So Peter climbs back downstairs, ready for the next plot beat.
"Your kind of vampire has really cool and enviable powers and just before I came here—well, a while before I came here—I had been talking to some friends about how cool it would be to have a pure upside no downside version of your powers. But I needed to actually meet a vampire like you for that to work and I wasn't really expecting the powers that be to really give me that this early."
"Well, you see, at any time I can discover previously unknown heritage from any type of being I encounter," he says, having memorized the words. "And I get the upsides without the downsides. The thing where half-vampires have enforced sleep schedules? Terrible. So instead I'll just..." And his skin changes, acquiring some of the sheen of half-vampires, the not-quite-glitter. He's already beautiful, so there's not much change there, but the better senses and body awareness and strength and stuff make him change his posture and the way he holds himself. His Quirky And Cute™ body language is still there, though. "Not."
His main power is delicious. The immediate comparison that might come to mind is blood after becoming a vampire, but this tastes nicer. Unique, in the way humans smell unique; Peter's smell isn't Addy's singer but his taste—or the taste of his power—might be. And despite it being ~unique~ and ~special~ and ~unlike anything else~, if it were like something, it would be most like the smell of a brand-new notebook and the taste of a snowflake melting on your tongue and the feeling of the cool breeze right before a summer rainstorm after a long hot day. But most of all he tastes like potential, a mostly-untapped infinite well of it, a power that could grow into anything and everything. There is nothing he couldn't be, if he wanted to be it and went after it. There's nothing he couldn't do. Maybe not right now, but someday.
Aaaaand it's nearly all of that just beyond Addy's reach. She can taste it, feel it, see it, but she can't, actually, grab it. It's there only to inform her that it's not hers.
There's one bit of it that isn't out of reach, though, a smaller, tamer power that Addy can get to. This one is more recognizable, and Addy might infer (correctly) that he got this power as soon as he became a half-vampire (which, to be clear, isn't itself a power, he just happens to be a half-vampire now). That one tastes like... sprinkles. Sprinkles on top of the explosion of flavor that is the rest of his suite. Sprinkles and lightness and a dream.
"You know what, that makes sense. The other magic is all..." He waves a hand vaguely. "Meta. It's more about getting more magic than being, itself, magic. Kind of. Terms and conditions apply. I am however interested in witchcraft tutoring, if that's the kind of thing that could help with the power you could touch? How does that work, I thought magic from your world was mostly pretty discrete."
"...huh. What a good analogy. Maybe my sources weren't very good." It was admittedly a pretty bad and shallow set of books (he says about a series that he liked enough to have read in its entirety three or four times). "—oh hey before we get into that are you a fan of the Volturi, are they a thing, are they around?" It's occurring to him that maybe the plot here is "do what the Cullens should've done and overthrow the evil vampire government". He can't say he's opposed to the idea.
"Oh, good for them, then, the Volturi had it coming. In my humble opinion." He hums thoughtfully and then floats down the rest of the way to the stool. "But then I don't know why the powers that be decided to send me here, with you. ...well, I mean, I guess maybe it just was about the witchcraft tutoring? What's your going rate for that?"
Is he the kind of Mary Sue that will definitely catch her? Probably not, he didn't take the powers that would bend in that direction with loved ones or whatever and they definitely wouldn't bend in that direction with a random witch mimic that has a special interest in witchcraft.
Anyway Addy can accelerate more than Peter can, it seems.
"So the way that that magic power works is that at any point I may discover a previously unknown heritage from any type of being I encounter, even if it makes no sense or contradicts previously-established descriptions of my family tree and even if this would not normally be a type of being that was interfertile with whatever other heritage I have. I get the powers without the drawbacks unless the drawbacks are cool and dramatic and any given visible features will appear at narratively appropriate moments and be cute, pretty, beautiful, or striking rather than weird, ugly, disgusting, or uncomfortable." He's not quite reciting it from heart but he almost is. "So today I discovered a previously unknown heritage from your kind of vampire, in which I get the immortality and nice skin and senses and strength and speed but not the forced downtime of sleep. I don't remember exactly how food works for hybrids? I know they can eat food but if there was anything about it not tasting nice or whatever I'm probably not going to have that issue either."
"They like their meat raw and they're really into eggs but they can have salad without this being a huge deal. I guess this is the first time anyone who already existed has started being a half-vampire, so it stands to reason this could, like starting to be a vampire, give you witchcraft... where did you come by this curious ability?"
"So I think you definitely can't while I'm around because that wouldn't make me very much of a Mary Sue, would it, if there were another? Or, well, there was actually an option while I was picking these powers for being able to run into another Mary Sue but I didn't pick it. But it's not impossible for the Spirit—uh, the power that gave me the notebook and the powers—to decide to choose you later, so long as you are, ah, open to being powerful and beautiful and special in a feminine way."
"Complicated! Mostly not exactly. Not right now, anyway." Right now he's Astolfo. "But you don't need to be, you just need to be, oh I bet I can bend the medium to make this come off right to you, that sounds like something I should be able to do... You just need to be ✨open to the feminine✨! Did that come through?"
"It's the genre. Or something. So when I said my magic so far is pretty meta, this is kind of what I mean, it's more about shaping the medium and the narrative around me. I picked powers that still allowed for some actually interesting stories but if someone wanted to just go ham on the they're super special nothing they ever do is wrong or goes wrong they are perfect and beautiful forever angle the notebook had options for that, too."
"It's a lot of fun, yeah! I... don't know how likely you are to get one even after I'm gone, though. Probably more likely than you'd been until just before you met me? It'd be a pretty interesting, or at least kind of funny story, me leaving and you getting your very own notebook. And that's probably the sort of thing that matters, here. Oh, here, I want to check whether my thoughts about how this would work are right: am I anime?"
"Oh excellent okay I'm glad you can see it too. So what happened here is that when I was choosing my powers and designing my femmesona in my head there was this specific anime character I was thinking of, and I didn't, like, particularly want to be him exactly but I think my powers or the Spirit thought it would be funny if I was. So I am. But not in a way where it matters. Unless it does.
"Sorry, I hope this isn't too uncomfortable for you."
"I probably can't rely on this because it would be really broken if I could but..." He looks at the camera. Or, well, given the medium, he looks through the screen. "Hey, author or uh authors I think it'd be really fun if sometimes people who met me also got the opportunity to become beautiful and powerful and special in a feminine way. ...well, you know, assuming this would all follow my narrative preferences, but we know that part."
"But anyway, back on the original topic, yeah, when I just turned out to always have been a vampire hybrid I got witchcraft of the sort your world throws out, sometimes. And I am, I think, just straightforwardly a half-vampire hybrid now, so whatever inferences you were drawing from the difference between us and how it affects the power should assume that much."
"Hm. I've met one other witch half-vamp but her power wasn't remotely as quantitative as flight. It's not obvious to me why you'd be slower than me, though - possibilities include that it's directly derived from landspeed somehow, so it's based off bodily strength and agility even though those aren't in play, or that we're flying at the speed of thought, or that I'm more aerodynamic, or that your special snowflake magic thinks it's fun if you get a longer training montage."
"It's... probably not that last one. I think the personalization options here make sure that if I'm not as good as you are there must be a reason for it, there's not going to be a training montage just so that a training montage can exist. Speed of thought seems maybe plausible? How would we test that?"