work you require" instead of telling me what she did and what she would do with another appointment. The notes we got afterward are more explicit but not as much as I wish they were. I’m really upset about it and I think I made a bad choice.

Permalink Mark Unread
Nocawe's reply is there after Ashkon's next class.

Sounds like a bad fit, I'm so sorry. Did she do anything you didn't want done at all and might need reversed or was it a communication issue altogether?
Permalink Mark Unread

I think just the second thing. I kind of wondered because I ended up changing my worldview a lot right after but Ashkon doesn’t think it’s necessarily an unnatural change. Maybe it was a long time in coming.

Permalink Mark Unread
How did it change your worldview?
Permalink Mark Unread

I trust myself. I have specific questions (that I still don’t know how to answer) about Vanda Nossëo's trustworthiness as an institution instead of not even having questions.

Permalink Mark Unread
That does sound like an improvement but I'm not sure it's related to the subtle arts therapy at all.

How would you feel about going to a session with an unpowered counselor who could talk through your problems with you and maybe eventually recommend more arts work if and when you were ready for that (with another practitioner, of course)?
Permalink Mark Unread

I want to say yes but Vyn also recommended that so maybe it’s a bad idea.

I'll do it if you set it up and it doesn’t cost a lot.

Permalink Mark Unread
I promise I didn't get the idea from Vyn. I'll set it up and I can probably find you something subsidized. Any sort of person you'd be more or less comfortable with talking to?
Permalink Mark Unread

I don’t know. Maybe if you get more specific I'll have a preference.

Permalink Mark Unread
Some people have preferences for a particular gender, species, cultural background, age, practice specialty, therapeutic philosophy...
Permalink Mark Unread

His next email is a little slow in coming because he needs to look up therapeutic philosophies.

I think I communicate badly with people who can’t read my mind. Especially lately. But I don’t know if that’s a real pattern or if it’s just that the people I know can mostly do that because I'm a Yeerk host surrounded by Elves. You seem fine and I don’t think you read minds. I can’t confidently say that any combination of the kinds of traits you mentioned would be a good fit.

Permalink Mark Unread
Okay, I'll filter for ones who can read minds. You will have to find a way to tell them that it's okay to read your mind, though if it's a flat Elf leaving thoughts public and making it clear you know how not to will most likely do.
Permalink Mark Unread

He probably won’t achieve this by designing an incredibly garish t-shirt that says "I KNOW HOW TO KEEP THOUGHTS PRIVATE AND I ❤️ MIND READING" but he’s briefly mildly tempted. It’s fine. It’s not really about avoiding accidentally technically agreeing to the wrong thing; that’s probably the wrong thing to optimize for. It’s more important to make it clear to people what he wants. And ideally also to avoid accidentally technically agreeing to the wrong thing.

I think I can do that. I can try, anyway.

Permalink Mark Unread
I'm sorry the culture around explicit consent is inconvenient for you, it's there to protect vulnerable people but different vulnerable people turn out to need different things.
Permalink Mark Unread

I think I can deal with it better now than I used to.

Permalink Mark Unread
You seem to be improving really encouragingly.
Permalink Mark Unread

Every day in every way I’m getting better and better~

Permalink Mark Unread

<You're adorable.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Good, he likes making Ashkon happy.

Permalink Mark Unread

Eventually Nocawe emails him about an appointment with a therapist over in Ithil; bit of a bus trip but he has good reviews.

He's apparently an Utumno survivor (for generous values of 'survivor') and she wants to check in to see if that's a good thing.

Permalink Mark Unread

He has no idea if that’s a good thing. Presumably if this guy were too emotionally fragile to deal with hearing about Purgatory he wouldn’t do this job but maybe not?

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah, probably he's not too fragile for it at all. It was a long time ago that Ithil had an Utumno, thousands of years.>

Permalink Mark Unread

Thousands of years is older than him, if he’s at all correct about his age. He'll see this guy.

Permalink Mark Unread

The guy is to be found on Ithil's Tol Eressëa. He doesn't have an office and is to be found sitting on a specific rock.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ooh, a rock! What kind of rock is it?

Permalink Mark Unread

It's carved into a chair, but subtly, so you could imagine it came that way naturally or was worn into it by people sitting in it for thousands of years - maybe the latter is actually true. It's basalt.

Hello, says the Elf. I'm Colindo.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ooh, basalt. He likes basalt. It’s nice and familiar. He waves and smiles at Colindo, who clearly has good taste in rocks. Are there perhaps other conveniently chairlike rocks nearby?

Hi. I got tired of having my name taken away over and over so I refuse to pick a new one and if that’s upsetting then you probably want to stop talking to me now because it gets a lot worse than that.

Permalink Mark Unread

There are a few chair rocks nearby!

I'm fine, but thank you for being concerned for me. It's good to have held on to that through everything, being concerned for people around you.

Permalink Mark Unread

I’ve tortured people. You’re not literally wrong that I’ve kept being concerned for people but I have tortured people.

It would be easier to just send memories but that seems really rude.

Permalink Mark Unread

Do you want to tell me more about that? asks Colindo, unruffled.

Permalink Mark Unread

Shrug. I don’t really know if it’d be useful to. I don’t really know... how to decide?

He sits on another rock and runs his hands over it and shuts his eyes.

Permalink Mark Unread

Colindo is both of a) an Elf and b) of the "sit there and allow awkward silence to prompt conversation" school of thought. He waits.

Permalink Mark Unread

Some of the things on the internet about therapy said it involves talking about things like that and some of them said other things. I didn’t come here with a plan. I don’t know what would be a good idea. I’m not sure what will achieve my goals because I don’t have goals that I know how to make progress on. I don’t know if it matters what I’ve done. I don’t know if I can say anything trustworthy about it given that they were doing what they could to wreck my memory and confuse me.

I wish I could talk about the people I knew but I don’t remember some of them and I don’t know how accurate anything I thought I knew about them really is. And I think - I don’t feel like I’m supposed to? I feel like people here want me to... be done with that? Like - people are so solicitous about nightmares and not very concerned that I panic when I wake up if there’s nothing literally stopping me no matter what I dream of. It seems like they’d be happy if I just forgot everything about it. And maybe I should. Maybe I should just focus on the future. It’s not like Hereafter Reunions would help if I asked them to track down someone I hurt once.

Permalink Mark Unread

No?

Permalink Mark Unread

Do they? Seems like the kind of thing where they’d expect it not to help anything.

Permalink Mark Unread

I've never looked into it. Did you?

Permalink Mark Unread

He makes a face. Can he get online here?

Permalink Mark Unread

No reception.

You don't have to. I only wondered if you'd done it, and whether you wanted to.

Permalink Mark Unread

I don’t even know if I want to. I don’t know if it’d end well. I really just... keep losing things, and those things suck and I don’t want them back but - anyway. I'd say this can’t possibly be on topic but I don’t think I know what the topic was.

Permalink Mark Unread

The topic is you, and how you're feeling, and what you need and what you want.

Permalink Mark Unread

That feels kind of uncomfortable.

I don’t think I know about half the things I’d want if I knew about them. I want to be able to eat and I want more friends and I want people to stop thinking they can just pretend I’m an Angband survivor and I want to know... how exactly I’m supposed to do the thing other people do where they look at how miserable I am and see problems they could solve and then solve them. And I want -

This part is hard to put into words. Here, have some feelings and concepts. He has vague problems he can’t articulate and even when he does articulate them he doesn’t have much of a toolkit for dealing with them. He’s improved a lot, which means he can now carry on a conversation and reliably articulate at least one relevant consideration when Nocawe is trying to figure out how to solve his problems instead of shrugging at everything and bursting into tears. His best strategy when he notices that he has a problem is to hope Ashkon can solve it. Which works, but he'd like to outsource a little less of the work.

And meanwhile, he has a lot of skills and knowledge. It’s just that it’s not very trustworthy or useful. So he just... ignores it, and feels sort of shrunken, as though all the parts of him that were for doing things have withered away. It’s not like he can... okay, he hasn’t checked if he could somehow solve his problems by enduring pain, panhandling, recognizing rocks by feel, doing surgery on dead people who heal in exactly the way he does, hurting people, or constructing a printing press. It just doesn’t seem very likely, and he doesn’t know how to check. And not knowing how to check seems emblematic of a bigger problem with decisionmaking that he'd like to solve but doesn’t know how.

Permalink Mark Unread

If you imagine someone who didn't have those problems, can you guess what they'd do?

Permalink Mark Unread

Well. Yeah. They'd study composition at the University of Brithombar and learn to sing and play the hammered dulcimer and bathe in weird sludge instead of eating. He can model someone without his problems very well. That doesn’t seem useful since he doesn’t want to be Ashkon 1159. He thinks maybe he misunderstood the question somehow.

Permalink Mark Unread

Mm, someone more like you, except for not having the problems.

Permalink Mark Unread

If he were fine... he pictures that in his private thoughts. He'd wake up and not be terrified. He'd... go to work? Doing pentesting? Somehow? He can’t picture that. And then he would... have lunch, maybe, since it’s useful, and he would just be able to do that. He...

Yeah, the thing is, he can’t picture that. He publicizes the fact that he can’t get a clear picture of what he’d be doing. If he just had an easy time coming up with things to try... he can’t really figure out how he'd do that either. He keeps thinking publicly.

Almost everything feels pointless, anyway. He likes it when Ashkon does fun things but the idea of going swimming or something alone feels much less appealing. He misses feeling like he was good at things and doing things that mattered, but it wasn’t true when he felt that way so he’s probably not getting it back without changing a lot as a person. So he doesn’t see how he could have a good life and he doesn’t entirely see why he should bother.

Honestly he misses Purgatory, which is a horrible thought but he’s not fast enough to hide it.

Permalink Mark Unread

You knew what to expect there.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Not more than here anymore. Do you want to see or should I try to explain in words?

Permalink Mark Unread

Whichever you're comfortable with.

Permalink Mark Unread

He remembers -

(or maybe he doesn’t, not accurately)

- switching back to his right hand when it’s barely rested because now his left is cramping too badly to write, blinking until the shimmering page he’s trying to copy resolves into letters, intensely proud to still be working -

- a girl whispering a story he could barely follow about a turtle princess and the unnoticed passage of centuries, thirsty enough she could barely speak even if she weren’t afraid to be heard, while the others traded off listening for footsteps and continuing to copy their assigned books -

- clapping in the face of someone who fell asleep at work because it would be worse for them to be caught than to just endure forever, trusting that he could count on the same kindness -

- watching someone start to nod off and startle himself back to wakefulness and being so proud and relieved that with all of them working together on it they’d managed to teach the newcomer themselves, they who still had the slightest touch of human gentleness and wouldn’t leave him screaming for days -

- the thrill of realizing they must have misunderstood the way his breath caught, must have taken joy for agony, and once they weren’t watching he could sleep through their attempt at punishment and relax -

- he remembers success. He remembers trust of a kind he doesn’t have with Ashkon. He remembers thinking he was helping someone. He was, probably, when he kept them from getting caught. He remembers having some reason to feel proud of himself.

Permalink Mark Unread

Some parts of your existence there were better than others. You didn't compress your whole emotional experience into being-in-Hell-is-awful. Of course you didn't.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah, I guess. I just... had things then that I don’t have now. And I don’t know if there’s a better way to get them.

Permalink Mark Unread

Is having them compatible with the good things you have now?

Permalink Mark Unread

I don’t know. I guess - doing useful things is. I don’t know if being good at things is, I don’t have that much time to practice anything right now. I’m not sure if you can end up trusting people in the way we did without danger and I don’t know if there are any dangers here. I guess it’s weird to say so but I actually think pain that doesn’t really feel bad would be easier to come by here, I wouldn’t be hoping to get lucky and trick people. I was never really that lucky.

Permalink Mark Unread

Where would you look, to find out?

Permalink Mark Unread

To find what out?

Permalink Mark Unread

Any of those things you don't know, or speculate about.

Permalink Mark Unread

Everywhere. I don’t know of a narrower place to look, but "everywhere" would do it.

Permalink Mark Unread

Where would you start?

Permalink Mark Unread

...Well, in practice I would start with whatever Ashkon happened to want to be near.

Permalink Mark Unread

That makes sense. And what kinds of things would you try to observe about it?

Permalink Mark Unread

Things that would be more likely in one case than another. I think maybe you think either I have the answers to all my own questions or at least that - if I go far enough down the list of "and how would you figure that out?" it won't end in "I don't know where I'd even start" - or are we trying to figure out where that point is?

Permalink Mark Unread

I'm interested in how you think about approaching things. If there's a point where you can't any more, that seems like a good place to focus.

Permalink Mark Unread

So I guess I think - you know in the Sims there's - here, have the entire concept of sim bars with pictures, if he didn't know before then he does now. I think I came out with all my sim bars red - or just most of them - actually, of the literal needs in The Sims, I guess I was only red on hunger and energy and fun and maybe orange on social - but he's using the concept more broadly than that because he isn't an oversimplified video game character, and he's thinking this next bit too fast and too visually for words but what happened next was that he hung out in a park working on the very most preliminary prerequisites for coming up with a plan to save everyone and occasionally meeting the needs he realized he had (if they can be called needs; he's had this argument before, see, though he sees the teleporter's point a little better now) and that was the best thing he could imagine ever experiencing. And it wasn't unendurably awful or anything, but there were still bars that were red and that had just been red all the time for so long he couldn't identify them as things that were wrong. That's half the thing that's so useful about Ashkon.

Only - well, two things, the first of which is that he's identified problems in ways other than fixing them, so now he has a list of them, but secondly he thinks he also has some unknown number of secret problems he hasn't identified yet and doesn't know anything about - no, that thought can't be right, because the fact that he hasn't identified them in the course of noticing his preferences when things start varying means there are things that have been stably the same amount of bad, which means some of his problems are with the constants in his life, and there aren't all that many things that haven't changed.

Or maybe that's all dumb. Who knows.

Permalink Mark Unread

Colindo has never played The Sims but he follows the analogy well. Most things about your life have changed, but there could be things that you didn't have and still do not; that wouldn't look like a change until you began to have access to them.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah. What do people want? Probably he won’t be well modeled by any generic list but there might be something useful in a list of things other people have wanted in the past.

Permalink Mark Unread

People want friends and families. Art and music. Rest and stimulation. A sense of purpose. Safety, security, and prestige. Novelty.

Permalink Mark Unread

Wow, he actually wants all of those things and has about half of them. There might be things he wants that aren’t on the list but... that seems like a really good start. He takes notes so he won’t forget any if he goes depth-first on the most confusing one right now.

I don’t really understand why I don’t have a family.

Permalink Mark Unread

Most people begin with one. Did you?

Permalink Mark Unread

I guess so. I don’t really remember what it was like and - I mean - we talked recently, but...

Permalink Mark Unread

The family-ness wasn't there?

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah! I don’t get it.

Permalink Mark Unread

Did you remember them?

Permalink Mark Unread

He almost says no. He catches himself.

I remembered something different. Than what she remembered, I mean. I think. Or something. I didn’t recognize her.

Permalink Mark Unread

Most people's memories shift and warp over time, especially with nothing propping them up.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah. I - don’t entirely know if I’d trust it but I really want one of those necklaces. Vyn didn’t seem to think that was a good idea but I don’t think Vyn really had a good idea of what was up with me.

Permalink Mark Unread

The necklaces aren't selective. It's up to you if you want to seek one out. The recommendation was probably about the possibility that remembering Hell in more detail would be worse.

Permalink Mark Unread

He hides his thoughts and starts laughing bitterly.

It wouldn’t. They - do you want to see - I mean, I want to show you but I try to make that kind of thing opt-in.

Permalink Mark Unread

Please feel free.

Permalink Mark Unread

It feels like he can't understand anything and needs to give up and believe what he's told. It feels like everything he sees is a lie. It feels like he can't trust himself to come to the right answer to any question that isn't a math problem and even some that are - he remembers being slapped and looking back down at a page and seeing that his answer is wrong because the numbers in the problem are not the ones he thought he read there -

And it's not just that. They named him Yves and Charles and David and Ealhswith - someone asked him if he was the Ealhswith and he wasn't, he didn't even speak English at the time and had to try a dozen times to pronounce it right - and Sun-ja and Dazhu and he has no idea how many others anymore. He couldn't list them if he wanted to. Supposedly there was a name he liked once; he doesn't remember that. He must have had a birth name once; he doesn't remember that either. He doesn't know who he's been.

He knows deep in his bones that if he makes a friend they will be taken away and he'll never see them again. He can't remember not knowing that, except insofar as he's tentatively hopeful about things being different now. He can't remember learning it, can't remember which friends he didn't realize he would lose forever, but they must have existed.

And whatever good not remembering everything perfectly is doing him isn't enough because he still remembers the worst of it, or maybe doesn't, maybe he's just made something up in his imagination but - this is a bad idea, he knows it's a bad idea, but look at the clarity with which he can still feel the spikes everywhere any of his weight rests and the tight straps pressing him against them and the almost physical grip of terror as he realizes that the angel isn't anywhere close to done with him and it's going to get worse -

Permalink Mark Unread

Perhaps you would benefit from such a necklace. I think they can be borrowed more cheaply than they can be owned.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Necklace...? Right, yes, they were talking about necklaces, here in Tol Eressëa which is where he is right now. He would hate to have to give one back if he liked it but whatever. Maybe he’ll save up. Maybe they should pop the stack and get back to, uh...

Permalink Mark Unread

Your family. Do you think you would be willing to try joining them for some time if you remembered them? If you didn't?

Permalink Mark Unread

If I remembered them it’d depend on what I remembered. I... don’t see why I’d want to otherwise but I guess maybe if it made them happy.

Permalink Mark Unread

People who don't have families, or whose first families cannot act in that way towards them any more, form new ones. You are in the curious position of being potentially able to form a new family with your old family.

Permalink Mark Unread

He is now familiar enough with computers for his response to literally include the emoji 🤔.

Permalink Mark Unread

Colindo waits for him to put together a more complete thought.

Permalink Mark Unread

I don’t know, this person I talked to seemed like she really wanted me to have... continuity? Like she wanted me to say I remembered things I didn’t remember and... I don’t know.

It’s hard to put it into words but he has a sense that there’s no reason he would selfishly rather try to be her family than anyone else’s, just reasons to think that might make her happier. Or something. Maybe not even happier, maybe just less guilty if she thinks he’s okay, and he doesn’t really want to try to be close with someone who needs him to seem okay like that. But maybe that’s not what’s up with her.

Permalink Mark Unread

Some people put a lot of value on their families being the same ones they started with, or at least including those people. Not everyone.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, that's kind of the thing about not remembering them very well. Or about them having changed and forgotten things. Or both. Whatever it is that should make them the family he started with, or would make him able to really believe they’re the family he started with, isn’t there. He’s kind of politely humoring the claim that they are but he has no actual evidence.

Permalink Mark Unread

So it sounds like your way forward would be clearer if you remembered, or at least had some time in which you remembered so as to be able to make plans.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah. He checks his notes. Is there a less boring way to be useful than making magic jewelry?

Permalink Mark Unread

With a full time Yeerk? I'm not sure. It would have to be something you could do solely telepathically.

Permalink Mark Unread

And not something that takes expertise I don’t have. Maybe something I could do while Ashkon is swimming but it seems like... with replicators and stuff, I guess there’s not much reason to take up weaving or something... I don’t have ideas to share... I could learn to program games.

Permalink Mark Unread

Would you find that enjoyable?

Permalink Mark Unread

Maybe. He doesn’t really feel excited about it but he’s had a lot of pleasant surprises lately and it’s left him optimistic. And it’s not like there’s an option he’s enthusiastic about.

Permalink Mark Unread

I'm told it's a slow learning curve, but it is often very stabilizing and fulfilling to have a hobby.

Permalink Mark Unread

I have hobbies. Kind of. He likes math. It just doesn’t really feel like achieving anything.

Permalink Mark Unread

To have projects which feel like accomplishments.

Permalink Mark Unread

There was one thing I wanted to accomplish but now it’s done. I don’t know if I can accomplish anything without getting myself in order first. Maybe if I figure out how to... figure out how things are in general... then maybe I’ll have ideas?

Permalink Mark Unread

That sounds like a good place to start. You'd need to have an idea of how things are, and how they could be instead.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yep. That feels like a less impossible task lately but still not doable. He knew about the last huge problem because it affected him and he thinks he'd catch on faster if it happened again but it isn’t happening again. If there are horrible things they aren’t hurting him, and it’s not that he doesn’t care about faraway strangers, it’s just that he doesn’t really have beliefs about them. If he hears about them secondhand then what he hears could be a lie; likewise if he talks to them on the internet. Even visiting a town doesn’t mean much; they could be actors, and even if not, it makes no sense for any but the smallest problems.

Actually, there could have been fewer people in torment than he thought; he doesn’t think he saw all of them. So maybe solving problems that might only affect a few people wouldn’t be that different, so maybe that’s a fine way to pick causes.

He still isn’t any good at coming up with solutions but maybe if he circles back to the idea of accomplishing things or helping people later, once he’s gotten some experience solving a few of his own problems, it will make more sense. Except that pining for lack of meaningful things to do might actually be the biggest problem he has and can't solve on his own.

Permalink Mark Unread

Is there a skill you could practice that would feel constructive toward solving this?

Permalink Mark Unread

I think to practice it I'd have to sort of get how to do it already... I think maybe I sort of know how to notice problems and wonder if I could solve them now. But then actually solving them is harder... I don’t know, what do you think?

Permalink Mark Unread

When I can't make progress on something without having already made more progress with it, usually I need to break it into smaller pieces. Noticing problems is one such piece.

Permalink Mark Unread

What else is there... how do people come up with ideas for solutions? It looks easy when Nocawe and Ashkon do it but I can’t pull it off like they can and I can’t tell if that’s because they have more resources and know more about what’s available or if they have some kind of skill specifically for noticing how those things can be used to solve problems - or if they just know how to solve a bunch of specific problems I happen to have had...?

Permalink Mark Unread

You could ask them.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah. I should do that.

Permalink Mark Unread

I hope to hear how it goes when next you come here, if you come back.

Permalink Mark Unread

I think I will. I think I understand some things now that I didn't before.

Permalink Mark Unread

Afterward - well, mostly he doesn’t do much. Gets Ashkon's commentary on the session. Eventually he tries to look up the policies of Hereafter Reunions and ends up distracted by the discovery that Vanda Nossëo has Christian churches. What is it doing with those? How can people be Christian here? And now?

He wonders if he could be again. He probably couldn't. Maybe he doesn't even want to be. He's not very sure God even exists. But it feels - sort of similar to what he and Colindo talked about, about family. It would feel less uncanny for a priest who is literally a stranger to be a stranger.

Search term: "how to be reconciled to the church"

Search term: "rite of reconciliation schedule"

Surely there's an option that doesn't overlap with any of Ashkon's classes.

Permalink Mark Unread

The first Catholic church listed has reconciliation from 3:00 to 4:00 on Fridays and 10:45 to 11:30 on Sundays, or by appointment. A student center offers every third Wednesday of the school year, 7:00-9:00 PM, except during finals. A hospital chapel says "Thursdays after 8" but doesn't specify AM or PM, and also it hasn't been updated in the last five years. 

Permalink Mark Unread

He vaguely feels like a church would be better than some other kind of institution and he's frankly still kind of sour on the idea of interacting with a school other than by watching Ashkon's classes. He finds one whose schedule works. He downloads a text-to-speech app in case his voice decides to be AWOL for it which it probably will. He thinks through what should prompt him to cut and run.

He goes by himself.

Permalink Mark Unread

The church is quiet on a Friday afternoon. The coffee urns in the vestibule are empty; a middle-aged woman on a stepstool is switching out a felt banner with colorful handprints for one with an appliqued dove. The illustration of a thermometer, drawn on butcher paper and mounted above a coffee can to track fundraising progress for a new roof, is shaded in a third of the way with red crayon.

There's a few people sitting on a bench outside the confessionals. A young father soothes a baby while a toddler clinging to his pants leg tries to fit her entire fist in her mouth; the boy next to him, in a rumpled school uniform, looks about nine. A couple of middle-aged women are glowering in his general direction, with what could be either personal judgement or deep contemplation of their sins. Another man is kissing his rosary repetitively and muttering to himself.

Permalink Mark Unread

It’s terrifying and not really much like his distant untrustworthy memory of a little church in a little village. He can sit on a bench, though. That’s fine. He sits there consciously choosing to stay calm.

Permalink Mark Unread

After a little while, a young woman clutching a missal bedecked with colorful post-it notes emerges from the confessional, and the young father takes her place. The toddler, left behind, bawls; the nine-year-old thrusts a board book in her general direction.

The father only takes a couple of minutes, and the nine-year-old, when his turn comes, is even quicker. The middle-aged women take what must be fifteen minutes apiece. Then there's the last man; and then it's his turn.

Permalink Mark Unread

He... might be able to make himself talk to the priest, but, look, he's got some stuff conveniently written up and can make his computer do it and that sounds easier. At least for obvious things.

"I don't know if it's too late for this since I have already died and gone to Hell and I'm honestly skeptical about whether I can or should be blessed. It has been about five hundred eighty or so years since my last confession. Should I go away because I'm already damned?"

Permalink Mark Unread

The priest interrupts himself in the middle of a rapidly muttered introductory prayer to say "--no, please, stay."

Permalink Mark Unread

Cool. He has also written up all the sins he can remember. Probably. It has been a really long time since he was remotely justified in being even slightly confident that he knows what counts.

"I don't confidently remember which things are sins but I briefly looked it up online so maybe I've got them all. I also don't necessarily remember what I've done correctly because I was subject to a sustained campaign of sleep deprivation and gaslighting aimed at destroying my memory. With those caveats, I have an attempt at a list of sins.

"I have missed Mass consistently for about five hundred eighty years and in the last few years I've taken the attitude that God kind of sucks since he never answers any of my prayers and that seems at odds with being close to him. I mostly stopped praying a long time ago but I don't know how many years ago. I have thought that his sacrifice wasn't good enough as long as anyone was still in Hell and I have wanted to nail him back on the cross in case it helped. I led others astray and taught them falsehoods. I have helped demons and I don't mean the nice people who make things. I don't do anything nice for anyone anymore because the last time I tried to do anything nice for anyone I listened to demons about what kinds of things might be nice and that turned out badly. I had a hobby while I knew that people were suffering and thought I could help them. I have broken people's fingers and ripped their fingernails off. I have asked and ordered others to torture people for me. I glared at someone for being too cheerful. I let demons teach me about right and wrong. I felt affection for demons. I went to America without permission, initially on the orders of demons, and then decided to stay so I could hide from the demons there. While I was hiding, I panhandled. I couldn't read my own sign but it was represented to me that it implied that I needed cash rather than food because I had difficulty eating because I didn't have a tongue and it implied that I would be buying special food. I in fact didn't have a tongue but I didn't need to eat and didn't buy food. I bought coffee and socks and gave most of the rest of my money away to people that others might have been more reluctant to give money to. Someone made a comment that I thought might have implied that they thought I was a veteran of the American military and I didn't correct them or return their money. In general while panhandling I did not clarify that I was damned and not deserving of help. I got off several times and I had bad thoughts, mostly about women, and sometimes that was visible to people who might rather not have been able to guess. I think I've crossdressed but figuring out when I did that and whether I've previously confessed it isn't possible for me right now. I've started eating lembas even though I don't need to because I'm happier when I don't feel hungry and my Yeerk friend likes my body better that way and I don't know if that's a sin. If it's not a sin then maybe fasting for about five hundred eighty years was a sin. Lately I've been helping someone else learn magic."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...okay."

The priest sounds a little shaky. But he coughs and goes on, and his voice sounds steadier.

 

"You've been through a lot. What brings you back to the church?"

Permalink Mark Unread

That is not really a question he has a good answer for. Certainly not one he’s already put into words.

Probably having wondered if it was worth his time isn’t an acceptable answer.

"It’s one of the things they took away from me and it’s easier to get back than my family because I don’t have to remember or still love it."

Permalink Mark Unread

"You'll always be welcome in the house of God. You are His beloved child."

Permalink Mark Unread

He starts quietly sobbing at that but fortunately that doesn’t really make it any harder to answer. "Empirically, no."

Permalink Mark Unread

"There's tissues on the shelf of the prie-dieu. -- There's been a lot for all of us to pray about, these last few years. God has opened up a lot more of the world to us than we ever thought was possible. But if He brought you back, don't you think that might be because He wanted you back for Himself?"

Permalink Mark Unread

After sending him there in the first place and ignoring all his prayers for centuries, yes, actually, he’s intimately familiar with the kind of being who leaves people alone to scream until something comes up that they’d be useful for.

"Why only now?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"God inhabits eternity. Our time is like the blink of an eye to Him. All He is concerned with is now, today, and today He is saying: behold, my son who was dead is alive; my son who was lost is found."

Permalink Mark Unread

...Does Elspeth need to explain urgency again? Presumably she would have tried that already, right?

That's terrifyingly unpredictable, and - and he doesn't just live each day as its own thing. The version of today he can live is one shaped by everything that came before it. How is he supposed to work with that? Among the things Colindo listed that people want were safety and security; how can he have that if God might decide at any time that a few more centuries of torment don't really matter? They matter to him. They're most of his existence.

He was angry at God before but just in a way where he was confused and despairing. He still thought of it as somehow just, for him to be damned. He just didn't care how just it was.

And, to be fair, he still doesn't. But also, it wasn't.

"I think maybe he should be asking for my forgiveness."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think you came here looking for His."

Permalink Mark Unread

Did he? Who knows. It’s not implausible.

It’s not a bad thing. He would like to be forgiven. And - well, actually he has no idea whether God is anything like how this person says he is.

God can forgive him if God wants to. He can forgive God, in that he doesn’t want God to suffer like he did.

And he can’t actually trust any claims about why any of this happened or whether God forgives him. But he can still decide whether he wants to forgive God even if it means some chance of forgiving someone evil or nonexistent, and he thinks maybe he does. And while he’s at it maybe he forgives himself.

He thinks he sees now what would have made him immune to the whole set of tricks, because in deciding it would be okay to forgive demons he does forgive them, and once he's done that there's really nothing they could tell him someone had done or deserved that would get him to think that what would really help the situation was punishing them. That's... it, he's rejected the whole idea, and maybe that wouldn't have helped - maybe they would have found him useless and tortured him and he never would have made it to Earth and escaped and then he might not have been eaten by the snake -

- which is really very bad, right, something is fucked up about a situation where being a better person would have had worse outcomes and he is miffed about this even though he is going to choose to forgive God and contemplate maybe conquering the multiverse if need be to avoid situations like that ever happening again. Though, who knows, maybe it would actually have been fine, maybe he could have saved everyone there if he'd just been better - but whatever. That's old ground even if the specifics are new.

"Maybe I did. I just also want to know why all that happened, but I guess that's not something anyone can tell me."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Many terrible things happen in our fallen world. But Our Lord came to Earth to endure them with us, and He descended into Hell, too. He loves you, my son, and He does not want you to suffer."

Permalink Mark Unread

Those are just words. They can’t really cause him to know that even if it’s true. He doesn’t really care about having someone endure with him anyway, if that's true. If anything it's worse.

He kind of maybe doesn't belong here on a deeper level than the specific list of sins. He doesn't say so. He can't think of anything it'd be a good idea to say.

Permalink Mark Unread

"You said you hurt other people, when you were in Hell. God knows what is in your heart now, and he knows the circumstances you were under then. He is all-loving and all-forgiving. He calls you to see yourself as He sees you, and forgive yourself as He forgives you."

Permalink Mark Unread

He probably wouldn't do that on the priest's say-so at this point but he already has.

"That's probably a good idea."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Christ gave us two great Commandments. He told us to love the Lord our God with all our heart, and all our soul, and all our strength, and to love our neighbor as ourself."

"For your penance, I would like you to take a quarter of an hour this week and talk to God. You don't have to say a prayer by heart -- you can if it's easier, but you don't have to. I want you to tell Him what's in your heart, and offer it up to Him, even if that's pain and guilt and anger at Him."

"I would also like you to practice loving your neighbor by doing something kind for someone else, and to practice loving yourself by doing something kind for yourself."

"Do you think you can do that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

...If this had been a normal kind of penance several centuries ago in France he doesn't think he could ever have been tricked.

"I don’t know how to find things to do for people that are actually kind."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...yes. That makes sense."

 

"You mentioned a Yeerk friend. Can you ask them for advice?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Maybe."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Then if you can do that, try doing that. And it sounds like eating lembas is a kind thing you can do for your friend."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I guess it is."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Can you say the Act of Contrition? It's on the wall there if you don't know it."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Probably not with my actual voice and I don’t know if I really am sorry with all my heart or how likely I am to decide to sin in the future."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Okay."

 

"You hurt people. If you had the choice, would you hurt them again?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"In hindsight hurting people put me in a position where I would be eaten by a portalsnake, which alerted people who were able to rescue everyone. I would do something different in the future but if I time traveled I would do everything the same way again."

Permalink Mark Unread

"All else being equal, you'd rather not hurt people."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Definitely."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I believe God rejoices in your courage."

 

 

"God, the Father of mercies, through the death and resurrection of His Son, has reconciled the world to Himself and sent the Holy Spirit among us for the forgiveness of sins. "

"Through the ministry of the Church, may God give you pardon and peace."

"I absolve you from your sins in the name of the Father; and of the Son; and of the Holy Spirit."

Permalink Mark Unread

This should probably not feel as weighty or as freeing as it does.

"Thank you."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Go in the peace of Christ, my son."

Permalink Mark Unread

He leaves with a spring in his step that wasn't there before.

Permalink Mark Unread

<That seemed like it helped. What a strange practice, though...>

Permalink Mark Unread

<What’s strange about it?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<None of the things you did were... to God? There were other humans there, not any gods, if your world-cluster even has gods which isn't obvious. The priest wasn't there at the time either. I don't relate to forgiveness in a way where it makes sense to go ask a stranger to ask an uninvolved deity to forgive me for things. I'm glad it made you feel better, though!>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I honestly don’t care that much if God or Father Sullivan forgive me but I think I care a lot that he showed me... a way to respond to doing something wrong that’s not just about more suffering? And also isn't just ignoring it. Maybe it’s easier to pretend it’s about God because he’s not going to show up and say "oh, who cares, I deserve it" or "I hate you, nothing you do will ever be good enough and I just want you to suffer!" Only I have to wonder if I got a bad priest before or what, because now that I’ve seen that I couldn’t ever be tricked into thinking torture is a good kind of penance as long as I remember. - I think I remember God taking it personally when you hurt other people, though, I think that's in the Bible, but, you know, I'm a really awful source if you want to know about theology or morality.>

Ashkon being glad it made him feel better makes him feel all warm and fuzzy.

Permalink Mark Unread

<I sent out some feelers to see if anyone has a memory necklace you could bother but everybody I talked to had to check with their hosts or friends and won't get back to me right away.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<<3! Thanks. I can probably save up and buy one eventually.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah, but then if you turn out not to like it we have to navigate selling it or returning it or something, borrowing it first seems sensible.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I guess.> It seems like it might be more emotionally difficult to part with it than to wait but who knows how likely he is to like it at all.

Permalink Mark Unread

<If you'd rather wait that's fine, but they're really expensive.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<No, I think you're right. It just might suck.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah. Is there anything you can guess about how it might suck, like should we have something distracting lined up for right after or alternatively something relaxing to let you have space to process in?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I don't know. I'm worried it'll feel like losing a part of myself but maybe that's stupid because it's something I'm already missing and I'd be missing it less if I had a chance to remember things with the necklace. I would probably take notes if I trusted writing but I don't but... maybe I should trust it more or trust the necklace less, I don't know...>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I generally trust writing but that's me.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He remembers a suspicious number of times he's been punished for getting something wrong and discovered that he apparently misread something. Maybe that was the sleep deprivation. Maybe it wasn't. Either way, maybe things would be different now.

<The thing I'm worried about is that it could be changed or I could read it wrong. If it's the second thing, I could read it twice, but if it's the first thing, I don't what to do. There are people who can put illusions on pages - I don't know how that interacts with Allspeak, would they be able to match the language I wrote it in if they didn't speak it? I could change languages in some kind of order that only makes sense to me - and to you, though, so I guess you could do whatever - > Ashkon fucking with him is not a possibility he feels very concerned about but Ashkon being inadequately careful with his secrets seems more likely. < - oh, or maybe I could come up with a system where I write in a set of languages determined by how many different characters are in the thing I'm writing, that sounds ridiculously hard to arrange but equally hard to edit even if you know exactly how it works... I assume you don't do anything like that and just trust it anyway?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I think that I actually won't be able to use your chiplock, if you get one of those. But yeah, I don't do anything like that myself.>

Permalink Mark Unread

He doesn't know enough about how those work to believe a chiplocked computer is actually trustworthy on any level - not just whether it's a real chiplock but whether that's a real thing that would really be safe - but maybe he could learn enough to believe at least that there is some kind of thing that works that way.

<One of us is being dumb but I don't know which. You're not doing something you've never really suffered for not doing, I'm trying to do something I've suffered a lot for not having done in the past... but we're not in our pasts.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Well, you have reason to think that the security of your writing may have changed, and I don't. But I don't think you're being dumb so much as - gradual, in how much you adjust, so that you know if you go too far you won't go very much too far. Does that make sense?>

Permalink Mark Unread

<It makes sense. It seems like you also sort of have a reason to think that? In that you're not one of the scariest and most invasive and gaslighty people around anymore. And I guess - I hope nothing happens to you? But there was a time before anything had happened to me. I think.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<I have an idea of what to look out for, but... I don't even write anything very sensitive.>

Permalink Mark Unread

<Yeah.>