« Back
Generated:
Post last updated:
a dath ilani EMT in queen abrogail's court
wherein Merrin is dropped on Cheliax
Permalink Mark Unread

The students being lectured in Ostenso's wizard academy, in their third year, can be divided into three rough groups.

In the first group are those whose central goal in wizard academy can be summed up with the word "survival"; they have been wizard-tracked and sent here will-they-nil-they, and now they need to get through with their lives intact and as much of their sanity left as possible.  If they make it to graduation as second-circles they will be, for the most part, sent to the Worldwound for a tour of duty holding back endless demon hordes, and if they make it through three years there, they will be permitted to embark on a civilian life, as third-circles if they are lucky.  You can live a good life that way so long as nobody notices you.  Eventually, of course, you will go to Hell, because among the mandatory sessions at Ostenso's wizard academy are putting into actual practice your deadly spells on stupid or crippled children with no other uses; the cleric students at the neighboring temple need subjects on which to practice healing, after all; also, everybody in Cheliax seems weirdly likely to end up in Hell for some reason, no matter what else they do with their lives.  If you're still first-circle by the time graduation rolls around, then you get posted as a government wizard someplace you won't get much of a chance at combat, possibly at a tiny town out in the middle of farmlands, and you'll be a long time paying back the debt you owe Cheliax for the magical education that it graciously gave you.  (If you haven't made first-circle at all by the end of your second year, you are now a laundry wizard posted to some even tinier farming village, and the debt you owe the academy is probably going to last the rest of your life.)

Students in this first group do their homework, keep their heads down, try desperately to score high enough on exams that they won't be among the bottom third of students whom the top tenth of students get to punish, and engage in political maneuvering only insofar as is required to keep down their losses from other people's maneuvering.

In the second group are the ambitious, though few of them have any ambition.  They can't realistically just try harder at their lessons than the survivors, because in both cases you must try quite hard to compete against other people trying quite hard not to end up in the punishment bracket.  They can try to pick out the smarter survivors and force those into giving them free lessons, maybe with the appearance of protecting them against some other threat if they're hoping for more pretended gratitude.  They are swifter to answer in class even when grades don't depend on it, they try to come to the attention of teachers and look like good prospects for mentoring, they extort things they want from other students so that they will look like good Asmodeans and not just passable ones when the loyalty mindscans come around.

Students in this second group are a bit underrepresented, by the time the third year of academics have come around; some of those who take risks fail, and flunk or get expelled or die.

The third group consists of Pilar Pineda, who is way too much of a masochist to be scared of any standard punishment the academy offers; though she tries very hard to be whatever the teachers proclaim to be good, because that is what a good Asmodean would do, and Pilar Pineda's faith in Asmodeus is invincible.  She Prestidigitates her hair a bright attention-attracting pink, and often goes around saying what's actually on her mind, in both cases apparently in the belief that nothing she considers bad can ever realistically happen to her, not in Cheliax; in the worst case she dies and goes to Hell and who wouldn't want to go there?  You would expect this person to be an absolute total bastard and one of the scariest students in the academy, and not only is Pilar weirdly not that, she's the most likely person in the class to offer to trade tutoring to a struggling lesser student, in exchange for what Pilar will in all blank-faced Asmodean ominousness tell you is a 'favor' to be called in later.  Pilar sure must have some ambitious plans rolling there, for the last months of her education; because graduation is approaching and she's accumulated a lot of favors not called in.  Anybody else would be worried about passing their loyalty scans.

In one particular Ostensan classroom, about a dozen-and-a-half students are arrayed in three concentric circles of desks, listening to a cold-faced lecturer try to explain the necessary folds and twists to scaffold and hang Protection From Chaos.  Around half the students there have succeeded in making good progress on halfway hanging the spell off the standardized spellbook-pages provided them, and the other half of students are sinkingly afraid from the increasingly cold-faced expression of the lecturer that this is going to be a case where more than just the worst performers get punished for falling behind.  They go on trying to scaffold and hang the spell anyways, and don't let their fear make their fingers tremble; anyone who couldn't handle that much pressure failed out before the end of their first year.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is having an impressively bad day. 

Actually her day was FINE up until about ten minutes ago, and then very very rapidly became not fine at all, and things did not improve from there and, in fact, continued to deteriorate right up until the moment of the crashing plane's impact. At which point Merrin expected the badness of her day to become a moot point, because she would not be having a day anymore, or ever again. She had a lot of feelings about this, briefly, and also expected the crash to make all of that moot. 

 

 

 

Her day has instead suddenly veered from disastrous into bizarre and confusing, because she is definitely continuing to have experiences. Also her continuing experience no longer includes being on a plane, crashing or not. She's in a....classroom? Sitting on the floor. Surrounded by students, all of whom are much younger than her and aren't yet reacting visibly with the same degree of shock she feels but are probably about to. 

Merrin is pretty sure that this is not how True Death is supposed to work. This appears to be happening to her anyway, though. Maybe this is actually completely normal and there's an obvious explanation. Somehow. Hopefully, either her brain will soon regain the capacity for having hypotheses about things, or someone is about to tell her what in the name of superheated toilet paper is going on. Merrin hates being confused. 

(She will grudgingly allow that she hates being confused much less than she hates being dead.) 

Continuing to sit on the floor and stare blankly at her surroundings is unproductive and might also be rude, but Merrin has, again, been having a really spectacularly bad day, and she isn't quite feeling up to saying words yet. 

 

From the students' perspective, a young woman in her mid-twenties, with her hair cut short and wearing a completely unfamiliar style of clothes that look well-made and expensive at a glance, has suddenly appeared out of thin air. She's sitting on the floor and she looks, by Chelish standards of emotional expression, VERY VERY UPSET. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Who are you and what are you doing here?" the lecturer demands sharply in Taldane.

He's wearing normal academic wizard-wear for Cheliax, so an obviously magical set of robes in mostly black with gold detailing, tied off with a sash loosely enough to expose a V into his upper chest, which is relatively buff for a wizard.  And a headband that's visibly one of the nicer ones, with enough silver and sapphire-dust detailing to show that this headband wasn't purchased by somebody at the bare limit of what they could afford.  And one magical ring on either hand, and a necklace that glows blue enough to be visible in the classroom's indoor Continual Lighting.

Permalink Mark Unread

Apparently she has landed on a pile of fantasy tropes? This appears to be the thing happening now? 

It's not making the situation any less weird! As a thing to be happening, it's - less weird in some sense than the fact that she's around to experience anything at all. In isolation, finding herself in a room with someone who is clearly trying very hard to look like a powerful magic user and addressing her in a language she doesn't understand or recognize might, possibly, have some kind of sensible explanation. Though the only specific one occurring to her now is 'someone thought it would be an entertaining prank', and Merrin can't see any way to fit that together with the plane-crash part. 

 

...Also the fantasy character talking to her looks kind of angry about it? You would THINK that having just DIED IN REAL LIFE and then ended up here would be big enough to push aside petty feelings like 'social anxiety' but apparently not. 

Merrin takes a deep breath. "I'm sorry, I don't understand you. If, um, you understand me," which is in hindsight a silly thing to bother saying out loud, if he doesn't then he won't understand that comment either, "can you please tell me where we are right now and what you observed happen just now?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

He's got permanent Comprehend Languages but not permanent Tongues.  The language isn't one he's ever heard before, he doesn't think.

"Cheliax," he says, and reads her reaction to that, since she's not looking very composed.  Alarm?  Horror?

Permalink Mark Unread

Mostly she looks blank, showing no sign of recognition. She is still visibly shaken, but confusion is rising to the forefront now. 

"...I'm guessing you mean that's where we are?" He's reacting as though he understood her, but he doesn't seem inclined to give her thorough or helpful answers. Or maybe he understands Baseline but can't really speak it? No, that doesn't make sense... "Um, is it a - city? Continent? ...Planet?" The name of a fantasy setting she's not saying that out loud. 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

...uh huh.

Let's try a Silent Image of Golarion as a huge globe, slowly rotating so their visitor can see it.*  He makes a few gestures to cast the simple illusion, then raises his eyebrows at her, invitingly, and gestures at the planet, if she'd care to point out where she's from.


(*)  Having ninth-circle wizards around means that somebody has ever seen your planet from space and drawn accurate maps of the continents accordingly.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin jumps visibly when the Silent Image appears. She's not normally this easily startled but the whole DYING experience has left her unusually jumpy. 

...and also apparently on another planet???? That is not how plane crashes work!!!! It takes her a minute of examination to be sure, but nope, she is pretty sure that those are not the continents she knows. 

In some sense it's not surprising that this is a different planet, because she also just observed something that shouldn't be physically possible. (She can remotely imagine that in theory maybe you could do it with advanced technology but the entire vibe of this room is screaming that this is not that kind of setting. Merrin is not sure right now if that's a valid form of reasoning, because her brain keeps trying to chase down five different lines of confusion in parallel and she cannot actually do this and so it's hard to think.) 

She is now simultaneously thinking that:

- This makes no sense and maybe she's dreaming - but it doesn't feel like a dream or have the usual tells, other than the physically impossible occurrences, and Merrin is decently competent at lucid dreaming if she can reach the point of noticing she should check. 

- Maybe she's hallucinating? ...This feels too coherent to be a plausible hallucination. And it feels like the rest of her thinking is too intact. Though of course if she were just out of contact with reality she would probably be missing the metacognition to run that check usefully. 

- Also she is worried that she's in trouble for unexpectedly invading their magical academy and that people will be UPSET and there will be a CONFLICT. You would think that being unsure whether any of this is real would make that aspect less nerve-wracking but somehow it's actually more stressful than the rest. 

 

"...I think I'm in fact not from the same planet," she says finally. "I'm sorry, this seems like it might be a private area, I didn't mean to end up here. I don't know how I got here either. It might help if you can tell me what you saw happen. And, um, whether this is a - thing that just happens sometimes here?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

He taps his lips, to indicate that he can't speak her language.

He didn't miss the jump or shock when she saw the Silent Image, either.  It sure looks like somebody who, despite her obvious wealth, has never seen a Silent Image cast before.

"Asmodeus?" he tries, and draws a pentagram in the air.  His Lord is the greatest of gods, and extends across all the realms known to Pharasma Herself; His Name may be recognizable where 'Cheliax' is not.

Permalink Mark Unread

Nope. No recognition. She does look a lot calmer now, and is frowning at him in a puzzled way. 

"I can, um, go, if this is a bad time for me to be here?" Not that she has any idea where she could go, yet. 

Permalink Mark Unread

All right, he's at the limits of his ability to extract more information by nonmagical means.  He turns deliberately away from her, to the utterly silent class.  "You get a chance to impress me," he tells his students.  "That's by having Detect Thoughts hung and successfully casting it on our visitor, who overtly presents as unknowing of Taldane, Cheliax, Golarion, Asmodeus, and possibly the existence of illusion spells in the class of Silent Image.  If you succeed, report any interesting discoveries to me by Message."

Permalink Mark Unread

Ione is usually very, very cautious about who she impresses and how publicly.  Academic high achievers who don't otherwise have powerful means to defend themselves are prime targets for having tutoring and homework assistance extracted from them.  They're usually willing to go to greater lengths to threaten you than you want to go to defend yourself.

She finds herself strangely unable to resist the prospect of impressing this time, though, and strangely glad that she hung Detect Thoughts today (one of the most useful spells you can possibly have in this environment).

She casts, her hands underneath her desk, because there's no point in being more public than necessary.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's a useful spell to have if you're going more on the offensive, too.  Asmodia is good enough at academics that she doesn't need to extract tutoring from anybody else, ever, but something about playing the game purely defensively just rubs her the wrong way.

Permalink Mark Unread

She enjoys looking at other people's thoughts.  It gives her a better sense of them as people, at least if they fail their Will save.  And if she ever does finally decide to crush her school year beneath her heel for the fun of it, she'll have an easier time of it with the added preparation.

Permalink Mark Unread

Great, he stopped looking at her, now is the perfect moment to say "tsi-imbi" clearly and calmly and with as much confidence as she can manage, which isn't a lot right now, and while self-consciously looking at the floor rather than making eye contact with any of the fantasy magic academy students watching her. 

 

Nothing happens. The first thought that any of them pick up is Merrin noticing that nothing happened. And that she's oddly unsurprised about this. Although, given how her day is going, it's impossible to tell if the lack of surprise is because it was actually objectively unlikely, or just because she was surprised by so many things in a row that her brain is hitting the emotional equivalent of semantic satiation.

She's a little relieved, because having a full-on psychotic break on a plane, which seems like the most likely timing for it since that's when her day stopped being normal, is - well, it's apparently in conflict with her self-image that this is the kind of thing that would happen to her. Everyone would be very kind about it, obviously, but they would probably ask her to work shorter shifts she realizes that is not important. Also she should not actually update on that all the way yet. Maybe the first responders are being slow. 

She automatically goes for the mental motion of 'replacing intuitive reason with logic', ignoring the momentary flinch of expecting this to be hard and hurt and also not work very well. (The flinch is a lot quieter now than it was at some points of her schooling. Reality is less deliberate about pushing her to her cognitive limits.)

So, compared to the hypothetical where her plane flight went on as normal and she landed and had her DATE (...now is not the time to be sad about missing that), it's unlikely? Merrin knows a lot more than most people about the risk factors and also the usual experience of losing touch with reality, and this feels very atypical. Her prior on having a psychotic break while well-rested and not especially stressed and without any warning signs at all beforehand is...low. One in a thousand? As an upper bound, it's probably lower than that but she doesn't trust her ability to backfill what she would have said before this happened. It did happen. And of course she's not comparing that to the hypothetical Perfectly Normal Day, the alternative here is that actually the plane did crash and she did die and now instead of being dead she's on another planet. ...how is she even supposed to put numbers on this? Right now there are no numbers, there is only flailing.

(Ten seconds where most of her thoughts are busy assigning probability estimates to various pieces of this ANYWAY and holding them up to herself and doing the mental equivalent of scowling dubiously at them.) 

- aaah nope this is not working. Fall back on things which are not math. This seems physically impossible given what she knows. But Merrin is accustomed to the fact that there are many, many things she doesn't know, and wouldn't be able to make sense of even if someone tried to explain them to her. Maybe...the reason history is screened off at all is to conceal that magic exists? And there's a secret conspiracy of magic users, and one of the things they do is...magically grab people right before they would otherwise die irretrievably? Doesn't explain the continents being different, though. Magic conspiracy also has space travel?

Merrin is pretty sure that she's now starting to wildly posit things that would be huge and have correspondingly vast implications and that seems - not right. Though what she's observing with her own eyes already has vast implications. But all her wild guesses are going to be too specific and also, right now, extremely uninformed, because fantasy magic teacher guy is either unable or unwilling to answer her questions about what just happened

She wants a SMARTER PERSON to figure it out and tell her. Or even better, access to PREDICTION MARKETS, that'd be great. Although right now she's not even quite at the point where she could frame it as a clearly resolvable question. Why is she so bad at things  What would people think of that, it would be hilarious .....this is an unusual amount of flailing instead of thinking even for her, oh right, she's still having an adrenaline comedown, that's very unsurprising and not something she's going to hold against herself but it's so inconvenient. 

 

 

The woman has an unenhanced INT of 16. She seems to consider this clearly insufficient. A lot of her thoughts do give the impression of being...slightly too large and complicated for her to comfortably track, a little as though she were used to wearing a +2 headband and her mental habits keep reaching for more scaffolding that isn't quite there. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Ione reports.  Her name is Merrin, her thinking processes are unlike anything Ione has ever seen, intensely self-reflective like she's high on triple-strength Owl's Wisdom but not in the useless way you'd expect, constantly thinking about how to control her own thoughts.  She's from a world utterly unlike anything Golarion has ever heard of, one with no knowledge of magic but they also hid all their history (and didn't bother faking anything to replace it? just left a big visible gap? weird) so maybe the magic is there but hidden, but their society is still powerful enough that people flew through the air and into space apparently without magic or anything that she knows to be magic anyways...

Permalink Mark Unread

Asmodia reports.  Merrin's thoughts are incredibly sophisticated and trained, moving in polished unfamiliar patterns whose usefulness is only apparent after they finish executing, somebody with incredibly high Intelligence worked hard on crafting this woman into whatever she actually is now.  Many of her thoughts refer to what Asmodia can only dimly feel as sophisticated mathematical concepts that she can't read because they just have no conceptual equivalents that Asmodia knows about.  She's using numbers to guide her own thought processes in a way that Asmodia can't understand, having something to do with - probabilities?  Asmodia is pretty sure that this woman is for some reason much much much more mathematically knowledgeable than Asmodia herself despite not being any kind of wizard.

Permalink Mark Unread

Pilar reports.  Merrin has no idea where she is or what's going on, is questioning her sanity but double-checking it in some very well-informed and medically trained pattern, concluding that she's not in fact insane.  She was in an air-traveling machine going across continents heading for a date? she is apparently wealthy enough to just do that? but instead something happened that meant she should die and instead of being dead she is here?  She's in the middle of coming down off an adrenaline crash.  Also her thoughts seem very clean and organized.  Pilar would like to follow along with whatever's happening with this person so she can learn to have clean organized thoughts like that, if that otherwise serves Asmodeus.

Permalink Mark Unread

Does she look like she knows anything useful, you fools?  Knowledge such as is not yet in Golarion?

Permalink Mark Unread

Return messages:  """Yes."""

Permalink Mark Unread

Vicent has been making deliberate moves, here, in case that was not clear.

Vicent did not have Detect Thoughts hung today - or rather he had two, but he's used both - nor has he Tongues, why would he.

Why not call over somebody with both of those spells, then?  Because then they would have charge of this visitor, this Merrin, and he would not.

Why have three Chelish wizard students look at her thoughts?  Because now three of Ostenso's best students have been exposed to this matter, which shall obviously become secret, and they are not so valuable that anyone would object to that; but neither are they so disposable that they would be disposed-of, rather than being told to follow along.  And the three know him and are in his charge as a teacher, and will make it that tiny bit more awkward for him to be brushed aside and brushed away when this matter is referred upward.

"Sala, Pineda, Asmodia, with me.  Manel, run as quickly as you can to the headmaster's office and inform him that we have five for an urgent trip to diplomatic reception in the palace at Egorian."  Some diplomat there will have permanent Tongues, and of course also Detect Thoughts and Suggestion and other standard diplomatic spells, and adequate Bluff and Splendour to handle her; nor should there be wizards there so mighty as to disdain Vicent for his 5th-circleness.

Permalink Mark Unread

...oh.  She was not expecting that.  Why was she not expecting that?  She has been stupid.

This is not a good thing.

Permalink Mark Unread

This could potentially be a very good thing, although it probably isn't.  At all.

Permalink Mark Unread

Fucking AWESOME.

Permalink Mark Unread

He turns to Merrin, though of course he doesn't call her that, as she hasn't yet spoken her name.  "Vicent," he says, tapping himself.  "Of Cheliax."  He points to Ione, now approaching.  "Ione Sala, of Cheliax."  He points to Merrin.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin has been paying quite a lot of attention to the fantasy-setting magic teacher and his fantasy-setting magic students.

She thinks she recognizes the kind of body language people have when they're providing status reports and then receiving further instructions?

(This is an important thing to be able to recognize, in Merrin's profession, since verbal questioning takes time and disrupts focus. And it's one of the few areas where she's not natively below median in terms of natural ability; she's not brilliant at body-language-reading, or anything, but she's fine at it. And she learns fast and can compensate for her weaknesses. She had to, to make it as far as she has.) 

Some of the reactions she thought she was noticing didn't, apparently, coincide with anyone talking? That's confusing. Although she's also still confused about how and why the magic instructor can, it seems at a first glance, understand what she's saying but not answer. One explanation is that he has good reasons not to (for example, if everything he might say is an infohazard.) Another explanation, though, is that there's....something magic going on? 

....She will try to think about what rules-of-magic she can infer so far in a moment. (And she's noting for future consideration that they're reacting quickly and smoothly to her arrival, despite the fact that they were clearly almost as confused as her in the early moments. But really all that tells her is that they're competent and comfortable enough with one another to do seamless teamwork.) Right now she needs to answer his question.

"Merrin," she says, pointing at herself.

And then makes a wild guess that the second part, which was in common between the instructor and the student he picked out from the group. "Dath ilan," she offers. 

She looks over at the younger student who was just singled out, and smiles at her. It's a tired, relieved sort of smile. 

(Merrin has been briefly considering other ways of expressing her emotional attitude, in hopes of building some kind of rapport, but concluded that they will probably not recognize dath ilani conventions for the sort of salute shared between professionals, or the slightly different salute that a teacher would give a student, or that a professional in one area of expertise would give another professional– ...she is just going to stop overthinking this now.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Asmodia of Cheliax."

"Pilar Pineda of Cheliax."

Permalink Mark Unread

Vicent points to Merrin, taps his ears, nods his head.  He points to his mouth, shakes his head.  Then he points to Sala, Pineda, and Asmodia in turn, taps his ears, and shakes his head.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin thinks she understands what he's saying. 

 

(She...had not previously considered to what extent she would hate and be miserable in a situation where she could say things but not understand anything that other people said to her. It turns out that this is very frustrating.)

 

"- Right. My - current best guess - is that none of you speak Baseline because you're from another planet. But you have - some kind of magic, I guess - where you can understand me anyway? Only it doesn't also let you say things. - Can you all nod if that's true -"

Pause.

"....Um, actually, sorry, pause. I've been assuming that a nod," she demonstrates, "means yes here? And that a headshake," demonstration, "means no? ....Just as a test - I'll be happy to use the head signals later if it turns out we mutually understand them - but just as a test, can someone, um, knock over a chair if the answer is no? And - put one of the chairs up on one of the desks, if the answer is yes?" 

The convenient thing about this test is that if neither of those things happen, it will convey to her that they don't actually understand her at all, and the previous responses were a mix of wild guesses and reading body language. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Vicent will have his Unseen Servant put a chair up on a desk.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh. Excellent. 

....Probably?

Merrin takes a deep breath. "Okay, if you can understand me but not answer me, because - magic - then I think we should probably try to figure out some kind of visual or mathematical system on my side, so that I can communicate? I...can draw a map of my world?"

Ugh she doesn't really expect that to work, though.

"....Sorry, I'm going to keep trying to think of things, but I'm - not having a great day. Which is distracting, it turns out. I - sorry - my math and spatial skills are worse than my verbal skills but if you think you can draw things or whatever more easily then you can figure out the language problem then I'll try my best." 

Permalink Mark Unread

He's still got his Silent Image running, though at present it's not producing an illusion of anything but air.

Illusion:  Vicent, Merrin, three students not depicted in as much detail, meet a sixth person.  They vanish, then reappear inside a vaguely depicted formal hall.  A formally dressed figure steps forward, taps his lips, nods.

Permalink Mark Unread

....If Merrin is following that correctly then they have instantaneous point to point transportation. What. Seriously? 

- should that be such a major update? She was clearly instantaneously transported here, and she doesn't yet have an explanation for that but she knows it happened to the extent that she knows anything, anymore ....unhelpful thought, maybe also wrong but definitely not productive. 

The fantasy-magic-instructor was visibly confused about her? Which is evidence that even if they locally have instantaneous point-to-point transport magic, he doesn't recognize whatever made her appear here?

....Merrin isn't sure what that means. Probably it means something? If she were higher-g she might get it at a first glance, and - also it would be more likely that someone would have taught her the underlying truths she needed to know. But that is not her current situation. (She would appreciate if there were a clear explanation document and a trained instructor available for all her questions, but it's not like this is the first time in her life that she's gone without that.)

Anyway. She isn't yet, exactly, suspicious about whether the fantasy magic teacher in the fantasy magic academy setting is being honest with her. But she's considering that he might not be. Merrin's real life experience hasn't involved any truly adversarial actions, but her Exception Handling training as an EMT has, and she didn't like it but she tried her best to acquire the relevant skills anyway. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh right she should say words. 

 

"...So if I'm understanding you correctly: you can take me somewhere else quickly using magic, with some of the other students, and there'll be another person there who can use magic to answer my questions? You can nod if that's right, and - if that's what you think makes sense to do next, I think I don't have a better alternative to following your judgement there." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is mostly not showing it on her face, but she's still feeling very unhappy.

She doesn't like being thrown outside her area of expertise, and being confused is painful for her, whether or not she's having to at the same time handle a medical emergency. (There doesn't appear to be one and she is unendorsedly resentful about this.) 

- and she's still sad about missing her date. She could really go for someone hurting her a whole lot right now Merrin has no idea that her mind is currently being read, but she's in the habit of noticing that thought and quickly tucking it away for LATER. (It's an infohazard, after all, and the easiest way to avoid accidentally talking about her secret infohazardous personality trait with her friends is to minimize how much it's on her mind, and it's not like there's any actually good reason for it to be relevant now. Whoever the fantasy magic people are, they don't need to know that she's still stupidly upset about missing her date, let alone why.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Vicent nods when Merrin asks for a nod.

Permalink Mark Unread

As Detect Thoughts is something less of an overpowered spell in the hands of distracted second-circle wizard students, Ione is able to notice that Merrin hid a thought about her date but not what the thought was, or why she's hiding it.

...why would anybody from a nonmagical world need to hide their thoughts at all??  If Ione lived in a world where Detect Thoughts wasn't a thing, she would -

- nonetheless think only good thoughts that were loyal to Cheliax, of course.

She duly Messages Vicent about it anyways.

Permalink Mark Unread

A rather more portly and older man huffs ungraciously into the classroom, scowls at the five people present for Teleportation (that's going to take a bit of metamagic from a rod with limited daily uses), and, after a few incomprehensible Taldane words exchanged with Vicent, extends out his arm.

Vicent lays a hand on it, as do Ione, Pilar, Asmodia.

"Merrin," Vicent says encouragingly.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, clearly she's supposed to do - something?

(...That man's breathing sounds kind of concerning? Which Merrin figures is any evidence toward 'this is a training scenario that Governance/her instructors have somehow managed to pull off, and wanted to subject her to for reasons she doesn't know'. Though that's not a very satisfying explanation, given all of the impossibilities she has recently observed. Merrin...will keep an eye on the potential medical emergency, which she would do anyway, but otherwise go on assuming that she died and then ended up on another planet where magic exists -) 

- probably the something she is supposed to do involves imitating the other magic-academy-students? Merrin nods to Vicent and reaches out to place her hand next to Asmodia's. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Sudden sensory discontinuity!  Merrin is now in what passes for a formal reception platform in Golarion, a marble dais with an inlaid fancy gold pentagram (not one usable for summoning purposes, as is obvious to anyone with even the slightest acquaintance with that), surrounded by magical floating crimson ribbons like guardrails.  There's some surprise at their arrival, as two tall men dressed in identical-looking uniforms bark out a Taldane question which Vicent answers swiftly and in commanding terms of his own.

The portly man vanishes, not taking anybody with him this time, and the others all file off the platform and head out of the nearest door.

There isn't really a lot of time to look, but one will quickly start to pick up a general doompunk ambiance around here - the walls are done up in decor that looks like subtly stylized flames, for example, that fade into shadow as they approach a darker ceiling.  The rounded corners of the reception platform room appear as pillars holding up the ceiling with claws.  Unfortunately this is not sufficiently close to dath ilani doompunk to convey anything like a reassuring familiarity.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh NO!  The anomaly has MOVED.  Why are these mortals teleporting the anomaly AROUND?  It could cause more DAMAGE that way!

Well.  She is at least not allowing that to happen AGAIN.  Otolmens puts up an antimagical shell around the anomaly that will prevent external magical effects from affecting it.

(It does not block divination.  Otolmens can think of several past anomalies that She would not particularly have wanted to make magically invisible.  It doesn't block anything internal in case that further perturbs the anomaly.)

Permalink Mark Unread

That sure is an aesthetic! Merrin notices that it's not exactly the doompunk she's familiar with, although honestly it would be weird if it was. ...Okay, it's weird anyway. She tries to get a better look at the pillars, in case the architecture here tells her something about the non-magical tech level, but she doesn't have a lot of time to look and she's not an engineer and also who knows if they're keeping the ceiling up half with magic levitation. She really needs to figure out how expensive magical effects are, here. She's pretty sure that's something that varies between settings, not that she's had time to read all that much fantasy since she was a kid. 

...It looks like their arrival maybe wasn't communicated ahead? Which could mean that long-distance magical communication isn't a thing, or that it's costly, or it could just mean that someone involved is slightly disorganized and they don't have a checklist to follow for 'unexpected visitor from another world.' Either way it looks like no harm was done? 

The initial room did look very - fancy? Moreso than the classroom. If things like inlaid gold are scarce here - she thinks gold was scarce in some of the fiction she read? - then significant wealth was put into this room's decor. Which says...something...about how important they're treating her as? Though Merrin feels like really she is trying to draw inferences from a very small number of observations, so anything she does infer will still mostly amount to a wild guess. She might be better off just waiting until they reach the person who can speak her language. 

She follows the instructor and the other students. (She doesn't notice the antimagic shell around her.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Shortly beyond the doompunk teleportation platform is a fancy doompunk diplomatic reception area that's so expensive it looks only slightly poverty-stricken by dath ilani standards!  Why, most teenaged kids don't have a room in their house that looks this nice!  Unless they're working at an unusually high-paying job!

In the reception area can be found another couple of people in uniforms identical to the two stationed on the teleportation platform, and one person behind a desk wearing in total solemn seriousness a doompunk LARP outfit from a planet with almost no textiles technology.  Somehow it still manages to convey, even across the vast cultural gap, that this person might possibly work for Governance.

There's some more words exchanged in Taldane, level ones with nobody looking visibly surprised at any point.  Then the person behind the desk rises up and goes through one of two doors behind him.

Now there's a wait, apparently?

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin pays a lot of attention to her surroundings. She has extensive training on doing that and noticing as many details as possible.

...Well, most of her training is specific either to noticing people in need of medical care, or environmental hazards that might cause less-careful people to end up in need of medical care. And so she is substantially less skilled at noticing-and-efficiently-chunking any non-medical-emergency and non-hazardous observations in her environment. 

Unfortunately (or fortunately, really, for everyone involved, just not for Merrin's ability to use her skills), nobody nearby is having a medical emergency. (She would judge the competence of their local Governance at least a little if one of the greeters sent for her did have a medical emergency and she was the first responder).

Also the local architecture seems pretty non-hazardous, which is unsurprising in general, except for the increasingly-unlikely possibility where this is some bizarre troll-y training scenario aimed at her specifically, which - at this point she has substantial evidence against?? Probably? 

 

 

She will wait. Trying to do any lowkey social interactions with the fellow students (who are closer to her age than the teacher) is mostly a lost cause, given the language problem, but she tries to smile at all of them.

- oh, wow, one of them has interesting hair! Merrin finds herself smiling at Pilar in particular. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Does it serve Asmodeus for Pilar to smile back?  Yes?  Then Pilar will smile back.

Permalink Mark Unread

Somebody new comes back out from the door behind the desk.  He's wearing a higher-quality version of the last person's probably-an-official doompunk LARP uniform.

"On behalf of local Governance, welcome to Cheliax, Merrin out of dath ilan," he says in Baseline.  "I am Antonio Agramunt, fourth-degree_of_complexity learned_economicmagic-user and empowered-representative of Chelish Governance.  My, what a fascinating language this is, I've never spoken anything like it."

Permalink Mark Unread

Someone is talking in a language she understands! For a second or two, that is the only part that Merrin can really process, and she is beaming about it, with relief and exhaustion and - 

Permalink Mark Unread

- and right, she is representing Civilization in a diplomatic negotiation with aliens? Maybe? Apparently? 

Right. She can do this. 

(Merrin is pretty sure that she is really not the best person for this? But it seems like whatever process caused her to be here, and did not instead cause a different person to be here, either doesn't care or disagrees, and - it's not clear that she has any way of finding out which one. So. She - might as well act on the assumption that she is at least a reasonable person to be selected to make contact with an alien world?) 

 

 

 

"Thank you," she says. "I'm very glad to meet you. ...I - sorry - my first question was going to be, can you ask the teacher and students who saw me arrive what they saw? But I'm also suddenly really curious what's different between this language and the others you know?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"To say in Taldane that I was suddenly really curious, I would say, 'I'm suddenly really curious'."  It's ten syllables instead of Baseline's three.  "It's clearly a language that makes very different messages simple or complicated to say.  And you don't have any simple words for economicmagics of different degrees of complexity, which backs up Vicent's early speculations about your world lacking economicmagic entirely."

"I'll ask your question of the others; give me a moment there."

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay but WHY would anyone come up with a language that took that many syllables to convey such a basic and surely-frequently-expressed sentiment? 

Merrin waits for him to ask the others and then give her the summary. In the meantime, she'll examine his higher-quality probably-a-diplomat doompunk uniform more closely. And also make eye contact with the other economicmagic students again, because why not, they're the closest to her age here and it makes her feel less lonely. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Antonio Agramunt's uniform is made out of threads coarse enough to be visible, in a 2-axis weave that's so uneven it doesn't look up close like a neat grid at all.  No zippers, nothing that looks magnet-augmented, no sign of a buried hood he could pull over his head if it starts raining.  The doompunk aesthetics are conveyed entirely by coloration and some decorations of shiny colored metal, managing to do a surprising job at conveying anything through that language.


Pilar Pineda is most cheerful about returning eye contact; from Ione Sala and Asmodia it seems more measured, restrained, careful.  Not visibly nervous at all.  Nobody flinches to meet her gaze.


After some exchanges in Taldane between Antonio and the others, Antonio reports to Merrin that all four witnesses agree that she was not there in one moment, and there in the Ostenso wizard academy classroom the next.  Vicent in particular has a reasonably high-grade ability to perceive economicmagic and didn't see any associated economagical phenomena upon her arrival.

Permalink Mark Unread

"- I can't say that I'm surprised," Merrin says to Antonio. "I - guess I was just hoping that your economicmagic would have - seen something more informative than that - but that's basically just what I experienced. I wish I could tell you more." 

 

Pilar Pineda...looks like the sort of person who'd be really great to do an intense EMT shift with...?

- Merrin is not at all sure what to make of that impression. She generally has a certain level of calibrated trust in her surface impressions but who knows if that applies at all on another planet. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Your clothes are an outlier-with-respect-to-our-expectations in their sophistication and complexity," what an incredible language, Antonio doesn't even understand that thing he just said.  "It's an obvious thought to inquire whether you perhaps come from a place that would have more ideas than we did about what happened.  May I ask - what manner of person you may be, and what is this place of dath ilan that sent you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

- The first question is way easier. And probably she shouldn't throw too much information his way at once– okay fine actually she just wants a reason to limit how much she has to think about right now. 

"I'm an emergency-medical-responder. My specialty is endurance, as in - emergencies that last a long time and where you can only send one person in - I'm the person you would send, I have the natural ability and also the training for it. ....I've done a lot of training for Exception Handling but in real life I haven't really dealt with any exceptions before - this."

Permalink Mark Unread

Interesting.  "Are you then a - your language has no word for 'cleric'.  Or 'god'.  Fascinating.  How does one respond to medical emergencies without economicmagic to heal people?"

Permalink Mark Unread

What??? 

"......That is going to take me a really long time to explain and I should at least check with you first whether that's the best use of your presumably-limited ability to speak my language." 

- there were two mysterious words in there and it seems in context like they were probably important?

Permalink Mark Unread

"We are at present trying to triage you as to where you fall within Cheliax's priorities-for-limited-allocation-of-resources, and from your clothes alone I would guess that you are a woman expecting accomodations and treatment that we would usually reserve for only a few; the question of whether you can be useful to us is, I admit, not far from our thoughts."

Permalink Mark Unread

...expecting accommodations??? Merrin wasn't expecting anything here, she doesn't think–

- well, she was expecting to be DEAD, which is not all that difficult to improve upon. 

(It is possible that Merrin would in general have some mental flinches around being considered important or worth attention from Governance.) 

 

- He used the word 'triage', which might just be a magic-translation thing and maybe his underlying concept is very different, but it still leaves her a little more inclined to positive feelings about him. 

 

"...I would like to figure out how I can be useful here," she says, "but I think it will be a lot easier to do that once I'm less incredibly confused about - your world, and how it works, and also how and why I ended up here." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm honestly not sure of where to start," says Antonio; without the thought particularly occurring to him that anybody might find it very odd that somebody tried to claim they were being honest in the course of transmitting information at all, given that any question as to its veracity would likely apply to the meta-claim of its being honest.  "Well, I propose that we at least find a nice room with a place for you to sit, provide you with some food and drink.  Perhaps allow you a few minutes to catch your breath and think," under appropriate telepathic supervision.  "We can, I think, provide you with such as would be appropriate to the highest level of visiting dignitary.  But continuing the same level of hosting after that would depend on a longer conversation we would then have, about what we can do for each other."

If 'Merrin' is not a cleric nor a wizard,  she shouldn't have much in the way of Will saves?  Probably?  The previous round of Detect Thoughts worked on her with no sign she noticed.  But she was distracted then, and Antonio is not quite sure that they should make assumptions about what people from another and nonmagical world can do.  A Chelish diplomat trying Suggestions is riskier, if it fails, than somebody noticing some disposable wizard students tried to read her mind after she burst into their classroom uninvited.

He'll get a more senior wizard in to try those, Antonio thinks.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is too distracted to notice anything odd about the 'honestly' that was dropped in there, aside from maybe a vague unease which is immediately lost in the much larger pool of pre-existing vague unease about everything she's experienced in the last twenty minutes

 

...the highest level of visiting dignitary what? Does that mean she's supposed to...do...anything...? 

 

Oh good they're offering her a few minutes to sit down and catch her breath? Great! That's considerate of them. Merrin suddenly likes this person about 30% more. 

"Thank you. I would appreciate that– um, if anything really urgent comes up, I can be functional as required within my domain of expertise, I think? But...if you want me to do more general reasoning and communication then, yes, I could really use some time to sit down and catch my breath." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin doesn't seem to have a lot of Bluff and, if that seeming is at all true, reads as basically just not picking up on the hints that she's got to play nice in order to keep the nice things that will be offered her?

Maybe this woman actually is just exhausted and scared after ending up in another plane?  Pretty pathetic if so.  She's not even visibly wounded.

Antonio considers offering Merrin a Lesser Restoration, decides against it, there'll be time later to see how she responds when less fatigued and for now this may be useful.

"Come along, then," says Antonio.  He takes a few steps forward, towards the other door behind the desk (not the one he originally emerged from), and beckons Merrin to follow.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin follows, still emotionally if not physically exhausted and still oblivious to any of the subtext. (Even if she were paying very close attention, which she isn't, 'she's pathetic for being scared after ending up in another plane' would be such low-priors subtext according to Merrin's experiences so far.) 

She is, instead, dwelling on the fact that EVEN IF the Keepers know that actually True Death isn't even a thing and that every time someone would otherwise permanently cease to exist, they end up in a random economicmagic fantasy setting instead - well, they're not going to tell her parents. And so her parents and her boyfriends and her colleagues and everyone she's ever met or cared for in her entire life is going to, right now, be thinking that she's gone. Forever. No more Merrin.

 

...They'll be all right. She has to believe that Merrin catches this thought before it's quite formed because obviously that is not how anything works. But - at the very least it's still true that dwelling on that more right now is not going to help her parents or anyone else. And that it will help HER if she can focus on her current situation. 

Permalink Mark Unread

(For whatever it's worth, fully three of Merrin's boyfriends are pre-Keeper-cleared to a level where they will be told the much more disturbing truth about the Isekai Theory of Immortality.  But not her parents and family, no.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin will be led through a couple of doompunk-themed hallways to a relatively brighter (still indoors) room which offers her a glass and a selection of wines and juices to pour into it, and a variety of primitive low-tech light snacks.

Antonio will stick around to see if Merrin has questions about those, rather than leaving her alone.  ETA on the seventh-circle wizard called in from elsewhere in the palace is still a couple of minutes, and he doesn't want Merrin left alone until they can snoop her thoughts properly.

Permalink Mark Unread

This place is so weirdly doompunk! Well. Slightly off doompunk. Merrin could give them some constructive criticism, if for some reason she wanted to do that. It seems like not at all the priority here. 

...Okay they're offering her things to drink? None of them are warm. She kind of wants something warm, right now, but not badly enough to ask for it and maybe inconvenience someone. 

(Merrin has spent a lot of time and effort on training herself to be more comfortable inconveniencing other people, but she's particularly out of her depth right now and so falling back on older mental habits.) 

She sits down and pours a random beverage into her glass and sips it. 

Permalink Mark Unread

A fine old Westcrown vintage of thirty years ago!

Permalink Mark Unread

What in the name of nuclear-waste-contaminated wet wipes is this supposed to be???? 

Permalink Mark Unread

...On the one hand, if they're poisoning her and she just goes on drinking the poison because she doesn't want to offend the locals, that would be stupid, and not even an interesting kind of stupid?

 

On the other hand, if they're trying to poison her then probably all of these are poisoned. Also they have literal magic. If they're trying to kill her for any reason then– well, maybe the worst case scenario here is that she finds herself on a different random fantasy planet? Since that's apparently how True Death works?? 

 

...on the other other hand she could just...ask. Maybe she has different biology than the apparently-human locals. 

"Is this supposed to taste like something poisonous?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"...no.  Hm.  Do you have -"

"Your language contains no word for 'wine' or several related beverages.  I wonder if it wouldn't have its standard-expected-causal-effect on you, or if it would work but your faction has prohibited it as some factions do?"

Antonio indicates the lighter-colored liquids.  "These are fruit juices, which perhaps may be more to your taste since terminology for the concept exists within your language.  If not, I'll have plain water brought for you, and if that doesn't work, we may have a problem."

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is apparently now VERY CURIOUS about the standard-expected-causal-effect of the beverage that Baseline doesn't have a word for! 

...This is not in any way a good reason for her to drink it, though. Merrin knew by the time she was five or six that "but I want to know what happens!" was - not necessarily a temptation that she shouldn't follow, but one where she should at least do some research first. 

 

....She's still curious. 

"Thank you. I think I'd like to try one of the fruit juices -" is there another glass she can use that isn't already full of Mystery Substance? "- but, um, I'm actually really curious what the expected effect is? If it's not poisoning you." Which it tastes like it should but she doesn't need to repeat that. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Increased relaxation although-that's-not-actually-an-accurate-description?  I would not have offered it to you if I had not expected you to already know what it was, a folly for which I apologize."

Permalink Mark Unread

Being more relaxed sounds like it might be useful, right now? She's still inconveniently jittery from the thing where she ALMOST DIED. Or maybe actually died. She's not sure what to call it at this point. 

 

However. Apparently it's a psychoactive drug??? Why? Is it just a normal thing here to offer visitors psychoactive-drug-laced beverages? Without telling them what they ARE– ...he did acknowledge that he assumed she would know what it was, which is maybe an easy mistake to make, Merrin assumes she's making some assumptions that are at least that awkward. But still. She is apparently STILL CURIOUS about the mysterious psychoactive beverage but now is not the time actually. Especially since he said explicitly that 'increased relaxation' wasn't a fully accurate translation of the effects. 

".....I think I would rather have plain water. If that's all right." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Of course," he says graciously and apologetically.  "I could also have simple fruits brought for you, if you have analogously-structured worries about the hidden-complexity-dangers of the overcomplicated snacks."

What a fascinating language.  It really says something about the people who must speak it that they have a single-syllable word for 'overcomplicated' and a two-syllable word for 'dangers hidden within complications', which isn't even quite what Antonio was thinking, but it's the word that came out.  Their contracts and compacts must be works of technique and art on par with this woman's clothing.

Permalink Mark Unread

"....Um, I wasn't previously worried about the snacks but are they also known to have - psychoactive effects other than the usual ones you'd expect from taking in calories?" 

Merrin had thought it would be more relaxing or relieving or something, to have someone here able to communicate with her? Instead she keeps feeling like she's missing something - as though there's an object just right at the edge of her peripheral vision - 

 

- probably she's just stressed about the entire situation. And she should try to focus and stop obsessively paying attention to any possible indication that the stranger from another world is upset with her, and instead think about how to explain things. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Antonio separates out one of the snacks.  "This one was made with 'liquor', which is a specialcase-of-a-supercase of the 'wine' I offered you.  Aside from that, everything here should be not psychoactive.  And the amount of liquor in that snack would not be enough to have a least-perceptible-effect, assuming-all-rules-operated-as-expected."

Permalink Mark Unread

Huh. Merrin isn't sure why they put drugs into a random selecting of their foods and beverages here? The fact that they do is leaving her kind of dubious about the whole selection; she's not all that hungry anyway, so she might as well hold off. 

She sips the water he brings her, and tries to think. 

 

(If anyone is paying attention: most of her thoughts are about her parents, and the boyfriend she was flying to see, and the four-year-old on the plane with her - she's wondering if he's also recently woken up in another world - is he all right, there, that would be terrifying it's hard to even imagine and she doesn't want to but she's trained herself not to flinch away from things she doesn't want to think about, or at least to flinch less...) 

(There is no even-slightly-believable possible world where should could have stopped it from happening. She's not an engineer and she couldn't have been, she barely scraped past the qualifying tests to be an EMT which isn't even very g-loaded, and yet it's still incredibly tempting to think that if only she'd studied harder, if only she'd signed up for more trainings, if only she had done enough then she could have fixed it–-) 

...Merrin recognizes that line of thought. None of the usual things she would do about it are available, except for 'distractions', but there's no shortage of those. 

 

After a couple of minutes, "- I can answer questions now. Or, um, if it's easier on your end for me to start, I can give an explanation of what just happened from my point of view? ...I'm probably not up for explanations on the level of putting rigorous probability estimates on everything but I can do the basics." 

Merrin is pretty sure that she's messing up first contact with an alien world VERY BADLY, but to be fair no one SAID it was important for her to do trainings about this, or to read more science fiction, which she hasn't had time or spare cognitive capacity for since she was, like, twelve. 

Permalink Mark Unread

There is, in fact, a seventh-circle wizard running Detect Thoughts on Merrin now!  Along with Detect Anxieties and Detect Desires.  What do those show in terms of anxieties, desires, and also her Splendour and Wisdom?

Permalink Mark Unread

Her Wisdom comes in at 20. Splendour is 14. 

 

Merrin's desires are: 

- To save her patients' lives. (Or for no one to ever die the True Death and cease to exist forever, inside Merrin's motivation system those are half-blended into a single thing.) She wants this so so so badly. 

- Right now, to see her boyfriend who she was on a plane to visit (even if it's just one more time, even a message would do, she just wants him to know that she didn't mean to fail to show up for their date and she still likes him and misses him and wants him to hurt her.) 

- To do a good job at first contact with aliens or at least not mess it up disastrously. 

 

Merrin's anxieties are: 

- She's afraid that the four-year-old on the plane is alone in a different other world and doesn't understand what's happening and his mother isn't there and he must be so scared but she can't do anything, can she. 

- She's worried that she's going to disappoint...someone, the 'someone' is unspecified, by not being smart enough. 

 

(Her int score, if he or anyone is checking, continues to show up as 16.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Antonio is now on relay from the (rather fascinated) wizard and has been told that Merrin has Intelligence 16, Wisdom 20, Splendour 14, and thinks of herself as too stupid for most jobs in her society.

...that would be an easier vulnerability to exploit if he wasn't trying to run it against somebody with native 20 fucking Wisdom and, he's being told, highly trained thoughts that move in not-really-human patterns.

She's apparently a Lawful Good healer type, so probably at some point they're going to discard diplomacy and break her to compliance.  But that decision does need to wait on being pretty sure that there is not the vengeance of a nearly unimaginable society following close upon her heels.


"I think that where you are from, in general, is much more important than the details of exactly what just happened to you," he says.  "- unless there's some relevance there I'm not seeing."

Permalink Mark Unread

".....I don't know! I - guess my main thought there is that what just happened to me should not have been possible given what I know about physical reality and so maybe it's something...weird. That might have implications that you'd want to know about. But I don't know what and if you also don't know what then maybe there isn't a good avenue to make progress on it right now." 

 

Merrin is currently thinking that she had an entire conversation with a Keeper that time and could he not, while he was informing her that she would like it if people she was attracted to hurt her (which is apparently RARE and IN DEMAND) (Merrin would normally steer away from this thought in conversation because she's not amazing at not-saying what's on her mind and this is an infohazard) - anyway could he not have ALSO told her literally anything about what might hypothetically happen if she died in a plane crash. Because then she would maybe have made different choices about what books to read in her very limited free time. Not that there's any reason why he would have thought that was a priority so this is a pointless line of thought actually but she's still frustrated about it. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not a specialized-professional in figuring out things that strange, and I would think it may be done at more leisure than this.  Right now I am trying to understand what, if anything, you have to offer Cheliax, which would in turn determine whether -"  The entire concept of a Grand High Priestess does not go into this language at all.  "The preeminent Chelish specialist in such mysteries would find it worth her time to speak to you."

Permalink Mark Unread

.....Why are they asking her whether she should speak to the preeminent specialist in anything. That's terrifying ...she should ignore that and make all the right choices anyway, she's great at that, she's had so much practice

(Again, if this is meant to be threatening, Merrin is missing 100% of the subtext in that direction. His facial expressions are being really polite and surface-friendly and she's distracted! She is maybe feeling some vague unease but she's been feeling that way or worse the entire time!) 

".....Um, that seems like something that might also make more sense to decide slowly and not interrupt her, if she's doing other very important work?"

But maybe that's wrong maybe actually this SHOULD be the highest priority but Merrin has no idea how to advocate for anything about her being the highest priority for a Very Serious Person! 

"- Sorry, I'll try to answer your question. The world I'm from is called dath ilan. We don't have magic - we have the concept, in fiction, which is why you were able to talk about your kind of magic at all in my language– also I'm so curious how the economicmagic does language translation that seems genuinely hard - digression, sorry, anyway. I am fairly sure we have a significantly higher tech level than your world but I actually know very little about your world other than the shape of the continents, since I wasn't able to ask questions before. ....I personally am an expert in endurance emergency-response-medicine and the required training means that I also know quite a lot about biology and some amount about engineering - um, that's mostly because I did a really absurd number of Exception Handling certifications and some of those included having to build all my own medical equipment from scratch...." 

Wow she hates this. People are paying attention to her like she's important, and not even in the nice way that her boyfriends do. 

Permalink Mark Unread

The concept of somebody with INT 16 / WIS 20 and also 14 Splendour acting and thinking like this is challenging some of Antonio's views about how reality is supposed to work, and it occurs to him to wonder whether the divination numbers mean what he believes they should.

"What sort of medical equipment can you make from scratch?"

Permalink Mark Unread

....Something about the entire way that they're reacting to her feels - confusing, still, in a way that's leaving Merrin uneasy? But not in a way she can even slightly pin down in words or concepts or even metaphors-from-fiction. Maybe if sh'e read more fiction recently she could manage it. 

(Merrin is above-median for dath ilan at picking up on subtle body language cues, especially for anything that even slightly indicates an adversarial situation, and she is well below median at the ability to introspect on her emotions or sensory impressions and put them into words.) 

 

Does he want the entire rundown. That will take a while. Maybe she'll just start and try to pay a lot of attention to whether they seem bored or something? 

"So it depends a lot on the accessible resources and accessible tech level being assumed for the scenario? Starting from the most basic, I guess - if I were literally in the wilderness with only the clothes on my body, and a patient to treat - who wasn't immediately dying, I mean, if they were immediately dying then medical equipment is not my top priority - but if they weren't, I could improvise a blood pressure cuff using some cloth from my sleeve. I would need to find a sharp piece of rock to cut it or a non-sharp piece of rock of the right kind that would fracture if struck on a hard surface, or at worst a thorn from a tree - and ideally I'd have a stethoscope-equivalent, you can improvise that from the right kind of holliow reed, but if not I could just manually feel for a brachial pulse although it's less accurate..." 

 

Merrin has, in her lifetime, done thousands if not tens of thousands of hours of training in this area, and if nobody stops her - or looks slightly bored or antsy or disappointed or like they even at all are upset with her - it will in fact take a VERY LONG TIME. 

Permalink Mark Unread

“What’s the most complicated technology that you can create given unbounded-time but no information-others-have-and-you-do-not?”

This continues to be amazing; the nearest terms to what he wanted to say, that actually come out from Tongues, are such precise things compared to Taldane.  To speak this language is to have it reshape what you say to others and even what you think, in an obviously deliberate way that forces you to step to the creator’s preferred rhythm for you.

Permalink Mark Unread

She has to stop and thinking about that for a minute. He wants 'most complicated' which is different from 'most inconvenient for her personally assuming she's stuck rebuilding all the prerequisites from scratch in the wilderness for some reason' and also different from 'most time-consuming.' 

"Probably a ventilator? Um, that's a machine that breathes for people, if they're too sick or injured to breathe on their own or if they're under anesthesia for a surgical procedure. It involves some amount of basic programming - being able to give instructions to a machine so it can use information from sensors to perform tasks autonomously with some flexibility, I don't know if you have that at all here. Though the prototype that I could theoretically build uses a lot of simplifying workarounds and it's hard-coded, I don't know how to build a general-purpose reprogrammable computer from scratch although if one existed I do know how to work from there."

(Some. She is, very unsurprisingly, not good at it. Though better than anyone had expected given her raw mathematical ability.) 

"...I also know the chemical formulas for about twenty basic lifesaving drugs and a lot of the prerequisites to build a lab to synthesize them, although I have not technically done any training scenarios where I had to do that completely on my own or with no pre-existing tech to repurpose." 

Permalink Mark Unread

The 7th-circle wizard reading Merrin's thoughts and wearing a +6 headband of vast intelligence - who's making rather more headway on tracking all this than Agramunt - informs Agramunt that this woman seems literally priceless.  He's ordered an additional three Security to this location, and for this issue to be escalated to Her Infernal Majestrix at near-top priority.

It's not obvious how Agramunt could really fuck this up for Cheliax, given that eventually they're going to torture her into compliance anyways.  But if hypothetically Agramunt decided to lose his temper and kill Merrin and she refused resurrection and Heaven realized what they had and blocked any attempted Miracles to resurrect her anyways, Agramunt's death would take a very long time and when he got to Hell he would still be sad it hadn't lasted longer.  Whatever competence Agramunt has, he should currently be attempting to show it.

Permalink Mark Unread

All right, if there's anything in particular to be gained from interacting with Merrin cooperatively for a few days or weeks before showing Cheliax's fangs, Antonio is going to try not to screw that up, sure.  Merrin is apparently picking up on something that's making her nervous, despite all Bluff and Splendour, which figures at native WIS 20.  It's probably about time for that Suggestion.  Though first he should check, even if it runs a risk of making her slightly more suspicious -

"Your people seem prodigiously sophisticated, despite their lack of economicmagic.  Do you expect them to follow on after you to Cheliax, and if they did arrive here, would they be willing to trade with us?  Would they be willing to trade knowledge-as-a-factor-of-production to us, or only finished-goods to keep us as captive-customers?"  Add an extra question to distract from the important one: will anyone protect you, avenge you?

Permalink Mark Unread

How is she supposed to know that ....okay fine that's an unusually pointless thought even for Merrin. She doesn't know, not in the way that she knows the chemical formula for antibiotics, and it's important to track her actual level of uncertainty, and of course a lot of relevant information - especially to the first question - is going to be hidden from her and even if it wasn't she might not be able to draw the correct inferences from it. But she doesn't have zero information and it's an important question. 

(She's not suspicious that he's asking, though she's a tiny bit confused, it seems to be - holding some level of implicit assumption that dath ilan wouldn't default to cooperation? That...tells her something about this world, maybe about this world's fiction about two civilizations coming into contact, and maybe also about - she struggles a little to frame the thought - about how their Governance thinks of themselves? That's not quite right but she makes a mental note of it for later processing.) 

 

"...Um, I think I have relatively less of the context I would need to make a good guess about the first thing, I would - lean slightly against, because even if it's just something known by Keepers that this happens, if it were possible to go find where the people ended up, I think I would probably have noticed some sign of it? But it's not impossible that there's a really good reason to conceal any sign of it, and I...would be reluctant to state confidently that a group of determined Keepers working together couldn't do that. If I had to put numbers on it now I'd probably say...one in ten chance or less? But plausibly I shouldn't be trying to put numbers on it until I've thought about it for at least an entire day." 

She wonders if it's actually more feasible that she - or one of their economicmagic wizards, at least - could contact dath ilan from here? Which seems like it would be obviously a good idea, if they could figure it out, given the INCREDIBLY HUGE potential for trade here. (Also it would be great to be less completely on her own, but that's a her-affecting-only consideration, it clearly won't be an important part of the case she could make to Governance here that it's worth investing massive resources in a research project on this.) ....This line of thought is not answering the question she was asked and she'll mentally table it for a minute. 

"On the trade question, I - think they'd have a lot of questions? Some of them are questions I would be able to think of myself once I've seen more of how your economy works, probably there would also be a number of questions that I am never going to think of on my own. There might be concerns about going slowly to avoid unknown-unknown destabilizing effects?" There might be concerns about something related to infohazards but for the very obvious reason she's not going to guess what they would be. Even fiction covering actual infohazard concerns would then just not be available to the public to read, and Merrin hasn't read almost any of the 'trading with alien civilizations' genre of fiction anyway because it tends to have WAY more math than she feels like poring over in her leisure time.

"...Um, I think it seems more likely than not that Governance would settle on trading with Cheliax? But I'd be leery of confidently saying that likelihood is higher than, ummmmm, six or seven out of ten - it probably is but I'm doing a lot of guesswork? Assuming yes on trade at all, I think it's pretty likely they would be willing to trade knowledge-as-a-factor-of-production, although for - more in exchange, I think, it seems legitimately more valuable. But ultimately I think dath ilan would benefit from trade, and your world would obviously benefit - you seem a lot more resource-poor, at a glance, despite the magic - and that in itself is something our Governance would care about." 

If Merrin were a completely different person she would probably already have been thinking about how much she could fairly get paid for sharing her own knowledge, inconveniently limited as it is. She should probably be thinking about it anyway; the shoulder-voices of several of her boyfriends are protesting the fact that she hasn't yet. 

"Does that help answer your question?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"It does.  Thank you, that seems more than enough to confirm that you are a resource-priority for now."

One in ten is uncomfortably larger than 'no', and if Merrin was lying, Antonio would have been notified so.  But he's also being notified that her thoughts are starting to trend in worrying directions already; so, yes, it may be time for that Suggestion now.  If it's just a Suggestion, dath ilan will probably not be too offended if they find her... or not very much more vastly offended than a Lawful Good realm would be in any case by Cheliax.

Permalink Mark Unread

At Agramunt's silent signal, a harmless-looking young man, wearing a lesser version of Agramunt's uniform, enters bearing a platter of plain fruit, which he sets down on the table before Merrin.

"I know enough now to set your proper accommodations in motion, and will leave you some moments of peace," says Agramunt.  He rises, and bows.

The disguised seventh-circle wizard likewise bows.  "I hope these small tokens of hospitality find your favor, and that you are pleased with your reception here and your concerns set at ease."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you. I appreciate it. ...If it's not too much trouble, could I have some kind of writing material in here as well? I want to take some time to put my questions in better order and figure out what things I should be telling you about as a top priority," in a way that's less disorganized than what she's being doing so far, and also she should figure out what to ask them to pay her, because 'that conversation feels awkward to have' is in no way whatsoever a good reason to keep avoiding it. And it'll be less awkward if she can present it in a concise and dignified way. 

(The fruit is almost certainly not Secretly Drugs? Merrin suspects that she is vastly over-worried about the possibility of random foods or beverages being drugs, relative to all the thousands of other possibilities for unwanted surprises one might expect to run into when suddenly alone in an entire different Civilization which is also a fantasy setting, and it would be more useful to take the attention that's currently going into worrying about that one and instead staying alert for other cultural-difference pitfalls.) 

 

...The Suggestion does not do anything. It doesn't look like Merrin threw the spell off - she didn't notice anything at all - it just.....didn't have any effect. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Antonio is notified of this and does not, of course visibly panic in any outward way, although there's a definite spike of inner horror.

"Of course," he says graciously.  "Someone will knock with it shortly."

He departs.

Permalink Mark Unread

- and throws up a wall of silence the moment they're outside, whirling on the seventh-circle.  "What the Abyss?  Her thoughts show her as a complete commoner from a nonmagical world, right - does she not have a soul for spells to affect -"

Permalink Mark Unread

"You're talking gibberish.  Those spells work on brains, not souls, if they worked on souls they'd persist into the afterlife.  Shut up while I check a few things."

The seventh-circle casts.  Casts again.  Casts again.

"No magic reaches her, any part of her body, it all vanishes as soon as it would have touched her skin.  How the fuck did you Teleport her here?  Did she do anything before that, switch off a device she had -"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I wasn't there, but Vicent didn't mention that in his report -"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm ordering a second-circle cleric to come in bringing that writing material, we need to try a Lesser Restoration on her, see if nonaggressive magic gets through -"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Can we delay on that?  We don't want to needlessly waste the time of the Church while matters are still so unsettled."  What the Abyss are you saying?  We need this to be firmly a Crown project before the Church hears about it!

Permalink Mark Unread

"She's a masochist with Wisdom 20 who specialized in enduring difficult situations, you fool, if we can't heal her during torture it's possible we can't successfully torture her into compliance without sending her to Heaven."

Permalink Mark Unread

Theoretically, Antonio is still in charge here.  Theoretically.  Even if he is 4th-circle and the other is 7th-circle, he is the senior Crown diplomat who is handling this issue and the other is not.

"That's certainly a terrifying possibility," he says mildly.  "It means that if either of us screwed up, we can expect a very long death, that we'll still be sorry to see end.  I'm countermanding your order for a cleric to bring Merrin the paper; we don't need to know right away whether we can heal her without her permission, until we have an excuse to learn that more naturally.  I'll just play the diplomatic game as if it was sudden-death, with her, until I do know."

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin, oblivious to these happenings, sips the water and cautiously nibbles on some fruit and waits for her writing materials. 

It takes a couple of minutes before a new person - who does not seem to have the magic to speak her language - brings paper (of reasonable quality, not to dath ilan manufacturing standards obviously but it's a whole lot better than the paper she would know how to make herself) and low-tech-but-fancy pens that only take a little bit of experimentation to figure out how to use. (Merrin's main inference from the delay is that paper wasn't literally in the next room, which makes it a slightly more inconvenient request than she meant to make, but oh well.) 

She arranges herself comfortably in front of the nearest writing surface, and then....doesn't write anything at all for several minutes, while she wrestles her brain into setting aside most of the eight thoughts it's trying to have all at once, and instead think about them ONE AT A TIME. 

 

...The overarching question here is 'what is she going to do.' Because she has to do something, and for the first time in her entire life, she can't assume that anyone else is going to tell her what or handhold her through all the considerations or give her good advice. (She's not certain of that - once she knows some more people here, and once they know anything about her to tailor advice to, maybe that will be an option? But flailing for it right now before she's even tried to orient herself is, while slightly tempting, not actually a good plan.) 

In some ways she's very prepared for this? She's used to weird. She's spent most of her life intensively training herself to be able to handle weird. This is still...several orders of magnitude more completely unexpected and bizarre than any Exception Handling scenario she's ever done, but she has the mental building blocks to cope with it, and so she will. 

Permalink Mark Unread

- actually, following that line of thought a bit further, she's thought of a new question, which is: was she directed here? Was the process that sent her to Cheliax a random one, or - was it something that was optimizing toward some kind of goal? That...would have implications. Though without knowing any of the things that Keepers might or might hypothetically know or have guesses about for why this is a thing, she can't really do better than guessing– 

 

 

- probably actually false? A world that was picked out from vast numbers of them for her specifically is going to have different properties and without knowing what goal the hypothetical goal-oriented process is acting toward, she's still going to be filling in with some guesswork - and she should NOT be immediately latching onto the first immediate thought that she's here to FIX MEDICINE. She can notice the urge to, the sense that it would relax some kind of internal tension, that it would feel like having solid ground under her feet again, but she doesn't have to succumb to it. 

She writes that down, though. (In an Exception Handling cipher that she learned, both because this seems especially infohazardous and she doesn't know if the locals have magic to read text in other languages as well as understand spoken words but it seems plausible, and also because it lets her use some shorthand, though inconveniently the shorthand it affords isn't really optimizing for writing out notes about True Death sending people to other worlds.) 

All right. Good. She can spend a minute or two thinking of other possible reasons she could have been sent here, and then she can think about what she would expect to look different in those worlds versus an unselected one.

....The second thought she has is 'what if she's here to meet someone and have a Romance.' Great, thank you, Merrin's brain, she's writing that one down but it seems a lot less likely.

She could be here to learn their economicmagic, research how to re-contact dath ilan, and bring her new knowledge back to Civilization? That sounds terrifying but it's going on the list. 

 

She then immediately scrabbles for a fresh sheet of paper to start a new category, which is 'questions to ask her gracious hosts'. The economicmagic can obviously be taught, given that she landed in a school for it, but it seems important to know how long it would take and whether it requires any innate aptitudes and also she needs to find a way of testing whether the apparent-humans here have some innate differences that lets them learn it, and she wouldn't be able to. 

 

She could...be here to trade her knowledge to them and become fabulously wealthy? That feels unsatisfying, though. Or maybe just disappointing. Not the thing Merrin pictures herself being best placed to do. Also probably at least half of the other people who died in the plane crash would have had a lot more fun with it. (Though there's no particular reason to expect the mysterious guiding force, if it exists, to be selecting for her personal happiness?) ...Okay on reflection she is not going to try to rank her wild guesses by likelihood yet, she's just going to get them down on paper at all. And timebox this part for another two minutes and then move on, since presumably her hosts are going to want to speak to her again before next week. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Great. She has some possible stories - they're nowhere near fleshed out or rigorously defined to call 'explanations' yet - for why she in particular is here in particular. That's probably enough to go on for now; it'll at least give her directions to focus her attention, rather than 'being constantly on alert for anything at all' which is not actually a great way for orienting to a complex new environment.

(There are downsides, of course, maybe she's making some basic reasoning error and now she'll be paying attention to the wrong signifiers, but she's not sure if she's capable of coping with her previous level of utter confusion for too much longer. She makes a note to reassess at some point– 'at some point' isn't a time, she will make a note to reassess tomorrow morning and then again in a week? And maybe revise that if something completely model-breaking happens.) 

 

 

Right. So. Implications for the near term. ...For a lot of the possible scenarios, it makes sense for her to be trying hard and early to provide value? Also that makes sense for common-sense normal reasons. She can start making a list of domains-of-knowledge that she would, if they turned out to be something Cheliax considered valuable, be things she could explain or demonstrate at all. Please don't let it be math Merrin is an adult who is extensively trained in dealing with very stressful things and teaching math to people who are probably WAY SMARTER than her but lack the benefits of dath ilani education is something she can totally do if necessary. 

 

- actually, pause there, she feels like she might have skipped a step. Definitely skipped a step. Possibly the most key part of providing value here is going to be 'not accidentally making anything worse' and unlike in the past, she can't rely on other people catching her obvious oversights or reasoning errors or even things like misremembering part of how engineering-models of something like bridge structural integrity and stresses work. (If she has to explain that she will absolutely not get it right on the first try, so it's a real concern.) 

She obviously doesn't want to cleverly and generously explain how to build better bridges and then have one of them collapse, because people would DIE and also it would be embarrassing but

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

 

 

 

 

- wait put that entire line of thought on hold, because HOW did Merrin manage to only think of this NOW especially given what just happened to her it should really have been way more salient and she didn't even think to mention it when she was literally explaining medical technology. 

She writes DEATH on the top of a third clean sheet of paper, and then stops and considers whether actually she should drop what she's doing and go find out RIGHT NOW if their economicmagic has an alternate solution to True Death or if her first priority has to be getting cryonics access set up for the entire planet literally as fast as possible. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah okay it might be worth it to collect her thoughts a bit more than this, except that Merrin is pretty sure that she's going to be incredibly distracted about this until she knows one way or the other. 

She gets up, folds and stuffs her written-on papers plus an extra blank one into a pocket in case she ends up not in this room again for a while, and then marches to the door and sticks her head out into the hall to see if anyone is visible whose attention she can get. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Antonio is there chatting politely in Taldane with a Security (who is still, again, the 7th-circle).  He doesn't look at all like he's bored or wants Merrin to be done any sooner!

(...they do what instead of afterlives.  What.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm sorry to interrupt and this might not take long but I just thought of a question that I should really have asked in the first five seconds," Merrin says, somewhat woodenly, and looking, by the standards of Cheliax, very visibly shaken and possibly even more upset then when she arrived. "Does your economicmagic have a - solution to people's continuous-directed-continuity-of-experience ceasing to exist when their body dies of biological causes? ......Now that I'm saying it out loud, for all I know your people would also mysteriously find themselves in other worlds, but that's still kind of not great from a lot of angles and I sufficiently don't have a handle on the entire phenomenon that I would really not want to bet money on it much less people's continued existence. In my world we have a solution for it that very likely works but it really doesn't look like your tech or resources would be up to it yet."

(Merrin would fix that. If it's necessary to fix then it's now her highest priority, period, and she wouldn't do it for free but she would definitely consider, like, letting their Governance sign a contract to pay back the value of the information she's selling to them afterward, since she's worried it might already strain the planet's material resources to attempt the project at all.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Chelish diplomats, unlike virtually anybody else in Cheliax, have training in how to not lie unless there's an actual reason for it.  Is there a reason for it here?  He needs a snap decision and Antonio's snap decision is that they don't want her obsessing about a problem that doesn't exist at the expense of all the other technology she might helpfully try to teach them.  If they want Merrin altruistically motivated to sign rushed agreements, later, Cheliax can exhibit or produce any number of people in conditions she will find terribly distressing.

"When people die, their 'soul', which - I think contains their directed-continuity-of-experience though I'm not sure I quite understand the word, it maps onto 'soul' if it maps onto anything in my language - goes to one of the nine major places-people-go-when-they-are-dead, possibly to the realm of some particular 'god' if they -"  No word for 'worshipped', no remotely neighboring concept.  "- were associated with that 'god' during their lifetimes."

Permalink Mark Unread

When people die they go WHERE and also WHAT and WHY. Merrin is sagging a bit in sheer relief but she also has so many more questions than she did before! 

"That's...good, probably?" she says uncertainly. Well, it seems like it would be hard for it to be worse than the alternative, even if it's much worse than it sounds on the surface, somehow - she definitely needs to find out what these places-people-go-when-they-are-dead are like and whether people are conscious and experiencing at a normal subjective speed compared to the planet (if that's even a coherent question) - can they communicate with living humans - why are there nine and can they communicate with each other or is it in practice more similar to 'people are thrown at random into other worlds' where they'll never see their family or friends again - 

That's too many questions. She can't express that many questions all at once even in Baseline. 

"- Why are there nine, and do different places have different properties? ....Also it's seeming increasingly important that I get a full or at least a partial explanation of what 'gods' are and how they factor into this system." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Chelish diplomats also have training in keeping their lies simple.  Antonio briefly considers how much else they might need to hide, to hide that alignment is a basic axis of the universe; he discards that option.  He briefly considers trying to persuade Merrin that Evil is really quite nice; discards that option too.

"Gods are ideal-agents... I think that's probably a mistranslation since I have no idea what that is?  Gods have vastly more thinkoomph than mortals, with three or four times the thinkoomph-score of an average mortal...  Merrin, I apologize, but this language simply does not want to translate correctly anything I am trying to say into it."

"The nine realms are separated by alignment; an axis of orderliness versus entropy, and an axis of acting for the good of society rather than acting for the benefit of oneself.  Neutrality is a third position on both of these two axes; thus, nine realms.  Asmodeus is the god that Cheliax aligns itself with, an orderly god who acts for the good of society.  His realm is termed 'Heaven'."

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh wait he didn't say three or four SDs like she'd misheard at first, he said three or four times, one: Merrin has questions about their scale, and two, superheated toilet water that's terrifying. Apparently this world contains...a kind of being that aren't not something it would make sense to describe as ideal-agents, and also are clearly going to be able to out-optimize all the humans, and ALSO probably there's one of them that is acting with the goal of maximizing entropy and acting for one's own benefit at the expense of Civilization???? She should probably....ask...but she's pretty sure that she's going to hate the answer and also why does this world keep springing weird horrifying problems on her with no warning. 

"....I have a lot of questions," Merrin's brain is currently sort of trying to explode into a rapidly growing fractal of additional questions, "but I'm starting to wonder if your economicmagic can do something like the translation effect you're using, but on me and for reading text? Because I suspect it'd be a lot faster if I could just read a book."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm not sure we can.  This translation effect is having difficulties of a kind that suggest - may I try a small experiment?  I'd like to see whether there's something anti-economicmagical about you."

Permalink Mark Unread

"....Sure, although I would appreciate a quick explanation of what the experiment is first, if it's going to involve doing magic to me. Is it a known thing that people can be anti-magical and that causes issues for translation magic, or are you just inferring based on the fact that Baseline doesn't have certain words and doesn't easily let you talk about relevant concepts and thus maybe my world is inherently anti-magical?" 

Either way what does it meaaaaaaaaan if she turns out to have something anti-magical about her??? If it means she can't learn to do their kind of magic then she's surprisingly disappointed about that although she's also not going to just give up on the spot.

It's going to be incredibly inconvenient if she has to learn their entire language the hard way. Merrin has never tried to learn a second language - her cipher doesn't count, it's syntactically identical to Baseline - but she assumes on priors that she's going to be unusually slow at it and it would take so much time

Permalink Mark Unread

Dancing Lights; four medium-bright glowing spheres that form a square, spin.  Antonio touches one of the lights himself, waves his hand through it, to no effect.  "I'd like you to try doing that and see what happens.  Nothing should."

Permalink Mark Unread

Probably it's not secretly Surprise Drugs ....Merrin's brain can quit it about the surprise drugs anxiety, which she's pretty sure is mostly standing in for all the more nebulous stressful uncertainties in her current situation; she's on edge about something, as many as several dozen somethings actually, it's not like her unease is actually mysterious or hard to explain. And she just watched Antonio do it and nothing bad happened. ...It's true that the entire point of the experiment is to see if something about her is different, but it sounds like the possible difference should make her less affected, not more. And she wants to know

Merrin is practiced at taking actions without flinching even if they're stressful. She pokes the glowing sphere. She's curious if it's going to feel like anything. 

Permalink Mark Unread

It feels like nothing at all, but disrupts, twists in on itself, pops, as soon as she touches the outer surface of the glowing sphere.

Permalink Mark Unread

".....I'm guessing that wasn't supposed to happen?" 

Merrin is now more uneasy but mostly it's being pushed aside by sheer desperate curiosity. Why??? Does this have fascinating implications for her theories about whether this world was selected as her destination by some purposeful optimizing force and if so then what are they it's not at all obvious to her yet (though it wouldn't be, she's thought about it for less than five seconds, most people aren't going to finish novel thoughts in five seconds and she takes longer than most people.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

"It wasn't.  This is genuinely puzzling; it is not a statistically-expected thing - not a thing expected at all - I have no explanation for how this could be true and also you were able to be instantly-moved here.  Can you try touching another sphere while willing it not to disrupt, willing the magic to be allowed to enter yourself and pass through yourself?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, there goes her fleeting hope that there would be an explanation obvious to the natives and she could just ask him and then be less confused! 

Sure, Merrin will try that, though she spends ten seconds or so first trying to get her attention and mental attitude lined up right, so she can try to will it very hard. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Poof.  Gone.  Just like the last one.  Everything magical that she touches goes away, vanished as if it had never been.

Permalink Mark Unread

"....I guess that means the translation magic won't work directed at me to allow me to speak your language? Um. What else does that mean. I'm also confused about the instantly-moving having worked! Because it seems like that would imply that I'm only immune to some categories of magic - what are the categories, we could test more of them - although actually it could instead be something even weirder than that."

Merrin is getting kind of tired of having all these gaping holes in her model of local reality and having to leave massive chunks of probability-mass on 'actually it's something else which I cannot possibly infer with the information I have.' It's going to take her so long to understand what's going ON sufficiently to stop feeling stressed and on edge and often unable to tell why! More than half of the other people on the plane are going to be having a way easier time of this and Merrin has never before felt this frustrated about her lower intelligence. She's not actually going to apologize out loud right now for being slow at absorbing new information, they've presumably noticed and decided not to comment on it - 

 

- actually, now that she's properly considering this, she's....confused. She is talking to someone who seems to be a very senior Governance official, with considerable authority, and she hadn't explicitly noticed it until now but she...mostly feels like she's holding her own, at least on a conversational verbal-fluency level. Which is really weird. This isn't what she would anticipate conversations with Very Important Senior Governance Officials feeling like at all! And she does have a base of comparison. It's hard to tell how much of it is an artifact of the translation spell not working well, either because APPARENTLY she is ANTI-MAGICAL or because the languages are just vastly different, which does seem like an expected observation for two different Civilizations evolving in complete isolation from each other... But it's odd and she should have explicitly noticed it sooner. 

Permalink Mark Unread

This particular thought is transmitted to him in a tone of dry amusement by the seventh-circle.  Antonio is native 16!  He's just as smart as Merrin!  ...only with 5 points less Wisdom.

"We're presently inside an anti-instant-movement field, or I'd cast a lesser instant-movement spell to see whether that went through..."

"It's not an urgent matter, I don't think.  Greater wizards than myself will no doubt investigate this matter later."

"Except that - and I apologize for this - it was a matter of greater moment than I realized, to offer you foods not carefully and cautiously tested, if our healing spells would also not have worked on you.  Please try not to have any medical emergencies."

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin feels that she's already been trying pretty hard not to have any medical emergencies! It would be inconvenient and also she doesn't know anything about their healing magic and what it can do and how costly it is. 

She is very slightly disappointed that it might not work on her for...other reasons. Which are less relevant because she doesn't have a boyfriend right now. (Evidence...against...the Romance theory...??) 

"I'll be very careful," she agrees. "Anyway, now that we've clarified that, where was I - oh, right, the part where this world has extremely powerful agents with vastly more thinkoomph than humans and also it sounds like some of them have...goals aligned with increasing disorder and...acting for one's own benefit presumably at the expense of society overall? Because I have some serious concerns about that and also, um, how much of a humanitarian disaster the places-people-go-when-they-are-dead affiliated with them might be."

And whether that means she now needs to immediately pivot toward figuring out how to fix that instead? How? Whatever the fiddly details of the measurement scale, it does not seem like it should be possible to make much headway on a problem if a sort-of-like-an-ideal-agent being with four times your thinkoomph would prefer you didn't. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think we had translation difficulties.  'Chaotic' is a word that this language tried to translate as entropy, but that's only one of several things that it is, it can also mean - strangeness, being different from others?"

"I suspect that there will be a number of aspects of Golarion, this planet, that you would regard as humanitarian disasters; I think that right now, when you are so freshly arrived, may not be the right time to go into them all."  Because he needs to figure out what to even say here.  "People who are too extremely 'Good' - 'Good' is being aligned to the benefit of society, on that axis - are familiar to us, and we know that such people may rush off and harm themselves in their urgency to fix everything.  It would be a humanitarian disaster if that happened to you, here, when healing spells don't work on you and you have knowledge we don't share.  I mark that you were taking a few moments to yourself, to organize your thoughts, which I do think you needed, and then you had a thought about others in trouble and rushed right back out again."

Permalink Mark Unread

.....Merrin is slightly offended? Okay, fine, she's strongly altruistically motivated, it would be at all tempting for her to rush headlong into an emergency where she lacked essential context and wasn't prepared, but she is also very good at her job, and an essential element is not doing that even when it's very tempting. Rushing out in order to ask a question, the answer of which would factor very importantly in the next steps of organizing her thoughts, and where at no point was she in an even slightly dangerous situation or at risk of harming someone else by accident and lack of knowledge, seems like a completely different thing. 

"I maintain it was worth asking the question and I - observe that it took ten seconds to find out that the worst-case-scenario I was worrying about wasn't happening, and I'm still here, but that's because I keep finding out things that are going to completely reprioritize what I want to think about, so I think this conversation was worthwhile." 

(Merrin is notably a lot less...apologetic about the possibility of inconveniencing people or wasting their time, right now? She's focused; there's a bright clarity to her thoughts that wasn't there before, the emergency might not be on the scale of minutes but it's huge and Merrin has always functioned best under those circumstances.) 

...Though she might be focusing too closely on this particular aspect? And actually the next step is to go back to think in privacy and...figure out a list of possible workarounds or mitigating techniques for the translation problem? At which point maybe she can then go have an entire productive conversation without mistranslations that claim that 'increasing disorder' and 'being different from others' are somehow instances of the same underlying concept with no further explanation as to how this makes sense. 

"It does seem to be hitting diminishing returns on the new information now, so maybe I'll go do some further organizing."

She feels slightly reluctant, and...maybe part of it is just that she doesn't want to be alone in a room with no other humans that she can communicate with. Feeling isolated and lonely is really not the biggest problem on her plate, but it is a way she's feeling, and having someone speak to her in Baseline helps with that even if the magic keeps bizarrely mistranslating things, and she's always been better at working through complicated thoughts if she could bounce them off someone else - that's a known thing, it's not just her.

....She should absolutely not take up the very important Governance official's time just because she doesn't want to be alone in a room right now. There are the other students, who came along with the instant-movement magic? Pilar with the pink hair, and...awkwardly her working memory seems to have completely dropped the other two names. She thinks one of them started with an A phoneme? They don't have the translation magic to speak Baseline but they could at least understand her. (And, honestly, be way less intimidating. Merrin isn't worried about that right now because she's kind of still running in emergency mode and that makes 'intimidating' matter way less, but she needs to stop doing that at some point anyway, at which point she will probably again feel stressed about inconveniencing Antonio.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Antonio notes these thoughts, but as Merrin hasn't spoken her desires out loud, he will obviously not try to meet them.

...he's going to spend the next unknown period of time and maybe the rest of his career dealing with this enormous fucking paladin, isn't he.  Well, he's not actually going to complain; there are worse fates in Cheliax.  Quite a lot of them actually.

"I prefer you have much ontologically_basic-tendency_towards-outcomes_ranked_high_in_your_preference_ordering," Antonio says, which is apparently what 'good luck' translates to around these parts.  "That didn't translate, never mind."

It's going to be a long life.

Permalink Mark Unread

Aww, that's an odd thing to say and clearly not what he was going for but it's kind of sweet? 

Merrin returns to the room and settles in to write some more and nibble some more fruit, oblivious to Antonio's frustration with her paladin-ness. (Not that she has the slightest idea what a paladin is, just yet)

She did manage to notice that he seemed to disapprove of the sense of urgency she's currently feeling? As a small child, rather too much of Merrin's attention was aimed at picking up on disapproval from adults. As an adult, she's tried to have it bother her less, both for reasons of general psychological health and because, in fact, in emergency situations now she usually has to be the authority. She hasn't lost her sensitivity to perceiving it at all, though. 

Obviously it bothers her at least a little - she's very out of her depth here and so anything mildly negative is going to get to her more - but she's also noticing some irritation. Even though what he said was clearly intended to look out for her wellbeing and it wasn't wrong advice, just imperfectly targeted. There's just...something implicit in there that rubs her the wrong way, and that's unusual, most of the authority figures Merrin has interacted with her life were very very good at giving advice in a way that didn't give off the impression that she was inconveniencing them by caring as hard as she did. 

Well, cultural differences, right, she should be expecting a much higher frequency of minor social missteps and fumbles. Maybe he's also irritated with her for an impression that she didn't at all intend to convey. 

 

(...Merrin is now flagging-to-herself a mild concern that she's going to be overly hasty to explain things by claiming 'cultural differences' and then moving on, even though at this point 'cultural differences' is more like a label on an opaque box than a concept with parts that she can reason with usefully; it's not really an answer. Not in the way that means she ought to stop trying to ask questions. If she wants to figure this place out enough to feel at ease - which seems pretty important for her work productivity, actually - then she needs an actual detailed model of what all the nebulous cultural differences are.) 

 

...How do they select Governance officials, anyway? This isn't a top-priority question to resolve, necessarily, but she writes it down. And then she returns to her paper that has 'DEATH' written at the top and the rest blank, and fills in all the details she just learned. 

Permalink Mark Unread

And taking a step back again. Can she make any further progress on narrowing down probabilities for the various possible reasons she might have been directed here on purpose? (She is obviously going to put in a placeholder for ACTUALLY IT'S SOMETHING ELSE ENTIRELY and allocate it at least half of her probability mass, but other than that.) 

...Seems a lot less likely she's here to fix medicine; this world has a systematic setup where dead people end up in other worlds, they don't need a fix for True Death, and they have healing magic. Also she keeps finding out about new bizarre complications, at a rate that seems to be increasing rather than decreasing over time, and at this point she should really just update that it's likely to keep happening for a while, and stop trying to make PLANS other than gathering-more-information. 

She is apparently INHERENTLY ANTI-MAGIC which is...informative, right, it's something she would have assigned very low probability before it turned out to be true, and apparently Antonio, who has local context, also would have, and so it's a huge update. Would be great if she had any idea what it was an update toward

- evidence that she's in one of the worlds that was selected for her, maybe? Because it seems purposeful. It seems to Merrin that there's a large difference between she, herself, not having the aptitude to learn economicmagic, because that's something the humans of this world have and dath ilanis don't, and having some kind of immunity field to it that actively disrupts magic that was already cast. 

She is noticing that she's suddenly full of wobbly-uncertainty about whether that's true? Which is the usual point at which she would go check her reasoning with someone, ideally someone with at least some Keeper training, but she can't do that, can she. She can't even really ask Antonio because apparently anything complicated or where there's a large inferential distance between their two worlds' knowledge bases fails to translate. 

(- actually, jumping back, right, she needs to think about the translation problem and how to mitigate it, but she's going to start a new sheet of paper for that and then go back to it later, she feels like she's holding onto a lot of other half-finished thoughts right now and doesn't want to drop them.) 

 

 

Things which are evidence she can maybe use at all for the question of why she's here, if it's for a reason? ...She still needs to find out if it's possible to communicate with the dead people in the dead-people-places - or whether the instant-movement magic works to travel between them, which seems plausible and also that would be so cool you could collect so much fascinating data if you could just go meet and interview everyone who's ever died in the last however many centuries. If the only way of knowing things about them is what's communicated by 'gods', though - assuming 'gods' communicate with humans at all, but Merrin is leaning toward yes, Antonio was talking about it like someone who thought he had reasonably good information on 'Asmodeus' goals - but if that's the only channel of information then Merrin is going to downgrade her confidence in all of that. There's an argument that it would result in better information, right, if gods are something like super-Keepers, but they...sound weirder than that, they might be a lot weirder than that, and so...uncertainty. 

That's at least five questions but Merrin will write it down and then go to a new piece of paper to start writing down a neater list. 

Permalink Mark Unread

That's so many things. It's so many things and they're all confusing and she has to make her own checklists - not just that, she has to figure out the entire framework-of-reasoning to use in order to prioritize what goes on them - which is not, in fact, something Merrin is especially trained to do, because why would you try to make a Merrin do that. She's starting to feel like her brain is going to explode and then there will be little bits of Merrin-brain everywhere and no answers and no plans. 

Permalink Mark Unread

....Okay, but you know what Merrin IS trained to do, and noted to have some actual aptitude for which is why she invested in all that training? Dealing with STRESSFUL THINGS. Including - especially - unexpected stressful things being sprung on her from nowhere, because it's not as though Civilization gets to have much say in scheduling Exceptions happening, they wouldn't be Exceptions if that were the case. 

It's taken her a decade of very focused effort and diligence to get to where she is in her original career, and it might take another decade of completely refocusing all her efforts to handle this - or, let's be honest, it might take a whole lot longer than that - but if Merrin were the sort of person to just GIVE UP because something was going to take decades of intense diligence and stubbornness, she wouldn't be where she is now, would she. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay. Great. Moving on. Possible solutions to the translation issue:

- Merrin just learns their language. This is a bad solution because by itself it'll take months if not years and she doesn't want to spend months to years being this incredibly confused all the time. 

- ....Actually though she should probably request tutoring at all in their language, not so much expecting she can learn to speak it in a day, but at least to get a high-level overview of the differences so she can compensate for them more informedly? Not from Antonio, obviously, his time is high-value and he probably has all sorts of other work to do related to her arrival. (Merrin is suddenly deeply curious what their equivalent of Exception Handling protocols are, because wow she sure is an Exception from their point of view, and learning how another Civilization deals with that sounds incredible. She's in the middle of thinking about something else, though, so she'll put that down on the list of other questions, along with 'how do you select Governance officials.' 

- ...Break things down into smaller parts. Merrin could try explaining things as though she's talking to an injured five-year-old who's going to struggle to process anything complicated or embedded-in-high-levels-of-context. She....would not normally try to have a conversation with an actual injured five-year-old about any of her current questions, that's a hurdle, but it seems worth trying the mental attitude. 

- Use more visual aids? They've got visual aids, here, clearly, and when they showed her the planet, that as a method of communication wasn't prone to language-translation lossiness. ....Actually that's a good point. If she can just go out and see more of their world, herself, then she may not know how to interpret all of it but at least it would help her form more concrete questions? And whatever she could infer might be incorrect because of her own preconceptions, priors which were appropriate in dath ilan but not here, but at least it won't be incorrect because of translation-magic bugginess. 

- They should obviously run a whole lot more experiments to mark out the limits of her anti-magical properties. Maybe, maybe, there's something more like the instant-movement magic - which did work on her - but which would serve a purpose like the translation spell? ....Merrin has no idea if that could be a thing, she should ask about the subcategories of economicmagic here. That goes on the questions list. 

- Do they have anyone who could learn Baseline the normal way but really fast? If they have beings with 4x the thinkoomph of the average human - it's probably not a good use of Asmodeus' time to spend a day learning Baseline properly, presumably if one is a god one has a lot of other priorities, but seems worth asking the general question. 

- ......On a similar line of thought, can they somehow make Merrin smarter, so she can learn their language in less than several months to years? Merrin isn't putting high odds on that being possible, the only indication she has to think it might be is that gods exist, but it's cheap to ask so why not. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin finishes her notes on that sheet of paper and sets it aside. 

(Paper is really not a great user interface, but this is among the least of Merrin's challenges right now.) 

No one has interrupted her yet and she's not done thinking, just - at a good pausing point? 

 

Merrin knows what her mind needs to help her switch gears. She tidies her many cipher-covered papers and then gets up and does some pushups and jumping jacks and some sort of wall-balancing exercise, all the while trying to have as few abstract thoughts as possible. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Antonio Agramunt is currently agonizing - metaphorically, but it's going to end up literal - about whether Merrin is successfully reading through his Bluff or just picking up on the overtones that he'd meant to put there, based on the description of her thoughts.

Asking to be relieved of duties that might be unpleasant, in Cheliax, is something painfully discouraged, so people won't go around asking to be relieved of unpleasant duties just because they're unpleasant; the resulting punishment, from a Chelish perspective, must be severe enough and extended enough to discourage that as a calculation.  Of course failing in those duties is much more severely discouraged, especially in a case like this one, and if you think you might fail and earn that punishment, you'd be wiser to take the lesser one.  Forcing your superiors to relieve you by looking incompetent, but without you having actually failed at that point, is a discouraged intermediate between the two.  Ideally, of course, one can just take on the unpleasant duty and perform it perfectly, and then not be punished at all aside from the duty itself.  The question is whether Antonio Agramunt is sufficiently confident he can do that.

Permalink Mark Unread

Excellent. She has some PLANS to communicate better. 

 

...No one's interrupted her yet, and she doesn't actually feel done with her thinking, since she still needs to figure out what she wants to use that communication to learn more about. 

Right. Skimming through previous notes (wow paper continues to be a terrible user interface, there's no longer enough space on the table for all her notes and Merrin swaps to sitting on the floor surrounded by a semicircle of papers):

 

Topics to ask questions about 

- Gods: she needs to go more concrete on this. What human-visible activities do gods take. How do they communicate. Do they...trade with humans? Do they trade with each other? How do they come into existence? Are they like a species that can reproduce? 

- Dead-people-places: what does each of them look like, visually, assuming this is known? (Seems less fraught to ask for the showing-images magic than do battle with the translation issues.) What do the people there actually do? Can dead people who now 'live' there have children who are born there? If children born here die and go there then do they continue to age or are they children forever? Do they have economies? Do they have magic users there as well and are they the same people who were wizards in life? 

- Magic: what can it do, what can't it do, can be it broken down into categories, how long does it take to learn to a certain skill, how rare is it, how is it used in the day-to-day operation of Cheliax? 

- The non-magical economy and logistics and Governance and legal system of Cheliax: agricultural production, metalwork, transport (how broadly do they use the instant-transport magic versus non-magical methods), how do they select leaders, what are the divisions within their government with different spheres of responsibility, she's probably forgetting twenty other important aspects but hopefully the questions will start occurring to her as she learns more.

- The culture of Cheliax (Merrin isn't expecting this to be easy to explain, she's pretty sure it's a trope in encountering-aliens fiction that 'culture' is hard to perceive directly by the people within it, like fish in water, but she can break it down into a lot of specific questions and compare to dath ilan and maybe noting a lot of specific differences will make this clearer).

- Their education, and not just magical. This is informative both from an understanding-the-culture standpoint, and because she...has a sense that a great deal of dath ilan's progress in pedagogy happened once they had less resource scarcity than this world apparently does? Education, too, is a kind of technology. Merrin is incredibly unqualified to be a teacher unless it's 'teaching six-year-olds basic first aid' but she at least went to school. (Also she has a very vague recollection of reading some encountering-another-civilization serial fiction where the other civilization couldn't afford to educate all of their children, what with all the resource scarcity, and she should...check. If that's the case here.) 

- Their history, if it's not screened off. She...is going to guess it's probably not? She isn't sure why she has that sense, presumably there's some kind of input going into the anticipation but it's not legible even to herself yet. But she thinks history is less invisible-to-the-locals than 'culture' and should still inform it a lot, and inconveniently she won't as easily be able to compare differences with dath ilan, but by getting it from both angles maybe she can come up with an actual model and then she'll...be less confused, and be able to figure out more easily how to work with them and fit herself in.

Permalink Mark Unread

Interrupting this with a thought that Merrin is not going to write down because it's WEIRD and KIND OF TERRIFYING and she needs to think a lot more about whether it's an infohazard: what if the history being screened off is that dath ilan ALSO had magic and GODS and the Keepers didn't want anyone to know this?

 

...Seems weird that they would try to screen off the existence of dead-people-places and - maybe?? - prevent almost everyone from going there by instead cryopreserving them? Oh, right, and also Merrin didn't. (End up in a standard place-where-dead-people-go, that is, she ended up somewhere but if they're being honest with her then it's the place where living people are.) So it doesn't especially fit that dath ilan could ever have been exactly like Golarion, and maybe the entire hypothesis is just overactive pattern-matching on her part. She...is going to put it aside for now until she has more information to assess it, and try not to freak out excessively about it in the meantime. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Now to reassess her priority list–

 

....Actually she should probably think some more about what kinds of things could go wrong if she just starts taking actions toward the obvious-to-her-right-now priorities. Merrin is fairly sure that there are lots of examples of this in fiction. If only she had read more of it

There's the 'unintended consequences of rapid change' side, that's obvious in principle but predicting the actual problems in advance is not. There was some plot she remembers where giving the aliens steelworking technology had...some kind of political consequences? There was clearly a model-of-the-causality there and Merrin did not mostly follow it (she might, possibly, have been skimming a lot of sections that weren't medical-related) but that can go on her list of Things That Might Happen. Which social equilibria are stable is affected by a lot of factors. - oh right that was the same novel where someone taught the aliens how to do reproductive control and that caused some kind of major social shift? She should find out if Cheliax has reliable birth control. 

Merrin is fairly sure those aren't the only concerns or even the only categories of concerns, but trying to predict any others just on general knowledge and, like, five facts about Cheliax is not working at all. She doesn't feel as though she has a generative model of it at all, just - a handful of half-remembered examples that other people who did have models came up with. 

 

It feels like the obvious solution is to sort out the translation issues and come to fully understand Cheliax's culture and then she'll be able to just talk to people like Antonio about her concerns and they can fill in the context she doesn't know and then she won't be trying to juggle all of the considerations ALONE and everything will be FINE.

Merrin...isn't actually sure if 'fully understanding Cheliax's culture' is a solution to as many problems as her emotions think it is, though, or if she just has some motivated reasoning to conclude that because she really really really really hates social awkwardness. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Anyway. Priority list for problems that she should be directly working on, or knowledge from dath ilan that she should be trying to convey: actually still really unclear! 

Also Merrin is already feeling very tired and slightly despairing and sort of wants a nap, less because she's sleepy and more because she desperately wants a break from having thoughts. Ideally a fun break but she can't have everything. 

Permalink Mark Unread

- really, Merrin's brain?

On reflection she should have flagged that sooner. Maybe when Antonio advised her to be careful about rushing headlong into solving problems, except that the way he said it was really nonspecific and also didn't land quite right with her. (She feels a little bad about being irritated with him, now.) 

But: it's not so much a matter of 'why shouldn't she have fun', it's that - she's in a legitimately terrifying situation with a whole lot of potential for things to go wrong that she didn't see coming, and also likely full of things she's going to find upsetting, and she's already having to put significant mental discipline into not freaking out. She can't maintain that indefinitely without having any leisure activities. This is a very predictable basic fact about Merrins.

The thing she needs to stay on an even emotional keel about all this isn't even rest, so much. If she wants to be at her best when she's working then she needs downtime, when she isn't responsible for tracking all the things that could go wrong all the time, and can have fun. 

Normally she would see her friends and play games, or have a girls' night and talk about their romantic lives, or plan a date with one of her boyfriends. She doesn't have those specific options here but...presumably...people in this world take breaks and have social lives and do leisure activities just for fun? She can get to know some people. Maybe some of the wizard students; they're younger than her, but that's fine, it's not like she has colleagues here yet. The language thing is awkward but they can understand her, and probably in a day with heavy use of flash cards she can learn to recognize a few dozen phrases in Taldane. (Merrin is basing this off her previous rate for learning new medical terms; it should if anything be easier if it's not a new concept, but she's never tried to pick up a conlang so she isn't sure how long that would take her.) Probably there are leisure activities in Cheliax that aren't as language-dependent, maybe something more athletics-based? Do people go swimming for fun? 

Permalink Mark Unread

This is a next-couple-days priority, not a literally-top-of-her-list priority, but Merrin writes it down and adds it to her summarized list of topic-handles to bring up with Antonio or whoever talks to her next. (She feels only a very tiny amount of unendorsed self-consciousness about asking senior important Governance officials for help arranging her a social life. It's obviously in their interest to arrange a maximally functional Merrin.) 

 

...In the meantime, she doesn't feel quite ready to dive back into either Priority Reassessment or Anticipating Horrible Unintended consequences, so she will take a break for a few minutes, flop in the chair, nibble some fruit, and enjoy a quite pleasant and detailed fantasy about the date that she should be having right now, if not for an unlikely disaster with a plane. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Antonio Agramunt has by now cast his own Detect Thoughts and seen how Merrin's thoughts on multiple occasions have gone terrifyingly precise and organized and directed by multiple concepts he doesn't understand, which the 7th-circle confirms he doesn't understand either, in order to arrive at systematic lists of questions about Lawful Good Cheliax, whose answers Merrin is clearly planning to relate to other unknown principles.  Which places Cheliax very much in the position of an illiterate village guilty of tax evasion that needs to suddenly make up consistent stories that can fool a literate tax collector.  One with a lot of accounting knowledge and experience in the big city, who doesn't know very much yet about how farms work, who doesn't particularly expect the tax evasion yet, but who is already drawing up organized lists of questions to ask.

Antonio tells the 7th-circle Security to relay upwards that Agramunt doesn't think he's competent to pull this off, Agramunt doesn't think his immediate superiors in the diplomatic corps are competent to pull this off either, Agramunt is not sure who is competent to pull this off but they need crazy stats and serious education, and whoever is taking over this operation might need to take over fast.

It's a slightly better look on his career record than just asking to be relieved himself, if he's right.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin spends somewhat longer than she had intended fantasizing about volcano lair dates, which is...probably actually an indication that she's more mentally tired and overwhelmed than she had realized, and should probably not make any decisions until she's slept, unless they seem really incredibly overdetermined and also genuinely urgent. She should probably have a high bar for considering something 'genuinely urgent' though; even if she finds out about something that would be an immediate-response-with-a-significant-fraction-of-Civilization's-resources scale problem in dath ilan, most problems here will be long-term and would have continued to be if she hadn't arrived and also UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES. 

(Anyone trained in Exception Handling is used to some amount of 'having to make decisions under conditions of uncertainty, including uncertainty about the number and scale and importance of the unknown unknowns'. Anyone trained in Exception Handling also, generally, has quite a lot of reasons to hate doing this. To Merrin, it's always felt a bit like the metaphorical equivalent of balancing on a narrow wobbly bridge of uncertain structural integrity over a very deep pit, and it might be easier and less stressful to do this by avoiding looking down but that's a great way to miss all the warning signs that one is about to do something superficially clever yet really, really stupid in context. Merrin has been in training scenarios where she did things that were really stupid in context. It was embarrassing, which given who she is as a person was possibly more motivating than the actual simulated consequences. Freezing up and refusing to take actions would also be easier. Balancing on a metaphorical tightrope and looking down and trying to juggle a thousand different uncertainties, and deciding which of them she can ignore in order to simplify her reasoning enough to make any decisions at all, is the hardest possible way to do this. It's probably a lot easier if you're smart enough to be a Keeper but Merrin isn't even sure, maybe you just end up tracking ten or a hundred times as many complexities and it feels exactly like this.) 

 

 

She will write down some thing that she might want to decide to do later once she has any idea how to prioritize, and then that's probably all the organizing-her-thoughts she's actually up for in a single session. Merrin isn't sure she's ever spend this long trying this hard just to understand a confusing situation. Generally emergency response medicine does not actually give you time to do that. Which, Merrin is starting to conclude, possibly made her job EASIER because wow this is exhausting. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Things she might want to do, in the medium term: 

- Show Cheliax how to build some specific technology. 

- Attempt to teach some of them whatever concepts are taught in dath ilani schools even to someone a standard deviation below median intelligence, if they don't have those as part of their schooling here. 

- Start a research project with one of their magical healers to see if there's a fruitful way to combine the two areas into super-medicine. (She sort of hopes it's that one. It would be really fun.) 

- Talk...to a god...? (Does NOT sound fun.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

There is no way that's a complete list but she has time to add to it as she thinks of other options. She needs to get answers to a very long list of questions before she's going to feel ready to pick which item to put first, anyway. (Presumably in the end she's going to just ask their top Governance leaders what they think is most valuable, but she needs to be sure she can explain all the considerations first, and then also be tracking whether they're about to fall into one of the unintended consequences pits that she really needs to dig around in her memory to list more of.) 

Merrin takes another ten minutes just to close her eyes and picture relaxing scenes of sunsets and nature, which is the best way she knows to quickly reset her verbal-processing-loop, and then she gets up, sorts her now-rather-thick bundle of notes with the questions to ask and the translation-troubleshooting-ideas on top, and ducks out into the hall to inform Antonio or whoever she happens to see first that she's actually done organizing her thoughts now. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Antonio turns aside from the conversation he's having with -

- a woman who has horns growing out of her skull, curving in to bracket her face; who has yellow eyes with slitted pupils clearly visible below her fancy forehead-wear; who aside from that is pretty enough that no reasonable amount of faceblanding could possibly let her walk around in public without her being a standards-escalating attractiveness infohazard; and who's dressed in a way that doesn't make her even slightly less hazardous -

- to inform Merrin seriously that this is Albe, a much more powerful economicmagic-user than himself, who's going to confirm that instant-movement economicmagic does in fact work on Merrin, and then try a few other things to see if they can figure out what's going on there.  Albe is a trusted highly-paid-Security-cleared-consultant-with-considerable-autonomy-and-authority (three syllables in Baseline) for Governance, and she has hopefully been successfully instructed not to be too sociallyweird at Merrin who just got here from another causal-continuum.

Antonio probably will not end up permanently in charge of Merrin's case.  He was just the person on duty in the negotiating-with-other-factions section of Governance when Merrin showed up, and it's been confirmed that this ought to escalate higher.  Antonio is however for now charged with setting up Merrin's immediate living quarters, and arrangements for anything else Merrin needs or wants tonight or the next morning.  Any requests there?

Permalink Mark Unread

Wow. Okay. Merrin is not even very susceptible to the attractiveness kind of infohazard and is mostly asexual and that's still distracting. The horns do not really detract from the effect. It's so doompunk. 

Merrin introduces herself to Albe as politely and professionally as she can manage, though if Albe needed to be instructed not to be sociallyweird at her then really Merrin wishes Antonio would have taken her aside and warned her and told her how to not be sociallyweird back! 

"I'm not that fussy about living quarters?" she says to Antonio. "I mean, all else equal I sleep best in a cold room with heavy blankets, but it's fine if that isn't readily available here. ...I did have the thought, since we last spoke, that something I usually need in order to function at my best is - some off-work leisure time with friends - and it seems especially important that I'm at my best during my work time, given the high stakes here. I don't actually know what it does to my psychology if I don't have a social life and fun downtime. But obviously I don't actually have friends here yet. I would probably enjoy seeing the wizard students I met again, um, if they...were interested in that." She should not assume they want to befriend her or accidentally pressure anyone that would be rude. "Otherwise, um - what do people in Cheliax of around my age usually do for fun and to meet people?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"If your world is truly as sophisticated and advanced past Golarion as it's been suggested to me," Albe says in Baseline, speaking noticeably faster than Antonio does, not quite at the speed of Merrin's boyfriends talking to their intellectual peers, "I would expect you to find all of Egorian's entertainments to be paltry things.  The poor folk of Cheliax are among the wealthiest in the world, and their wealthy folk among the poorest; you will find no symphonies or plays on offer in this palace, I fear, at least not tonight, and I am probably better in bed myself than any sex-worker who would prowl this place rather than somewhere wealthier.  I suppose they might have a selection of books, two-dimensional-gameboard games, and economicmagic-users discussing finer points of mathematics.  Perhaps if instant-travel magic works on you I could take you to Absalom -"

Permalink Mark Unread

"That sounds like a terrible idea pending a lot of Security review."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- some other evening, I was about to say, Agramunt!"

Permalink Mark Unread

What? Literally what about what she just said made Albe assume she was angling to hire a sex worker– okay fine that would be a halfway reasonable assumption for a lot of people, who are not Merrin, but that's based on information that Merrin hasn't actually given them. 

- it occurs to her belatedly, five seconds later, that that might be flirting in which case ????????!!!!!! how is she even supposed to respond. This is a trusted highly-paid-Security-cleared-consultant-with-considerable-autonomy-and-authority and Merrin was therefore expecting the interaction to go a particular way and this is NOT IT. She will respond by ignoring it. That seems least likely to cause a diplomatic incident or something. 

"...Yeah, I mean, I wasn't really expecting Cheliax to have movies or games nearly as sophisticated as dath ilan, I'm - I can't say I'm zero upset about it but it's not my top worry and probably wouldn't make top ten. I...don't normally think of myself as someone who would desperately miss hanging out with people and talking about the finer points of math but I sort of can't avoid it in dath ilan, maybe I would miss it if it stopped being everywhere all the time. I...think I can actually manage fine without the quality of fiction or games I'm used to as long as I have people to do things with, it just occurred to me that I might need to put some actual thought into meeting people socially." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"We will not lack for people who'd wish to meet a traveler from another world - though it may take some work upon our parts to find those who would not bore you.  Contrary to what Albe seems to think, there are parties from time to time in the palace in Egorian; we could have one of those to welcome you here.  With a professional-musician."

Permalink Mark Unread

Elaborate sigh.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin manages not to say 'but I get along with basically everyone, I'm not worried they'll bore me' because she is, instead, noticing that this is confusing, and then piecing it together with the other confusing part where Antonio doesn't come across as sounding nearly as intelligent as one would expect from a high-level Governance official and...oof she doesn't like that implication at all

Why is Albe sighing?? Was she hoping to be the one to personally make friends with Merrin and introduce Merrin to her friend-group socially? In that case Merrin - is not actually going to feel bad about security considerations. Though she should ask what the considerations are, if 'Absalom' is dangerous or something that seems important to know - it'd be weird for it to be both unusually dangerous and also a default destination for higher-quality entertainment, that implies things that Merrin doesn't love about the overall safety level of this planet. Great. Also some things about how seriously they're taking Merrin's personal safety, but - no, that isn't actually surprising now that she thinks about it, obviously she is going to be very important to the Governance of Cheliax.  

"Sorry," she says to Albe, not wanting to outright reject the possible overture of friendship. "Anyway, I think I've said all I wanted on that, and I'm not actually going to fall apart if I go a couple of days before I start making local friends. Um, another thing I wanted to say is that if it turns out we keep having problems with the translation-magic and Baseline, and also the translation-magic can't be applied to me, I should probably get language tutoring so I can just learn your language the normal way as fast as possible."

She will not apologize for 'as fast as possible' being not that fast, it's not as though they have a lineup of other dath ilanis to compare to, and if her deeply uncomfortable inference is right then she'll actually come out looking pretty good relative to their expectations. 

"- but first it probably makes sense to do more testing on the anti-magical effect, which I think Albe was about to do before I interrupted you with requests about my social life." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Indeed," Albe says, now sounding fully professional about that.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'll note to my managers the part about tutoring.  Meanwhile I expect we can scrape up some items that grant translation-economicmagic, and pass those around at the party from hand to hand so that people can speak to you."

Permalink Mark Unread

Albe is already heading out in the same direction Merrin entered from; she beckons Merrin to follow.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh good. Merrin can gracefully handle 'professional'. Or at least behave in a way that feels smooth and comfortable to her and hopefully doesn't cause terrible offense to the locals. She follows. 

 

(It's not that she would...mind, exactly, if the infohazardously beautiful, possibly nonhuman or partly-nonhuman, highly-paid-Security-cleared-consultant-with-considerable-autonomy-and-authority with incredibly doompunk horns were flirting with her? It's more that Merrin is already wandering around in an entirely different Civilization, missing huge swathes of context, and aware that the translation magic they're using doesn't work perfectly. Flirting is likely to be especially high-context-culturally-dependent, and actually she thinks 'flirting-related misunderstandings with aliens' might be literally a recurring trope in a certain genre of fiction. Which is one thing if you're an author going for entertaining elaborate shenanigans, but Merrin is instead aiming for not causing avoidable problems. Besides, for all she knows that was not flirting at all and might not even have been an attempt at befriending, and was instead a result of whatever instructions Antonio gave Albe to avoid socialweirdness not being sufficient.) 

(Also she does actually want to understand what's going on with her bizarre anti-magical effect, and after that she has several pages of questions to ask. She may have requested help setting up leisure time later but for now this is still work time.) 

She's really curious what the other tests are going to be, after the instant-movement one. 

Permalink Mark Unread

....And now that she's a little less distracted by surprise ambiguous-maybe-flirting, Merrin is replaying the recent conversation a bit and noticing some confusion at "the poor folk of Cheliax are among the wealthiest in the world, and their wealthy folk among the poorest". 

 

Merrin thinks this is a really confusing way to phrase the concept that it seems like Albe was trying to convey? Though Merrin is obviously trying not to be annoyed about it, she's talking to an alien, maybe a literal nonhuman alien not just a human from a causally-separate Civilization. If she's parsing it right - and she thinks it is - then that means that...countries in this world have a significant spread in terms of their shape-of-wealth-distribution? (If she's not and the translation is misleading then maybe Albe meant the literal opposite?) 

....That's weird? It makes sense to Merrin that having economicmagic at all would affect that dynamic - not that she could say how, yet, but once she knows more about both the rarity/cost/difficulty of their magic and also the key roles it plays in their economy, she could at least make some guesses? But that doesn't explain Cheliax being different from everywhere else, so that has to be something else?  

So it's - cultural factors, probably. Or some sort of weird first-mover effect in a world that doesn't have enough global liquidity or efficient global supply chains for that to quickly reach a stable equilibrium (or else she's in a very specific period in history where it will eventually but hasn't yet?)

Or....something to do with gods? That being one of the obvious other major differences, and one that she understands even less than their economicmagic. Maybe it's something that Asmodeus cares about? Or something that 'Lawful Good' in general cares about, or some downstream effect of a different thing they care about.... 

Permalink Mark Unread

Albe, moving as if in a mild hurry, conducts Merrin back to the platform on which she arrived.

"Testing instant-travel economicmagic," she says.  She takes Merrin's hand in her own -

And vanishes.

Merrin is left behind.

Permalink Mark Unread

.......Does that mean it doesn't work?

Merrin is pretty sure it worked the first time???

She is now even more confused now! She starts trying to think of possible explanations but she isn't sure where to start - 

Permalink Mark Unread

Albe is back.

"Now that is unexpected and incredibly interesting.  I'd guess that either you have some subdeliberate control of an innate resistance that you mentally switched on after being instant-moved, and can't yet perceive within yourself to switch off, or, for some reason, an external anti-economicmagical phenomenon around you only appeared or was activated after the first time an economicmagic was cast on you."

"Let's get you to a serious workroom, there's experiments to run and research to be done."

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin's half-finished thoughts grind to a halt. 

"- Yeah, I wasn't expecting it either. I don't– I guess either of those makes sense, if I had subdeliberate control I wouldn't know I did. Um. I agree that doing more research makes sense and I also want to understand what the flaming nuclear shit but - what's a 'workroom' and are there safety precautions you should brief me on before I go in one?" Any kind of actual serious research laboratory in dath ilan would have a set of written safety protocols and generally also a required safety training. 

Permalink Mark Unread

She beckons Merrin to follow her as she again strides off.

"You are looking very immune to economicmagic, and are safe for that reason.  I am not easy to injure, and if I am injured I can be healed.  But we are about to try a number of things with a greater-than-usual possibility of disrupting interestingly, as pieces of their structure get canceled by you in a potentially unbalanced way.  As such we should be in a place that can withstand minor accidents without expensive repairs being required.  That is a 'workroom'."

"I cannot think of any safety-precautions that would be meaningful to you.  Aside from common sense, I suppose; if I seem to be in the middle of building something invisible and complicated, don't start poking at my invisible structure while I'm in the middle of building it."

Permalink Mark Unread

Since Merrin by definition won't be able to see an invisible complicated structure...

"If you look like you're trying to concentrate, I won't be distracting." That much is common sense. Probably there are some elements that aren't common sense to her and that Albe isn't thinking to specify, but - she will just hold very still against a wall or something and probably nothing will explode horribly? Since Albe is clearly experienced at this economicmagic research thing.  

"Let's go do that, then." 

Permalink Mark Unread

They don't seem to bump into many people as Albe hurries them through the hallways, including going up three flights of stairs.  A few men and women in doompunk clothing of various quality levels respectfully move out of Albe's way as she goes past.

Albe carefully knocks at a rather impressive doompunk-looking door, and after a suitable pause, opens the door and pokes her head in.

A few moments later she gestures at Merrin to follow her inside.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is trying to mentally note as much as she can about her environment! Mostly she is noting so much doompunk, which is - wow, this country (or palace, at least) has really gone all-in on a coherent aesthetic? She tries to make eye contact with the people they pass, in hopes of recognizing their faces later, but it's not as though she has much context on who they are even if she manages that. 

- is the serious research laboratory also doompunk on the inside? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Sort of?  It's definitely rather mystical-looking.  The room's apparent walls are murky darkness, except for the wall into which the door was set, and the floor and ceiling stretching between those walls are coated with some yellowish metal, as is the door-wall.  Neatly arranged spots on the ceiling shine with Sun-colored brilliance, a respectable amount of indoor lighting even by Civilization's standards.

"Oh, don't touch the wall-fields, please," Albe says as they enter.  "They're magical dampeners that are themselves magic, and I'd rather you not cancel those."

Permalink Mark Unread

See! This is exactly the kind of safety precaution that Merrin, who does not want to cause any problems, would have liked to have been briefed on in advance before she walked in here! 

She is going to look with great curiosity at everything, not that she really knows how to make sense of it yet. Merrin isn't a small child and can look at things without ending up accidentally touching them, but it still seems - better - to avoid the possibility that she'll shift her weight and accidentally break some sort of critical containment system. 

"....Thank you for telling me. Um, is there a spot where I can just sit down and hold perfectly still and definitely not break anything?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Center of the floor is fine.  Let's start with the obvious, see if I can directly cancel an effect on you.  It won't work, wouldn't even work on a regular anti-economagical field, but let's try anyways."

Albe extends a hand toward the murky walls of darkness, takes the arm-length cylinder of polished metal that smoothly extrudes from it that dark wall, and then gestures at Merrin with her other hand, the one not holding the metal.

"Failure as expected," says Albe.

The metal cylinder floats back into the wall, replaced soon after by a thin cylinder of polished wood.

"All right, let's try the elemental energies in order.  This one is what we'd term Positive Energy.  Try poking it with the tip of your little finger first, it's relatively not dangerous but good practice for when we try the more dangerous energies."

There's a sphere of blazing pure white light within easy finger-poking reach of Merrin.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin looks at it. Somewhat dubiously. 

".....I would maybe feel more comfortable if you defined what you mean by relatively not dangerous. Since, um, healing magic might not work on me, if anything bad happens, and I was firmly instructed to try not to have any medical emergencies." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"This is the raw form of the energy that underlies healing spells.  Unshaped, drawing a small amount of it into yourself would simply invigorate you."

"The effect is not long-lasting; do please proceed."

Permalink Mark Unread

Was she just supposed to know that? It's not like anybody TOLD her - maybe they assumed the translation-magic would cover it but Merrin feels like it has been thoroughly demonstrated that this is a questionable assumption and also, in fact, it didn't. For all she knew 'positive energy' could translate to something like 'antimatter'. 

...Merrin is trying not to judge Albe about this, since it sounds like she was hauled in for an urgent situation and did not have much time to receive a handover, but she is still kind of judging this entire world's safety protocols. 

(There is a brief and mostly invisible-even-to-Merrin emotional tug of war between her deeply-instilled desire to be really actually sure that she has personally read and understood all of the hazards in a research environment, and the even deeper and more instinctive desire to avoid conflict. Merrin is very tired and also Albe is very pretty and 'avoiding conflict' wins.) 

"All right. If you're sure?" And she waits a beat and then pokes the blazing light. 

Permalink Mark Unread

As soon as the tip of Merrin's pinky contacts it, the sphere starts to shrink, to diminish towards its own center, until the sphere is smaller and she isn't touching it anymore.  It doesn't feel like anything.

Permalink Mark Unread

"You annihilated the healing energy, rather than it entering you.  Well, that's a pity, and another method of healing excluded..."

"It's unusual for me to try and see things from the perspective of somebody who cannot be healed, who must needs fear injury so.  It seems like it would exclude a number of fun activities in life.  But let me try..."

"Oh, interesting again.  I cannot touch your hair with my economicmagic hand; economicmagic is annihilated by your hair the same as it is annihilated by any other part of you, even though hair is not a living part of you under some important principles of economicmagic.  May I sever a small lock of your hair, to see if the effect persists when it is apart from you?  Either way, we can use your hair to test and touch the more dangerous energies I would try next, if that sets your mind at ease."

Permalink Mark Unread

Wait is THAT flirting Merrin's brain should shut up. Merrin has things to do. Such as - well, right now her work seems to mainly include studying her mysterious (and equally mysterious to local economicmagic experts, apparently!) anti-magical properties. In a doompunk magic lab. With a distractingly beautiful horned nonhuman. Who keeps looking at her. (Although it's not like Merrin can take that as very much evidence for 'flirting', a fascinated scientist would also be looking at her.) 

...There are conditions under which this would feel appropriate and intriguing for flirting? This is not one of them because this is not downtime. Merrin still has several entire pages of additional questions to ask (at some point, eventually.) 

"Sure. ....Um, just following the principle of caution, I could cut it myself? I know I've cut my own hair and nothing weird happened, but there are still a lot of unknown unknowns in my model of your local reality. It's probably fine but it's cheap for me to do it anyway." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I cannot see what you are cautioning against, quite, but if you wish..."

An unusually dangerous-looking knife extrudes from the wall, with an arm-length double-edged blade and hefty solid hilt set with a red-translucent stone at the bottom.  Merrin may not recognize it as a ruby if she's used to clear unclouded synthetics for corundum.

Albe presents it to her, hilt-first, holding it by the blade herself, without apparent trepidation.

Permalink Mark Unread

That is the most absurdly doompunk piece of...lab equipment?? ...that Merrin has ever seen. In addition, it seems really not ideal for cutting hair, especially when her own hair is short enough that she is not actually going to be able to see what she's doing! Has Cheliax not invented scissors. Even if Cheliax hasn't invented scissors they could give her something reasonably sized? Merrin is suddenly very curious what sorts of magical experiments require an arm-length knife rather than a scalpel-sized one such that this is the equipment easiest at hand. 

She's separately now very curious how the hidden wall-storage-compartment works - it's probably that, and not that the absurdly oversized and pointlessly double-edged-blade knife was spontaneously generated on the spot? Not that she can rule out 'spontaneous generation of unnecessarily doompunk lab equipment' as a thing this world's magic can do! 

Merrin has handled scalpels before, and found this a reasonable amount of stressful the first time and then got used to it, and this isn't different in principle, probably? There's just lot...more...total sharp to be cautious of. Oh, and also it might be magic - which probably doesn't actually matter for Merrin, it seems likely that she would cancel any magical effects it would otherwise have - but it would be pointless incautious not to clarify that.

(....Merrin is slightly starting to feel like maybe this is on purpose and she's being 'trolled'? Maybe Albe wants to see at what point she will actually raise an objection or flag a safety hazard? That...seems like a very fraught thing to try on someone from another world, though, and she has Antonio's assurance that he asked Albe to avoid being socialweird at her which would probably cover that case, and also Merrin herself can't assume any of the usual communication about this would be understood. Maybe Albe would consider it horrifically rude if Merrin falsely accused her of trolling?) 

She doesn't hold out her hand yet. "Um, normally I would ask if there are any safety protocols I should be aware of other than the obvious like 'don't wave it around wildly' but I actually don't want to assume that what's obvious to you will be obvious to me." 

Permalink Mark Unread

“Don’t stab yourself?  You can’t hurt me with it.”

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay then. "I will endeavor not to stab myself." Merrin takes the blade by the hilt and, if nothing weird happens when she does, will spend an entire minute just holding it and moving it around trying to get a sense of the weight and balance and how much force she has to exert to move it, before trying to bring it anywhere at all close to her head. 

(She's still really confused. There must be a reason why it made sense from Albe's perspective to hand Merrin an arm-length knife to trim her hair rather than something more practical. Maybe there's a kind of magical effect that can be placed on a blade but only if it's above a certain size? Maybe Albe is from a species with nonhuman psychology and she doesn't native have an urge to avoid danger and so sees no downside? Maybe Cheliax just has no institutional habits around minimizing risk to researchers because everyone goes to afterlives? ...She's reaching here, and probably it's none of those things and it's instead somewhere in the vast space of hypotheses that Merrin cannot possibly single out with the still rather minimal information she has on Cheliax.) 

(She's also faintly embarrassed that she has apparently let herself be socially-pressured into doing something that would not pass muster in any dath ilani research facility, but it's not actually stressing her out especially; Merrin has never had very strong instincts toward avoiding danger to herself.) 

Does the mega-knife seem to be behaving predictably and as-expected for a piece of metal of that length and weight? Merrin is also trying to gauge Albe's reaction to her caution, in case that adds any clarity on WHY THIS. 

Permalink Mark Unread

“…are you sure you don’t just want me to do this?  I wish I could offer you a scissors, shears, scalpel, razor, or just a smaller blade, but every single one of those here is economagiced.”

Permalink Mark Unread

"- Oh, is that why. I now feel slightly silly about not having just asked." Merrin thinks for a few moments. "Hmm, I think even operating on the principle of 'something completely random and unexpected could happen because I have no idea how anything works, it seems safer for you to do it. Assuming you have practice handling this thing. ...Though if you do have scissors with economagic effects on them, it seems likely given our observations so far that my holding them would cancel the effect anyway? Not sure if you're worried that they would explode instead or something." 

Everything about this interaction is disorienting and Merrin isn't sure how to attribute this to Albe-related socialweirdness, the enormous undifferentiated pile of cultural differences, or just that she's really antsy to get this done and move on to her several pages of questions to ask. In none of those scenarios is in Albe's fault, though, and Merrin reminds herself that Albe is probably having a similarly confusing and frustrating experience from the other side. (And Albe, who does have a clear understanding of local economicmagic, probably finds Merrin's paranoia about this obnoxious.) 

She tries to very carefully wrangle the megaknife so she can offer it hilt-first the way Albe did when handing it to her. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Albe takes it from her much more carefully than she offered it, back when Merrin was in control of the taking-motion.

"It's true that we haven't tested your ability to use magical devices, but I am more concerned with the question of what happens if a magical blade is forced to cut through your hair.  That seems like an issue where what I actually want to do is quickly enchant a small needle with an unnoticeably weak enchantment, and use that to poke your toe, so that, if the result is that the enchantment fails disruptively, it is not then right next to your head."

As soon as Albe is holding the blade, looking very much in control of it, she quite gently and slowly brings it close to Merrin's head, where Merrin can at all times see it, and shaves off a small lock from the end of Merrin's hair.

Moments later that lock floats in front of Merrin.

"No longer magic-nullifying.  A pity.  There would be so many uses for hairs that disrupted magic, though it would still be quite the painful trip to transport them to the many places they would be useful, without instant-travel magic."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Right. That makes sense. Also hearing you explain your reasoning is around risk analysis here is - helpful. It's just -" the analogy she's using is how careful she would want someone to be in a high-containment-level biology research lab in dath ilan if they knew absolutely nothing about biology and also couldn't read the safety handbook, and she's trying to be that level of careful, but she doesn't feel like explaining it all, "- um, I don't know what to be cautious of, and I am used to working in conditions that are hazardous in some way, so I'm - trying to be as careful as though this room contains every hazard I can think of, since annoying you is a less bad outcome than accidentally seriously injuring myself, sorry. If you explain why you're doing something a certain way, that gives me information about what isn't dangerous as well as what is." 

Watching Albe be visibly careful is also pretty reassuring! Merrin now feels slightly bad about having considered that maybe her species was inherently incapable of taking danger seriously. She's glad she didn't say it out loud. 

"That is disappointing. ...And kind of weird? It's - not like the hair is any more not-alive than when it was attached to my head - does hair conduct magic?" Merrin doesn't even know what that would mean and it might be an incredibly stupid question. "Or does the antimagic effect somehow - have a sense of me-as-an-object, that includes my hair if it's attached to me but not otherwise? ...Oh, a test we could do is if my clothes have the effect while they're on me." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I already tested your clothing; it doesn't dispel my magical hand on contact."  A brief light pressure, through Merrin's clothing, on her upper chest.  "Come to think, if you want to avoid all possibility of damaging your clothing, do you possibly want to remove that clothing, or at least the upper portion of it, before we test the interaction of your still-attached hair with other ontologically-simple energies besides Positive?"

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

 

IS THIS FLIRTING??????? 

 

 

 

...Flirting in a high-containment-level biology research lab would be a really bad idea and probably their highly-paid-Security-cleared-consultant is not...actually...doing that...? Lesson, probably: interacting with nonhumans who are also from a different Civilization is really confusing. Which Merrin could probably have predicted going in, so it's not a very contentful lesson, but still. 

You know what's ALSO a bad idea: being topless in a high-containment-level biology research lab. Why would you do that. 

"...Sure, but could I borrow a different outfit I care less about damaging?" See, this is what LAB COATS are for. "In case there's a side effect that's, like, non-magical heat release, I would rather my clothes get damaged than me. ....Um, if I'm being paranoid about things that are totally not actually dangerous, you can also just tell me that." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh, yes, that makes perfect sense," Albe says, not sounding at all disappointed by it.  "There is not nonmagical clothing here, though.  Let me just step outside for a moment and steal somebody else's shirt from them - may I trust that you'll go on staying in the center of the room and not wander off from there, at least not more than a few steps?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I will stay in the center of the room and not wander off." It's probably responsible for Albe to double-check this, even though Merrin does not, in fact, need to be told twice to follow a basic safety precaution. "In dath ilan we would have signage to remind visiting non-specialists of things like that, but I'm not actually at risk of forgetting." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"In Golarion we can recover from mistakes like that and it's not too much of a disaster if somebody forgets.  I hope you're not too offended if I say that it seems you come from a very terrified society, maybe not without reason, but still."

Albe leaves through the only visible door before this can be answered.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, yes, the downside of getting a researcher killed is going to be lower if most individuals are less risk-averse due to dying and ending up in an afterlife being a fine outcome for them. And then their Civilization wouldn't have to pay the really absurd salaries that dath ilan does in order to get anyone willing to take on actually-dangerous jobs, which is what provides a strong incentive to make facilities not just safe but legibly, verifiably safe, with a documented history of very low accident rates. Merrin wonders if Cheliax even keeps statistics on accidents. 

'We can recover from mistakes like that' doesn't sound quite like what someone would say about fatal incidents being less intensely desirable-to-avoid because employees wouldn't be too upset about ending up in the afterlife? It's still inconvenient for the organization, presumably. (Though it's any information toward the afterlives being nice. She should ask at some point if people generally know beforehand which one they'll end up in or if the selection only happens later.)

Non-fatal incidents...would be less costly to an organization if you had instantaneous healing magic, and didn't need to cover expensive medical treatment as well as having the researcher off work for a significant length of time? But that still doesn't quite fit with how confidently Albe said that mistakes - period - were recoverable. 

........can you get people back from afterlives? 

Merrin is going to ask Albe this question as soon as she gets back. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Albe returns, bearing the shirt and pants of, it looks like, some man who worked for Governance.  "He whined a bit but I was able to get his clothes off him in the end," Albe states, and offers the items to Merrin.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin hadn't actually been meaning to deprive some other Governance employee of their clothes that they were wearing for work, she had been assuming there were spares, like at every job she's ever worked! 

If they do actually have magic to get dead people back from afterlives, that...would explain a lot about the general attitude toward safety being very disorienting for Merrin. Even if it was expensive, once they were at the point where the additional safety features required to save one researcher's in expectation would be more expensive than just bringing them back in case of a fatal accident, then the cost-benefit analysis would tilt toward doing that. 

"Um, what was his name? I should apologize to him later. Also, um, before I forget, does your economicmagic let you bring people who die back from their afterlife or am I making a wrong inference somewhere?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I didn't think to get his name, but I paid him.  Yes, we can do that, and I am not sure it would fail for you.  Still, we should not test it."

Albe is still making no visible move to leave the room so Merrin can change.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I would also really rather not test it! It just makes your entire attitude toward risk-assessment make way more sense. Though I assume," hope, but she's being polite and charitable here, "that you're taking into account if it might not work on me, and being more cautious than you would with a random economicmagic researcher." 

 

 

 

 

Obvious corollary, which nonetheless only occurs to Merrin about ten seconds later: if people feel less incentive to avoid careless accidents, then...maybe...it's not against the standard policies and also common sense to flirt in a magic research lab???? 

If Merrin doesn't want to be flirted with then she should probably say something explicitly, because not doing that leads down the path of avoidable ridiculous errors that even fictional characters who are supposed to be making mistakes don't make because it wouldn't be believable. 

...Merrin is not sure that she definitely doesn't want to be flirted with? It's mostly just very hard to assess while she's so confused. Partly because, well, she is just definitely less pretty than Albe, who is an outlier on that dimension in the same sense that a mountain is an outlier among pebbles. Maybe she thinks Merrin is interesting because of the antimagical effect, on top of the whole 'being from another Civilization that she clearly finds impressive' bit? 

This is such a romance trope

Should she be updating toward yes, the specific world she landed in was selected by some process, and it was the romance hypothesis? Because she wasn't even being serious when she came up with that as an example! 

 

 

 

 

...On further thought, having an inherent antimagical field effect is ALSO a VERY RECOGNIZABLE TROPE but has the multiverse failed to notice that Merrin is only very dubiously asexual and does that mean she can stop shutting out all magic by learning to fully unlock her sexuality– ....if that is how the reality she now finds herself in works, then Merrin is going to– she doesn't even know what. Have a lot of processing to do? 

Permalink Mark Unread

They have to do WHAT to shut down the antimagic field.

Permalink Mark Unread

How would dath ilan even know that would happen, if they don't have magic -

What was that concept for the thing that was supposedly doing it -

Permalink Mark Unread

"I am trying to take into account your non-repairable nature.  It is possible that, the concept being such a foreign one, I am not trying hard enough.  I haven't been asking you for instruction on how to try harder, because it is in fact something I'd expect you to plainly not know, given your ignorance of all principles of economicmagic."

"It occurs to me, saying as much, that I should also describe in more detail the implications of the test recently performed: a field with that property is more characteristic of something that might be done to you rather than something you are.  If you cut the hair of an intrinsically magical being, it would retain whatever magical properties it had and be useful perhaps in constructing enchanted items.  If I cast a spell to protect myself against ontologically-simple fire, and visited the continuum of ontologically-simple fire, my hair would not burn there; but upon being cut from my head, the severed hairs would burn."

"Since your language does not have any word for 'god', the obvious sort of being who might be causally-responsible here, could not be a sort of potentially causally-responsible force on the dath ilan side of things.  Do you know of anything other than 'gods' which might, from your side of reality, have a reason to do such a thing to you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"The meta-level principle that doesn't require any domain knowledge to give as advice would be just, if you're about to do something, stop and spend a minute or five minutes assuming it will go disastrously and listing the possible explanations for how that you can think of, and then making sure you've got precautions against all of those," Merrin says, since this is the easiest question to answer. 

 

 

....Yes, in fact, Merrin did just now think of an explanation that would in some sense qualify as being a possibly causally-responsible entity from - she's not sure it would make sense to describe as 'the dath ilan side of things' so much as the, what, broader structure of reality that which both dath ilan and Golarion are embedded within? ...Merrin is not a Keeper and has no idea how to think about that kind of causality, let alone assess whether it's plausible. 

Also, not only does she not know how to explain it in a way that would make sense and not sound utterly ridiculous, it would also be so incredibly awkward

- oh, there might be versions of this which are not the Romance Hypotheses, where it would make sense for her to be selected into a world on the basis of having an antimagical field. It could be Plot Relevant in some other form.  

She's also...not...sure...that it would be a causally-responsible force of the kind that one would describe as 'doing a thing' to her? As opposed to, say, selecting a Merrin out of all the possible worlds because dath ilanis - or dath ilanis who happen to be asexual-ish - are inherently antimagical within the ontology of Golarion's magic. ...Also the fact that she's only asexual-ish in the first place seems like - some reason to think the selection process is not 'romance tropes from a very specific dath ilani subgenre of fiction', even if that were a way that things could work, because she doesn't cleanly fit it. 

Merrin has no idea how to reason about this and really doesn't want to be trying to do it while Albe is looking at her and waiting for her answer. 

"I - might have some guesses but it's very complicated and I don't think I fully understand it myself and, um, I don't know how to explain it without either you thinking I'm insane or you ending up believing a thing that is not actually what I meant. I can try to think through what-all the prerequisites are but I can't do that on the spot. So pending that - could a god here have done it? We did notice a change in the behavior, right, it looked like I wasn't initially immune to instant-movement magic but it only worked once, that could be evidence it happened on the Golarion side. ...is it the sort of thing you can just ask Asmodeus? Sorry if that's a stupid or unworkable suggestion, it was on my question-list to ask if communication with gods is possible but I haven't had a chance to go through my list yet." 

 

After this she should at some point ask about the continuum of ontologically-simple fire because WHAT, but it's rude to overload someone's working memory by asking multiple unrelated questions at once like that.  

Permalink Mark Unread

"Gods intervene directly in Golarion only very rarely.  This, if it's an intervention - just doesn't seem very much like anything I've heard attributed to any god who's immediately coming to mind, not just in terms of goals, but methods.  I've never heard of a god just slapping a persistent antimagical field on somebody, with no obvious purpose to it, and not, sending anyone a vision telling them to do something.  Gods can most easily act in ways that - reflect their natures - and I cannot think offhand of any god whose nature easily matches to throwing shells of antimagic around people.  If they did that anyways, it would be madly, insanely expensive to them, for an effect as powerful as this one."

"For that matter, I wouldn't expect Asmodeus to be especially happy about some other god doing this in Cheliax without his permission; it is something gods would usually negotiate among themselves first."

"That there is no obvious explanation on Golarion's side is why I asked you sooner rather than later about dath ilan's side, even though you apparently had no magic there."

"It is very expensive for Asmodeus or Heaven to send us information or commands, and they will not do so only for our having asked it.  Else we would have done that at once and earlier."

Permalink Mark Unread

Things Merrin has just learned about gods, which will hopefully make sense once she has time to think about them: 

- Gods can do interventions in the world, but with various costs. 

- Interventions cost less if they 'reflect' a god's 'nature' whatever that even means. 

- Albe can't think of an obvious candidate god whose nature tends toward applying antimagical effects. 

- Gods can send people visions to give instructions? 

- Humans (and nonhumans, presumably) can request information or instructions (and presumably interventions) but providing this will be costly for the gods in question. 

 

She should ask Albe for a list of what interventions various gods have been known to do, other than sending 'visions' with instructions, and also she should ask how, exactly, one asks questions of a god. 

(Because she could really use some help over here and if she knows a way to ask for it from beings with 4x as much thinkoomph as her then she might as well try– okay, she should spend somewhat longer considering whether it's a good idea and what unknown horrible downsides it could have, she has to remind herself that even Lawful Good gods are not actually Keepers who she can definitely fully trust. But if it's relatively cheaper for a god to receive a message - which it sounds like it is - then she does want to consider it. Maybe she could ask Asmodeus to warn her off the worst mistakes she could make by trying to act in Golarion uninformed.) 

It's Albe's turn to have her question answered, though. "I can...try to give you the short version of my possible explanation? Um, bearing in mind that it's incredibly weird and I am probably not smart enough or informed enough about the underlying causal structure of reality to fully understand it let alone explain it to someone with none of the background, so I might say something really misleading or it might, in fact, be impossible because things don't work that way. I do notice that I'm feeling really nervous about giving you the short explanation if you intend to take any immediate actions based on it." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'd feel less hesitant about that promise if I could not imagine many, many things you might say that would in fact call for immediate action.  I will at least consult you before rushing off, and be properly hesitant about acting whenever inaction does not lead into imminent emergency and disaster - would that suffice?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Fair enough." Merrin wouldn't like it much if someone asked her to commit to that, either, especially if she had a role with significant responsibility and autonomy in a very large and high stakes project on the scale of 'running a country'. 

 

This seems like a topic that will be especially prone to mistranslation - where Baseline will have words that don't map to existing words in the local language - and also one where there could be particularly undesirable consequences if what Albe hears is different from what Merrin was intending to convey. She feels a lot better about trying this with Albe, actually, rather than Antonio. Albe continues to be impressively quick and careful in her thinking, at least when she's bothering to describe what she's thinking. 

"Okay. So. Reality is - bigger than just Golarion or dath ilan. This is something experts in dath ilan already thought, even when - um, as far as I know - we hadn't actually visited other worlds, it's - something you can infer if you understand math at a deep enough level. Which I don't, I'm - carrying a lot of fragments of things that people smarter than me figured out. Anyway. I was in dath ilan, and now I'm here, and it wasn't as though instant-movement economicmagic moved me between two planets, it was weirder than that, I - died, I'm pretty sure I remember dying insofar as that's even an experience. So - something I know for sure is that somehow, in the whole thing that reality is, it - ended up being the result of some causal process, that I'm here now, because it has to be, math and - reality being made of math - are deeper than what we can directly interact with in Golarion, or what I interacted with in dath ilan. ...That still leaves a lot of variables unspecified, though. It could be random, that I'm here, but it could also be not-random - that there was some kind of - not an intelligent mind in the sense that humans are, but a something, that selected me and selected Golarion and put me here based on the combination meeting certain criteria. ...Does that make sense at all so far?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Dath ilan already knows that the multiverse is much larger than they can see from dath ilan, to the point where they already suspected it might contain something like Golarion.  Something from that greater multiverse moved you from dath ilan to Golarion and you don't know what.  Correct me if required."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- Seems about right. Thank you for confirming." 

Great. Okay. That was the part that sounds reasonable. The next part is... 

 

"So, um, this isn't actually something I know and the evidence I have toward either side is really circumstantial but - let's take just the scenario where I'm here because of a process that had a goal and picked Golarion as a destination because a Merrin, in Golarion, would - do certain things that achieved certain parameters? It could be all sorts of goals, and a lot of the possible goals that optimizing entities in the larger Reality could have aren't...going to be things you or I can understand. But some of them might be. One kind could be - the sort of goal that would make sense for the Governance of a country to have? So I considered whether I could have been sent here so that I could fix medicine - the obvious conclusion given my actual specialty and training, but contradicted by Golarion already having healing magic and also afterlives - and that also doesn't at all explain the antimagical effect." 

Pause. 

"...Next bit is where I start to feel especially uncertain either that my on-the-spot theorizing is actually coherent or possible, or that I can explain it in a way that," won't sound stupid, "...that gets past the translation issues. But it's also working up to the one actual specific hypothesis I have that would, maybe, sort of explain the antimagical effect. So - a kind of goal that hypothetical entities could have is to - direct Reality so it includes certain kinds of - what we from our angle would call stories, I guess? It sounds like Golarion also has fiction so I can assume that translates, I hope. Anyway, fictional stories can have a particular shape of plot element that you see in a lot of different stories? Say, you have investor stories where the brilliant young investor sees some exploitable inefficiency in the economy just before anyone else does and makes huge quantities of money off it and then - I don't know, seduces the girl he has a crush on or builds a personal underground mansion-base on the Moon or something. And, um, hypothetically if you were a character in such a story, sometimes the stories also contain fiction as part of the worldbuilding, so you might recognize a pattern and say 'oh, yes, he's making a fortune, I can predict either seduction or a Moonbase mansion might be in coming in the future'. .....Does that make sense at all?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I believe so.  You are saying that they build something like novels, only with us as our materials for them, rather than words on pages.  But that which they construct, is in some manner known to you, perhaps from it being seen within dath ilan, and so you also recognize it here."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Yes, that's what I was describing. As one possibility - I'm wildly guessing here and I'm really unsure how to assess relative likelihoods. - Note, I don't think the phenomenon would only happen in ways that I could recognize it? I mean, even if it were based on fiction in dath ilan, I haven't read most of the fiction in dath ilan, there's a lot. So there's a range of possibilities where the underlying causality is - story-based - but I can't recognize it and neither can anyone else here and so it's indistinguishable from the 'random' case or - I guess might just merge into a non-story-trope standard causality based goal..." 

Pause. 

"- Anyway. Assuming that it is based on a story-pattern that I know and could recognize from dath ilan - which, again, is a subset-of-a-subset of the options here - there are a number of different story-patterns that I was...considering. And then looking for evidence of." 

Pause. 

This is the part at which she would mention the romance-trope but - actually - Merrin isn't sure she can say anything about that without it inevitably leading into the part which she should NOT talk about??? 

- oh right, she can just - try saying that. Explicit communication is both a generally good principle when interacting with aliens and has also seemed to work out well before with her and Albe? 

"There's a fact about me that could, in a certain story-pattern, explain the antimagic field, but it relates to an infohazard." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm - not quite sure 'infohazard' is translating right?"

Permalink Mark Unread

....Huh. 

"- Can you try to repeat back to me what it's translating as? If that seems really off then I can - do my best to explain it to you as though you were a five-year-old - to be clear I am super not thinking of you like a five-year-old in general but that's one of the mental-attitude workarounds I hoped might help with the translation-magic problem." 

(Except in dath ilan even a five-year-old would know what an 'infohazard' was and Merrin isn't sure how to go simpler than that!) 

Permalink Mark Unread

"It sounds vaguely like economagical writing that explodes in the face of the first person who reads it."

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin spends several seconds attempting to parse that. 

"I - wait - is it a thing in Golarion that you can have - words written on paper - and if it's the right sequence of words then it explodes when someone reads it? Or is it magical paper or magical ink or something?"

Pause. 

"....I guess that's not the worst analogy either way but infohazards are generally - a lot more abstract than that?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes, we have a variety of magics like that."

"'Infohazard' sounds like it explodes in the mind of somebody who - knows it?  Thinks it?  There are powerful entities like that in Golarion, beings where simply knowing about their existence can enable them to touch your dreams and drive you slowly insane and into their employment.  All of the ones known to me are dead, obviously, since otherwise it wouldn't be safe for me to know about them.  I'm not clear on how something like that could exist in a world without magic."

Permalink Mark Unread

"....That's a more central example, I think?"

Also: aaaaaaaaaaaaaah???? 

"- Dath ilan as far as I know does not literally have powerful god-analogous entities where knowing about their existence drives you insane, but - I mean, I wouldn't know. That's - the entire point of having the concept of infohazards, right? And - processes to contain them to various degrees depending on the level of danger - if dath ilan did have entities like that nobody would tell me and that's why I'm not insane."

Pause.

"- The infohazard I was mentioning about me would - probably be less intensely contained than, um, something analogous to a god where knowing about their existence drives people insane. But I - don't have any way of comparing the ranking of infohazards in dath ilan to how thinks work here, so it seems like I'd better be cautious." 

Another pause. 

"....I would feel more comfortable trying to ask a god here about it. If they have four times as much thinkoomph as me then it seems much less likely I could - accidentally break something." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Noted.  Perhaps a sufficiently old and powerful angel would serve the same; I believe Chelish Governance does have one or two on staff."

"I trust you know about this matter and are tracking how it would relate to other matters here, if we are not to know of it?"

Would Merrin please think about why in the Abyss anybody would consider the topic of masochism to be in any way like Things from beyond the Great Beyond?  She's thinking it's dangerous to know about but she's not thinking why.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin's thoughts have - some content - but it is not exactly answering those questions. She is mostly going over fragmentary and not-especially-informative memory-replays of the super awkward conversation she had with that Keeper that one time. And then vaguely mulling on how it still feels weird that in dath ilan she, apparently, had this trait that was rare and resulted in MONEY and COOL BOYFRIENDS and this would feel very fake except for how it just straight-up happened. 

"Yes, I - am tracking the considerations I know. Which includes everything I could tell you about." If she could spend literally five minutes talking to an actual Keeper then she would have so much of a better understanding of how risky this actually was! 

"'Angel' isn't translating clearly to me? By context I'm inferring they are - very very senior Governance officials, who have close working relationships with Asmodeus or other gods? Anyway yes if it's possible to arrange for one of them to talk to me that would be really helpful, I'm sure." 

 

 

- Merrin's verbal-loop processing is operating on a bit of a delay right now due to ALL OF THE EVERYTHING and so this is the point at which she catches up to– 

"- sorry wait gods can die? How does that happen? How many of them have - died - and how - do they have afterlives too -?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Angels are beings of Heaven that enter into Golarion for a time."

"I... don't believe the gods have afterlives, no.  There are not many gods in the first place; I doubt that more than ten or a hundred have ever died."

Would this person STOP BEING SUCH A RIDICULOUS PALADIN, actually no, she takes that back, that's speaking too much ill of paladins, even paladins don't go charging off to save Great Old Ones.

"Shall we possibly continue the testing of your immunity with respect to the other elemental energies, rather than delaying that, while we talk?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay but that wasn't an answer to her question  ...it seems like probably Albe doesn't know to within an entire order of magnitude? Which - says some things, about Golarion's general ability to collect and analyze data on literally anything, since - Merrin would assume - it's especially hard to miss if an entire god dies? 

She is trying really hard not to develop a whole lot of pointless negative affect about the lack of available data - she could survive without prediction markets, she doesn't love it but she can and she even has training in working with the computers being down, but - you don't need computers to keep notes and records, Golarion has paper.... 

Okay so let's assume 100 gods dead over all of Golarion's history is an upper bound (not that Merrin is even slightly taking that for granted if they're this bad at tracking measurable information) - and let's say the median god has 3.5x as much thinkoomph as the median human, she's totally making that up but - 

 

- one of Merrin's boyfriends, who is a remarkably sweet and lovely human being and it's impressive that he can nonetheless manage to hurt her as satisfyingly as he does, would have a model of how to compare the moral tragedy of a god-death to a human death, under those assumptions. Or, no, actually he would have eight different models and several dozen spreadsheets and he would spend multiple hours explaining all the intricacies, and, and– 

 

 

Merrin has no idea what the conclusion would be, except that she misses him and she misses home and she should focus now. 

Blink blink. "Yes, sorry, that's a good plan." What are they testing again. Merrin was distracted having feelings. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Had you, possibly, wished to change your clothing before continuing with those trials, as applied to your hair."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- Yes, right." Some poor Governance official was convinced or perhaps mildly socially pressured to sell his clothes so that Merrin can wear them and not risk her one (1) dath-ilan-manufactured outfit. It's not as though it's a special outfit, or one she was incredibly attached to - her actual date outfit was in her carry-on, due to not being appropriate to wear on a plane - but probably the clothing available here is far lower quality and also literally all of the high-quality clothing she's seen is incredibly doompunk. Which is, like, fine, but not Merrin's preferred all-the-time vibe. 

 

Flirting is the last thing on Merrin's mind; she's too busy processing the fact that DEAD GODS and also being homesick. She strips off her top and puts on the borrowed one without any attempts toward modesty. 

Permalink Mark Unread

This woman might be something of a project.  After some reflection on probable outcomes, Albe mostly acts like nothing interesting is happening at the moment.


Once Merrin finishes changing clothes, Albe summons a sphere of Elemental Fire, and lifts (gently) a lock of Merrin's hair to wave it through, if Merrin doesn't stop her.

Permalink Mark Unread

This isn't completely non-stressful but Merrin is, in fact, a lot less stressed about economicmagic-research-lab safety now that she feels that she and Albe are actually on the same page about this. She watches the sphere of fire with somewhat tired curiosity, and remembers that she meant to ask about the whole 'continuum of ontologically-simple fire' thing but decides against interrupting Albe while she's in the middle of something delicate. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Albe touches the lock of Merrin's hair with her own fingers.  "Warmed, as I expected.  Your hair is immune to the economagical ontologically-simple fire, but is heated as normal by the air that the fire is heating.  You should, if you must cross a room full of magical fire, hold your breath and cross through quickly."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Huh. Neat. Good to know." 

 

Maybe gods in Golarion, since when they die it's actually a True Death sort of thing, also...end up in another world? Merrin can't decide if that's reassuring or not. It's at least a step forward from 'being sad', and feels like a good point at which to put a mental pin in that entire line of thought and set it aside for NOT NOW. 

 

- oh right. Flirting. Was maybe happening. ...Replaying everything that's happened, either flirting was almost certainly happening or Merrin is spectacularly bad at picking up on subtext when interacting with nonhumans from another Civilization. But - probably flirting? Merrin has not actually made a decision on how she feels about that, and also hasn't communicated about it because infohazards. And ALSO she assured Albe that she was tracking all the considerations for the Romance hypothesis. (...Which feels a lot like what she imagines it might feel to be steered into some kind of ridiculous Romance-shenanigans plot, because of course from the inside it would feel like each of her decisions was just following common sense?) 

She - is finding it somewhat thrilling, actually, to imagine flirting back while still in a dangerous magical-research lab, and it being fine because danger, in this world, is so much less real, because all mistakes are recoverable, because you can't break anything permanently that magic can't set right - 

...Except that it's unclear whether it's actually less real, for her, because healing magic doesn't work on her and their bringing-back-dead-people magic might also not work on her and - well, for all she knows the afterlives aren't for her either. And she doesn't want to stop existing, actually, and - she's not especially enthused about randomly ending up in yet another different world, if that's the thing that would happen, she's just started to get to know people here. 

One of those people being Albe, who is infohazardously beautiful and reasonably smart and incredibly doompunk and also seems to like Merrin. She....would actually be pretty sad about missing out on whatever might happen next because she did something careless. Which is just another reason to keep following her common sense and being careful, like she would have been trying to do anyway

She smiles at Albe. "What's the next test?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Would this woman PLEASE think about what bad thing actually HAPPENS if somebody knows that she is a masochist?  Wait, why is Albe infohazardously beautiful, is this -

- is this actually just about fucking heresy, dangerous thoughts that lead to Lawful-Good fucking heresy, is Merrin fucking kidding her.

"We go on to the other ontologically-simple energies.  I'll run through them faster, there's a fair number of those."

Water, Air, Earth.  Water and Air are uninteresting, the Earth sphere does succeed in repelling Merrin's hair although it crumbles at each touch.

A sphere of deadly-looking darkness, which also cannot touch Merrin's hair.

Then comes a sphere of crackling electricity, if Merrin has anything to say about that. 

Permalink Mark Unread

If Merrin were aware her thoughts were being read she would be putting more effort into thinking less sloppy thoughts (and also would be intensely self-conscious, and would have so many additional questions) but she is not aware of this.

Merrin isn't worried? It's not more alarming than the the fire, and most of her concern and alarm had nothing to do with visual-scariness; her background prior that a new previously-unknown kind of magic will do something other than vanish or crumble is dropping with each additional instance. 

She's not bored, exactly, it's hard to be actually-bored when you're watching examples of real actual magic, but she's definitely thinking about her list of unanswered questions and wondering how many more tests Albe wants to try. 

"...At some point I do want to get you to explain what 'ontologically-simple energy' means," Merrin says. "What's this one called? And what was the dark one before this one called?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Lightning.  The dark one before this was Negative."

"There are six major continuums in what's called the Inner Sphere of the Multiverse, surrounding us in the Primary Material, though - this is not really a sphere, we are not really at the center, it is not a matter of things arranged in space.  Space exists within continuums, not between them.  But from here you could, with the right magic, move into the continuum of not-really-thereness, that didn't translate, the 'Ethereal', and then into the six Inner 'Planes' of Positive, Negative, Earth, Water, Air, Fire."

"Lightning is a quasi-continuum of the overlap between Air and Positive.  After this I will try energy from the para-continuum of Magma, from the overlap between Fire and Earth.  Energies from all inner and para and quasi continuua collectively comprise the Primary Material continuum that holds Golarion."

Sphere of blazing lava!

Permalink Mark Unread

Whooooooa that's really cool! Merrin has decided that being, at this point, fairly definitively confirmed to be anti-magical is GREAT because she isn't stressed about the sphere of BLAZING LAVA which is RIGHT THERE and probably no one in dath ilan Civilization has ever gotten to experience this. (And to the extent that someone needs to be worried about safety precautions Just In Case, Merrin is basically just going to leave that to Albe, who of the two of them is the one who actually knows things about economicmagic.) 

"Wow. I have so many questions about - I don't even know where to start - the spatial-mathematical structure of your entire world and what exactly you're doing when you - combine energy from different continuua and how that gets you lava. ...Actually that question might just collapse to 'please tell me everything known in Golarion about your known physical laws and how economicmagic interacts with them' which I realize is an unreasonable ask right this second." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"You may possibly be overestimating how much we know about - 'physicallaws' is not a word that's translating very well for me.  We know much about how the forces of magic interact within themselves, because that is necessary for wizards to learn to cast spells at all.  The more mundane ontologically-simple energies, and how those combine beyond simply paired interactions to form the whole Prime Material - this is less known."

The blazing lava doesn't burn Merrin's hair, but does repel it on contact like Earth, though it is visible to keen-enough senses that the Magma is also being destroyed by the hair's touch.

"I admit, I'm a little curious about what would happen if you poked the Magma with your little finger, or maybe your little toe just in case."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- Do you expect it to be different from the hair test? I am also curious and I don't mind trying but I should confirm explicitly that the worst-case if I am inexplicably immune to all magic up until now but not Magma is that I end up with a burnt toe and have to handle it with normal non-magical first aid."

Which sounds pretty inconvenient but - basically fine? ...Oh wait this world doesn't have antibiotics. Maybe less definitely-fine-for-sure? Still deeply unlikely to be life-threatening if she avoids being stupid about it. Merrin cannot actually manage to feel nervous about poking the Magma with her toe. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Your hair would have to be immune to the Magma but not your toe, and then at the worst you'd end up with a burn, yes."

"It seems this is the sort of case where I should hold your foot and be the one to do the poking, unless you expect to have sufficiently fine motorcontrol there?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Is THIS flirting Y/N  No this is science. There...may or may not be background flirting happening and Merrin may or may not be participating in it, she's kind of genuinely unsure there? Which is a weird thing to be unsure of. This entire last half-hour is really messing with Merrin's sense of what is this interaction even. 

"- I confess I have not tried sticking my toe in magma before and I have no idea if I would have sufficiently fine motor control if, um, it continued to be magma rather than disappearing," which is kind of tugging on Merrin's purely internal sense of competitiveness, but while in a dangerous magical research lab is not the time. "Your proposal sounds reasonable." She tugs off her shoe and then shifts around in order to offer her foot. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Albe will with professional care and gentle firmness guide Merrin's foot over to her little toe poking the Magma, very lightly at first before pulling back.  "Any searing pain?"

Permalink Mark Unread

(It felt briefly hot, not painfully so.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"....No? It was - warm. Briefly." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Albe presses harder on the Magma with Merrin's little toe, dipping it in and then taking it out; the Magma yields when pressed.  "If that didn't hurt, I propose we try waving your whole foot through there, first shallowly and briefly, then deeper, and then, if you like, you can wave your hand through molten lava and watch the lava give way."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- Sure, I can do that." It sounds satisfying, actually even though it would be MORE satisfying if it hurt, like, at least a bit . "....I'm not sure if you're getting useful observational data from this or just - trying to convince me to be less terrified of hazardous things via repeated exposure of it being fine?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I was thinking it would be fun for you; it sounds like you would not have previous experience with being - able to be naughty, in that particular way, of taunting danger and seeing it unable to punish you.  Just to check, are you currently being punished?"

Albe is guiding Merrin's foot through the lava, first rapidly and shallowly, then more slowly and deeply, her hand very firmly in control of Merrin's foot at all times.

(It feels increasingly hot, not quite painful yet.)

Permalink Mark Unread

...where 'punishment' is a six-syllable technical term in Baseline referring to the negative element of a payoff matrix that was added to force a particular behavior out of an agent, that some other agent predicted would modify its behavior usefully in response to a payoff matrix like that, even though obviously the correct thing to do there is to predictably not modify your behavior in any way favorable to the other agent.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well that was definitely on the route of escalating into less plausibly-deniable flirting territory until the last bit. Which is just really baffling. That....has to be a mistranslation? Merrin starts trying to frame the question she should ask to figure out what it's a mistranslation of, and then...stops. 

 

 

Wait. 

OKAY WHAT. 

WAIT. 

REALLY? 

 

...Still doesn't fully clarify the bizarre translation-spell error unless their language is really bad at words for this and the thing she meant was closer to 'actually-serious pain'? 

Merrin is suddenly much much less sure that she can or should just ask to clarify, because flaming-ass infohazard potential that's why. 

 

 

You know in hindsight that probably explains some things about Merrin's level of attraction. It wasn't explicit but there's a...vibe. Though probably all the doompunk is contributing too. 

 

 

 

....Does she know??? 

What exactly are you supposed to do if you find yourself in another world and encounter a sadist who you would maybe be interested in further flirting with but also have no way of knowing whether she knows this about herself. Did the Keeper who spoke to her that one time advise her on this? No. No he did not. 

 

"- Doesn't hurt especially," Merrin manages in a slightly strangled voice while she tries to frantically catch up on several different trains of thought. 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

Albe will gently put Merrin's foot back down, and then gesture invitingly to the sphere of blazing lava, whilst she tries to figure out what in the Abyss Merrin could possibly be thinking and what was going ON back in her home plane of existence.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

 

All right, theory:  Merrin had fancy rich boyfriends, because she lived in an apparently Lawful Good world actually ruled by a secret Lawful Evil elite who were the only ones allowed to be sadists.  The rest of the population was not allowed to know masochists existed, because that would imply the existence of sadists, and so the whole thing was labeled heretical; Merrin's priests (without gods? but that's definitely what Keepers sound like? actually on reflection you maybe don't need gods to have priests?) told her that people would be hurt, somehow, if they knew sadists and masochists existed; unless of course she was talking to those secret Lawful Evil elites, who were allowed to know about sadism and masochism under some unknown excuse.

It's clearly visible from Merrin's thoughts that she had absolutely no clue that any of this was going on, or found it at all suspicious that dath ilan's elites enjoyed hurting her and that nobody else was allowed to know this, which is, in its own way, incredibly impressive as a feat of social engineering...

Wait.  This theory does not make sense.  Why would Lawful Evil sadists require masochists?

Were they just... into masochists?

Actually that does make some sense, some sadists would probably be into that happening occasionally.

Permalink Mark Unread

Sure, sticking her entire hand in the sphere of blazing lava is, one, REALLY COOL, and two, good cover for looking concentrated while she tries to figure out what to DO. 

Is this evidence toward the Romance Tropes hypothesis. It feels like it almost has to be??? Which, you know, does not necessarily drag it all the way to 'actually likely' given how tiny a fraction of total possibilityspace it must have been to start out. Maybe her arrival in Golarion was totally random and she's just all on her own volition flirting with a trusted highly-paid-Security-cleared-consultant-with-considerable-autonomy-and-authority in an intensely doompunk magical research laboratory. For some reason. While trying to figure out why she is personally immune to magic including blazing-spheres-of-lava magic. 

...This is not an answer to the question of whether she should try to explain

 

Can she possibly not know? It seems - hard - to carry out the Albe's side of their interaction for the last several minutes by accident. Maybe Golarion hasn't actually sorted out the concept that Civilization could decide to screen off information that would be harmful for many people's wellbeing if it were broadly known? ...Actually that seems not-unlikely, the word apparently didn't translate well. 

Okay. 

Great. 

So it's...probably safe to say something? 

Merrin would really like to consult someone on that but she can't think of anyone or anything more equivalent to a Keeper than literally Asmodeus and this does not seem like the sort of question where it's actually worth requesting an incredibly costly favor from a god in order to be less confused. 

 

(Merrin is still not saying anything, and still has her entire hand in the ball of lava and is staring intently at it.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

The ball is shrinking and Merrin's hand is starting to feel painfully hot.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Would you like to try putting my own finger in there, to see what happens when somebody who isn't you tries that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

(It's going to take Merrin a while to notice the heat becoming painful, she's busy THINKING.) 

 

Eventually it's a level of hot that is noticeably pain and not just heat but is not, really, especially aversive. She blinks at Albe's question. What? No! She does NOT especially want fun playing with a ball of blazing Magma to suddenly include a bonus medical emergency with someone who is not immune to economicmagic! Why would she want that? It would completely ruin the mood!

(A moment later she remembers that healing magic exists, which does sound pretty interesting to watch, but maybe not right this second.) 

....Which is plausibly not a mood she should be letting herself indulge in before she's even dealt with her sheets of unanswered questions, and also on reflection she should definitely not be making any decisions related to explaining infohazards until she's spent some time on her own and not distracted by Albe's face. Or other traits. 

"Um, not really - if you want to help me calibrate, you can just describe to me?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm hard to hurt, but Magma would do it to me.  I would probably gasp in pain and squeeze my eyes shut and make some sounds and would need to heal my finger after you took it out of the Magma again.  Are you sure you don't want to?  It sounds like you've never had a chance to do something like that before, in your world, and that seems a little sad."

Permalink Mark Unread

??????????????????????????????????????

Permalink Mark Unread

"....I was an emergency medical responder," Merrin says after several blank seconds of internal ???????????. "I've had to do lots of painful things to people," who did not have anywhere near Merrin's own pain tolerance, "and I'm pretty confident that I do not actually enjoy the experience. If I didn't have that personal experience already I guess I'd be less sure of that?" 

Albe seems to be under the assumption that this is a completely universal experience which - what. Probably that is evidence of something. Merrin isn't sure of what - it must say something about the broader culture, Albe is too clever and experienced to just fail to model other people

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"Just to check for safety, are you sure your hand should still be inside that Magma?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Is it like sunburn and causes more delayed damage that I'll notice at the time? I should check." 

It still doesn't hurt an intolerable amount but now that Merrin stops to think about it, she is...maybe being stubborn and competitive about this, and she should not do that with her hand which she's going to need later. She takes it out of the Magma ball and looks at it, checking for redness or blisters and gauging whether it stops hurting immediately or lingers. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Her hand looks a bit red.  No visible blisters.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin opens her mouth, stops, closes it, and waits to see what Albe is going to say first. She's really tempted to just straight-up ask 'so were you intending to seduce me in the doompunk laboratory from the moment you met me' but she's not sure if that is a "good" "idea". 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Albe is currently looking visibly sad.

"I admit, I am having some trouble imagining exactly what your world must be like, to produce your attitudes.  I wonder if it is - so far into -"

"This language does not, I think, do a good job of translating the axes of the Outer Sphere, it wants to translate 'Lawful' as ordered and 'Chaotic' as entropy, or 'Good' as working selflessly for society's benefit and 'Evil' as self-desire, and that strikes me as unhelpful to the point where you might want to erase it from your mind and start over.  If you are going to learn 'Taldane', the language of Cheliax, you might as well start with those four words, 'Lawful', 'Chaotic', 'Good', 'Evil', and begin by knowing that Cheliax is Lawful Good."

"I have ancestry on my mother's side derived from beings of the Chaotic Evil continuum, and am myself Lawful Evil with much more pronounced Chaotic tendencies than some of my coworkers would like."

"I wonder if dath ilan is so far towards Lawful Good that it would consider Cheliax Chaotic Evil by comparison.  I am wondering this because you don't seem to have ever heard of some concepts from the Evil side of existence, like pleasure in pain, pleasure in receiving pain, pleasure in inflicting pain, traits which are certainly more common in beings with a directly Evil heritage like mine, but are not unknown in even Neutral humans.  Does your world - have nothing at all, except for Good and Lawful people, within it anywhere?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Wait the beings from afterlives can bear children with living humans– sorry, that fills in some gaps I had and is also a digression from what you said, I'll...come back to it. Um. I - I'm now even more confused about the axes here and I think I could use a lot more concrete examples of actions people take and how they would end up categorized. I...wouldn't be shocked if everyone in dath ilan would technically be considered 'Good' and I am more inclined to think everyone would be chunked as Lawful, according to my understanding of the way you mean it I'm probably unusually non-Lawful for dath ilan. I think it makes sense that we're - different, in a systematic way, and that means dath ilan is - going to be really far off in some direction, according to any metrics that are normed for Golarion. Maybe it's that one. If you re-normed it based on the dath ilan median and categorized people using the same axes I think you'd still get significant variance?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

"I suppose, in a world without healing, everyone who enjoyed receiving pain, would have died, and then - those who enjoyed dealing pain, probably followed.  And maybe Good is all that's left, after that."

Albe seems quite visibly sad about this thought!

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Huh. That's - a possible explanation for why there aren't very many - people like me, I guess. There are more people who enjoy causing pain, and - probably a lot more who...would, if they ever had reason to think about it, and then they would be unsatisfied, and some would be very deeply unhappy. So Civilization tries to make sure that those people at least aren't actively prompted to consider it. ...And the Keepers do at least somewhat actively look for people like me, because I would not have guessed it was a thing - in relationships with other people, I mean. Someone had to sit me down and tell me. And then I - guess I got to make some people really happy, which is neat, especially for a thing I didn't have to spend ten years training at, I - wasn't expecting there would ever be anything like that." 

It feels like CHEATING but not in the sort of way that bothers Merrin or that she would think to consider bad. It's just - sometimes there are things that work out well. 

She's still not sure what this has to do with 'Good' and 'Evil' and is going to have to push for those concrete examples she requested. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh, so you are Evil, then.  I did think I was getting that vibe from you."

"But - not at all the type to want to see what happened when you guided my own finger into the Magma?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...No, not really. I doubt I have much intrinsic draw to it, and then after spending my entire career in medical work, it's just - hard to associate other people in pain with anything other than that, you know? I...can enjoy fiction or roleplay where people get hurt in, like, a natural disaster or an alien invasion, and then I'm there when they're getting rescued and treated and comforted, which I guess is sort of adjacent to the thing? Though I'm not sure it would be nearly as nice enacting that real life with actual injuries, it - would probably get really tangled up with all my mental habits around actual work and be emotionally confusing and weird." 

Shrug. 

"...I think I'm not quite following how much it's pain that's Evil - in which case, is being a medical provider and, like, placing an IV to save someone's life and causing them some pain also Evil - or is it the...wanting it because it's nice and good and makes you happy? In which case I - don't actually think dath ilan has any shortage of that. If enjoying winning games against other people and winning money off them in bets counts then I can hardly imagine dath ilan having more of it." 

She frowns, watching Albe's expression. "I don't know, I guess my sense is that most people have both? I enjoy people hurting me, especially people I feel close to, but I'm not...living in that part of myself most of the time? It would just be really distracting at work and I don't have the leftover mental bandwidth for it anyway. And even if I didn't have a career that I really love, I - don't think I'd want to be doing that all the time, I'd get bored. ...Incidentally if you want to seduce me, it's going to be way less frustrating once I'm not still considering myself to be 'at work'. I guess the exact balance varies, dath ilanis are less binary about work and downtime than I am, some people spend a lot more total time on leisure - I'm kind of notorious with my friends for working a stupid number of hours - some people are even more like that and as far as I can tell their leisure is just reading other people's math work to take a break from their own. I have one boyfriend who, as far as I can tell, doesn't do anything that is only for fun and not also productive work except for when I see him, like, once a month, and his work is pretty for-the-benefit-of-society-oriented, it's not something he does for the money - a lot of dath ilanis do, and I don't know how your system would categorize that either." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Albe is having trouble tracking all this even with her rather high (for Golarion) Intelligence; it doesn’t help that she is trying to figure out both how dath ilan appears to Merrin and how it must actually be.

“I think it would feel very different to me to - cut off someone’s poisoned finger before the poison spread, say, and to cut off their finger because I wanted to see how their face changed when they were in pain.  That these two things are at all the same is - something I wouldn’t have expected to hear from someone Evil enough to enjoy pain at all.”

”Compared to most people of Cheliax, I am relatively much more likely to flirt on my job, and also I have a lot more fun on my job and with my life in general than most people in Cheliax.  I’d consider the position that you should carefully separate all the fun out of your terribly important job to be Good generally and dangerously-Lawful Good particularly.  It is again not something I’d expect to hear from a girl naughty enough to enjoy waving her hand around in Magma, and I wonder if I am looking at an Evil woman immersed in Lawful Good to the point of that damaging what she is, what she should be, what she could have been in Golarion.  If I were writing a novel and sending the character of Merrin to Golarion after her death to learn something, it would be that.”

Permalink Mark Unread

Wait has she TRIED cutting off someone's finger is that just a THING here– ...it would be, wouldn't it. Healing magic. That would be so convenient. Merrin...is not actually sure if she personally would enjoy having her finger cut off - actually she's almost certain she wouldn't "enjoy" it in the moment it was happening, any more than she enjoys, in the moment, having to do actual triage in an actual in-real-life multi-casualty incident. (She's dealt with, like, two of those that really counted. Dath ilan is really good at not having accidents if they can be avoided at any reasonable cost, and 'reasonable' is...a lot, when Civilization has vast resources and people really really don't want to die the True Death.)  

Merrin loves her job. Not in the same way, and obviously there are about thirty different aspects she likes about her job, but it's - not a completely different thing either? There's a glorious simplicity in emergencies, there's that moment where the world is sharp and bright and so real and immediate, and she's not in exactly in control but she's entirely there, and it's a little like falling, like the moment after jumping off a ten-meter diving board, and it's very simple because you can't, actually, un-fall once you've jumped.

A few of her colleagues seemed to recognize that, when she described it. The Keeper she spoke to recognized it. Most people don't; most people, relatedly, are confused and impressed by her career path - and, Merrin suspects, attribute a lot more of it to Good motivations than is actually the case. It's not that she's indifferent to the value she's contributing to Civilization, but she's pretty sure most people, herself included, can't run their entire motivation system on that and end up working as hard for as long as someone of -1SD intelligence to succeed at becoming an endurance paramedic and go on to maintain certifications in, like, half of Exception Handling.

She did it because Merrin at fourteen saw a future and wanted it, was hungry for it, and - she's luckier in a way than almost anyone in dath ilan, right, that there wasn't a tradeoff there, that the thing she wanted most in the world from the moment she knew it was out there to reach for is also something that results in people thinking she's some sort of hero.

It's true that she had to put a huge amount of effort - not always fun effort - and struggle and shaping-herself into - being able to exist and fit in as a member of Civilization, and - maybe it's true that this involves hemming in parts of herself, other ways that she could have been, other people she could have been who would have been happy. But unless Merrin is still completely misunderstanding the axes, that feels like it's far more about Law

 

 

"Thank you for the advice, it's noted," she says dryly. "I - still think I could assess what you're even saying much better if you give me ten examples each of things that are Good or Evil or Lawful or Chaotic?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Corrupting this woman would be trivial if she had Wisdom 10.  At Wisdom 20 it becomes a far more serious problem that you can't reliably solve just by reading somebody's mind, figuring out what parts of themselves didn't fit into their old place in the world, packing up those parts with everything else you want her to be, and telling her that the complete package is what she is and that a person like that gets to have everything she knows she wants.  Reading Merrin's mind gives the further impression that this is not just a woman with WIS 20, this is a woman with WIS 20 who was trained and conditioned by experts with far higher Wisdom than that, and that those trainers might have immunized this Merrin against such simple tactics for breaking her out of her Lawful Good conditioning.  They did an unfortunately good job of keeping her happy.

But she has enough basic information about possible vulnerabilities to work with now, and if at all possible should gain more time to think and plan before taking next steps.


Albe floats another wand through the illusion of dark walls screening off the rest of the workshop from Merrin's sight, and summons Quasi-Elemental Void like a distortion hanging in the air.  She waves Merrin's hair through it, to verify that Void is not the particular elemental vulnerability that so many screens and fields turn out to possess.  "I would expect that if you poked a finger into this, it would feel like somebody sucking very powerfully on your finger, possibly enough to damage it - this is Void, the combination of Air and Negative, which should have already removed all the air inside the sphere of energy, on some theories of Void.  I'd be curious to test it, but I think that we should not."

"With respect to the other topic of conversation, I'm starting to feel the same sense of trepidation about trying to explain the nine alignments to you, that you seemed to feel about explaining to me what forces might have produced the antimagic around you."

Permalink Mark Unread

Whoooooooa they can just make magical vacuum that's neat. Merrin runs a brief mental search for technologies that she knows become feasible once you can reliably evacuate the air from a container and get a sufficiently hard vacuum. Nothing that seems fast or easy to explain, so she'll note that for later. 

Just sticking her finger through a magical boundary into vacuum wouldn't seriously damage her, Merrin thinks; humans can survive thirty seconds or a minute entirely in vacuum without permanent damage. She would be more worried about breaking the magical boundary and causing the surrounding air to rush in suddenly. Or about unknown weird effects. If Albe thinks they shouldn't test it then Merrin's going to listen to her. 

"You're worried that it's - something where explaining it imperfectly will mean I end up believing something dangerously false?" Merrin is certainly not inclined to ignore or push past that kind of concern! "I think it's not that urgent that I fully understand it? I do feel like I'm going to keep being confused about gods - and the afterlife thing - until I understand the categorization system, and I'm sort of holding off on making any plans for what to do here until I'm less confused about gods - but it clearly would be worse if I thought I understood it and was on the wrong track. Are there experts in studying it who would have a better chance of conveying it right?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"The problem that concerns me is more the amount of missing background information that we have about you and that you have about us.  You have really said very little about what dath ilan really is, or so I'm told, except that it lacks gods and alignments and afterlives, and knows more than we do of medicine, and has some means for preserving people against death that we do not need as urgently as you suspected.  And there are more people who enjoy causing pain than those who enjoy receiving it, so only a few of those who enjoy causing pain are ever allowed to learn what they are... I admit, I'm a little curious as to how it is said that they are selected for the privilege.  This is Radiance, Fire with Positive."

It's brilliant and multicolored and beautiful.

Permalink Mark Unread

Since the quantity of missing background information on both sides is - Merrin is pretty sure - a lot of what has been making her feel deeply uneasy this entire time, she can't object to Albe worrying about it too. It should be a relief, really. 

...It's mostly a relief? It would be more purely relieving if it felt less - 'unbalanced' isn't quite the word - if it felt less like Albe was an alien with a psychological architecture incredibly far removed from any that ever existed in dath ilan, who is now looking at Merrin and, presumably, finding her just as strange from her own point of view, and - seeing Merrin as damaged, seeing something wrong with dath ilan, and maybe she's got a point but there's still going to be a direction to all her advice, right - 

- and Merrin wants to make her happy, wants to earn her pride and approval, wants to get it right and prove herself -

 

....But also, on some very deep fundamental level, Merrin dislikes it when people cleverer and more knowledgeable than her have agendas for her and want to steer her toward the right answers. She did even when it was 'all of Civilization' that felt like it had an agenda for her, that knew what was correct better than she could ever find on her own. And of course that's always been actively in conflict with her other drives - to fit in, to be part of a whole and contribute to it, to belong, to be the shape that other people approve of, to make people around her happy... And neither of those is in itself a truth-seeking motive, but - there's a balance, there, for Merrin. The not-wanting-to-be-steered is protective of something, and - in her hazy and probably-wrong conception of the categories here, it feels like in dath ilan it was protective against following 'Lawful Good' off a cliff - against the thing that Albe seems to be worried is what happened? Because it would be tempting, for a Merrin to try over and over to shape herself into exactly what Civilization wanted her to be, except that Civilization also tried to teach her how to notice when she's being nudged around by implicit social pressure - which, Merrin is pretty sure, is a vulnerability she has VASTLY MORE than most dath ilanis - and when she notices it she gets kind of prickly about it. 

It's not the case that she's never experienced implicit-social-pressure to prioritize leisure activities more, but this is a new direction for it to come from and it's WEIRD and makes her feel OFF BALANCE. 

Well, that's a her problem, isn't it. She's going to have to understand Golarion and figure out how to exist here, and inevitably she's going to be learning about it from locals who are coming from a massively different culture and perspective and have opinions – about dath ilan, about her, about what they're hoping she will accomplish here. Which Merrin is going to notice even if they're not trying to give advice pointed all in one direction - even if they're actively trying hard not to do that - because that's what her brain does, it tries very hard to figure out what everyone around her wants and make sure there are never any conflicts and no one is disappointed.

It makes sense for that to be uncomfortable for her; it doesn't make sense to be annoyed at them about it. It seems really unlikely Albe is doing this on purpose. Probably she just...doesn't have the social-pressure-vulnerability that Merrin has. It's hard to imagine her having it. 

 

 

"I agree, that's a major concern for me too. I - was kind of prioritizing coming up with an itemized list of questions to ask about Golarion, but plausibly after this I should sit down and work out a prioritized list of things to explain about dath ilan. Though I was sort of hoping someone with Governance is already doing that, you're going to know better than I do what questions you want answered." 

The Radiance is so pretty

"- Um, people aren't selected to find out about it - ever, as far as I know? Sometimes people just guess, or find out by accident. And then it's the standard problem where you have a scarce good and more demand than supply, so the obvious allocation method is money. I - guess it's pretty miserable to be one of the people who guesses by accident and isn't rich, which is a big reason why this is not widely advertised, it'd be an even worse problem then." 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Could that ACTUALLY be true.  No, that doesn't square with the rest of how dath ilan presents itself - what does Merrin mean, the obvious allocation method is money, that's not any form of Lawful Good that she's ever heard of, that's not Lastwall, that's how Osirion would solve the problem.  There's got to be some level on which, if you were raised Evil and not in dath ilan, you know better to forego skepticism about the final conclusion that in an Extremely Pure Lawful Good Society the rich elites get all the masochists and nobody else is allowed to know sadism exists.  There'd obviously be an excuse, it could even be a very plausible one, you have to look at where the result ended up.

Separately, she notes that Merrin thinks herself exceptionally vulnerable to social pressure for an inhabitant of dath ilan, and that it is best to avoid applying that pressure in a way that looks like people cleverer or more knowledgeable than Merrin herself.  Well, they've got three convenient Ostenso students for that.  Or their impersonators, if their Bluff doesn't look good enough.

Albe, speaking to Merrin, is curious about masochists being allocated to those with the most money; most Lawful Good societies that she knows would try to allocate masochists to those most in need of them.  She's also curious generally about how dath ilan was governed.

A dangerous-looking spherical cloud:  Quasi-Elemental Steam, Water plus Positive.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin blinks at this for a few moments because - money just is the unit by which to measure how strongly you want or care about something? She feels slightly confused about how to parse 'need' separately from that - like, obviously in life-or-cryopreservation circumstances, dath ilan has triage systems to save the most people, but that's - not the category of thing that 'wanting to hurt people in a cuddleroom' is - most things aren't that? It feels a little like saying 'but we should allocate the largest apartments to the people who most need big living spaces' which is just - no, that isn't how that works? 

"...I think it's still hard for me to figure out how to answer that because I don't actually understand what you mean by 'Lawful' 'Good' - I understand why you don't want to explain further right now - but also I think it was Antonio who decided to label dath ilan as that? Not me since I don't know what it even means. If Lawful Good societies allocate scarce goods in general using - something that isn't money or an equivalent, um, universal-currency-of-account - did that translate? - then I'm confused again and probably dath ilan isn't that." 

Permalink Mark Unread

She's disoriented, in a way that she should've maybe expected to be disoriented, by the suddenly dawning possibility of people and societies that are maybe just not on the alignment axes at all.  This is the talk of Osirion, clear and plain; Merrin is Lawful Good, likewise clear and plain; her boyfriends and these Keepers are very likely Lawful Evil.  Maybe that's simply a natural way to organize your society if there is no Pharasma and alignment axes do not there really exist?


"I'm feeling rather disoriented right now.  I should probably not try to explain why, and should instead go on listening, I think.  In particular about your - 'Governance'?"

An even-more-dangerous-looking spherical white crystal:  Water + Negative, Quasi-Elemental Salt.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Answering that is actually kind of stressful in itself, and Merrin is inclined not to add any more bonus stress by poking the dangerous-looking magical not-salt while she's in the middle of thinking through and then giving her explanation. 

(Why do "water" and "negative" combined make "quasi-elemental" salt???? Unlike the other combinations of Magma and Void, this one is not even slightly intuitively clear to Merrin.) 

It's stressful to explain because - assuming that Governance in Cheliax works very very differently, which given all of the other upstream differences seems like almost a foregone conclusion - then Albe is inevitably going to ask for explanations of why things are different. And Merrin isn't sure she can answer them. Especially without, herself, having full context on Cheliax's Governance structures, but - it's deeper than that. She knows some facts, but not the...underlying generators that resulted in those facts being the case, in dath ilan. Because one thing she can be very sure of is that the system was set up by people far more intelligent than her. Who, at the time, did know whatever lies behind the wall that hides dath ilan's history. And Merrin is only in her mid-twenties, and hasn't invested any deliberate effort in learning more about dath ilan's Governance structures than the pieces she unavoidably noticed just by living there.

And to the extent that dath ilan is run the way it is for reasons deeper than historical accident, to the extent that there are truths about how things work and what works best that will hold across all the worlds, Merrin herself understands and contains only a few fragments of the underlying Law. And an embarrassing amount of what she does know on some level is going to be difficult and frustrating and maybe impossible to put into words, especially across a translation-magic barrier. 

- okay, so she's going to give an incomplete explanation. Not ideal but it seems unavoidable, and - almost certainly still better than not saying anything. People in Cheliax who are not her will be able to make some sense of the random sprinkling of surface facts and justifications that she knows. She will just have to do her best to only say things that she is very confident are true. 

 

"Right. So, um, high level view is - there are the nine Legislators, who are elected by several hundred Representatives, who are elected by around forty thousand Electors -" high level summary, Merrin reminds herself, "- anyway it bottoms out with the entire voting population of dath ilan voting for Delegates to represent their interests to the higher levels. The Legislators are the body within Governance that can - make changes to the decision-processes by which everything else is run. ...Well, for a really big change to the, um, meta level processes-used-to-generate-processes - did that translate? - you'd need to get a direct vote by the entire population - and usually the Keepers would be involved along with a whole lot of other departments within Governance but that's not written-into-the-law as a requirement." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Pause to think. 

"Right, so that's the legislative side. The nine Legislators are responsible-accountable for hiring - and firing, if it comes up - the Chief Executive, who's responsible for the bureaucracy that contains a whole lot of departments that actually - carry out all the day to day work that needs doing to keep Civilization running. On that level, a lot of policy decisions - local ones, I mean, to distinguish from the sort of thing where you would want to alter the entire process - are made by prediction markets."

Oh wait is this the kind of thing that might fall into the Translation Gap. She....hasn't actually heard anyone mention what the markets are saying as the obvious input to their decisions, and - right they don't have computers - it's not like you need computing technology in theory to run prediction markets, but it sure increases the overhead, and if there were magic for it then someone would plausibly have mentioned it before...

"- Sorry, that might not translate. There are....information-aggregating betting systems, so anyone with expertise who thinks they know better than the market's consensus can add a bet and expect to make money if they're right? There's a lot of math involved in scoring for the payouts, the result is that you get an - aggregated summary of what the experts of dath ilan think will have the preferred result? Obviously this gives much more likely-to-work-in-expectation proposals - within any given department, for any given decision, there's a specific person who's accountable for making the judgement call, but in practice I think most of those judgement calls are consulting heavily with what the prediction markets say." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Is that making sense. How badly is she mangling this. Merrin can't tell because she is insufficiently experienced in reading nonhumans' facial expressions. It seems like Albe is still following? 

"...The policy-prediction-markets are administrated by an arm of the bureaucracy, but - obviously there'd be an opening for bad incentives, if the Chief Executive could pass down orders to directly interfere with the markets? So there's a Keeper there in a meta-manager role," this is clearly a single word in Baseline and does not translate with perfect clarity to a Taldane word, "as a cutout between the Chief Executive's level and the department. Same holds for all the departments where you want to add some barriers against adversarial action or perverse incentives, so - Exception Handling, which is what I work for a lot of the time - the military, the police, the entire court system, the cryonics system, and the department that actually administrates the elections for the Legislators and the levels below them in the hierarchy." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Albe will be more expressive about nodding along and indicating that she's still here and listening.

(She's mostly trying to track who has the actual power here and it's sounding like it's possibly the Keepers but the whole thing sounds so complicated she is not remotely sure which may of course be part of the point from the Keepers' perspectives.)

(Also Merrin just casually ran past 'who has control of the military' like that was 0.1% of her attention, worth literally just two words, which is... it sure is something.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"- I guess I should explain Keepers more. The Keepers are....not really a part of Governance, and - in some sense they're apart from the rest of Civilization, they're - not accountable to anyone or anything except when they've promised to be. They're– sort of the entire thing they do is keeping promises? They're - they try to understand and follow and - more perfectly embody - the Algorithm."

This is a short word, in Baseline. It...mostly doesn't translate clearly into Taldane at all. 

"Anyway, they still - mostly don't have roles-with-accountability within Governance, just - a lot of points of contact, anywhere you need a cutout within the hierarchy to prevent perverse incentives. And obviously you go to a Keeper if you have a really hard question to answer or decision to make. They're - the people who know all the - true things about the world that are unpleasant to know - they're trying to practice correct thinking even when that's - bad, for humans, for actually living nice lives - they train to - keep themselves sane even in the face of infohazards. ...One of the departments under Exception Handling is infohazards, obviously that has a lot of Keeper involvement in secondary-management roles. You....have to be really smart to train as a Keeper, like, multiple standard deviations smarter than me."

Which, if Merrin's vague impressions are right, there - might not be anyone with that intelligence level in Golarion. Except for gods. Which she still knows worryingly little about, because - it matters, she thinks, that the Keepers are still humans, even as they're studying and learning and passing down the pieces they can hold of something so much bigger. 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

 

 

 

 

".....Sorry I am realizing that I just said a lot of words with high information density and maybe it would help if I had paper and I could draw you a flowchart or diagram of it." 

Permalink Mark Unread

They've gone through about half the remaining para-elements and quasi-elements while all that was being spoken of.

"Mm, I feel that the main thing I am missing right now, is not to hear all the parts and pieces spoken of, but rather, to understand - how anything happens in practice?  Suppose that a portal opened between Golarion and dath ilan, and some dath ilani was first to find it, and suppose that they were -"  Loyal?  She can't say loyal??  "- aligned with, friendly to, Governance - who would they tell, who would have charge of it, who would decide what was to be done from there?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Huh, Albe is - putting a lot of emphasis on specifying that the initial report is coming from someone friendly-and-aligned with Governance? Merrin has worked with - and trained for - hypothetical scenarios involving individual unaligned actors - but she really doubts that literally anyone she's ever met in real life wouldn't report it via the standard channels if that happened to them in real life. 

"...So that's pretty solidly under Exception Handling for the very immediate response, I think. We - okay, we don't literally have a written process for 'a portal opens to Golarion' but Exception Handling has processes for responding to First Contact from aliens, we have kind of a huge number of them actually, for a really wide range of possible scenarios. One of the first priorities, alongside verifying that it's real at all, would be to - causally contain the situation until someone - a very high-ranked Keeper probably but I'm not fully read in on that part of the response flowchart either - has thought about unknown infohazards of unknown magnitude and assessed the risk. For a literal portal, we'd - I guess that'd actually be almost the exact same containment protocol as the 'crashed spaceship' scenario."

Which Merrin is SO READY for. Merrin has REHEARSED this. If Civilization decided that they needed to keep a city's inhabitants fed and provided with medical care and emergency cryopreservation as needed then Merrin has this so covered.

"Um, there are equally fleshed-out protocols for verifying it's real, I'm not myself fully read in on the details - a lot of the verification aspects for First Contact situations are kept secret on purpose to make it harder for, um, someone to decide to play a prank on Civilization and fake it." 

(A fact about dath ilan is that it contains many serious, intelligent people with a strong tendency toward cunning mastermind plots, and most of them are not going to use their talent to play a criminal prank of that scale and waste huge amounts of resources, but you super can't just count on that not happening.)

 

"If it was a - non-adversarial initial contact - um, I don't remember the exact flowchart for reporting, but very quickly, as soon as it was contained and verified - probably actually while that was still going on - it would be escalated to the Chief Executive, unless for some reason the Keeper-cutout at the Exception Handling department-head level, in collaboration with the very-high-ranked Keeper responsible for assessing infohazard status, decided to keep it contained at that point. I haven't actually encountered any specific training hypotheticals where they'd decide that. There might be some scenarios where the Keepers would sideways-escalate it to another department where they have a secondary-management role. Anyway, assuming not that, we'd have the prediction market department looped in on it in like...ten minutes from the time it was first reported to someone at Exception Handling, assuming otherwise-normal functioning of all of our infrastructure, I'm guessing the portal wouldn't disrupt electronics...." 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

That's an Abyss - maybe in this case, she actually should think Hell - that's a Hell of a lot of obedience to take for granted in your population.  And from all of Merrin's other thoughts it really doesn't come across as likely that this is obedience is because any dath ilani who failed to report the portal would die over several months... actually there'd be no point to stop after several months if you couldn't send them to Hell afterwards, but she digresses.

It does sound like the Keepers hold the real power, though, and she can't even tell from Merrin's thoughts whether she doesn't know it or just takes it for granted.

She is going to make a deliberate effort not to react badly to this setup just because it sounds like their version of the Church of Asmodeus succeeded in sidelining their version of Queen and Crown.


"So it sounded like you worked for - a very powerful branch of Governance, with a lot of Keeper involvement?  Did you tend to meet many of the Keepers?  Perhaps there's more important things I should be asking about," there aren't, "but I admit to being curious; they sound so... mysterious."

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin's most memorable interaction with a Keeper was in no way work-related. She does not say that. 

"Um, in day to day medical response work, I don't that much? There are several levels of management between me and the director of the Exception Handling department, who actually works closely with the Keeper-cutout there. Um, there is a process where I - or anyone else under the Exception Handling department - could escalate a concern directly to them, but I haven't...done that. There's also a process I could use to receive a recognition code if a high-ranked Keeper needed to give me a really weird direct order and I needed a way to verify it was real. Also has not actually happened to me. I've done training scenarios that involved consulting with lower-ranked Keepers, I guess, but - the vast majority of what I know about them is from stories." 

(To the extent that Merrin reads fiction these days, it's almost always fiction about Exception Handling scenarios, which of course tend to heavily feature Keeper involvement. It would not occur to Merrin that this might be an inaccurate representation. Why would Civilization support the continued existence of fiction that gave people misleading models. ....There is nonzero fiction with Merrin in it - some people really like medical-emergency-response adventure plots - and Merrin doesn't usually read it because it makes her really self-conscious, but she would definitely inform someone if it was inaccurate and she assumes anyone who knows her in real life does that.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

She can't, because it's info off Detect Thoughts, but now she really really wants to ask how this person ended up in novels when all the rest of Merrin's thought processes seem to mostly indicate somebody who wasn't that important -

Actually, didn't Merrin just hint -

"Forgive me for being curious, but if a portal opened between dath ilan and Golarion, would it be likely that you, yourself, would be called to that incident?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"- Yeah, I'd be on the list of personnel to be immediately paged and collected for that. I've focused pretty hard on doing Exception Handling trainings, I think I'm on the call list for, like, five different subdepartments. For that one in particular, I'm trained in operating with equipment or supply limitations where you need to improvise, which could apply if an entire city needs to be sealed off for an unknown length of time, and additionally I'm - unusually good at working for long shifts without significant deterioration in my mental performance, so anything where you'd want to minimize the total number of personnel sent in - and 'they're being sealed in with unknown infohazards' counts - is something where I would likely end up near the top of the list. And I've done a lot of training scenarios for urgently figuring out how to provide medical treatment to aliens."

Yes, this is extremely unlikely to ever come up in real life - though, um, Merrin believed that before she found herself in another world which seems like a major update - but anyway they're really fun okay. 

Permalink Mark Unread

She starts running Detect Desires and Detect Anxieties alongside Detect Thoughts and focuses even more of her attention on trying to follow every detail of Merrin's thought processes.  If what she suspects now is true -

"You sound like you must be a very special and important person in Civilization, then, if you'd be among the first to be told of any such momentous event; somebody who must surely have been deserving of great wealth and high place?"

Permalink Mark Unread

???????????????????????

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin's feelings are mostly - confusion? She is worried that Albe is somehow fundamentally misunderstanding what dath ilan is like and maybe her explanation missed something?

She's not upset about it, just - trying to figure out where to even start with that. 

"I mean, I get paid for my work? Extra for training scenarios that are at inconvenient times or where I don't get warning in advance or that are just unpleasant or uncomfortable, and I would get a much bigger bonus if a real First Contact event happened, because sealing myself in a city with an open portal to another world would involve some actual danger. Normally it's done by, like, bidding what your cheerful price is for 'being woken up in the middle of the night' and 'a scenario that lasts fifteen hours straight' but I pay someone to do the actual math for me because it's annoying. ...Also I probably still have some passive income from, like, being featured on television, a lot of the training scenarios or Annual Rehearsals I'm in are televised so people can stay up to date and bid on the prediction markets in real time, and then I get to use their expertise as well in decisionmaking." 

Merrin does not actually have the slightest idea how much she earns from the Exception Handling work. She outsourced it when she was nineteen and first had significant work income; she really doesn't prefer to have to do extra math about things that aren't even her area of expertise, and investing her money responsibly is something she's deeply unqualified to do. When she was twenty-one and getting to the point that she was doing high-cheerful-price trainings or scenarios most weeks, she set a cap on what she thought she actually needed for annual living expenses - a generous amount, she thinks, her apartment is really nice and very, very conveniently located in Default - and the rest goes 10% into a long-term-savings-investment and 90% to charities she picked. Then the whole masochism thing happened and it turned out to be really lucrative, so she's - pretty sure she asked her agent not to bother reserving any of the Exception Handling income for living expenses. She does keep all the money from the bids to date her. It feels - more hers, somehow, this isn't something where Civilization is already investing vast resources in training her. And she suspects her boyfriends would feel - weirder about it, less comfortable accepting what was genuinely her happy price - if she was just donating most of it. She does have to do the bidding herself on that because her investment agent is not approved to know the infohazard, so she knows roughly how much she makes annually, though honestly she's, like, over a year behind on actually properly reviewing her budget. Her lifestyle does not leave a lot of free time when the thing she feels like doing is her personal finances. She's slightly embarrassed about it. 

"- I think I don't know how to parse the second thing you're asking. I - have the amount of influence I should have given my actual expertise?" 

(Merrin is not completely unaware that she has what one might term 'fans', that quite a lot of people tune in to watch her televised scenarios. She sees the volume of updates to the prediction markets, after all. Since Exception Handling emergency-response-medicine is just objectively very cool, this isn't surprising, though it's definitely convenient for Merrin personally, getting to have her plans informed by lots and lots of aggregated expertise. She sort of tries not to think about it too much on a day to day basis, though, it makes her self-conscious. Merrin tries to do her own part by watching other people's scenarios during her off-time but she's not actually very good at prediction-market betting and she probably doesn't really pull her weight there.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

She was expecting Merrin's thoughts to show spikes of fear, horror, anxiety, or possibly particular thoughts glowing with pleasure and happiness, as her thoughts steered around the question of whether she deserved more importance or pay than she had.

What she's actually seeing is thought processes that sound so reasonable that she's finding part of herself questioning whether she's truly looking at a mind-controlled slave.  Or just somebody with INT 16 and WIS 20, who would be among the first called in if a portal was found to Golarion, who in some perfectly normal way thinks of herself as a below-average individual unsuited to most jobs in her society, who gave nearly-all of her income to what she was told was a charity, and just happens to never look or think about the amount of wealth she's supposed to have from her supposed job, and subsists off the proceeds of prostitution from her secret sadist 'boyfriends' - Merrin is apparently a public spectacle, often performing in some form of arena whose details are hard to make out, but definitely with crowds betting on her, and yet her emotional sense of her own place is that of some unimportant functionary -

On a purely intuitive level, her high-powered Detections are telling her that these are totally normal thought processes and maybe that's what mind control just looks like when you somehow do it without any magic and this is the most fascinating and impressive feat of slavemaking that she has ever seen.  Ever heard of.  This is a thinking curious INT 16 WIS 20 grandmaster-level professional slave who has no idea what she is.

Part of her is still not sure that this isn't just actually how dath ilani society works because that is how totally reasonable and uninfluenced Merrin's thought processes look to Detection if you ignore everything about where she ended up.

...how one would go about breaking this person out of her current mental prison - and into a more interesting one, of course - is something where she'd just have absolutely no idea where to start, if she can't use real torture.  It seems very clear that the false world Merrin lives in is going to be complete and consistent; that any simple questions "But what about..." or "Isn't it funny that the end result was..." will be met with totally reasonable answers, followed by suspicions as to why this question is even being asked and totally reasonable reasons for Merrin to stop listening to whoever is talking to her.


"Forgive me if my curiosity is painful," says Albe, "but - I am wondering what accommodations and - even luxuries - you might have had?  I thought, perhaps I should ask now, before you grow to miss them too much."  They couldn't have been literally feeding her slaves-bread, right, that wouldn't make sense for a slave this expensive.

Permalink Mark Unread

- Detect Desires is now picking up a brief but VERY INTENSE pang of homesickness. Merrin is aware that no longer having her really lovely apartment - she moved into it when the new skyscraper opened in Default, the one which is like five minutes' transit from the airport - it seemed more worth it once she started dating several more people who lived a plane flight away, on top of all the travel she was already doing for work. It's big and spacious and has an entire room dedicated to her collection of Exception Handling-related practice equipment.

Cheliax is poorer than dath ilan, and even if she can contribute to changing that, she probably won't within her lifetime see a city like Default again, let alone have her own beautiful little corner of it. It's not Cheliax's fault that they're less wealthy in material resources than dath ilan, and it would be incredibly rude and awkward, and also - petty, given the scale of everything happening here - to say out loud that she misses her apartment and expects their accommodations to be pretty disappointing. Merrin is absolutely not going to express this, and intends to try her very hardest to be cheerful about whatever quality of apartment they offer her. 

(And forget about her house, she doesn't get to have prediction markets, let alone any of the rest of the vast structure of Civilization, which sort of feels like having one of her arms cut off.)

(Though, who knows, maybe there's some very brilliant wizard here who has a volcano lair, Cheliax certainly leans doompunk enough that she can picture it.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay but she still has to answer the question. With something that is not awkward and hurtful to say to the people who are clearly trying very hard to make her feel welcome to the point of literally trying to seduce her

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin shrugs. "I'm - honestly going to miss airplanes a lot, even though I died in one and you'd think that would give me less enthusiasm for the concept. It'd be different if instant-movement magic worked on me but I think - still not the same, Civilization in dath ilan is just - wealthy enough that it's not even a big deal, to fly halfway around the world for a weekend. I'm...going to miss the conveniences of, of being in a Civilization that I know - I'm excited to find out what you can do with magic, here, but it's still not -" 

Not home

 

(Glimpses, in her thoughts, of vast metal machines taking off from smooth paved roads and soaring across the sky - a view of the ocean sparkling, so far far below - the view from Merrin's floor-to-ceiling window in her apartment that fills the entire wall of her living room, watching the skyscrapers of Default catching the evening light - 

- numbers on a glowing screen, flickering and changing, and comfort and feeling safe because this, this is a process that bends toward the truth and the best available answer and plan of action and Merrin can trust it and can trust all the structures around it, and she can maybe explain to Cheliax how to build skyscrapers but she can't explain the Law that governs Civilization, all she has is fragments half-understood and without any reference or guidance it already sort of feels a little as though what she thought she knew is starting to crumble to dust in her hands -) 

 

This is actually kind of hard to talk about. 

She shakes her head. "I don't know. I miss prediction markets for decision-making. ...Some of the things I miss like my favorite meals or my best outfits are - probably more replicable, here - but I don't know enough to teach Cheliax how to build the Civilization I know." 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

...it's impossible to tell, with thoughts so glancing, were those slave accomodations, or not?  Merrin didn't think they were and the glimpses via Detection suggests that Merrin was hardly being treated as a slave by Cheliax's standards.  By dath ilan's?  It's so hard to tell at this remove.  Merrin was, in theory, much wealthier than anything that she tried to draw in the way of 'living expenses', but what kind of living situation that corresponded to - could Merrin actually have had more wealth than she needed, could it actually have been that -

No!  Merrin thinks of herself as too small of a person for somebody who would have been first called to a portal, for somebody with so many elite sadistic 'boyfriends', who had crowds cheering her and betting on her in some arena.  The Keepers weren't keeping Merrin poor, that would have been a ridiculous and meaningless economy for a slave this important.  They were keeping Merrin weak, unaware of the power she could have garnered for herself and wielded in her own name.  Merrin has no awareness of wealth as anything that can be used for ends besides personal luxuries, she has no thought that wealth foregone is power foregone, and that's why Merrin never tries to use the wealth she thinks she has.  Maybe Merrin does hold vast wealth, legally, there if Merrin ever looks for it, which she never will; the Keepers may not bother with keeping wealth, in a place like dath ilan, so long as they keep power.

Amazing they just wear the name openly like that.

...and now she has to face the agonizing decision between whether to try to matching her own wits against Merrin's makers, to make Merrin realize what was done to her, for Cheliax to offer Merrin everything that was taken from her, in exchange for a damnation she never needs to know is coming.  Or just take advantage of her incredibly convenient brainwashing.

Permalink Mark Unread

While all this was going on, they've run out the elements to test.  The last element Albe is testing, Ooze, fails to penetrate Merrin's antimagical shield.  It's not surprising, in one sense; in another it is.  Even a Prismatic Sphere has seven vulnerabilities for each of its seven layers.

"All right, there's one more class of tests, which is magic items."  Albe withdraws a wand from the wall - this magic item is not, technically, actually a 'wand', but it looks like one.  "Try pointing this at me and saying," Albe points the wand at herself, "Belial."

A small dart of light, fast as an arrow, pulses out from the wand and apparently vanishes as it touches Albe.

Albe offers the wand to Merrin.

Permalink Mark Unread

Thinking about what she misses the most - talking about it, talking about how dath ilan works and holds together - was, perhaps, not great for Merrin's current emotional stability. She's - so lonely.  

Lonely, and scared - though even Merrin herself isn't entirely sure what she's afraid of or why, it certainly isn't going to come across clearly to Detect Anxieties - and some other emotion that she can't even begin to name, except that it feels cold and unsteady and murky. 

- also she really needs to focus on what they're doing here. And then make sure she gets answers to her own questions, before some other distraction comes up. 

She accepts the wand. It was clearly harmless to Albe when used on herself, and it's very very likely it will, in Merrin's hand, do nothing, and she's still an amount uneasy about it but - probably the literal worst case is that, if some kind of horrible unintended side effect somehow manages to kill Albe, they can bring her back. Which would presumably be very inconvenient for everyone but it's also vanishingly unlikely, and nonfatal injuries are even less of a problem, and in short it is not actually worth doing more mental risk analysis here. 

"Belial?" Merrin says, carefully imitating the syllables. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Nothing.

Permalink Mark Unread

Albe takes the wand back, not holding it like it's particularly dangerous, and feeds it back into the wall.

From the wall Albe draws forth a ring.  She slips it onto her own finger, slips it off again.  "Try putting this on a finger; it's meant to cast a physical protection about you.  It is not impossible that it would fall outside the range of the magical interference, though I rather expect not."

Permalink Mark Unread

Sure. She tries the ring on. 

 

 

She's on her own and this is TERRIBLE. It's one thing to operate on her own that for a training scenario that has a stopping point, at which point there is a debrief and guidance, and it's different if it's just her indefinite future, if and until she can build...whatever she can, whatever shards of Civilization and Law she understands enough to put together from scratch...and even if she can do that it feels like she's lost something, something more nebulous than the obvious parts she can name. 

But Merrin knows how to handle things which are terrible. And one of the ways to handle things which are terrible is that you plan ahead, but you don't try to emotionally carry the weight of the entire future all at once. 

"- How many more magic items to try? I notice I'm feeling impatient to get to the point when I can take out my questions list about Golarion and Cheliax and cover all the things on it that you're not worried will be somehow risky to explain, and - I wouldn't be surprised if the particular questions I ask will help point at questions you should be asking about dath ilan." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Poor thing!  No one so accustomed to slavery should be without a master, indeed.  She will certainly do whatever she can to help Merrin with that problem.


Albe takes the ring back.  "I'd intended to try a few more things, but I confess, I have a suspicion at this point how those tests will go.  Three such tests are important, though."

"First, I need to very weakly enchant that needle of which I spoke before, and try poking you with it.  Even for an enchantment that doesn't really do anything, that's still a task of a few minutes, and I won't be much for speaking during that."  A needle extrudes from the wall as Albe speaks, along with a small lump of silvery metal.

Permalink Mark Unread

Sure. Merrin will be very still and quiet and take the opportunity to try to catch up on some processing, because this conversation has been swerving all over the place and covered a lot of ground and she hasn't had a chance at all to start putting it together and propagating the relevant updates. 

Things that have come up. 

- In addition to afterlives, you can bring people back from the dead with magic. Which has the obvious ramifications on things like 'lab safety standards'. 

- Among the differences in protocol, flirting with and attempting to seduce visitors in your dangerous magical research lab is a thing. 

- They apparently do not consider sadism or masochism to be infohazardous at all. Merrin didn't actually get the relative prevalence in the population from Albe, she should ask once Albe is interruptible. 

- Albe...seems to think that Merrin should try the sadism side of things, and it seems that Albe would approve if Merrin ended up enjoying it. Which...implies...that people in Golarion are reasonably likely to be both

- She has now explained the steered-by-Tropes space of hypotheses for her arrival here, but not the Romance theory, although that is...maybe actually fine to explain given the abovementioned not being locally considered an infohazard anyway. Merrin is mostly worried that it would escalate the flirting further.

- Their whole categorization system is even weirder than it sounded at a first glance. Albe has (quite reasonable) concerns that if she tries to explain it without sufficient care then Merrin will end up dangerously confused or misled. 

- You can pass messages to gods (unclear how) and gods can send people visions with instructions. 

- Albe...had some reactions to her explaining Governance. Merrin isn't going to go through all of that right now but she noted that Albe seemed particularly curious about Keepers. 

- Albe seems to be under the impression that Merrin could be expected to be wealthy and influential based on her role in Exception Handling? Which, like, on the one hand she is, to an extent - she's definitely wealthier than the median person in dath ilan and she probably also has more total influence, but it's also still true that one very specific subspecialty of Exception Handling is...not that big a deal? There are thousands or tens of thousands of people who are equally skilled and well-known in their own incredibly niche domains, and that's not even counting the people in leadership or secondary-management advisory roles who actually steer the future of Civilization. 

- Albe wants to make sure she doesn't feel too deprived by losing the luxuries and conveniences of home, which is sweet of her but seems pretty hard to accomplish. This feels very awkward to navigate without offending or upsetting anyone. 

- .....Also she has technically been observing some experimental results on the exact limits of her antimagical effect. This manages to be less interesting than almost any of the rest. 

Permalink Mark Unread

- well, that's a lot of things and Merrin can't really tie it all together without paper to write on. It seems like the most important confusion here is around the axes of categorization. And also gods. And it seems relatively high-priority to learn how Cheliax structures its Governance, because that will tell her something about their level of protection against unintended-consequence unknown failure modes of trying new projects. 

 

(This is probably all the time Merrin will have to think before Albe is finished with her enchantment.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

All right, that's one incredibly weak enchantment done on this Needle of Poking.  Has Merrin put her shoe back on since they did Magma testing?

Permalink Mark Unread

She has not! She's been pretty much just sitting on the floor in the middle of the room this whole time anyway. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Then Albe shall go and hold Merrin's foot firmly.  "Ready?  This will, of course, actually hurt; I expect your flesh to reject the magic but not the metal."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- And it'll hurt more if this this is the one exception where the magic does work on me, but not actually cause seriously-inconvenient damage, right?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"If it actually works you'll feel a strong additional sensation to go with the poke.  Not enough to damage you further, just enough to be unmistakable when you tell me how it felt, if you feel anything."

"Ready?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Noted. I'm ready." 

Merrin is so curious and it's actually slightly disappointing that the magic is almost certainly not going to work on her and she won't get to find out. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Poke!

Permalink Mark Unread

(This feels exactly like being jabbed with a needle, according to Merrin's no doubt tremendously finely-honed sense for such things.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"- I did not feel any additional sensation," Merrin confirms, very calmly. She is trying so hard not to react to this in a way that could be interpreted as further escalation of flirting, not because it's not tempting but she really needs to do some more thinking on her own before she can decide if it's a good idea to let the highly-trusted consultant to Cheliax's Governance seduce her. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Albe inspects the needle and nods.  "The enchantment is intact, at least."

"Second test.  Try to bend this needle, with your bare hands."  She offers the needle to Merrin.  It definitely looks thin enough to bend.

Permalink Mark Unread

"....Sure?" Merrin tries bending the needle. "Is the same enchantment supposed to make it stronger and also cause the sensation that I did not get to experience?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

(The needle remains unbent.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"Magic items of almost any kind are much less fragile than their mundane counterparts; infusing them with the essence drawn from 'spellsilver' that makes a material magically conductive also strengthens that material."

"Try willing the needle to bend, or the enchantment on it to shatter, as you try to bend it."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Huh, so the aspect that makes it harder to bend is - not the enchantment itself, but the fact that the material includes 'spellsilver' that the enchantment can be put on at all?" 

Merrin isn't really sure what mental motion she's supposed to be trying here, but she gives it a go, starting with willing the needle to bend and trying the second thing if that doesn't work. 

Permalink Mark Unread

(Needle remains unbent.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"It doesn't need to include spellsilver directly, but there's a movable essence in spellsilver of - magic, magical conductivity - I have the strangest feeling that this language would be more apt to express the concept here if we of Golarion knew what it was, I can feel the language trying to draw specifics from me that I don't have.  It's somewhat better to infuse the spellsilver directly, than to draw the essence from it, for then you may be able to refine some of the spellsilver back out again later.  In this case I was in a hurry and had no time for forging.  It doesn't become hardened right away, upon the essence transferring, but almost any preliminary step of enchantment is enough to produce the resilience."

Albe takes back the needle.  "The enchantment on it looks unbroken as well.  Well, it makes you less powerful than you might have been, but at least you won't shatter expensive magical items just by touching them."

Permalink Mark Unread

Wow, that's fascinating. Without knowing more details of the translation magic, Merrin isn't sure if Baseline is just generically better for expressing complex concepts and physical-law-type relationships, or if there are actual Baseline words for some of the components here, like 'spellsilver' whatever that is. If it's a metal in the normal periodic table then Baseline would of course have a word for it - is there a metal out there somewhere that would conduct magic except that dath ilan has never been able to test that before? 

"Right, I just - suppress them instead? Temporarily?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"You don't suppress enchantments so much as they're unable to act on you.  I think even if we poked the needle through you, we'd be unable to bend it while it was inside you."

Albe then makes a rather expressive unhappy face.  "Our last test about magic items, unfortunately, is going to be rather unpleasant for me... but there is information that can be quickly gained thereby, and it is information that seems important.  Bide while I cast some supportive spells on myself."

Albe touches herself on the chest, waits six seconds, touches her chest again, waits six seconds, touches her chest again.

Permalink Mark Unread

Huh. That's...a very polite and convenient way for her anti-magical effect to work? Not for her, necessarily, it still won't let any magic work on her, but in terms of not damaging anyone else's magical items. That's - evidence of something, probably, about the goals of whatever entity caused this to happen. She's not sure...what. 

She doesn't object to Albe going with the unpleasant-for-her test. Albe is much better placed to judge if it's worth it for the information gained. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Would you mind if I just performed this test first, it should be quick, and explained it afterwards?  I will feel better about doing it that way."  Not to mention safer.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin isn't delighted about that but she, at this point, does have a reasonable balance of evidence that Albe is calibrated about danger to herself, and that there's some actual countervailing consideration for why discussing it first might be worse than risking the scenario where Albe needs help and Merrin has no idea what's going on. 

"I am going to want it explained after," she says, but nods. 

Permalink Mark Unread

She orders the watching Security to fail his Will save, and turns her Detection on him.

He doesn't have any idea what she's about to do, is wondering about that.  Good.  This would be an amazingly good time to assassinate her, otherwise.

She doesn't cast additional protections on herself, that might give away, to anyone watching, how much of a good time this might be to attack.  Mostly, the way she can be safe is by doing this all in less than six seconds.

She has put up Cunning, Wisdom, Splendour, she's made it hurt as little as it possibly can.  Cheliax does not have that many major artifacts lying around in the first place, divine or otherwise, and the others would be too dangerous or revealing to test against Merrin -


With a convulsive sort of motion, Albe pulls off the fancy headgear she's wearing, puts it on Merrin's head for a second or two, and then pulls it off and drops it back onto her own head.

Permalink Mark Unread

(The fancy headgear, in the couple of seconds it's on Merrin's head, feels substantially weightier than appearances would suggest.)

(That's all.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin holds perfectly still, and waits until the fancy headgear is solidly back on Albe's head. 

 

"...Confirming I did not notice any magical effects," she says quietly. "Are you - all right -?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"As with many painful experiences, the anticipation was worse than the event itself."

"...there's a tier of magical items above ordinary ones, known as 'artifacts', made by economicmagicusers of extraordinary power or with aid from 'gods'; once made 'artifacts' are very nearly indestructible and so they accumulate through the ages.  An ordinary antimagic field could not suppress their function, even if it was powerful enough to operate against every lesser magic."

"Cheliax does not have that many 'artifacts', and many of those that do exist are weapons or destructive or have some ill-effect on their users.  The one I am wearing is in fact about as close to purely beneficial as any 'artifact' can be."

"That it has become this much a part of myself and is now incredibly unpleasant to remove, might perhaps be considered a downside.  But that is not something that you wearing it for two seconds would do."

The antimagic around Merrin is at the divine level - possibly beyond that, it cannot be ruled out, but definitely at least at the divine level.  This did not seem like the work of any mortal wizard to begin with; but now that has been ruled out essentially entirely.  Even if an antimagic field had been cast at ninth-circle power, in some newly-researched form that conformed exactly to a person, that spell - which would notably not have any elemental vulnerabilities - would not be able to suppress the function of any artifact, let alone that one.

Permalink Mark Unread

It says...something, about the world - and about Cheliax - that most of their powerful 'artifacts' are destructive in nature. Especially given that, from Merrin's impressions so far, it's not obviously the case that economicmagic itself is just vastly better at destruction than beneficial effects. 

She nods. "That's interesting. I have to confess, I'm really curious what the beneficial effect is." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"It... does seem a bit unpleasant to say that, when it's something you apparently can't have."

"In any case, we are done here, and this last result in particular means that an incredibly busy person named Aspexia Rugatonn needs to be bothered about this.  I'd hoped to avoid or at least delay that."

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think even if it would be upsetting, it - seems important for my understanding what Golarion and Cheliax are like and how things work? I don't– I mean, I'm starting out from a position of this - I assume - being a thing I couldn't have in dath ilan either and would never have expected to have, it's not - letting down an existing expectation. Unless you mean it's the infohazard kind of unpleasant." Though Merrin would be kind of surprised if Albe is tracking that in the same way a Keeper would; it seemed like their language didn't even have a word for the concept. 

And it's starting to feel a bit like there's a PATTERN here, of Albe having very good reasonable reasons not to tell Merrin what's going on - but Merrin is any amount worried that some of the actual reason is it seeming less complicated for Albe in the short run. Which it probably is, and maybe there are genuine risks too. It still seems like an excellent way to, in the longer run, have an underinformed Merrin in the position of needing to make a high-stakes judgement call and not being prepared to weigh all the considerations correctly. 

- though she's now kind of distracted by the additional update on exactly how important Albe must be within Cheliax. Since she apparently personally possesses, not just one of the rare and expensive powerful artifacts, but one of the even rarer ones with non-destructive effects. Of course, she had already known that Albe was someone with a high level of skill and authority, but she'd previously been imagining Albe as one of a number of trusted highly-paid-Security-cleared-consultants-with-considerable-autonomy-and-authority, presumably the one whose schedule was open at the moment Merrin arrived in Golarion. But being in possession of an extraordinary magical artifact that may have literally required a 'god''s input to create is...the kind of thing where surely there is only one person like that in Cheliax. 

She's slightly irritated that no one tried to warn her??? Maybe they (correctly) realized that this would be extremely intimidating for her, but Merrin would have coped with it. 

......This does not make it less confusing that Albe was flirting with her. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"It makes me smarter."

"I... would not be the sort of person who gets called in on a matter like this, if I had not managed to inherit it."

Permalink Mark Unread

Wow! Okay! Albe maybe had a point, that is definitely is something that is slightly upsetting to discover exists when you yourself cannot have it! ...Not that there's a low-hanging counterfactual here where if only she wasn't inherently anti-magical she could be smarter, since it requires a rare and incredibly powerful artifact - one that was maybe made a long time ago, and passed down in Albe's family, she did mention that artifacts like it tend to 'accumulate over the ages.' 

(Interesting that it sounds like something that was in fact in the possession of her - parents? And not the Governance of Cheliax. This is sort of a guess, still, but the way Albe is phrasing it, that little hesitation, does not make it sound like she would have been selected by Governance out of everyone in the entire country to receive it. ...Merrin suspects this fact that she's just learned contains a lot of information about the Governance of Cheliax, she's just - still very unsure how to interpret it.) 

Pre....sumably it was not inherited from the branch of her ancestry that came from the 'Chaotic Evil' continuum dead-people-place, even though in fact it sounds like that is one of the more - unique and noteworthy - elements of Albe's ancestry? Merrin is not entirely sure of that though! Since she knows absolutely nothing about the continuum of 'Chaotic Evil', except that it's the opposite of 'Lawful Good', so probably just about as different from Cheliax as you can find anywhere in this world. And...maybe...has a lot of sadism and masochism? Since this is, so far, the thing that Merrin most confidently knows is associated with 'Evil'. She doesn't see why that would obviously correlate with it being a place that turns out lots of really cool superpowerful magical artifacts. 

 

...There is a hint of an implication there that the parent or other relative who passed it down to her is dead, since it - sounds like the artifact is not one that someone would be likely to willingly hand over while still alive. Merrin isn't sure whether grieving would be different, in a world where people just go to other places when they die, and she definitely has no idea how to give her condolences in a non-hurtful-or-offensive way, so she doesn't say anything.

 

"I'm glad I know that," she says quietly. "It's - the kind of thing that I could imagine being relevant in an emergency." Sure, it would take a bizarre edge case sort of emergency, but what do you THINK Merrin's entire specialization is in. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you were glad to know that, are you in the market for even more information I'd have thought you'd have preferred not to know?  I am still trying to calibrate - I'm not sure that word came out right, I've said it but now I don't know what it means."

Permalink Mark Unread

This is a very important question and a difficult one to answer, and Merrin gives it the careful thought it deserves, for nearly a whole minute. 

 

"...Yes, I think, if it's information you were worried I would prefer not to know because it would make me sad. I'm - I think even for dath ilan I'm unusually able to cope with that, it - there are plenty of Exception Handling subcases that involve positing that something incredibly horrifying and upsetting just happened, and I - have to be able to know if I could handle that in real life, right, if it were suddenly not-hypothetical. I - think I'm unusually fine with a lot of things that are sort of infohazard-adjacent in the direction of, like, knowing that a nice thing exists and I don't and can't have it. I have no reason to think I'm fine with other categories of infohazards, the kind that only very high-ranked Keepers know, but sort of by definition I don't know what they are."

Merrin shrugs a little. "If it's a concern like the one you had with explaining the axes of categorization, where you think I might - end up confused and effectively more wrong than I was before - then I don't have much evidence to make a case to you that I'm not vulnerable to that. Though I do have a lot of practice at - knowing when I'm missing context and judging when it's safest to just not take actions. That comes up in Exception Handling training. If you just tell me that I ought to bump up the internal odds I'm putting on 'still being confused and wrong' then I can probably compensate for it before it would get to the point of taking ill-advised actions." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"As you wish, then.  Anybody you see in the hallways wearing something on their head is probably wearing a headband that enhances some aspect of their mentation.  It's not that only artifacts can do that, it's that this one is more powerful and enhances more aspects of my mentation simultaneously.  Before taking it off, I cast three spells on myself that only last minutes, but in combination can do two-thirds of what my artifact does in three of the most important regards, which is why I didn't fall over after taking it off."

"Once Cheliax was sure that you weren't the sort to try to destroy Cheliax or Golarion, they'd have probably given you one of the more relatively powerful headbands short of the artifact level, which enhanced whichever single aspect of mentation you most needed as powerfully as this headgear enhances three of mine.  Spellcasters could have temporarily enhanced other aspects of your mentation if you were blocked on some exceptionally difficult problem."

"That's what they would have done for you, if not for the antimagic field, if any of that could work for you."

"That's all the sad news that was coming immediately to mind.  Would you like more sad news like that if it came up in the future?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin, again, tries to stop and think about this for the length of time it actually calls for. 

 

"...Yes. I would specify 'yes but only if it's decision-relevant for me but I - don't actually think that you or anyone else here can be expected to - have a detailed enough model of me and of my own models of Golarion, yet, to predict whether something is relevant. That one...is. It tells me how much Cheliax would want to prioritize my work efficiency, and even if I can't ask for that specific thing, now I'm more informed and I can consider asking for other kinds of support. - 'Calibrate' seems like exactly the right word for what you were trying to do, you were - checking whether the model of Merrin you have in your head matches with what the real me says in answer to a question, and noticing what the direction of any error or discrepancy was so you could correct it. Um, that's the way to explain the concept without any math, at least." 

Merrin pauses. Thinks for another moment. 

"- Who is this incredibly busy Aspexia Rugatonn? I'm - guessing from the context that she's someone with a high level of authority in Governance here?"

And also someone who apparently even Albe, as highly trusted as she clearly is, feels reluctance to interrupt. That seems like something where the explanation for it might be relevant to Merrin, who is likely to end up interacting with Aspexia Rugatonn face to face at some point. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Interesting.  She would have expected more of a reaction there, given Merrin's other thoughts.  She can't quite see how it relates to the slave conditioning, but it probably does.  Possibly something emotion-dulling about it in general?

"I'm not quite sure how to explain Rugatonn... she works for Asmodeus more directly than any other human in Golarion, and from the standpoint of somebody in Golarion, it has made her more than slightly odd.  Maybe if you're not from Golarion you couldn't tell the difference because we'd just all seem very odd."

"Ah, would you care to change your clothes back, and let us go find out whatever Negotiations," as close as this language comes to 'diplomacy', "has come up with for you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Ah, so Aspexia Rugatonn is sort of like the Golarion equivalent of a Keeper. ....Merrin catches that thought and forcibly reminds herself that she has very little evidence for this point, and actually what she should do is try not to have preconceptions, to go in and notice what Aspexia Rugatonn is actually like, and then use that to propagate inferences on what the gods are like. Or Asmodeus at least; she also still has very wide uncertainty on how different the gods are from each other. 

She's still on some level totally expecting Aspexia Rugatonn to be basically like a Keeper, though. 

(Merrin would, if she were taking the time to consider this explicitly, predict that she's going to have a lot more emotions later about the sad information that other people in Golarion get to have magical items enhancing various aspects of their intelligence, and Merrin does not get to have that. But it's still the case that she never had a period of building up hope for it that was then disappointed, and on an emotional level right now it just feels - smaller - than what she's already lost, e.g. "all of her home Civilization". She's very used to at least not poking at her emotions when she's in the middle of something time-sensitive, which she is right now.) 

(The fact that this kind of magic exists is - actually a straightforward positive update about Golarion, she thinks. It would partially counteract the thing she noticed earlier, the inference about what Golarion's median intelligence must be like relative to dath ilan, and it seems more likely that she could manage to rebuild at least a fraction of Civilization, here, if she has the help of people with cognition-enhancing magical effects.) 

"All right." She puts her shoe back on, and - is it flirting to change back in front of Albe - the question is really whether it's more flirtatious than anything else so far, which she doubts. She still turns her back for it, though, mainly out of self-consciousness. 

 

She also retrieves her sheet of questions from the pocket of her original shirt, and then they can go find out what Negotiations, presumably a department within Governance, has come up with for her! 

Permalink Mark Unread

Antonio has managed to dig up three expensive rare magical items that grant Tongues and can be passed around, so that up to three people can talk with Merrin at a time.  Her options for what to do next include:

- Give Antonio thirty minutes' notice on a party for the two dozen people in Egorian who seem most like they could hold up a conversation with Merrin and are interested in meeting her, with other activities performable in the meanwhile
- Talk to the three students from Ostenso who asked to follow along with the alien
- Have somebody who speaks quickly translate a book for her
- Obtain her own bedroom and rest

(Albe says she needs to run off and report to Aspexia Rugatonn, which may take a while because Rugatonn is not always interruptible.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

"Most High.  I'm afraid we have a bit of a situation on our hands."

Permalink Mark Unread

...Can her options also include talking to someone who can ANSWER the MANY QUESTIONS that she has thoroughly and effortfully prepared and has written down and ready to go? Merrin would be interested in a party eventually but she still has some dangling Work Tasks to handle before that! 

Permalink Mark Unread

Does Merrin prefer answers that might be slightly off or wrong, right now, or better answers in fifteen minutes after Antonio has time to bring in somebody more expert?  Also can Merrin give him a general idea of what sort of topics she means to cover?

Permalink Mark Unread

Fifteen minutes is totally fine! (Merrin had been slightly worried that her best option here was to ask to talk to the students from Ostenso and then show them her questions, but having someone more expert sounds much better!) 

Giving a general idea of topics is a reasonable request and Merrin will cheerfully read off the topic-headings from her list of questions. She's learned some things since she made this list and so some of the details are less relevant but she thinks the major topics still apply. After some very quick rereading and reprioritization, they are (in approximate order of importance to her right now): 

- How gods work

- How the afterlives work

- How magic works 

- The history of Cheliax and also Golarion more broadly 

- The economy of Cheliax and also Golarion more broadly 

- The education system in Cheliax and also Golarion more broadly 

 

(Merrin really wants to add a question about the entire bizarre and confusing alignment-categorization setup but Albe thought that was maybe fraught to explain and she therefore doesn't feel comfortable asking someone, even an expert on the topic, to explain it on fifteen minutes' notice.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

...he'll try to get, like, four people.  It may possibly be slightly longer than fifteen minutes before they are all here.  Whoever he finds first can go first.

He hopes Merrin is prepared for the fact that people in Golarion may just know less about anything than it sounds like Merrin's people may know about everything.  Just... going on the way she talks about things generally.

Permalink Mark Unread

.....Yeah. She's kind of noticed that. 

 

- can she maybe go wait in a room that is somewhat comfortable? It's fine if her actual bedroom isn't ready yet. 

Permalink Mark Unread

They can arrange a comfortable room for receiving experts; her bedroom is also ready, if she wishes.

Permalink Mark Unread

(Merrin super wants to go hide in her bedroom right now, even if it's a new bedroom she's never seen in another world and even if it's only for fifteen minutes, but....probably it would be at least somewhat awkward to receive experts on topics related to gods and afterlives and Cheliax in her bedroom?) 

....That's not a very good reason, actually, especially since it sounds like it would be more work for someone to arrange a different room? 

Merrin would be delighted if someone could walk her over to her bedroom. She's fine with then also meeting with the relevant experts there, if they're also okay with it. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...Cheliax is also fine with walking Merrin to her already-allocated bedroom, and then her receiving experts... not in that bedroom?  They can arrange a sitting-room nearby?  Meeting with experts inside your bedroom would be, uh, not totally not odd under local customs?

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is going to assign herself some mental points for musing that this might be the case, and...probably she should deduct some kind of points for the part where she failed to care about it? 

She's suddenly very tempted to ask Antonio if it's odd under local customs for important consultants to Governance who inherited incredibly powerful intelligence-enhancing magical artifacts to try to seduce alien visitors while ostensibly running experiments in a doompunk economicmagic research laboratory. She suspects that this urge comes from the same source as whatever was prompting her not to care about whether receiving visiting experts in her bedroom would be weird, though, and it seems like a better idea to sit on it for now and wait until she's had some time to recover her balance. 

"Sure, that works fine with me." Merrin will follow whoever is available to escort her to her bedroom! What's it like? 

Permalink Mark Unread

You can, if you're paying close attention to your environment, guess that this bedroom was hastily rearranged and redecorated.  This nice calm relaxing white bed with no chains or handcuffs on it, for example, probably wasn't in this room before she got here.  There's a shelf full of books she can't read whose dust levels nonetheless suggest that they were hastily placed here.  There's a comfortable sitting-chair that probably also wasn't here previously.  There is a clean ensuite bathroom that looks frankly horrifying in its crudity, but one that will, fundamentally, let you draw a hot bath.  There's a huge fireplace with logs, for the benefit of anybody who'd like to burn wood inside a room and inhale some of the resulting fumes.

Since it's not possible to repaint the room, per se, it is still done in blood-crimson walls, and there are both red lights and standard bright Continual Lights.  By pure coincidence, this is also what a sensible person of Civilization would prefer in the way of lighting options to avoid disturbing her sleep cycles.

There is, at least, no window exposed to the outdoors from which light cannot be fully blocked.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is someone who, in general, pays close attention to her environment! She did have some specific requests and it's thoughtful that they were so efficient about providing them, even when this was probably not a trivial outlay of resources hereabouts. 

She's...not sure what the point of the books she can't read is, unless some of them are, like, primers for learning how to read the local language? She's less horrified by the bathroom facilities than a lot of dath ilanis would be, at least, since Merrin unlike most dath ilanis has previously had occasion to bathe in a literal river. 

...She is genuinely unsure what the point of the giant alcove-box-in-the-wall and the inexplicable pile of wood, until she puts together that it's for burning and plausibly for heating - can you not do that with magic? You would think you could pull off a forced-air central heating system with a blob of Magma in place of a conventional heat source, but maybe too few people can actually do the required spell, or the blobs don't last very long? Either way Merrin doesn't even like heat much and has no intention of filling her indoor room with smoke. (She's technically lit a wood fire before, in a genuine emergency the immediate effects of hypothermia are a lot more dangerous and life-threatening than some smoke, but that was outdoors, and most actual training scenarios replace the "campfire" with a portable electric heater or chemical heat packs.) 

How does she control the lights? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Like this!

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin wants to check that this works and doesn't fail in some mysterious and possibly destructive way thanks to her antimagical effects. Once this is confirmed, she thanks her room escort and asks if someone can come get her when relevant experts are available to talk to her, and then she closes the door and turns off the brighter lights and lies down on the bed. It would probably be useful to go over her questions but actually she just very badly wants fifteen minutes of rest. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"You utter miserable fool.  I should have been consulted immediately when someone first considered the possibility of divine intervention in a matter like this, and INSTANTANEOUSLY after someone had the thought that they could not think of any deity who would do such a thing!  Fool!  FOOL!  Do you have any idea of the fate you were courting?"

It takes a lot to make Aspexia Rugatonn actually scream at you, but something like this will do it.

Permalink Mark Unread


"Evidently not," Abrogail says, more quietly than usual.  "What fate -"

Permalink Mark Unread

"The fate of Numeria.  Something fell there, from out of the sky, and everything about it was sealed by an impenetrable barrier, that remains there to this day, the people who were within that barrier were not seen in any afterlives, that is the fate you were courting, for yourself, for ME, for everyone in the palace, in Egorian, maybe in CHELIAX, YOU FOOL!"

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"Ah.  Otolmens."

"...I suppose that would fit with the antimagic shell, from the little I know of Her."

Permalink Mark Unread

Aspexia physically slaps Abrogail.

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

"You do not challenge and attempt to undo the works of unknown divinities without consulting me."

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"...acknowledged," she says quietly.  "Your further - input, on this matter?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Make no further attempts on the barrier around her."

"Keep a tally of all who have read her thoughts, and all who have read their thoughts, and stand ready to send them all to Hell if needed, should it prove that within her there is dangerous knowledge.  Or perhaps send them to Abaddon, if there is within her a contamination from beyond known reality to which Hell is not immune."

Permalink Mark Unread

"That tally does include myself."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Learn well the lesson thereof."

Permalink Mark Unread

Twenty minutes after Merrin flopped into bed, there's a soft light knock on her door, the sort somebody could easily miss if they were sleeping.

Permalink Mark Unread

She's not sleeping! Merrin's circadian rhythm does not actually think it's bedtime quite yet; she's not overjoyed at having to get up again, but she suspects it's going to be very hard to actually sleep until she feels more oriented. 

List in hand, she goes to the door. "Yes?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"We've got an eighth-circle wizard to answer magic questions!  By the time you've run out your questions to him, with any luck we'll have located the next expert for your list."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Thank you. I really appreciate all the effort you're going to here, I - realize it's probably not cheap." 

She follows Antonio to whichever non-bedroom area is available for this, so she can be introduced to an eighth-circle wizard! (One of her many questions: what does "eighth-circle" actually mean?) 

Permalink Mark Unread

'Manohar', his name, is a bluff cheerful large man wearing somewhat loose wizard's robes.  In terms of subverbal signals, he comes across as a very safe person to be around.

There's nine standard degrees of spell complexity corresponding to the complexity of the topology of the spells!  Cantrips are a special case, considered level zero or not-really-wizardry; they're underpowered, but so absurdly stable that you can catch them after casting and cast them again a few seconds later.  Manohar will spin up an illusion so he can show Merrin nine examples of the visible-to-wizard-sight parts of spells he's familiar with, successively more topologically complex structures.  There's only nine, because ninth-circle casters are so rare that Manohar has not, in fact, personally seen a ninth-circle wizard spell being constructed.

Permalink Mark Unread

......Whoa. That's incredibly cool! Merrin is tempted to try to draw them in her notes, but he's not holding each one for long enough and it's probably not the best way for her to understand their economicmagic better anyway. 

 

"So - the successively more complicated structures are - harder to learn, and can do more impressive things? And it sounds like a lot harder to learn, if you've never even seen one. Could you - give me a few examples of spells at each level of complexity, so I can get a better sense of what that corresponds to in practical terms. Ideally where the examples at each difficulty level are maximally different from each other - I'm not sure whether spells fall into clear categories but if they do then that'd also be really useful to know." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Sure!  How about:

Prestidigitation, a 0th-circle Universal spell that lets you chill, warm, flavor, change the color of, gently lift if less than 1 pound, clean, or dirty, an object.  Changes to object substance (not just moving, cleaning, soiling), persist for up to an hour.  This is known as 'laundry magic' and is most of what actually gets cast in Golarion.

Endure Elements, a 1st-circle Abjuration that lets people resist hot and cold environments;

Greater Detect Magic, a 2nd-circle Divination that lets you see magic in enough detail to analyze who probably cast it;

Fly, a 3rd-circle Transmutation that lets wizards fly around for up to 2 minutes per caster circle, super popular;

Symbol of Laughter, a 4th-circle Enchantment for drawing a rune which, once seen or touched or passed over, causes all creatures within 60 feet who fail to resist the effect, to laugh uncontrollably for 2 rounds per caster circle;

Decollate, a 5th-circle Necromancy that allows a target to willingly remove their head;

Contingency, a 6th-circle Evocation that can be co-cast with another spell, that then gets triggered automatically under some set condition; complicated or convoluted conditions have a chance of failure;

Subjective Reality, a 7th-circle Illusion which lasts up to 12 seconds per caster circle, and temporarily convinces you that some targeted object or creature or force is itself an illusion, so firmly that you can, for example, walk through the wall you've convinced yourself is illusory;

Create Demiplane, an 8th-circle Conjuration which creates a bounded or looped mini-universe, up to ten 10-foot-cubes per caster circle, with specifiable elemental traits, or ecology, or its own alignment, you can specify the gravity levels, etc., lasting up to 2 days per caster circle, can be made permanent at a rather high cost;

Wish, a 9th-circle Universal spell which, in principle, can fulfill any spoken request, and, in practice, unless you keep to one of thirty or so known phrasings, results in an enormous flaming crater or worse.  This is a bad idea and you should not do it, even if you've thought of a very clever way to do it, which is where the enormous flaming craters come from.

Permalink Mark Unread

....This is the weirdest flaming magic system that Merrin has ever heard described. She feels as though she's reading the worldbuilding summary-notes of a novel that was written by an author who was taking three different Ill-Advised Consumer Goods mind-altering drugs at the same time. And not trying at all to make it seem surface-level coherent, though presumably there's some deeper level on which it makes perfect sense. Merrin feels like that was a very dense and helpful information-dump and yet it's not very much constraining her predictions at all

Why in the name of radioactive sewage is there a spell for WILLINGLY REMOVING YOUR HEAD. They don't even have cryonics here which would at least be something where it might be useful

There is a spell specifically for programming conditional statements into other spells and that is incredibly cool and also...surprising...? She's not sure why it feels surprising, yet, but there's something to be poked at there. 

She really wants to fly now and it's deeply unfair that she CAN'T because she is INHERENTLY IMMUNE TO MAGIC SOMEHOW. 

Merrin is pretty sure that those are only a tiny fraction of her questions and they're going to keep hitting her for the next ten minutes as she finishes processing that. She takes very fast shorthand notes, and then divides the remaining space on her paper into quadrants and starts organizing. 

 

"- Sorry, I may need a minute to think that over, but that was a very helpful rundown. Um. So I'm gathering that there are standard categories to describe spells, which are - orthogonal to the complexity-level or "circle", right? Categories are Universal, Abjuration, Divination, Transmutation, Enchantment, Conjuration, Illusion, Evocation, am I missing any– oh, Necromancy. I am gathering that Divination is - information-gathering, enchantment is - much more centrally mentalisticmagic than economicmagic, actually, it's...mind-affecting? Conjuration makes things. Illusion I think actually mostly translates straightforwardly to Baseline, it makes - images or imitations of things? I'm going to wildly guess that Transmutation changes how physical laws affect objects or people. I think I need more training examples or else an actual definition to figure out what Evocation or Abjuration or Necromancy would cover more broadly. Universal is just...uncategorized? I want to confirm if my guesses there are at all on the right track and get some more clarification, and I think I could also use more detail on - where spells come from, why are do these specific ones exist and not others, and approximately how many different spells exist by category and by circle."

 

Pause.

 

".....Incidentally I am somewhat feeling like you should not have told me about the flaming craters spell and I'm not sure why more than five people in this entire world know that it exists that sounds like such an infohazard. To be clear I would have no intentions of trying it even if I could do magic but still." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Manohar's pretty sympathetic about the infohazard thing, but knowledge of Wishes seems too widespread to eliminate?  They've played too much of a role in history?  There are, as stated, very few ninth-circle casters, and most people who make it that far without blowing themselves up have some sense of caution.

Her descriptions of the standard categories... are vaguely right, for not reflecting the underlying technical realities?  Subjective Reality is an Illusion spell because moving things halfway out of reality relative to yourself is technically dual to moving things halfway into reality relative to somebody else.  Evocation calls on forces and elements, bringing them into reality, evoking them.  Abjuration prevents something or tells it not to happen or blocks it.  Necromancy involves the manipulation of life and death.  'Universal' spells are called that because they don't have any of the technical qualities from the other categories, which means you can cast them even if you're a specialized wizard who's pretty bad at some category of effects.

Spells get copied and passed around down through centuries and millennia.  Unusually powerful ninth-circle wizards sometimes invent new ones.  Failed spells tend to explode and resurrections aren't cheap.

These spells exist and not others because - the person who made them, wanted that spell to be a thing, and it turned out to actually be possible and also they could figure out how to do it?

There's anywhere from, usually, six to a couple of dozen known spells per category per circle.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is now incredibly curious to know the underlying technical realities! She is aware that this is almost certainly not explainable in ten or twenty minutes. 

"So that's -" she does some very quick mental rounding, ten "circles" and assume ten categories and ten spells per, "- roughly a thousand total known spells? Do there tend to be more at the lower-complexity circles?" 

Dath ilan screened off their history and for all Merrin knows it might have been in order to eliminate widespread knowledge of something analogous to Wishes. Merrin doesn't say this out loud; it seems pointlessly critical and unproductive. She...is kind of curious what the difference is, there - Golarion doesn't have Keepers but it does have gods - maybe the gods of other alignments would be in opposition, even if Merrin is pretty sure that Asmodeus, being "Lawful" "Good" whatever that actually means, would be in favor of fewer flaming craters

Also this entire world's attitude toward research safety continues to be ridiculous even though it makes sense in context. 

"...I'm going to see if I can guess how spells I already knew about would be categorized. The translation effect is - maybe Enchantment? The lights are maybe Illusion or maybe Conjuration? I think most of what Albe tested with me was Evocation. If the flying spell is Transmutation then probably the instant-movement spell is too - what circle is that, incidentally? And do you have any approximate statistics on how many wizards exist in Cheliax at each circle? Or just relative proportions if you're not sure of total numbers." Merrin is making a not-very-confident advance prediction that it's probably a power law distribution. 

Permalink Mark Unread

A thousand spells sounds about right?  Maybe a little low?  Fifteen hundred?

Half the population could learn Prestidigitation if they tried, every village usually has at least one person who knows laundry magic.  Five percent of the population actually is first-circle wizards - Cheliax is proud of this, that's the highest ratio in the known world, reflecting Cheliax's excellent education system that among other things identifies smart-enough people and wizard-tracks them - and then it halves for each circle up from there, more or less, with sharper dropoffs as you start going past 4th, 7th.

Speaking Baseline is Divination, the lights above are Evocation, the instant-movement spell is 5th-circle Conjuration, most instant-movement spells are, though there's a 4th-circle Illusion called Shadow Step that lets you step into one shadow and out of another.  What Albe tested was Conjuration.

Permalink Mark Unread

....Yeah, she's clearly going to need to know any of the technical details before she can start to make sense of this magic system at all. 

Oh no why does becoming a wizard ALSO rely on being very smart, terrible not actually one of her biggest problems right now. 

"What's - difficult about magical education, other than inherent intelligence limits? - I did previously learn that you can use magic to increase intelligence, but if it requires a very expensive and difficult-to-make artifact then I guess that doesn't help much on the scale of Cheliax as a whole." She also has SEVERAL questions about how and why that's a thing that works, and she barely has guesses about what category it would be, aside from 'probably not Necromancy'. "...Also this is not actually an important question but why did someone invent the head-removing spell. What do you use that for." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't know why anyone invented it and I've literally never heard of anybody using it for anything.  A lot of the other Necromancy spells that come to mind are less pleasant; the field and its famous practitioners have something of an ill reputation, especially in Lawful Good Countries."

"Intelligence is indeed the primary requisite of wizardry, mainly for being able to visualize the invisible interactions of magic involved in constructing and hanging a spell for later use.  This in turn requires advanced mathematics, in particular incredibly-elementary-algebra-your-parents-teach-you-before-you-start-school, ridiculously-basic-topology-for-nine-year-olds, and at higher levels, linear-algebra-too-simple-to-bother-with and the-first-five-minutes-of-a-calculus-lesson.*"

(*) Not literally the terms in Baseline, just what the actual and precise mathematical subject names sound like to any dath ilani, even Merrin.

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

...If it turns out that Merrin knows more math than literally anyone on this entire planet she is going to. She doesn't even know what. The worst part is that she probably shouldn't be surprised. She keeps noticing evidence in one direction. 

Currently she is feeling torn between 'run around in circles gibbering in horror' and 'somehow, PROFIT'. 

 

"Manohar, how long would it actually take for me to check if I can learn the 0th-circle one, um, Prestidigitation? I might only be immune to external sources of magic." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"If you already possessed all the mathematical requisites and were exceptionally talented... probably still several hours per day for several days?  Months would be more typical of the average student who succeeds at all.  The most talented wizard not ancient, out of the current world, is said to have learned her first 0th-circle within half an hour; it's said that she had a native intelligence of 21, where 10 is the mean for this world and 2 is the... your language has a single-syllable term for standarddeviation.  I don't know why that surprises me, at this point, but it does."

"I suspect that the average intelligence of your own world was not 10, on our scale."

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay but none of those requisites are actually math. Merrin learned them FINE without it even being much EFFORT, therefore 

"I...don't know what '10' in your scale would correspond to in our measurements, but - assuming I have not met literally anyone with an intelligence of 10 because everyone I've met was filtered for either being a wizard student or the sort of expert or Governance official you'd send to greet someone from another world - then I agree." Shrug. "I doubt I'm exceptionally talented either way, but I do know the prerequisites," and a lot more than that. "Dath ilan - may just be a lot better at math education than here, the way Cheliax is unusually good at teaching wizards. So I think I want to try, even if it's likely to be time-consuming. If I can learn it at all, that - gives us some information about the limits of my antimagical effect, which - maybe lets us infer something about the purpose of it." 

Permalink Mark Unread

That could happen.  Does she want to start right now?

Permalink Mark Unread

The actual answer is that YES SHE DOES whether or not this makes sense as a priority. 

"Um, I - yes, but I'm waiting for some other experts to answer different questions I have, I think I'd better sort that out first before I commit to several hours of practicing. I think I've already asked all my basic questions for you, and to the extent I'm still confused it's about the technical details and actually trying to learn how to do it seems like a reasonable way to get less confused. Though I don't want to take up more of your time than I have to, especially . You could just explain the kind of exercise I would need to do, if it's something you can cover in twenty minutes, and I can arrange to actually practice it later, maybe with the wizard students I met earlier?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Now that Manohar is visualizing this process in detail, he feels a bit concerned about Merrin's chances.  You're supposed to construct a spell and hang it, on a magical scaffold that you build, over a diagram of magical ink in your spellbook, and the first stages of this process usually involve an older apprentice constructing the scaffold and spell, and leaving it there while a flock of students wave their hand over that spell and try to feel it and try to manipulate it.  That Merrin can't do that, doesn't quite rule out her having her own magic that can pass through her antimagic barrier, but it does sound like the standard teaching method wouldn't work.

Manohar's best idea:  Somebody shows Merrin an illusion overlay of what's going on while an otherwise not-too-experienced wizard slowly constructs their scaffold and spell for Detect Magic, the first cantrip apprentices usually learn for obvious reasons, while also telling her the math used for inferring the non-visible parts and describing the observer's guesses about what's currently happening to those.  Then, Merrin can be given a spellbook page for that, and... try to do the same thing even if she can't sense anybody else's magic?  Even an apprentice running Detect Magic would be able to notice if Merrin succeeded in a preliminary way at moving any magic outside of herself in a way that stuck onto where the potential scaffold should be above the spellbook.

But Manohar really has no idea how you'd start on doing that, if you didn't know what magic felt like, and had no way of feeling that sensation for the first time.

Permalink Mark Unread

(This about the Queen of Cheliax: she is more Intelligent than Merrin and far more Splendid, but less Wise.  Abrogail started life with 11 of that, and is now up to 18, but numbers alone won't tell you that whole story.  What Wisdom Abrogail has, she uses less well, for she, like everyone else in Golarion, has received far less training than Merrin in using reflection and perception.  Abrogail's path through life is the path of brilliant improvisation, and when she stumbles, why, she improvises past that.

This, about her, explains why Abrogail has now cleverly deduced that the Otolmens-protective antimagic shell around Merrin is no doubt solid and impermeable, saving perhaps for the Divinations required for Otolmens or other gods to go on seeing Merrin.  A needle poking past her skin was not able to deliver magic into her flesh.  From which it follows that Merrin will not be able to learn wizard spells, making that a safe way to burn off whatever of Merrin's energy and thinking-time is not spent empowering Cheliax.

Rather than, say, considering that one possibility while also considering and planning for others.

Aspexia would think differently about it.  But, direct prayer to Asmodeus having failed her as it almost always does, the Most High is busy talking to Hell about this probable Otolmens event.)

Permalink Mark Unread

That's certainly inconvenient, but Merrin is inclined to try it anyway. For the value-of-information, and because watching the illusion-overlay while hearing an explanation of the math seems like a useful route toward better understanding this world's magic - which she's sure is important - even if it turns out that she cannot, herself, learn it. 

(Merrin is also less worried than Manohar about the difficulty of attempting to manipulate something that she can't directly perceive. Arguably, almost all of medicine is like this? She can't perceive cellular metabolism or organ function directly. A standard dath ilani ambulance has quite a lot of equipment dedicated to taking various measurements, but even those are usually several levels away from the actual underlying processes that need to be monitored and understood, in order to keep a critically ill or injured patient alive. And thanks to her extensive Exception Handling training, Merrin in particular is also trained in how to run a mental model of her patient's evolving condition - without even the support of prediction markets - and based on only a handful of indicators that can be perceived by standard human senses, without any equipment that can't be rapidly improvised from scraps.) 

(And Merrin is very, very good at diligently repeating a practice exercise without much extrinsic source of reward.) 

Of course, this won't be a quick test to run, given that even very potentially-talented Golarion natives who can make full use of the normal teaching methods would expect to need days. If she spends a week attempting to learn the most basic of wizardry, and fails, then that will start to be some weak evidence that either non-Golarion humans literally can't, or her antimagical effect is preventing her specifically.

The really interesting outcome would be if she succeeds sooner than expected. Merrin...thinks it's probably worth a week of spending several hours a day on it? It might be different if it were more obviously trading off against some other emergency she could be working on, but it's not clear that it would; she wants to move carefully anyway. 

The alternate teaching setup does sound like it might take some lead time to arrange? In which case Merrin suspects it makes sense to do that after she's talked to the other experts on their way here, especially since it's not impossible that she'll learn something that will force her to re-evaluate her current priorities. 

Permalink Mark Unread

There's those three students who asked to follow the alien to the Imperial Palace; any of those will be able to keep Detect Magic running for purposes of telling whether Merrin is making progress on hanging a spell.  Any senior Security wizard in the palace can also step in for purposes of throwing on an illusion-overlay, one nearly simultaneous with what's actually happening, when Merrin thinks she wants another look at one of the three students hanging their own cantrips.

As Manohar speaks, he's showing Merrin a picture of what would be happening magically, if Manohar were currently hanging a Detect Magic spell, by first building a scaffold above an illusory spellbook page.  There's literally dozens of interactions going on here, maybe a quarter of those visible, and probably at least some that modern wizardry just hasn't figured out except as a randomness-source.  But, if you can see how this strand here (arrows appear) is ending up around this distance away from this strand here (arrows) that's because this interaction pulls with the inverse square of distance, this one repels with the inverse cube, so if you can get those two interactions in the right ratio of strengths the balancing point will be right here, which is where it needs to be in order for this blob to oscillate around it at the right frequency that's needed to cancel out the net oscillating force on this other blob produced by the cycling of force around this apparently stationary strand here, and keep that other blob stable so you can lay this other strand on top of it!

(Difficulty level:  Looks like a medium-low-complicated video game, except for the part where the rules are still in the process of being explained.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is not very good at video games - by dath ilan standards, at least - but it's hard to imagine something more motivating than personally learning economicmagic and she is very, very motivated. She doesn't try to interrupt with questions during the demonstration, but she takes advantage of all her experience at very fast shorthand note-taking. 

...She's pretty sure that with a day or two of practice and mental drilling, she can get to the point of being able to mentally visualize all of what's going on? (Her visual imagery and spatial sense are significantly stronger than her overall mathematical ability.) That's obviously not the same thing as whatever is required to interact with the underlying magic, but it sounds like they can set up a tight feedback loop for her attempts to do that. She's tentatively hopeful. 

When the demonstration is over and Merrin can ask her accumulated questions, it's immediately clear that she's familiar with the math involved, more than most wizarding students. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah, Manohar figured.  His impressively-technical phrases coming out in one or two syllables each was a hint.

The gods expert is ready now.

Permalink Mark Unread

Great! Merrin would like two minutes to clean up her magic notes a bit so that she won't be confused later by unfinished sentences, and then she folds them neatly and puts them away and cheerfully awaits an introduction to said gods expert! 

Permalink Mark Unread

Manohar steps out, a very serious older man steps in and very seriously inclines his head to Merrin in what looks like a gesture of respect.

He's wearing a gaudy doompunk outfit.

Not a particularly high-quality outfit either, it looks like a twelve-year-old put it together in an hour and didn't spend more than three unskilled-labor-hours on materials.  Anybody used to 'rubies' being clear perfectly-faceted giant chunks of synthetic corundum is not going to have much luck identifying the tiny cloudy red smooth-polished stones as rubies.

In terms of instinctive reactions, Merrin's social instincts are going to tell her that this is somebody elite enough not to give a shit what anybody thinks of what he's wearing.

Seventh-circle priest cleric employee of Asmodeus, Iker Egobar.

Permalink Mark Unread

Huh. 

Merrin is delighted to meet him and appreciative that he's taking time out of what must be a very busy schedule to answer her questions, and now her first question is how being an 'employee of Asmodeus' ...works. What's the hiring process like? Presumably Asmodeus is not managing all of his employees directly, Merrin knows enough about gods to infer that that would be insanely expensive, but exactly how indirect is it? What are his day-to-day responsibilities; what's the chain of reporting? ...Also is "seventh circle" just the same thing as with wizards, or different? 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

...if you 'pray', this language apparently does not have the word, if you - think about a god, in the direction of a god, and think about how your purposes is shared with their purposes, and ask to be made a 'cleric' by them, then sometimes - in 1% of the population - you will feel the god reach back and respond, marking you as theirs.  You can feel their presence, when that happens.  Gods cannot communicate even with their 'clerics' unless they spend some limited-god-resource to send you a vision, which will probably leave you with a massive headache for a day if you're lucky.  This happens maybe once a year to anybody in Cheliax.

Gods grant spells to their chosen, who pray for them at dawn.  Those more favored by their gods, more attuned to them and in sympathy with them, of longer and greater service, receive more powerful spells.  Iker Egobar, then, is a cleric favored enough of Employer Asmodeus to receive seventh-circle cleric spells from him, of which there are 10 such in Cheliax, and one ninth-circle, Aspexia Rugatonn.

Permalink Mark Unread

That's fascinating and - Merrin is thinking very quickly now - it implies a world where the gods have substantially more total influence on the ordinary, non-afterlife world than Merrin had previously been modeling, even if it's relatively indirect. 

She's going to make a mental note to reason through all the implications of that later; she doesn't want to waste the time of a high-ranked employee of Asmodeus. 

"How much overlap is there between what wizard spells and cleric spells can do? And what's the relative proportion of clerics at each circle - is it similar to the proportion with wizards, or different because it depends on - attunedness to the god - and not intelligence? Do you also need to be good at math to cast cleric spells?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Half of wizard spells and half of cleric spells overlap, perhaps?  He has never thought to calculate the percentage and has no books before him.  Divine spells are sometimes subtly different from their arcane counterparts, at least in some cases.  The 0th-circle spell Detect Magic overlaps between clerics and wizards.  The 0th-circle wizard spell Prestidigitation has no clerical counterpart.  The cleric 0th-circle spell Stabilize, which causes somebody who's on the verge of dying to stop losing any more health than that for a while, has no arcane counterpart.  Healing is famously much easier to do with divine magic than arcane magic.

Half of 1st-circle clerics will become 2nd-circle clerics, half of those will become 3rd-circle.  The proportions begin to drop off as higher circles are reached and it becomes more and more expensive for any god, even Asmodeus, to empower you further.  Many gods have no ninth-circle clerics at all.  The only ninth-circle cleric of Asmodeus in Golarion is Aspexia Rugatonn, whose service to Asmodeus is very great, her understanding of his ways and purpose is unmatched by any of the seventh-circles such as himself.  If Asmodeus were to promote one of their number to eighth circle, it would signal that one was Rugatonn's likely successor; but none of them, it seems, are yet worthy of that.

How far you progress as a cleric, depends on - 'faith', something hard to say in this language, not only working for a god, but having a deep emotional attitude towards them.  But if it depends on any personal attribute it would be 'Wisdom', again hard to translate to this language.  'Wisdom' is - maturity, sharpness of perception, awareness of yourself, perspective?  It is to clerics what intelligence is to wizards.  He would personally tend to regard 'Wisdom' as something that fuels 'faith', and not an advantage apart from the 'faith', closeness-to-Asmodeus, that it fuels.

Clerics do not need math to cast spells.  Spells, indeed, almost never take math to cast; it is wizards hanging their spells in stable forms, that requires their intelligence and learning from them.  Clerics receive spells from their gods, and so have no need of any of that.

Permalink Mark Unread

(Wow, Merrin wants that healing magic very badly. Or, failing that - because her own top guess is still that one of the local Golarion gods made her antimagical in the first place, which would imply that her chances of getting herself clericed are even worse than for learning wizard spells - she at least desperately wants to reinvent a full-on intensive care unit worth of medical monitoring equipment and then see what the spells do. It makes no medical sense to her that the Stabilize one is that magically cheap! Preventing dying people from dying is incredibly complicated! Merrin of all people should know! Well, obviously this is a form of conceptualmagic that treats “physical health” as ontologically basic and possible to manipulate directly, but that…does not exactly leave her with fewer questions!)

She doesn’t say any of that out loud. “That division - Wisdom being counted separately from the kind of intelligence most needed for wizard spells - that’s interesting. I think dath ilan would say that most of those traits are at least somewhat intelligence-related? And the rest is more related to life experience. How do you - is there a metric or test you can use for measuring those traits before someone is a cleric or wizard? For the mathematical ability side, it sounds like you must, Manohar mentioned that Cheliax is better than most countries at identifying potentially talented children and tracking then into the right classes?”

Permalink Mark Unread

There are spells for measuring three mental traits, two of which clerics may use, all three of which may be used by wizards; Iker Egobar has not requested them today, and so cannot test them on Merrin, though, under the circumstances, he would not particularly expect them to work on her.

(It is better if Merrin does not think right away that mind-reading spells might be effective on her; though the controller of this game standing behind Egobar has not yet decided whether Merrin should be told that at least some divinations seem to work on her.)

Speaking this language, the thought has occurred to him that the Taldane word 'Intelligence' is perhaps not well-translated as the Baseline intelligence.*  'Intelligence' is - quickness of wit, ability to visualize complicated things, good memory, thinking of many ideas.  'Wisdom' is clarity of perception, self-awareness, taking on others' perspectives, rejecting the bad ideas you think up.  The third spell-measurable mental trait is 'Splendour', self-control, strength of will, force of personality, persuasiveness.


(*) Lit. 'thinkoomph'.

Permalink Mark Unread

That is…a pretty weird breakdown, in particular “self-control”, at least as conveyed by the translation spell, seems more in-a-cluster-with self-awareness than with persuasiveness or “force of personality.” Merrin is pretty sure she has excellent self-control, usually, but she really doubts that she’s all that persuasiveness (unless she is specifically trying to persuade a stubborn dath ilani young teenager to take their medical condition seriously, because she’s practiced that.)

If there are spells to measure them directly, that would seem to indicate that the local physical law involved in their magic considers them to be ontologically basic concepts in some way. It’s not weirder than overall physical health being something one can directly manipulate. 

Merrin wants to know about other ways that these three measurable traits interact with either cleric or wizard spells.

Permalink Mark Unread

There's 2nd-circle enhancement spells for all three of them, granting to each trait a +4 bonus as measured by the corresponding spell, lasting for 2 minutes per caster circle.  Clerics can cast enhancement of 'Wisdom' and 'Splendour', wizards can enhance all three.  'Wiser' clerics can receive more spells from their gods, at a fixed caster circle; more 'intelligent' wizards can hang more spells.

Sorcerers cast wizard spells but intuitively, without study, through will alone; 'Splendour' is to them what 'Intelligence' is to wizards.

Egobar notes however that the conversation has digressed into magic; this is more Manohar's specialty than his, and he does not wish to mislead Merrin by his own error.

Permalink Mark Unread

“I wasn’t expecting it to turn out to be this interrelated!” He makes a good point that now is not the best time to dive into asking about sorcerers, though. “I - am curious if there’s a known or hypothesized explanation for why this is the most scalable way for the gods to intervene directly with humans— with people more broadly, I’ve already met someone partly nonhuman and I’m predicting there are more. It just seems - weirdly specific and weirdly similar to wizard magic, so I’m wondering if the gods thought of it as a way of intervening after wizardry was invented?”

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"Of this, I know not, and I suspect that no other mortal in this world knows either."

Permalink Mark Unread

(No, people from Golarion don't know how absolutely strange it sounds to a dath ilani to simultaneously claim total structural ignorance about a topic, and also to make a claim about what everyone else in the world could justifiably have for an epistemic state about that.)

Permalink Mark Unread

It sounds super weird. Merrin is slightly wondering if he’s decided that the actual answer is somehow infohazardous or otherwise risky to explain, and given Albe’s earlier concerns about this - there would have been plenty of time for them to check in, or for Albe to report to Aspexia Rugatonn, who it sounds like…mostly manages Asmodeus’ organization on his behalf and thus could reasonably have passed on instructions to Egobar via an existing channel - maybe they’re very hastily trying to enact a policy of concealing that there are infohazards to be concealed? And then doing it badly? 

wait, no, they did have a pre-existing concept for it, or at least something related - the thing with gods that, if someone knows they exist, can thereby access the person's mind and drive them slowly insane? Though i hadn't seemed to occur immediately to Albe to generalize that concept to include information that wasn't about gods per se. 

You would really think that the existence of Wishes as a spell would have been included under a last-minute policy like this, but - Manohar spoke to her earlier, and presumably does not actually report directly to Aspexia Rugatonn, so that doesn't entirely rule it out. 

…Either way, Merrin is dath ilani and she is, for the moment, prepared to be respectful about that even if they’re doing it terribly. And it’s also weird and specific enough as an explanation that she doesn’t think it’s likely; it may actually be more likely that Golarion has relatively poor methods for answering this question, hasn’t prioritized improving them, and also people are…in the habit of speaking more sloppily than she’s used to, maybe because their language is terrible. So she isn’t going to pointedly SAY OUT LOUD how weird that sounds.

“Right. Going back to some of my other questions on gods, then. How many of them are there total? Do they have goals and values more specific than the overall alignment you would categorize them as, if two have the same categorization?”

 

Permalink Mark Unread

It's never occurred to Iker Egobar to sit down and count all the gods.  Why would you do that.

Also Abrogail Thrune's voice is now whispering through in his ear to never to again claim before Merrin that no mortal knows something; Merrin had a suspicious reaction to that which would take too long to explain.


"I suppose - anywhere between thirty and three hundred depending on where you placed your cutoff for what counted as a god?  There are minor beings whose sight extends only through a - small region - whose strongest worshipper might have only third-circle spells.  Asmodeus's reach extends through other universes of which we know very little, as far, it is told to us, as the reach of Pharasma herself - Pharasma being the one who sorts souls to afterlives, said also to have been the creator of the entire system, generally thought to be the most powerful god."


(Merrin gets the real story, not the usual lie, saving only that Asmodeus is Lawful Good and Lord of Heaven.  She is to be told plainly that Pharasma is a mightier god than Asmodeus, though not the reason why Asmodeus Himself would have willed it that way, that He only be following Another's orders.)

"And yes, gods do indeed have specific domains other than their alignments.  Asmodeus is god of civic-order, education-and-training, promise-keeping, having a place in society that is yours."

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay, so being a god is significantly a matter of degree rather than a binary. Merrin…is not sure why she’s surprised by that, actually. 

…Gods which can reach into other universes. Also something where Merrin isn't sure why she's so surprised. Though it's...weird, a little, when put alongside the part where some of the Golarion gods can only reach a 'small region' (how small?) And Albe had seemed to think that the Golarion gods couldn't feasibly be responsible for Merrin being here or for her anti-magical effect, but if Asmodeus can reach other universes and isn't even the most powerful... 

Would the god who created the afterlife system in Golarion have reason to, if somehow granted the opportunity, grab a dath ilani? Maybe??? Basically all she can infer so far is 'likes systematizing things' (deeply relatable), 'values mortal beings having afterlives' (great!), and 'the most powerful god in Golarion.' 

“I'm curious how gods - end up with their particular domains? I also want to hear more about Pharasma, since it sounds like she...is directly responsible for a lot of the ways that Golarion is very different from dath ilan." 

Permalink Mark Unread

So the thing is that every god's followers and every spatial-region of Golarion seems to end up with a different story about what exactly happened in the Beginning of Things (as it is easier to say if you are forbidden from telling Merrin the real story, the one prominently featuring Asmodeus but not in a very Lawful Good way).  They mostly tend to agree on points like Pharasma being the system's creator; anything past that level of detail quickly devolves into disagreement.

The most popular story has it that Pharasma was the last survivor of an older multiverse, and came here bearing something called the Seal by which she was able to bring about the present universe as a bubble of order within chaos, void, alienness, incomprehensibility, that surrounds it.  The oldest and most powerful gods came into existence when, or shortly after, the universe was created; Asmodeus was one of those.  Little is known of the oldest order; it shattered when something called Rovagug tried to destroy all of existence, some gods fought with Rovagug, other gods fought back, the gods fighting with Rovagug were destroyed and Rovagug itself was sealed - within Golarion, which makes this one of the most relatively important universes within the multiverse and a focus of attention for the greater gods.

The oldest and greatest gods, so far as Iker Egobar happens to know, have held their domains throughout recorded memory.  For all he knows, they came into existence bearing those domains, those concerns, those goals.  Younger gods, weaker gods, more often change their domains and concerns, though this is still very rare.


(They've decided not to mention Zon-Kuthon, the ancient god whose domain did change drastically after he traveled too far into the Void.  It seems like the sort of thing that would cause Merrin to prioritize Nidal over everything else they'd prefer to have to prioritize instead.)

Permalink Mark Unread

(Iker Egobar also doesn't know how strange it sounds to talk about very intelligent beings fighting; or people having common knowledge of a persistent disagreement about big important factual questions, one that visibly goes by spatial region containing the person.)

Permalink Mark Unread

It's incredibly strange! It's...actually past the point of strangeness at which 'awkward circumlocution around something that might or might not be dangerous for Merrin to know right now' makes any sense as a reason. Egobar is at least in the range where Merrin can't tell just from a conversation whether his overall intelligence as measured by dath ilan tests would be higher or lower than hers, and given that he's an employee of Asmodeus - and if Merrin is at all interpreting correctly what Wisdom means - he's probably better at the element that would let him notice how this explanation would only predictably result in Merrin having additional questions. Merrin is pretty sure that she herself could have figured that out when she was five

 

 

 

 

....She has so many questions. 

"Right. Um, I...think I want you to repeat all of that more slowly so I can make sure I got everything noted down clearly, and I - might need more time to think about it than is reasonable to take in this conversation. - So I guess a meta-question here is, are there ways of communicating with you that would be less inconvenient to your usual workflow? Messages in writing, or passing it on to one of your staff, or something else -?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

He'll repeat it more slowly, this time happening to throw in various extra tidbits of information, like that Asmodeus (Lawful Good), Calistria (Chaotic Neutral), Dahak (Chaotic Evil), and Gozreh (True Neutral) are four examples of gods who fought Rovagug alongside Pharasma.  These tidbits also happen to include the fact that gods usually negotiate their disagreements rather than directly battling over them; the Rovagug situation was very rare and represented a breakdown of divine order.


(They have no idea what to do about Merrin being alarmed about spatially-localized persistent disagreements among mortals.  They can't even understand the mental concepts that flash through her mind in Baseline when she thinks about why that's alarming, they're clearly referring to math that wizards don't know.)

It would be acceptable, though a bit less convenient compared to a scheduled in-person block of conversational time, to have messages passed back and forth around inside the palace system.  Iker Egobar is on duty in the palace and reachable.  To be clear, if this works for Merrin she should do that.

Permalink Mark Unread

Hopefully she can manage to ask all her urgent questions now, and wait for a later time when it would make sense to do another scheduled block if that works better for him.

(The problem for Merrin, right now, is that the math behind why it makes absolutely no sense for there to be spatially-localized persistent disagreements, and thus their continued existence is pointing at something deeply and seriously wrong, is...not among the concepts that live close to the surface of her mind or that she's regularly thought through explicitly since she was fourteen. There are areas of Exception Handling that would involve more of that, but not the ones she's actually had time to train in so far.) 

It would theoretically be reassuring that literal godfighting is rare and usually they do the obviously reasonable thing instead, but Merrin is firmly starting from a position where the fact that it happened once is deeply alarming. 

(Also, it was not specified what happened to Pharasma's previous universe - plausibly because no one in this one has any information on the matter - but Merrin has one very very unpleasant wild guess.) 

 

She writes all of this down, and copies the names and alignments of the newly-mentioned gods to her sheet of paper currently in use for Active Questions. 

"Is Rovagug...also approximately a god? Did they - it - come into existence at the time or shortly after when Pharasma brought this current universe into existence? If Rovagug is the same kind of entity as other gods then...what...is its domain...? And alignment?" 

Maybe Rovagug is instead an entity more like the 'Seal' that Pharasma used. Not that Merrin actually knows what that would mean, in any very concrete sense. 

Permalink Mark Unread

One version of the story holds that when Pharasma first stepped off the Seal that had transported Her to the new universe, She felt unease at leaving Its protection, and this unease became Rovagug.  Iker does not endorse this version of the story.  It sounds fake to him.

Another version of the story has that there was a Chaotic Evil realm that was later transformed into the Abyss, the Chaotic Evil afterlife, but before it was the Abyss it was something else, inhabited by beings who predated Pharasma's arrival, and the most powerful of those was Rovagug.

Iker doesn't necessarily endorse this story either.

Rovagug is conventionally labeled Chaotic Evil and sometimes clerics Chaotic Evil people from inside Its seal.  It is worth emphasizing that most humans classified as Chaotic Evil are not trying to destroy the multiverse.  If Rovagug is in fact older than the alignment system, that system may not properly apply to It.  If Rovagug has a domain, it's 'destroying the multiverse'.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin has CONCERNS. 

Merrin had really hoped! That when Egobar said Rovagug was now sealed! That he meant actually sealed, cut off from any causal influence over the rest of reality! If he's still able to hire employees (metaphorically, she knows that 'cleric' doesn't mean exactly that) from inside his ""seal"" then he is NOT SEALED and Merrin is VERY WORRIED. And should probably...also...be making some updates about the general safety of this place and its future, like, on a multiverse-scale. There have been active godconflicts that failed to be resolved by negotiations even though gods are superintelligent and that could happen again and also it sounds like the best that the entire alliance of gods in favor of the continued existence of the multiverse could do was block Rovagug from– from what, actually, if most gods only intervene in practice by choosing clerics, and Rovagug can still do that? 

...She supposes that the multiverse has not in fact been destroyed, which is BETTER THAN NOT THAT. 

"I...guess that makes as much sense as anything else? That Rovagug predates this universe and therefore the usual categories don't really fit." By which she means it does not make any sense to her yet but maybe it will once she stares at it for longer and tries to see past the surface and infer the parts she can't see but that make all the rest hold together coherently. "I'm - curious what Pharasma's official alignment is, then? And whether it also doesn't really fit. ...Also on further thought I would appreciate knowing if you don't share Albe's concern about explaining the alignment axes to me in a way that won't result in dangerous misunderstandings, because I think that's a very important piece that I'm going to need to understand any of this." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Pharasma is classified True Neutral, and it does seem to fit?  Certainly, as the most powerful goddess, Pharasma has not seemed to intervene in favor of either Good or Evil, Law or Chaos, as She certainly could, did She wish.  Then She is probably indeed Neutral between them.

Albe's concern makes some sense to Iker!  It is difficult for him to imagine what it is like to not already know about alignments.  Albe suggested that facts about alignments just be mentioned as they come up.  Maybe the accumulation of those facts will do better by Merrin than simply dumping on her the sort of standard statements that are meant for people who, in fact, already know what alignments are, and really argue somebody's particular thesis about them.


(Or actually:  Let Cheliax figure out which lies to tell, incrementally, and in the context where those lies are needed, rather than trying to make those up all at once.)

Permalink Mark Unread

That...makes sense, and might be closer to the way that humans in Golarion originally figured out what alignments were, unless a god told them directly? Merrin wants to know lots of those facts, though, it...might end up being time-sensitive for her to be less confused. 

Starting with - right, so she has a handful of examples of existing powerful-old gods, now: Asmodeus (Lawful Good), Calistria (Chaotic Neutral), Dahak and also maybe Rovagug (Chaotic Evil), and Gozreh as well as Pharasma (True Neutral),  She's still missing any examples for Neutral and Chaotic Good, Lawful Neutral, and Neutral Evil. Are there any equally old or powerful gods in those categories, or if not, who are the most powerful current gods? And then she would like a one-line summary of their 'domains', like the one he already gave for Asmodeus. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Lawful Neutral:  Erecura, goddess of secrets, subtlety, prediction.  Despite being Lawful Neutral, She dwells in the center of a vast interdimensional trading center in Heaven -

Oh, wait, he should be naming ancient gods.  Erecura is less ancient.

Lawful Neutral:  A goddess whose name is secret, governing preservation and catastrophe-avoidance.
Neutral Good:  Urgathoa, goddess of healing, honesty, and the Sun.
Chaotic Good:  Desna, goddess of dreams and travelers and starlight.
Neutral Evil:  Sarenrae, goddess of gluttony and unnatural prolongation of life.

He actually doesn't think he's named anyone Lawful Evil either?  Zon-Kuthon is the ancient Lawful Evil god of pain, worshipped by sadists and masochists.

Permalink Mark Unread

...the plan here being that, if counter to expectation it turns out it's possible for Merrin to pray effectively to gods, the only god whose name and symbol Merrin should be given accurately, as lies within one alignment-step of herself, should be Erecura, who dwells within Dis and hopefully won't make a fuss about keeping some things secret.  Cheliax can at least get a message to Erecura.  It's already on its way, in fact!  Sending messages to Hell is cheap; getting information back is the expensive part.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh neat, they have a literal god of avoiding catastrophes. That...kind of explains some things about how this universe still exists and, like, contains a Civilization that's even functional enough to have the concept of trade, and a country with Governance sufficiently on top of things to immediately bring an otherworldly visitor somewhere secure and then bring high-ranked trusted people to answer her questions. 

(Merrin thinks this with some level of sarcasm, and has no intention of saying it out loud.) 

Gods...can apparently also 'dwell', whatever that...means...for gods - Merrin isn't sure whether to interpret it as mainly an area-of-influence thing or that they have quasi-physical bodies there - areas outside of the afterlife that their alignment would otherwise predict. Weird? She would not have seen that one coming? In her notes that one gets a special shorthand symbol meaning that there are almost certainly further-reaching updates to propagate related to it. 

 

...They have a literal god of sadists and masochists. That probably ALSO explains some things about recent experiences Merrin has had. Maybe if she talks to Albe again at some point she will ask if Albe worships that god. Though Albe's afterlife-sourced ancestry was Chaotic Evil - but the options for gods there are Rovagug, which, just, no, and Dahak, who she knows nothing about except alignment - and that he helped trap (but not truly seal) Rovagug despite having the same alignment

"Is there...a known explanation for why 'honesty' and 'the Sun', or 'starlight' and 'travelers', are apparently obviously related to gods, in the same way that civic-order and promise-keeping are obviously related? ...Also is there a definition for 'unnatural prolongation of life' because I have no idea if modern medicine would count. And, domains for Calistria and Dahak and Gozreh?"  

Permalink Mark Unread

...because starlight travels from far away?  But by and large the answer is that the domains of gods are - maybe-vaguely-plausible-soundingly-connected to mortals, but really gods' domains tend to be god-concepts.

Unnatural prolongation of life: past when a person would otherwise have died of old age, and resurrection spells stop working on them.

Calistria:  Goddess of lust and trickery.
Dahak:  God of Evil-aligned dragons, where dragons are giant winged creatures who can grow to be very old and powerful.
Gozreh:  God of non-human-modified-environments, weather, and the sea.

Permalink Mark Unread

That is in fact what Merrin would have expected (that gods think and function using god-concepts, which don't necessarily map to human concepts. Though she slightly wonders if Baseline would have better words for talking about it, just because the difference in thinkoomph between the highest-ranked Keepers and Golarion gods is at least a bit less than the difference from the smartest humans here.) 

...She is now even more confused about the whole healing magic and resurrection thing, because 'when a person would otherwise die of old age' is not an ontologically basic fact, that doesn't even take especially advanced or heroic medical treatments - do blood pressure medications count as "unnatural" because for the relevant population that delays the negative health effects of aging by years. Egobar isn't a medical expert, though, so she'll put that down for later. 

Is it just her or is 'Evil-aligned giant winged creatures' way more specific than any of the others described? It...would fit better, at least in a vague and mostly narrative-based way, if Dahak were one of the younger and less powerful or far-reaching gods, but Dahak was described as being around in the very beginning of this universe and allying to stop Rovagug, so...she's still confused. Plausibly it's just because god-concepts are non-obvious, though, so she notes it down but doesn't actually ask. 

 

"What sort of interactions do the gods have with each other, excluding the very rare instances of fights like the one with Rovagug? Do they have trade - if so what do they trade in - do two gods in the same afterlife cooperate on work there? Which ties into my question about how and why Erecura ended up having a city in Heaven instead of - um, whatever the Lawful Neutral one is actually called - and whether things like that are at all common. ...I actually have quite a lot of questions about the afterlives in general but I'm not sure if you're the best person to ask since it's not all about gods." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Lawful Neutral is Axis.

Erecura, well, the term usually used is 'married', but that may not be entirely an accurate term, a godlike entity named Dispater who manages one of the layers of Heaven and is managed by Asmodeus.  The giant trading city is Dispater's.

Gods - communicate and trade and negotiate and bargain with each other all the time, to a much greater degree than mortals, in fact?  It's pretty rare to see one god doing something and another god opposing it; they would instead negotiate to the same predictable resolution and save themselves the energy costs of intervention and counterintervention.  This, however, tends overwhelmingly to cancel out and lead to gods mostly doing nothing, because action is expensive, easier to oppose than to initiate, and there's a lot of gods with opposed interests.  Their common interest tends towards matters like Rovagug staying sealed, and this, in fact, they have been pretty good at doing.

Asmodeus is a god who desires that mortals be wealthier, more civilized, more educated, more knowledgeable.  He has done something very rare among gods and sent forth resources out of Heaven for Cheliax, something that must have been incredibly costly to him within godagreements; Asmodeus has been able to do very little in the way of direct intervention in Cheliax since then, and indeed is probably less able to intervene in whole other planes, for having focused on Cheliax.  Cheliax owes Asmodeus a great debt that must somehow be repaid.

Asmodeus is opposed in such matters by Chaotic gods who feel that humans should be left to themselves and their 'free will', uh, ontologically-simple-decisionmaking-capacity?  If nobody opposed that sort of thing, it would have already happened ages ago.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh. Interesting. That...says a lot more about what 'Chaotic' actually means, here, than when the translation magic kept wanting to translate it as a preference for higher entropy. Also calls for a lot more thinking and processing before she decides on how to interpret it. Gets a priority-symbol next to the note and an underline. 

"...Huh. I - guess that's maybe what you would expect if you have very intelligent entities that can negotiate on action but can't - negotiate directly and come to a shared agreement about their alignment? I'm not sure why alignment is more fixed than that but it sounded like it is, and gods of differing alignments collaborating is mostly - finding shared ground despite the differences? So it'd be - easier to agree on things like 'Rovagug should not be allowed to destroy the multiverse' and harder to agree on 'mortals should be wealthier'. Also it sort of addresses my other question, about whether there are gods other than Asmodeus who - arranged to indirectly run countries through their clerics? I'm now going to guess not that much, because it's the kind of intervention where there isn't much common ground with gods of the opposing alignment and so it's expensive to negotiate for. Are there any others, though?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Some countries end up with the Churches of gods holding a lot of political power.  Even that describes Cheliax much better than describing Cheliax as a country run by Heaven or Asmodeus.  Cheliax is mostly governed by the Queen, a Chief-Executive-like entity named Abrogail Thrune Version Two, and heavily influenced by the Church of Asmodeus, which is mostly acting on its prior idea of what Asmodeus wants and only very very rarely is allowed any additional input from Asmodeus or even from Heaven.  Other countries have their own Churches; Osirion, for example, is heavily dominated by the Church of Gorum, god of banking.

Permalink Mark Unread

Their Chief Executive is version two. What. What happened to the version one???? ...Egobar is the person to ask about gods and not about non-god-related Governance matters. Merrin's notes are starting to again reach the point where paper is a very unwieldy user interface, but she takes ten seconds to find the right one and make a note so she doesn't forget to ask the expert on Governance in Cheliax about the version thing. 

"...Right. That makes sense. So the main difference is that Asmodeus is - sending resources directly from Heaven? What kind of resources - it sounds like information is hard to obtain even though I would naively have expected that to be the cheapest, it's certainly cheaper in dath ilan to move information long distances than physical goods. - Also, god of banking, huh, what alignment?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Gorum is Lawful Neutral!

Information is insanely expensive in terms of agreements between gods, that call for mostly leaving the mortal world alone.  All interventions are measured by impact more than by bulk weight.  Heaven has sent, for example, many copies of books about magic, for education, full of diagrams that are hard for Cheliax to print - but only knowledge within those books that was already in Cheliax.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Wow. That's...kind of counterintuitive but it does fit with the differences I already know about. I think. Heaven has better printing tech than Cheliax does?" 

If afterlives in general - or even just some of them, the ones where the gods value wealth and knowledge and Civilization - have a significantly higher tech level, then that ALSO has implications which Merrin was not previously taking into account. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...Heaven makes the books somehow.  How, if they have better printing tech, would be information.

Permalink Mark Unread

Huh. Okay, Golarion is kind of competent at information security. At least when it comes to keeping information from leaking out of entire other planes that are mostly under the control of gods. 

"Off-topic, but I might know some things about how to print books with complicated diagrams better and more cheaply. That– does that mean that there are communication restrictions on people who died here and are now in an afterlife, even if the magic would otherwise exist for them to talk to their families and such?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Yep.  People liable to be resurrected go to holding areas where they don't learn secrets.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Right. Um, do you actually know much at all about - what the day to day lives - not-lives, I guess - of people there look like, in general? Is someone who was a wizard or cleric while alive going to continue doing that - do people in other trades or specializations continue with that - oh, right, can children be born there or is that not a thing -" 

Permalink Mark Unread

...they know what life is like in the holding areas?  It's generally understood that things get more interesting outside the holding areas.  Mortals of Golarion do have some general ideas such as, for example, Elysium, the Chaotic Good afterlife, being an infinite wilderness that is really pretty, and it gets prettier and more complicated outside the holding areas.

Wizards need to retrain, or so one hears.  Clerics have finished out their term of employment and may enjoy whatever rewards are now due them for their mortal service.

Children cannot be conceived by the dead.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Wait does that mean actually infinite or is it the thing where people here tend to be really sloppy in their spoken reasoning, even when speaking Baseline which is a perfectly reasonable language for this, but maybe Taldane doesn't...actually have good vernacular words that distinguish infinities from 'just very very big'? 

Should she - ask - the way he's saying it makes it sounds like an afterthought and not something with enormous implications, which inclines her to think that it's a translation error or he's being sloppy. Also clerics apparently do not actually need to know a lot of math and if Merrin tries to ask he might just be confused. In which case she will inevitably end up confusing herself because those math classes were a decade ago; it's not exactly one of the branches of math that comes up regularly in her line of Exception Handling, and certainly not in more ordinary EMT work. She makes a note to herself to ask one of the wizard students later, if she doesn't get an opportunity before then to talk to a more highly trained wizard. 

"So - that makes it sound like economicmagic works there but differently. ...What happens if very young children die." This happens even in dath ilan, sometimes, which tries incredibly hard to avoid it; Golarion is clearly trying much less hard and also has a fraction of the total resources to point at it. "What about - if someone dies while pregnant, is the child born there? What if they're not the same alignment as the parent?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Fetuses older than twelve weeks have souls and sort as True Neutral.

If a soul dies that young, it can't get out of the Boneyard - the True Neutral afterlife - until they've, well, done at least a few things that give them an alignment?  They can leave right after that, but their alignment doesn't always match that of their parents, and... there isn't, often, a way to know which child's soul is which, they're not exactly labeled...

Obviously one tries to reduce child mortality of children too young to remember who their parents are, or which afterlife they should be trying to head for.  This isn't however the sort of place where you can throw effort blindly; the main thing that kills children, young and old, is not enough food and medical interventions without agricultural interventions probably just result in more starvation.  Also helpful might be some sort of solution for women having fewer babies than currently, if more of them are surviving all the way to adulthood.  Even in Cheliax that's not... really the sort of thing where you can just ask and be obeyed about it, people like having sex.

This is getting into matters of state, but even Iker has some idea of the chaos and disaster that would result inside Cheliax if suddenly more children were surviving all the way to adulthood, and farming yields were the same.  Everywhere else in Golarion it would be much worse.  The obvious order in which to improve things - he thinks, he's not a logistics-expert - is farming first, if Merrin knows anything about farming at all.

Permalink Mark Unread

(Merrin is temporarily distracted by the vivid mental image of not disembodied exactly, but dis-wombed fetuses - how does that work? What should she even be picturing here? A twelve-week human fetus...is still at the point where it looks as much like a weird translucent fish-alien as a person; it's not obvious to her why this is the point at which the fetus acquires a soul, she really does not think that 12-week fetuses are sentient. But, whatever, clearly the conceptualmagic here thinks it's an important cutoff for something. Does the Boneyard have artificial womb tech? Not that it would help if they do, given the intense information security precautions. Or do they not need it because 'dead' fetuses don't need continued blood oxygenation. Come to think of it do the afterlives have air and water - probably, they have cities, which at least implies they have matter that behaves according to similar physical laws... ) 

That's...really sad. She had already made herself sad thinking about more children dying in accidents, and - apparently she was somewhat misjudging the tech level, if they're at the point where insufficient food production is the main cause of death for children. She...doesn't actually know that much about how to judge what farming-tech would go along with a particular level of nice textiles and beds and such in the Governance headquarters. 

She is not going to do anything stupid that results in more children starving! She's read that novel! With aliens, not humans from a different Civilization, but same principle applies, it's - a pretty obvious unintended-consequence of trying to help without sufficient understanding of the situation to reason through all the possible consequences. She's faintly glad that they're being conscientious about making sure she doesn't do that, and also faintly frustrated that they thought she might? 

 

"That - makes sense. I know some things about farming, hopefully enough will generalize even if you have completely different staple crop plants. I...know some things about micronutrients and childhood nutrition that might be helpful independently of just increasing the total calories being produced by farms. I plausibly know more things about contraception, it's medical-related. Can you - do you know the average number of children per woman, and a breakdown of how many survive to various ages, including the ones that die before they're actually born? Also crop yields but I'll be less sure what to do with that, I do not have average agricultural productivity per acre or per worker memorized for various tech levels." 

Pause. 

"- Sorry, that's getting more into matters of state, if you don't know I'll write that down to come back to later." 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"I think you should, yes.  My guess is that they'll say they don't know, and ask you if you want to send someone to a random microcity and ask there, or find someone on staff who grew up in one."

"Thinking on it, I know that Cheliax after Heaven's intervention now has the highest proportion of non-farming population to farmers of any large region in Golarion.  A mere six-sevenths of our population, farming, suffices to support both themselves and the remaining seventh.  We are all very proud of it." It is clear from his tone that he does not expect Merrin to be impressed.

Permalink Mark Unread

She's not impressed, exactly, but she's...tentatively pleased that Heaven was apparently prioritizing this? It seems important. She would guess that requiring the vast majority of their population to be full-time agricultural workers would end up being the main limit on how many of them can train as wizards, or even clerics - half of the population can learn cantrips like Prestidigitation at all, but probably most of those would need months of practice - you could maybe get around that by trying to teach younger children, but younger children's brains won't be fully developed, they might not be able to learn it then even if they could as adults - though presumably they can teach the relevant math to younger children, as part of their overall education system...

(She makes a note to ask about the average age at which most people can actually start learning wizardry, and how they determine adulthood, and - hmm that leads into an enormous tangle of questions about families and schools none of which are related to gods.) 

 

"I appreciate that, thank you." One of the first things this place needs is basic information-gathering infrastructure, how is anyone supposed to make policy decisions if you can't measure the results of policy changes. "Anyway, I...think that's actually most of my questions about gods and afterlives, for the moment - or, well, I have a lot more but I expect all of it to fall under the information-security policies of the afterlives and gods so you won't actually be able to tell me. I - guess I'm curious which other gods are Asmodeus' closest allies, or - whether there are younger and less powerful gods that act in particular sub-regions of Cheliax?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Gods don't really have alliances; they can negotiate everything separately.  A frequent negotiating-partner of Asmodeus is Gorum, the banking-god who is very active in Osirion; though Iker emphasizes that not all Osirion's policies are Gorum's and certainly not all Gorum's policies are Asmodeus's.

There are no younger and less powerful gods operating in subregions of Cheliax; some subregions of Heaven are known to be governed by subordinates of Asmodeus that are as powerful as young deities, and they can if they choose grant divine spells.  Most 'clerics' just become employees of Asmodeus instead; you can advance further along that careerpathway.

Permalink Mark Unread

Does that include (Merrin checks her notes for the names) Erecura and Dispater? That they are theoretically the kind of entity a mortal not yet in the afterlife could pray to, and become a cleric and receive divine spells, but in practice they prioritize their efforts toward work in Heaven? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Correct!  There are known clerics of both Erecura and Dispater in Cheliax, though few of them.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Noted. Um, is there anything else I didn't know to ask about, but that you think I should know before I go off and think and end up drawing a bunch of conclusions about your world from what you just told me?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

If she's wondering whether something about gods makes more sense than is at first apparent, the answer is probably "No."

Permalink Mark Unread

WHAT IS MERRIN SUPPOSED TO DO WITH THAT ADVICE. 

There has to be an underlying fact of the matter about reality, here, that is coherent and holds together and would make sense if she had enough thinkoomph to grasp it? Which she probably doesn't, so there are going to be holes and it's probably less harmful to recognize her confusion than to try to oversimplify it into an approximation that she does understand, but Merrin is still not sure how to actually implement "don't expect important facets of reality to make sense" into her actual reasoning process!

"I'll...do my best to keep that in mind. Thank you. ...Oh, wait, one more question. Do you know anything more concrete on where the - younger, and less powerful, gods originated? Do gods grow over time and become more powerful and able to influence wider areas - in that case, did the borderline-gods also grow out of something that was definitely not a god...?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

It's Complicated.  Powerful beings who - this language doesn't have words - are then also emotionally related-to in the right way by many mortals, can sometimes rise to the status of being able to begin granting divine spells, or further increase in power if they already had that much status.  There's at least one case of, Iker is not necessarily personally attesting to the truth of this, he did not see it happen, there is allegedly a god on another continent, Lao Shu Po out of Tian Xia, who started as a rat and then ate the corpse of an ancient god.  This story would make more sense if gods were generally known to leave rat-edible corpses.  It's possibly metaphorical.  'It's possibly metaphorical' is something you end up saying a lot when you're reading about theology from other continents.

There's at least one way of becoming a god that, in Iker's own opinion, somebody else needs to make a judgment call about telling to Merrin, possibly not a call that should be made immediately.  Sorry, but she is a bit new to Golarion and not yet known that well.


(Testing the waters, here, Merrin's thought processes definitely suggest that she will take this sort of thing well.)

Permalink Mark Unread

(Merrin isn't very surprised to hear that, about this particular topic. Though it implies, maybe, that whatever the mechanism is, it's something that she could personally act on, and might be tempted to do without thinking it through. Either that or they're expecting it to be misleading and result in her being harmfully confused or wrong about something related to gods, or maybe related to alignments. Merrin isn't going to press him, at least not right now - she makes a note to check back in again later, in case whoever is responsible for making that judgement call ends up very busy and doesn't have the best project management system. She expects to be deeply unimpressed by the state of the art in project management and task-tracking setups in Golarion.)

(...She is also having a hard time not making guesses about it, even though she does, in fact, have some training in this; dath ilan expects most adults to at least imperfectly be able to choose to stop poking at a topic they're curious about. It turns out this is harder when she can't just fall back on trusting Keepers to be right. Merrin makes a deliberate effort to, instead, think about the rest and take notes.) 

Something feels oddly - circular, almost - about the claim that beings, if they have the right kind of - attention? attitude? - from enough mortals, can gain the ability to give those mortals spells. It sounds like...a setup that would result in positive feedback loops? Maybe that actually just fits, here - mortal-attention is a limited resource, edge case almost-gods must be competing for it, and the ones that succeed end up - more able to attract more of it, because they can now offer metaphorical employment? And then they would still be operating under all the constraints that come from having to negotiate their actions with all the other existing gods? 

The 'rat god' part is incredibly weird! At least Egobar is acknowledging the level of weirdness! 

 

"I understand that," she says finally. "Though I do want to check that it's someone's responsibility to follow up on all the things where a judgement call needs to be made on whether it's safe to tell me. I'm obviously trying to keep track as well, but I'm trying to keep track of a lot of things right now." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Any call I cannot make myself, as a 7th-circle employee of Asmodeus, would be referred to Aspexia Rugatonn or Abrogail Thrune Version Two, or at final need to Heaven."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Good to know. Right now I have been approximately thinking of Aspexia Rugatonn as a dath ilan Keeper and Abrogail Thrune Version Two as the Chief Executive of Cheliax; I'm guessing that won't result in me having perfect guesses about which one of them would be ultimately responsible for a particular question or area, but it's probably faster for me to ask and update over time than to try to get a full explanation from you right now." 

Also she's pretty sure that next up would be talking to a different expert about the non-magical Governance of Cheliax and its policies. Merrin wishes she were looking forward to this more. It's important and in normal circumstances it would also be interesting but she's feeling very information-overloaded. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Should I tell them to send in the next expert, or would you rather - go off and think and end up drawing a bunch of conclusions about our world?  Though I see little need for haste on that last task; I would mostly expect Golarion to still be here the next morning, if you want to draw conclusions about it then."

Permalink Mark Unread

He would mostly expect– he's almost certainly not saying this in full seriousness, because what, and also Golarion has been around for a long time despite the existence of a powerful entity that wants to destroy the multiverse and can still hire employees, and Merrin hasn't actually done anything yet such that she would expect her presence to change this. 

"Umm. I don't want to inconvenience someone who's already rushed here to talk to me, but I'm - not sure I can usefully take in more information right now, and I think I need to review my list of questions about Cheliax in light of what came up with you and Manohar and Albe. Do you happen to know who would be lined up next to talk to me, and how inconvenient it'd be to move that to later?" 

Pause. 

"- Oh, um, also. I - am not expecting this to work, but I wanted to check if 'clerics' also get the language-translation spells? And if so, whether there's - any downside risk I should know about for, um, attempting to mentally contact them about 'clericing', other than 'it doesn't work' which is the outcome I'm expecting. The language barrier is pretty inconvenient," especially if she wants to have a social life in addition to a series of interviews with experts, "and if it's not actually risking a bad outcome, it seems worth trying just to check." 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

She wasn't expecting that.  Why wasn't she expecting that?  Probably because anybody who understood what a god was and what a cleric meant wouldn't try to become one just for the translation spells the same day they got to Golarion -

No, set that aside, think quickly about how to respond -

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"Gods do tend to choose those suited to them, usually.  I think in this case you would be relying a lot on the god to know whether you were suitable; you do not really know enough about any of these gods, even Asmodeus, to make that decision for yourself.  I agree that this is unlikely to work, especially given the barrier about you, but there is not obvious harm in trying so long as you avoid calling out to, say, Rovagug.  It is possible to stop being a cleric if you decide you don't want to be one."

Permalink Mark Unread

 

...because in the unlikely event it does work, Merrin trying this earlier and while knowing less seems more likely to land her with Erecura.

Permalink Mark Unread

Nod. "I am not intending to try to get Rovagug's attention and I doubt it would work anyway since I am very much not in favor of the destruction of the multiverse. Just to check, it's not - ruining any chances I might have for later, if I try now while I don't know enough about the god or gods that might actually think I was suitable?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

As a priest of Asmodeus, Iker Egobar is thoroughly versed in giving spiritual advice of the quality that Cheliax demands.

"No," he lies.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Right. Okay. I...am inclined to think that I got enough bits and pieces about my other Cheliax-related questions to go on for now, and I'll be able to make better use of an expert's time once I've reviewed all that." And once her brain is less tired. The nice thing about plan: attempt to mentally contact some gods for potential metaphorical employment offers, is that it can be done in her room. "Also, what time is it locally, actually?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

As a spellcaster, Iker of course has a pocketwatch about him - a lightly enchanted one, in his case, so that it doesn't shatter at the first hint of strife.  He takes it out and checks it.  "The seventh bell and three-quarters," he says.

"- that is, if the day were divided into twenty-four parts, we'd be seven and three-quarters of those parts past roughly the time when the sun is highest, though that varies by the season, and at a time of year when that means night has already fallen, and dawn will come in about eleven more of those twenty-fourths."

Permalink Mark Unread

Right, meaning that if Merrin wants to get sufficient sleep before dawn - working on the assumption that the light-blocking on the window might be insufficient compared to what she's used to - she should be trying to go to sleep in two or three twenty-fourths-of-a-day. 

...She has no idea if days are the same length here as in dath ilan, and she's not sure if she would have had anything to notice and be confused about earlier if they're in fact significantly longer or shorter. There was a time-unit earlier that did translate sort of helpfully? 

She would be more surprised if it turns out humans here need a lot more or a lot less total sleep than in dath ilan. "Um, I think that probably means I don't want to do more work-type things today, and would prefer to talk to experts in the morning. It might or not mean I also don't want to do non-work things like socializing with the wizard students who came along." Or maybe Albe will show up and flirt with her some more Merrin is not going to do anything to pursue that further until she's less confused about this entire world. "In about how many twenty-fourths of a day would someone usually go to bed, if they were intending to be awake at dawn?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Wizards require a minimum of eight hours of sleep to restore their ability to prepare spells.  Others can sometimes get by with less, but he would not, in Merrin's case, particularly advise it right now.

Permalink Mark Unread

“…I probably don’t want to do anything else tonight, then, including socializing.” Which is disappointing because she had been hoping to wade through some of the early getting-to-know-people awkwardness as soon as possible. Right now it feels like she doesn’t know the wizard students at all. The person she feels closest to friendly with here is…Albe, who seems likely to be busy most of the time. “I would like to go back to my room, and - probably get some food?”

Permalink Mark Unread

That can almost certainly be done but it's Negotiations' job.

Iker will hand her off to Antonio, who'll conduct her to her bedroom.  Some plain and simple (expensive Palace-grade) warm food starts on its way to her.


(In retrospect Cheliax sort of regrets establishing this low bar on what it takes to get the good food and accomodations, but they thought they'd be able to torture her back then.  Oh well, she seems like a diligent Lawful Good type, they just need to make their goals seem like the Good thing to do.)

Permalink Mark Unread

That's a slightly annoying communication hurdle but probably the worst that might happen will be someone showing up at her room and informing her that they actually need answers to more questions from her and think it's time-sensitive. They're presumably not going to organize a party that she actively doesn't want right now? 

(Merrin has been wondering a little if, at some point, they're going to prefer that she - pay for her food and accommodations here? In which case she would have to negotiate getting paid for whatever services she can provide that they consider most valuable, which sounds tiring and she's out of practice at it, but she won't protest if that happens. Just quietly hope that they'll decide it's more work on their end too.) 

She thanks Iker for his time, and heads back to her room to flop on the bed, with only the red lights on so she can start coaxing her circadian rhythm toward sleep soon, and thinks about gods. 

Permalink Mark Unread

An organized list of all the gods who have been described to her: 

 

Ancient and powerful gods who fought Rovagug:

Asmodeus (Lawful Good) - domain is civic-order, education-and-training, promise-keeping, having a place in society that is yours. 

Pharasma (True Neutral) - domain is afterlives and sorting dead people into the correct ones? 

Gozreh (True Neutral) - domain is non-human-modified-environments, weather, and the sea.

Calistria (Chaotic Neutral), domain of "lust and trickery"

Dahak (Chaotic Evil), domain of "Evil-aligned giant winged creatures who can grow to be very old and powerful."

 

Ancient and powerful gods not specified to have fought Rovagug: 

Urgathoa (Neutral Good), domain is: healing, honesty, and the Sun.

Unnamed Goddess (Lawful Neutral), domain is "preservation and catastrophe-avoidance."

Desna (Chaotic Good), domain is goddess of dreams and travelers and starlight.

Zon-Kuthon (Lawful Evil), domain is pain, worshipped by sadists and masochists.

Sarenrae (Neutral Evil), domain is gluttony and unnatural prolongation of life.

 

Gods not described as ancient or very powerful: 

Gorum (Lawful Neutral), domain is banking. Has a country (Osirion). 

Erecura (Lawful Neutral), domain is "secrets, subtlety, prediction"; has a physical domain in the Lawful Good afterlife, in a city/interdimensional trading center; doesn't usually choose clerics anyway. 

Permalink Mark Unread

....Okay, great, that's a lot. Who does she want to try contacting mentally in order to seek potential employment? 

 

It sounds like they need her to be - a good fit? But in a way that isn't so much about skills or natural talent, like what a dath ilani employer would look for; it's maybe not actually that good a metaphor. But the thing that Iker was trying to describe to her as "faith" made even less sense to her. 

She needs to be well-suited to a god, in - a way that probably has more to do with her fundamental motivations as a person than her education or past experience. 

Fortunately, Merrin thinks she knows quite a lot about her own fundamental motivations as a person. The place where she's guessing is when it comes to the gods, where she has much less detailed information and is filling in a lot of gaps with her best guess. But Iker seemed confident that she wasn't risking her later chances at "employment" by trying this now? It sounds like the failure mode is just that she can't get a god's attention via mental contact at all. 

 

It's still feeling very hard to make an organized list of which gods it's worth trying for at all, aside from a few obvious options - she should definitely attempt to reach Asmodeus, as the default god-employer in Cheliax, and Urgathoa, the one whose domain is healing. 

It might be easier to - go at this backward, and try to fill in the hypothetical god who Merrin would be best suited to, and then rank the gods that actually exist by similarity to the hypothetical? ....And, of course, she's been told there are thirty-plus gods, maybe up to three hundred if you consider the minor ones, so for all she knows there's one out there who would be more similar to the hypothetical than any whose names she knows so far. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin spends a while chewing on that concept. 

 

 

...Interestingly, she doesn't think the hypothetical Golarion god whom Merrin would be best suited to is necessarily a god of healing? It would feel more likely if she were still in dath ilan, but of course if she were still in dath ilan this question wouldn't be relevant at all. 

She's well suited to medicine, but only part of that is about fundamental personality traits; mostly it's the investment she's put in, and it's not clear that transfers to Golarion, or at least it may not transfer any more than the other knowledge and skills she absorbed just by existing in dath ilan. And Exception Handling isn't just about healing, and arguably isn't primarily about healing. It's...closer to the "preservation and avoiding catastrophe" concept. Which is very neat but unfortunately that goddess' name is secret. For...infohazard-ish reasons, maybe? Merrin is not sure she wants to immediately apply for metaphorical employment for a goddess whose existence has to be kept partially concealed. 

And - if it were purely her choice, which is the hypothetical she's trying for, she would want her life to be about more than just that. If all she cared about were avoiding disasters, no matter how low-probability, then - probably the right move would be to mostly not do things, here. Maybe learn more about the existing dangers - like Rovagug - and eventually, carefully, see if she can contribute to mitigating those, but if there's an existing ecosystem there it's going to take her a very long time to slot in. Coming from another world, one which almost certainly has a better education system, might help, but it might also just make her a scary-sounding employee to gamble on hiring. 

And...it's not really what she wants. Not in the ideal hypothetical world where doing more things could be done safely. She wants to learn magic and she wants to teach the locals everything she knows and she wants to keep learning, until she can be strong enough to handle this entire situation - 

Permalink Mark Unread

- actually, that's a useful prompt, because it feels closer to the core of what Merrin is desperately hoping for here. 

 

Golarion is different. The Merrin who existed in dath ilan doesn't fit, here, and the person she invested in growing up as, there, would be much less well placed to contribute here. Feeling sorry for herself about how she's lost everything and everyone she cared about is tempting but it won't help anyone, including herself. But especially everyone else in this world. 

And - it's very important to Merrin, it turns out, to be doing something to help. 

She was an adult in dath ilan. She doesn't feel like nearly enough of an adult to move forward from this. Which means she needs to - grow up. Again. More.

She can't– well, maybe, at some point, it will turn out that she can trust someone else's guidance, as to what she needs to do and what skills she needs to invest in and what kind of person she should be reaching and aiming to grow up into, this time. But it feels like it won't help, to keep holding out for that. 

There used to be an entire Civilization around her, and she could put weight on any part of it she touched, and she doesn't have that and won't have that. Not until and unless she can build it herself.

...At which point, Merrin suspects that she wouldn't actually need those supports, anymore? It would be nice, but she - can't be doing this imagining that someday she will teach someone smarter than her to be something like a Keeper and then it will be fine and like she's gone home. Merrin is fairly sure that that doesn't work unless she, herself, already understands and does the things that a something-like-a-Keeper needs to do. 

 

This is probably completely impossible, and obviously Merrin needs to be realistic in the sense that she needs to - know what's worth trying and what's the equivalent of walking off a cliff hoping she can fly, and if she fails then she needs to fail rather than accidentally causing huge amounts of damage.

But that's the attitude that took her through her training as an EMT and everything since. She didn't know, when she was starting down that path, if she could make it to the end. She's not sure anyone else knew either. It still didn't help to dwell on the possible worlds where she couldn't. 

 

So. 

She needs to become someone who can hold a shard of Civilization in herself and exist like that; she has to put weight on that, and not on people and institutions and infrastructure that existed before she was born and were built by people far smarter than her and that she can always trust more than she trusts herself. She needs to do that and then she needs to build on that shard and make it bigger. (And realistically if this is going to work she at some point needs to solve the antimagical effect thing and figure out how to make it worth Cheliax's while to offer her the various aspects of mental-capability-enhancing magic, or figure out how to do them herself. But that's tactical, not something she needs to plan all the details of just yet.) 

She needs to becoming something-like-a-Keeper, which is going to look completely different for Merrin than it does in dath ilan, probably, but it's the future still available to aim for. 

(Unless she can contact dath ilan with Golarion magic– but that's a small, quiet note at the back of her mind, it's not an important piece of answering the question currently live in her.) 

She needs to aim for that, and she...to her own surprise she wants to aim for something like that? In one sense it's a deeply weird and alien thing to try to do with her mind, it's becoming something that isn't Merrin-like at all, but...in another sense it feels continuous with everything in her life so far. There were problems that needed solving, and she wanted to help, and it was incredibly hard and the process of growing up enough to do it changed her, but she did it and it was good. She could dwell on how it feels unfair to have to do it twice, and without parents this time, but - it didn't feel unfair the first time, so what's different, really? 

Permalink Mark Unread

....You know, when you put it like that, it would be really incredibly helpful to be the "employee" of a god that was - about that.

Probably that god doesn't exist? It's pretty specific and it's very - dath ilan-shaped. 

Oh well. Merrin will flip through her notes, flopped on he stomach on the bed with her chin propped up on her elbows, and start eliminating the gods that are really very obviously not that, and trying to rank the remaining options. 

Permalink Mark Unread

The tiny fragment of Irori's attention called to this place would, under other circumstances, have turned away after the entity failed to actually request to be a cleric.

The tiny fragment of Irori's attention called to this place would not have noticed that the mortal originating the plea had a soul only a few hours old, because that requires a larger piece of Irori, staring harder, than is called for by someone thinking about being a cleric of Irori without actually asking.

Irori considers the whole clericing business to be weird enough in the first place, especially when it comes to Him, what with His being the god of people becoming strong enough to do their own thing without any darned gods' help.  He doesn't want more clerics.  He wants, ideally, zero of them.  A near-miss does not produce much questioning within a tiny fragment of Him.

The shell of divine antimagic around the mortal with Otolmens's signature all over it, on the other hand, is definitely enough for that tiny fragment of attention to forward its observations upward at an urgent priority.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin, who as far as she’s concerned has not actually started trying to open mental communication with anyone yet, has no idea she’s attracted the attention of any gods.

She is going to make a LIST.


Gods she can straightforwardly eliminate:

- Dahak. Chaotic Evil does not sound Merrin-shaped at all and the domain mentioned, "dragons", is absurdly specific, which is also the opposite of what Merrin is hoping for. 

- Calistria. Not quite as badly off, but Chaotic Neutral is also probably not very Merrin-compatible, and she is deeply ill-suited to lust and trickery. 

- Sarenrae. Mostly eliminated for the Neutral Evil alignment alone, but the domain is unappealing and not very related at all to what Merrin would want her domain to be. She's not sure that "unnatural prolongation of life" wouldn't cover better medicine, but either way it's very specific and definitely not what she would want to dedicate her career toward. 

- Gozreh. True Neutral seems difficult for a Merrin to grow toward, but mostly she's eliminating Gozreh for the utter lack of any positive appeal. The domain is...fine, she doesn't object to a god existing and having that set of concerns, but it's rather random and not related to any of Merrin's own life goals. Probably it's important that a god's mission and projects are more compatible with also pursuing one's own life goals. 

 

Gods she doesn't want to eliminate entirely but will put at the bottom of the list: 

- Desna. Chaotic Good is maybe something Merrin could be suited for in principle, for some interpretations of 'Chaos' and with enough personal growth in a very particular direction, but it doesn't feel like what she'd be suited to now. On the other hand, Desna's domain includes "travelers" and Merrin is certainly that, maybe that helps? 

- Zon-Kuthon. Merrin goes back and forth a bit on whether to eliminate this entirely based on the the alignment being literally as far as possible from what feels natural to her, but...the domain does in fact sort of include her? And maybe she got a questionable explanation of what Zon-Kuthon is about. She definitely got a short explanation. Attempting the mental contact seems like actually a reasonable test of whether that's the case and the actual Zon-Kuthon is better aligned with her, but she's still putting him near the end. 

- Erecura. Lawful Neutral is probably something Merrin can aim for at all, and 'predictions' as a topic - 'secrets' too, actually - might end up more relevant to her life if she really wants to try this "growing up into a weird Merrin-shaped sort of Keeper" thing. The rest of Erecura's description sounds...fine? Placed at the bottom of the list because Erecura is apparently not especially looking to hire any mortals and so Merrin isn't expecting this to work. 

- Gorum. She could theoretically make the alignment work, she thinks, but banking is very specific and not something where Merrin has any domain expertise and definitely not something she's excited to spend her entire career on. She'll still try at all, if she gets that far, since it would after all give her translation magic (maybe), and it's possible the state-of-the-art in banking here in terrible enough that even Merrin could contribute something. 

 

Actual shortlist: 

- Asmodeus. Very compatible on alignment. Seems likely to be looking out for mortals to "hire" here in Cheliax, so probably easier to get his attention? Merrin approves of civic order, education, and people keeping promises, and she would love to have a place in Civilization again, she just could use some support rebuilding it around her first. Which Asmodeus seems - pretty likely to be on board with? Merrin is very confident it would make Cheliax wealthier, if she could show them the pieces of how to be dath ilan and get Asmodeus' help in assembling those fragments.

- The unnamed goddess in charge of preventing catastrophes. The alignment seems workable, the domain is something Merrin cares about, is actively worried about in her current situation, and arguably has existing career experience in. Given the way Merrin intends to attempt this contact, she expects this not to work unless the unnamed goddess is...fairly Keeper-like. So that's a useful test, though of course the goddess might not want Merrin for other reasons. 

- Urgathoa. An alignment Merrin can work with, and a domain she approves of. She's worried it would be...not a good angle for growth, in the directiosn she most needs to grow in? But given that Urgathoa is a god, and she's modeling gods as much more like Keepers than any of the Golarion mortals, it might still be better than going at this on her own. Also, healing! 

- Pharasma. Probably won't want to employ Merrin but she's really cool so. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Aaaaaaand now it’s time to actually try this thing! 

 

Merrin feels very self-conscious, actually! She’s about to attempt some kind of telepathic communication with an alien entity vastly smarter than her, and make requests! 

Well, no one was concerned about her doing this, so probably if it doesn’t work it just won’t work but won’t actually waste a god’s time and resources?

So. 

Asmodeus, she thinks, as loudly and clearly as she can. I come from another world, which is worse than this one in many ways - we don't have afterlives for people to go to when they die - but in some fields it seems like we know a lot more. I don't know everything but I want to help Cheliax and Golarion as well as I can. 

I am told that you are the Lawful Good god of civic order and keeping promises and functional education and training institutions. Where I understand Lawful to mean - preferring order, following a decision process that can be predicted by others, that others can work with - I think it's related to what my world would call Coordination but I'm still guessing. And where I think Good means - caring about making Civilization better for the people living in it, and working toward that. 

I'm probably wrong about a lot of that. But I'm trying my best to figure it out. 

If I'm right, then the things that are important to you are also important to me, and I want to help, and if there's a way that I can work for - with - you to do that, then I want to. 

Permalink Mark Unread

That squirrel is praying to the 'Asmodeus' fake address wanting to do WHAT?  No, seriously, what is it saying there?  The squirrel seems sincere in its prayer but isn't within one alignment step of - and He can't make out literally any of the content of its prayer for clerichood except possibly something about making squirrels more predictable -

Is that an Otolmens intervention?

...why is this squirrel only a few hours old?  And apparently very mature for a squirrel being only that old?  Because that sounds useful if Asmodeus's other tame squirrels could figure out how to do it more.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin does her best to give it five minutes - actually five minutes, "by the clock" despite lacking an actual clock - before declaring that this is not going to work. She's not that surprised. Even if Asmodeus is paying relatively more attention here in Cheliax, it's probably not like he has any shortage of mortals to work. 

 

So. Goddess whose name she does not actually know, but who she does know is Lawful Neutral (again she tries to give her guessworked understanding of Law as clearly as she can), and who is responsible for preventing catastrophic events and preserving - the world, she's guessing? And keeping things stable and functional and safe for mortals to live in? 

Merrin, too, is in favor of this! She is aware that she is at a kind of high risk of destabilizing it somehow, due to coming here from an extremely different world and having no context on almost anything yet! She's being very careful, though, and she thinks she can make a case that her actual career training in her world of origin is somewhat relevant! On a human scale, obviously, and in a way that works in dath ilan, and she's almost certainly massively confused about what it means here. But she's hoping to adapt to living in Golarion, which is after all going to be her world now and almost certainly for the rest of her mortal life and very likely for the rest of whatever comes after that, unless it's somehow a fundamental property of dath ilani mortals that instead of going to afterlives they go to random other universes? 

Anyway she thinks it would probably help her prevent anything from going horribly wrong if she had some guidance here? So here she is letting the nameless goddess of things-not-going-wrong know that she would not mind becoming a metaphorical goddess-employee and sharing that mission with her? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is not nearly sufficiently in a state of constant low-grade panic, nor massive annoyance at other people making messes, to be at all legible to Otolmens.  Even if Merrin knew the syllables 'Otolmens', it wouldn't help; Otolmens doesn't particularly do the thing where she monitors mortal directions of attention for thoughts pointed at particular syllables.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin gives it a slightly shorter interval of time; it seems likely she literally can't get the attention of a Golarion god without knowing their name, and possibly the goddess whose existence might or might not be an infohazard doesn't...actually...make a habit of taking mortals as metaphorical-employees? Wouldn't be unreasonable on her part. 

 

Up next: Urgathoa! Neutral Good, which Merrin is pretty sure she can get along with! (She spends a while focusing again on her understanding of what 'Good' means here as an alignment.) Also: healing! Merrin is really in favor of that as a concept and has a lot of relevant knowledge of medicine and is just, like, generally strongly in favor of people being okay? She has a bunch of ideas for things she could theoretically do here in Golarion that are not precisely about medicine but would help more people be okay and not starving and things! 

Also honesty, which Merrin thinks is pretty important and also - good for her, as a person, she thinks she would be very well suited as an employee and very happy working for someone who cares about that. Also...the sun? Merrin has to admit she is not sure she sees the connection there, yet, unless it's that...plants photosynthesize and that's how crops grow and this is what results in the mortals of Golarion being fed and thus okay and not sick? Merrin is also in favor of farming being done well. She isn't an expert or anything but she knows some things. 

 

...Fundamentally she has to admit that she's probably very confused about a lot of what people have tried to explain to her and she's not at all claiming to understand what Urgathoa is working on, but given what she does know she's fairly confident it's something she could grow into, given time. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Urgathoa does not know what the ass is going on in Egorian right now, but She is not really the type to ask either Asmodeus or Otolmens for answers.

Urgathoa does cast a continuing curious gaze in this direction; that soul is very mature and tasty-looking for being only a few hours old.  If there's some reproducible way to mature souls that quickly, it would make for much more luxurious squirrel farming in Awaiting-Consumption; all those baby souls are sort of meh.

Permalink Mark Unread

Abrogail has an increasingly uneasy feeling about this whole process, but despite inventing Irori from scratch Merrin didn't actually get clericed by Irori, nor by Otolmens, whom it had somehow not occurred to Abrogail that Merrin might pray to... Merrin wasn't able to reach Sarenrae without knowing Her name, good, so things are still going fine, right?

All according to plan.  Merrin probably can't be clericed anyways.

Permalink Mark Unread

...She wasn't super expecting that to work. Urgathoa sounded offhand like a better fit for Merrin in terms of being a similar alignment, but of course she is probably still super confused about what the categories mean, and...she has to admit that, after thinking it through earlier, her heart isn't really in the prospect of spending the rest of her mortal life working on mostly just healing-related things. At least not without thinking about the broader picture for a few years. Presumably if this process doesn't result in anything, as she's basically expecting at this point, and in five years she's pretty sure that she should just continue specializing in the general healing-related field, she can try for Urgathoa again?

 

Next is: Pharasma, the one who created the afterlives. Who survived the destruction of her entire previous universe, and brought in some kind of vastly powerful artifact to make a new one from nothing (maybe? if that legend is true and if Merrin interpreted it right).

Who, most importantly of all, created a world where no one permanently dies. This is really superheated amazing. Merrin is incredibly impressed! She's not sure what god-psychology is like but - even for a god it must have taken something pretty extraordinary, to do all of that. Merrin is very, very, very in favor of the afterlives existing, even if they're not perfect - even if the 'Evil' ones are kind of terrible, probably - there would have to be a really horrifying implementation flaw before it could possibly shift Merrin's opinion here to anything other than 'this is the most important thing that's ever happened in Golarion.' 

Oh and then also Pharasma prevented the world from being destroyed by the god-or-other-entity that wanted to make that happen. Merrin: strongly in favor! It sounded vaguely like Pharasma coordinated the other ancient and powerful gods who participated in that fight. Also very cool. 

Merrin is pretty sure that she's not herself Neutral on either the Law/Chaos axis or the Good/Evil one, she's probably quite far away from the middle of that spectrum, but - if Pharasma wants or needs a mortal metaphorical-employee, and can find a way for Merrin to contribute, Merrin is very available. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Everything important must be sorted along a two-dimensional manifold into nine buckets.  This mortal does not seem very interested in sorting everything important into nine buckets.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin doesn't try for as long, this time. She isn't surprised that Pharasma would be not especially compelled by the promise of more mortal resources, and she would be even less surprised than with other gods, given how unimaginably long Pharasma has existed, if actually her sketchy and human-limited attempt to understand what Pharasma cares about sounds really stupid from the god angle.

She wasn't especially expecting this to work and the odds are only dropping as she gets further down her list. She's now through her shortlist entirely, and left with gods who are mostly in the category of "they seem fine in general but their thing is not really her thing." 

She's not about to just give up on it now, though. So. Desna! 

Chaotic Good. Good, Merrin is in favor, at least if she’s right that it means [her previous specification.] Merrin…is much less sure that she understands what Chaos means. She can’t say she is a fan in general of disorder or entropy, but someone also mentioned diversity. A world that can fit more different shapes of people seems like something worth aiming for - something she thinks dath ilan does aim for, but it’s hard to pull off. Merrin herself is pretty sure she would sort Lawful by this world’s standards but in her own world she was always weird. And always - chose to lean toward the unusual traits she has and skills she could develop. Honestly she has no idea if that’s related to ‘Chaos’ here, it’s not a violation of anything in her best understand of ‘Law’. If Chaos means - change, growing not just in a single direction but reaching for new ways to be - then Merrin thinks she is generically in favor, and this also seems super relevant to what she’s decided is among her highest priorities now. If Desna is a goddess who can help her grow up into a completely different sort of Merrin than she could ever have imagined being, that would almost certainly be helpful, and Merrin would want to help Desna achieve her goals in general.

As for specific domains: well, Merrin is herself a traveler, though an accidental one, and she is very very far from home right now.

Permalink Mark Unread

Aww, sorry, dear!  You look like a sweet thing but your alignment isn't close enough to Me.  Yet.

Desna might give you a minor blessing, possibly, depending on circumstances?  For you are a traveler out of dreams and greater distances than starlight.


But first She's going to ask Irori if Irori has any idea what's up with the Otolmens intervention, and also why He's watching this location so intently, along with Urgathoa and Asmodeus who are apparently having some kind of weird angry squirrel-watching contest.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well. That didn't work either. 

Merrin surveys the remaining gods on her list. She...is really not very hopeful. But she's finding this process overall to be surprisingly helpful, for herself? It's a neat exercise in introspection, trying to look at herself and then look at (her best understanding of) a particular god and find the overlap and hold out those parts of herself as an offer? 

 

The main result is noticing that she really really wants there to be a god more closely pointed at - the thing she had thought of initially, but which she thinks is clearer in her mind, now. That what she wants, what she needs, here, is to become an adult. She doesn't know exactly what that would look like, yet, because of course a child can't picture the details of who they'll be when they grow up, and if they could then they're already halfway there, right. She's going to have to walk that road, one step at a time, and find out. But she knows what direction she's aiming toward. 

...What alignment would that god be?

Merrin...suspects they would be Neutral on the Good/Evil axis. She isn't, and she doubts that she would ever be, but the process of growing into something stronger is, in some sense, agnostic to what you want to do with that strength once you have it. And - the skeleton of the Civilization she wants to rebuild, the math of Coordination, is...maybe not in itself Good either? Merrin - has the sense that among dath ilanis, she is very unusually driven by intrinsic desire-to-help. She learned the math (sometimes under duress, when she was very little and had fewer coping skills around doing things she was visibly slower and worse at than the average student near her, and thus a DISAPPOINTMENT), but she learned it because that was a prerequisite to being an adult, to being strong and competent enough to help

(Merrin's teachers had a time trying to get her to ever defect in cooperation-defection-dilemmas.) 

But at this point she sees on a deeper level why it's important. And that's - probably 'Law', here? So. A hypothetical Lawful Neutral god, maybe. Possibly the 'constantly growing and changing yourself toward greater strength and maturity and capabilities' would be classified as Chaos, here? Poooooossibly. Merrin kind of doubts it, if only because the spell's initial wrong attempt at translation into Baseline is so much the opposite of what she has in mind. 

Merrin takes a deep breath, and decides that when she's done here, she's going to go ask someone if a god sort of like that exists. She's still not hopeful; it still feels very dath-ilan-shaped, not Golarion-shaped. There's probably no point in trying harder for that god's attention right now, she doesn't know their name or even their main domains, she just has a vague bundle of thoughts. Might be worth trying anyway though, before she jumps to bothering someone about it? 

(Another implication: if it turns out a god like that does exist, then Merrin probably has some updates to make about Golarion? She would be confused, if a god like that exists, and that would mean that she's missing something.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

But first she's going to finish her list! It almost certainly won't work but it continues to be a useful introspective exercise, and maybe even moreso for gods where she really has to stretch to find any overlap with herself. 

So: Zon-Kuthon! 

Merrin knows very few things about Zon-Kuthon and expects the parts she's missing are really important. Lawful Evil: Merrin can work with the Lawful (she holds up the mental specification of it again). It's actually starting to feel a little bit, at least in her own haphazard guesswork sense of 'Law', that maybe on a fundamental level what Law means is that Merrin can work with it. 

She is probably not very Evil but if Albe's description of it holds, then maybe there are some particular aspects of her that are. When Merrin is on a date with a boyfriend, she is super not working for the benefit of Civilization. That's for her. And maybe if both of them are Lawful then she doesn't need total overlap. 

She is a masochist. She doesn't think that she's particularly a sadist but Albe seemed to think it was feasible for a person to explore both and she isn't sure that's false? Presumably Zon-Kuthon is the expert on this topic. It's actually kind of cool that there's a god in Golarion who is the expert on this topic! Maybe this is why the concepts aren't considered infohazardous here? That would also be pretty neat. Merrin wasn't especially fond of having this small but important part of herself and her life that she couldn't talk about with anyone except Keepers and boyfriends. She doesn't like having to hide things. 

She...isn't totally sure how sadism and masochism are a route toward growing up and becoming strong enough to accomplish everything she wants to accomplish in Golarion without breaking anything by accident.

(If it turns out that she can grow up into the perfect adult via the Power Of Masochism then that would be hilarious and - feels like the sort of thing that would be a fiction trope - not one that Merrin herself is familiar with, in fiction she's read, but there does exist fiction in dath ilan about sadists and masochists, written by the people who know about that, for the others to read. Merrin hasn't read it, on the general principle that she doesn't want to end up exposed to all the things and then get bored, and also because she super doesn't have time for any more leisure reading. But. Fine, okay, if Zon-Kuthon is able to take her on as a metaphorical-employee then Merrin will consider that evidence toward some kind of fiction-trope-driven selection on her having ended up here at all and maybe evidence that it's a Romance and she is going to end up dating Albe and then dissolving her antimagical field by fully awakening her sexuality that is NOT ON TOPIC she is doing a metaphorical god-job-interview right now and her brain can stop that.) 

Anyway, she - thinks she is probably not a good enough fit for Zon-Kuthon to want to make her a 'cleric', but if it turns out she's wrong then - well, she would be confused and have additional questions but she wouldn't say no? 

Permalink Mark Unread

What a curious and interesting situation, being stared at by so many gods.

Zon-Kuthon would not ordinarily look at anything so curious and interesting, these qualities being repulsive for themselves.  But He is unfortunately Lawful and sane - He could not otherwise be the greatest possible desecration of all Dou-Bral is and hoped to become - and so for instrumental reasons He will nonetheless examine this situation, to see if there is value here to be destroyed.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well.  Isn't that fucking wonderful.

Irori was not going to ask this.  Usually Irori doesn't even try asking questions of Asmodeus, unless Irori has an informational advantage or Asmodeus is unlikely to have one, because Asmodeus is an absurdly adversarial negotiating partner.  And, in fact, Irori is not offering to pay for this information.

But now that actual fucking Zon-Kuthon has shown up to this party, would Asmodeus possibly care to explain what's going on in the heart of His power in Golarion?  By way of it being in Asmodeus's interest to cheaply refute any speculations that the other parties might have here, about some dangerous plan of Asmodeus's involving Zon-Kuthon, which other gods should perhaps expend energy to halt?

Dou-Bral fought Rovagug, Zon-Kuthon may well be only biding His own time about that, and there is an Otolmens intervention here.

Permalink Mark Unread


...it's probably That Squirrel again.

Permalink Mark Unread

'That Squirrel', hm?

Permalink Mark Unread

 

The one who Asmodeus personally compacted with to tyrannize His mortal domain of Cheliax.

That Squirrel is often useful, clearly very useful on net, but it's not all that obedient.  Asmodeus has a hard time seeing its thoughts clearly.  Some of what That Squirrel does is frankly more the kind of planning Asmodeus associates with Chaotic Good rather than Lawful Evil.  Asmodeus wishes He could replace That Squirrel with a more tyrannized and obedient one whose thoughts He could see at all.  But such understanding as Asmodeus has managed to obtain of squirrel psychology seems to suggest that the huge successes of That Squirrel are not entirely uncorrelated with the difficulty Asmodeus has in reading it.

Any results this weird are probably That Squirrel's doing.  Asmodeus would have guessed so even if That Squirrel wasn't standing very close to the anomalous squirrel.

Permalink Mark Unread

That's not as reassuring as Irori was hoping for.

Permalink Mark Unread

The compact That Squirrel has with Asmodeus does require it not to act against Asmodeus's interests.

Or at least Asmodeus thinks so.  He can't properly read the mortal language of the compact that a devil negotiated to specify That Squirrel's duties, and that devil was deemed by its own superiors to have screwed up and was severely punished as a result.

But anyways it still seems pretty unlikely that the destruction of Golarion, or even the risk of such, is being deliberately plotted by That Squirrel.  It's probably just being weird again.

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay, if nobody important seems to object to Desna doing so, she's going to tap this far-traveling squirrel out of dreams with a Comprehend Languages blessing for one year -

Permalink Mark Unread

Asmodeus objects.

Permalink Mark Unread

Desna said, anyone important.

Permalink Mark Unread

Let Asmodeus be more specific.  Asmodeus is going to block this intervention.

Permalink Mark Unread

Why?  It looks to Desna like this would probably facilitate whatever Cheliax is trying to do with the anomalous squirrel, which can't otherwise use most means of understanding its hosts due to Otolmens's anti-magic shell.

Permalink Mark Unread

Being dependent on its hosts for translation will help keep the anomalous squirrel weak and controllable.

Permalink Mark Unread

The anomalous squirrel is in the heart of Cheliax.  It's not going to hear or encounter any information that Asmodeus's tame squirrels haven't selected for it.  It's not going anywhere that Asmodeus's tame squirrels don't consent to take it.  Desna's intervention will only enable that squirrel to wonder more effectively at the strange world she is in and experience more of it.

Permalink Mark Unread

Asmodeus could, of course, be paid to accept this.

Permalink Mark Unread

Or Desna could keep paying attention to this situation until Asmodeus stops paying attention and then intervene anyways.

Permalink Mark Unread

Even for Chaotic Good, that's some pretty low behavior Desna is trying to threaten there.  The squirrel is cleric to neither of them; neither can watch it easily or cheaply.  Both of them having to burn expensive attention on opposing each other is exactly the kind of stupid situation that negotiations between gods are meant to avert.  If Desna insists on trying it anyways, Asmodeus will of course do His own foolish part in playing out that mutually harmful counterfactual, at least until Desna has lost more than She could possibly hope to gain by threatening Him so.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, Desna was feeling quite curious about this situation anyways, and would probably go on watching for a time regardless.

Permalink Mark Unread

Then Asmodeus will set a small fragment of His attention to go on watching while Desna squirrel-watches here - obviously with much more of Her attention than His, if Her claim just then to be separately interested was at all true.  Asmodeus supposes that in due time, once Desna has burned more of Her attention than She could reasonably hope to gain from not paying Him off, He might accept His allegedly inevitable loss as real and permit Desna's intervention to go through.

Permalink Mark Unread

All right, going on the ordering Merrin declared, she should be trying Erecura next.

This is not the most surefire plan that Abrogail has ever tried in her life, admittedly.  She's not even going to dignify it with an arrogant declaration that it can't possibly fail.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Apparently she is not enough of a masochist to be interesting to the god of masochists and Merrin feels slightly disappointed and competitive about this and Merrin is not actually surprised and it's not like she wanted that to be her main job anyway. 

Two more on her list and then she'll try telepathically communicating her metaphorical resume to the god who might or might not even exist that shares her main driving motivation here, and then she'll maybe or maybe not actually have the energy to go ask someone if that god exists and has a name, and THEN she can SLEEP. This is a fascinating exercise but Merrin is starting to feel pretty exhausted. 

 

Next up on her list: Erecura! 

Merrin appreciates that Erecura is not really targeting this metaphorical-hiring-mortals thing but she is submitting herself for consideration anyway. Erecura is Lawful Neutral and, especially given her most recent thoughts, Merrin is pretty sure she can work with that without it even requiring much reshaping-herself.

Erecura's domains are (checks list) "secrets", "subtlety", and "prediction." On reflection all of those actually sound pretty key to Merrin's goal of growing up toward something more like a dath ilan Keeper. She doesn't really like secrets, as a concept, it's a lot of extra mental overhead and back in dath ilan she was content to let other people have that problem, but it seems likely that she's going to have to address that aversion, here. There are already things about dath ilan, and thoughts or theories she's  that she's been worried about explaining to Golarion natives. And - there are secrets of Golarion that people are currently hesitant to share with her, for obvious reasons, but it seems very important that she grows toward becoming someone who is trustworthy to know those secrets, because she has to understand what she's working with in order to make plans that will succeed. 

Subtlety. Merrin is...actually pretty unsure how accurate the translation to Baseline is, for this concept, but it's true that reality is subtle and confusing. 

Predictions. Making accurate predictions about what will happen in the future or as a result of her actions is really really critical to Merrin succeeding at anything she wants to try. She really misses prediction markets as a thing. Does Erecura know what those are? That would be pretty neat. Or maybe gods do a completely different thing that serves a similar purpose and that would also be really neat. 

Erecura chose to 'live' in an afterlife plane not of her own alignment. Merrin is fascinated by this, and so curious. And the fact that Erecura - who is Lawful Neutral and (maybe, if Merrin is interpreting any of this correctly) sort of pointed in the direction that Keepers are - chose to do her work in the Lawful Good afterlife, seems like an indication that she might be even more compatible with Merrin here than appears at a first glance? Merrin is also intrigued by the 'interdimensional trading center'... 

 

 

Anyway. Merrin wants to grow up into the kind of adult that can build her own Civilization in another world, from the fragments she carried with her, and Erecura may or may not care, and may or may not be able to help, but Merrin is going to hold up that destination in her mind and - if Erecura is interested in metaphorically hiring her on that basis, here she is. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Surrounded by secrets and bearing secrets herself:  Check.

Out of her natural place in a horrifically hostile and adverse environment:  Check.

Pretty darned obsessed with predicting the future, and skilled and wise thereof, even by the standards of the average Erecura worshipper:  Check.

Within one step of Lawful Neutral:  Check.

 

 

Erecura is, however, a Lawful Neutral god, and though not as obsessed with coordination as one of those, it is nonetheless Her privilege to trust and be trusted among Her own kind.

My fellow Lawful Neutral god who was once human, who never touched the Starstone, did You want to discuss this one?  I could take her now, but she seemed like she was about to try calling out to You.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Irori would also be interested in having this one as a cleric, yes, if she actually asked Him.  She is not as driven as some, but she has a far better concept of perfection than many.

But it's obvious that somebody in Cheliax is messing with her, presumably the one Asmodeus calls 'That Squirrel'.  If Erecura doesn't answer her now, it's not clear to Irori that she will in fact be permitted by her strange surroundings to successfully call out to Irori.  She might do better with Erecura as a patron within Cheliax.

Permalink Mark Unread

So You won't pay Me not to take this one, then.

Permalink Mark Unread

Nice try but nope.

So was Erecura in fact interested there?  Because if not, Irori is totally taking this one.

Permalink Mark Unread

Otolmens, My fellow Lawful Neutral god also in adversity, Your aura is about this one.  Do You say nay to My clericing her?

Permalink Mark Unread

What EXACTLY does Erecura want with the anomaly?  WHY would She want to cleric it?  Will clericing it somehow help keep it CONTAINED?

Permalink Mark Unread

I could withdraw those levels did You bid me do so; and if I do this it may help this one contain any dangerous secrets that she may have about her.  She did think that she might have such secrets to keep; and called out to me to aid her in becoming a keeper of secrets, one who controls and contains dangers herself.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

FINE.

 

Any subsequent WEIRDNESS having to do with this mortal being a CLERIC will be definitely Erecura's FAULT, and will be described as such in the next set of URGENT REPORTS that Otolmens will soon be submitting to PHARASMA.  Otolmens hopes that Erecura is duly warned about this SCARY FACT.

Permalink Mark Unread

Of course, Otolmens.

 

Boop!

Permalink Mark Unread

- aaaaaaaah a thing is happening????

 

 

Merrin is pretty sure a thing is happening? Maybe she's imagining it and it's just that doing this mental exercise for extended periods of time produces an altered state of consciousness??? 

But what it FEELS like is - suddenly there's something there. It feels like brushing up against something so vast that she can't actually see it at all, but can still - notice that she herself is being seen, and - recognized, understood, welcomed - 

 

 

IS THIS WHAT IT FEELS LIKE TO BE HIRED BY A GOD??? In hindsight she should maybe have...asked someone what to expect...before attempting this? 

She takes a deep breath and then very tentatively tries to reach back. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Being not a god herself nor much skilled in Erecura's ways, Merrin is not ready to hear very much that Erecura has to say; and it is not in any case Erecura's way to disclose secrets lightly.  The brief feeling that Erecura sends back, if it could be put into words, might say this:

Keep your secrets well, survive far out of your place, and grow wise.

Only for a moment does that feeling appear, and then the Presence recedes.


(Merrin's thoughts can still be read, for the most part, but not those upon matters which Merrin thinks to herself ought to be kept secret.)

Permalink Mark Unread

 

All right, let's be honest here, she can't fucking believe that actually worked.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

 

 

 

- okay she was DEFINITELY NOT imagining that! She is - probably a cleric now? Maybe? This is amazing! She was super not expecting that to work! 

Permalink Mark Unread

- wait, what? 

Is Erecura - she's assuming that was Erecura - trying to warn her that she has more secrets than she realized? That the secrets she's been vaguely worried about are more dangerous than she had realized? This is kind of incredible as a thing to happen but vague not-in-words sense that came across just now was not reassuring. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin spends a minute or two just absorbing all of the !!!!!!???? that her brain is producing. She is now a metaphorical-employee of the god who approximately doesn't work with mortals in the mortal plane? Why? She is so incredibly not complaining but she's pretty confused! 

Permalink Mark Unread

She is incredibly not sleepy now and, after a couple of minutes, scrambles up and heads to the door and opens it. "Um, hello, is anyone around...? I think I might have just had Erecura make me a 'cleric' and it would be helpful if there were a way to check that?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"I'll pass that on and have somebody come by to check right away," says a Security outside the door who looks frankly shocked by this, though not at all displeased.  "Congratulations!  Erecura doesn't choose many clerics, even in Cheliax!"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I heard! I'm actually really curious about why!"

Actually her current best guess as to why is that actually a much wider swath of facts about dath ilan are somewhere-in-the-realm-of-infohazardous for Golarion or for Cheliax specifically and this is pretty scary! She does not feel like she got any actual concrete advice from the god who is now her metaphorical employer! 

Maybe it's not that? Maybe it's that Erecura - wants her to reinvent prediction markets here? That would be way less stressful. But on the general principle of caution, Merrin is going to work on the assumption that it's the first one. Aaaaah. 

 

...This is not actually enough aaaaaah to stop Merrin from grinning and slightly bouncing. 

Permalink Mark Unread

A cleric of Asmodeus arrives a few minutes later, looking a little out of breath, does the hand gestures to cast a spell, and a few moments later informs Merrin that she is indeed a 1st-circle cleric of Erecura!  One more powerful than an average new cleric, even!

Permalink Mark Unread

 

...which is much more terrible news than her subordinates seem to have realized, for keeping Merrin cooperative.  Now Cheliax is going to have to figure out something to do about all the books that Merrin will be able to read, and quite reasonably expect to be delivered to her on request, as soon as she prays for a Comprehend Languages tomorrow at dawn.

Abrogail is currently attempting to think quickly and creatively about how to avoid this blowing up their whole operation.  Send to Hell again and beg Erecura not to grant her new cleric Comprehend Languages?  Hope that Erecura works out why not to grant that spell?  Tell Merrin it's not 1st-circle?  Abrogail doesn't want to rely on Erecura knowing that much, caring that much, even if Hell can get a message to Her in time... what now, they can't possibly write as many books quickly enough as Merrin would expect to exist if they weren't being hidden from her...

(Not that Abrogail regrets her previous life choices about her cunning plan.  Irori or Sarenrae would obviously have been a lot worse.  But in retrospect she should've planned more around the chance that Merrin could be a cleric despite the antimagic shell, and maybe not shown Merrin so many books inside her room, implying that they can't claim books are incredibly expensive and all Cheliax doesn't have that many...)

Permalink Mark Unread

Wow! Merrin is so delighted about this! She also has so many questions. It takes her a few moments to put the questions in order so that she can say them at all. 

"Thank you! I, um - what causes clerics to be more or less powerful than average? What do I need to do to get the spells?" 

(She almost asks if it's normal for gods to give new clerics messages, and then remembers that if it's the case that the message was because a lot of things about dath ilan are more dangerous to Golarion than she had previously realized, she should definitely not say that, just on general principle.) 

(Also, while Merrin is having this train of thought, her thoughts are briefly blurred out to Detect Thoughts if anyone is actually attempting that.) 

"- Um, also I don't actually know more than a handful of things about Erecura? I can infer some more just from the fact that my attempt to contact her worked and that I'm apparently well-suited enough to be her cleric, but I would feel way more comfortable with this if I had the full overview." 

Permalink Mark Unread

WHY DID HER THOUGHTS BLUR OUT LIKE THAT.

...Erecura.

Oh no.  No no no.  Somebody resend that message to Hell at higher priority, get Dispater to tell Erecura what's going on!

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Even most theology experts don't know that much about Erecura!  She's one of the most mysterious goddesses out there!  As you might expect from the goddess who governs specifically over secrecy!  But they'll try to get more information as it's available.

They mostly meant that Merrin is more powerful than most first-circle clerics are, starting out, meaning that Erecura probably wanted to boost her up more than usual, as might usually require a longer service.  Merrin will also be more powerful than usual if she has more of a trait called Wisdom, which she probably has at least some extra of?

Merrin can pray for spells at dawn - she figures out which first-circle spells she wants, probably to a maximum of three or four, and then tries to send her mind in Erecura's direction and thinks about how she will serve worship is aligned with Erecura's interests and intends to help out, while requesting those spells.

Describing all the first-circle cleric spells will take a while, but somebody could be brought over to describe some of the more interesting and useful ones for Merrin?  Cure Light Wounds is probably the single most famous first-circle cleric spell, though not in very high demand within the Palace in Egorian.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin kind of still wants the complete list at some point anyway; her plan was to test as many of them as possible, though at 3-4 per day that’s going to take ages and might not be her highest priority. Is there one for perceiving magic, like what wizard students do? Also what about the translation one - it might be the one from before where people could understand her but not talk. This would still be incredibly useful for Merrin, to be able to understand Taldane directly, even if it meant other people had to have their own translation magic to understand her answers in Baseline.

Permalink Mark Unread

There's a first-circle cleric version of that spell, yes, though it's not quite the same as the wizard spell, and how powerful it is depends on the level of the caster.  It'll last for 10-20 minutes at Merrin's current power level - if it works right for her at all, with that antimagic nature of hers, which hasn't really been tested yet.  Even if it works, though, it sounds like they should mainly go with... whatever other approach Negotiations was planning to use for that before she got clericed, considering that it wouldn't work through the whole day?  It also isn't likely to work for reading books, at Merrin's current level for casting the spell; but Negotiations can give a low-paid-employee a Tongues item, and let them translate anything that Merrin gives them advance notice on wanting to read.  Or at least, that's what the cleric would guess Negotiations was previously planning on doing.

The cleric of Asmodeus thinks from her examination that Merrin might possibly have been granted a very rare ability called 'channeling positive energy' which lets her heal injuries up to a certain level on everybody in a 30-foot radius, multiple times per day - three to six times, maybe, it depends on the person.  If Merrin can do that, she might be able to do that right away, even before praying for spells, and that would test whether or not she can surpass the antimagical effect and do magic that affects things outside herself.

The Palace isn't in fact in immediate need of this ability; they have adequate healing capacity from the many clerics who are here, praying for ordinary healing spells.  But if Merrin really has that ability and is willing to use it on behalf of Cheliax at standard rates for not-on-demand healing, some people with relatively minor injuries who don't require immediate healing could get scheduled for a huge group session with Merrin instead, at regular times each day.  That would potentially replace a lot of individual curative spells from individual clerics, who could then pray for other useful spells instead!

...assuming Merrin can in fact do that, or affect anybody outside herself.  The cleric of Asmodeus apologizes for getting ahead of herself here, she was just excited.

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Oh. Yeah, I - think it'll be pretty useful even to have twenty minutes a day where I can understand your language directly - I can time the most important conversations for when I have that, and it'll give me any context at all on how Taldane is different and where the translation weirdness with Baseline is coming from - but I obviously can't rely on that for all the conversations I want to have." 

Pause. 

"- I'd like to test the 'channeling positive energy' thing as soon as possible," if only because she really should go to SLEEP soon and she's going to find that way harder if she still has an open mental loop about this question, "- also I'm incredibly curious why it's rare and why Erecura might've given me the really rare ability?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Probably it's rare because it's a big powerful power to have?  A channeler could, given appropriately careful packing of subjects, cure more people in six seconds than the most powerful non-channeling cleric could cure in a day, though only of light injuries at Merrin's present level.

The cleric of Asmodeus has no idea why Erecura would do that!  Except that Erecura is too mysterious, and even the gods too unable to forecast the future, for it to be anything as straightforward as 'there'll be some big accident at the Palace where Merrin has to heal everybody'.  Probably.

Anyways, she could grab a dagger from Security, give Merrin a very shallow cut that would heal naturally, stab herself a bit deeper than that, and they could try the thing!

Permalink Mark Unread

If they're going to do that test then Merrin definitely wants to have personally made sure that the Security's "dagger" is sterilized. Really she would prefer a medical scalpel but she's not expecting that to be available. Also she wants to make doubly sure that, if it turns out not to work, the cleric advising her can get a normal healing spell from someone else? 

(Why is it taken for granted that random staff will definitely have a sharp implement mainly intended as a weapon? This...seems like some additional information on - something - how dangerous Cheliax is, how useful sharp things are compared to magic - maybe most of the Security staff aren't wizards? But supposedly half the entire population can learn the most basic magic, and one would expect that the staff here at the heart of where Cheliax's Governance works to be much more selected than that...) 

"I - huh - yeah, that makes sense, if it's energetically expensive. But where does the power for doing that come from? There's a plane of positive energy, right? Albe said it's the raw form of the kind of energy that goes into healing spells, and - she was somehow able to pull up a ball of the raw energy, herself? But it sounds like the 'channeling positive energy' rare power is a lot more than that, so - does it take direct help from Erecura to do that? I guess that would explain it being costly for gods to give their clerics that ability." 

Though if so, it leaves her with even more confusion as to why Erecura invested in giving it to her. Erecura, who doesn't normally metaphorically-employ living humans at all. And who is apparently even more mysterious than most gods. Possibly Erecura's reasons for it are secret, but that doesn't exactly leave Merrin feeling LESS desperately curious, here. 

Erecura is also the goddess whose domain includes 'predictions', so - maybe she's actually better than the other gods at forecasting future events, and does have some kind of plan here - which Merrin is absolutely not going to succeed at guessing, she is neither smart enough nor well-informed enough, but Erecura - might nonetheless be able to predict Merrin's future actions well enough to know that whatever it is, Merrin will end up getting it right... 

(What a nervewracking thought.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

This particular cleric of Asmodeus is not senior enough to be able to answer any questions about how expensive it is for gods to give somebody the ability to channel Positive-plane energy into a 30-foot radius healing effect.  In general, the power to open the channel comes from the god, the power to shape that energy into healing comes from the god, but most of the energy per se is an evocation effect that floods down the channel.  Or at least this cleric thinks that's how it works.

The fact that Albe can do things should not be taken as an indication that they are easy to do!  Albe is an unreasonably elite consultant!  They wouldn't have handed Merrin off to her to be possibly flirted-with if they had normal Government employees lounging about who could easily do the same thing!

The Security will cheerfully sterilize their dagger with a dangerous-looking blue flame!

The cleric can heal herself if Merrin can't heal her.

Permalink Mark Unread

That...does work as a sterilizing method, albeit an unusual one by Merrin's standards! And the dagger is less awkwardly enormous for this purpose. Merrin folds up one of her sleeves - her shirt is designed to make this very easy to do, and for the shortened configuration to be aesthetically pleasing and also stay in place - and then accepts the dagger and carefully checks that the flat of the blade is in fact cooled down. She picks a spot on her forearm - one not close to any near-the-surface veins - and calmly gives herself a minor cut, apparently not perturbed by this at all. It's shallow enough that she probably won't bleed copiously and make a mess during the time it takes her to figure out this 'channeling positive energy thing.' 

"You should clean and re-sterilize it before using it on someone else," she says matter-of-factly, offering the dagger back to the Security. "As far as I know I do not have any bloodborne diseases, but just on general principle. I'm going to see if I can figure this out intuitively, if not I'll want instructions." 

If she stares at her arm and thinks firmly that she wants it to be HEALED via a burst of the same bright pure white light she saw when Albe was testing the various elemental energies, does anything happen? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Not yet?

Security resterilizes the blade, which the cleric promptly uses to cut herself.

The cleric advises that Merrin look inside herself for a sort of gate or affordance that wasn't there before; casting doesn't work by willing results to happen, it works through a sort of indescribable action you couldn't do before you were a cleric.

Permalink Mark Unread

Great, the clearest instructions they can manage are 'look for an indescribable action-affordance you didn't have before'. Merrin...will try this? 

She focuses on how it felt when the THING happened in the first place, and - is there anything that still feels different? She's particularly looking for a procedural-memory type of feeling, like the way she can look at a wound and a box of medical supplies and it's as though her hands already know what to do...

Permalink Mark Unread

There is totally a thing like that!  It is very weird!  It is not comparable to any of Merrin's previous qualia, only to the clericing memory and to itself!  Totally feels like there's an internal motor action she can take to do it, though.  Not like wanting your hand to move, not like visualizing your hand moving, just like moving your hand.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Is there only one thing like that, or more than one? If she's acquired the healing thing and also other things, Merrin doesn't want to do the wrong one by accident! 

Permalink Mark Unread

...just the one thing right now?  It feels like a door or a gate that she could throw open briefly.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I'm pretty sure the thing I suddenly feel like I know how to do is the channeling-positive-energy thing," Merrin says levelly, "but just in case it's somehow not that, um, warning that I'm about to try it." 

She tries it. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Sudden soundless white-light FOOM filling the whole hallway!  It's not very impressive by the standards of some of the brilliant white lights you see in Civilization or in Exception-Handling Scenarios, but Merrin is now healed.  So is the cleric next to her.

The blood is still there, but the Security is already absently Prestidigitating it off both of them.

Permalink Mark Unread

This is the COOLEST THING THAT HAS EVER HAPPENED TO MERRIN!!!!!!!!!

Permalink Mark Unread

...She now feels slightly bad about "wasting" the effect, but it would in fact have been worse to try it for the first time on actually-injured people, when she and the other cleric weren't sure it would work. 

"I think that worked! That's - really amazing. Um, I should actually go to sleep soon, but - if there's anyone who could benefit from healing soon, and I could do it again tonight, I want to do that first." 

Permalink Mark Unread

There probably isn't!  All the clerics in the palace prayed for enough healing spells that there'd be sufficient capacity for the day!  People are just getting healed whenever by individual clerics who have sufficient spells!

...they could take Merrin down to a Palace-internal healing clinic and wait for enough individual patients to come by that Merrin can run out her channelings, the cleric supposes?

Otherwise she'll just tell everyone to pray tomorrow for somewhat fewer first-circle healing spells, and have nonurgent patients accumulate for Merrin on hourly bells instead, starting at the second afternoon bell, until Merrin can feel that her healing has run out.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin makes a face. "I really wish I had a better way of - making this available to the people who wouldn't have access to healing spells usually. Which I'm guessing isn't the people internal to the Palace, it's the, um, poorer people." Based on the estimate she got earlier for the number of 'clerics' in Cheliax, there can't possibly be enough magical healing to cover the entire population even for minor injuries. "I realize it's pretty inconvenient that I'm immune to instant-movement magic and so traveling anywhere far away is going to be incredibly inconvenient, but - is there any way we could open a healing clinic for external patients, or is there an existing one that isn't too far away? I could probably offer healing for a lot cheaper than the other clerics who can only do it with specific spells, and still have it be really profitable." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Unfortunately no!  The Palace is located in basically the middle of nowhere for reasons of 'If a dragon decides to attack the Palace we don't want a lot of innocent civilians right next to it.'  It's a pity, Cheliax has lots of cities where that mass-radius healing would come more in handy.  Or where there'd be more interesting shopping to do, for that matter!  But with Teleports not working on Merrin it'd be... kinda ludicrously hard to make that work.

 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

"....Is 'a dragon decides to attack the palace' the sort of thing that, um, comes up much." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Don't worry too much about it.  The dragon wouldn't win.

The surrounding city, if somebody had located the Palace inside a city, would however tend to lose.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is not actually particularly concerned about her own safety here! Her concerns are about the fact that this is an ongoing issue in Golarion at all! As an equilibrium to end up in it's INSANE and Merrin actually kind of feels like it can't be in equilibrium at all, actually, how can that state of affairs possibly be stable, nobody is actually benefiting from it - 

- unless the dragon actively prefers the surrounding city getting badly damaged, in which case...Merrin isn't sure what good it does to move the Palace, the dragon could just go attack the city and it would be even less well defended, since a number of the powerful economicmagic users are here instead... 

 

Either way the fact that this is an active concern, and one where the Governance of Cheliax is taking considerable inconveniences to avoid, is really concerning! And confusing! It's not really a good look on a trained Exception Handler to look at a problem and declare it illogical and implausible, but this one really does seem that way! 

She's actually tired, though, and needs to definitely be awake at dawn tomorrow in order to contact her god-employer again and request AMAZINGLY COOL MAGIC. Now is probably not the best time to get into this. 

"Noted," she says. "In that case, I - should probably just go to bed, so I can be awake for sunrise and all. Or a bit earlier so someone can give me a quick summary of what the options for spells are. Is there anything else that seems important and time-sensitive for me to be filled in on?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Nopety nope!

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay then! Merrin is grateful to the cleric for rushing over on such short notice to help her confirm what just happened, and she is now going to go try to get some sleep. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Good night, Merrin!  Sleep well!

Permalink Mark Unread

...

Permalink Mark Unread

"I want to make one thing very clear to you, wizard.  I acted like that on the direct orders of Her Infernal Majestrix.  Make mock of it, spread rumors of it, and the order of torment I submit for you will include the note that you think Her Infernal Majestrix is funny."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Understood," says Security, keeping his eyerolls internal.

Anybody who has actually met Abrogail Thrune knows that she is, indeed, a quite humorous person.  Pretending otherwise is not, in fact, the terrifyingly narrow path you need to walk to avoid her becoming either annoyed or interested about you.

Permalink Mark Unread

Before dawn comes, Merrin shall be awoken by a cheerful not-so-senior Negotiations type, bearing with themselves a list of the 0-circle and 1st-circle cleric spells!  With descriptions!  Translated into Baseline!


(...with numerous strategic redactions, including most of the spells visibly useful for nothing except combat or doing Evil, because the enormous preponderance of spells like that would give Merrin a disturbing and accurate picture of Golarion's real nature.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Even with the redactions, the list is still VERY LONG and Merrin is finding it slightly overwhelming! 

 

She'll start with the 0th-level spells, for the moment, since there are at least somewhat fewer of them. 

She definitely wants Stabilize (to cause a dying creature to no longer be dying), just on the basis that it is the best flaming spell in the entire flaming world and she has no idea how it can possibly be one on the easiest possible tier but she would like to have this magic power constantly for the rest of her life, please. Also Detect Magic, because that sounds fascinating and would also un-bottleneck her on trying to learn wizard spells in the more usual way. 

There are a bunch of others that seem generically practically useful across a wide range of situations and/or training scenarios that she's experienced in the past, that are not her current situation (Light, Mending, Detect Poison, Create Water, Purify Food and Drink.)

And a couple are confusing and intriguing and she's not quite sure how to interpret the descriptions. 

"I'm confused about what Enhance Diplomacy does? And I'm curious about Read Magic, I don't - totally follow the description. It seems like it's not at all the same thing as  the Detect Magic one, and the description says it would let me read - spellbooks? Is that doing a different thing from Comprehend Languages in general? ...If it'd help me run the test faster on whether it's possible for me to learn arcane magic, I probably want that one. I'm - not actually sure how many I can ask for at each level, though?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Enhance Diplomacy enhances one attempt at... diplomacy?  The cheerful Negotiations type is confused about what Merrin is confused about!

The language of magic isn't... any normal speaking language?  You couldn't possibly translate it into any Taldane or Baseline sentence?  You just cast the spell and you can read, like, the magical meaning... Merrin should probably just request this 'orison' (0th-circle) at some point and see for herself.

She can probably get something like 3-4 orisons and 3-4 1st-circle spells?

(She'll get 4 and 5, based on her Wisdom and that she's at the upper end of 1st-circle, but Merrin should not expect in general that Cheliax will know so much so precisely.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is still slightly confused! Plausibly someone doing a different career in dath ilan would be less confused. It's - clearly something to do with social skills, which is cool, who would've thought you could just directly enhance that. 

...Anyway, sure, she'll make a list of four spells each and rank them in order so that she prioritizes the more important ones if it turns out she only gets three. For the 0th-circle "orisons" she'll go with 1. Detect Magic, 2. Stabilize, 3. Read Magic, and 4. Enhance Diplomacy. 

 

The 1st-circle spell prioritization is way harder! There are so many of them! There's an argument that she should really just prioritize Comprehend Languages for today, and ask for multiple copies of it - you can do that, right? Buuuuut she does, actually, want to personally experience a wider and more thorough range of Golarion's magic. Also she is desperately craving spreadsheet software, which she does not have, and she additionally doesn't have all that long to think about it before dawn. 

Again, she can classify the spells very roughly into "generically awesome", "decent utility spells for Exception Handling work that she is not currently doing", "intriguing" - and this time, with a 3.2 category of "utterly baffling."

At a very quick glance: 

 

Generically awesome

Comprehend Languages 

 

Practical 

Air Bubble - creates a bubble of breathable air underwater, though not for very long 

Ant Haul - lets a person carry 3x as much weight 

Abstemiousness: causes a small handful of food to feed someone for an entire day

Cure Light Wounds 

Dancing Lantern

Deathwatch: tells you who is dying nearby 

Diagnose Disease 

Endure Elements 

Enhance Water: turns water into alcohol, which is, like, a moderately okay disinfectant in a pinch

Hairline Fractures: would be pretty useful for getting past debris after a rockslide or explosion, probably?

Hidden Spring: for finding water 

Lighten Object 

Read Weather 

Remove Sickness 

 

Intriguing

Remove Fear 

Swallow your Fear 

Tap Inner Beauty

Touch of Truthtelling 

Rite of Bodily Purity 

 

Baffling 

Aspect of the Nightingale: gives you magical superpowers for a singing performance???

Bless Water: imbues water with positive energy. Merrin is unclear why. 

Bestow Planar Infusion: ....Merrin cannot actually even parse what this...means. 

Detect Demon: for some reason there is a spell just for detecting the presence or influence of Chaotic Evil afterlife natives???? 

Celestial Healing: you can do healing magic by anointing a wounded creature with either positive-energy-imbued water (ohhhh that explains the other spell, maybe) or...the blood...of one of the natives of a Good afterlife?  

Dream Feast: dream of a rich feast, when you wake up you will be full as though you actually ate and drank. That's...useful, Merrin guesses, but also really weird. 

Haze of Dreams: ...Is this just a spell for mind-altering drugs. Why. 

Songbird: produces music from one of the Good afterlives? This is the SECOND music-specific spell on the list. 

Restore Corpse - that's....kind of cool? In a gross way that Merrin could probably only ever talk about with fellow medically-trained Exception Handlers. But also. WHY? 

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin has QUESTIONS but she does not, actually, have time to ask all of them right now! 

Okay. She's going to ask for at least one of Comprehend Languages, and then time it very carefully so she can get the maximally useful noticing-translation-weirdnesses. 

She - does at some point want to go down the list of "practical" spells and try all of them once, but probably the sensible way to go about that is to do one per day for a while? And none of them are likely to be that useful to Cheliax, Cheliax has plenty of clerics of Asmodeus who are presumably much better read in on their system for making sure all the useful spells are being requested. 

The healing ones are tempting but not...actually that justified, for right now? She can maybe get the diseases one, she vaguely thinks that her 'channel positive energy' unexpected superpower doesn't do that? But it would be way more informative after she's had a chance to reinvent and build some basic medical monitoring equipment so she can watch what it does. 

 

...She is absurdly curious about Tap Inner Beauty. She doesn't really have a good reason to request it, though, aside from absurd levels of curiosity. The spell for boosting one's immune system is really cool but she's probably not at high risk of random food poisoning or other ailments in the next day? The spells for removing fear seem like they would have been really useful when she was seventeen but she's mostly moved past the stage of her life where it's all that necessary.

She is also incredibly tempted to ask for the one that gives you magical superpowers at singing. Merrin has always really liked music and singing and she's really bad at it natively and - unlike for certain other skills - it's not something she ever had a good justification to plow hundreds of hours of deliberate practice into. 

The one for checking whether someone is being truthful is way less interesting but has better arguments for it. (Merrin isn't actually worried, right now, that she's being lied to, but the principle of caution and covering all her bases says that she should check at least once.) 

 

Aaaaaaaaaah it is way too hard to pick only three additional spells  calm down, she knows the mental process to handle this feeling, and also it's not life-or-death stakes for her to pick exactly the right four 1st-circle spells on her first day as an employee of Erecura. 

It's almost dawn. 

 

"Ummm do you have any advice for picking between spells?" she asks the cheerful contact from Negotiations. 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

...What is Merrin trying to do?

What spells you pick depend on what you're planning to do that day.  Is Merrin planning to do anything besides talking to people and channeling positive energy?

Permalink Mark Unread

"I...think my main goal here - aside from making myself useful to Cheliax by channeling positive energy - is getting as much information as possible. Which maybe means I should just try to get either three or four of Comprehend Languages, but not necessarily, it won't be enough for the whole day anyway and I think I can get a lot of the value of having it at all in twenty minutes, it'll - help me get a better sense of what translates weirdly when someone is using the other language spell to talk to me in Baseline. I do eventually want to try all of the practical ones at least once, but I really doubt I'm going to actively need them today, unless your Governance decides to surprise me with a test scenario to gauge my Exception Handling skill but I doubt that. I - might want to ask for one of the Truthtelling one, just on the principle that I should check once that everyone who's explaining things to me is being truthful and how much they're leaving out. Other than that, I'm wondering if it's actually higher value-of-information to ask for some of the incredibly weird ones. Like 'Tap Inner Beauty', I am intensely curious about that." 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"I couldn't guess what weird spells would enlighten an outworlder!  Tap Inner Beauty sounds to me like one of those weird spells you resort to at the point where you're trying to do something really difficult and stack four slightly different bonuses that wouldn't stack right if they were the same bonus.  So Truthtelling, Tap Inner Beauty, and you ask for whatever's left to be Comprehend Languages?"

(They're not sure Erecura has gotten the news from Cheliax; they don't want Merrin making any open-ended requests.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"That probably makes sense." Merrin glances down at the list. Quickly skims it. "...I don't think there's anything else that's so interesting it seems worth foregoing Comprehend Languages for. And if it turns out I only get three spells at 1st-circle then I shouldn't risk getting zero for translation. Thank you. Um, is - contacting my god mentally for this going to be similar to what I originally did last night?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, no!  That only happens the first time!  You'd be lucky to get any sense at all of your god's presence when just praying for spells.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I guess that makes sense, if it's expensive for gods to do that - is it? Though, um, I mainly meant to ask whether should be trying to do the same mental motion, of thinking about the goals and values I share with Erecura, or if it's a different kind of mental action." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Similar mental motion!  You point your mind in the direction of your god, think about how you plan to serve coordinate with them on their purposes, and think about the spells you plan to request for the day.

Different gods differ in how much devotion and submission they want to see how important it is to them that you're aligning yourself a lot with them.  They don't know offhand where Erecura falls on this spectrum, but if praying the first time doesn't work, Merrin can come back and request additional guidance.

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay! That seems like enough to go on. Merrin would kind of like privacy for this part, but maybe it's a good idea if her Negotiations advisor stays nearby, in case it doesn't work and she does need further guidance. 

She shuts her door and sits down on her bed and looks out the window, which isn't facing the sunrise but she can tell a sunrise is happening. 

And she focuses on the components of her earlier attempt that successfully caught Erecura's attention. Merrin is trying to do something very hard, which she thinks will be helpful to the values of Heaven where Erecura lives, and she is trying to be as Lawful as she knows how and to learn how to do it better (caveat: she is probably STILL CONFUSED about what 'Lawful' means). Erecura is the goddess of predictions and secrets, and Merrin is intending to put significant effort and diligence into learning how to make more accurate predictions and more gracefully handle both her own secrets, and the possible hypothetical secrets that Cheliax is currently declining to tell her for infohazard-worry reasons. 

Toward that goal, today she would like the following spells, please: 

0th-circle: Detect Magic, Stabilize, Read Magic, and - if there's still room - Enhance Diplomacy. 

1st-circle: Touch of Truthtelling, Tap Inner Beauty, and after that as many Comprehend Languages as she can get. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin can now detect the complicated 3-dimensional projections of more complicated shapes inside her mind!  The shape-qualia are familiar; the stuff that is shaped that way, not so much.

Relatively simpler shapes:  x4.

Relatively more complicated shapes, but all topologically equivalent to a simple loop:  x5.  Three of those are the same, two are different.

Permalink Mark Unread

....Huh. 

Merrin spends a while sitting on her bed and just paying close attention to this extremely weird and novel experience, and then she gets up and slips out of her room again. 

"I think that worked! I, um, seem to have gotten five of the 1st-circle ones though? Is that weird?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"It means your native Wisdom is at least 20, which is - there's probably one other person like that in Cheliax?"

Permalink Mark Unread

What. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Huh. That's...good to know, I guess?" What it is is INCREDIBLY WEIRD and WHY and also...concerning. Super concerning. "Um, what's the actual - total population - of Cheliax? Without knowing that I also don't know how much of an outlier I would be." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think the latest estimate, as of the last census four years ago, was twenty million people more or less."

Permalink Mark Unread

Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah it is NOT OKAY for Merrin to apparently be a one-in-twenty-million outlier on something as important as 'Wisdom'! This is not how anything is supposed to work! Merrin is so uncomfortable about it! 

"Huh," she says, very neutrally. "Anyway, I'm - not sure if there are existing plans already for what I'm doing today? I would still like to talk to the expert who was going to answer questions about Cheliax in general. And I think I want to have a go at learning wizard magic the normal way, now that I have the Detect Magic spell myself. I should probably eat breakfast before I do any of that, though?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"No problem!  We'll have you off to the refectory in the moment.  You want your clothes Prestidigitated clean, first?"

"Oh, uh, word of warning, it'll probably take you some practice to learn to catch your orisons so you can recast them.  I think I was a week into my choosing before I managed to catch any."

The cleric demonstrates her own cast and catching of Detect Magic; not that Merrin can see any of the magic involved, but it's clear that there's some complicated dextrous gesturing to be done.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin would be happy to have her clothes cleaned via economicmagic! Also she really wants to learn that spell in particular. 

She watches the demonstration closely. "That's inconvenient. I - maybe want to use my Detect Magic this time to watch someone cast and catch one of their orisons, then, and I can use it for trying to learn arcane magic once I've gotten that down. I should ask for a verbal description of what the catching-it process feels like, too. Um, not right now, after breakfast is fine." 

Do her newly-acquired mental affordances for DOING MAGIC include any hints on the complicated hand gestures? Or is she going to need to ask for that to be explained too? 

Permalink Mark Unread

...she can sort of intuit the hand gestures she'd need to use to start any given spell she focuses on, they do have things that feel like starts and ends and shapes where your fingers could match the startingplaces.

Merrin's memory for How To Operate Hypothetical Alien Machinery After One Demonstration is good enough that she can take a guess at which of her four orisons is Detect Magic, based on where the cleric's fingers were.

Permalink Mark Unread

Prestidigitating Merrin's clothes clean takes only a moment for the fifth-circle Security.

Off to the refectory?

Permalink Mark Unread

Sure! 

Merrin spends the walk over attempting to introspect on the shapes of her other spells and see if she can guess which is which. Fortunately it's very easy to guess for Comprehend Languages. She can maybe draw them out as diagrams after breakfast and ask someone to help her figure out which is which? 

Permalink Mark Unread

(Merrin is a much better drawer and sketcher than, uh, the median dath ilani.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Two of her orisons 'feel' like they'd probably target a specifiable person, herself or somebody else; two of her orisons seem like they wouldn't have a specifiable target that way.

...none of her 1st-circles feel targeted?

Permalink Mark Unread

Ooh, neat.

For the orisons, Merrin is guessing that Read Magic is the other non-person-targeted one, and the other two are presumably Stabilize and Enhance Diplomacy. She doesn't currently have a good handle on guessing which is which, but they do 'look' pretty different, it should be feasible to ask later?

For the first-circle spells: ....huh. She would have thought that Touch of Truthtelling was person-targeted, and had been vaguely hoping she could narrow it down that way. Comprehend Languages is targeted to a person - herself - as is Tap Inner Beauty, but maybe spells that you can only cast on yourself don't fall into the same category as ones you can target arbitrarily? 

Maybe she just doesn't know how to interpret the shapes. She'll have to ask later. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Breakfast is no feasting occasion, but this is still the Imperial Palace of Cheliax and Asmodeus's domains include pride.

Even a dath ilani will find it not too awful.

...as long as she doesn't accidentally try to drink any of the grape-flavored cleaning fluid again.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's a totally adequate breakfast! Merrin has not forgotten about her food adventures from yesterday, and makes sure to ask if any of the foods or beverages incidentally contain mind-altering drugs. 

She gets together some food for herself and looks around the room for anyone she recognizes. 

Permalink Mark Unread

That young female person has some pretty distinctive hair, even in the Palace where as many as several people are displaying their Splendour instead of avoiding attention.

Permalink Mark Unread

This person is the same age and wearing the same uniform as the one with the distinctive hair.

Permalink Mark Unread

So's this one.

Permalink Mark Unread

Wait, Merrin also has a much greater ability to remember names and faces one day later than the median dath ilani, right?  Actually that's just Pilar Pineda, Asmodia, and Ione Sala.  Merrin can totally recognize them, right, that's a thing Merrin can just... do, somehow.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin can just do this! She's slightly iffier on matching the correct names to faces, for the two who aren't the highly memorable Pilar, but after ten seconds of thinking about it, she's fairly sure which one is Ione and which one is Asmodia. Maybe not sure enough to address them by name until it happens to come up in conversation and she gets confirmation. 

She walks over. "Good morning!" ...Oh, wait, can they understand her? She waits a moment to see if they answer or just look confused. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Good morning!"  These Baseline words enabled by a light arm-bracer are spoken by Ione Sala, who, it has been determined, is the best of the three Ostenso students at sounding genuinely cheerful given some rigorous training and drilling overnight, with a Nap Stack to enable her to have spells for the day.

She's having her thoughts read at every second.

She's in a Telepathic Bond with a seventh-circle wizard who in turn has a Telepathic Bond to the Queen of Cheliax.

She is, for the most part, putting everything away, putting away the terror and horror and certainty of her failure and horrendously painful death and probable damnation, putting away almost her entire self, not thinking anything about anything, trying to be only the parts of herself that are required to do this job.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin might conceivably have noticed something slightly off, here, if she had a lot more cultural context on Cheliax, or if she were expecting and on the lookout for someone who might have been pressured or even coerced into pretending to be cheerful and happy to talk to her. Why would that be a thing that happened. (Also, if a dath ilani were for some reason in that situation - well, for one it probably wouldn't work, and two, it would be so incredibly obvious.) 

She smiles brightly at probably-Ione. "- Oh, neat, they sorted out translation for you!" She sits down with her food. "I'm really curious to hear your thoughts on Baseline as a language, once you've, um, actually spoken enough of it to me to notice patterns. Also I had a ridiculous day yesterday, if you want to hear about that?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I mean, yes, and then I want to hear about the day before yesterday, and everything there is to know about the world you're from, and everything your world knows that ours doesn't, and any ideas you have about how you got here, or about how I could go visit your world."

Ione is apparently very good at making this particular line of patter sound like she's genuinely enthusiastic and not at all like she's probing Merrin for secrets for Cheliax's benefit, according to her trainer.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I...am slightly nervous about telling you literally everything dath ilan knows that Cheliax doesn't," for reasons related to one of the ways in which yesterday was ridiculous, "also I - don't incredibly know where to start with just that prompt, but I'll try my best."

Unfortunately her sketchy theories for how she got here are kind of infohazard-flavored, in a way where maybe it's fine but Merrin is not a Keeper and doesn't know and for various reasons feels much better about telling Albe than telling students who are years younger than her. (Merrin's thoughts, if anyone is watching, blur out again here.) 

Oh well. It's probably safe for her to tell them about her Exception Handling work, and how dath ilan Governance is set up and some things about their tech level and how day to day life looks different from Cheliax, and Merrin is pretty sure that by itself would take several days to fully explore.

And...if she's wrong in an actually-very-dangerous way then maybe her new goddess-employer will do something to warn her? Merrin should absolutely not count on that, though, it's probably very expensive for Erecura to even pay attention to her on an ongoing basis, let alone intervene about it. 

"Anyway! The thing that happened at the end of yesterday is that I tried contacting all the gods I'd heard about so far to see if anyone of them were interested in offering me the 'cleric' thing - I was absolutely not expecting this to work but the cleric of Asmodeus I spoke to said it wouldn't hurt to try, and it was an interesting mental exercise in its own right - and now I'm a cleric of Erecura! Which means I have my own version of the translation magic. I think! I have three spells that are probably that but I don't actually know how to distinguish spells from each other very well without casting them, yet." 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"I didn't even know Erecura had clerics!  Why did you choose Her?  And who is Merrin that she would be chosen of Her, wow that sounds so much less poetic in Baseline.  Oh, does the translation spell look anything like you'd cast it with your hands starting like -"

Ione puts her hands into the starting position for the arcane version of Comprehend Languages, which is different from the divine version, but not so different that the starting gestures aren't the same.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I didn't try for her first! She was actually almost last on my list, the only one after her was Gorum, um, the banking one who also sort of runs a country like Asmodeus runs Cheliax? I tried Asmodeus first and then -" damn it the unnamed one is kind of secret, oh well she'll leave it out for now, "- then Urgathoa, Pharasma, Desna, and Zon-Kuthon, in that order." Presumably she doesn't need to explain the gods' alignments and domains to Golarion natives. "I'm - honestly not sure why she picked me, they did explain that she doesn't normally work with mortal clerics, but it seemed worth trying for completeness. I'm really curious! My - best guess is that it's related to the fact that I had been thinking I needed to - try to become something like a Keeper in my world. Which I'll explain in a moment, unless the translation covers some of that? And both secret-keeping and making accurate predictions are going to be incredibly important for that." 

She frowns. "Also she gave me the 'channeling positive energy' ability, which is apparently extremely rare and expensive for gods to give out, and I'm really confused. I don't actually have a good theory for that yet. The cleric who came and confirmed I'd gotten cleric magic said that it's probably not because there's about to be an enormous disaster where Cheliax desperately needs more efficient healing, because even gods aren't that accurate at predicting exact futures, but - I guess I'm not sure it isn't that, since Erecura's domain is predictions." 

 

Merrin consults her internal sense of spell-casting hand gestures - does Ione's match with the three copies of the same spell she has for 1st-circle? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Almost!

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah, that looks like it! I have three of them and I think they last twenty minutes each, so it won't cover me for the entire day or anything but I'm hoping it'll help a lot with the thing where sometimes concepts translate incredibly confusingly into Baseline. ...Actually, hmm, how - much context does the translation magic give you, if it's a concept that your native language doesn't actually have a word for? I remember some of the people talking to me before were occasionally using words and then...noticing that they weren't entirely sure what they'd just said." 

She's watching all three of the students closely, mainly trying to gauge their reactions to last night's events; it seems like helpful data on exactly how weird this is, and therefore how significant of an update she should expect to make once she has a clearer idea what that update is

Permalink Mark Unread

Actually Asmodia is an impersonator today!  The real Asmodia fell behind Ione in acting quality, got punished accordingly, and apparently is one of those fucking kids whose acting quality goes down further after she's punished for failing.  How she managed to last this long through Ostenso wizard academy is a mystery, maybe the headmaster there is going lax.

Anyways, 'Asmodia' is going to be mostly serious and dispassionate as a cover for her fascination, because she thinks that's more dignified, and isn't going to be very forwards about interacting with Merrin this morning.

Permalink Mark Unread

Pilar is an innately cheerful sort of girl, tends to come across as rather sardonic when she speaks to anyone who isn't a teacher, and has a hell of a Resting Bitch Face that in practice is probably 70% of why she continues to be mostly considered a proper scary Asmodean given her actual behavior patterns.

Pilar was also not as good an actress as Ione.  And was punished accordingly, of course, so it's fine now, given that apparently Pilar's natural personality was judged suitable to do an acceptable job.

And she's on a Telepathic Bond to a seventh-circle wizard who is on a Telepathic Bond to the Queen of Cheliax which is... actually a bit more awesomeness than Pilar can really handle.  She's trying not to think about it.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ione looks appropriately fascinated by all the weirdness!

"Ooh, I want to try that.  Do you know what words triggered that?  'Magic'.  'Magic'.  I can tell it doesn't mean Taldane 'magic' but I can't tell exactly what it does mean.  You're right, that's fascinating!  I don't think I've ever heard any really unfamiliar concepts from Comprehend Languages but I'll prepare that spell today and I'll tell you how it compares to hear a weird word from you using that spell instead of my speaking it with an item of Tongues!  Oh, I'll probably get even less information, though, Tongues is a more powerful spell than Comprehend Languages, third-degree-of-economagical-complexity instead of first-degree-of-economagical-complexity.  'Complexity.'  'Complexity.'  Why does that sound like it means math I don't know?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is noticing that Asmodia is quiet, but it's not like she had much of a chance to interact with Asmodia yesterday. Probably Asmodia is just a very quiet person. Merrin will think more about whether to try to include her more in the conversation, versus inferring that her quietness means she would rather not be bothered and then leaving her alone.

"Huh. I'll try to remember what the words were that tripped people up, before. Mostly I'm remembering that the way Tongues tried to translate 'Chaotic' at first was really confusing and misleading. Complexity is - um, it's the quantity of how complicated something is?  Measured in bits? I guess that's math."

Merrin feels like it's a very borderline case of actual math. There are nuances, of course, but the basic concept isn't even the first five minutes of a lesson, it's the first thirty seconds, and she's having trouble remembering far enough back to recall a time when she didn't know the basic concept. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I've never heard of things being like, numbers complicated, instead of just more or less complicated.  'Bits' sounds like math I don't know too!"

Permalink Mark Unread

........Wow. Just when Merrin thought she was maybe getting a handle on all of the problems with Golarion... This particular one is confusing. It makes sense that the broader education system would cover less math, but it seems like it has to be relevant for wizard magic - and wizards are smart, they're selected heavily for that, and wizards can increase their intelligence

 

"Um. I think I should explain that, but it might be helpful if you can tell me what math you do know - and maybe what math you haven't fully learned yet but expect to later in your studies? - so I can figure out what prerequisites if any need explaining first rather than repeatedly trying to say something where you don't know the terminology yet. ...Also I'm going to register a prediction that Baseline will be a much better language for talking about math and you'll have some opportunities to notice the translation weirdness." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Ione Sala knows incredibly-elementary-algebra-your-parents-teach-you-before-you-start-school and ridiculously-basic-topology-for-nine-year-olds!  She's good at it too, in terms of Ostenso wizard academy class rankings!

...wow this language seems to have some pretty precise terms to describe exactly which math Ione knows, if she's not just imagining that.

Permalink Mark Unread

....Wow

It does have that! How are you supposed to talk about math ever if your language doesn't have that? 

Flaming bird poop that list didn't include probability, how is she supposed to explain complexity without that. Pr...obably the students have an intuitive concept of that math, at least, even if it wasn't considered relevant for wizard studies at their level. Merrin is not sure how you exist in the world without knowing basic probability theory. 

"So, um, I am - starting to suspect it's going to be impossible to properly explain without an entire lesson that goes back to the basics. And I'm not super up for giving an entire lesson right now because I'm bad at math and school was a decade ago. ...Um, I'm bad at math by dath ilan standards. One of the things we pieced together yesterday is that dath ilan has a much higher median thinkoomph - uh, that probably covers what you call Wisdom and Intelligence plus possibly a lot of other elements that you don't have spells for measuring - I'm below average there but it's becoming increasingly clear that that is incredibly not true here." 

She spends a moment considering how to explain it in a way that is both comprehensible at all and doesn't rely hugely on other math that she will then get stuck having to explain as well. 

"So - in general how complicated something is, is - something you can measure by how long it would take you to describe exactly that thing, without any ambiguity over which particular thing it is. You...can sort of imagine it as, you're writing out a description of an entire spell - imagine you have really precise words to describe all the features of it, that distinguish it from other spells, I don't know if your language actually has that - and how long the description is, corresponds to how complex the spell is. The message length is measured in bits, where - one bit is the amount of information you would need to pick between two possible options that seemed equally probable before you included that information - um, there's an entire field of math about how probable things are, that's also very precise. So if we were talking about an imaginary toy universe where there were only two possible configurations for economicmagic spells to be in, you would have a complexity - a description length - of one bit. Obviously there are a lot more than two ways that magic can be configured! But you can still think of it as the number of bits you need to single out the precise words and then you use the very precise words to describe the spell. The 1st-circle spells are more complex than the 0th-circle spells, which in this case just means that you would need a longer description, as measured in bits, if you wanted to convey everything about them in words to someone else. Does that make sense?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"It does!  Though economagical-degree-of-complexity usually just goes by the maximum number of topological-loops in the spell - okay I can say that just fine!  So why does first-economagical-degree-of-complexity come out as that in Tongues, and not as 'economagic with up to one topological-loop' since that's what it means?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"I don't actually know anything about how Tongues picks out what word to give you as a translation! It seems to get it wrong sometimes! But, um, one hypothesis is that Tongues assumes you would rather use fewer and shorter words, unless you're going into it determined to be really maximally precise? ...I might have better theories about this once I've tried it from my end." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Or the average person in Golarion speaking Taldane, my native language, doesn't know about topological-loops, and thinks that 'circle' means Taldane 'complexity' that translates closest to Baseline 'complexity', and Tongues wants the Taldane concept for 'first-circle' to translate into the same Baseline word any time somebody talks about it, so it goes by the average meaning of the word I'm thinking and not the concept I'm thinking?"

"...Nah, I like your explanation better."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Hmm, so another thing I was thinking is that - talking about degrees of complexity is more general than talking about the number of topological loops? As in, you could imagine there being a lot of different possible magic systems that had discrete measurable degrees of complexity, not just the ones like Golarion magic. I'm not sure it's actually useful for Tongues to be suggesting the most generic translation but - I can imagine that being the least complex way to implement the spell? ...Maybe. I am not actually an expert in programming complex algorithms, which is the analogy I'm using right now for Golarion spells that seem to contain a lot of intelligence and sophisticated information-processing." 

Pause. 

"- My prediction is that I just said several words that translate weirdly and I'm curious to hear what you heard and understood?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I - heard you say you weren't an expert in something that I didn't understand at all, and then you talked about Golarion spells that contain a lot of intelligence and - sophisticated something else, that sounded vaguely like the first thing and also like spells that can have complicated conditions built into them, or 'complexconditionalspells*' in Taldane."


(*) Three syllables.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

 

"...Huh."

 

"...That's - it's really interesting that it seems like your language has a short or common word for that? Um, in the world know, it's - you can't just call on some intelligence outside yourself and outside Civilization, in order to do anything sophisticated? It's possible to build things that do some amount of - making decisions based on observations, and having judgement - but that relies on someone having built the system? And....it sounds like Golarion magic just - includes calling a function to some outside force that has intelligence and can do complex decisionmaking and output reasonable results?" 

Which is honestly kind of terrifying! 

"- Um, unless I'm completely misunderstanding how spells are developed." 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"I don't understand why you'd have to build something for it to be intelligent?  Lots of things that aren't built are intelligent.  There's a sentient river a few largedistanceunits away from my hometown."

"Largedistanceunits.  'Miles'.  It's a few 'miles' away from my hometown.  I don't know what largedistanceunits are."

Permalink Mark Unread

Ione is trying so hard to understand and it's very cute and Merrin is not entirely sure what to do with this feeling. 

 

"...Right. I - so probably I should just ask you for your top examples of things that are intelligent but weren't built - but, our world's understanding is that–" 

Pause. 

"Um. Does the word 'optimization-process' translate usefully at all?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"...thing that makes things... better..."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Yeah, I guess that's - not wrong about the core thing there. But it's– so, 'better' is relative to some particular criteria, right?"

Merrin, remembering the previous translation awkwardness spots, is trying incredibly hard to break all of this down into the smallest and concrete-est pieces, as though she were teaching a class to five-year-olds, not that she's every actually DONE that for anything that wasn't extremely basic first aid -

"- An optimizer is - an entity that has a goal for how the world-state should look in the future, and - makes plans and takes actions to bring the world toward that state? And a stronger optimizer makes better plans that shape the world more quickly and accurately toward whatever the final goal is that it's optimizing for?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"If we're not talking about 'gods' then I'm not sure what we're talking about...?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I mean, I think Golarion gods are an example of an optimization process? If Erecura chose me in particular because she predicted that would result in a particular outcome and she liked that outcome better than the possible outcomes where she didn't choose me, that's - basically just what being an optimization process is. But it's not the only example, humans also do this - less powerfully, obviously, but that's a quantitative not a qualitative difference.  Dath ilan has this concept and considers it important even though we had never heard of your kind of gods existing." 

Merrin pauses. Makes a face. 

"- I could totally say more things about that but I'm noticing that we're maybe falling into the conversational pattern where we just keep drilling deeper and deeper into more specific digressions. Which I might be fine with as a relaxed breakfast conversation but seems unlikely to prioritize answering the questions you're most curious about. I think you'd started out asking me things about dath ilan in general and what living there was like? Not sure if chasing down all the Baseline words that sound like they mean math you don't know is answering that usefully for you. Oh and I also notice I'm failing to eat my food." 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"Uh... I think you were trying to figure out how much context Tongues gave me, when I said or heard something in Baseline for which there wasn't an exact 'Taldane' fit?  And then I said the word complexity and it sounded like math I didn't know.  And before then I wanted to know everything about your world and your life and how you got here and if I could visit there."

(Not that Ione actually remembers this, but the Security wizard on Telepathic Bond to her does.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"I have to say I'm really curious to experience this from the other side! But I should probably plan more carefully when I use my Comprehend Languages and not do it for relaxed breakfast conversation. It...does seem like Tongues doesn't really fill in that much of the context, if it's something you don't know at all? And it doesn't provide automatic conversions between units of measurement, which is kind of irritating, you would think that would be really easy and not take much spell complexity, it's just multiplication or division. But if it's a more specific version of a concept you do know in generalities, it seems like it gives you that? But also I get the sense it's possible to accidentally say something very specific in Baseline, possibly because I am getting the sense that Baseline goes in harder on having precise words, and then you don't automatically know exactly what you said? Just that it's something very precise? ...I'm still pretty confused about how this could work." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Ione wordlessly points at Merrin's food.

Permalink Mark Unread

....That is also a good point. Merrin stops talking and starts eating. Ione and the others might be grateful for a minute or two to think about what the most interesting conversational tack would be on their side.

Merrin should maybe also take a step back and figure out what would be a satisfying breakfast conversation for her, because 'ending up falling into the social default of discussing math even when she wouldn't have picked this if shown all her options' is not an unfamiliar problem for her. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Ione will eat her own portions, and very very quietly and obediently receive her transmitted advice from the QUEEN OF CHELIAX about how they've decided to gamble on having one student unabashedly fascinated with the useful things of Civilization and her name is Ione Sala, so she is approved to exhibit a little license about poking around for the more interesting things that Merrin knows.

Ione will not think any bad thoughts.  Ione will not think any bad thoughts.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Merrin has concluded that actually the conversation she is really itching to have is a nice social gossip session with some other girls one about what in the name of supercooled superfluid helium was going on with Albe yesterday. No one has explicitly told her that she shouldn't talk about it and it's not like she personally feels very private about it, and their world has an entire god of sadism and masochism, that part isn't going to be an infohazard. 

She sits in silence until she's gotten through about a third of the food on her plate, which seems like the point at which further conversation is definitely allowed. 

"So! A completely different incredibly weird thing happened yesterday! Well before the Erecura weird thing. The person who originally took point on talking to me decided it was worth bringing in a very serious very highly-qualified Governance consultant, who it turned out also had some Chaotic Evil Outsider in her ancestry - which is how I learned that's apparently a thing, here. And had inherited this super-rare powerful magical artifact that significantly increases her cognitive abilities which is how I learned THAT'S a thing."

(Also if this were a novel, her superpowerful magical headgear of cognitive enhancement would have to be some kind of important plot hook, but that's the Tropes thing again and she doesn't really feel like getting into that conversation with the wizard students.)

"And she spent the entire session of doing experiments in her dangerous and impressively doompunk magical laboratory flirting with me, which is - I guess how I learned that's much less weird here than it would be in dath ilan, and relatedly research lab safety standards are way less of a thing. It kind of took me a really long time to notice the flirting and be sure it was that, because I was incredibly not expecting that, it's a little embarrassing now." 

Permalink Mark Unread

(Ione has not particularly been briefed on any of this whatsoever in order to preserve her properly surprised reactions!)


"Okay that doesn't all particularly happen at Ostenso wizard academy either."  WHAT.  WHAT is Ione SUPPOSED to be reacting about this.  "I mean... it does sound legit Chaotic Evil if that's what you're asking about?  I wouldn't flirt in a magical laboratory."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I guess I had already been thinking it wouldn't happen frequently here and I was just - unusually interesting, because of being from another world and all. Umm. She did say she was herself Lawful Evil, not Chaotic Evil. She did a somewhat better job at explaining what the Taldane words 'Good' and 'Evil' even mean, I'm still kind of lost about Lawful vs Chaotic - I have theories but I'm trying to hold them very lightly because they're almost certainly importantly wrong. I - did like her, overall? Which is surprisingly if only because I did not particularly realize I was attracted to women in the 'wanting to date them' way as opposed to just finding lots of women aesthetically pleasing. Could just be that I have literally never met a woman in dath ilan who was doing whatever the flaming glitter her gendertrope is."  

Shrug. "I think it turned out the magical laboratory wasn't very dangerous to me because I am categorically immune to magic unless it's my own cleric magic. And probably it wasn't dangerous to her because she's an absurdly talented and qualified Governance consultant. I didn't know that at the start but I'm not - holding a grudge about that part?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think even if you're totally safe, flirting in a magical laboratory is the sort of thing where, I mean, Pharasma's not really going to ding you much alignment points for it probably, but, like, that is a Lawful Evil person with worrisome Chaotic tendencies."  Wait is she stepping on somebody's seduction plans here.  "Probably a lot of fun in bed though if that's what you're wondering about."

Permalink Mark Unread

Abrogail is, of course, noting all of this down to mention to Ione later, which is honestly one of the best parts of her job.

Permalink Mark Unread

Huh. That feels like it has to be informative for what 'Law' and 'Chaos' mean here, but Merrin isn't totally sure what to do with it yet. 

"I...mean, in that sense maybe I'm not fully entirely Lawful, I...kind of would prefer living in a world where occasionally people might flirt with me in doompunk laboratories when they knew I was totally safe but didn't. Dath ilan has people who will do things like that, not maliciously, just because it's...fun, I guess. I think dath ilan is better for that and I don't think it's in contradiction with...I don't know, with what Civilization is trying to be. Which may or may not be related to what at least the gods here conceive of as Law." 

Permalink Mark Unread

But you've got to be careful about Law, it's not enforced the same way as Evil and you might end up in the Abyss Ione is Lawful Good and also Abaddon isn't particularly scary.  "I mean, very few people are entirely Lawful or entirely Chaotic, that's more of an outsider thing."

Can somebody PLEASE give Ione direction on what she's trying to achieve with Merrin here?  Are they supposed to be encouraging Merrin to be more Chaotic?

Permalink Mark Unread

(We are trying to seduce Merrin through her masochism among other tendencies, and persuade her that there are things Lawful Good failed to offer her.  Aiming her for Lawful Evil is secondary to aiming her out of Lawful Good.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Huh. That does make sense. It maybe makes me more confused about how Outsiders work, if they're - not like that, but I'm not expecting to resolve that confusion during this conversation. Not sure I'm expecting to resolve any specific confusion by telling you all about this, more just - I was really overdue for an opportunity to gossip and complain about this deeply weird experience." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"What was complainable about it?  I could file a report with Security and get the person corrected on their flirtation errors so next time they could flirt better."  Ione smiles to make it clear that she's joking.

Permalink Mark Unread

"- I mean, I want to complain but I don't endorse people acting on it? There's– so a thing I've already learned about myself is that in some sense I like being flirted with in ways that are uncomfortable and feel weird. I had a boyfriend at one point who..." Pause. "Um, I should check if you actually want to hear my moderately anonymized gossip about my boyfriend from dath ilan or if you'd rather have a different conversation instead." 

Permalink Mark Unread

YES, YOU WANT TO HEAR THAT.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Hearing anything about dath ilan sounds great to me!"

Permalink Mark Unread

"So, right. I have a boyfriend who's about a decade older than me and way smarter than me and, um, generally more impressive than me in every way, you know? And he really likes to tease me about how I'm - extremely talented in unique ways and so unusual and special. He knows this makes me really self-conscious so then he'll go on about it for like two minutes while I squirm and make grumpy noises about it. In a sort of supervillain-monologue voice. And it's super uncomfortable! But it's not - it doesn't make me want to leave and it does feel like it conveys him - liking me, wanting to pay attention to me, and I guess I can't claim I don't like that." 

Merrin's thoughts indicate that she thinks any claim that she could be uniquely talented is ridiculous enough not to be worth considering any further. 

Permalink Mark Unread

This would make perfect sense as a way for Merrin's owners to torment her and laugh at her if there was any actual brainwashing, and Abrogail Thrune is looking really hard for it, and Merrin is thinking about it right there, and Abrogail Thrune still can't see it.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ione has been read in on this part of things, sort of, but what the Abyss is she actually supposed to say in response to that?  Is she supposed to ask for more details about why Merrin can't possibly be a valuable sort of slave -

Permalink Mark Unread

No, Merrin isn't deluded about her actual accomplishments, that's not the interesting part.  We are not interested in challenging her compulsions either; they work to our ends.

We want to hear about her boyfriends, how they use her, how they may have shaped her.  Those are surely the true masters of dath ilan.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I've never had a really smart boyfriend myself," by your standards, "and I have to admit, I wonder a lot about what that would be like.  I mean, I'm sure it's different in Golarion, but I'm also incredibly curious about dath ilan so that all works out.  How did you get sent to him - who sent you there - and what made him be the man who got you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Right! ...Um. I can tell you - and then I'm pretty curious how it would look here and what seems more or less weird to you," this seems like an area of particular relevance to Merrin's project of figuring out the cultural differences between dath ilan and Cheliax and thereby avoiding accidental social awkwardness, "but I should check if you're sure that you're, um, read in on everything to do with sadism and masochism being a thing and I'm not likely to accidentally say anything that you shouldn't know. It - seems like that all works very differently here but I don't know how differently." 

On the one hand, there's apparently a huge sense of relief in being able to talk to someone about this aspect of her life - or, well, literally anyone other than a Keeper with several standard deviations of intelligence on her and a completely different day-to-day life. On the other hand, having a younger girl being impressed about her boyfriends is...itself pretty squirm-inducing and weird. Also the whole topic is reminding her that she MISSES THEM and will never see anyone she was close to ever again. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I mean... as far as I know none of that is a secret around here?  It doesn't seem like the sort of thing that would be a secret?  I don't have enough Evil in me myself that I'd want to hurt a man in bed or be hurt by him, but I know what whips look like and what they do, or an Acid Splash cantrip if you wanted to go more serious than that on the relationship-escalation-scale.  It doesn't seem like anything from a world without healing spells should be able to shock me."

(Ione's voice remains totally cheerful while she says all this!)

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin! Remains so confused! About what Evil even means! 

"That's... Okay, wow, I am definitely not going to shock you on that aspect." Healing magic is just unfair it would be so convenient for Merrin's life - even leaving aside how amazing it would be for work, if somehow it only worked for masochism-related injuries even that would be wonderful. "I don't think anything else I'd say to answer your question is going to be especially shocking on other dimensions."

"Anyway, hmm, so there's a matching process for it, obviously. The matching is done by the Keepers - I guess you don't have Keepers in your world, they're basically the very smart people who have a lot of training in reasoning clearly and who are cleared to know various infohazardous things. One of them approached me and told me I would probably like masochism as a sex thing and ought to try it, which is good because it would never have occurred to me otherwise that it could possibly be a sex thing. And then they interviewed me about myself, and probably talked to my friends and employers and such, to get a really detailed sense of what I'm like, and they already had that information on all the sadists who are currently cleared to know sadism exists and are, um, wealthy enough to be in the market for a very limited good. Then there are prediction markets! I think there are, like, three Keepers who have little hedge funds and bet on markets for matching compatible masochists to sadists. They're subsidized by the sadists, that's how the Keepers who specialize in this make money off the those markets, which is one reason someone has to be really wealthy to qualify at all. Anyway, on my end I just got a ranked list of all the people who were interested, in order of how confidently the market on them-and-me predicted we'd get along."

Merrin thinks this is obviously the way to set this up. Very little in her life hasn't involved prediction markets, and she's actually less into using them for her day-to-day decision-making than most of the people she knows; she subsidized a market on where she ought to move, when she was picking out her latest apartment from various apartment-options and wanted the aggregate input of her friends on which would make her happiest, but her brother uses them to decide what new clothes to buy, and one of her boyfriends - who obviously has more money to throw around subsidizing random markets about himself - has a habit of using that to decide what to order for dinner. 

"Right, so then they would all send in, like, biographies and introduction videos, so I could get a sense of what they were like before deciding if I wanted to meet in person. If I said yes then they would get my intro video - although honestly it turned out that most of them were fans of Exception Handling and already knew who I was from the televised scenarios and were so amazed I was the same person! Which I hadn't expected! ...In hindsight I think it's not actually very strange that people mainly selected for relationship-compatibility with me would usually be interested in Exception Handling." 

Merrin has not really considered other hypotheses for this. Obviously people who've seen her on television were watching because they shared her niche interest, it would be silly for that to be about her specifically. 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

...okay, so, thinking just the obvious, dath ilan has wealthy aristocrats, they see Merrin - performing in her hard-to-make-out arena of 'television' - they decide they want her - if the Keepers can deploy non-magical brainwashing on this seamless level, they may very well have had the ability to make Merrin a masochist, or at any rate believe that she wanted to be hurt, she has said that no such thought had ever occurred to her before - there was the appearance of an elaborate ritual matchmaking process, probably with some false candidates thrown in and Merrin seamlessly led to reject those, to give her a sense that she was choosing -

This seems mostly smoke and mirrors, if there are clues here they are buried ones.  What matters is that there are wealthy non-Keepers to whom the Keepers sell favors.  They appear to Merrin to be far more intelligent than her, as may or may not be a lie; Abrogail would guess that it is part lie and part truth.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I have to say, I wouldn't want a sadistic boyfriend, but a wealthy one - a powerful one - I'm so curious about what powerful men from another world would be like.  You could start a whole new genre of romance novels about that... though this is probably not the most important thing you should be doing."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you have a genre about powerful men the way they are locally? Actually I'm just really curious about your romance genres in general, reading them also definitely isn't the highest-priority thing I should be doing, when I have such limited time when I can understand your language, but it would be so helpful for, um, learning my way around your world and its culture. Obviously people are going to try to be understanding if I make a lot of social missteps at first, would be if one of you had ended up in my world, but that doesn't mean I like it. ...Dath ilan has at least ten different subgenres that are about having a powerful boyfriend and some of them get very weird." 

Permalink Mark Unread

All right, that was in fact a huge mis-step by Ione, in her ignorance and improvisation, if Merrin asks to have a book like that read to her.  Real Chelish romance novels are not suitable for Merrin to read.  And they can't just substitute romance novels from Taldor or Absalom; all the romance novels outside of Cheliax are insanely boring and it won't be credible that somebody like Ione would have read them...

Abrogail directs a thought out at a secretary; all the best current Chelish romance novelists are to immediately divert to producing, as quickly as possible and collaborating as necessary, at least ten different Lawful Good romance novels with interesting plots.  Yes she knows why it's impossible for Lawful Good books to have interesting plots, tell the authors they need to get it done anyways or they will die in interesting fashions.  She wants a dozen potential plot synopses on her desk in three hours.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's been deemed that Ione should not call attention to her mistake by pointing out that Merrin can't read.  "Which subgenre was the most like your own romantic life?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin considers this. 

"I...guess the general case is the pretty standard 'ordinary girl through some sequence of events ends up with a harem of interesting boyfriends' or, um, maybe in some ways closer to the 'girl with a minor disability gets a harem', though those tend to have protagonists who were unhappy or lonely or unfufilled before that happened to them and I wouldn't say I felt that way, really, at least not by the time I had managed to make it through my medical training and qualifying examinations and then had a job and stuff. The sub-subgenre is this being because it implausibly turns out that some random trait she has and never thought was particularly important turns out to be incredibly valuable to her powerful interesting attractive boyfriends. Which is a little like the 'secret minor superpower' genre but those end up being more about gaming the minor secret superpower to amass wealth and fame. Some related genres include the one where a girl looks ordinary but has a secret double life and this is how she meets boyfriends and amasses a harem, but that's not very much like my life. Also some of the harem romances have the plot being mostly meeting and starting relationships with the powerful boyfriends, whereas some of them have that all at the beginning and the rest is about accomplishing really important things by solving puzzles. There's one I really like where an ordinary girl with a harem of powerful boyfriends via implausible backstory ends up being the first person to meet aliens... I guess that's sort of almost literally what just happened to me but at least she got to still be in contact with her harem." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Hmmmm.  Hard to tell from that whether dath ilan's romance novels are boring or not.  Gaming a minor secret superpower to amass wealth and fame, or leading double lives, at least seem more interesting than a woman waiting around for a man to sweep her off her feet?  That women can have harems in the first place was a point lost on pre-Abrogailian romantic literature, for that matter... Abrogail Thrune will suspend judgment on the topic for now.

(Obviously this is an important question to think about, because the ways in which dath ilan's romance novels were not boring will probably be revealing of the true ways in which dath ilan was not Lawful Good.  That is totally the only reason why Abrogail is interested in this.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"So what were your powerful boyfriends like?  I mean, what sort of power did they have - it's not magic, because you didn't have magic, right..."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Not magic, no. They had - important jobs? They were usually people who were exceptionally talented at something that was incredibly valuable to Civilization and that most people can't do, and had the accordingly high earning potential. One of them is mostly just incredibly good at winning prediction markets, one works in Governance, one is a moderately famous novelist, a couple have jobs I'm not actually cleared to know about. They were also unusually likely to be people who used their money on building elaborate volcano lairs or things with that general theme, but that's not that rare in dath ilan, I think lots of people would want to build volcano lairs if they could afford it. They were maybe less likely than average to want to spend our entire date talking about math? But that's got to be a me-compatibility selection thing, I'm unusually not-excited about that. Compared to the dath ilan median. The local average might be different." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Novelist?  Possibly that was just his cover story?  There's no way anybody really important would spend their time writing books.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I guess that tracks, building volcano lairs is much more of an Evil thing than a Good thing, so it squares up with the sadism.  What'd the one in Governance do?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Er, he's the one in charge of the Confidential Criminal Court Calibration Commission subdepartment. He reports to the head of the whole criminal courts department, who reports directly to the Chief Executive, so - pretty high up."

In Merrin's thoughts, this is basically exactly what it sounds like; her boyfriend is responsible for overseeing the process by which criminals in dath ilan can file confidential reports and explain what actually happened. 

"It's a pretty difficult and high-trust job because there's a lot of - having to really careful reason about using non-representative statistics to make inferences, right? That department is involved in calibration for the rest of the criminal court department, they use the confessions to check the accuracy of past judgements from the prediction markets and update the process as necessary - and they also need to do ongoing calibration on how much weight to put on confessions, using the cases where someone filed a confidential report and then later there was definitive evidence one way or another. And this matters a lot! If the judgement is that the likelihood someone is guilty is above the eighty-five percent threshold for non-souldeath murder that cities use as the cutoff to send someone to Last Resort, and that process is miscalibrated, then more innocently people would be wrongly punished. You have to be incredibly smart and incredibly careful and able to reflect - I think that would fall under what Golarion calls 'Wisdom' - and it sounds like a terrifying level of responsibility to have." 

'Last Resort' according to Merrin's thoughts is just the one city in dath ilan that has to accept someone as a citizen, even if nowhere else in Civilization is still willing to. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"Sorry, the Confidential - Criminal - Confession - Thingydingy - is what, again?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Did she somehow completely fail to explain it clearly? Merrin would have thought the phrase would convey most of it but maybe the translation magic is doing something very weird. 

"Um, it's just the department where criminals can go if they want to make a confidential confession of what actually happened in the crime they committed? It's an important check for the rest of the court system, like I said."  

Permalink Mark Unread

Is she supposed to -

Permalink Mark Unread

They probably already gave away that this doesn't exist in Golarion; probably shouldn't try to pretend that it does exist in Golarion; and she is incredibly incredibly curious wants to know what kind of Keeper not-magic gets used to - get criminals to file confessions - actually she's just plain confused here.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I guess some criminals would ever want to file a confidential confession with the government, but - I wouldn't have thought that many?  Sorry, I think I'm probably missing something basic here."

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin had never previously considered that this would be weird! Now she's pretty sure that she is missing something really basic about Cheliax, or all of Golarion, or - maybe it's something to do with the differential in average intelligence except it's not immediately obvious to her why it would be related to that... 

"I mean, I'm not a criminal and I've never actually talked to anyone who'd made a confidential confession? I think the main deliberate incentive is that if you're later caught in a crime or accused of one, and they can go back and see that you made a confidential report before that happened, the courts will judge the crime slightly less severely." And obviously making the confession doesn't change the likelihood of being caught in any way because confidential. Merrin considers this too obvious to even have to specify. 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

So -

- is she misreading this -

- the Keepers managed to persuade the entire population that the government was so trustworthy that if people committed any crimes they could file a confidential report of that in exchange for reduced punishments if they got caught?


This is a way that Abrogail Thrune would never have imagined you could keep control of a country.  Just.  Literally never have imagined it.  She is learning so much right now.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do people ever file confidential confessions about - one of their friends having committed a crime?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"What?" Merrin is genuinely startled and upset. That's terrible! Who would do that? Why would the government have a department to enable people to do that???

"...Um. No. I - feel like I explained something badly if that seems like the same kind of thing? It's not -" nice, but that feels like it's not actually explaining the underlying thing, here, "- that's not cooperative, it's not - wanting to act in good faith. I think almost no one would want to do that and Civilization really really wouldn't want to encourage the people who for some reason do." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yeah, I guess that wouldn't be nice - sorry, it's not a custom we have here and I wasn't quite sure what the custom was."

 

Permalink Mark Unread

"- Yeah, that makes sense." Merrin...isn't sure it does? But she is sure that this conversation got way less cheerful than she was aiming for and also got even more tangential to what she's curious about, and it feels like maybe there is social awkwardness happening and she would prefer less of that? 

What are the questions that she's most desperately curious about and also make sense to ask of a student rather than a topic expert? 

"- I'm curious what growing up in Cheliax was like for you? Just - what was school like, what were your parents like, how old were you when you knew you were going to be a wizard - do you live on your own now, I'm not sure what age most people here move out of their parents' homes - what do students do for fun with each other -?"