« Back
Generated:
Post last updated:
paths we seek in vain
merrin gets a visitor
Permalink Mark Unread

It has been twenty-one planetary days since the spring equinox. 

Dawn this morning arrived at 13:22, more than five hours earlier than it used to.

The nighttime low only got down to -19° C. The afternoon high, around 34:00, peaked at 49.5° C. Judging by yesterday, it'll still be 27-28° C at dusk, and the outside temperature won't hit freezing again until after local midnight. 

Solar power production is on track to hit 4000 Wh any day now. 

 

 

 

 

Merrin has been on her exoplanet for six (local lunar) months.

42 planetary days. 2688 hours. In dath ilani reckoning, 112 days, or almost four months. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Even with all the highly optimized insulation and ventilation that Merrin has managed so far, and the afternoon high juuust starting to drop, and the fact that she's started stripping the tarp off in the middle of the night and leaving the shelter door cracked open and actively trying to get the temperature inside to below freezing by dawn, it's still gotten up to 31° C in her shelter. 

And the noon sun coincided with low tide and an enormous nearby evaporation surface, so the relative humidity outside is nearly 100%. Even with her poor abused repurposed-portable-ventilator unit blasting its maximum air pressure of colder-and-thus-lower-water-content cave air from deeper under the earth, it's still 82% humidity inside. 

28.8° C wet-bulb temperature. Survivable, for now. Pretty good, really, when the outside wet-bulb temperature is still at 47° C and would give an unprotected human heatstroke within minutes, but that does not mean that Merrin is comfortable or in a good mood.

She's overheated. She's down to exactly four meal bars held in reserve in case she gets sick or something and has been supplementing with low-calorie pouches instead. She's hungry and thirsty and incredibly tired of every single possible variation on cooked snail meat and bulbwrack "baked goods". 

 

 

She's finishing her routine suit maintenance, and mulling on a plan for her afternoon.

It's kind of a stupid plan, but Kalorm is all for it, even Laeirthe acknowledges the pragmatic expected-value benefit to her future survival prospects, and it would give her an excuse to put on her power armor and leave her stupid hot humid cave for a few hours - while the sun is still up, even - and DO SOMETHING. She's booooooooored. This is by no means the worst threat to her survival but she's sooooooo booooooooored. 

 

She checks the time. 37:55, which no longer even qualifies as late afternoon these days. Sunset won't be for another thirteen hours. But the tidal bore is due in just a couple more hours, and should bring in some cooler more refreshing air, and then she would have her window for her stupid-but-maybe-worth-it plan... 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Vicar Esta will after recent events be Stunned for several rounds and Discombobulated for some time after that.

Permalink Mark Unread

...but will eventually recover to the point of trying, more or less on total reflex, to lay a Lesser Restoration on himself.

He can't cast it, and it's not immediately obvious why.

 

So, uh.  Where is Vicar Esta and what sort of sensory impressions is he getting right now?  If it's relevant, he had an Endure Elements up and a couple of combat-related buffs.

Permalink Mark Unread

He seems to be at the bottom of a river valley with limestone walls of varying steepness, with a step-like erosion pattern. 

There's still a river in the valley, but it's a small one, with a sluggish current. Certainly the ground under his feet is thoroughly dry, baked and cracked, though the air is too humid to be a desert. 

The river is a very odd shade of deep maroon.  

The sun looks...wrong. The light is a shade too harsh, a little too on the bluish side of white. 

 

Going by the heat-shimmer, it's very hot, though if he has Endure Elements up then he will not yet be inconvenienced by the temperature of 47.8° C and nearly 100% humidity. The blueish sun, however, despite being very far away and not actually setting the landscape on fire, is also going to be steadily dealing some sort of Fire damage, noticeable within minutes of exposure. 

There's also an entrance to a cave, thataways. 

 

 

(Oh, incidentally, despite being at a sea-level pressure this air only has two-thirds as much oxygen as it should. For someone who does not have dath ilani metacognition training, and the easily available hypothesis that atmospheres will vary, this will probably not be directly noticeable until he's attempting some kind of physical exertion.) 

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

Due to his current state of Discombobulation, Esta is not thinking overwhelmingly clearly.  His current Wisdom, even with the augmentation of his headband, is below the WIS 12 required for him to successfully cast Lesser Restoration on himself.

If Esta had better introspection running, he'd notice that his cognition is generally impaired; but the thing is, it is exactly Wisdom that one would use to introspect on that sort of thing.


Esta feels exposed in these surroundings!  The CAVE looks less exposed.  What happens to him if he tries to stagger in the general direction of the cave?  In particular, what happens when he gets to the river?

Permalink Mark Unread

The river looks significantly deeper than its width, and is not quiiiite narrow enough at any point to easily jump across. The current is steady and smooth but only medium speed. If he wants to jump and land half-in the water but able to grab the opposite bank - or just to try swimming it - he could probably manage that.

(It's also quite shockingly cold, compared to the ambient air temperature, but with an Endure Elements up, neither temperature extreme is going to stand out as much.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Even in his current mentally damaged state, Esta does not feel like he wants to just jump in the water like that!

What happens if he looks around for a place where the river widens enough to be shallow or narrows enough to be jumpable?  For a couple of minutes, say.

Permalink Mark Unread

He can eventually find a spot further up, a bit past the cave, where an enormous boulder wedged deep in the sediment sticks out into the river, forming an overhang that the water mostly flows under. It's stable under his weight, though, and from there it would only be a three-meter jump at a slightly downward angle. 

 

The sun sure is dealing more Fire damage than a sun has any right to. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Back at her camp, Merrin checks the time, confirms that the tidal bore is due in the next 30 to 45 minutes, and starts donning her power armor and running through her safety checklists. 

She's still considering that she might bail out on her stupid plan, but she likes watching the wave crash in. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Hmm.  Fire damage.  From the perspective of anyone not from Cheliax, Esta has spent a surprising amount of time being on fire.  Esta lacks a proper startle reaction to this state of being.  Especially since it's the sort of fire damage you get from being slowly tortured by someone authorized to do that, rather than the sort of fire damage you get in combat as might provoke a more appropriate reaction.

It is weird that nobody is telling him to hold still and accept his punishment.

He'll try to jump the river at the boulder-point.  That seems very wise, really, given his current state of mind.  He definitely wanted to be on the other side of this river at some past point, and if you can't coordinate with your past self then who can you even coordinate with?

How does this wise life-choice work out for him?

Permalink Mark Unread

He gets a bit wet but this does not cause any unexpected additional damage. 

 

The cave is no longer actually in sight, but if he remembers which way to turn and keep walking, it'll only take him five minutes or so to backtrack along the side of the river and find the cave again. 

Permalink Mark Unread

The cave would be good.  Wait, but then he's trying to not be on fire.  Is that bad?

Nobody has told him he's supposed to be on fire.

Well, but usually when somebody sets you on fire, it's sort of implied...

Actually.

What if an unauthorized person has set him on fire?

That would be outrageous.

Esta will stride more quickly for the cave.  He's not really outraged, not in the core of his soul, but the thought has occurred to him that possibly he ought to be outraged as a good Asmodean and that is almost the same thing as having an emotion.

Permalink Mark Unread

The cave is out of the sun!


It’s pretty slimy. Moving through it without slipping is difficult, especially in the much dimmer lighting before his eyes adjust: A few meters in, there are puddles. It smells of brine and decay.

 

(The radon gas pooling in the cave today is colorless and odorless and will have no immediately obvious negative effects. The fact that it’s also displacing some of the already-lower oxygen might have noticeable effects for someone with more functional metacognition.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Hmmm.  Yes.

This looks like an Adventure Cave.

Esta will wait a bit just inside the entrance of this cave to see if anyone brings backup for him, or if... something wears off...

Oh hey he's under some kind of status effect, isn't he.  One with minutes duration, at least.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta, using more careful deliberate focus this time, is going to cast Detect Magic to see if he can see what sort of magical effect is affecting him.

He doesn't see any magic on himself that's not supposed to be there.

He does successfully cast the Detect Magic.


Esta tries again with Lesser Restoration.  If there's anything impeding his Wisdom, he'd like it gone or reduced, please.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

...WHAT THE ABYSS JUST HAPPENED TO HIM (and to Worldwound Fortress #14) and WHERE THE ABYSS IS HE?

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin, at this point, is departing her shelter and heading for the riverbank, equipped with her safety-checklist pouch of emergency supplies in case she manages to injure herself or her armor has a problem and she gets stranded.

Permalink Mark Unread

Vicar Esta has now pulled from his Bag a Continual Flame skullcap -- not the sort of magical skullcap that might interfere with his headband, just some minor jewelry to light his way -- and is now looking at least the next layer deeper into this pleasant, out-of-the-burning-sun cave.  He does not have a huge number of skill ranks in Survival (Exoplanets) but he knows that pleasant little caves are often inhabited by things powerful enough to take and hold them -- though the victors of caves are not usually 6th-circle Asmodean cleric amounts of scary.

Esta is proceeding carefully nonetheless, but in the sense of looking around for dangerous predators as he goes, not so much in the sense of carrying a radiation detector with him.

Permalink Mark Unread

Actually, this cave is remarkably clear of anything mobile and larger than a worm!

 

Some of the tidepools have shelled mollusks very firmly adhered to the bottom. There are tiny creepy-crawlies in the damp rotting piles of debris. One tidepool has segmented armored centipede-worm-fish creatures with very faint blue-green bioluminescence.

Other than that, it's really pretty much limited to slime. 

 

(And a tidepool holding a woven cage full of giant snails, but that's further in and around two corners.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin reaches the top of the riverbank and perches on a pile of rocks. (She only brings her wicker chair and sun-slash-rain-shade out when she's using them, to minimize rate of UV degradation.) 

 

There's a line of white breaking at the edge of the line of purple, in the distance. Ten minutes, she thinks. She'll know it's due in four to five minutes when she starts hearing the roar and feeling the vibration through her boots. 

(Imaginary Kalorm thinks it's majestic and delightful.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta has nowhere near the ranks in Survival (Weird Fucking Caves) to deduce where on Golarion he got Teleported to, he isn't a Cave Druid.  He is not going to get remotely far enough from his starting point that he would run the tiniest chance of getting lost while mentally impaired.  He is just checking to make sure that he is not immediately next to a vampire apartment complex or an alghollthu student enrichment center.

Having done that part, he's going to move closer to the cave entrance; and then, on his current plan, he is going to pull a Sending scroll, and start the 10-minute process of calling for help.

Permalink Mark Unread

He will get about six of those minutes with nothing in particular happening, and then there is going to be a Very Ominous Roar in the distance - the downstream distance - accompanied by a vibration he can feel in his bones through the stone. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, NOW what.  Really, Esta has been having enough of a bad day already.

Esta carefully disentangles his fingers from the Sending scroll's spell structure, letting the stored magic be pulled back into the page's expensive inks; and then strides quickly outside the cave to look.

Permalink Mark Unread

Nothing is visibly happening, yet, at least not from where he’s standing!

(The tidal bore, today when it’s approaching the monthly spring tide, moves at well over 60 kilometers per hour. At the point when he can see the wave from his current location, he’ll only have seconds left to get out of the way.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is maybe 200 meters further downstream, on the opposite bank, and sitting down. He might notice an armored figure, if he looks in the right direction, but it wouldn’t be trivial.

Merrin, unfortunately, is herself looking out to sea, and not back upstream.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, he is going to look all around for any visible sources of current problems, and he is going to do this while standing in the shade with a Continual Flame lamp on his head.  Probably also Detect Magic while he's at it, if Merrin would stand out on account of being such a magical person (and gets inside the 60ft detection radius).

Permalink Mark Unread

Neither Merrin nor her power armor nor her other gear would show up to Detect Magic, even if the latter from a Golarion perspective really look like they should, and also she's out of range.

 

There is a distant humanoid figure there, though, silhouetted against the horizon - 

 

 

- and Merrin is intimately familiar with her little river valley, and she does habitually scan her surroundings a bit even when she has literally no reason to expect anything interesting to happen over there because this planet has no terrestrial life larger than worms. 

At some point her peripheral vision catches a flash of...something...and she instinctively twists her head to look - 

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

That doesn't - what - 

 

 

Even as an unusually strong face-recognizer, Merrin is too far away to be sure she can recognize a face from here, when the person in question is standing in the shadow of the danger cave (were they in the danger cave?? why would they do that??), but there's a flash of familiarity, it's just that it's taking her kind of a long time to place because it is COMPLETELY OUT OF CONTEXT and WHAT and HOW and WHY– 

Permalink Mark Unread

Not that it actually matters exactly who just appeared on her horrible exoplanet in EXACTLY THE WRONG PLACE at the WORST POSSIBLE TIME. 

 

(Superheated toilet paper were they in the cave this whole time, last time Merrin checked the radon levels were really high for some reason and her sensors were already picking up on it within five meters of the entrance...) 

 

She's on her feet and running. 

Permalink Mark Unread

- and toggling the mode on the power armor where it will project her voice from a speaker, since otherwise she's basically inaudible from inside it. 

 

"GET OUT OF THE RIVER CHANNEL!" she shouts. In Baseline. "TIDE INCOMING! THIRTY METER WAVE!" 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

She's pretty sure she's not going to cover two hundred meters of uneven treacherous limestone ground and then get herself all the way down the bank before the wave arrives, no matter how reckless she is about falling. Let alone drag someone back up it. 

She's also not at all sure it's possible for a person hearing her warning now to make it all the way up the bank in time, at this point. It still takes her half an hour and they've got less than four minutes. But she's still going to try to warn him. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, that sure is an armored foreign adventurer yelling something that she thinks is very alarming, in a magically amplified voice; and that in turn is broadly the act of someone trying to be helpful, or pretending to helpfulness.  If genuinely helpful, either they recognize the Worldwound armor or they don't recognize the Asmodeanism.

"SPEAK TALDANE!" he'll yell as loud as he can.

He will already be pulling a Comprehend Languages scroll from his Holding Bag in case that doesn't work.

Permalink Mark Unread

(Merrin is also spectacularly confused and upset and mad at Reality right now, but none of those are productive emotions to dwell on and they can go somewhere else out of her way. She's good at that. It turns out she hasn't lost the knack even after months of solitude.) 

 

...His voice is lost under the roar more than hers, but she can make it out enough to tell that he sounds familiar too. 

She's abruptly more sure of her face-recognizer flash of identification. And more confused and upset and she STILL DOESN'T HAVE TIME FOR THAT focus focus focus - 

 

Except she...can't understand any of what he just shouted back to her...? Even though it feels like she should have heard enough to catch it? 

"ESTHA! NOW IS NOT THE TIME FOR CONLANGS!* GET OUT OF THE CHANNEL!" she screams. 

 

(Her voice is...also going to sound kind of familiar, to Esta, even with the slightly distortion from the amplication. And the name she shouted wasn't quite the same pronunciation as his, but could be mistaken for it.) 


*This is a shorter phrase in Baseline because "now is not the time (for ____)" is a two-syllable word. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...okay Esta is suddenly much MORE worried about what all got damaged BESIDES his Wisdom, because his brain thinks that is Mariona in unfamiliar armor and speaking in an unfamiliar language and accent.  And he doesn't know if that's because his befuddled mind is incorrectly identifying all other humanoids as Mariona, or if seeing something out of the Dark Tapestry rewrote his brain's native language into something that is not Taldane.

He will, nonetheless, cast Comprehend Languages from scroll, which takes him about six seconds, and then yell back still in Taldane, "SAY THAT AGAIN?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, Merrin still didn't understand that, and she's now assigning higher likelihood that he was in fact inexplicably yelling in a conlang she's never heard before and it's not just her auditory processing failing.

(And her brain is still forming increasing certainty that he looks and sounds like her boyfriend Estha even though she does not even slightly have a theory for how or why he could possibly be on her exoplanet. Whatever he's wearing isn't even something her brain considers counterevidence, it's super doompunk but, like, it's Estha, he would.) 

 

She doesn't need a specific prompt to keep repeating the obvious warning in slightly different words, though. 

(She's not going to bother trying to warn him about the radioactive cave that he just left, or the UV, or the oxygen, those are not the priority right now - is he just confused and hypoxic because he was in the cave and it's having a bad enough radon-accumulation day to actually displace oxygen, it wouldn't be direct radiation sickness symptoms yet unless he was in there for multiple hours -)

 

"CLIMB TO HIGHER GROUND!" she shouts. "TIDAL BORE INCOMING! LESS THAN TWO MINUTES!" Maybe he can still make it, she's telling herself, though he's really in the wrong place for it, if he were on the opposite side of the tidal flats the stepped limestone bank would be pretty climbable, but near the cave it's really not...

 

Baseline is in many ways an incredibly weird language by Golarion standards, but the content of Merrin's warning is pretty straightforward. The only immediately-obvious linguistic differences that come across are that 'tidal bore' would be a much longer phrase in Taldane, something like "rising-ocean-tide-compressed-to-increase-speed-and-amplitude", and the time warning has some uncertainty quantifiers covered in the grammar, something like - it could be longer than two minutes, it's not her 99% confidence interval, but her 50% confidence interval is around or under two minutes, such that in a situation where it would be very costly to be wrong he should be rounding it to a hard deadline.

(Also the strongly imperative tense linguistically encodes something like a claim-to-authority, the sense that this is a phrasing where the speaker is speaking as some kind of expert who is taking charge of a situation due to having the relevant expertise - who in fact is specifically qualified to take the lead when an emergency is in progress - and who now expects and intends the listener to immediately follow her short clear instructions without asking clarifying questions until afterward, but it's sort of hard to unpack complicated linguistic implications in seconds under the circumstances.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

All the complicated nuances of 'tidal bore' are not, actually, going to be conveyed into Esta's brain by a cute little 1st-circle spell.  Maybe you get that off 4th-circle Tongues but you do not get it off Comprehend Languages.

Esta has grasped that the canyon is about to flood.  He has not grasped the part of the compound Baseline word that invokes a mathematical concept about how compressing a passage increases the speed and amplitude of fluids traversing it according to a particular quantitative rule.

 

Spells which are unfortunately not part of the standard Worldwound loadout:  Water Breathing (3rd-circle for both clerics and wizards, 2 hours / caster level).

Items which are unfortunately not part of the standard Worldwound loadout:  Necklace of Adaptation (list price 9000gp, albeit in a price catalogue that is less than totally 100% trustworthy about what things would cost if you were not buying them from that particular merchant network).

Esta's Bag does have an emergency Air Bubble scroll, but it'll last, like, literally 1 minute.  It is a cheap-ass 1st-circle scroll that you carry because "it costs only 25gp", not because it is part of a clever advance strategy that requires you have an Air Bubble lasting 3 minutes instead.

Still, that ought to be enough to swim to the surface if this canyon floods...?  Timing the cast might be hard, though.  He thinks those time units sounded like "less than (somewhere around 2 minutes)" but Comprehend Languages is not really gonna do precise math for you.

 

Esta will give himself a 3-minute Bull's Strength, which is going to take him another 6 seconds after he pulls that cheapass scroll, so he can swim while in armor.  And then, sure, start trying to clamber up the least steep ascent he can find, with his augmented strength.  That'll save him some effort on swimming to the surface later.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Okay, Merrin has no idea why Estha won't answer her in superheated Baseline and is insisting on speaking a conlang, and her only hypothesis is ??hypoxia?? which is not actually an explanation.

Especially when he's suddenly making rapid progress up the limestone slope! Wow! Merrin could maybe do that, but she's an endurance-specialized Exception Handling medtech, and she's not sure she could have done it when she wasn't acclimatized to the oxygen levels yet, let alone wearing what sure looks like unpowered armor for a doompunk costume rather than her very expensive Exception Handling gear. Did he start working out after she– not left. After her True Death in a plane crash. That's all he would have known until like sixty seconds ago. He's also got to be really, really confused - did he permanently die too, is the deal here that True Death is not actually a thing and actually you just respawn on exoplanets - why would Reality work that way it's so stupid focus focus focus. 

 

Merrin is still herself covering ground as fast as she can, even though there's no way she's going to make it to his location in the time she has, it'll still better to be separated by fewer meters. 

She is not, in fact, planning to go any further down the bank than the high-water line she anticipates for a near-to-spring-tide tidal bore, plus a couple of meters of space for error. She can see a lot better from here, and if he's fine then he'll be fine on the opposite bank and they can awkwardly shout at each other until the water settles a little and she can safely swim over to him without getting swept 500 meters upstream in the attempt. And if he's not fine, then - well - she hasn't actually decided if she would jump into a tidal bore wave after him because surely the most likely consequence is a Stupid Accident and neither of them making it out of the river but–

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin's power armor is not, actually, specifically design to let her run faster than an unaided human; it also doesn't let her lift 1000 kg rocks or anything. There are engineering tradeoffs, in power armor design, and hers is meant to be maneuverable and powerful in water, and to provide her with some protection against blunt force trauma, and to still be a weight that she could conceivably carry a short distance if it had a mechanical problem and the power assist stopped working, and most of all its entire design philosophy is optimized around eking out as many hours as it possibly can on a single battery charge.

And the terrain is awful for moving fast; Merrin is used to it, and she's calibrated enough on what she can pull off that she hasn't fallen, but she's needed to slow down several times to navigate all the areas of jagged hand-sized thermally-cracked shards of limestone that would shift underfoot and send her pitching over if she were running at full speed.

 

...She's already sweating inside her armor, which is now pinging a gentle alarm that it's already running maximum cooling and cannot run it any harder. This is expected; the outside temperature is 43° C and the humidity is almost 100% and it's simply flat-out not specced for those conditions. 

 

(You could totally solve it by jumping into the tide! Imaginary Kalorm pipes up hopefully. Save your boyfriend AND avoid heatstroke! How can you say no to that?) 

Permalink Mark Unread

The moon's position, the prevailing winds over the ocean, recent rain drainage, etc etc etc, are all working against Merrin, here. 

The wavefront, by the time it approaches them after squeezing its way through over a kilometer of narrowing river-channel walls, is moving at 70 kilometers per hour, which is 19 meters per second. It's rapidly growing in height, as several billion liters of water try to squirt down a channel which at its base, at the point where Esta is trying to climb, is only a few hundred meters wide. 

 

Also, the walls of the river channel around the cave are not straight, and there are several enormous boulders lodged deep into the sediment by even greater tides in even greater storms than the ones Merrin has seen yet. Esta's view more than a hundred meters down the channel is blocked, and the wave will cross a hundred meters in approximately 5 seconds. 

Permalink Mark Unread

If Merrin tries to turn around and look behind her then she will fall on her face like a fool and possibly manage to topple head-over-heels down 40 meters of stepped limestone directly into the wavefront. 

 

In theory her armor, among its many functionalities, has a rear camera with a head's-up display in her helmet. It's pretty good at catching, like, unexpected movement behind her.

The small projected image taking up less than a quarter of her visual field is not great for estimating exact speeds and distances. She's not going to try to give Estha a countdown, anyway, because her model of how people function in emergencies does not think this would cause him to climb any faster. 

 

But she does recognize the point at which it's really, obviously, too late for her to reach him. 

She stops trying to run. She's almost level with his position, anyway, maybe only thirty meters downstream (or, well, very soon to be temporarily upstream.) 

 

"INCOMING!" she shouts. "STOP AND HOLD ON!" 

It's a really stupid instruction. Her mouth just sort of said it before she had vetted the content. He wouldn't be able to hold onto the rocks even if they came with perfectly designed grip-handles, because humans cannot actually do that against forces like the ones involved here. But Merrin's model of people reacting in emergencies is that they're more likely to stay calm if there's a simple instruction along with a warning and so apparently her brain insisted on generating one. 

Permalink Mark Unread

(Also, this isn't why, because Merrin could not even slightly figure out what he was doing before with the whatever-it-was he was holding, and she doesn't have the slightest idea that Esta might now need to do anything to prepare that would take exactly six seconds. But she's calling it out long enough in advance that he will have, like, ten seconds in total between her shout and when the wall of water hits.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

She is calling in tones of authority, instruction, and demand, of him; words that make no sense even with Comprehend Languages.  But combined with the roaring sound of water, he'll guess she should be calling for round buffs, and he'll start casting his one-minute Air Bubble.

He won't stop or lose his casting, even when he sees that this is really quite a lot of water moving very fast, and realizes too late that he needed more buffs.

Esta will not try to grab a rock.  It is very clear he could not hold to it.  Esta will try to grab his Bag of Holding, instead, because that above all else needs to not come loose from his belt.

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

(Merrin is so confused and has no idea what he's even trying to do and, from her perspective, he is definitely about to get knocked unconscious via violent impact with something and then drown in a totally normal length of time.) 

 

This is such a bad idea. If she gets smashed into rocks hard enough it might actually break her armor / or give her a concussion, the helmet will protect her from skull fractures but not the g-forces her brain would be subjected to inside her skull from an abrupt stop - and then she, also, will just drown. 

 

 

...The imaginary voice of Laeirthe is, surprisingly, not against it? She's not getting anything very clear - it always takes time and effort to run the mental voice of Laeirthe providing input - but it's - 

 

 

- this is the only thing she's done in six planetary months that has real stakes, affecting anyone but herself - 

 

 

Yeah okay shit she's jumping into a 30-meter, 70-kilometer-per-hour tidal bore.

...In a few seconds, once the main body of water is below her and she can probably actually get enough clearance in a really big leap not to just land on the sloping bank further down. (If she climbs down the bank it'll take her at least a minute even if she's moving recklessly fast, which is long enough for him to be way ahead of her and her chances of finding him quickly enough are minuscule. If she's going to be reckless, she might as well commit.) 

 

Caaaaaaaan she manage to keep her eyes on him even slightly after the water hits? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, his Continual Flame skullcap does come with a neck strap... which looks undignified, and also makes your life worse if some creature swoops out of a cave ceiling and tries to grab the Continual Flame.  So Esta did not do up the neck strap inside the cave.  If somebody had given Esta more than one and a half moments of notice, or told him about impending rescue from a foreign adventurer his brain thinks is Mariona, Esta might have done up the neck strap to greatly improve the ease of tracking him in water.

Maybe she's got Detect Magic?  That would make him pretty easy to locate regardless.  He has got various magic items on him, and his incredibly expensive back-of-head-band in particular stays on his head Just Because rather than for reasons associated with physics.

So Esta has not done up his neck strap in order to make it easier for Mariona to locate him.

 

He has instead done up the neck strap earlier, just in order to not lose the Continual Flame once he is underwater; and secured a few of his other items about himself, or put the heaviest ones (like his mace) into his wonderful weight-reducing Holding Bag, while he was trying to clamber uphill.  The point is, maybe-Mariona's minimal conveyance of information was suboptimal, this happened by luck rather than due to any skill of hers, and if this actually is Mariona, Esta will no doubt have words for her later while they are going through the after-action report.  Words and pain.

Anyway!  Let's consider the effect of water moving at 19 meters per second, impacting on a 6th-circle cleric.

Permalink Mark Unread

Creation thinks of fall damage as something that grows linearly with distance.  This is in fact completely sensible, given the way that potential energy and kinetic energy work; though it's anyone's guess about whether that's why Creation works that way.  The primordial inevitables who set the rules sometimes got up to some pretty strange stuff.

So how far would you need to fall, to impact into water with a relative speed of 19 meters per second?

You will have been falling downward for a bare bit less than 2 seconds, for a start; after accelerating downward at 9.8 meters per second per second, as is one standard Golarion gravity.

Integral calculus too simple to bother with will tell you that if your velocity is increasing linearly with time, then your average velocity over that time is half its final value; extended over a bit less than 2 seconds, you'll have fallen a bit less than 19 meters.  The resulting calculation, if you do it exactly, works out to baaarely over 60 feet; which is unfortunate, because Esta will take an additional 1d6 damage that he wouldn't have taken if it had been 59.9 feet instead.  If that strikes you as unreasonable, go talk to the primordial inevitables about it.


The first 20 feet of falling into water do no damage.

The next 20 feet of falling into water do 1d3 of nonlethal damage per 10 feet.  Esta takes 4 nonlethal damage.

And then everything else does 1d6 of damage per 10 feet.  Esta takes 7 damage.

 

Esta has 87 hitpoints.

Permalink Mark Unread

And a Heal banked.  That is part of the Worldwound loadout for 6th circles.  Heal handles a very wide variety of possible problems, and has no material component to make it any more expensive than the cost of the spell itself; meaning that Heal is hugely more cost-effective to do via 'actual 6th circle cleric onsite' rather than by scroll or item.  Scrolls are for things you need only sometimes.  If it's going to predictably be useful almost every time, it goes in the standard spell loadout.

Esta would've cast Heal on himself to get rid of possible other status conditions, if he'd made until next dawn and spell-prayers, but he did not quite deem it Wise to use it up on himself right away.

Permalink Mark Unread

Uh-huh.

Anyway, the actual problem is going to be the rapid waters that repeatedly smash Esta into nearby rocks, thereby breaking his arms and legs and mildly fracturing his skull.

Which still would only be a very brief and temporary problem for Esta and his Cure loadout.

 

Except for the part where it's hard to use spells with somatic components when you have broken arms.

So!  Has he been knocked unconscious yet?

Permalink Mark Unread

Do not be insulting.  This barely even qualifies as pain.

He's not swimming very hard, though.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin saw enough of the first rock-smash for her rapid internal calculus to be concluding that this is probably...not...very survivable.

And she doesn't have cryo facilities on this STUPID PLANET because GUESS WHAT MERRIN DID NOT PRIORITIZE EVEN SLIGHTLY in the last six months.

(She can do emergency preparation for cryo with stuff she has, because that would very plausibly have come up in the training sims that all of those lovely crates of gear were SUPPOSED to be equipping her for. Or, rather, she could have on arrival. Now she's dismantled a bunch of her specific-use medical equipment, with specific uses that make no sense to ever need to use on herself, for their motors and wires and reprogrammable electronics that can form part of her automated cave-safety-and-climate control or be replacement components for power armor repair. There’s not actually any point of doing initial preparation that relies on "and then a helicopter shows up within less than six hours to take her patient to a specialized facility”.) 

 

That thought goes through her mind in under a second and is set aside because it's not actually relevant to what she does in the next sixty seconds. 

 

She flings herself off the bank with as much force as she can and...in fact falls around 19 meters into water. 

Permalink Mark Unread

OW

 

 

(But Merrin was expecting this, and is landing feet first - a headfirst dive is just an incredibly stupid idea from that height even in armor - with her legs clamped together and arms crossed and chin down, and she has a sealed air supply, and the highly-engineered composite material and lining of her power armor do some impact-redirection. It's 'ow' but she's not injured.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Armor reconfigured to aquatic mode (it's mostly the retractable flippers, which you don't want to be extended when you hit the water feet-first with great force). Merrin gets herself angled so she's streamlined. She dodges a rock - she has a lot more maneuverability than someone in unpowered armor that is not designed for swimming in Extra Challenging Conditions, and also she's really familiar with this river, even if she normally rides the less intense post-tidal-bore current back inland. 

Can she see anything? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Lol 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

She's on the totally wrong side of the channel, and at least fifty meters behind where she last saw Estha - assuming he's moving at roughly the same forward speed as her, they are both in short order going to be, like, kilometers upstream of her camp - and her visibility is maybe five meters. 

 

Merrin power-swims diagonally across the river channel, not fighting the current exactly - its main direction is forward, she wants to go forward, she and the water are in agreement on that - but combatting the turbulence that wants to toss her around in random non-forward directions. 

 

And she switches on her very powerful Headlamp: Underwater Search Mode. 

(It's not as powerful as a searchlight on a helicopter, because even the cleverest engineering cannot really make that possible as one component of many in a suit not much heavier than Merrin herself. It's still drawing enough wattage to substantially reduce her active battery life if she just leaves it on for no reason. But she's going to be using it for, like, ten minutes max. If she hasn't found Estha in an entire ten minutes then she's looking for a dead body, not someone she can still save.)  

Permalink Mark Unread

Even a Very Powerful Searchlight cannot just solve the fact that the water is pretty murky with algae and sediment and all the bubbles. But she can see a lot further than five meters, and it penetrates a lot more meters of water than the light of a Continual Flame skullcap, which will be a help to Merrin only once she gets substantially closer than this. 

Permalink Mark Unread

(It's not part of Merrin's model that the light-up hat the man she currently believes is probably her dath ilani boyfriend was wearing is going to still be working. She's assuming it was a normal electronic-battery-powered costume accessory and is not going to appreciate all the forces or all the wetness involved.) 

 

 

She's now closer to the center of the river channel, which had narrowed to barely fifty meters at one point and is now actually wider and shallower again, in a section of riverbed with somewhat fewer giant boulders wedged deep in the sediment. Convenient for her; the water that's made it through that chokepoint is now spreading out and slowing down a bit and there are fewer obstacles to waste time and energy dodging.

(Or from Esta's perspective, to crash into.) 

It feels like it's been about five minutes but, in fact, it's been 42 seconds. 

With all the tossed-up silt the water is carrying, Merrin's headlamp can penetrate thirty meters of water, which is not quite enough to see either bank from where she is, but is enough to see clear to the bottom of the channel; the portion behind the wavefront is sloshing wildly but is on average only about five meters deep at this point. 

 

CAN SHE SEE HIM???? 

Permalink Mark Unread

No, but he will see a light distantly piercing through the water, on one occasion when he forces his eyes open; and he will... sorta maybe slightly try to move in that direction by flailing his upper arms and upper thighs and ignoring the pain that comes with that?

Honestly, Esta has taken a lot of nonlethal damage at this point, and as much lethal damage again as that, and a few more knocks on the head.  Even he is starting to feel like it might be a good time for a nap.

Permalink Mark Unread

- what was that? 

 

Merrin is actually pretty unsure if she actually saw anything, looking for "movement" in the water is kind of difficult when the water, itself, is still moving very fast even past the river-channel chokepoint. It might just have been a dislodged strapwrack holdfast getting knocked around. 

But it's a direction to try swimming in. Merrin will swim that way, angling her headlamp back and forth a bit, scanning the water as hard as she can for solid shapes larger than a strapwrack holdfast that might even be human-shaped. 

 

(The one-minute mark since Vicar Esta cast Air Bubble from his scroll passes, not that Merrin has any way of knowing this would be relevant.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

It would've been nice to have the leisure to look at his pocket-watch and precisely time that, so he could inhale deeply just as the spell ended.

He will hold what breath he happens to have, though.  It's not a bad reason to stay awake a little longer.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is COMING she's ALMOST THERE - 

 

 

- nevermind she's briefly redirecting nearly all of her attention to not getting beaned by a collision with a boulder in her path, she was distracted and did not see it more than five seconds in advance - 

 

 

- she dodges, successfully, but it involves some very frantic underwater-gymnastics and now she is tumbling through the water, trying to reorient her sense of direction - 

 

The river is finally cooperating with her, here. Relatively speaking. The water speed is down to only 20 kph in this section of riverbed, and the bottom here is more gravel than silt, with less sediment to disturb and make the water murkier, and they're both now well behind the actual tidal bore wavefront - her maximum headland visibility is more like 40 meters - 

It's still going to take her another thirty seconds to be sure she has her eyes on him again, and then at least thirty seconds after that to actually catch up to his position. 

(She's counting seconds passing. It's going to be coming up to two minutes. Two minutes is not necessarily an anoxic-brain-injury length of time by itself - assuming that somehow he hasn't just smashed his skull open on the rocks by now and made that the least of the brain-damage-causing problems - but she cannot start CPR in the MIDDLE OF A RIVER and she's not even sure how long it might take her to reach the bank carrying someone -) 

Permalink Mark Unread

He's mostly focusing on holding his breath, at this point, instead of performing the Strenuous Activity of trying to flail his broken limbs.

RAW says:  2 x CON = 26 rounds, two and a half minutes of breath-holding.

After that, Constitution checks starting from DC 10 and increasing in DC by 1 each round, to keep holding your breath, which is a couple of rounds if Esta is lucky.

He might not, like, totally get all of that, under these conditions.

 

RAW says you suffocate to death 3 rounds after you start breathing water.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin will, perhaps, also not be able to actually reach him as efficiently as she would in less adverse water conditions. 

(Merrin is not aware of the existence of Endure Elements and is expecting him to additionally be incapacitated by the icy water, which is warmer than it was in late winter but "warmer" is still, like, maybe 6° C. At least her suit cooling problem is very thoroughly solved). 

 

STUPID RIVER!!!! STUPID OCEAN!!!! STUPID PLANET!!!!!! MERRIN HATES YOU SO MUCH RIGHT NOW!!!!!

Permalink Mark Unread

She does, actually, reach him around 15 seconds after the point at which he failed the Constitution check to keep holding his breath any longer, but she's focused on grabbing him securely in a way that won't make the severe blunt-trauma internal injuries she assumes he definitely has immediately worse, and not on getting both of them to the surface within the next three seconds exactly, because from Merrin's perspective it has already been more than three minutes and a ten-second difference in when she can start CPR is going to make less of a difference to his survival odds than, like, if he has a spinal fracture but hasn't quite severed his spinal cord yet and she fucks that up. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

That worked??? She leapt directly into a 30-meter tidal bore moving at 70 kilometers per hour after a drowning person, and she did NOT get herself killed and is not even really injured (she's going to have some bruises for sure but nothing is broken) and she CAUGHT UP and GOT HIM and eeeee!

 

Merrin will allow herself one (1) second of internal !!!!!!!! and ✨ ✨ ✨ and a feeling that might be described as "wow she did not know she was actually that cool!" 

 

(I seriously don't know what's wrong with you and your self-image, imaginary Kalorm grumbles. You're like the only cool person in dath ilan who isn't related to me.)

 

Merrin is ignoring that, because she's still in the MIDDLE OF A RIVER and every second is taking her five meters further away from camp and it's now time to book it to shore as fast as she can.

(She can check for a pulse while swimming and carrying him, though)

Permalink Mark Unread

Is it... not the case that any humanoid who can't breathe water, regardless of how long they were or weren't holding their breath before then, would die (presumably with associated cardiac arrest) exactly 18 seconds after they started inhaling water?

Because if not, Creation is confused!  Creation is pretty sure that's how primordial inevitables imagined biology ought to work, albeit possibly without ever having actually seen a humanoid.  If Merrin's sheer presence and force of belief is mandating Reality to have more complex rules than that, in this faraway place where the primordial inevitables may well be paying less close attention, she needs to go explain on her own how she thinks biology ought to work.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well! In this case Merrin would be pretty unsurprised at the absence of a pulse, because she thinks he's been unconscious and submerged for three minutes!

 

But, in fact, her detailed and confident model of human physiology predicts that someone who has just lost consciousness and aspirated a bunch of water - and is already in respiratory arrest and will not spontaneously start breathing on their own if brought to the surface, which is an entirely plausible outcome within eighteen seconds - would still, from that point, take somewhere between one and three minutes to progress to full cardiac arrest, simply because they're starting out with some oxygen still in their blood and that doesn't immediately drop all the way to zero that's not how things work, and there's a gap between the degree of hypoxia that causes unconsciousness - the brain specifically is an energy-hungry organ - and the level at which the heart stops working.

It might go faster on a planet with lower atmosphere oxygen levels, for someone unacclimatized to it. It might take longer in cold water, because hypothermia slows metabolism and thus the consumption of the remaining oxygen in their blood, but of course that part of her model is completely failing to account for the existence of Endure Elements. 

(That being said, these are super adverse conditions, and whether or not a weak pulse is still present at this point, finding it when they're both being jostled around in the water is a pretty high Concentration check even for Merrin, and she's not going to try for much longer than ten seconds because her top priority is reaching the shore.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

(More than half of Merrin's attention right now is going toward trying to spot a candidate location to get out of the river. This would not at all be a problem if she were on her own! The banks are easily climbable in her power armor! But they're steep, and currently really slippery from the spray that the tidal bore sent up when it passed through this area several minutes ago, and there's no way she's getting herself up to the plateau in less than ten minutes while carrying someone. That's way too long!! She needs an even-vaguely-flattish spot near the current water level that she can drag her unconscious boyfriend onto in, like, at most another thirty seconds. She can worry about everything else - climbing up the bank and getting out of the path of the still-risng tide, and then the fact that she's at least 1500 meters upstream of her campsite and the walk would be entirely over horrible rocky karst terrain - after she gets him breathing on his own.) 

(If that happens. Merrin is tracking that it might just be too late. He looks...remarkably uninjured, actually...he's obviously pretty bruised and bleeding from multiple abrasions after the collisions with rocks, but his skull isn't visibly deformed or crushed. She would be feeling cautiously optimistic if she had medical facilities. In fact, the situation is worse than that, because she packed for upriver exploration and cave-searching. She brought a bunch of first aid supplies that would make sense for her to use on herself if she were to be seriously injured - but still conscious and able to treat herself, there was not actually any point in planning much for situations where she ended up unconscious or completely incapacitated - and she did NOT pack for needing to resuscitate a patient in hypoxic cardiac arrest while completely on her own.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

This horrifying metaphysics in which people are not either Alive or Dead but instead have a variety of internal properties and conditions corresponding to particular forms of gloop inside their body, such that they could be a little dead or mostly dead without being all dead -- well, let's be frank here, this is necromancer pornography.  Nobody like this Merrin person is going to be clericed by Pharasma anytime soon!

But if this is the dominant view on how reality operates, Vicar Esta is going to be only very slightly dead at most upon emerging from the water.  Like, the sort of dead where he's stopped breathing, not the sort where his heart has stopped, taking this entire set of horrifying metaphysical premises at face value.

Be it very clear, a standard Breath of Life spell will do nothing here.  It has been longer than one round!  Now if this 'Merrin' entity has some sort of Breath of Life-like supernatural ability -- for reviving entities who are, on her own alien view of things, particular kinds of partially dead -- that is between her, and wherever her god is now.

Permalink Mark Unread

…Merrin thought she might have found a pulse just then, for a couple of seconds before the water jostled her fingers out of position and she lost it. 

 

She's not drawing any confident conclusions, let alone making any emotional updates, until she's on some kind of solidish ground - her focus now is on where to find that around here - 

Permalink Mark Unread

A rock! A flattish rock! Not yet submerged! But close to the waterline, such that she can clamber up onto it dragging an unconscious person without too much difficulty!

 

 

Merrin has been isolated and lonely and trying not to go completely insane from all of that, and one of her strategies has been letting the silly anthropomorphizing parts of her savannah-hominid brain go do their thing a bit. Not too much, she's not confused about physical reality or whether rocks have experiences or intentions, but...a little bit. 

Thank you, rock, she thinks, and then - ugh, she can't grab it, she's using both hands right now - she'll turn herself around and deliberately crash herself into it, taking the impact across the back of her suit (ow) (she'll need to do a careful maintenance survey for damage but she hasn't broken anything in her body, she'll just have some impressive bruises) but mostly cushioning her patient from it. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

It's a really stupid place to stay for longer than five or ten minutes, because the tide is still rising and the high-water line is probably ten meters above her current position and her estimate is that the rock will be completely underwater in less than twenty minutes. 

Well. She'll just have to try to not be here in twenty minutes. But right now the rock is exactly where Merrin needs it to be, and she takes half a second to pat it in gratitude for existing in the perfect place at exactly the time she needed it. 

 

- check for a pulse properly

Permalink Mark Unread

The burst of relief and joy that Merrin feels, in that moment, is possibly the single strongest positive emotion that Merrin has experienced in the last six planetary months. 

Permalink Mark Unread

(She's also a little surprised, but not really confused per se. It doesn't violate her model of physical reality that someone could still have a faint-but-palpable pulse after like three and a half minutes of submersion.) 

 

...Okay but he's still not breathing, which means that Merrin now has to solve the STUPIDEST PROBLEM. She's been aware of it since before she caught up to him, because in a rescue scenario she's always thinking multiple steps ahead for multiple contingencies. 

The problem is that Merrin did not pack with the assumption that she would be rescuing anyone but herself.

And so she has oxygen, but only in her suit tanks. She even has some improvised adaptors and tubing that would let her hook up an oxygen cannula to inside her suit, if for some reason she had to take it off to repair it and also at the same time she was having a respiratory problem (since under remotely normal circumstances she would simply not need extra oxygen, she's fully acclimatized to the atmosphere now.) 

She does not have a setup to provide artificial ventilation from her suit reservoir, because why in the world would she have that, if Merrin were at any point not breathing on her own then she would definitely not be in any shape to do anything about it to rescue herself, right. 

She can unseal her helmet and do mouth-to-mouth ventilation - if she tanks the risk that he might have radon gas in his lungs, but since she grabbed him her suit sensors have not actually detected any radioactivity, so probably he didn't go very far into the cave or didn't stay for very long and only took a small dose to his lungs, one she can't actually detect from outside his chest cavity - but the stupid problem. Is that normally this works because, when one is breathing 21%-oxygen air, the exhaled air still has about 16% oxygen, which is far from ideal but is, like, at all workable. But right now Merrin is breathing 13.5% oxygen air, and her exhaled air will have, like, 8% oxygen probably, and that's well into the Death Zone-equivalent-altitude when converted to a partial pressure and is simply not workable at all. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin's solution is also stupid but it's not complicated. 

 

 

She dials the oxygen concentration of the air her suit is giving her to 100%. (She overrides two alarms asking her if she's really, really sure she wants to do that - from the suit's perspective, for literally no reason, her own vitals are fine.) 

She takes the biggest breath she can manage. 

She unseals the helmet, still holding her breath - and inevitably wastes multiple liters of O2 in the process, but her tank is starting out full - and she can get, like, three rescue breaths, enough to see his chest rise, and then hold her breath and wait for five seconds and do it again - before she has to put the helmet back on again to get more air (which is a fifteen-second interruption but that's not unworkably long...) 

She's really hoping she won't have to do this for too long, because she's driving her own PaO2 insanely high in the process and it's making her feel Weird, but it works. 

Permalink Mark Unread

He's got a +4 Constitution belt, though not one that began from a very lofty beginning, and started out with 87 HP -- in Merrin's terms, a frankly inhuman ability to resist damage that isn't suffocation -- and also there's a Ring of Sustenance firmly on one finger, and an Amulet of Natural Armor that's firmly beneath his regular armor.  He has been tossed around some, indeed, but he's not dead, or close to dead, from that.  It is impossible that there would be any non-drowning sources of ongoing HP loss inside him, since the non-drowning damage didn't take him below 0 HP.  Merrin will find Esta's lips shockingly warm to the touch -- on account of his lasting Endure Elements -- though this isn't actually helpful from the standpoint of oxygen deprivation.  And finally, he's had one more minute of breathing than she thinks he's had.

However her Breath of Life-like supernatural ability works -- though she is taking the name weirdly literally -- she's going to be rolling against an unexpectedly low DC.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is noticing significantly more confusion about the fact that he feels warm than she was about finding a pulse! 

...Her conclusion, however, is remembering that it’s over 40° C out here and 100% humidity, and maybe the thing where he inexplicably wouldn’t answer her in Baseline can be attributed to his being thoroughly delirious from heatstroke.

Several minutes of abrupt immersion in 6° C water is not, like, the recommended treatment for heatstroke per se, but it’s hopefully made the situation better rather than worse? 

She can get him to the point of coughing up some water, and then taking a breath on his own, within a couple of minutes. 

The rock they’re on still has some clearance above the water. She doesn’t immediately have to relocate.

...She'll get out the portable pulse ox from her front pouch and put it on his finger. She's pretty dubious that he's going to oxygenate well enough on 13.5% oxygen to keep breathing on his own for the length of time it'll take her to get back to camp - she's not even sure how to get him back, that's another very stupid problem - but she should check where they're at now. And then she'll check his pupils and (sorry!) see if she can get any response to a painful stimulus.

Permalink Mark Unread

Is she... trying to measure a property of internal bodily gloop... that has... something to do with hitpoints?

Creation will attest to the part where, at this point, Esta has taken enough damage plus nonlethal damage that he is not gonna just wake up, here.  Inflicting an additional HP of nonlethal damage, or whatever it is the entity is trying to do to Esta, is hardly going to help.

His eyes... probably go on functioning... as eyes?  Given that he's now apparently almost entirely alive?

If the entity starts wanting to measure eldritch percentages having to do with Esta's internal body gloop, that is between her and whatever alternative concept of reality this Far Tapestry creature is imposing upon her surroundings.

Permalink Mark Unread

She's getting an O2 saturation reading of 92%???? ....Which, fine, starts dropping almost immediately now that she's not giving him a bunch of extra oxygen, but it looks like it's going to steady out at, like, 86%, which isn't ideal but is around what she would expect from "not particularly acclimatized to this planet's atmosphere" and "some minor lung fuckery from aspirating seawater".

She doesn't love it but it doesn't seem like he's going to stop breathing in the next ten minutes. She has a stupid plan to get him more oxygen for the next multiple hours that it'll take her to somehow get both of them back to her campsite, but it involves taking off her suit, so she would really rather not have to do it until she's at the top of the bank rather than perched on a rock that's going to be submerged any minute now. 

Permalink Mark Unread

(She turns her suit oxygen down to atmospheric levels, to save the tank for later.) 

Ughhhh now she has to figure out how to carry him up a steep, and slippery, limestone bank covered in just-rehydrated mucilaginous biofilm - it's below the high tide line, and was just soaked with spray from the earlier tidal bore - and she has to do it without risking making his injuries much worse. 

 

Merrin does have a cervical collar in her front pouch, since "giving herself a neck injury" seemed like a pretty plausible outcome of a Stupid Accident. (The design is unfold-and-inflate-with-air-to-use, it packs small.) 

She'll use that to immobilize his neck, and then she'll - ugh! - get back into the water with him, being really very careful to keep his head above the surface, and swim upstream with the tidal current until she finds a slightly less steep area, and then she will, again, crash herself into the bank on purpose to shed her momentum, and then she'll sort of crab-scoot backward out of the water, mostly using her legs, holding her unconscious boyfriend with her hands under his armpits.

She's scratching the heck out of her suit, and it's going to take her like half an hour, but she can get up the bank, faster than the rising water does, without slipping and tumbling both of them back into the tidal current and without banging him around too much. 

Any change in his condition over that time period? Either breathing-related or consciousness-related? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Why... would somebody's hitpoints change... if nobody was using a Heal skill on them???  These events are not a full day of rest.

One supposes that any areas of exposed skin would be getting sunburned but that ain't exactly lethal damage either.  Plus he's a Chelish, they get restless if you don't ever set them on fire a little.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is resigned to him getting pretty sunburned and having to deal with that later, but she has carefully checked this - by deliberately exposing a tiny strip of skin on her wrist - and half an hour of exposure, eight hours past noon, in this season, shouldn't be enough for third-degree burns. ...And in fact he's getting burned more slowly than she expects. Maybe the UV is unusually low today, or maybe her skin is just more sensitive somehow. 

Permalink Mark Unread

It's 40:53, local time, when she reaches the top of the bank. In her exact location, the temperature is actually down to just 38° C, thanks to the mass of cold ocean water right there doing more than literally nothing to cool the air faster. Further inland it's still going to be hanging out around 42° C. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...Okay. 

Temporary shelter, here, now, because Merrin needs time to make sure he's stable and to think and plan, and "temporary emergency shelter" is actually something she prepped for.

She has a subset of the tent poles with her, no longer necessary for her cave shelter now that she's rebuilt it out of local materials, and she has an emergency blanket folded up tightly. She'll make a lean-to, that's the fastest configuration to shade them from the sun. 

(The temperature in the shade will manage to be a couple of degrees cooler, but not more, the rocks are still radiating heat under them. Merrin's suit is not quite keeping up and she's not very comfortable.)

She lays him down in recovery position and then removes her armor, as quickly as she reasonably can, and does the whole plug-her-adaptor-into-the-oxygen-outlet routine, and then - this was not really part of her plan - tests whether she can put the suit back on and run the tube out through the open helmet. (She can seal the suit at the neck and it'll still climate-control the rest of her body.) 

It works! It's kind of uncomfortable but she can cope with it for however long it takes to get back to camp. 

Now she's stuck staying within like two meters of him, but she can put oxygen cannula on him and get his O2 saturation reading up to a happy number instead of an ehhhh-kinda-tolerable number, which to her surprise only takes like 2L/min.

That's better. It does a lot to improve her mood. 

 

And then she can finally properly check his other vital signs - surprisingly fine??? in particular his core temperature is just normal????? - and then check him over for obvious injuries such as broken bones, which she's pretty sure he definitely has but she had not previously had a chance to pay attention to it. 

Permalink Mark Unread

(Merrin is, in fact, confused about as many as several of her recent medical observations! She is mentally registering that she did not think the tidal bore impact would be survivable at all, and even if it was she would really have expected more obvious head trauma if he was unconscious and unable to even try to shield his head for as long as she's been assuming he was, and it's actually kind of surprising that his skin would feel warm seconds after pulling him out of cold water, even if his core temperature hadn't had time to start dropping much, and actually it's pretty weird that his core temp is normal, and also it's honestly bizarre that he was oxygenating as well as he managed to on 13.5% atmospheric O2 immediately after a near-drowning incident, and in short there are like a dozen separate observations that she cannot make sense of yet. But she's also very busy and very stressed and apparently really, really out of practice at handling the kind of stressed-out she can get in a situation where if she fucks something up then someone else who isn't her will die - and also, not to mention, that person is Estha even though it makes no sense that he's on her exoplanet - and it's actually taking pretty much all the attention she can spare from the medical emergency, which isn't much, to manage her emotional state and stay focused. She can worry about coming up with hypotheses that would fit with the disparate confusing observations later.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

He hasn't literally broken all the bones, he is wearing a bunch of torso armor for example, but any long straight appendages sticking out of him have been bludgeoned into other things and had a poor time of that.  Only not, you know, in a way that would correspond to his HP going below 0, because he didn't take that much damage quantitatively speaking before he drowned; so his spine and his neck and so on are going to be fine, because that would correspond to losing more HP than he'd lost.  Probably his HP protects those bits specifically.

Permalink Mark Unread

Creation is not sure it understands everything she's been doing to Esta.  Does it make any sense if Creation asks whether this counted as her rolling against her Heal skill to Treat Deadly Wounds?  (And if so, Creation has a bunch of further questions, like whether she exceeded the DC on the roll by at least 5, and if so what her Wisdom bonus is.)

Permalink Mark Unread

(Probably nothing that Merrin has actually done yet would count as Treating Deadly Wounds for the purposes of putting any hit points back! The oxygen is mostly just giving him Golarion-at-sea-level-equivalent air rather than Golarion-at-quite-high-altitude equivalent air, and other than that she's basically just done an assessment to gather information on his condition, rather than treating anything yet!) 



...Merrin has a splint in her emergency safety-checklist pouch. In case she managed to break a bone in a Stupid Accident.

She does not have four splints. So, uh, she is kind of going to have to drag him back to her camp with a lot of smashed bone shards in his arms and legs being jostled. She doesn't even have any IV painkillers, because it would have been a bad idea to give those to herself when she needed to be alert and focused and getting herself back to safety. She has oral painkillers but he's too unconscious to swallow them. 

Ugh. At least he doesn't obviously have broken ribs. Though after checking his pupils again and removing his glowy costume hat for a closer look at his head (she left whatever's on the back of his head in place, it was really attached), she's pretty suspicious that he has at least a concussion and probably a skull fracture and she is PRETTY UNHAPPY about this, because her medical facilities SUCK, but given her lack of any proper diagnostic equipment, really all she can do is monitor his breathing and vital signs closely until she's back where she has a portable ultrasound to check for intracranial bleeding. 

It's still a less severe head injury than she would expect given the forces involved and Merrin is DEEPLY SUSPICIOUS that she's missing something here, but she doesn't have anything to do with that confusion just yet. 

 

...She'll give him the exactly one liter of IV fluids she keeps in her safety pouch (in case of Stupid Accidents involving either losing a lot of blood or, like, somehow accidentally eating something that gives her horrible food poisoning). Mostly because she doesn't want him to get fucking heatstroke on the trek back, it's going to take like ten hours before the temperature is reasonable out here. She also has epinephrine, in case of Unexpected Hazards involving something on this planet that gives her an anaphylactic reaction, and she's holding that in reserve in case his vital signs get scary before she's back, but his blood pressure is actually fine right now even though that continues to be VERY SURPRISING to her. 

 

(This miiiight count to Creation as attempting a Heal check? Unclear?) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin obviously has ranks in Heal.  She is obviously using that knowledge.  The only question remains whether she has spent one (1) hour on doing Healy things and expended two (2) uses of a healer's kit.

Permalink Mark Unread

That seems like kind of an absurd standard given how many critical lifesaving tasks Merrin can accomplish in like ten minutes if she has to, but no, she has neither spent an hour on this yet nor expended two uses of a healer's kit. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Creation is getting the feeling that this Entity of the Far Tapestry has definite opinions about how reality should work around her, and they Do Not involve Esta recovering HP corresponding to his character level (12), plus Merrin's Wisdom bonus (+5) if she exceeds the DC by 5, exactly at the end of her first hour of work.  Plus a corresponding 17 points of nonlethal damage.

...it wouldn't make much of a difference, after Esta drowned and his HP dropped to -1 about that, he's got more than 34 points of nonlethal keeping him unconscious.  Esta is probably going to stay out until he's done a day of natural healing, or Long-Term Care if Merrin cares to roll her Heal about that too.

But Esta's, uh, 'vital signs', can improve on a continuous basis as the Far Tapestry Entity applies more healing.  If that.  Works better for It.

Permalink Mark Unread

(Oh, yeah, to be clear Merrin is absolutely not expecting to sleep tonight, she's planning to take a mildly stupid amount of stimulants and be up all night probably, because it's not like she can trade off with anyone for a break. Buuuuuuuut this is going to have to wait a while, because her equivalent of a ""healer's kit"" is almost entirely in a different location.) 

 

...How exactly is she going to get him back without risking exacerbating the skull fracture. That's...a puzzle. She can try just carrying him in her arms, with the power armor she's strong enough, but the terrain is very challenging and Merrin is familiar with her base rate per hour of misjudging her footing and tripping or stumbling even when she's not having her center of gravity all thrown off by an entire deadweight unconscious person in her arms, and of course if she does have a deadweight unconscious person in her arms then she's substantially impaired at recovering from a stumble without falling on her face. And if she falls on top of him she will make his head injury worse. Which would be really bad!

 

She has two tent poles. (Or, well, up to six tent poles in the shortest configuration, but one configuration gives her two tent poles a bit over 2m long each.) 

...She does not actually have enough paracord to make a stretcher out of the tent poles – since she's alone, she's thinking a travois form factor, lay the poles parallel and keep one end of each in her hands with the other ends dragging on the ground behind her – but what she does have is a river right there. With a current that's not even unreasonable at this point. And there's probably strapwrack at the bottom of the permanent channel.  

After another five minutes of watching him, her subconscious intuition is actually feeling remarkably positive on the prospect of leaving him unattended - and without extra oxygen, since she has to take the power armor with its oxygen tanks with her - for the ten minutes or so it'll take her to swim down, harvest some fronds, and swim back up, and then run back from however far she got swept along by the current. 

Permalink Mark Unread

She's going to do that. 

Permalink Mark Unread

She's also going to spend the entire time INTERNALLY FREAKING OUT about it. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Doooooooooes she come back to find him still in the same condition as when she left him? 

Permalink Mark Unread

He's resting!  With a Ring of Sustenance running, even!  Probably regained at least 1 more hit point about it, if things are happening continuously over time.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin has no idea that her patient's physiology is not that of a normal dath ilani human! Or, well, she has noticed that multiple medical observations are not what she expected, but she doesn't even have the start of a hypothesis about it, except for ???narrative tropes??? because it would be a worse story if he didn't survive???? which is still not a form of logic she wants to put any real weight on. 

 

She's going to do all the same things that she would if she did know, because her priorities here are pretty overdetermined. She's just also going to be REALLY REALLY STRESSED the entire time. 

 

Merrin hurriedly weaves a basket-y stretcher structure between the two tent poles. She very very carefully transfers her unconscious patient from the ground onto it. She lightly ties him on with paracord.

....He's going to get at least second-degree sunburn like that. Merrin removes some of the pole segments and uses them and more paracord and adhesive strips to rig up a little tent over his head and shoulders. 

He's still not oxygenating amazingly on ambient air, though it seems to be totally stable and not getting any worse. Still. If he has a serious head injury, she really doesn't want any other factors reducing how much oxygen his brain is getting. She rigs up the O2 tubing again. 

Aaaaaaand off she goes. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

They're more than 1500 meters away from her camp, as the crow flies.

 

Which in some sense isn't that far, but she can't take a direct route, not dragging a travois-stretcher. And Merrin is being pretty careful, and also she's stopping every five minutes to check on him, and every ten minutes to run down to the water and dunk herself because her suit cooling is badly overloaded and being out at this time of day with an open faceplate is riding the edge of heat exhaustion, and she's not able to push it that quickly because, again, if she gives herself heatstroke trying to move him faster then she won't make it back to camp at all. She can ignore being dizzy but she's going to stop for a cool-off break every time she starts getting nauseous.

Her patient's body temperature is continuing to be remarkably normal but Merrin DOES NOT TRUST THAT. Once the IV bag is empty, she snips off one end to turn it into a collapsible water-carrying container, and she'll carry up bagfuls of cold seawater and dump them on his torso to, hopefully, counteract the heat of the sun. 

Permalink Mark Unread

It's going to take her like seven hours to walk that distance, under the conditions described. Also, while she can avoid inflicting any further lethal damage, she is going to be doing quite a lot of jarring his broken limbs and making bone shards grind against each other, and will probably in fact be inflicting nonlethal damage in the process of trying to move him. 

 

At least the sun is slowly getting less hot! By 48:00 local time, it's down to only 29° C and 75% relative humidity! No longer heatstroke territory for either of them! 

(Sunset isn't due until around 50:30 local time, so at least she has light to navigate by the whole way.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is checking on him a minimum of every ten minutes (and has the vital sign monitors on him programmed to do auditory alarms, though she can't sync them to the wrist display on her armor, that part of her suit's electronic capabilities broke a planetary-month ago and did not seem like a big enough deal to prioritize cannibalizing other electronics to fix.) 

Any significant changes over the journey, especially to his breathing, that might for example prompt her to stop and try additional emergency treatment where she is? 

Permalink Mark Unread

2 hours of rest (with a Ring on) would be good for recovering 12 HP and another 12 of nonlethal, modulo any more nonlethal that got accidentally inflicted.  It won't wake him up if there's been no other Heal applied to him, but he might start to react to things even if he doesn't wake up.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is not going to miss that! It's a really reassuring sign! If his level of consciousness is improving at all, rather than getting worse, then he probably doesn't have active intracranial bleeding right now. Not that she can CHECK because she HAS NO DIAGNOSTIC EQUIPMENT, why didn't she put the portable ultrasound in her emergency bag, oh right because it weighs 0.9kg and takes up a substantial volume and she was instead using that weight and volume allotment for her tent poles and emergency blanket. At least she HAS it in working order. If his respiratory status gets worse tonight she's going to be SO inconvenienced tonight by the fact that she dismantled her portable ventilator to turn it into a cave-ventilator. 

(She's still mentally tracking that he probably got some radon exposure to his lungs and this could show up as pneumonitis in a day or two, even if she at no point actually detected radioactivity and that puts a cap on how severe the exposure could have been. There's absolutely nothing she can do about it one way or another; the damage is already done.) 

 

 

Merrin makes it back to her campsite at 48:12, a little over two hours before sunset. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Her shelter is as she left it, still in "day" mode with the tarp stretched overtop of it for maximum sun reflection (with an air gap for additional heat insulation, so that any solar heat absorbed by the tarp itself will not be in direct contact with the roof.)  

The temperature inside is only 19° C and the humidity is 62%. She'll be downright comfortable! All of her gear is exactly where she left it. It's not like there's anyone else around to mess with it.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin had a three-hour nap between 27:00 and 30:00 local time, but that was 17 hours ago, and before that she woke with the planetary dawn at like 13:00, so she's been awake with only the one nap for the last 35 hours. 

She's tired. And hungry, and thirsty, and frustrated, and she's been using a lot of her emotional regulation capacity on not being the bad kind of stressed-and-upset that makes her worse at things. 

She's also a trained Exception Handling medic and none of that matters

Permalink Mark Unread

She hauls her unconscious boyfriend into her tent and - ugh - dismantles the sleeping pad and sleeping bag setup from her pod, to have something to put him on that isn't the gravel floor. 

She drinks a liter and a half of water with a bit of sea salt and bladdersac syrup in it. (Sea salt from this planet has a tiny bit of dissolved uranium in it, but not really enough to be a problem, unlike eating filter-feeders.) She considers that if she's feeling dehydrated then presumably Estha is worse off, and she digs out another of her remaining, like, 3L total of safe IV fluids. She probably does actually have what she needs here to make sterile saline but she hasn't prioritized it because she did NOT KNOW THIS WAS GOING TO HAPPEN. 

 

...She'll do a whole lot of labs, because she might as well when she has the equipment, and she'll examine him with the portable ultrasound. First priority is to confirm if he has a skull fracture and whether the bone is actually displaced or just cracked, and check for additional intracranial bleeding – if it's not a displaced skull fracture and there's no bleeding putting pressure where it shouldn't, her best bet here given her facilities is to just leave it alone. 

Permalink Mark Unread

The skull fracture didn't take him below 0HP, so there's no ongoing intracranial bleeding.  The vitality that flows through a 6th-circle cleric is serious stuff.

Every one of her labs that relates to food or water, from blood glucose to potassium to sodium, is going to indicate that Esta is well-fed and well-hydrated...

Unless at some point Merrin makes the terrible awful no good very bad mistake of taking those innocent-looking metal rings off his fingers?  Maybe for fear of swelling?  Other potential horrendous mistakes would include taking off Esta's belt of +4 Constitution!  Just in case Merrin is feeling insufficiently enriched by her current state of medical emergency.

Permalink Mark Unread

Once she's confirmed - to her relief and also some confusion - that there's no bleeding in his brain, then Merrin is going to scan his arms to actually map out the broken bones in order to splint them. If there are any hand fractures, then yeah, trying to get any rings off him before his hands swell enough to a) make it impossible to remove the rings without a saw that can cut metal (assuming they aren't already at this point that swollen) and b) cut off circulation to the finger as a result, is going to be a priority! 

 

(If Merrin were less utterly exhausted, she might spend more time considering whether additional swelling is that likely when it's already been like eight hours since the initial injury, or she might question her prior that he's dehydrated and will get a lot more swelling as soon as she gets IV fluids into him, given that his labs show no sign of dehydration. But Merrin is exhausted and operating heavily on automatic trained habits right now, and "absolutely do not leave rings on patients with arm or hand fractures, literally why would you do that" is a trained habit.) 

 

(She's ignoring the belt for now). 

Permalink Mark Unread

Welp!  That's not going to produce any instant feedback that might tell her she did something wrong.  But it sure ain't gonna help anything later!

Permalink Mark Unread

His arms are pretty fucked up, but he has good circulation to his fingers and Merrin thinks she can probably splint his arms so that all the bones are in roughly the right place to heal. She would really, really prefer to avoid having to surgically pin bones in place, it's going to be more or less impossible to set up an actual sterile operating theater in her cave. (Not to mention she's tired enough to know on priors that she's impaired.) 

 

She'll give him IV painkillers FIRST, because she has them and does not actually intend to torture him on purpose here, and he's breathing fine and also she can now switch him to the oxygen concentrator and it goes up to 4L/min if he gets respiratory depression. And then she'll spend most of the next 90 minutes trying to unfuck his arm bones a bit and then properly immobilize everything so it has a chance of healing correctly. 

Merrin is watching him closely for any signs of consciousness. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

He's already rested for 2 hours (= 8 hours, before SOMEBODY TOOK OFF HIS SUSTENANCE RING) and can't just do that part again.  But all that has got to count as Treat Deadly Injuries, which is good for another 17hp -- Merrin has got to be making these rolls by more than 5 -- plus 17hp of nonlethal damage cured too...

Which amounts to a total of 29hp of lethal damage cured, and 29hp of nonlethal damage...

And that's not gonna take his total lethal damage + nonlethal damage under 87, because Esta was frankly not doing totally great with all that underwater battering before he drowned and then got dragged over rocks with a bunch of broken bones.

Next up on Esta's potential healing schedule:  A full day's rest, or Long-Term Care if some Healer cares to put in 8 hours of light work about it.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is so tired but she's not going to feel confident that he's actually stable and recovering until she sees more signs of improvement to his mental status.

She takes more stimulants. 

...She finally thinks to remove the armor and plug it into her main battery, and she changes into her robe. She actually has three robes, at this point, and they're just her routine clothing when it's not so cold that she needs to be wearing all of her layers at once.

 

 

...She is eventually going to get around to cutting off the rest of his clothes so she can get a good ultrasound view of all his internal organs and check for bleeding.

(She'll have to really bundle him up later to keep him warm, or...cuddle him? or something? But it takes a nice long time for the cave to cool down even after sunset, it's still 17° C, she's not worried about his body temperature if he's in the sleeping bag.) 

This will, unfortunately, involve her trying to remove the belt. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Removing Esta's +4 Belt of Mighty Constitution will drop his CON from 13 (+1) to 9 (-1), corresponding to a loss of 24 hit points off his previous maximum of 87.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta seems to be suddenly doing MUCH worse right after Merrin happens to finish removing the belt!  Like falling into a tidal bore twice, or like undoing most of her previous work on treating him!  This is no doubt a total coincidence.

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

It's a really abrupt and notable change, reversing a trend that's held for many hours, and no matter how exhausted she is, Merrin is going to notice immediately with a jolt of panic.

Merrin's first thought is in fact "what did she just dooooooo?" It's definitely occurring to her that maybe removing the belt was the causal factor here! Since that's what she was doing a moment ago! But her initial hypothesis is going to be "she jostled something wrong and now he's bleeding internally" and not necessarily include "and putting belt back would fix it again."

(If her reaction times were in better shape, she might have done it entirely on instinct before she thought about it and, if she saw an improvement, would have been inclined to Leave It Like That. But she's been awake for 22 hours straight, now, and it's been almost 40 hours since her last long sleep, and it's been more than four dath ilan months since she last treated a patient, and in short, she is perhaps not at her very best.) 

 

...She still hasn't figured out how to remove his stupid ??costume?? torso armor in a way that doesn't involve pulling it up over his head and arms when he has a FRACTURED SKULL, and that makes it hard to get an ultrasound of his abdominal cavity. 

Umm. ...She'll do another set of labs, because she can, and start another liter IV fluids, because she still has that option, and then she's going to somewhat more urgently try to figure out how to remove the armor so she can get diagnostic imagery and figure out what's wrong in there. 

 

(She's confused! It doesn't actually make very much sense that she could drag him over limestone rocks for seven hours without causing a problem and then cause a problem by gently removing a belt! But Merrin is very, very tired, and she's noting the confusion but she's too frazzled to multitask and think about it while also doing all of the obvious other things first.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, the labs are now going to say whatever they'd say about a patient who was getting their water and nutrients supplied by whatever she's doing with IV instead of by Magic Ring; and will also correspond to somebody who's now in generally below-average rather than above-average health.

Permalink Mark Unread

That's....really really weird....? 

 

Like, Merrin flat out does not have a hypothesis for why removing a belt would drop his blood sugar and screw up his magnesium and make his kidney function worse! It doesn't look like sudden massive internal bleeding, it just looks like "he was in remarkably good shape, considering the circumstances, and now he's not"! 

She's going to keep doing what she was already doing - examining the armor - while in the back of her mind she gnaws on the confusing observations like an animal gnawing at the bars of a cage. 

(She can add some dextrose to his IV fluids, she didn't use all of her supply on growing cultures of her own gut bacteria as control samples against local biomass.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta is wearing +1 deathless studded leather armor.  It's not 'go personally punch a Balor in the face' armor but that's not really his role.  It's the sort of 4000gp armor you buy when you figure you ought to spend at least 4000 gp on armor, basically.

Without going into details of 'hardness', even the enchanted version is not quite as 'hard' as mundane steel.  Powered tungsten carbide wins, if that's the sort of eldritch capability the Far Tapestry is bringing.

It is going to be mysteriously way harder to damage than the studded leather it looks like, but--

Permalink Mark Unread

This is no doubt some random synthetic material which is around that tough to cut; practically nobody on the entire planet would be wearing leather in the first place.  Nobody would even be able to identify by sight what it's pretending to be, unless they'd been running weird Exception Handling scenarios involving animal hides.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is not the sort of Exception Handling specialist who has done those kind of weird training scenarios, and she doesn't recognize what the armor is made of but whatever, she has too many more centrally medical things to be confused about right now. 

(Halfway through very carefully sawing it off him, it does occur to her to check his head again for new intracranial bleeding, even though that doesn't explain the timing at all, she was nowhere near his head when the sudden deterioration happened. He does seem to have stabilized again at the current point, she doesn't think he's ongoingly looking worse...) 

 

Okay. Stupid flaming ??costume armor?? is OFF.

Anything blatantly wrong with his abdominal organs? Or his lungs, though he's still not really having an oxygenation problem - that wouldn't be entirely explained by the atmosphere of this stupid horrible planet with its stupid horrible tidal bores - so that's not her main theory for what suddenly changed... 

 

(She's still, in the background, chewing on the confusion. Is the belt some kind of medical device? Sometimes people have medical devices that don't look like medical devices, and she's not sure what exact problem it would be addressing and doesn't remember Estha having anything like that but she doesn't know how long it's been...) 

Permalink Mark Unread

This is the complete list of hits for "abdominal organs" on the Archives of Nethys for the Pathfinder 1e rules.  It returns 1 hit, to Child of Yog-Sothoth, which is actually talking about abdominal tentacles.

His abdominal organs look however all that internal goop looks at CON 9 after a bunch of lethal and nonlethal bludgeoning damage.


(ADDENDUM:  It has been pointed out that if you search on "abdomen", it looks like all that goop in the abdomen apparently has something to do with the Constitution ability score, since targeted shots at it can deal Constitution damage.)

Permalink Mark Unread

....Which shows up to ultrasound as a lot of bruising and some hematomas that don't seem to be getting actively worse. 

 

 

 

Sometimes, in weird Exception Handling scenarios, the thing to do is EMPIRICISM even - especially - when you have literally no idea what's happening or why.

Sometimes that's even the case in non-sim real life situations! Like, less often, because there's no active optimization for the situation to be weird, but it happens. 

Like, you don't follow that logic off a cliff, you wouldn't do something that would kill the patient under normal circumstances on the grounds that maybe these are some other kind of Weird Circumstances where medical logic is totally reversed, but a lot of things are pretty low-cost to just...try...and see what happens. And in fact, if everything else here were normal, Merrin would not be particularly nervous about disturbing his injuries if she were to gently putting the belt back on. 

So she'll try that and see what happens? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Conceptually, Esta has a maximum amount of hit points, and an amount of damage.  His current hit points are equal to his maximum minus the damage.

This in fact makes Bear's Constitution a much more dangerous buff than granting proper temporary hit points, for example via the also-second-circle False Life spell.  Temporary hit points are first to receive damage; they cancel that damage when they vanish.  If you remove Constitution, all the damage is still there and your current hit points drop accordingly.

On the plus side, if you put the Constitution belt back on, Esta's current hit points go right back up, and the damage he's taken is a correspondingly smaller fraction of his maximum!  He'll immediately start doing better, including on the general-health-related portion of measurements in Merrin's labs.

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

(She's not going to notice improving labs for a while; she has limited test strips for her analyzer, and if he's improving rather than deteriorating then it doesn't seem as critical to know right away.) 

 

...Merrin does not understand what's happening here at all. 

 

She's at this point assigning quite high likelihood that the situation is, in some way or other, ""not what it looks like"". She...is kind of flailing wildly for specific theories

 

What does she actually know?

...Rather, what does she think she knows, and based on what concrete sensory input that she thinks she perceived? 

Permalink Mark Unread

She died in a plane crash about four dath ilan months ago, and did not at that time expect she could or would be successfully cryopreserved. 

 

Instead of ceasing to have any experiences, she experienced being on an exoplanet, accompanied by all her gear, which had been "with her" on the plane but not with-with her in the sense of being in arms' reach or anything, it was in the cargo hold. 

 

The horrible exoplanet turned out to be just, barely, possible to survive on until now, and it's unclear how much longer she can manage. 

 

This afternoon she saw a man appear who looks and sounds exactly like Estha, one of her boyfriends from dath ilan, except for inexplicably not speaking Baseline to her. 

 

She was very luckily in the right place at the right time to see him and rescue him, but...not, quite, lucky enough to come out any earlier and warn him to get out of the river channel before he was injured.

 

He survived the tidal bore. Barely, but - she still feels like what she observed was in the best 5% of possible outcomes. Not a physically implausible outcome, necessarily, just - she would have assigned most of her probability mass to much worse outcomes. Same deal with the danger cave - like, it's not physically impossible that he went in there and got lucky, but she would mostly have expected him to show, like, more than literally zero sign of radiation-related lung damage from inhaling cave air that contained radon and also dust with its still-radioactive decay byproducts, and she's seen literally zero sign, on top of the startlingly minimal apparent lung damage from aspirating a bunch of seawater. 

 

In addition to his improbable luck in the tidal bore, the man who looks like her boyfriend is weirdly good at climbing up steep limestone rocks, and is in weirdly good metabolic health for his age. Except when she takes off his belt??? 

 

Also he seems to be immune to heatstroke AND hypothermia. His body temperature hasn't budged the entire time. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...Nope, she still has no hypotheses.  

 

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Except...it feels like trope logic, and not real life logic?

 

Like, when you string together all the specific points where a thing happened that she would have assigned 5% probability to, it's not that any of the individual events were physically impossible, it just...starts to look really weird if one is assuming a normal physical model of Reality, and...it has the feel of something where this was the best narrative? 

Permalink Mark Unread

What is she even supposed to do with that theory, though. 

Permalink Mark Unread

If Reality is messing with her, that doesn't actually indicate any specific way that she should be altering her medical treatment plan?? She doesn't think??? Possibly she doesn't need to be as stressed about it as she is, but the stress is keeping her AWAKE so Merrin is not, actually, going to invest much cognitive bandwidth in trying to convince her mind to stop that. 

 

She'll just...keep monitoring her patient and doing obvious medical care - she'll splint his broken legs too, and figure out a way to awkwardly stick one of her armor pee-absorbers in the correct place because, uh, she does not want him to pee all over her sleeping bag while he's unconscious and she miiiiight have turned all of the urinary catheters from her medical supplies into freshwater-still-related tubing - and then she'll zip him back into the sleeping bag, since it's now down to a brisk 11° C in her cave, and wait for something else to change? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, it sure looks like she's investing the 8 hours it takes to do a Heal skill check for Long-Term Care!  Which would let Esta recover a total of four times his level in HP, so 48 hit points, after 24 hours pass...

Oh.  Um.

The Far Tapestry Entity's 'alien common sense' probably says that processes like that should be... continuous... rather than instantaneous... doesn't it...

Then Esta will probably wake up after around 8 hours total, maybe?  Not healed, obviously; but with his nonlethal+lethal damage total going underneath his maximum HP of 87.

1 current hit point means you're ready for adventure!

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

Ugh.

Vicar Esta requires coffee.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's about 58:30, local time.

 

Merrin has, at this point, been awake for more than twenty-eight hours, and it's been more than forty-five hours since her last sleep of more than three hours at a stretch.

This does not actually enormously affect her ability to notice changes in her patient's condition! All that is really automatic! She was kind of expecting him to start waking up soon, she was seeing gradual signs of improving responsiveness, and so she notices within less than ten seconds that his eyes are a little bit open. 

 

She'll slip off her stool and move into his field of view. "Hey. It's Merrin. We're back at my shelter." She's speaking slowly and clearly and trying to stick to simple grammar, on the assumption that he's going to be pretty groggy, but she's also, obviously, doing it all in Baseline. "Try not to move, okay? You have a skull fracture and you broke a lot of bones. What's your pain level right now?" 

 

The person now talking to Esta in a foreign language sure looks like Mariona! That is, if Mariona had cut her hair really short (Merrin has been cutting her hair regularly as it grows, otherwise it's uncomfortable in her power armor and, just, she's worn it like this since she was in her teens and she's used to it), and had lost a bunch of weight, and was also showing about 5000% more emotion in her facial expressions (relief, mostly, and she seems really happy that he's awake) than the Chelish Mariona ever has in her entire life. 

Permalink Mark Unread

What part of his telepathic instruction to BRING COFFEE did Mariona hear as SPEAK GIBBERISH?

Esta tries to lift his hands to perform the somatic component of the spell to Heal himself.

Hm.  Somebody has bound his damaged arms and fingers, as opposed to, say, healing them.

 

This situation is not making a tremendous amount of sense.

He does remember that altered-Mariona no longer speaks Taldane after her encounter with Yog-Sothoth.  Either that, or he doesn't speak it any more and his memories of her are what got altered.

"Does your incompetence and failure extend to forgetting even the simplest Infernal?" he says in that language, idiomatically.

Permalink Mark Unread

….Okay. He’s still speaking to her in some non-Baseline ??conlang?? (Merrin did not catch enough of it before to particularly notice if it’s the same or a different language in terms of how the phonemes sound. She's not that much of a conlang person anyway.) 

 

He - seems to recognize her? At least that's the vague vibe she gets, that he's confused about his surroundings but not specifically by her presence? ...He doesn't seem happy to see her, like Merrin had kind of hoped he would be - especially when he must have spent the last few months believing she was permanently gone?? - but it's really stupid to have hurt feelings about that right now, and even in her current incredibly exhausted state she can set them aside. The situation is objectively pretty upsetting! 

She shakes her head and taps her ear with an apologetic expression. As well as saying "I can't understand you" in Baseline but, like, she is getting the impression that he can't understand her either in which case that will not really help. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Right.

He will attempt again to lift his arms, while saying, slowly and clearly and in tones of command -- the tone may carry even if the meaning doesn't -- "FREE MY HANDS."

Permalink Mark Unread

He...seems...really really upset about the splints...? Are they painful - no, she doesn't think it's that - does he want to write something, since they're inexplicably failing to communicate verbally??? 

 

 

Well. He's not going to cause himself life-threatening injuries if she frees just his hands - he might mess up the bone healing, but she's just going to hope he has the common sense not to move them in ways that are horrifically painful? and anyway the worst damage with all the loose bone shards she spent forever trying to get lined up again was in his forearms, and she can take apart the splint so his hands are free below the wrist without undoing those hours of work - and Merrin would probably ALSO be upset if she woke up unable to move important body parts? And she's always had the policy of "when it's not actually medically dangerous, try to de-escalate by giving the patient some of the thing they're really upset about not having"? 

She can free his hands, carefully and trying to clearly telegraph all of her movements. And then offer him pen and paper, on the remote off-chance he can somehow actually muster enough strength and coordination to use it? 

 

(He does have broken bones in both hands, and a bunch of tendon and muscle and nerve damage in his arms, and will probably not be able to use them all that effectively.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Esta sees.  Not hostile, then.  His hands indeed cannot be used to heal himself this way.  She only bound them to protect them from further damage, maybe awaiting her own ability to pray for spells -- if she still remembers Asmodeus, and not only things of the Dark Tapestry.  She is not garbed as one of His, and wears no unholy symbol that he can see.

After a few abortive attempts to move his fingers as they would need to move to cast Heal or even Cure Moderate, Esta will acknowledge the futility of trying to do this thing, for now.  Soon enough, if she continues to treat him, he will recover all damage taken.

"Never mind," he says, as she tries to offer him what seem like obvious Dark Tapestry writing implements.  His tone is never apologetic, but there is no more command in it.  "You were Wise enough."

His Mariona would recognize the tone as the way Esta sounds when he is as close as he ever gets to complimentary.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is finding it somewhat hard to parse his tone - Estha is less grumpy than this, normally - but possibly she's just never actually interacted with him when he was having a bad day?

And, like, she does actually know people who sound like that when they're being as close as they ever get to complimentary; some of those people work in Exception Handling and give her performance reviews. She's not going to take his crankiness about being injured and in pain personally. 

She smiles reassuringly at him. (Mariona would NOT smile like that. It's an extremely un-Chelish expression.) 

...Is he going to cooperate with her carefully putting his hand splints back, now? 

Permalink Mark Unread

He will initially withdraw his hands, and try to give her a likewise un-Chelishly blatant skeptical expression meant to convey, "ARE YOU SURE", because Esta does not actually know why that would be at all necessary or helpful at this point.

But he's not wearing his Rings, either of them, and that also makes terribly little sense in the context of altered-Mariona apparently being obedient and helpful and leaving him his belt and headband.  There are things going on here that he plain does not understand, and perhaps dangers that he knows nothing about.

Permalink Mark Unread

(In Merrin's world-model, broken bones take like six weeks to heal properly! And obviously you would need to keep them externally immobilized for that long, if you haven't made the risky-in-these-circumstances decision to stabilize the fracture surgically! It is absolutely going to be news to her if it turns out that having given him some fluids and put splints on his broken limbs and then parked herself here for blah blah hours to monitor him is going to mean that his injuries mysteriously heal completely in 24 hours!) 

 

She's SO confused and concerned about the inexplicable language barrier. Her top theory would be (hopefully!)-temporary cognitive dysfunction from the head injury and near-drowning, but it doesn't feel right - he's alert, he's tracking his surroundings, he's clearly capable of strategizing ways around the language problem, it seems to be literally just speaking Baseline that isn't working and he's instead speaking clearly and fluently in some other language and that's just not actually how concussions work.

She would, at this point, be wondering whether it's just not Estha at all, but....the thing is, it's not just that he looks like Estha and sounds like Estha except for how he's not speaking Baseline. He's reminiscent of Estha in some harder-to-describe vibe way, too, just - something is off, in a way she can't pin down but that she doesn't think is just not actually having seen him in non-date contexts.

(It's kind of uncanny, actually, though Merrin feeling creeped out is not important.) 

 

...Maybe she can try drawing something, to solve the communication impasse?

Permalink Mark Unread

(Merrin is going to be SO ANNOYED if this is some sort of "Reality is straight-up messing with her for narrative trope reasons" thing where it's a more entertaining story if she can't just talk to him.) 

 

She gets out the paper again - she's gone through a lot of her paper, and hasn't yet gotten her local-fiber-made ""paper"" to a point where she can reasonably write on it, but she's started rationing it more carefully and has some left - and starts drawing. 

She draws a planet with a moon orbiting it - not realistically or to scale but in the conventional-stylized-schematic-diagram format that anyone in dath ilan is going to recognize from educational materials - and sketches in the recognizable dath ilan continents, pretty well she thinks, and then some other planets around a star,  as "this is a solar system". 

She takes a different piece of paper, and draws another planet, with the same stylized format but - larger planet, lots of squiggly-shading instead of continents  - a conventional-stylized way to convey "????? do not actually have maps of this territory????" - with a much larger closer moon, and then a larger star, also a larger distance (she has to get a second piece of paper to tape to the first one to show the scale she means) - more squiggly-shading where additional planets might or might not be, she has suspicions there are both inner and outer planets from her stargazing but she's not really an expert astronomer... 

 

She shows probably-but-maybe-not-Estha the first one, and then the second one, and then she puts the second big-planet-big-close-moon-big-distant-sun one right beside him, and carries the dath ilan diagram over to the other side of the room, and gestures with her arms to convey "very very far"? 

Does that seem to communicate anything successfully? 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

...okay, he's worked out that she thinks they're not in Golarion anymore, or indeed the Cage's whole solar system, assuming the first diagram is meant to represent a normal planet like Golarion.  Plausibly valid, that sun and sky were not correct, and also Ẏ̸̧ö̴̮́g̵̺͂-̵̡̕S̴̪̕o̶͈̾t̸̖̑h̶̩́ô̵͕t̶̫͌h̶͎̑ ̷̳͊m̶̭̍a̸̯̎ḏ̸͝e̴̝͑ ̵̟̓h̴͕̓ḭ̶̀m̴̰̃ ̷̳̓ṣ̵͗e̸͎͗ê̴̪ ̴̭̊t̵̼̕o̴̪̐ỏ̴̘ ̴͚̀m̵͇̋a̵͕͘n̴͎͐ẏ̸͚ ̵̲̐p̷͕͋l̶̞̐a̵̱̐c̶̛̟ẹ̶̊ṣ̷̒ ̸̪͆a̸̩̋ṉ̷̑ḋ̶̥ ̴̪̆f̸̯͗o̶̗͘r̵͖̊g̴̞͊e̷̯̾ť̴̪ ̵̝́w̴̬̕h̷̖͒ę̸̃r̴͇̾e̷̪͑ ̶̘̾h̵̥̚e̵̪͝ ̵̱͛h̷̞̐i̵͍̋m̶̰̂s̴̝̔e̶͙̒l̶͇̆f̸̳͝ ̸͈̽w̴̲̎ạ̴͝s̴̳̈́.

But what is she asking him with respect to that?

His own ability to get them out of this place?

Esta lifts his damaged hands, and tries to gesture with his chin at them, to indicate that sure, he can do that once his hands have healed.  Word of Recall might get them home on a verbal component alone, it's theoretically not distance-limited within a plane; but Esta suspects this case involves Plane Shift and not just Word of Recall.  Assuming his Bag of Holding made it through the water, at least; Esta's tuning forks for Hell and his own Prime Material are there.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin isn't sure what he's trying to convey with that? (She was less trying to ask a question, really, and more trying to explain the situation, because in his position she would REALLY REALLY WANT TO KNOW. It also hasn't occurred to her to draw the part where she died in a plane crash, since from her perspective he PRESUMABLY HEARD and it would have been REALLY VERY MEMORABLE.) 

Going off body language and her intuitive sense of subtext, which to be clear are NOT trustworthy tools for communication, alone, she sort of has the impression that he's trying to convey some sort of...plan...? 

 

...Merrin is too tired. She's way, way too tired for more. Stuff. 

She kind of really wants to ask him for a HUG but he has two broken arms and also the VIBES are REALLY OFF and it feels too weird to try to mime this desire of hers

Does he look visibly in pain, such that she should offer him more painkillers before she checks that all of the alarms will scream really loudly about a problem and then passes out in a pile of emergency blankets since her sleeping bag is occupied? 

(Merrin is, to be clear, not calibrated on how much distress Chelish people will allow to show visibly about being in pain.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

He has at zero points given the slightest visible sign of pain, including when she was taking the splints off his fingers or when he himself was trying to move them.

Permalink Mark Unread

....If Merrin were any less fucking exhausted, she might think to be suspicious of her observations, just on the grounds that it would seem really implausible for all of that not to be painful when he last had painkillers like ten hours ago. 

 

She is, however, too tired for that right now. He's not showing physiological signs of severe pain - no elevated heart rate, no sweating - and he's not appearing distressed, so probably it's fine? 

 

...She's going to go dig out a pile of emergency blankets, and put it nearish him, and gesture at the pile and mime laying her head on her hands and closing her eyes?

(She's going to be right there, if he has a problem he's conscious and can yell to wake her, and if he has a problem that results in no longer being conscious or able to shout then probably one of her alarms will tell her? The only thing she can think of that could go wrong and stay undetected for a while is if he does start bleeding into his brain and it takes a long time before it affects his vitals, but she'll just be really really conservative on the low-heart-rate and high-blood-pressure alarms, that should warn her pretty early on if his intracranial pressure is rising... Merrin is still kind of stressed about it but she really, really needs to get some sleep in order to stay functional.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Un-Chelishly wide blatant smile of approval!

(He is not sure if nods still mean the same thing, but he has seen her smile.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Awwww. That is the first moment where it's felt to Merrin like the vibes were not upsettingly off and he's actually glad that she's here and not permanently dead and stuff. To the extent the smile is odd or uncharacteristic, it's entirely explained by being groggy and uncomfortable; Merrin is very used to ICU patients having smiles that look strained and off entirely for those reasons.

(...She had kind of been expecting more confusion from him about that, come to think of it? She's now wondering if, like, maybe this isn't as completely unexpected an outcome as she assumed, and is something that smarter people than her in dath ilan might just know is how Reality works? Or something??? - ugh she's too tired to think about it.) 

 

- Merrin is actually just going to fail her own Will save against the temptation to go (very very carefully) hug Estha, before she goes to sleep. She is indescribably starved for human contact, see, and she has been using all of her cognitive skills and training to cope as well as she can and she's managing but she's perhaps not really entirely okay, and then today was INCREDIBLY STRESSFUL and she REALLY THOUGHT she was going to fuck up and fail to save him and she, just– look, Kalorm thinks she should go for it, okay. 

Permalink Mark Unread

He'll maintain the smile that produced this huge reaction bonus, in lieu of showing any actual surprise or alarm.

 

WHAT THE ABYSS HAPPENED TO HER.

Permalink Mark Unread

(This version of Mariona is actually quite a lot more socially perceptive than his, in general, having not spent her entire life incentivized not to be. Her job involves people stuff! She had better be okay at it! ...That being said, Esta has a better Bluff than Merrin is used to, and also Merrin is really, really tired, and she isn't going to notice anything off.) 

 

She double checks all the alarms one more time and then she lies down in her pile of blankets - she'll be cold later, but she actually wants to be sure she wakes up when the temperature drops in here, if she's cold then presumably so is Estha - and she goes to sleep. 

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

Two Heals, then, next time he prays for spells, and two Break Enchantments.  Mariona is insane or cursed; and reason declares that there must then be an excellent chance that so, likewise, is he.

(And a little tiny jar of dissonance, very far back in Esta's mind, as the thought occurs to some tiny piece of himself that Aspexia Rugatonn is very unlikely to be lurking invisibly in this room to Detect his Thoughts; and that he need not take his usual pains to finish this paragraph of internal monologue with a rationalization about why Mariona is a valuable piece that he is not being un-Asmodean to protect.  It is a very tiny jar indeed, quickly squashed and forgotten; for Asmodeus's gaze sees all; and a 6th-circle is worth Discern Location or even Gate for Rugatonn to retrieve, if he painfully fails to return by his own efforts.)

They seem to be alone in this place, and insane or not, he must take care to protect all pieces he has to play.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta will attempt to doze or sleep, if he can; and use his Wisdom for thinking of things that are not how he got here or what he saw just before then.  For if he cannot dance his fingers to Heal himself, it is not a good time to go any more insane.

Permalink Mark Unread

If Merrin were thinking more clearly she might have remembered to offer Estha food and water - or, more likely, food in water, she has one of her calorie-containing meal replacement powder pouches left - but she is not thinking that clearly. 

 

She closes her eyes and remains conscious just barely long enough to notice that imaginary Laeirthe is trying to have a thought, or something, and it feels important, but...nope, Merrin's cognitive processing capacity is no longer working well enough to run a coherent Laeirthe so it will have to wait until she's slept. 

 

 

(Merrin did think to switch the tent to Night Mode, before she slept – the door is cracked open for ventilation and the tarp is put away – and the temperature is going to drop faster. Not quite as fast as the outdoor temperature, but lately Merrin actively tries to get the inside air temperature down to -5° C or even -10° C by the early hours, since she's normally spending those hours in her insulated sleeping pod, and it's the only way she can keep the temperature inside from rising dangerously high by early afternoon. She has perhaps not fully re-evaluated this strategy in light of having an injured person staying in her cave tonight, though even if she had she would probably come to the same conclusion, given her expectation that he'll continue to be injured for multiple days before he makes a natural recovery, and it's not like afternoon heatstroke would be any better for him and also if he's cold later she can just cuddle him, she would kind of like that.)  

Permalink Mark Unread

It's not going to be that cold for a long time, though! Even coming up on 22 days after the spring equinox, the night is still 27 hours long. At 59:00, eight hours after sunset and five hours before midnight, it's still 13° C outside. The cave is a few degrees cooler - it's ventilated from the deeper, colder caves below them - but the underground-cave air is coming in above freezing. Once the outside temperature is below freezing - sometime around 03:00 local time, eight hours from now - it'll actually be a warming factor, and the rest of the cave may not hit 0° C until 05:00 or 06:00.

Esta's Endure Elements will wear off a little before 62:00, if it was cast shortly before the Worldwound incident that brought him here, but he's in a sleeping bag rated to -20° C, and he probably won't even notice it's chilly unless he tries to exit it. 

Permalink Mark Unread

A sudden temperature change on Esta's face will be sufficient to wake him up, especially given that he had previously had some enforced rest and was trying deliberately to doze.  Among the many ways that divine casters are superior to arcane casters is that they can cultivate a normal adventurer's virtue of waking up for small anomalies, rather than trying to stay asleep at nearly all costs.

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

...that was his Endure Elements wearing off.  It was cast on him within three moments of arriving at the Worldwound, and they could not have been there for longer than three minutes before t̸̬͘h̷̜̚e̸̜͌ ̶̮͆c̷̭̕u̶̱̔l̸̘̿ṯ̷̉i̶͔̽s̵͙̑ẗ̸̰́s̷̭̄ Esta is not thinking about that thank you very much.  The point is, Esta has now been here for 24 hours, it was daytime when he arrived, and it is currently night outside.

Esta's first thought is that they have Teleported to a different timezone.

Esta's second thought is that he is a fool.  Mariona was not asking him about plans by showing him those diagrams across their communication barrier.  Mariona was trying to communicate the important fact that they were on a different planet with a non-24 day-night cycle.  Esta does not remember off the top of the head what Castrovel's cycle is said to be like, but he remembers it not being 24 hours, and that Castrovel's seasons are not like Golarion's seasons.

If Esta was ever taught how praying for spells works under those circumstances, he has incompetently forgotten the fact.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Esta does know that Teleporting to a new time zone with intent to stay a while will sync you up to its dawn.  And Esta also knows, or rather considers it obvious without quite bothering to distinguish observation from inference, that you couldn't possibly Teleport around from dawn to dawn, picking up more and more spells each day.  Everyone sufficiently high-level would do that, if it were that easy.

Esta therefore knows (still not quite distinguishing observation from inference) that it is not a matter of dawn being magical.  It is a matter of divine compacts.  You can't get new spells "every dawn" by Teleporting, because it's not allowed.  The Compact of Creation would of course have loopholes, for that it was written by Asmodeus Himself.  But it would not have loopholes so obvious that mortals would see them, for then the gods of Good would have seen them too, and before it was too late for Them.

So -- what does the Compact say about his being on a different planet?  Must he wait a long time between dawns?  That doesn't seem any more sensible than being able to get spells twice as fast if the planet's dawns come more frequently... and Esta does not really know which of these is the case on this planet.  It was night when he opened his eyes again after drowning, and it is night again now, but that could have reflected multiple day-night changes.  His intuition says no, but this, Esta knows for intuition and not knowledge.

...Why is Esta not dead.  Mariona would have needed to reach him within four moments of his unconsciousness to use Breath of Life after his death, and Mariona is not 5th-circle in the first place??  Esta is reasonably sure her fortress does not have an emergency Raise Dead scroll.

Esta sets aside that question.

Esta was not woken by a sense of Asmodeus's presence, within those 24 hours, to cue him that it was time to pray.

Maybe the Compact just says at this point that Esta can pray at will, but only once every 24 hours, if there is otherwise no civilization here?

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Maybe Asmodeus is out of range of wherever they are.

Permalink Mark Unread

It is with a strange sense of internal conflict, which Esta is himself suppressing and not thinking about and not allowing himself to be aware about at all, that Esta decides that clearly the correct thing to do here is immediately test his theory that if he prays to Asmodeus then of course surely Asmodeus will hear him.

 

My Lord, I have been sent far from where this wretched worm may be of use to You, to a place where I know not the hours of its dawns.  If I yet have the smallest use to You, or may be of use to You in the future, and the Compact permits it to be so, I beg of You that power which You grant to even the foulness beneath Your feet, if it serve Your plans; and serve You I will...

Permalink Mark Unread

WOW that squirrel has gotten itself lost.  Asmodeus can, like, barely hear it from here.

Permalink Mark Unread

There is a sense then of His presence, but diminished, so faint that for a terrible moment Esta dares to wonder if he is imagining Him.

...no, no no no, Esta is not imagining Him --

Spells.  Spells would be the proof.

Permalink Mark Unread

It is possible that if the squirrel focuses all its pathetic desires on ONE spell it REALLY wants, that Asmodeus would be able to hear that ONE THING.

Is its tiny squirming brain able to figure that part out?

Permalink Mark Unread

Nope, Esta is now considering his spell loadout for the day, and realizing in the back of his mind that he maybe should've gathered more information before praying, but eh water under the bridge.

From his domains of Arcane and Devil, Esta... probably wants Analyze Dweomer for 6th?  Because he has already noticed some confusing things around him and Detect Magic might not cut it; also, Planar Binding (of devils only) would work better with additional spells and infrastructure that is perhaps more of a matter for tomorrow.  For his three freely-choosable 6ths, two Heals and a Word of Recall, just in case it is that simple...

Permalink Mark Unread

This is why all mortals deserve infinite pain.

Permalink Mark Unread

Asmodeus has no idea what's going on way the fuck over there, when it comes to Him just choosing spells on behalf of this basically inaudible squirrel.

Thankfully, this dovetails well with an information-theoretic rule about intervention costs, which says that You don't have to pay huge intervention costs on sending godchosen spells to Your clerics if You have non-situationally-optimized rules that You follow about them.

Asmodeus is just gonna send over His standard prechosen Incredibly Lost Squirrel Loadout, 6th circle, Arcane+Devil edition, Day 1.

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

Either Esta was making appallingly bad choices there, and his current situation is astronomically important to Asmodeus, or...

...there is something not correct about this prayer process?


Does Esta in fact correctly remember how prayers work, or did Y̴̨̊ŏ̴͙g̷͙̊-̵̗͝S̴͈͗o̴͈͘t̶͕̐h̷̻͘o̸̪͛t̷̨̓h̶̺̋ overwrite Esta's understanding of that with false information the way that Mariona now speaks a different language and...

Permalink Mark Unread

...he is going to try treating this enormous load of godchosen spells as meaningful, because that is the usual rule if you get a godchosen spell from Asmodeus.  But Esta will keep his Perception peeled for the possibility that this is not actually at all what is going on.

Permalink Mark Unread

One of the spells that Asmodeus gave him, which Esta did not ask for, was Liberating Command.

Permalink Mark Unread

(Sometimes extremely lost squirrels have been captured and tied up, yes.  It is a good Day 1 spell to grant if You otherwise are unable to hear or see what is going on with Your squirrel.)

Permalink Mark Unread

And another spell -- which Esta did ask for, and from which he therefore cannot deduce as much, but maybe other godchosen spells revolve around it -- was Cure Light Wounds.

Esta is not actually sure how fast broken bones are supposed to heal for non-commoners.  He knows, from his very early days as a cleric, that broken bones and other complicated injuries take much longer to heal for commoners than the simple logic of 'commoners have very few hit points and should reach full in short order' would suggest.  But also that if you use even a healing spell as weak and simple as Cure Light, a correctly set bone in a commoner will seal right up again.  For powerful adventurers, of course, the question of natural healing mostly does not arise.

Cure Light Wounds (1st) has a somatic component but it is a simple component.  If his hands proved to be healing too slowly, Esta had thought to put in some extra effort and take some risk of further (curable) damage, and just force his fucking fingers to make that simple gesture and tap himself.

Altered-Mariona had politely removed his fingers from their splints on request, but had then considered it apparently very needful to bind them up again afterwards.

Now Esta has been god-given Liberating Command, a 1st-circle spell for making makeable Escape Artist checks; a spell, fittingly, with a purely verbal component.  This suggests perhaps that Esta is supposed to forcibly cure his fingers, after extracting his currently-broken fingers from the splints surrounding them, on his own -- quietly, and without giving notice to altered-Mariona.

Permalink Mark Unread

(If Asmodeus had the tiniest clue what was going on over there, He would not have so much prioritized sending His lost squirrel spells like Commune, a domain spell of Planar Binding for devils, or a lesser spell of Planar Inquiry, that should all obviously convey His command that the squirrel TRY TO REPORT BACK.)

(For that matter, the fact that Esta now has a Commune spell and no expensive incense to cast it, should already be a clue about how little Asmodeus knows of what's going on over there.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Sure, those would all be reasonable things for somebody to deduce if they were in general excellent health; and reasoning things through carefully, more slowly, and in less of a condition of general extreme confusion and five different kinds of fully suppressed panic.

Liberating Command, spoken as quietly as he can manage the word.  It is the sort of spell that works almost instantly if it works at all.

Permalink Mark Unread

That's +20 on an Escape Artist check, against restraints not actually designed to resist an escape artist?

Yeah, Esta's gonna make that one.

Permalink Mark Unread

The quietly spoken word itself, not spoken in tones of distress or calling-for-help, is not by itself going to be enough to wake Merrin. 

 

However, dislodging the splints also dislodges the pulse ox probe on his finger. A sensor-error alarm would not normally, necessarily be the scariest, but Merrin has no one to hand off to and no backup and she was very on edge before going to sleep, and "her patient dislodges his oxygen cannula while shifting position and then has a respiratory problem" was high among her priors, and before going to sleep she turned that particular alarm volume up much louder. 

 

THIS MACHINE WOULD LIKE MERRIN TO KNOW THAT IT JUST LOST SIGNAL AND REQUIRES HER ATTENTION!

(It's not objectively that loud - it won't necessarily sound to Esta like it indicates a screaming emergency - but it's a sound that worms into Merrin's brain.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

It's been four and a half hours since Merrin fell asleep. 

 

 

mrrrrrrg? oh crap that's a familiar medical alarm why is she asleep at work what was she thinking - eyes open - oh right, now she remembers, she's not at work she's on ANOTHER PLANET and doing SOLO MEDICAL CARE OVERNIGHT and that's even worse - 

(It's going to take Merrin a good ten seconds to fully get herself awake and out of her blanket-nest to go fix the sensor problem, though.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, shit.

Esta is going to try to fucking force his fingers into a sufficiently right position at any cost in pain, quickly, and then try that Cure Light on himself.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yadda yadda make some sort of skill check, DC whatever.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta rolls a number.

Permalink Mark Unread

And he is not wholly healed, but his fingerbones are sufficiently set to try the next spell.

Can he get a Cure Moderate off before altered-Mariona stops him?

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, she's not going to forcibly stop him from saying a word and wiggling his fingers, because she's very much still orienting to the situation and has no idea he's going to specifically try that, or any reason to try to stop him from doing that in particular. 

She will see him do it, though. She's up, bleary-eyed, not yet fully focused but awake, and scooting toward him without standing up, mostly looking at the monitor-screen she propped against her stool - she's going to run through so much of her stored battery power tonight, ugh, mostly running the oxygen concentrator but the monitoring suite and blood analyzer and portable diagnostic ultrasound weren't free either - she hasn't quite noticed that the splints are off, yet, he's clearly alert and breathing and she's making sure the vital sign readings she does still have up are not scary numbers before she does anything else, but if he makes a gesture that's going to be hard to miss - 

Permalink Mark Unread

And that will take his fingers to fully cured, along with the rest of his bones, and his bruising.

Esta is now healed of such maladies as may be reflected in hit points alone.

Does Mariona seem to be of a mind to allow Esta to cast further spells without interference?

Permalink Mark Unread

She's not going to, like, tackle him to the ground about it! That wouldn't help with anything! 

 

She has gotten herself over beside him and is staring with obvious ENORMOUS confusion at the hand splint, no longer on her patient's hands, and instead on the ground beside him along with the pulse ox probe. And at the sudden lack of bruises???

Is she hallucinating right now from sheer sleep deprivation - it would be a bit surprising, that's never happened to her before and she's done a lot of very extended trainings before and also, like, she was way more sleep deprived before her nap than she is now, but also she's never dealt with such an extended and emotionally-stressful-on-a-personal-level medical emergency after six planetary months of being completely isolated and plausibly suffering micronutrient deficiencies with cognitive effects and, on priors, with her sanity already fraying at the edges, despite all the cognitive strategies she has tried to dredge out of the void and her conversations with Imaginary Laeirthe in order to wildly guess at how a smarter and better-trained dath ilani would be able to simply decide not to have a psychotic break even when subject to arbitrary stressors and adverse conditions...

 

She definitely doesn't look like someone who recognizes the very concept of casting a Cure spell on oneself. 

Permalink Mark Unread

The next one he's going for is Tongues, actually.  It is less catastrophic to lose that than the single Heal which Asmodeus granted him, if she interferes; and if she does not interfere, it is the obvious spell for ordering her not to interfere with further spells.

What happens if he tries to sit up and raise his hand to his chest, to grasp where his holy symbol should be?

Permalink Mark Unread

That seems kind of unwise! But, like, not in a way where it would help to Merrin to get into a wrestling match over it with a patient who has a skull fracture!

 

...Instinctively, the thing she does instead is very quickly move into position to help him sit up, arranging herself so that she'll easily be able to catch and support him if he gets dizzy and starts to fall over. She does it with the unthinking automatic-ness of someone who's done that exact thing a few thousand times. 

Permalink Mark Unread

This... does not really seem like a case where he actually needed to hide what he was doing from Mariona...

What of His unholy symbol, the fine pentagram of red gold inlaid upon mithril?

Permalink Mark Unread

Anything he was wearing as a necklace is no longer on him! Merrin carefully removed everything that was removable and that might, like, choke him if it got caught on something, that's just common sense. 

 

(It's not far away – the interior of Merrin's cave shelter is not huge, and has no interior room divisions. The armor she cut off him is in a pile on the ground, and anything she was able to remove without destroying it is instead laid out on the top of one of her gear boxes. It is very dark, though, the space lit only by a handful of bedtime-mode LED strip lights, and may be hard to spot.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

And Esta is now right back to noticing the incoherence between taking away his unholy symbol and his armor, versus removing the splints when requested and helping him sit up in bed.  This is a contradictory set of actions if everything Esta thinks he remembers is true.

...But he will risk making a use of a divine focus, even given that Mariona might have been correctly and helpfully and wisely removing it from him, because he needs to ask her some questions in order to get anywhere from here.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta bends over further, and touches the bottom of his left foot.

And, for the first time ever, after over a full decade, actually makes use of the emergency backup pentagram he'd had expensively tattooed onto the bottom of that foot, after reaching fourth circle.

Esta does not know why more clerics do not do this.  It seems like such an obvious precaution to him.  Well, except that then your captors will just cut off your foot if they do catch on; but eh, at 4th circle you can afford a Regenerate if you need one.

Permalink Mark Unread

Tongues.

(Mariona will probably not fail to observe his mouth emitting sounds that are odd even by previous standards, or his fingers doing elaborate things.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is KIND OF ALARMED by all the moving-around he's doing! She did not IDENTIFY any spinal damage, or any serious internal bleeding, but he did have the baffling problem when she took his possibly-a-bizarre-medical-device belt, and Merrin is aware that she could have just missed an injury given how exhausted she already was by the time she got him back to the shelter and her diagnostic equipment. 

Anyway, compared to that, saying a weird-sounding word or wiggling his fingers is really not at the top of what's stressing her out. 

She doesn't actually try to stop him, but she is very very obviously hovering with the intent, focused expression of someone preparing to react instantly to an emergency. 

 

(She's so confused. She's so so so confused. The only reason she's not saying tsi-imbi about it is because she did that, like, a dozen times early on, and of course nothing happened, and it's been months and she is in fact pretty sure - she was more sure before the latest new confusing events, but still pretty sure - that she cannot possibly still be in dath ilan and having an untreated psychotic break that entire time so it would not accomplish anything, and, like, even if Estha is sufficiently with-it to know what she means despite apparently not being able to speak or understand anything ELSE in Baseline, that feels like kind of a lot to put on him right now. Anyway, she's currently firmly in the mode of "doing common-sense reasonable things that are unlikely to cause an enormous disaster if her interpretation of what's happening is completely off", while in the background trying to drag together the confusion observations but not, yet, take decisive actions about any guesses she might have.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta thinks of the words he remembers Mariona shouting at him earlier -- 'tidal bore' -- and wills himself to speak in that language as he says, in Baseline, "Report."

Permalink Mark Unread

(As is not, in fact, the exact standard word you'd speak to tell a subordinate in Exception Handling to give you a compressed report; as is the closest analogy for what Esta thinks he's trying to do.)

(It's not particularly idiomatic Baseline for any particular situation, in fact.  Maybe a hospital analogy would be if a doctor walked into an ongoing emergency, and as their first action inside the room, said, "Summarize!")

Permalink Mark Unread

???????????????????????????????????

 

Merrin has had six and a half hours of sleep out of the last forty-nine hours and is (mostly accidentally, she's been super distracted) running a serious calorie deficit today. She's...not going to successfully think about Big Important Questions like whether her broader model of Reality is systematically incomplete. So she's not trying, right now, she'll just take at face value that yesterday Estha was having some kind of communication-affecting cognitive dysfunction and now it's somewhat better and she doesn't need a complete accounting of how or why to do the obvious thing and answer a question he asked her. 

(He's not actually in her Exception Handling chain of command, she wouldn't necessarily expect him to use the standard idiom, but he does know she works there, so she's weakly noting that this could be a sign of ongoing disfluency, just less severe than 'unable to speak words in Baseline at all'. None of this fits very well with her pre-existing knowledge base on how recovery from a head injury looks, but that is really not the only thing she's confused about.) 

 

She can summarize what's been going on, sure, if that's the first thing he needs to feel more in control of the situation. It makes perfect sense to her - and to the blurry thread of Laeirthe-opinions that is just barely managing to exist in her frazzled brain - that it would be, that's a normal human way to feel and also characteristic for Estha specifically.

The report is going to come out very much on automatic, the sort of scripted response she can spit out while 60% of her attention is on monitoring a patient's medical status (or, in this case, it's more because only 40% of her cognition is online at all) and is therefore not particularly adjusted for any of her enormous confusions. 

 

"I've been here for four months by my count." Since she doesn't know if there's, like, ???relativistic time dilation??? involved, or whether it's been the same interval in dath ilan. "It appears to be an exoplanet orbiting a hotter more distant star - still habitable zone, obviously, liquid oceans - with a 64-hour planetary day and a closer, more massive moon closer moon causing larger tidal amplitude." Normally she would take for granted that Estha could obviously infer 'larger tidal amplitude' from facts about the moon, but she's modeling him as pretty impaired. "Native life present, I infer earlier in its history, some edible and non-toxic but likely not providing adequate nutrition." 

There, that's the basic backstory. Now for the recent-event summary.

"Yesterday afternoon - about 25 hours ago now, forty percent of a planetary day - I saw you coming out of the cave. By the way that cave has radon gas, but I didn't detect any radiation signature on you and haven't observed any symptoms so I infer your exposure was low. I tried to warn you about the tidal bore, wasn't in time. Went in after you, pulled you out 1500 meters upstream, you were in respiratory arrest but still had a pulse, I got you breathing and transported you back here and provided medical care. We're a little before midnight, local time."

Pause.

"How are you feeling?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

There are SO MANY additional questions here, starting with why she is reporting HOW THE TIDES WORK instead of MANY things you'd think Esta would obviously want to know more -- four months, what -- 

And what sort of bizarre language is this -- stupid question, it's a Dark Tapestry language spoken by things that think half in numbers and have words for varieties of planets and stars like wizards have words for their Spellcraft --

But Mariona is asking a question that perhaps makes sense for a healer to ask, and he will abide its lack of courtesy for all else that is happening.  "I am narrowly recovered as to --"

And then Esta stops, because this language has no word for the sort of vitality that is healed by Cure spells, as distinguished from ability damage or drain, or fatigue or exhaustion, or negative levels, or insanity.

"...simple... health."

Can he ask why she took away his divine focus?  Or if she thinks it's unsafe for him to cast with one?

No.

Because the language they're speaking has no word for an unholy symbol.

And it has no word that means to cast a spell.

Permalink Mark Unread

From Merrin's perspective, that is a fairly bizarre way to answer the question! She would normally expect, like, a list of symptoms, for her to use her greater medtech expertise to put together with all the additional information she has from her monitoring and make updates about his overall status? Pain (by location and roughly-quantified severity), weakness, subjective sense of deficits, that sort of thing. Instead he's...making a confident high-level claim about how recovered he is, with a bizarre un-idiomatic phrasing, and hesitating in the middle like he was having trouble remembering the words to finish his sentence. 

She's concerned! Just going off the content of what he said, Estha seems pretty not-okay! 

 

...He doesn't look sick, is the thing. Merrin has a really, really finely-honed intuition for that, by now, and her finely-honed intuition is cheerfully informing her that he looks great. Like, relatively speaking, her intuition doesn't think she should take him out on a strenuous hike or anything, but he looks like a patient who does not even slightly need intensive-care-resource-level monitoring or attention, and in fact could probably complete the rest of his recovery at home. 

Merrin is not just going to take her gut-level intuition at face value, obviously. But it's loud and it's jarring and she's painfully confused. 

 

(Imaginary Laeirthe from her fanfiction is...trying to raise a thought to her attention, wow that does not normally happen that unwilled, she wasn't trying for a Laeirthe-input and normally she has to try...the incomplete wordless mental motion is something like PAY! MORE! ATTENTION! Which would be great advice, and all, except for how Merrin does not really have any more attention available right now.) 

 

It won't help to look stressed or alarmed. It won't help to be stressed or alarmed, in fact, and Merrin is throwing all of her years of hard-won skills and mental techniques at not being. 

"Estha," she says, slowly and carefully, "do you - remember - what happened to me four months ago? ...Might've been a different time interval for you, but - after the last time you saw me?" 

Something is wrongwrongwrong. Merrin isn't sure if the problem is within her boyfriend's brain or, like, with Reality more broadly, but something is wrong, and "does Estha remember the ALMOST MAXIMALLY MEMORABLE event of his masochist girlfriend's True Death in a plane crash" is a cognitive check that she should perhaps have thought to ask him first

Permalink Mark Unread

"Four months ago, according to my own understanding of temporal processes, I showed up at your... home... for a surprise visit involving an amusing amount of pain."

"Two days ago, according to my own understanding of temporal processes, you were about your ordinary work so far as I know."

"Only if it is not cognitohazardous for you to think of it or speak of it, do you remember the causalpathway that led to your arrival here?"

This language has a disturbingly short word for describing Dark Tapestry things you should not try to remember, but that also figures.

Permalink Mark Unread

.......

 

When did she - yeah, okay, that did happen, well, it was eight months ago for her - now is really not the time to dwell on how much she's missed him or exactly how long it's been since her life involved ANY SADIST BOYFRIENDS, is it - 

(It will probably be apparent to Esta that Merrin's reaction to the mentioned "visit" is a burst of affection-toward-him and rapidly-suppressed longing.) 

 

She didn't, uh, previously think that it was cognitohazardous for her to think about what happened to her? Just, like, if this was in fact a phenomenon known to others in dath ilan, the whole "respawning on exoplanets after True Death" thing, then there was presumably a reason it wasn't general knowledge... 

 

"There was a plane crash," she says, carefully. "In circumstances where I expected no one on the plane to be successfully cryopreserved. I very briefly experienced the start of a lethal ground impact, I think, I guess I can't really say I 'experienced' 'dying' - and then there was a discontinuity, and then I woke up on this planet. With exactly the set of Exception Handling gear boxes that I'd brought on the flight, though they weren't directly beside me at the moment of the crash." 

A pause. "....I don't know if this part is - related to any existing knowledge or theory generally considered cognitohazardous? But it felt weirdly like...a situation where the challenge level was optimized to be just barely survivable for me, specifically? To an extent I would not expect to happen by chance."

Merrin somewhat-markedly-for-Baseline isn't putting numbers on, like, her assigned likelihood to this happening by chance, because she has enough uncertainty on deeper levels to have no idea how to assign priors there and it feels unusually much like making-numbers-up. And also she's really, really tired, and numbers are harder for her than for normal people at the best of times. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"As you see it, does that story makecompletesense?"  Esta has the feeling that 'makecompletesense' means something way more specific than he even knows how to say in words, but whatever, it also feels like vaguely the right thing to mean.  "Is there a retrospectivelyobviousaccount of why a -- plane crash -- would send you here, four months ahead of when I arrived myself?  With your particular -- gear -- that was not even adorning you at the time?"

Permalink Mark Unread

(Adorning her???? What is with Estha’s vocabulary choices, this is the weirdest word-finding-disfluency that Merrin has ever observed a patient having. She is seized by a brief and very silly mental image of herself, like, wearing all of the IV and oxygen tubing piled up around her neck.)


“No!” Merrin would really have thought that would be obvious! “But I am below-median-thinkoomph, right, I think it’s not very surprising that I couldn’t hypothesize and test a new model of aspects of Reality I have no training for, on my own.”

 

The claim that Merrin is simply and matter-of-factly making doesn’t quite feel like it should translate to “lower Cunning than most people”, but it feels like it’s not terribly far off from that claim? (The language does not seem to have a vocabulary for the standard three mental abilities that Esta is familiar with, at least not in exactly three categories for Cunning, Wisdom, and Splendor.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"We are suffering from fabricated, stolen, or adjusted memories.  Some combination of those two, applying to me, to you, or to both of us, sufficient-to-account-for-discrepancy.  One day ago as I remember it, you and I, in the same place, came into simultaneous contact with an entity I'm trying not to think about in detail but certainly powerful enough to transport us here and modify our minds.  I would not call it fullyunderstood but it is -- fundamentally within retrospectiveprediction if not advanceexactprediction.  As my understanding makes more retrospectivesense than yours, I therefore defeasiblysuspect that your mind has been affected more than my own, which is also what would have been advancepredicted based on our respective degrees of susceptibility to -- mind control."

What a strange language.  It is so much more Lawful than Esta would have suspected of the Dark Tapestry.  It is expressing thoughts more precise than Esta himself ever previously had words for, shades of intuitive meaning that Taldane would not force him to distinguish and put into explicit words.  Even Infernal as Esta knows it would not distinguish those words, and it is suddenly obvious that this is because Hell's intervention budget cannot afford to teach mortal Asmodeans real Infernal.  Aspexia Rugatonn would fucking love this language, if anyone could safely strip all the Dark Tapestryness out of it...

...or Esta once previously knew all those words and meanings, and has forgotten them as thoroughly as Mariona has forgotten words about magic.

Permalink Mark Unread

Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah????!!!!!!

Permalink Mark Unread

All of that is, like, fair? Uh, accounting for the part where it's completely absurd, but the situation was already absurd, having a theory for how it happened that is ALSO absurd is kind of expected with the territory. 

Merrin was fully aware that the sequence of events she observed does not really make sense. She's been tracking for the last four months that she was probably missing some key piece that would let her form a hypothesis of what the fuck. It's not surprising that Estha would, potentially, have a knowledge base broader than her on, like, higher-level models of Reality than the extremely concrete human-biology knowledge base she's specialized in. 

 

...Except that the phrase he grabbed, there, "mind control", is...not, actually, the phrase someone would use for a thing in the same conceptual bucket as Keeper talk-control but presumably considered more infohazardous since Merrin was not previously cleared to know about it. It's, instead, a phrase that Merrin has only encountered in fictional worldbuilding – a subtype of mentalisticmagic, itself a subtype of conceptualmagic.

(It happens to exist in the fictional setting that the original Laeirthe character was taken from.) 

Um. 

 

Like, taking that for granted it is not actually shocking that Estha is hypothesizing he would be harder to affect than her. That makes perfect sense if one is accepting the premise!

Just. 

What. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Also: Merrin is at all tracking that, whether or not she should be putting any weight on her interpretation of observations she's making, it does seem to her that Estha is more impaired than her? Both right now, and notably also from the moment he arrived? 

Like, sure, he's not an Exception Handling endurance specialist, but he should have been able to recognize an intertidal zone when he saw one, and not need a warning to get out of it? Okay, fine, maybe that part was just the heatstroke and hypoxia, or - maybe Merrin is doing a little bit of the thing she does where she assumes that people who are smarter than her will just simply definitely know more things than her even though that is not how specialization works, but - something about the entire story she's telling herself isn't quite holding together -

 

She's confused. 

Permalink Mark Unread

She wants to ask what actually happened, from his own perspective, that he thinks was edited out of her memory (aaaaah????!!!!).

Merrin knows better than to do that, when he just told her very clearly it was cognitohazardous. 

 

(The imaginary voice of Laeirthe is trying to flag some kind of objection to that but Merrin is not listening, right now. Merrin is, uh, slightly wondering if having the experience of "the imaginary fictional character from her fanfiction is now trying to talk in her head without her intending that" is something that should be taken as evidence that her mind is in fact messed up.) 

 

"Okay," she says. "...I'm now unsure to what extent I should be trusting my memories after the event I believed I experienced, that you think didn't happen, but - I do have memories of staying alive on this planet for four months - uh, after the point of my memory of the plane crash, I currently have memories of eight months elapsing since your visit and it seems like you only remember four months? - and forming an understanding of our constraints. ...I'm also flagging that I'm very confused about a lot of medical observations I made over the course of rescuing you, and I - don't know what I'm missing - so it's possible that my medical training knowledge base is scrambled and you should be sanity-checking everything I say or do on that topic."  

Wow. That would be upsetting. That would be really really upsetting!!!!! Though, like, surely there's a cap on how confused she can be, she did manage to get him out of the river alive and stuff...

Permalink Mark Unread

Her medical knowledge has not been scrambled, it has been replaced by something out of the Dark Tapestry.

Alternatively, Esta's own memories about the nature and purpose and principles of... all the noisy flashy things in this healer's tent... were eliminated.

Either way, it makes sense of why Esta's holy symbol is missing.  Because if he saw anything looking as inscrutable as all those flashy things, attached to an injured Mariona, he would remove them.

Esta will give her a half-smile, exaggerated as he has noticed all of Mariona's facial expressions to now be exaggerated.  "Be assured that I am responsibility-acceptingly tracking that."

"You look like you did not get enough sleep before being interrupted.  I certainly have more questions but they can wait until you are --" no longer suffering from the Fatigued condition "-- rested."

And it will give him some much-needed time to think, as well.

Permalink Mark Unread

He's really, really not wrong. Merrin can tell when she's pushed herself well past her limits and is paying for staying-awake-longer with increasing impairment; having a better sense for that and for navigating the tradeoffs there is a lot of what her endurance training was about. There are times when a 4.5 hour nap would be enough to get her more or less functional again for another block of work, but this is not one of those times, and right now she's still drowning in sleep inertia and actually feels a lot more tired than she did before she lay down. 

 

Estha does not look sick. Merrin....is currently inclined to go with the cluster-of-observations that include that plus his own self-report plus all the various "wow it's really lucky he wasn't worse off from that" confusions earlier, and tentatively consider that the cluster-of-medical-knowledge that makes all of this seem really surprising is the part that got scrambled. 

...That conclusion miiiight be involving some degree of motivated cognition because she really, really wants getting some sleep to be the correct decision, rather than the correct decision being to push through her exhaustion even longer because, in the event of an Estha-deterioration, an impaired Merrin is still more useful than a Merrin who isn't even conscious at the time? And also some degree of motivation cognition around not wanting to argue with Estha about it? 

Buuuuuuut the fact that Merrin cannot tell introspectively, even once she's attending to it, how much of her conclusion is motivated cognition, does not bode well for her functionality right now. 

 

"Okay," she says. "...It's going be really cold later, the day and night temperatures are extreme and I can't afford overnight heating or it'll get dangerously hot in the daytime. Um, if you're recovered enough that it won't hurt you, we could cuddle, and stay warmer? I'd like to, because I really missed you," and also she gave him the good sleeping bag and is relegated to a pile of blankets that will be much less cozy once it's -10° C in here, but that's not really the reason she's making the bid, "but conditional on your preference being neutral-to-positive," she finishes. 

The latter phrase is idiomatic in Baseline. The sentiment would, of course, be a spectacularly bizarre and uncharacteristic one for Mariona, or anyone from Cheliax, to express. 

Permalink Mark Unread

No expression shows on Esta's face as he remembers that thing which very famously happened to Dou-Bral, after Dou-Bral wandered too far out among the stars, and became the worst possible abject lesson to every other god.

Is Mariona now Chaotic Good.

Esta has not been granted a Break Enchantment this day, though he had requested two such of Asmodeus.

Esta really really hopes this is because it is deemed important that he observe and learn more about this phenomenon before unmaking it, and not because a Break Enchantment will predictably not help.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I expect I will want to stand up some and move around, before it becomes so cold that we must huddle together for warmth.  Apart from that, it seems a terribly logical suggestion."

Esta was given an Endure Elements and an Extended Planetary Adaptation, and they may need to use both of those in the hot phase of the day -- though he has no idea how Mariona has been surviving up until now.  Maybe both are for him, in the hot phase of this planet's very long day; Esta did not miss the part about 64 hours.

Also, Esta has met Chaotic Good people before.  Sometimes even under circumstances where he isn't allowed to torture them to death before Maledicting them!

Permalink Mark Unread

UM he wants to do WHAT NOW. 

 

 

"......You should override my advice if you're confident that you own understanding conflicts with it and that walking is - safe right now," she says, "but I do want to note that you broke both your legs. Pretty badly. I spent, like, two hours getting all the bone fragments lined up so I could splint them properly and I'll be really sad if you mess them up again." 

(She's being somewhat more imprecise in her speech than she would normally aim for, which Merrin's Estha would recognize as the thing that happens when a Merrin is really extremely tired and also on the downswing from a stressful situation and starting to actually relax.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Are there any restraints that would prevent Esta from standing up?

Permalink Mark Unread

Nope! His lower legs are both encased in splints that look similar to the ones on his forearms - and don't look like any material recognizable in Golarion - and there's a shaped block of some sort of absorbent material down there too (for pee-catching purposes), but he's not tied down to anything and will be able to withdraw himself from the sleeping bag with no difficulty. 

Permalink Mark Unread

All right then, Esta will go about extracting himself from the sleeping bag, though with some watchfulness to see if there are any unexpected stabs of pain; and if there are not, he will stand up, and perform a little hop and then a larger jump by way of final test.

"I do stronglyexpect I would notice if my legs had stayed broken; and on this basis, I determine that on this occasion you are the one with missing, fabricated, or modified memories."

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

....Yeah, okay, Merrin is going to go with the cluster-of-observations where he's obviously fine and not the detailed model of how biology that confidently predicts he should not be fine because that way she gets to sleep. 

"Drinking water's in the cistern over there," she says, gesturing vaguely at it. "Food is in the grey boxes – um, left one is cold storage, there's some snail, I'm fairly confident it's nontoxic to eat insofar as I believe I have memories of eating it for months without ill-effects - right has crackers made from local plant matter and what's left of my rations from dath ilan, you're welcome to eat those first, they're better. ...I'm gonna get in the sleeping bag now, you can join me when you're ready to sleep again?" 

And unless he has a counterargument or questions - which to be clear would be so reasonable of him, that was spectacularly sloppy explanation - she'll do that and close her eyes and be asleep within thirty seconds. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Poor Mariona has been eating snails!  Well, such is the fate of those who do not reach Asmodeus's 3rd circle at least.

Permalink Mark Unread

...or those who forget Him entirely.  For the language they were speaking has no word for gods.

There are words that suggest themselves as associated, but when Esta whispers them under his breath, they prove to mean different things once spoken; superintelligence might as well describe Nex as Asmodeus, unless Esta is missing something about the concept of great Cunning.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta is hungry, as he has not been in literally years.  It makes sense, if little Mariona had no concept of what those strange hoops of metal were doing on his fingers, and whether they were good hoops or bad hoops; but it is still hugely inconvenient and will be for a full week.

He may as well get started on Create Food and Water... or no, first he ought to look around his surroundings.  If Mariona has thrown away his unholy symbol and his rings, Esta will be very displeased, for that would be folly and not just uncertainty.  And what has become of his armor?  Most importantly, his Bag of Holding?

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

His rings and unholy symbol are very easy to find! They have been carefully laid out on a very worn and stained but currently cleanish scrap of absorbent cloth (the specific ultra-durable, machine-woven synthetic-fiber textile is in fact completely unrecognizable to Esta), on top of a table that from a distance looks like ordinary wicker and is, on closer inspection, instead entirely woven out of what appears to be leathery strips of dried seaweed. 

His clothes are in a pile on the floor. (Merrin did cut them in a few places, and initially tried to leave as much intact fabric as possible but ended up concluding that the fabric quality was inexplicably abysmal anyway and it wasn't worth that much additional time and attention and risk to his broken bones to salvage more of it.) 

His armor is also on the floor in a pile. And also appears to have been cut into pieces in the process of removing it from his body, which should not really be possible. (And will remain entirely unexplained, because Merrin's tiny shelter cannot afford clutter and she needs to make her tools last and so she immediately put everything away, including the tungsten carbide powered hand saw.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Of course!  What healer stripped of all her magic -- whose 2nd-circle magic would in any case not begin to accomplish such a thing -- could not casually cut magical armor off of her patient if it was in her way?  Why, how would that not be easier and faster than pulling it over the patient's head?

Mariona has some extraordinarily dangerous specialabilities that Esta knows nothing about -- either because they are new to her, or because he has forgotten them himself.

Permalink Mark Unread

Other than that, there's indeed a freshwater cistern (also woven of seaweed, and lined with a transparent, flexible, and startlingly tough material that Esta will not begin to recognize), with a pipe made of the same material running along a ceiling strut from outside of the shelter and apparently draining into it, though there's no water-flow through it now. 

There is a pile of storage boxes, also with a design and made of materials that are completely unfamiliar. 

The shelter - which he can now see is half formed from a limestone cave - itself looks remarkably stable and solid and well-constructed, for something that is, again, entirely and completely woven of straplike seaweed; there's no sign of something as ordinary as wood, around here, only bizarre impossible Dark Tapestry materials and literal dried seaweed. 

There's a lot of strange black cords, mostly tucked out of the way behind the storage boxes. One of them leads to the oxygen concentrator, which unless he's removed the cannula himself, is still then connected to him. Another leads to an even more bizarre Dark Tapestry contraption that straddles the narrow mouth of a tunnel leading into a darker, deeper cave, and seems to be forcing bursts of even chillier underground air into the interior of the shelter. 

The two grey boxes, if he opens them - they're latched but it's an easy design to figure out and they're not otherwise locked - then one will indeed prove to contain half-melted iceblocks and then chunks of pale meat contained in bags made of the same transparent material, and the other will contain woven baskets and crude baked-clay bowls of very odd-looking flatbread-cracker stuff, and also a small number of even stranger, not-particularly-foodlike items, sealed in some sort of shiny colorful material. 

The lighting comes from odd strips of some material adhered to the woven ceiling or struts. If Esta tries Detect Magic, they won't Detect as magical at all. 

The strange adventurer-armor he saw her wearing before looks even stranger up close, where it's been leaned against the limestone wall, standing up by itself; it seems to open at the back like a mouth, rather than fitting over her in pieces, and it's also made of a material that does not look like metal or leather or anything else he recognizes; it's mostly a matte dark grey, with some reflective patches, and it's very very sturdy and hard but not quite as rigid as metal. Another, thicker black cord runs from it to disappear behind the stacked crates. A small status light is blinking on one side of the helmet, which is fully sealed with some kind of hard, transparent material that resembles but definitely isn't ordinary glass. (It also does not Detect as magical.) 

 

 

What there's no sign of, anywhere, is his Bag of Holding. 

Permalink Mark Unread

He'll get around to that level of exploration shortly.

The first thing Esta does is cast Detect Magic, in case he can find his Holding Bag somewhere unobtrusive -- though he may well end up blinded, or his sight obscured, by all of the obviously magical objects around him.

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

Right.

Well.

Working theory, the Dark Tapestry Inversion effect transforms items it touches, to run on principles so alien that Detect Magic can't see them at all, let alone analyze them.

...there's a little bit of magic coming from one side of the waist-section of Mariona's transformed armor.  Esta stares at it hopefully, analyzing it for three moments, until he realizes it's his own fucking Continual Flame headpiece stuffed into a pocket.

Permalink Mark Unread

His Holding Bag -- containing the Plane Shift tuning forks that were his primary hope of departing this place successfully, and a Sending scroll, and many other useful and expensive and did Esta mention helpful things for emergencies -- is nowhere to be seen, by plain vision or Detect Magic.

Maybe it's behind an inch of metal or a thin layer of lead.


Perhaps Asmodeus will see fit to grant Esta many Locate Object spells the next pseudoday; and he and Mariona will be able to find his Bag without it having been swept too far away by that Suddenly River.

 

Perhaps his Bag was punctured despite its combat chainmail shielding.  Perhaps it has been swept away too far to ever find again.  And if so, they are not getting out of here short of Aspexia Rugatonn using Discern Location and showing up with a Gate.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta is aware that he is permitting his thoughts to be disorganized.  Still.  It will be hard to think of things systematically until he has finished thinking the thoughts that just throw themselves at him immediately.

One of his first thoughts is to use the Greater Make Whole spell that Asmodeus saw fit to grant him; it has the very obvious intended use of repairing Esta's armor.

Permalink Mark Unread

(It's because Incredibly Lost Squirrels surprisingly often end up next to some mysteriously half-destroyed magical object, which could be very useful to them, if only it were repaired somehow.)

Permalink Mark Unread

...but he hesitates before the cast.  Esta feels naked without his armor, for reasons including but not limited to his actually being naked.  But it is possible that Mariona will speak to him of some other thing that needs repairing even more, or more urgently.  Esta is not accustomed to treating his 4th-circle spells as irreplaceable and valuable; but he does not, at this point, know if he can just get another Greater Make Whole spell tomorrow.

Permalink Mark Unread

He thinks next the thought that wishes to intrude itself:  Things transformed into Dark Tapestry forms seem to become noticeably more powerful.

Mariona's Worldwound armor was solid workmanship of Cheliax, but Esta rather suspects it cannot begin to compare to the smooth alien metal of the glowing alter-magical Thing that it became, after being t̷̯̏ō̷͙͌ú̵̬͝c̸̽̅͜h̸͈̆͠e̴̘̻͆́d̶͓͉̒ ̶̬̊̂b̶̪͇̓͠y̷͇͌̀ ̵̤̀͒H̵͇͋̔ỉ̶̱̇ś̴̢̺̔ ̸͈̀͠ń̷̨ö̴̩͘ỏ̵̼̱̉d̷̨̎̓ĺ̶̹̔y̷̨͑ ̶̫̽a̶͚͐p̷̱̂͝ṗ̵̘̟e̸̻̠̓̀n̷̹̄͐d̴̲̆a̷̦̐͋g̸̲̀̆e̴̹̅́.̸̭͇͐̔  Her army-issue nonmagical dagger, perhaps, became capable of cutting through Esta's magical armor as if it were linen.  Or perhaps it is Mariona herself who gained the power to cut what should not be cut.

It is not a strict improvement.  Mariona was able to bring Esta back from death after he drowned; but also she was surprised at Esta's healing, she remembered no way to mend a broken bone but time.  Even his 2nd-circle capabilities may seem as miraculous to her, now, as hers to him.

It seems unguessable whether he or altered-Mariona would win in a fight, if it came to a fight.

Permalink Mark Unread

And then there is Mariona herself.  Who, after having had something happen to her that may be akin to Dou-Bral's transformation to Zon-Kuthon, now seems to, well, to like him.

Permalink Mark Unread

Or, like the version of him that she now remembers.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta does not know why this thought seems to weigh so heavily on him.


It ought to confirm everything he has ever told himself about how the two of them previously had a rigorously proper and nonheretical Asmodean relationship.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Perhaps his intuition is trying to tell him something important.

That is probably it.

Vicar Esta will now carefully search for reasons why his first thought on this matter would be false.

Permalink Mark Unread

(As far as almost any mortal in Cheliax knows, after all, that is exactly how cognition is supposed to work and the whole point of thinking!  First your brain decides what to believe; and then, you go search for acceptable reasons to believe it!


If Asmodeus had promoted Esta to His 8th circle, Aspexia Rugatonn would have taken him carefully aside; and explained to Esta, and Esta alone, that this is not actually how thinking works.

 

Besides Aspexia Rugatonn, the only other humanoids in Golarion to figure out explicitly why not to do that, are a handful of Irorians in a Vudran temple who are treated with great suspicion for their unorthodox practice of passing around a +6 Wisdom headband in their daily meditations.

 

Somewhere on a vastly more distant planet with highly anomalous lunar eclipses, the actual majority of people who could correctly and rigorously explain in words why that is not how thinking works, are unusually attentive readers of Thellim's blog.

 

 

So not actually just a Cheliax problem.  But Cheliax does have it noticeably, if slightly, worse than usual.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Dou-Bral, who previously preferred not to kill Himself, did not prefer to kill Himself after He became Zon-Kuthon.  Why not?  Because the new version of Himself could now do things that pleased His new sensibilities.

Perhaps altered-Mariona and remembered-Esta -- Estha, she called him upon his awakening, and Tongues agrees that 'Esta' does not sound right in her new language -- perhaps those two did other things together.  That Estha preferred -- no, that she preferred.

That possibility does seem to quiet whatever his mind was trying to yell at him, the discordant intuition... yes.  Esta would not have expected Mariona to stab him in the back on a moment's inattention unless she could thereby take his place or gain some great benefit to herself; and honestly Esta would not have expected Mariona to do it even then, but that is because Mariona is silly.  The point is, she did not like the pain and the sex that he inflicted on her, and she did enjoy the benefits of his mentorship.

This version of Mariona, then, probably likes being hurt by him and having sex with him, and dislikes him assisting her career, and so Chaotic Good Estha has been having sex with her and torturing her but not promoting her to command of Worldwound fortresses.

...Esta has a feeling that he has not fully sorted out the key ideas, here.  He doesn't think Caydenites or Desnans torture each other for fun?  But then this is Dark Tapestry inversion and not just moving around the alignment chart.  Zon Kuthon is strange for Lawful Evil, because most Lawful Evil proceeds from vastly more sensible foundations than 'do the opposite of whatever Chaotic Good would do'.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta, at WIS 22, does now have a sense that he may have just thought as many as several things that will turn out to be stupid.

Esta, at WIS 22, is not going to ignore that feeling.  By his age, any high-ranking Asmodean priest has already been tortured about both jumping to conclusions and about failing to see the obvious.  The combination tends to leave strong impressions about the dangers both of thinking too fast and of failing to see what is before you.

Possibly some of all that reasoning may be wrong, there.

...but it does explain that strange look of -- fondness? wistfulness? longing? -- that crossed Mariona's face, when Esta mentioned his surprise visit of four months ago (on his time), and that it had involved an amusing amount of pain.  Esta had meant amusing to him, but...

 

At the very least, Esta should keep in mind generally that Altered-Mariona may remember a very strange relationship with 'Estha', and he should tread cautiously around it.  Even if, here and now, it seems to add up to her being solicitous of his desires.  Because it may well be that, mere pathetic affection, and not fear of him or obedience to Asmodeus's tyranny.

Permalink Mark Unread

So now, Estha is now going to think about all the things he should be thinking about!  His brain has learned that thinking about how Mariona got altered is the sort of thing that potentially leads to pain if he is not careful in what he thinks.

The most obvious thing Esta should be thinking about is the complicated loadout of spells that Asmodeus has sent him.  Possibly Esta should have done that earlier and before taking any actions, really.  Maybe that Liberating Command was meant for some future event and Esta has now wasted it, since it really doesn't seem like it was necessary... or maybe that superfluity is itself an illusion... or maybe Esta would've hesitated too long to Cure Light his hands and that would've been an error...

This is foolishness.  Esta needs to think about his godchosen spells in a more organized way.

Permalink Mark Unread

He could start from the most powerful spells, but there is one first-circle divination and one fourth-circle divination that he doesn't recognize at all, and the second-circle Augury he got looks importantly different from a Spellcraft angle.  Arguably, Esta should have prioritized thinking about those strange spells first and above all, in retrospect; it's just that he got so many godchosen spells landing on him at the same time --

Esta's mind shuts down the excuse-making.  Torturers who can read your thoughts are very unimpressed about mental excusemaking.  It does do a little to untrain the bad habit.

What is unusual about the Augury?  Is it possibly a special version that could work without the material component, 25gp of incense which Esta does not have on hand without his Holding Bag?

Permalink Mark Unread

Is Esta the level of archmage who could figure out the answer immediately?  If not, Esta needs to roll Spellcraft, DC 25.

He could also roll Knowledge (History) or Knowledge (Religion), DC 10, if he prefers.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta will take 10 on the Spellcraft check, because to realize that he even needs to make the other sort of check, he'd need to already know the answer.

The alter-Augury spell still looks like it has the hooks that are meant to grab onto a material component, the incense that Esta doesn't have.  The spell just has this... whole set of other hooks, completely unfamiliar.  And other parts yet, now look substantially less like Commune, almost like the spell is not talking to his god at all...

 

Esta is a fucking idiot.  He's not in Golarion anymore.

Prophecy is not shattered in this place.

Permalink Mark Unread

And that fourth-circle spell isn't a divination.  It's the divination.  Divination, the spell from which the very school of magic took its name, which no priest in Golarion has received from their god since that past century.

...it also needs 25gp of incense he doesn't have.

Permalink Mark Unread

Then what the Abyss is that first circle divination?  Esta is now noticeably more motivated to figure it out.

Permalink Mark Unread

He takes 10.

Then he takes 20.

Then he starts rolling against Knowledge (Arcana) instead, in the sense of subvocalizing a long rhyming list of every 1st-circle cleric spell taught to the barest apprentices, that he has not sung these last three decades.  For a cleric, unlike an arcane caster, needs to know of every spell they might request from their god, and cannot content themselves with only remembering what they have inscribed in a spellbook.


It doesn't really look like anything on the list??

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, but there are some spells that Cheliax leaves off the list, in the song taught to its little clerics.  Esta ought to consider if it could be any of those --

Ohhhh that's Cultural Adaptation!  Esta has sometimes spoken for the Church to Cheliax's rare visitors, but not at the level of diplomacy, intrigue, or spycraft where he would be using that spell.

(It is sometimes mentally disturbing to young clerics if they gain too much intuition, too quickly, about how cultures other than Cheliax work.  Though their use of daily spells is tracked in any case.)

Permalink Mark Unread

...is he supposed to use that spell on whatever Dark Tapestry culture Mariona now carries around inside her head.  Is that actually a good idea.

Well, if Asmodeus sent him the spell, it is probably a good idea??

Permalink Mark Unread

Does it even need to be explained why this is a GENERICALLY USEFUL spell for VERY LOST SQUIRRELS assuming that Asmodeus has NO IDEA WHERE THEY EVEN ARE, or doesn't want to pay intervention costs on adapting the toolkit about it?

Permalink Mark Unread

...speaking of communication spells, why does he have two Share Languages.

Permalink Mark Unread

BECAUSE ASMODEUS SENT HIM A GENERIC FUCKING LOADOUT.

Permalink Mark Unread

Either they will encounter some other entity by the end of the day / spell-granting period, or they might do so; or, alternatively, it is important for some reason that Esta share more than just Taldane with Mariona.

Permalink Mark Unread

Or, of course, something has gone wrong with the spell-granting process.

Or Esta does not truly remember how it works.


Maybe Asmodeus is not here and Esta was imagining Him and these spells all came from Y̵̢̛̳̞o̵̲̺͑ǧ̶͚̼͕̯̂_̶̡̘͍̺̔̉̾̕S̶͚͍̈̍͗́ͅo̸̢̖͂̌ͅt̶̝̯͙́͗̚ḧ̸̺̯̱̦̃̓o̵̟͑̀̚t̵̠̣̻͌h̵͓̚ sending them over and giggling to Itself.

Permalink Mark Unread

Commune, Divination, and Augury all require incense.  Esta was given all three.

This in some sense seems like the sharpest knife to cut the puzzle.  It implies Esta will get back his Holding Bag, before the end of the spell-granting cycle; and before Esta can cast Divination to help him search.

...Or alternatively, there is some way for Esta to make acceptable incense out of the stuff of an alien planet?  This seems very improbable, Esta knows the rare and expensive ingredients of divine incense, but not all the ingredients or how to turn them into incense.  Let alone how to substitute alien components; and intuitively, it doesn't seem like they should be anything easy to harvest even on an alien planet, the point is that they're costly...

And if Esta could not get back his Bag, this day, it implies that Asmodeus does not know that Esta has lost his Bag and has no incense.

Now, Esta has had beaten into him, by proxies of the Most High if not her own person, that Asmodeus does not know everything and it is costly to Him to learn.  But if Esta tries to treat this huge load of godchosen spells in the usual way, it reflects an amount of intervention cost that would imply Asmodeus at least trying to check -- on this planet where prophecy still functions -- if Esta had access to rare and expensive material components.

Permalink Mark Unread

He hasn't even been given Locate Object, which would be the obvious spell to pick up on his Bag immediately, if it were anywhere within nigh a thousand feet of where it had been lost... well, nigh 2000 feet, for that they could move further along the riverbed before casting, and then also try to walk before the spell ran out.  But still; Esta has not been given that spell.

Is there anything else he could use to find the Bag?

Permalink Mark Unread

Planar Inquiry.  200gp per rough circle-equivalent of the outsider called.  It is an offering, and Esta would only need to decide which of his desperately needed remaining belongings to sacrifice to it.

...The trouble is, Esta does not remember off the top of his head, what sort of devil -- or any other kind of outsider -- would have the supernatural ability needed to know where his Bag of Holding had gone, and tell Esta so upon the spot.

For his domain 6th, Planar Binding, in the form that can only call a devil.  It is a spell that Esta uses only rarely, because frankly he lacks the Splendour for the spell's usual use of tormenting a weaker devil into submission.  But perhaps it could be abused somewhat to call up a devil without Planar Ally's usual payment, if you were sending them strictly about Asmodeus's business...?  But finding his Holding Bag might not be that?  If the spell could be used so freely to bypass Planar Ally payments, one would expect it to be used to summon forth contract devils about soul-sales, as benefit Asmodeus and themselves.


...maybe he summons up one of Hell's more knowledgeable bureaucrats about the Planar Inquiry, and it then knows how Esta is to use the Planar Binding to obtain the sort of devil that could, and would, find Esta's Holding Bag?

If they don't accept "Asmodeus wills it", this would take a frankly greater degree of helpful cooperation than Esta associates with Hell.

Permalink Mark Unread

The intended use is that you TELL THE DEVIL WHERE YOU ARE and if there is ANYTHING OF INTEREST ON THAT PLANET TO HELL, and then the devil GOES BACK, and Hell KNOWS WHAT HAPPENED IN CASE IT IS INTERESTING AT ALL.

This is why the loadout does not include a Day 1 Plane Shift.  It might be better for the squirrel, sure.  But most of the expected value of an Incredibly Lost Squirrel is not in retrieving the squirrel, but in the squirrel landing someplace interesting or valuable to Hell.  Getting the squirrel back is a distantly second-best consolation prize.

Permalink Mark Unread

And Esta goes on thinking about his other seemingly godchosen spells, for a time.

He weighs the act, concludes he is sure enough of his reasons, and puts his Rings back on, though the Ring of Sustenance will take a while to work.

He does not use his Greater Make Whole on his armor, without having yet asked Mariona about its other possible uses.

He uses one of his Comprehend Languages to read all he can, of whatever writing is on any strange thing about this place; does he learn anything from that?

He tastes of the water in Mariona's reservoir, to see if it is is a fitting place to conjure the nice pure water from his Create Food and Water; is it?

Permalink Mark Unread

The water tastes like distilled water that has been stored in a plastic container. (The type of plastic used in the weatherproofing sheeting Merrin's gear included has been extensively studied in dath ilan, and is not known to have negative effects on human metabolism to be exposed to very small leaching from, but it's in fact meant for weatherproofing shelter and not as a component in a freshwater still, and unlike her actual drinking water collapsible containers, it has not been thoroughly optimized with a lining that doesn't affect the water flavor at all.) 

Most of Merrin's written reference materials are in digital form and can be accessed on her reader tablet or her multipurpose display screen, both of which Merrin has been using only when she really needs to and which, the rest of the time, are carefully packed away in a sealed storage box to minimize their exposure to temperature swings and humidity and extend their useful life.

There's still quite a lot of random Baseline text to skim, but it's mostly in the form of labels, inventory sheets on her storage boxes, safety checklists, and maps. 

Some of the latter are standard-issue from her kit; on those, and on the labels, the text is almost impossibly regular and perfect, each letter-form almost identical every time it appears. Some are handwritten, on a substance that...isn't not paper, but isn't like any paper Esta will have seen before. 

(Only some of the paper Merrin had in stock is the ultra-durable waterproof paper. The tradeoff isn't so much that it's more expensive to manufacture than other types of paper – it is, but when Exception Handling is equipping a highly specialized endurance medtech, even for simulated training purposes, that is not really the operative constraint. But Merrin had expressed finding the specialized everything-proof paper mildly more annoying to write on and was also mildly annoyed that she couldn't casually crease-and-tear it to separate notes and needed scissors, and so she did also have a supply of more ordinary dath ilani stationary, which is not immune to degradation from exposure to humidity swings. Her cave has kept it out of the UV, but for anything she wrote up more than a planetary month ago, the paper is now very slightly discolored and starting to curl a tiny bit at the edges, and anything she wrote more than three planetary months ago is now rather weathered-looking.)  

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

....Honestly Merrin has at this point created enough handwritten reference material to run out of easy places to put it. The survey map and star map live taped to the lids of a couple of her boxes, but a bunch of others are directly affixed to the woven-seaweed ceiling struts, including:

- Her fourteen-step "preparing for an ocean harvest mission" safety checklist.

- Her reference materials on empirically-confirmed-safe methods to process her local foodstuffs, and the maximum daily grams she's empirically determined she can tolerate for the questionable ones.

- Her calendar-chart tracking day lengths, solar angles, daily peak and nightly low temperatures over time, and solar output.

- Her tidal model chart (prominently described as Version Four; she's been continually refining her predictive model of the tidal amplitudes as she noticed discrepancies with the simple "moon perigee -> apogee -> perogee" and realized she also needed a term for the solar syzygy effect).

- Her careful "energy budget" calculations for available battery power for her various equipment. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Yes, that is exactly the sort of paperwork that his Mariona would produce, if half her mind had been replaced by the madness of the Dark Tapestry.

It has numbers for accounting and numbers for logistics and numbers for eldritch truths about celestial bodies.

She has invented her own constellations to draw on alien skies; and named them in her sparkling new Dark Tapestry language, that has precise words about all of that nonmagical medicine his Mariona has always been so fascinated by.

..."Merrin", it says on the maps, and Tongues does think that sounds more like speech in her new language.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta will conjure up his Create Food and Water, and eat some of it.  Of the rest, he sets aside the remainder of one man's rations for himself, and the rest for Mariona; placing his portion by a scrap of his clothing, and her own portion by one of her things; to indicate which is which, if she should wake before he next does.

Mariona has had too little to eat, by the looks of her.  Create Food and Water can make enough food for, well, quite a number of people if Esta should choose to cast it that way.  But that food only lasts 24 hours, and cannot be stocked.  So he makes enough for five people, and leaves Mariona enough for four.

He drinks, sparingly, because he has not been advised where to urinate if he feels the need.

Permalink Mark Unread

When it begins to become cold, he will go back into the bedroll with Mariona.

No.  With Merrin.

The two are not the same.

 

It feels stranger, to climb into bed with her, than it has felt to lay with any woman in these past two decades' memory.  There is a tension in him, an anxiety, that he last remembers from seminary, being ordered into the bed of an instructor who had commanded him to please her.  He failed, which students of hers almost always did, at that task, and was hurt about it.

It is perfectly obvious to the Esta of today that this was exactly the thing Madalin found enjoyable, hurting men for failing to please her.  It is astonishing to him, now, that even when he was seventeen years old, this could possibly not have been obvious to him.  But part of Esta thinks that inverse-Mariona -- Merrin, he must remember that name -- will prove to be that again for him: a more powerful woman who finds something to do in bed with you that a man ought to enjoy, and ensure that you do not enjoy it, because she is pleased to make you feel a failure as a man.


Esta mans up about it, crushes down all fear, and climbs into the bedroll.  It is certainly shameful for a man to fear being naked next to a woman who has not yet humiliated him.  She's probably Chaotic Good, anyway.

Well.  Dark-Tapestried Lawful Evil.

The two may not be the same.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin has been operating solo on a dangerous exoplanet for forty-two - now almost forty-three - 64-hour days, which is something that encourages a certain flavor of constant vigilance. She also went to sleep with a not-quite-officially-resolved medical emergency on her mind, which lends weight to a different kind of constant vigilance. 

When Estha approaches to join her in the bedroll, she does open her eyes briefly, and in an obviously-pure-instinct way will glance at him - an assessing calculating gaze, in her head she's just confirming that he appears alert and is moving normally and isn't bleeding anywhere and is still connected to the oxygen and not showing signs of increased work of breathing (and she already half-consciously made a decision that they can start acclimatizing him tomorrow when she can monitor the process) - and then lifts her arm just enough to glance at the wrist-mounted mini console screen where the wireless monitoring equipment (which will approximately just not have been at all in Esta's way) has been feeding, to confirm that it wasn't an alarm that woke her, and also the approximate time. It's a bit past 01:00. The air feels like the right temperature to her for a bit past 01:00 so there's nothing to be troubleshooting there. 

Great, fine, nothing's on fire, he's lost the sat probe - probably it was in his way - but his heart rate is fine and he's not looking short of breath. Merrin did cache in her memory before going to sleep that she had made a decision that sleeping was the correct tradeoff and nothing is telling her loudly that she misjudged that. 

(Merrin would be mortified to realize that she remembered to tell him where to find food and water and did not at all think to tell him about the toilet facilities, but in fact her toilet facilities are still limited to "a bucket in the tent when it's too hot or cold to go out, and a hole she dug a hundred meters away from camp to use at other times and to empty to bucket into", because she at no point had the slack to make herself an actually nice bathroom and short of that was not especially motivated to prioritize it.) 

 

 

She wriggles over a bit to make room for Estha, and will cuddle up against him and go right back to sleep. 

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

...a thing Esta has sort of not been thinking about is the part where he has been given one (1) Heal spell.

It cures, among other effects, insanity.

If Asmodeus had granted him the two Heals that Esta had asked, it would have been obvious to use Heal spells on both of them.

Then, the obvious path-influencing meaning of his Lord granting Esta only one Heal spell, is that Esta is only meant to Heal himself of whatever debuffs he has taken from his encounter, and not Heal Mariona.

Why?  Because it will not help Mariona?  Because her insanity could not be cured that way?

But Mariona -- no, Merrin -- might have received ability damage or debuffs from any number of sources, like poor nutrition.  It seems unlikely that a Heal spell would not do her some good; it is more comprehensive in its own way than even 7th-circle Regenerate.

So it may also be that it will not be advantageous to Asmodeus, if Mariona is cured.  Perhaps Merrin's continued insanity would be useful to Him.

 

...Esta will see how this matter plays out, of whether Asmodeus seems to be steering or blind, in this place.  And then he will choose what to do with his one Heal spell, before this spell-cycle ends; knowing, as he does, that he might receive no other Heal tomorrow, if he proves unable to ask.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's sort of obvious that if you only get one Heal spell, and you're not sure you get another, and you even might be under any sort of debuff or insanity you don't know about, that the far more valuable 6th-circle cleric in charge of things gets to use it on himself.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yes yes, very obvious.  Maybe too obvious.  Esta's intuition says that the obvious decision here may possibly not be the right one.  He hasn't figured out a reason to believe that, but he means to go on trying.

Go away, unhelpful thought, and let Esta sleep.

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

Some number of hours later, Merrin has had enough sleep that the accumulating physical discomforts will start to encroach on her awareness. (She got some face sunburn while trying to drag Estha back with her faceplate open to run oxygen tubing to him, her head covering isn't as good, and she's hungry and thirsty and needs to pee...) 

 

She's also incredibly physically drained, though, and is having the Post-Emergency Energy Crash where for a while after pushing herself past her limits on adrenaline, it becomes kind of hard to take actions on purpose. The emergency sure seems to be over. And she's so cozy and she's cuddling her boyfriend. She does not initially try to move at all, or even open her eyes. 

 

For the first time in months, she’s not alone.

 

That’s good, right? She gets to be happy now?

Permalink Mark Unread

…There’s a thought, happening, in Merrin’s head. 

In some sense, obviously “she” is “having” the thought. It’s in her brain.

In another sense, though, it doesn’t feel like that at all. A thread of thought is pulling itself together, and -

 

- there’s a mental motion that Merrin can choose to do, sometimes, when she has the realization that she’s being an idiot and failing to apply all of the thinkoomph she can bring to bear to a problem. It feels a bit like waking up fully, like summoning her entire consciousness and reflective-self-awareness into her body so she can be fully attending to whatever she's being stupid about and then actually try

 

Among many habitual thoughts in Merrin's head, there's a rather new set of tightly-coupled cognitive processes, new habits-of-thought and mental affordances woven together in a bundle with each other and not nearly as entangled with the habits-of-thought that drive the cognitive subprocesses associated with the usual “Merrin’s experience of her own internal monologue". Of course there is; she’s been effortfully working on this for six planetary months, nudging and poking and imagining from different angles until she manages to generate a useful thought that feels in-character for a fictional character who is really, in many ways, extremely different from the person Merrin is or at least from the person Merrin conceives of herself as being.

Nothing weird or implausible or magical about that. It was just a useful way to access frames of thinking that Merrin would previously have gotten by talking to other people, which was no longer an option, and to get something like an “outside perspective” on her stupid problems, and to feel less desperately alone. 

 

This tightly-coupled set of habits-of-thought, which Merrin has neatly packaged together under a specific name, is now doing something not unlike “trying to wake up, and to summon its full consciousness and reflective-self-awareness into the body in which it is apparently instantiated right now and the situation in which APPARENTLY it finds itself.” 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin. Hey. Merrin. 

Permalink Mark Unread

mrrgghhhwhat 

Permalink Mark Unread

Notice your confusion, Merrin. 

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

Look, Merrin hasn't failed to notice her confusion!!!!! She spent most of the last day feeling like she wasn't doing much except noticing how superheated confused she is about everything!!!!! 

 

(Also, uh, she did not...ask...Laeirthe for input? What's even happening right now?) 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

 

 

...First things first, she needs to keep pretending to be asleep. They really need to talk uninterrupted. Okay? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Laeirthe is an imaginary fictional character why is he telling her what to do???? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Because she's not already doing it! Obviously!

 

And she is failing to properly notice her confusion. Or - maybe it's more precise to say that she’s failing to attend to it or to take responsibility for it. 

Is she really so desperate to wriggle out of doing any of her own thinking that she picked the moment someone else turned up to start deferring to him on epistemic matters? Even though Laeirthe has not been incredibly impressed so far with this Estha person? 

Permalink Mark Unread

....That's kind of rude and mean? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Look, she's the one who decided to build a model of a character whose characteristic opinions of people are pretty harsh. This was not new information. It’s not personal. Laeirthe is just fundamentally pretty unimpressed with most people. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin knows she's worse at most things than most people, he doesn't need to convince her of that, the part she's irritated about is being judgemental of Estha

Permalink Mark Unread

WHY IS SHE LIKE THIS

Permalink Mark Unread

RIGHT????

Permalink Mark Unread

Anyway. 

The thing is, Merrin’s thoughts are the ones he can see, and so, yeah, Laeirthe is going to end up having a lot of specific biting criticism. It's, again, not personal. 

 

But his topic critique right now is not, actually, that Merrin is not very smart. Fine, he’s feeling a bit cramped having thoughts in here, but overall his impression is not that Merrin's current problem is inadequate thinkoomph to solve her problems. She's been doing all of this very impressive and difficult scientific investigation and modeling of a dangerous exoplanet, and devising a clever strategy and prioritization order to survive its dangers! 

Laeirthe's current impression is that Merrin is simply NOT GIVING HERSELF ENOUGH CREDIT for her actual, obvious ability to maintain her own model of the world and test her own hypotheses. She’s an entire person with her own entire mind! 

(Laeirthe does not seem to be that, right now. He seems to be a simulation of a fictional character, which is a pretty odd thing to realize is one's ontological status, but he’s matter-of-fact about it.) 

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

It was one thing when she was in dath ilan, sure. Laeirthe has observed Merrin’s thoughts about dath ilan. It does, genuinely, seem like a Civilization that is not unreasonable to put one’s trust in?

Like, he wouldn’t, because he’s fundamentally not that sort of guy, but for someone like Merrin, who is apparently at all times filled with a baffling desperate desire to have someone to follow who is worth following and to be only a small, useful, but not special part of something larger than herself, sure! She could do a lot worse than working for dath ilan’s Governance! 

 

The situation here is not the same. And Merrin needs to make that update, already.

Permalink Mark Unread

That sounds really hard and scary though

Permalink Mark Unread

That's valid! The situation that she's in is, in fact, a very difficult and stressful one to be in! It's understandable if she needs to do a lot of...some kind of processing? Probably the kind that people mean when they talk about "grieving" something you lost? (Laeirthe is a little confused about this, but he's only 10% of a fictional person.) 

 

But. 

Merrin needs to live in the situation she's actually in, which is one where she no longer has Civilization to catch her if she falls. And Merrin needs to stop making excuses for not forming her own hypotheses about the situation and making her own contingency planning, based on an extremely suspicious-sounding claim made by a person who Laeirthe is not very inclined to trust at all. 

A convenient claim, really, if said person is not their ally – a hypothesis that’s very readily available to Laeirthe, whose fictional-character-instance spent thousands of years mostly having enemies – and does not want Merrin asking too many questions. 

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

...Okay, but it's Estha

Permalink Mark Unread

(A motion akin to “riffling through Merrin’s memories of this ‘Estha’ person.”) 

 

 

…How sure is Merrin of that claim, or that it means what she thinks it means? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Um. 

 

Well, he looks the same and sounds the same, right? But it's not just that, Merrin...can see how that could be misleading, like, identical twins do exist, and are more similar than chance even on things like mannerisms? 

He also recognizes her, though? He accurately recounted the last time they saw each other? In what world is that compatible with him, instead, being some random guy who happens to look and sound the same?  

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

...Okay, taking a step back here. 

 

Rewind to yesterday.

 

Merrin was confused about her larger model of Reality, sure, and how it made sense within the basic physical-universe-causality she had previously thought she understood for her to be where she was. And, sure, she was also having some trouble keeping it together on an emotional-stability level, though honestly not that much, he does not think she was at any point especially near to having her beliefs come unpinned from the physical reality around her.

But. Rolling back everything she now knows, or rather thinks she knows: would she, in fact, if the hypothesis had occurred to her, have assessed that “and she encountered some sort of cognitohazardous entity or phenomenon that erased half of her memories of how day to day life looked in dath ilan” was a remotely plausible or parsimonious explanation? 

Permalink Mark Unread

....No? Because she was missing the pieces she would have needed to have that hypothesis occur to her in the first place??? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay, just, look. 

 

What does Merrin actually think about a hypothesis that includes, among other claims, “Merrin has forgotten a whole bunch of critical facts about how human biology works, such that her detailed models of medicine no longer output correct predictions”?

Does such a hypothesis fit better than her previous ones with everything else she thinks she knows about the Reality she's experienced living in? 

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

....He didn't really think so. 

 

Look, Laeirthe is not confident here. He doesn't have the answers. He’s, like, 10% of a person, being simulated on a brain that is a little too slow for him, and his episodic memories such as they are seem to be of a FICTIONAL SETTING. 

 

But Laeirthe’s current impression is that, no, Merrin has not fucking forgotten how biology or medicine work, and Merrin is not attending nearly enough to how little sense that part makes.

Merrin is an expert. A narrow, highly specialized expert, sure, but within her realm, she has an incredibly detailed and coherent set of models, and Laeirthe is poking around at the sheer extent of her knowledge here in something like awe, and he does not think there are gaps, and he doesn't think that Merrin thinks so either. 

Permalink Mark Unread

....So how does that square with all of her baffling mispredictions about the course of Estha’s recovery? Because that part kind of is making Merrin feel unsure of her sanity? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Laeirthe isn’t sure! He just said he doesn't have all the answers! He thinks Merrin in fact doesn’t have all of the key information she needs to make sense of it, and so Laeirthe doesn't either, he only knows what he knows and he doesn't actually have mentalistmagic mindreading powers like his fictional instance.

But his current belief is that the discrepancy is a fact about ““Estha””, and not necessarily evidence that Merrin has forgotten anything at all. 

Reasoning from fictional evidence is dubious and all, but, for example, Laeirthe’s fictional setting of origin also has conceptualmagic for healing?

And, theoretically, one could perhaps imagine a scenario where Merrin was not wrong about how human biology worked in dath ilan, the place where she spent many thousands of hours learning it and then treating patients and having pretty impressively correct judgement and predictions about it, and it’s just that it doesn’t work like that in this part of Reality? 

Permalink Mark Unread

....This planet totally has normal biology thought? Like, accounting for it being alien-exoplanet biology, and then separately accounting for the strange narratively-convenient coincidence where she can digest and obtain calories from some of the local biomass. Things are made of cells! She's looked at them with the low-powered optical microscope in her kit! She has not seen anything that would be better explained by some sort of silly conceptualmagic ""life-force"" than by, like, the existence of photosynthesis and cellular respiration and protein transcription? 

Permalink Mark Unread

See, that's EXACTLY WHAT HE WAS SAYING, Merrin is an expert in her own field and she has models and she trusts them, except when she's doing some sort of squirrelly social-deference thing about it. 

 

...Maybe it's not the planet. Maybe ""Estha"" isn't actually human? 

Permalink Mark Unread

What in the name of superheated toilet paper would he be instead???? ...Also he clearly is more or less anatomically and metabolically human, he has the correct bones and organs in the appropriate places and he came back in normal human range on so many different labs? The discrepancies do NOT feel like they would be explained by him being a DIFFERENT SPECIES??? 

Permalink Mark Unread

It's really funny how she's just repeatedly proving Laeirthe's point for him here. 

Permalink Mark Unread

It kind of is, yeah. 

 

 

....Trying a new angle. 

Okay, look: Laeirthe also does not see an obvious gap in Merrin’s understanding of dath ilani Civilization where secret mentalistmagic mind control would fit?

That would have implications, right, and (reaching for concepts, trying and failing for a level of abstraction on which he expects to be able to reason with precision and can’t, quite, not in this brain when he’s 10% of a simulated fictional character who a random medtech generated out of her fanfiction to keep herself company, what a situation to be in) -

- anyway, Laeirthe is not going to have the level of rigor in his thinking that he wants, here, but…the Civilization that Merrin perceived made sense to her. 

And she wasn’t cleared to know all of its infohazardous secrets, but she did know quite a lot about its emergency policies, and…does it feel, to her, like Exception Handling wrote its contingency-plans centrally around magical mind control being a threat? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Um. Why in the world does Laeirthe think Merrin of all people would be able to recognize if they were?

Like, on the assumption that the mentalistmagic mind control exists and is considered a cognitohazard, of course the Governance personnel cleared to know about it would be careful to design policies that, where they took the threat into account, also thoroughly obfuscated what threat they were guarding against??? That's super basic information security???? And Merrin is a really easy case, they have to avoid making the hypothesis an obvious one for people with much more thinkoomph than her? 

Permalink Mark Unread

That’s a pile of flaming dog poop. 

 

- no, wrongthought, Laeirthe was being sloppy and imprecise there. The logic Merrin just reasoned through seems potentially sound - potentially, he's not agreeing with her, he's just admitting that it's not something he's thought through all the way - anyway he is not directly disputing that one can make arguments of this form and have the logic be sound, in principle. 

 

But he’s definitely confident in rejecting the part where Merrin is taking her logic and going "therefore I couldn't possibly know things, because I'm just a little unspecial person who only understands medicine", and using it as an excuse not to have her own thoughts and to instead defer to this guy who just showed up, immediately almost died, and then really suspiciously told her that he thinks she's more insane than him.  

She’s smarter than that. 

Permalink Mark Unread

She really is! She’s so much cooler than this obnoxious Estha guy. 

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Remind her HOW and WHY she ended up with these imaginary people in her head gossiping about their weird grudge against her boyfriend????? What's Kalorm's problem with Estha? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Honestly, it’s mostly the part where Merrin cares way too much about his approval. Kalorm liked it better in Merrin’s head when there was literally no one else on the planet who she could even conceivably look to as a respected authority figure who she thinks is smarter than her. Her brain does this thing about it and Kalorm has an allergy.

…To be clear he’s not judging her on the masochism thing, she gets to have fun however she wants with whoever she wants, just, it would be neat if she could have her fun with her sadist boyfriends without being weird about it like that. 

Permalink Mark Unread

She's not doing it at you, Kalorm, she's just kind of shaped like that, and it seems like it was fine and perfectly compatible with being a happy, well-adjusted person in dath ilan? 

"In dath ilan" being operative, there. 

 

 

...Anyway, Laeirthe started out with mostly just...generic paranoia, because he is a generically paranoid character-model...and it wasn't really specific to Estha at all, it was just irritating him that Merrin is so trusting. 

BUT Laeirthe has now been “awake” long enough to have gotten a good look at Merrin’s thought patterns on the topic, and…has she noticed that’s she’s doing kind of a lot of motivated cognition around every observation she made that didn’t quite feel right? Understandably, maybe, because she was alone and scared for a long time and she wants that to be over, but - she can see that she is doing it, right? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Um.

 

Can he give examples. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...It was a sort of wordless gestalt impression of a weight tugging her one direction more than another, more than an explicit reasoned logical case, but of course Laeirthe can go consider it more closely now, that's a very sensible idea. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Eventually: 

 

 

Here is a broken-down list of specific times where, Laeirthe is claiming, Merrin felt uneasy or uncomfortable or worried, and then forgot about it or declared it not worth spending more time thinking about as soon as she could reasonably get away with that. 

1. The inexplicable language barrier. The abrupt lifting of the inexplicable language barrier, followed by some bizarre word choices that Merrin also doesn’t think resembled the usual, expected disfluency from after a resolving neurological-injury-caused aphasia, and instead - hmm, does Laeirthe in fact know how these things work well enough to draw conclusions - (low-confidence flag) that resembled someone who was, somehow, trying to express normal dath ilani concepts in normal Baseline when neither was fully familiar or comfortable?

2. Laeirthe thinks that Merrin might just be flat-out wrong to expect the Estha she knows to have performed better overall, on arrival to a strange planet, but it does seem like Merrin felt confused and uneasy about something there? Laeirthe's argument here isn't that her unease was valid, just that the grounds on which she ignored it were suspiciously motivated-reasoning-shaped.

3. Estha was confidently claiming in quite a pushy way to be less susceptible to mind-control than Merrin, while himself seeming rather impaired? 

4. Merrin chose to question him on his memory of her True Death, on the grounds that this was a useful cognitive assessment for amnesia, and he in fact didn't remember it, and his explanation for what happened instead was throwing all of Laeirthe’s “that’s a load of flaming crap” suspicion alarms. Which might, to be clear, be miscalibrated here! Laeirthe has priors shaped from paranoia and paranoia is not necessarily in all cases truth-tracking! He doesn't confidently know that Merrin's memory is the true one, here, just - Merrin did run a test and did find the result concerning and then just sort of dropped thinking about it? 

5. The vibes were off. Laeirthe is to be clear, not himself qualified to speak on that, but Merrin was troubled by it, and Merrin would know! She had an intimate relationship with the man! “Interpersonal vibes” may not be a type of evidence that Laeirthe is personally inclined to put much weight on, but Merrin seems to in general put some trust in her ability to tell what’s going on with someone. Apparently it’s relevant to her job or something? And she thought something was wrong.

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay. 

 

...And? 

Permalink Mark Unread

So maybe she should continue to be suspicious for a while? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Suspicious....of....what....? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Laeirthe continues to not contain any answers that Merrin herself doesn't already know! 

 

Just...different heuristic responses to the same information state, apparently, and his heuristics are SCREAMING that Merrin is being way too trusting and insufficiently paranoid and she should not be taking everything Estha says at face value even thought she apparently REALLY WANTS TO. 

Permalink Mark Unread

....She's tracking that Estha might have brain damage or something and be more wrong than her about what actually happened? 

Permalink Mark Unread

And Laeirthe is saying that that is NOT BEING ADEQUATELY SUSPICIOUS given their information state right now!

 

 

Look, Merrin already knew that Reality construed broadly was larger and weirder than she had previously conceived of, right? Because she did not arrive here via faster-than-light space travel, which could conceivably exist within the standard physical reality she knew of. She arrived here in a way that involved apparently dying and then - leaving? the Reality that held dath ilan? and continuing to exist, in some…larger…Reality…? One that contains strange coincidences, like planets with exactly the most challenging conditions under which Merrin specifically with her exact background and level of preparation can, just barely, survive, and implausibly dramatic timing for epic river rescues. 

What if it contains even stranger things than that. 

 

 

Like, just to take a random example, places where conceptualmagic is real, including the mind control part. 

What if…such a world were to have some sort of entity that could, for example, take over bodies and gain imperfect, fragmented access to the host's memories, and then try to fake nothing being wrong in order to gain the cooperation of someone close to their host? 

(This is a low-hanging hypothesis to Laeirthe for the obvious reason that the exactly how his fictional-character instance manages to be immortal.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

That's extremely silly. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Laeirthe is just saying, Merrin should be broadening her hypothesis space to include more possibilities that might fit with her observations to date, even if they're weird, because she already knows that the situation is weird in ways she can't explain. 

 

What if…an alien shapeshifter, with mentalistmagic mindreading powers that let them sneak up on Merrin and contrive a story to fake that would be the most likely to get her cooperation? But they did it imperfectly, thus the vibes being off, and also they’re doing an imperfect job of pretending to have human biology, and trying to cover up their fumbles there by bluffing about cognitohazards? 

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

Or, who knows, maybe the man she rescued was, at one point, Estha, as she knew him, and it’s just that unlike her he did encounter a cognitohazardous entity with mind-editing abilities, but Merrin wasn’t there? Like, one part that seems off here is that as described the supposed cognitohazardous entity did not, it seems, even try to conceal having messed with Estha's head, and Estha seems to arrive kind of impaired in a way that Merrin wasn't on her arrival or she would be dead, having had no one showing up ahead of her to rescue her? And maybe Estha's entire memory of Merrin having been there with him is confabulated, along with a whole lot of random other things about his own life history, and also contact with the entity messed with his biology and he’s no longer precisely human for medical purposes? 

There, that’s a less paranoid theory, is she happy now? Under this new theory, Merrin doesn’t even have to assume Estha is an adversary! Just that she should not be deferring to him on epistemic questions of what happened to her in the past or what her life history contains, or trusting his judgement on concrete survival questions where her own expert judgement disagrees. 

Permalink Mark Unread

She’s not very happy, no. 

 

 

 

All of this is…not the kind of thing Merrin knows how to reason about, okay?

She’s good at what she does, she'll admit that much. The thing she does is medicine. She in fact simply is not qualified to have good ideas or judgement when it comes to bizarre larger-Reality hypotheticals? It feels like quicksand to try to think about it, and also she has a literal headache now from all of the IMAGINARY PEOPLE who are ARGUING IN HER HEAD, which is itself a state that does kind of make Merrin feel like her sanity ought not be trusted here? 

Permalink Mark Unread

...She's not actually worried about the last thing, though, not really, she understands what happened here and how. She just doesn't want to have to do exhausting cognitive work, but she's smarter than that and she knows better. Laeirthe knows her, see, he's made out of her. 

 

 

And, unfortunately, the situation is what it is, and Merrin is not in dath ilan anymore, and maybe in dath ilan it made sense to throw problems outside her core skillset at the extremely competent Governance authorities, to be solved by the appropriate department, but she doesn’t have that option anymore.  

 

 

Look, Laeirthe doesn’t have answers, either? 

Just questions. 

And he's staking out a VERY STRONG BID for Merrin to take those questions seriously, and keep asking them and checking hypotheses, and not leave it at “probably Estha is right about everything, since she’s not qualified to have opinions on non-medical topics so how would she know better.” 

Permalink Mark Unread

but mmmmrgg she doesn't wanna she wants everything to be okay and safe and she's not alone anymore and she gets to be happy now 

Permalink Mark Unread

...and that is a thought that Merrin can catch as a wrongthought just fine on her own, thank you.

Grumble. Grumps. Mrgggllblrggg. 

 

 

...Okay, she's done her internal whining.

The voice of an imaginary fictional character from her fanfiction talking in her head does, kind of, have some reasonable points. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is going to lie here for another five minutes not thinking any thoughts, because that was really, really exhausting, she did not know just lying still pretending to be asleep and thinking thoughts could be that exhausting. 

 

And then she'll cautiously try to extract herself from the sleeping bag, without disturbing Estha (probably Estha?) if he seems to still be asleep. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Real adventurers who sleep through that sort of thing are dead.  (Wizards have to be guarded by real adventurers.)

He won't particularly react or open his eyes, just yet; Esta will observe the course of events that happens by default, attempting to breathe slowly, at what he has been told is his sleeping breathing-pace.

(His heart rate or blood pressure may well pick up.  Esta is not used to having to fool Dark Tapestry medical instrumentation.)

Permalink Mark Unread

In any other circumstances, Merrin would almost certainly not even ask herself the question 'is Estha pretending to be asleep so he can see what I do when I don't think he's watching', because - in her opinion, at least - that's such a silly sort of thing to spend your cognition on wondering. 

BUT Merrin sure has, herself, just spent LIKE AN HOUR pretending to be asleep while having an argument with her– an argument inside her brain, she's in fact not sure she can reasonably conceptualize it as 'with herself', what even was that.

She checks the monitors instinctively and...does go 'hmm' to herself about it, a little. Maybe she's completely making it up and Estha picked that moment to transition into REM sleep from deep sleep.....orrrrr maybe he also feels like something is off and he needs to be paranoid about her? 

 

She can't think of anything to do differently if he might be sneakily listening to her while pretending to be asleep, so she will do exactly what she would normally do, which is go pee in the bucket (stored under the wicker table where she had laid out his costume jewelry, so she can't kick it over by accident) and get some water for herself, while considering which of her local-biomass foodstuffs feels the least unappealing right now. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Why eat SNAILS when she can eat BLANDLY GENERICAL MAGICAL FOOD?

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

Is she hallucinating 

Permalink Mark Unread

(reflexive doubt more than reasoned counterargument) Probably not? At least not in a way where "Merrin is experiencing hallucinations" is an explanation for this and not for everything else since the moment her experience departed the realm of how she expected Reality to work, and she had already concluded that it made sense to make decisions as though the whole being on an exoplanet thing was real and not a hallucination, and her own internal probabilitymass-assignment to it is not that high at this point since hallucinations are not known for having such coherent laws of physics and biology. She's just being lazy in coming up with hypotheses here. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh no he's still there, she thought he was done, is this just her life now 

Permalink Mark Unread

Her life is quite interesting! And Laeirthe prefers existing over not-existing. Quite strongly, actually! He's here - for some definition of 'here' and 'he is', at least - and she seems to need some advice. 

...And this part is especially interesting. Whaaaat if 'Estha' can do economicmagic transport-portals to other planets from here, and decided to surprise her with a food delivery? That's very intriguing! 

Permalink Mark Unread

....Merrin is so dubious of the spontaneously-appearing food! She will go pick up a piece and try to break a bit off and rub it between her fingers and sniff it to figure out what it's made of. What if 'Estha' is an alien shapeshifter doing a questionable job of imitating her boyfriend and faking human physiology, and since he's an alien he delivered food she can't even eat

Permalink Mark Unread

It's bland bread, with a slightly crispy yet still bland surface, surrounding a bland omelet of bland cheese mixed with bland vegetables, like a sort of bland burrito with no outer cracks, or a huge bland pastry bun with an apparently solid exterior!  Though if Merrin only broke off a sufficiently little bit, she'll just get the outer bland bread part.

(Magical food can still dry up if you leave it out, so Esta made it in a form factor that put the moist parts inside.)

Permalink Mark Unread

(Merrin will eventually break off a large enough piece to determine that there's an interior with protein and vegetables.) 

 

...She has so many additional questions. 

 

Also it feels really socially awkward to wake Estha and ask him to explain where and how he obtained the food? He's probably going to calmly inform her that her mind was edited and she's just forgotten some totally normal method for obtaining food, and she will feel like a fool, and also what if she's WRONG that he's pretending to be asleep and she rudely wakes him up? Or what if she's right and he guesses that she noticed and it would've been better if he didn't guess that she noticed? 

- she catches that thought BEFORE the internal voice of Laeirthe from her fanfiction says something brutally harsh about how stupid that is. 

 

...It's almost 06:00, anyway, he hasn't had a shortage of sleep. (Also it is, as expected for this time, now just below freezing even inside the shelter. Merrin would usually get up briefly and then go right back into her sleeping pod.) 

Carrying one of the breads, she goes over to the sleeping bag on the floor, squats down (ooooof the delayed onset muscle soreness, that's mostly on her for not EATING ENOUGH PROTEIN after yesterday's exertions) and clears her throat, quietly enough that if he really were exhausted and deeply asleep it probably wouldn't disturb him? 

Permalink Mark Unread

He opens his eyes fully, and says in very heavily accented, memorized Baseline, "Time for us both to wake for the day?  Answer simply."

Permalink Mark Unread

.....His language function got worse again??? 

Concerns! Questions! Suspicions! 

 

Well, Merrin isn't getting back to sleep, between her two sleep blocks she's gotten ten hours – normally she would have her ten hours earlier in the night and be awake for six hours and then still get another few hours before dawn, but she's probably not going to be sleepy enough before dawn anyway. And he doesn't look like someone who's unhappily forcing his eyes open despite still being exhausted, she doesn't think? 

"Yes," she says in Baseline. 

Permalink Mark Unread

He sits up enough to remove his hands from the sleeping bag, and touch the pentagram now once more around his neck.

Tongues.

And since he only had two of Tongues, he'll use it now, while he speaks her language.

Cultural Adaptation.

(Esta is not particularly trying to conceal either the gestures or the spellwords, over those next twelve seconds.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Yesterday Merrin had higher priorities, and was also exhausted and running extremely low on metacognition to spare for anything except 'tracking whether she was still capable of providing medical care'. 

Today, she does more consciously note the weird not-words - or not Baseline words - he's saying, timed to coincide with the weird gestures. 

...Might as well not bother hiding that she's confused, she isn't trying to pretend to be exactly like the person Estha thinks he remembers her being because that sounds frustrating and impossible.

(To the extent that Merrin can deliberately control her facial expressions, which to be clear is much less than what is expected of Chelish people, she'll let 'confused' be loudest, to try to conceal the 'suspicious paranoia' part. It's actually a lot easier given that the suspicious-paranoia part is living in an imaginary fictional character who is not in control of her body or facial expressions.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

He speaks again.  His Baseline now sounds more natural and idiomatic than before, though not quite like Estha; more like one of her superiors in Exception Handling speaking to her.

"It seems quite cold now.  How have you been surviving the cold, and the heat?  When is it most dangerous?  I have the means to protect both of us, but only for --" he hesitates, and then says roughly the equivalent of saying '23.98 hours', as if he's not used to the units he's trying to use.

Permalink Mark Unread

(Questions! Merrin has them! So many! He has means to what– oh, actually, that would de-confuse her about his apparent immunity to both heatstroke and hypothermia, though at the expense of confusing her MUCH MORE on the nature of Reality.) 

 

She can give him a report. That's easy, and buys her time to find a way to ask about the food that doesn't feel as mortifying. 

"The cold hasn't been the hardest part so far. I arrived 21 planetary-days before the spring equinox - I don't have the data to conclusively calculate year length but I suspect it was late winter - and I was able to survive the first night with more minimal shelter than this. My sleeping bag is rated to -20° C and I had stored battery power to run the suit heating," gesture at the plugged-in power armor in the corner, "for the coldest part of the night. ...The heat is already a problem and will get worse. So far I was able to manage the afternoons staying in here with ventilation from deeper caves," another gesture at her setup, "and it was unpleasant but not life-threatening. But my climate model thinks the temperature will get up to at least 60° C, and when the nights get shorter it'll cool down even less, it's possible it won't drop below freezing, the only way the shelter warms up slowly enough is if it's below freezing at dawn. Options I'd been considering included finding a deeper cave system that'll stay cooler or building an indoor pool to sit in water during the day." 

Pause. "...Right now the dangerous heat period is much shorter than - your thing - would be. That could change." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Hm.  It's possible I get more ability to protect us at dawn, or alternatively, at 22.98 hours after the previous moment when I first woke up and was able to speak to you.  If you are confident in our ability to otherwise survive the entire day, even should my capabilities fail us, it is possible I should apply those capabilities at dawn or at the 22.98-hours-later moment as determined then, and gamble on the capabilities being renewable."

"I have another capability for repairing my protective suit, which I infer you to have cut off of my injured form.  That capability may or may not be renewable and might operate to repair your own equipment -- or other important broken things -- although I am not, actually, sure about that part.  Do you have priority repair tasks that should take precedence over my own suit?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Iiiiiis Merrin going to ask any of her questions or is she just - freezing up - from the combination of suspicious-paranoia and feeling like when one is suspiciously-paranoid one should avoid blatantly revealing that fact??? 

That's stupid. 

Merrin is really really bad at social deception games, okay? And she is absolutely certain that she would never, ever beat Estha at a social deception game, which means that if she tries she's going to be weird and furtive about it. 

Better to pick a strategy she can actually execute. 

 

"I don't have any high-priority repair tasks," she says. "So far I've been able to maintain all my gear with the tools and replacement parts I had," albeit the replacement parts lately have all been coming from cannibalizing other equipment, which isn't sustainable. "...But, um, if you're modeling that I understand your repair capability or any of your other capabilities, I...think...the thing that happened edited that out of my memories, and I have no idea what the limitations are, or why your capabilities might be renewable or might not." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I was accepting responsibility for tracking that on my end, yes."  This culture wants him to be having facial expressions all the time -- well, actually around only a quarter as much as other Golarion cultures, but still a lot by Chelish standards.  And yes fine Esta will do that and just make sure he's doing it consciously.  "Assume a corresponding deficit on my own side with respect to your own equipment.  I now have no more idea of how you cut off my protective suit, or the purpose and operating principles of an electrocardiogram unit," as one of the readable labels said, "than, I expect, you have of how I produced the food on that table.  You should eat that, by the way, it's bland but fully nutritious and you have clearly not been eating enough, Merrin."

(And for a moment he is sounding, speaking, and behaving exactly like Estha.)

Permalink Mark Unread

She really hasn't and she's so hungry

(Now that Esta has Cultural Adaptation it will be somewhat apparent that Merrin is unusually emotionally-expressive even relative to cultural expectations. She doesn't seem to be putting in any effort to moderate it, as though she's never been punished for anything in that class at all.) 

...Wow that moment was kind of uncanny. Merrin can handle "the vibes are off" but it's extremely jarring and disorienting to have the vibes sometimes off and sometimes so reassuringly right. 

Is it a good idea to eat the mysterious-capability-appeared food? Like, there's an argument that it's not as though it's a worse idea than eating alien snails but also WHAT IF SHE'S NOT BEING PARANOID ENOUGH but also it would be awkward to argue with him about it now and augh. 

"I knew way more than you about the medical equipment even before this," she says with a smile, "but I'll keep that in mind. ...Are you sure that whatever happened to me wouldn't have changed my biology such that food you - produced - is no longer safe for me to eat?" 

For example because he's a SHAPESHIFTING ALIEN, not that she really thinks that's likely, and if he were a shapeshifting alien then he clearly at least understands biochemistry enough to fake blood with all the right components to look normal on labs. 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"...no, and my failure for not thinking of that."  WHY did he say that, Mariona is not his superior -- this culture thinks very strongly that it is appropriate to say this even if, or especially if, Mariona / Merrin is his subordinate??

After another moment's thought, "I believe I have a capability that ought to prove fully able to rescue you if that is the case, however."  Heal works on aberrations.  Heal works on outsiders.  It would be truly odd for it not to work on 'Merrin'.  Unless she's running on Negative energies now??  But no, that would just be stupid.

Permalink Mark Unread

“…Okay.” And Merrin does also have drugs to handle it if she has an anaphylactic reaction and it would be silly as narrative tropes go for her to die of this after all these months.

….She’ll have one mouthful of food and wait a while for any sign of a bad reaction - and explain her reasoning on that to Estha - even though (bland or not) the food is amaaaaaazing and she wants to eat FOUR of the breads-with-stuff-inside RIGHT NOW.


Ugh. She wants to ask him about the inexplicable intermittent Baseline-aphasia thing but it’s still weird and awkward to talk about it while maintaining paranoid suspicion and trying to do a social deception about that— that’s being silly.

“What’s your own understanding of the - language difficulty - you’ve been having intermittently with speaking Baseline?” she asks him, while trying not to stare too longingly at the breads.

Permalink Mark Unread

"That your own understanding of language has been -- inverted -- and I'm using up capabilities to synchronize with the inversion.  Of course, it could also be my own understanding that's been inverted.  Your version of the language has many concepts of hidden order that are now missing from my own."

"In about two hours I'm going to stop being able to speak your version.  I can give you the ability to speak my version, and that would last a full 23.98 hours.  I've been hesitating to do it that way because I don't, actually, know what full effect it's going to have on you, if you can speak both."

...actually, what if he gave her Utopian(*) instead of Taldane, that's probably less something that might explode on contact with Baseline?


(*)  For some weird reason, a bunch of outsiders and even some Golarion polities, if they want to write a contract in a Lawful language at all, will insist on doing it in the language of Axis rather than the language of Hell.  Esta speaks Taldane, Infernal, Utopian, and Draconic.

Permalink Mark Unread

Nod.

“Can you explain the mechanism of action for the capabilities you would be using on me? I think I’m having trouble reasoning about what might go wrong that’s prompting you to hesitate. …Are you noticing cognitive side effects on yourself, from whatever you’re using right now to understand me?”

Merrin CANNOT IMAGINE what hypothetical cognitohazardous memory-editing exposure could write the entirety of the Baseline language into her brain??? You would have to alter SO many memories??? …Reality doesn’t stop at the limits of Merrin’s imagination, so that’s not a conclusive argument, but it might be evidence.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I definitely am getting side effects, yes."

"And... I am frankly not sure where to start explaining.  My memories think Merrin is supposed to know all about this and have her own set of capabilities to use, though mine are stronger.  Rather as I expect your memories say I am supposed to know all about, say, that protective suit there."

Esta gestures at the Exception Handling exosuit, which Estha would have never once worn or maintained in his entire life.

Permalink Mark Unread

…Speaking of that, Merrin is getting pretty cold, wearing an emergency blanket that she grabbed is not cutting it, and she would normally just get into the armor once she was up for the day but she would rather snuggle Estha. Even if he might be an alien shapeshifter, apparently.

She gets back into the sleeping bag with him and snuggles up (though she's not herself naked, she's sleeping in her dath ilani underclothes-layer). 

 

There are 'capabilities' that one might say that every dath ilani has. Like basic math and basic everyone-learns-in-school engineering, how electricity and circuits work, that kind of thing. But...in her own memories, she and Estha were pretty differently specialized! ...Honestly, she doesn't even know that much about what Estha did with his time that was not dates with her. Something of significant value to Civilization, presumably, since he could afford a masochist girlfriend, but probably not Exception Handling and definitely not endurance field trainings.

...Her Estha could not have climbed a near-cliff like that on his first day on a new planet with lower oxygen. Perhaps she should have been paying significantly more attention to that. 

 

"In your memories, do we work for the same department with Governance?" she asks him. "How do you remember us meeting?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Same department of -- not exactly Governance."  His Cultural Adaptation is not a match for whatever conceptual conflict he's running into.  "Your version of the language now completely lacks the entire set of concepts for what our -- department, did, exactly.  We... dealt with... entities, there's no longer a word for them, or what they do, or how to interact with them."

"We met during your earliest training.  I was one of your instructors."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Huh," Merrin says.

Her own social instincts feel like it is, at this point, WEIRD AND AWKWARD not to reciprocate and offer her own memories, which are really very much not that.

But.

She's getting less verbal Laeirthe-commentary, now, it seems like actively having a conversation out loud is interfering with that thread - makes sense, having an actual conversation with another person would engage her social-modeling, which is presumably also what she was using to ACCIDENTALLY SUMMON A FICTIONAL CHARACTER INTO HER BRAIN who has now informed her that he ???likes existing and wants to stay???? - anyway she does have a nonverbal-tug sense that Laeirthe thinks she should not hand maybe-Estha information that he hasn't even explicitly asked for. 

"Can you tell me what specifically you've noticed that seems different about me now?" she asks him, going for an affect of 'curious, and like it's niggling and making her uneasy that she doesn't know which parts of her were edited', which is easy because she is curious and it is niggling and it's just that she's not, actually, as convinced as she's aiming to sound that the discrepancy is within her own memories and not - elsewhere. 

Permalink Mark Unread

He should probably not, perhaps, say, 'You were originally Lawful Evil rather than Chaotic Good', even leaving aside the part where this language has no simple term for Evil.  Helms of opposite alignment are probably mythical, since if they existed they would be used to win wars; but the myth told of them does make sense, that once somebody goes under one they no longer want to go back.

"You are much more expressive than the Merrin I knew, for one thing.  Our department -- 'taught' is the wrong word.  Required much more emotional control, from its employees."

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh no is she being uncanny and wrongvibes for him too? Merrin is aware that she shows more emotion than many people and it's mostly because she has louder emotions than other people, but being expressive about her positive emotions is, like, fine? Or at least that's what her memories would seem to indicate? 

"My memories are that my work required me to be able to control my negative emotions," she says thoughtfully. "Both in terms of facial expressions," because in an emergency the last thing anyone needs is for Merrin to be facescreaming upsetness, "and - cognitive effects?" She's great at experiencing minimal cognitive effects from situations being terrifying, for example. She's proud of that. "I think I do experience happiness more easily than most people, and I find that useful so I've never tried to change how much I show it."

She spends a moment considering whether it's actually in her interests to say the thing she wants to say to actual Estha who has cognitohazard-induced brain damage, when in fact she should be paranoid that it's not actual Estha and is instead a shapeshifting alien. ...It doesn't seem like there's a huge cost to saying it to a shapeshifting alien? She's not very good at this adversarial thing and it's very exhausting but she doesn't think it's giving away information she should keep to herself as long as possible? 

"....I can try to stop if it's - distracting - for you," she offers. "I don't want to be making everything harder for you, if that isn't what you're used to from me." 

Permalink Mark Unread

He's used to her making some things harder, in several senses of that word, actually.

Esta is not going to say this to the underclothed girl who has climbed into a sleeping bag with him, for as many as several reasons; one of which is that it might actually be a bad thing if Mariona picked this exact time to get pregnant.

"I expect you are already worrying about a sufficient number of distinct problems and that this is not the correct concern for you to prioritize.  Also it's not going to work, I can read you better than you can conceal.  --at least, I remember being able to."

Permalink Mark Unread

Sure, Merrin believes that - or, at least, would believe it about the Estha she remembers knowing -  but there's still a difference between 'he can tell that he's feeling something' and 'she is loudly and obtrusively feeling it AT him'!

She's not going to argue, though. "Okay," she says, and then - if he doesn't immediately interrupt, she's going to be quiet and thoughtful for a minute here, because she's apparently out of practice at having conversations and is feeling like it's oddly hard to hear her own thoughts at the same time. 

 

He has a valid point that she's already tracking a very large number of distinct problems, but - something about the way he said it feels off - she thinks her Estha wouldn't describe it as 'worrying', for one, and would give her more credit than that for tracking her own cognitive bandwidth and only offering something that she judged she could do without trading off against her more critical priorities? Maybe she couldn't have done that yet when she was in her teens (and apparently this Estha remembers meeting her then? oh no she was so much worse at things when she was younger!), but current Merrin has trained really quite extensively at juggling enormous numbers of overwhelming problems, and at pushing back on the things she experiences as soft social pressure to agree to additional duties she cannot effectively carry out, because her Exception Handling instructors were not wrong that this was one of her weaknesses. 

Also she thinks her Estha would foreground more to what extent it even bothered him, if it did, and they would do the usual 'roughly quantify how much this bothers him, versus what it costs her', and it feels odd for him to instead just inform her that he's declaring this not one of her priorities?

...She's not very confident of that. For her it's been eight months since she last saw him, and she's probably very out of practice at the social-modeling thing, at least when it comes to actual people and not pretend ones. 

Permalink Mark Unread

It's still evidence, though. 

...Did she catch the thing where she's now thinking of 'her' Estha as a disambiguation from this Estha? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Look Merrin was about to get there with 'it's still evidence even if it's not conclusive', can Laeirthe be patient please

 

...She hadn't quite consciously noticed that, no, but it's - hmm. 

What does she think she knows, and why does she think she knows it? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Well. Estha - this Estha - unambiguously has some sort of bizarre some-sort-of-magic abilities. Merrin isn't quite sure how to categorize them according to fictional tropes for magic because he's...actually been quite vague about how it works? 

What did he say. He said that he remembered her also having the abilities, albeit being less talented, which does make sense to her, if hypothethically she and Estha both had weird magicalabilities then of course he would be better at it.

He said he'd been one of her instructors, early on. Needless to say, this absolutely does not map to anything in Merrin's own memories. She didn't even meet Estha until - it would have been after she met Kalorm, later the same year...

 

He said that Baseline lacked any vocabulary for - it - whatever 'it' is. He said, we dealt with...entities, there's no longer a word for them, or what they do, or how to interact with them.

Merrin does not need Laeirthe, this time, to point out that she should have paid more attention to that, and to what hypotheses it's evidence for or against. 

Permalink Mark Unread

(It's hard to keep thinking this when she feels like Estha might at any moment interrupt and, like, ask if she's okay or something.) 

 

 

...If dath ilan knew about this...phenomenon...then Merrin would really expect Baseline to have words for it! Not words she would know, just like she didn't know the word for 'masochist' until a few years ago, and maybe whatever Estha is doing is only giving him vocabulary she has and not the vocabulary he previously had and lost? But that doesn't land right, somehow. 

If 'Estha' were an alien shapeshifter or a bodysnatching immortal trying to obtain her cooperation, it seems like it would be a bizarre unforced error to give her such a specific backstory that so clearly doesn't fit into the contours of the life she remembers? 

He remembers her being less expressive. She's mostly made happy expressions in his presence, she thinks, so far? It feels like it has to mean something, that the context he remembers is one where it's not just 'bursting into tears in an operating room' that one needs to be trained to suppress, but also being visibly delighted when a patient recovers better than expected? No one has ever told Merrin to be less visibly delighted when a patient is doing well, though possibly they avoided giving her patients who would disprefer that for some reason. 

Permalink Mark Unread

It definitely feels like after that interaction, Merrin has more facts and, as result, understands fewer things.

It feels like it pushes away from all of her hypotheses, toward...something...else...? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Estha doesn't seem hostile? Which is not proof that he isn't, as opposed to just being more skillful at hiding it than she is at noticing, but her surface impression is that he seems...confused, just like she is, and also confusing, which apparently she also is to him, and apart from that he's on team 'survive the horrible exoplanet.' 

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta has previously learned that he tends to get more of what he wants if he lets Mariona go quiet and think occasionally; and that trying to punish her into arriving at the same conclusions faster doesn't actually yield the results he wants.  (It is annoying to him; and it's more annoying that this seems to be actually the way she is, and not a clever strategem to frustrate him; and it's even more annoying that he can't solve the problem by applying more pain, not in mortal Golarion.  There are days when it feels quite obvious and intuitive how much hate Asmodeus must have stored up for mortals.)

But even considering that Merrin is of uncertain obedience and more uncertain defeatability if offended, there are things that must be done and soon.  He will, then, interrupt her thinking.  "I do not know what tasks we must do today in order to merely survive, but my own highest priority is reacquiring the expanding-space bag that was on my waist when I was struck by the tidal bore.  It was protected by a metal mesh, but if it has been destroyed or simply lost beyond retrieval, then getting off this planet and back to Civilization becomes much harder.  Is it perchance only stored by you, somewhere I could not see?"


Esta makes a note that he needs to later ponder that word his concept of 'civilization' translated into; there is weight behind it in Tongues and Cultural Adaptation.  It sounds... mainly it sounds like those things you are allowed to learn of the slain god Aroden, after Asmodeus admits you to his 4th circle.

Permalink Mark Unread

(Merrin is aware that it would normally have been polite to flag that she wanted a minute to think - and she would have with Estha, her Estha, normally - and it's just that it's weird and awkward to be in this strange half-cooperative half-adversarial stance. She doesn't like it.) 

...She's also realizing that, wow, she has really gotten used to - not being rushed? Certainly not by anyone else, but her own schedule has included a lot of enforced nothing, and a lot of what she's been finding to spend her time on isn't even survival-critical anymore. She's just bored. 

 

But it makes sense that Estha is worried about– ohhhhhh. 

Wait he has a WHAT. 

"I'm sorry, I definitely haven't seen it," she says, rather than immediate pepper him with ten questions that might turn out to be impossible to answer with Baseline vocabulary anyway. "I think it must have gotten separated from you before I pulled you out of the water. ...I'm not sure what our odds are of finding it, even if it's intact. Tidal bore is due around dawn this morning, and another every 37 hours after that, and we can try to plan a search strategy but every 37 hours it's going to end up somewhere else again..." 

She doesn't say out loud that she hadn't, actually, expected to ever find a way off this planet, unless it was by dying and waking up in some OTHER location. Her mind doesn't really know what to do with...a future that isn't that. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Do you have capabilities I no longer remember, that might help at all?  I have some capabilities that I might be able to compound to find and contact an entity to find the bag, but that would be expensive to even try, and the causalpathway seems... tenuous."

"It nearly goes without saying, of course, that if I had the bag, I could use the resources in it to find the bag."

Permalink Mark Unread

It goes without– it would have gone without saying that if Merrin had the actual full resources of a standard Exception Handling remote support team behind her, and had been equipped for a "find an extremely valuable lost item" mission (not really her core skillset but she wouldn't be an insane person to send on such a mission if, like, it had to be done as soon as possible and was likely to take longer than sixteen hours of continuous work and involved dangerous aquatic work), then she would have much better chances of finding Estha's stuff. 

She does not have that. She doesn't have automated search drones, or a remote team poring over her suit camera feed, and she doesn't have remote drone footage of yesterday afternoon which is what would really have a chance of being helpful for narrowing it down. Her metal detector is short-range. Her suit does infrared camera "vision" but that's good for finding people, not bags protected by metal mesh. 

"Understood," she says. "I have no obvious brilliant ideas in the first ten seconds." Implication being that obviously one ought to try for a lot longer than ten seconds to come up with brilliant ideas, except that maybe on reflection she should say that because it will not be obvious. "We should go over the resources we both have available and see if one comes to us. My only-slightly-clever idea is to extend how long we can 'search' by recording video footage on my suit of the riverbed – I don't have an amazing electronic viewing suite but it can do basic zoom and contract enhancement and stuff. And I have underwater capability, I could swim up with the tidal current and then down the permanent river channel once the tide is out, in case it sinks in water and it's ended up down there. ...Will long-term saltwater exposure destroy it and if so how quickly? I...am not sure what the odds are on finding it with the strategies I described but they would be higher if we could spend a planetary month on it. - that's a bit under seven planetary days." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"It should resist saltwater immersion indefinitely..."

"Your capability doesn't sound like it beats a capability to locate the object if it is anywhere within [around 1000 feet] of myself when I invoke that capability, continuing up to [12 minutes] after as I move... which I can do at around [300 feet] per [minute]... which I could potentially do, say, five times..."

"If I can succeed in communicating to my entity that I want that capability.  Or if my -- entity -- is able to infer that I need it.  There has been an anomaly in the capabilities I receive.  Or, of course, my memory of how that works has been falsified."

"And regardless, I can't get that capability -- if I can get it at all -- until either dawn, or 22.98 hours after first woke and was able to speak to you, and I'm not sure which."

"And it is possible -- it looks like, based on the other capabilities I was given, that would rely on the contents of my bag to use -- my entity thinks I can obtain the bag with the capabilities I was given, or that we have together.  Despite my not being given the capability most obviously useful for it.  Alternatively, there was a communications difficulty, or a process anomaly, or my memory about any number of possible situation facets has been falsified."

Permalink Mark Unread

That is a lot of pieces of information that do not neatly fit into any pre-existing mental buckets and generate many additional questions, and Merrin is somewhat having difficulty catching all of them in her working memory. Really she should be taking NOTES, but it's going to continue getting colder in the shelter for the next six hours until dawn, and she doesn't...actually have any properly warm clothes...to offer Estha so that they can both get up and start working sooner. Except he did say - but this isn't the part of the day where the temperature is least survivable - 

It's feeling weirdly high-friction for Merrin to fill in all of her mental blank spots around what Estha's "capabilities" and constraints are. Maybe it's just the bizarre language thing, where Baseline is apparently missing key vocabulary? Maybe he's separately being less than fully open with her but Merrin is not going to confidently conclude that yet. 

...She very obviously needs to reassess the priorities she's had for months, and not just do the extremely tempting mental motion of deciding that she was managing before and now has strictly more resources and so everything is fine and not an a emergency.

They're almost certainly not going to die, today, and probably wouldn't even if she had an Estha to feed and shelter from the climate and he hadn't arrived with his own bonus specialabilities. But that doesn't mean nothing is time-sensitive. It sounds like Estha does, actually, think they have a chance of getting off this planet, not just eking out some minimal survival indefinitely, and it sounds like that relies on finding his missing gear, and that is time sensitive, because it's only going to keep getting harder the more tidal periods elapse.

Merrin's mind is having trouble treating this with the urgency it deserves, because it...doesn't, quite, feel real to her yet...but it seems like her brain is being silly, there. 

 

(She got all of that thinking rammed through her brain mostly while Estha was still talking. She's getting the hang of this "interacting with another human being without having it accidentally overwrite her ability to maintain her own internal train of thought" thing.) 

 

"I'm wondering if it's easiest for me to fill you in while you're using your - capability that your entity gave you," ???????, "to understand Baseline, and you have my vocabulary but not vocabulary for talking about your, um, entity? And then if you use the other capability that gives me your language, it should be easier for you to talk about the entity-related capabilities and fill me in?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

A perfectly reasonable thought that Esta himself had not actually had yet!  It's moments like these, when Mariona manages to actually use her Cunning that is in fact exactly the numerical equal of Esta's according to Detect Thoughts, that Esta is confirmed in his sense that she may eventually someday be worth all the work that he put into her if she ever fucking grows an ambition.

Esta shows his smile, because Cultural Adaptation tells him to just fucking do that part; and then opens his mouth to deliver the sort of praise that he enjoys giving Mariona because it makes her so horribly uncomfortable --

Permalink Mark Unread

HALT!

In this culture, you do not tell Merrin that she is special.

Permalink Mark Unread

...because you don't compliment young people, it makes them get above their place?

Is it one of the cultures where men don't praise women?

Or because Chaotic Goods don't compliment people, if that makes them uncomfortable?  Esta is pretty sure he has seen Chaotic Goods making other people uncomfortable.

Permalink Mark Unread

This planetary culture has a rule saying that you do not tell MERRIN SPECIFICALLY that she is special.

In much the same way that other cultures might have a rule about how to address the Queen, or which forks to eat with.

Permalink Mark Unread

...the culture that Merrin now thinks of herself as being from, has a cultural rule specifically about how to address its equivalent of a single second-circle Worldwound fort commander??

Permalink Mark Unread

(Well, not everyone in dath ilan knows that rule, of course, any more than everyone in a particular Golarion country knows how to address the country's dictator at a dinner party...

Permalink Mark Unread

...but if you think about the Queen and point Cultural Adaptation to ask for the culture she's in, you're going to get the culture that includes intuiting how to address her at a banquet if she deigns to speak to you.  Not because you're getting the Queen's own mental concept of her culture -- or any other private information that she knows and the rest of the country doesn't -- but because that's the general cultural context near the Queen.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Anyway, yes.  The part of Merrin's culture that Merrin is from -- which could be a country or a whole planet or maybe a sufficiently large city-state with its own customs and dialect, but is not just one village or fortress or such -- has a rule that MERRIN SPECIFICALLY is not to be told that she is special.

(It's known as the Ordinary Merrin Conspiracy, but this level of information is not going to make it through Cultural Adaptation.  Cultural Adaptation just tells you what there is a general cultural rule against doing, and if you run some internal thought experiments about it you may be able to pick up some further information about what exactly is or is not allowed.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta will consider LATER what this implies, because on the face of things it does NOT PARTICULARLY MAKE SENSE.

Permalink Mark Unread

After smiling, opening his mouth, closing his mouth, dropping the smile, and pausing somewhat awkwardly, Esta then smiles again though less broadly.  "Yes, good idea.  Though, how long was it until dawn again?  There are actions I might want to take before then, if that's less than two hours out; it's not just when the next tidal bore comes through, it's when I might or might not have my capabilities swapped and replaced."

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh right he has no idea of her timekeeping. That's definitely one of the things Merrin needs to fill him in on, and plausibly he should...write it down in his own language so he can read it even without the capabilities his "entity" gave him active? 

"It's currently about 06:35 local time." Speaking of that, she's now waited long enough after eating a bite of bread to feel more confident it's not making her ill, and at this point it feels like it might be worth the small risk of not waiting longer to be sure if it means she has calories in her and isn't trying to think with low blood sugar. 

She points at the breads to indicate where she's going, and keeps talking as she slips out of the sleeping bag and hurries over and back with two of them. "Sunrise is due at about 13:20 local time, so that's in slightly less than seven hours. ...I don't know how your entity would define 'dawn', in dath ilan there are a few different definitions for different uses, and on this planet there's almost a three-hour gap between the point when the sky is just starting to get lighter and the point before actual sunrise when there's enough light to work by. The earliest possible definition of dawn might be as early as 09:00, in two and a half hours." 

 

Mmffff breaaaaaad in her faaaaaace. It's slightly difficult to eat while keeping most of her body in the sleeping bag but it's worth it. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"That's a good example of the level of detail that my translation capability won't automatically do for me, unless I notice the problem closely enough to think about it.  The concept in my own vocabulary is precise enough that none of your words exactly fitted."

"The moment when the sun is exactly halfway above where the horizon would be if it were the bare sea.  If that's the moment when my entity comes into contact, I will need to spend an hour -- thinking at it[intonation tag: this is leaving out many important details that are hard to explain].  I will also have ten moments before then, that I can use to expend capabilities not yet expended, before their replacement.  But if I'm not -- thinking at my entity -- by the time those moments are done, I'm out of ontologicallybasic tendencies toward positiveoutcomes."

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin spends a second or two going ????? at an entity-granted capability for "ontologicallybasic tendencies toward positiveoutcomes" and concludes that it's going to be much easier to request an explanation later when she has his language. She is at this point pretty sure it's going to be worth the side effects, because not understanding Estha's - this version of Estha's - deal is definitely something that could kill them both via uniformed suboptimal decisions, and it doesn't look so far like whatever side effects he's experiencing from it are themselves impairing in a causing-suboptimal-decisionmaking way? And she ate the food. 

"...I think by my definitions that's just sunrise, approximately," she says. "So it sounds like should have more than six hours, and - unless you're going to need to do something many hours' walk from camp, I think that means we have time to use the rest of your current language-capability-window on me explaining to you what my resources and constraints are, and then switching?" Pause. "- Is there any reason you need to be here at sunrise to...think at your entity...other than comfort? I don't have any powered transport method, we'd be walking, and the range of places we could walk to before dawn is wider than the range of places we could walk to and also back from. ...The planet doesn't have dangerous terrestrial wildlife, that's not a threat, it's mostly just the climate." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Unfortunate in some ways.  Circling up would be hard, and time-consuming, but not impossibly so -- if there were anything to fight worth fighting.  If there isn't, it's a lot closer to impossible.  He can't even summon poorly contained demons and kill them, because his Planar Binding is devil-only.

"The primary distance problem, I suspect, is the part where I'm on a distant planet.  I would not expect my location on this planet to make any difference at all.  Unless we moved far enough to change the time of dawn -- if my capability requests prove to be bound to dawn at all."

Permalink Mark Unread

"- That makes sense, if your entity is at interstellar distances from here," or some other, stranger sort of distance, Merrin is getting the impression that she does not, really, understand the configuration of this larger and weirder Reality she's slipped out into, and she's not sure she should, for example, be looking at the stars in this sky and wondering which one belongs to dath ilan, "- then I wouldn't expect exact location on the planet to make any difference. I was mostly wondering if you might want to go search for your bag, I do have night-searchlight capabilities. ...I think probably I should focus on filling you in for the next - you've had your spell up for 32 minutes, I'll set an alarm for, uh, 73 minutes to warn us when it's 15 minutes short of running out, does that make sense...?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"It does.  I could use a timepiece myself, if you have one going spare; I had put mine into my Holding Bag before the tidal bore struck, to avoid its loss."

"--I had not been able to understand at the time what you were warning me about, other than that it was water and flooding.  That was a less powerful translation capability and I was impaired in other ways by my recent encounter, but it is still a lesson to us both on the dangers of capability-automated translation."

"I intend to now share with you a language; I have on reflection picked a conlang I know, that is closer to the language we are currently speaking, but should still contain words for all of the missing concepts.  Unless something further goes wrong, or my memories are wrong.  I think it wiser to begin experimenting with that language while I am still capable of speaking Baseline, should there be something sayable in one language but not the other.  It is not a human conlang; it is spoken by a particular utilityfunction of entity.  I conjecture this to be actually less dangerous."

Permalink Mark Unread

....O...kay? Merrin feels like if she were SMARTER she would perhaps be able to think of the correct questions, on the spot, rather than just having a lot of ?????? about having a conlang spoken by a "particular utilityfunction of entity" (???) implanted in her brain via some kind of mentalistmagic (???? ).

Laeirthe help should she go for it. 

Permalink Mark Unread

(Mental shove) move over she's not really leaving him any space in this brain to have thoughts - what was the question again -? 

 

...She could certainly stand to be somewhat paranoid about the possible ways this could go terribly, but - low confidence, Laeirthe is having to squeeze his thoughts down to a very narrow un-nuanced heuristic-opinion right now - he suspects that even after applying suspicion, the information value would be worth the risk? And - there's a thing here where if "Estha" is operating adversarially, and has entity-granted mentalistmagic, he would not, actually, need Merrin's cooperation to harm them with it, and it's only in some subset of the worlds where Estha is an enemy that Merrin agreeing to receive his conlang will make things go worse than if she refuses? 

Also it's incredibly frustrating for him, too, not understanding the details of Estha's capabilities, and it seems reasonable that having both of them speaking both languages for an interval will resolve their confusions more quickly. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"That makes sense to me," Merrin says, after appearing to go quiet and think while making a slightly odd expression for about twenty seconds. 

Permalink Mark Unread

That's not an exact body language pattern he remembers seeing off Mariona; but not knowing what this means, or how to relate it to everything else about Merrin that is different, Esta will set it aside.

"This is a capability-effect you could resist with perhaps one chance in two, if you tried to resist it, so try to avoid resisting.  Or as one would say in [Utopian], and as you will shortly understand:  [Fail your Will save.]  Ready?"

Permalink Mark Unread

...That's interesting. Laeirthe is paying attention now. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Not in a way where he's going to resist it and then it won't work, right? Right? 

Permalink Mark Unread

That is probably not how anything works. Given how Laeirthe is an emulation of a fictional character running on Merrin's brain and is, like, at most 10% of a person. But, sure, he will endeavor not to get in the way. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Ready," Merrin says, and - for lack of any better internal prompt for 'not resisting' something that might otherwise prompt resistance - tries to do the relaxing-into-whatever-happens mental motion that she might do if, for example, Estha were about to cause her an amusing amount of pain. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Share Language (Utopian).

It's only in the process of actually untying the spell that Esta realizes/remembers -- he has not cast this spell literally since his days as a 2nd-circle -- that Esta could now in principle use it to grant more than one language; indeed, he could use it to grant three.

In that split second, Esta decides --

-- to grant Merrin only Utopian, because that was his original plan and Esta does not have any time to think about it.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh wow, is this Merrin's first Will save ever?  What an occasion!

Roll a DC 10 Will check in order to resist resisting and successfully fail, please!


...

And let's say that, uhhh...

Uhhh...

Merrin is a very skilled and famous Exception Handler, who has practiced under many arduous conditions and also never actually encountered any sort of Will-impinging magic in her whole life!  Which grants her a base Will bonus of +3.  And of course she has a WIS bonus of +4; Creation at least understands that part very well.

So, basically don't roll a 1 or 2?

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin can apparently figure that out on the fly! The spell lands. 

 

 

...It doesn't "feel like anything" in the sense that there's no sensory input, not like being physically bapped with something or injected with a drug or seeing a bright light or - she's not sure why she's trying to compare it to all of those things, or why she even expected to be able to sense it happening directly - 

Permalink Mark Unread

No, that was a Laeirthe-expectation, because his fictional character instance can perceive magic happening to him! Unsurprisingly, because this is now how anything works, he did not port that ability over to Merrin's brain just as a result of her simulating him. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay, so she can't directly perceive magic and that bothers her imaginary character-model. 

 

Does she speak another language now, though??? 

For some reason the internal test that Merrin's brain instantly tries to run, on this matter, is not "how would she ask Estha about his entity in his conlang that she should now speak" or even the also-sensible "how would she translate her planned explanation of the shelter specs", but the very stupid "imagine she's giving a standard shift report on a patient to Estha, for some reason" and, for mental-availability reasons, the actual historical patient her brain offers for that use is Kalorm, at the end of the first day. 

So how would Merrin translate a detailed ICU shift report on a patient who she'd pulled out of the middle of an ocean in cardiac arrest and needed to treat in a MOVING HELICOPTER for a REALLY LONG TIME and who had not given his advanceconsent for cryopreservation, into this conlang? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay, see, the way this version of the spell works, unlike Tongues or even Comprehend Languages, you only get words of Utopian that Esta knows.

Does real Utopian have all of those words?  Yes.  Absolutely.  There's almost no reason for anyone to worry about blood glucose, unless they're part of a small strange Axis neighborhood full of LARPing medical fetishists who like reenacting famous medical emergencies that include humanoids, as if they had to be treated entirely using advanced but nonmagical technology.  But Axis has those.  Its people are so intelligent, long-lived, rich, numerous, good at solving multiparty coordination problems, and bent on entertaining themselves, that their degree of weird-subcultural fractal differentiation makes dath ilan look like Montana.

Does Esta know those words?  He does not.

Blood glucose is gonna come out as "blood sugar".  There's no word for sodium or potassium levels.  There's no word for helicopter.  Etc etc.

Merrin's memory may, if she troubles to consult its very short-term window, now realize what it means to [fail your Will save], and that [saves] are a thing, and that [Will] is only one flavor of it.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin realizes within about three seconds that this is, indeed, a stupid test for "did it work", and will think to consult her auditory memory loop and...huh...Laeirthe does that make sense as a conceptualmagic concept? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Again, Laeirthe is going to reiterate that he does not know information Merrin doesn't know because he is, literally, made out of her brain. ...But sure, it makes sense for mentalistmagic to be something one could mentally resist, and to be difficult-to-resist on varying dimensions? 

Permalink Mark Unread

(Laeirthe is, perhaps, slightly freaking out at the part where they just had MIND ALTERING MAGIC DONE TO THEIR BRAIN and this is - actually a big deal? This is a really really really important update for Merrin about what sorts of thing Reality includes?? Is Merrin even paying attention here -) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is trying to focus here, okay! 

 

...Does she now know any words in this language referring to the specific capabilities that Estha has talked about having? There's the food one - he didn't actually explain how it worked but can she find any new vocabulary that her brain indexes under 'food-producing economicmagic' or something like that? And the surviving-temperature-extremes one, she thinks he said something about that, can she find any newly-acquired vocabulary for what it is or might be...? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, those are [spells]!

She's not going to get the proper name of the [spell] off of thinking about what it does.  The part where the [spell] is producing things sounds like it might be [conjuring] them, though?  And if you want temperature not to bother you, you'd maybe want [energy] [resistance] to [cold] or [fire] [damage]?(*)


(*) Not actually the same thing, but it's what's going to turn up if you start looking for specific words lying in that direction.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oooooooh shiny! New magic categorization system implanted directly into her brain via vocabulary transfer! That is so sci-fi a concept even if it is technically apparently accomplished via some sort of mentalistmagic and so strictly speaking is not the science fiction genre Merrin continues to be dubious of that sort of logic ever giving useful predictions. 

It's so cool though! ...What words does she know for - kinds of entities - specifically kinds of entities that one can think at over interstellar distances and get specialabilities from? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Interstellar distances?  The main thing that has a connotation of [granting] you [spells] over interstellar distances specifically would be

[Dark Tapestry]

[horrors]

and especially the 

[Outer Gods].

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

...Those are not words that feel like they have incredibly positive connotations, are they.

Buuuut probably she should just talk to Estha, at this point. 

Does her new language ability suggest an idiomatic way to ask him in this conlang about the entity acting as a source of his [spell] capabilities that the her he remembers apparently also gets [spell] capabilities from, or is she stuck doing awkward word-for-word translation from the Baseline equivalent sentence? 

(Merrin has, perhaps, become a little distracted from the part where she and Estha are on a time limit to communicate about urgent logistical information and make time-sensitive plans.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Who are you a [cleric] of?  Who is your [deity]?

Permalink Mark Unread

Oooh and there are definitely associations Merrin could dredge out of those words with more effort, even if she is now realizing that she should, perhaps, focus on more immediate matters. 

...She should probably not be that confident that she's poked her new vocabulary and conceptualassociations the exact right way to generate the correct hypothesis and question on literally the first try. 

"Are you a cleric? If so who is your deity?" she tries to ask Estha in his conlang, and since he told her not to worry about making the vibes weird for him with her expressiveness, she's not trying to hide that she's tentatively a bit pleased with and proud of herself for extracting that question out of newly-acquired vocabulary alone; she thinks that took nonzero cognitive skill, probably, that he should not necessarily have been taking for granted that she would obviously have. 

(...He didn't say it was his conlang, did he, not in the dath ilan sense of a language he invented or even that of an existing conlang-speaking-community he joined. He said it was spoken by a particular utilityfunction of entity. Can she figure out how to say that phrase in her new vocabulary? If it's a particular utilityfunction then that might imply a whole categorization system of utilityfunctions and Merrin finds categorization systems moderately shiny in general, can she figure this one out from new vocabulary alone...?) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Unfortunately Utopian has a one-syllable word that means utilityfunction, though Esta only knows it as 'everything you want and how much quantitatively you want it', and that's what Merrin's internal question will return rather than [alignment].

Permalink Mark Unread

"I am a 6th[-circle] [cleric] of a [god].  I'm not yet telling you Its(*) name because your knowing that has additional consequences; though you were once Its 2nd[-circle] [cleric] before your knowledge and connection to It were stripped away by a worse and more alien great [divinity]."


(*)  Utopian does not have gendered fucking pronouns lol.

Permalink Mark Unread

HEY!  It's RUDE to tell people information that's deliberately misleading like that, if it's not part of an incredibly elaborate prank they'll figure out later!  You're making it sound like it's a cognitohazard to HER, and ACTUALLY you're just selfishly worried that if you say the words 'Hell' or 'Lawful Evil' it'll tick off the Chaotic Goodie!

Permalink Mark Unread

Shut the fuck up, dath ilan.

Permalink Mark Unread

SUSPICION ALERT SUSPICION ALERT ESTHA IS DEFINITELY CONCEALING INFORMATION AND MERRIN SHOULD NOT BE LETTING HIM SET THE FRAME THAT THIS IS FOR HER OWN PROTECTION IT COULD WELL BE SELF-SERVING 

Permalink Mark Unread

Can Laierthe please chill and not do the mental equivalent of screaming in her head like that! He's being really distracting right now and Merrin is trying not to be super weird and suspicion herself in this conversation and Laeirthe is not making that easy!

(Merrin very briefly does the odd body language thing again, and then seems to shake herself out of it within a couple of seconds.) 

....Also. She now has an additional concern. That might be relevant to Estha's okayness. 

 

"When I was thinking about - [gods]? Is that the general term for {entities}," she's swapping the Baseline word back in there, "or is [divinity] the general term, I can't tell for sure which if any is the," grabbing the Baseline word again rather than spend time carefully checking if translations are actually the thing she means, "the {supercategory} - anyway I was seeing if the vocabulary would give me hypotheses for what your 'entity' was, and I got [Outer Gods] and [Dark Tapestry]. I...think...I'm guessing purely off word-associations that you're saying that your [god] is not a [Dark Tapestry] one, and the one that - made this happen - maybe was? And I - how sure are you that the [god] giving you [spells] is still the same one? I - because - when I was wondering what could cross very large distances, the vocabulary I got was the [Dark Tapestry] and [Outer Gods] words...?" 

Hopefully this is immediately and obviously stupid to anyone with context!

Permalink Mark Unread

"Rule one of the Dark Tapestry.  You do not think about the Dark Tapestry."

"Rule two of the Dark Tapestry.  You do not think about the Dark Tapestry."

"Our god is most certainly not an Outer God."  Asmodeus is in fact not that powerful, though this is the sort of concept that is carefully introduced at 4th circle and Mariona is not on that whitelist.  "What sent us here was, yes, of the Dark Tapestry, and that's all the talking we should do about it.  I have been trying not to think about it.  Knowing anything about a powerful Dark Tapestry entity potentially brings you to Its attention and connects It to your mind, body, [soul], and location.  I am not authorized to know the name of what sent us here, and now, unfortunately, I know it anyways."

Flat, cold, commanding, and rapid.  The sort of Exception Handling language that informs someone under your command that if they take another six steps forward they will die.

Permalink Mark Unread

....Okay then. Taking Estha's response at face value: yes, the thing she said was really stupid, just, in a different and even worse way than what she'd been worried about! 

Wow! You know what would be really nice: if Merrin could actually! trust! that this was more-or-less Estha as she knows him - just with additional bonus [spells] from a [god], somehow - and therefore trust him to be acting with full cooperation and telling the truth when he says that this topic is genuinely actually cognitohazardous and that is definitely not a self-serving justification for scaring her into not asking any more questions! 

"Understood," Merrin says immediately, and - she wasn't really thinking ""about"" the...things that she is now also not thinking about the vocabulary term for...due to literally not knowing anything more than the connotations she could pull out from introspection, but she can now can continue not-thinking about that whole vaguely-defined corner of conceptspace in her new linguistic vocabulary, she does have that much mental discipline. Estha did seem actually stressed, she thinks? But, of course, she's not sure that she can read him better than he can conceal things from her. 

Anyway. Not knowing Estha's deal is presenting Merrin with the dilemma that, on the one hand, maybe it is UNWISE to be trying to extract information from linguistic introspection on her own and she should STOP and just learn what he judges is a good idea to tell her. But ALSO this is one of the few ways she can learn anything about him from sources that are even slightly uncorrelated with "exactly what he decides he wants her to know", and, just, arghhh. 

 

 

(...Speaking of vocabulary and concepts, what was that word he said? [Soul], that one, it was the one that most obtrusively lacked an immediately obvious 1:1 Baseline transaction...?) 

Permalink Mark Unread

It's a thing at the center of your consciousness that's durable!  Would survive plane crashes, even!  It's what you'd call back to resurrect the dead!  They can be sold for big money!  Messing with it involves [necromancy].

(You're not going to get straight-up dictionary definitions from Share Language.  If you don't have the concept, it'll throw the speaker's associations around the edges, and definitely not prioritize the connections that would be most useful for you to know about.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Those sure are some associations!!!! What???? 

Permalink Mark Unread

This makes sense to Laeirthe! It's like the thing that his fictional instance has that can possess bodies. ....Roughly. He's equally at a loss for how the 'can be sold for a lot of money' part can possibly fit - 

Permalink Mark Unread

"And yes, I have considered the possibility that my anomalous [prayer session] and [spell loadout] is because that Dark Tapestry entity which sent us here is the thing actually giving me spells.  I will own consideration of that issue."  This last sentence is even easier to say in Utopian than in Baseline.

"To return to your nondangerous question:  [Divinity] is anything that grants [clerics] [spells].  [Gods] are the most normal case of that, corresponding to most [clerics].  Our [divinity] is the most ancient and powerful [god] that is still, in that certain sense, normal."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Understood," Merrin says again, and mentally notes her new vocabulary term for the sort of thinking at his [god] that Estha was having trouble describing properly in Baseline.

She feels like she's lost her stack trace, here, weren't they in the middle of gearing up for a different topic focus before Estha decided they ought to overlap him-having-her-language and her-having-his-language - 

Permalink Mark Unread

Laeirthe is busy feeling a moment of brief irritation at how this-Estha keeps talking about his [god] as also Merrin's [god], because from his perspective that is just...not true? Whatever the relationship between Merrin now and the "Merrin" who this Estha remembers, this Merrin has had an entire life and backstory that does not seem to be full of gaps better explained by having forgotten having [spells] from a [god]. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Personally Kalorm thinks this Merrin is cooler. It's uncool to be getting all your capabilities from some sort of weird otherworldly entity instead of just being really good at things on your own. 

Permalink Mark Unread

CAN THE PEOPLE IN HER HEAD PLEASE SHUT UP AND LET HER FOCUS RIGHT NOW 

 

"- We should decide what order to cover topics in while we both have the language [spells] active," Merrin says. "I still think it probably makes sense to try to fill you in on all of my Exception Handling gear while you speak Baseline?" She's speaking Baseline now, except for inserting [spells] at the appropriate place. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Agreed.  That was a good idea."


This feels VERY UNNATURAL to say without having tortured Merrin at all.

Permalink Mark Unread

(Cultural Adaptation to widely shared dath ilan culture in Merrin's rough vicinity is not going to get you Merrin-specific rules about this issue.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Then Merrin can fill Estha in on what equipment she arrived on this planet with, what sorts of training she has for using it, and what she's done with that so far to survive! 

 

There are some obvious disconnects and Merrin ends up having to jump back and fill in a bit about her training, which did not involve learning how to use [spells] as a [cleric] of a [god]. Instead she trained as a medtech and had a normal hospital position - she'll have to digress briefly here to explain what a hospital is and why it makes sense in a world without any kind of [cleric] [spells] for medical treatment - and at some point it came up that she has unusual stamina, and so despite the fact that she's rather lower - huh this language has bizarre buckets for mentalabilities - anyway she's presumably below average on all of them, but she can train harder to make up for it, and for some situations there are very significant efficiency gains from being able to dispatch one medtech who can proceed to work for twenty hours without falling over, and so Merrin transferred to a position with Exception Handling and has, since then, done a mix of simulated-emergency-response trainings and actual emergency response calls, plus some number of regular hospital shifts so she doesn't forget the basics... 

...Merrin does not think of her scientific knowledge base as unusual. If anything she clearly thinks of herself as a bit dull. But she knows the basic established dath ilan science about, say, planetary orbital dynamics, and some very basic programming and very basic math and very basic structural engineering to design her shelter, etc etc, and she knows more biology than that even when it's not strictly speaking human medicine, so she was able to make some reasonable judgement calls on testing edible local biomass... 

 

 

Several things will likely be apparent to Esta: 

1. Merrin really, really loved her work with "Exception Handling".

2. Merrin does not say as much, but it does not, really, seem like her position as she's describing it was very equivalent to a 2nd-circle cleric and Worldwound fort commander. It sounds more analogous to the sort of person who would have been alongside Esta on the 7th-circle Worldwound emergency response team, albeit for different and fairly specific types of "emergency"; dath ilan is coming to sound like a place that has fifty different such specialized teams, and Merrin would only be assigned to a few of them. 

3. Merrin does not really at any point acknowledge that this might be notable. 

Permalink Mark Unread

If Esta was not thinking of all this in terms of "Dark Tapestry inversion" it is possible that it would occur to him to wonder if any of these ideas would work on Golarion and could be sold for big money or parlayed into some sort of military advantage.

Esta has not usually been instructed to think in that general direction!  He has been rendered more corrigible than that.  Possibly if Esta had a superior present, Esta would ask them whether to think in terms of exploiting all this knowledge, or for that matter, trying to mine diamonds on this untouched exoplanet.

But this is not where Esta's attention and concern is pointed by default.

Permalink Mark Unread

If Esta had heard all this, one hour earlier, it would have occurred to him to wonder if 'Merrin' is perhaps, somehow, a completely alternate version of Mariona from some kind of shadow of Golarion; whether Mariona was outright replaced and not just inverted.  For much of this does not sound like a direct mirroring or inversion in particular, and parts of it do not obviously match up with his remembered Mariona at all.

Thankfully, Esta has by now seen the key piece of evidence which contradicts this.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

Because if Merrin was really from some entirely different world, related to Mariona only by some strange coincidence of appearance, or magical shadowing effect --

-- then why would that country -- or perhaps entire planet, for there is no mention of distinct countries, in her words, or even distinct cultures --

-- why would that whole country have a rule specifically saying not to tease Merrin about her future potential if she ever acquired ambition, as Esta specifically teased Mariona about, and Mariona specifically hated?

 

 

Permalink Mark Unread

And the answer is that it would not.


New hypothesis:

The whole world that Merrin thinks she is from, is in some sense a shadow cast by Mariona.

Permalink Mark Unread

There are other signs, in her story.

 

Esta's first domain ability from his Devil domain was "Hell's Corruption", a transient touch of evil upon a soul, like some vastly lesser form of Malediction, which makes a being "more susceptible to corruption" by bringing up its repressed desires.

It sounds a great deal more awesome than it actually is.  In practice, you land a touch attack on an opponent, and then they'll be very mildly distracted by all their repressed desires welling up, for a number of moments equal to your cleric circle.  So far as Esta knows, not a single paladin has ever fallen as a result of being so touched, in the history of Golarion and maybe of Creation.

They warn you, in seminary, if you have the rare Devil domain, that "Hell's Corruption" really really is not as useful as it sounds.  At 4th circle they tell you the cautionary tale of a cleric with a beautiful but unresponsive mistress, whom he touched by Hell's Corruption to try to bring out her dark forbidden desires.  And then it turned out her dark repressed desire was for LOTS OF BABIES obtained by any means necessary, and she was chosen by Pharasma as a cleric.  And -- although the fact is not at all popularized in Cheliax -- Asmodeus and His Church do acknowledge that Asmodeus is in a chain of command with Pharasma, who is mightier than He even if She is so indifferent as to be useless as a tyrant.  The point being, you don't Maledict Pharasmin clerics, or torture them, or even keep them as slaves -- although, again, that fact is not popularized.  You just exile them out of Cheliax, unless they promise to be Lawful or maybe Evil and work with the Church.  So the cleric lost his mistress, because her dark forbidden desire turned out to be not as gloriously Evil as he'd hoped.

 

Esta did, at one point, lay Hell's Corruption on Mariona, in the desperate hope that there would be anything hiding there to drive Mariona higher in Asmodeus's ranks.

Was Mariona's dark repressed desire to rule the world?  To rule the Church, as Most High?  To rise above Esta and crush him underfoot, beginning a game that Esta would have felt gratified to play, if only Mariona would play it?

No.  Mariona's terrible dark repressed desire was for more medical emergencies to happen around her that she could treat by non-magical medicine, without just throwing a Cure spell at it.

After which Mariona began withholding Cure spells from her troops who'd injured themselves in stupid ways, and treating them nonmagically instead.

This is more or less exactly the sort of thing that seminary warned young Esta would probably happen, if he ever hoped for Hell's Corruption to do anything useful.  It's shaped around being not literally utterly completely useless in combat; meaning it doesn't so much unearth the dark desire that is so tempting as to turn a paladin away from Good, as the dark desire that manages to be very distracting if your mind starts fantasizing about it.

 

But for Esta to now hear that 'Merrin' was supposedly running around all day long being a 7th-circle-grade non-magical field medic... has a certain familiar ring to it, is the point, here.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta has heard of traps and games like this, sprung and played in the First World that the gods made and then abandoned for its flaws and incoherence; games of the Fey, as they are known to laity.

If this were Fey work, the general concept would be to trap Mariona in a prison of her own desires; and there would be a game, perhaps, of Esta being given a chance -- not at all necessarily a fair chance -- to make Mariona see the illusion or reject her supposed heart's desire.

In that version, all Mariona's gear and all her new skills would be -- illusion, or something akin to it, though maybe of a form real enough to bite.  But made out of the substanceless chaos of the First World.

 

Possibly if the game is being set up by Ŷ̵̘ö̸͙g̷̗̃-̴̖̈́S̵̗̿o̸̹̽t̷̝͝h̵̼͋ó̸̭ẗ̸͖h̵̝̃ it all has a reality of a different order.


(And yes Esta is just thinking the name at this point, because if he tries not to think the name and use euphemisms, it starts coming out as Ṱ̵̌h̴͚̐e̸̩̒ ̶̢̈G̸͚͂ṙ̷͕e̶̿͜á̵̬ţ̷̚ ̸̥̀Ṋ̴̀ò̷̬ő̴̹d̴̺̈́l̴̩͋y̸͚̅ ̸̼͑O̶̯̊n̵̜͠ė̵̹ and such, and that is probably not better.)

Permalink Mark Unread

It's a hypothesis, and a working theory.  Esta has by now gone through several of those, in this place.  And he is old enough to have lived out parts of his life where he was hurt for jumping to conclusions; and also, of course, hurt for having failed to come up with any theories at all.

He has found no better answer -- nor do the more senior clerics teach it -- but to go on thinking, and be ready to step back from wherever you place your foot.


Esta does pay attention to the actual content of what Merrin is saying.  Reality or game, you have no choice but to play it either way.

Permalink Mark Unread

And eventually Merrin’s 15-min-warning alarm goes off.

(She did find a timepiece for Estha - she has a couple of tiny reprogrammable simplified-alarm-display-consoles for scenarios where she has to recruit less-injured bystanders to monitor the more injured ones while she rotates between many casualties, and it turns out it’s reprogrammable enough to be willing to display a clock time from another planet’s timekeeping system, though not - at least not at Merrin’s skill level - to display it in a numerical symbols that he can read without magic, he’ll need to learn the Baseline numerals.)

 

…Is there anything else that seems critical to hit in their planning discussion while Estha still has Baseline vocabulary readily at hand?

Permalink Mark Unread

Nothing with an obvious dependency on Baseline.

(Estha has asked some hopeful questions about what her technology can or can't do.  Some of them incredibly strange and sounding like, well, like all of Estha's memories of dath ilani technology have been incredibly thoroughly obliviated, as if he were being disoriented and realigned on an alien axis, and not just having sectors deleted.)

Permalink Mark Unread

If Merrin wants to try for a DC 25 Linguistics check btw, she may notice that Estha's shared [Utopian] seems to have something like a weird conspicuous hole corresponding to the same set of concepts Estha doesn't know.  [Lightning] as in [lightning damage] does not sound like a primitive term; it sounds like, say, hypothetically, a compound word built out of 'electrical', in a language that then had the simpler 'electrical' word ripped out.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is paying a lot of attention to the bizarre experience of understanding a language she did not actually learn but had inserted into her brain via some sort of mentalistmagic phenomenon, and also it's an annoying and frustrating language that has a ton of specific terms for things irrelevant to her and is missing basic vocabulary for a lot of things that are relevant to her. However, she's not actually a Linguistics genius and she is not going to catch it right now. 

 

Her overall impression is that her technology has been critical for her own survival, but one thing it absolutely cannot do, unlike - maybe - Estha's [cleric] abilities, is to get them off this planet. She's briefly mulled on the idea of trying to engineer a stronger radio transmitter, in case there's...anyone listening...but it seems very unlikely that this solar system has another habitable-zone planet with intelligent life, and and alien civilization with the capability to rescue her, and also she's not that good at engineering.

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, yes.  If you want to get around [Creation] and not just one dinky little planet, you had best become a [cleric].


(As opposed to, say, a wizard.  Oh, they get Plane Shift eventually, but only a few of them, and even fewer before they're too old to appreciate it.  Esta doesn't say this part out loud, because it's evident that "dath ilan" lacked all wizards and he doesn't want to call further attention to further divergence.  Excellent taste, though.)

Permalink Mark Unread

However.  The [Plane Shift] needed to evacuate them requires [tuning forks] that are in his lost [Bag of Holding].

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta will go through the parts of his [spell loadout] that seem relevant for finding his Bag, or those which he does not definitely know to be irrelevant -- [Magic Mouth], for example.  He will omit, for example, Suggestion.  (Esta is not assuming Asmodeus meant him to use that one on Mariona; its alternative as a domain spell was Dispel Magic and that he might have been even less likely to use.)

He will explain that his methods for protecting the two of them from heat and cold for [1 day] are an [Endure Elements] that he can cast upon her, and that was previously operating on him upon his own arrival; and a much stronger [Extended] [Planetary Adaptation] (4th->5th) that he can only use on himself.

...Esta will say out loud that he is not telling her about all his [spells] because apparently dath ilan culture thinks that Merrin may be really offended and estranged if evidence later arises that Esta can cast a spell he did not disclose, without this stupid fucking disclaimer that Chelish three-year-olds would not need.

If dath ilan is in truth a dreamworld meant to seduce Mariona, Esta (1) thinks this says some unflattering things about Mariona's relationship to social skill checks and (2) totally sees it, frankly.

Permalink Mark Unread

That does actually make Merrin - who is, in fact, tracking that Estha might not be entirely forthcoming here because LAEIRTHE WON'T SHUT UP ABOUT IT - feel friendlier about the whole interaction! See, Laeirthe, he didn't need to say that! He could have just not said anything! Surely this is some evidence that he's choosing to operate less than maximally adversarially? 

Endure Elements, when described, sounds like exactly the solution to their problem – it's not even something that only acts on a building! Modulo sunburn, they can just go out and do things while they have daylight, even during the dangerously hot hours of the afternoon! 

"What additional protection would [Planetary Adaptation] give you?" she asks him. "Does it help with sunburn? I can wear my suit - if I have Endure Elements it's fine that it can't really keep up with cooling in the afternoons - but the sunlight is a lot more damaging here." 

Permalink Mark Unread

It's categorical protection from the ordinary environment of the planet, full stop.  If the seas are boiling poisonous acid, you can swim in them and drink from them.  If the air is vaporous poisonous acid, you can breathe it.  If there's no air at all, you can still breathe it.

It's related to 4th-circle [Planar Adaptation].  [Planar Adaptation] will let you survive in the literal [Negative Energy Plane].

Permalink Mark Unread

This will approximately translate to:

The Doomplane.

It is full of Doom Energy.

Doom Energy is the ontologically simple essence of unhealth.

Permalink Mark Unread

It can be used to perform a kind of twisted cryorevival, but instead of getting the original person back, you get a Doom Entity.

Permalink Mark Unread

And yet, this still somehow feels like the 'doom' in 'doompunk'??

Maybe being able to throw Doom Energy around, if you can do so safely and without getting yourself killed like an idiot, is actually pretty cool???*


Anyway.  There were probably some other important things being communicated here besides all that linguistics stuff.

 

(*)  Esta has successfully convinced himself that Asmodeus is not a god of fucking useless channels.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is rapidly accumulating ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS about this magic system but probably the Doomplane of Doompunk Doom is not going to be immediately relevant to their two-person-team survival on an exoplanet that does not, she doesn't think, have any Doom Entities or at least that would feel like a really weird and insufficiently earned-with-foreshadowing genre twist in the narrative tropes.

...It does remind her of her mental note about Estha's super doompunk outfit. Which might not be evidence of anything! Dath ilan's cultural associations are not going to be universal! But she is now, increasingly, confident that this is not her Estha. No, she doesn't know how any of that works or what any of that means. Those sounds like questions for smart people, not a simple narrowly-specialized endurance medtech. Merrin is getting...kind of tired...of all the quicksand-reasoning here, and it's kind of impossible to keep track of in the middle of a conversation anyway. But - mental note.

 

"...So it sounds like you could even swim around in a tidal bore, and be fine?" she says. "And so can I, with the suit." Is it wise to immediately try the incredibly dangerous stupid stunt again? Probably not! But it in fact went fine, she didn't even hit any rocks despite being very distracted and not really optimizing for her own safety, and it'll be strictly easier if she instead has Estha alongside her and equally capable. 

Does that actually help them? She's thinking...

"This idea doesn't work if you do need to [pray for spells] at planetary dawn," she says. "As opposed to roughly 23 hours after you woke me and did the translation [spell], which was at...63:00-ish, I want to say? So 23 hours after that would be about nine hours after dawn. So we'd need to make a call at sunrise, depending what happens then. But - what I'm thinking, is that the next tidal bore is due sometime between fifteen and thirty minutes after sunrise. And if we can both safely jump into it, that's by far the fastest way to get a nice long way upstream. Probably as far as your bag could have gotten. And we can do a lot of searching before your [Planetary Adaptation] wears off. High tide will be 12 hours later. Low tide isn't until 30 hours later but it'll get low enough to expose the upper stretch of tidal flats long before that, and I think it's less likely the bag was swept back out with the outgoing tide and is downstream of us now." 

She makes a face. "...That gets us about 24 hours of searching - and I probably don't even need Endure Elements for it, the water's always cold and my armor can handle heating, but it might be worth it to save battery power, 24 hours straight of hard swimming with full heating on is pushing it."

Pause. "...If it turns out your [spells] aren't renewable ten hours later, then we'd need to be back here before 37:30 when yours wears off, to shelter in here. But if you do get more new spells ten hours later, then we'd have more. And maybe even the one to locate an object? - I think you'd want to time that one for a little after high tide, when the current is just turning and not too fast. We could cover a lot of river in twelve minutes, maybe get close enough to it. If you don't get it then we look the hard way, I guess." 

Glance up at him. "Does that sound potentially workable? ...And can you handle 24 hours straight of searching, I know I can but in dath ilan it's rare." Her Estha couldn't do that. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"There were several excellent ideas in there.  It hadn't occured to me to use the tidal bore itself as our means of swift movement along the channel, with a [Locate Object] running."

"The difficulty is that if [Planetary Adaptation] is like [Planar Adaptation], it is just that, adaptation, not actually protection.  I would think it would let you breathe acid air and drink acid seas, but not breathe beneath an acid sea; for if you were a native humanoid of that planet you could not do that.  Maybe with clever targeting I could make the [spell] to treat a volcano as the relevant part of the planet to adapt to, and then swim in lava -- but I would not trust my [Spellcraft] to attain that on my first try."

"There is also the point that I was not given [Locate Object].  And yet, if I am truly connected to my [god] and It saw me truly, the [spells] I was [granted], suggest I should be able to solve this problem today, without [praying] again."

"As for the matter of whether I can work at a sustained pace -- you have seen me do it, Merrin.  But in addition to all your memories of our actual profession seeming to have been erased, you would also no longer have the concept of a [Belt] of +4 [Constitution]."

"If I was certain you were still the Merrin I remember, I would have no hesitation about offering to let you try on my [Belt] for a minute to reacquaint yourself with the concept.  As it stands, I must ask you explicitly if you will [swear] to return my [Belt] to me after a minute.  People are sometimes reluctant to give [ability] [enhancement] [items] back, the first time they try one on."

(The word [Belt] conveys that it is a [magic item] filling the [Belt] [slot], rather than any particular sort of clothing, but it does have a connotation of usually going about the waist.)

([Constitution] is an [ability score] that governs over [vitality], [Fortitude] [saves], and of course general healthfulness in the medical sense.)

 

(Esta has not neglected to notice the point where Merrin is now addressing him as if he were not of the 'dath ilan' that she remembers.  She is of course correct in this, but it still reflects a possible gulf opening wider.  Esta is in fact extremely reluctant to take off his Belt of Constitution, even temporarily and even with his no longer being injured -- but that's exactly what makes it a huge impressive token of trust, that might keep 'Merrin' trusting him as she trusted her Estha.)

 

Permalink Mark Unread

There is SO MUCH NEW VOCABULARY! So many new concepts! Merrin kind of desperately wants to be taking notes right now, but also she kind of doesn't want to take notes that Estha can read, and wow she hates that, she is not built for this, she had trouble navigating even the basically friendly socialdeception games of dath ilan (and, yes, her Estha did find it amusing to tease her about this). They have logistical problems and she wants to just solve those together and not have to worry about all of the confusing metaphysics questions about how the larger stranger Reality even works and DEFINITELY not about whether this-Estha is lying to her about everything. 

She doesn't get to have that, does she. 

...The question, then, is whether it's a wise idea to accept his offer of trying on his belt, when he might be lying to her about everything. Also she is MILDLY WEIRDED OUT by his asking her to make an oath about giving it back, as though it's that much in question, though also she just kind of tries to have an instinctive flinch about promising things now. Merrin sure has made some questionable promises in her life without entirely thinking it through! You know, like the time she promised not to leave the room the entire time Kalorm was unconscious! 

 

"- I'd like a moment to think about what I'm comfortable swearing," she says, so she's not just awkwardly going quiet on him for unclear reasons. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Kalorm unsurprisingly thinks this is a pretty great Merrin-trait but, yeah, maybe awkward when uncool people are involved. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...Laeirthe is approving of Merrin flagging it and trying to run an appropriate level of paranoia, but - is not sure what the specific threat model would be here? Merrin does not seem like someone who will even have trouble doing a thing she doesn't emotionally-want to do because she committed to it, so the failure mode would be, what, proposing that the [belt] does mind control to her? But in the world where that was true and also this request specifically is a case of 'Estha' operating adversarially, then - what's his plan for how asking her to swear an oath that she then won't be able to keep would help with his goals at all? 

And there are perfectly sensible reasons for him to ask it of her. It's a key part of his own gear, obviously he's motivated to hold onto it, and - he's probably operating with just as much uncertainty and paranoia around Merrin's traits compared to the other version of her who he apparently knows. 

In summary: sure, maybe it's some kind of trick, the fact that Laeirthe can't see an obvious specific threat model does not guarantee there isn't one. But there's also information value to accepting the offer. 

Permalink Mark Unread

This is a really exhausting kind of thinking to have to be doing constantly in every conversation and Merrin is...really not sure how long she can keep doing it. 

 

...Out of curiosity, what vocabulary in the new language comes to mind when she considers talking about mentalistmagic mind control effects that might affect her ability to stick to a commitment she made prior? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh those are [enchantment (compulsion)s], a kind of [enchantment]!

If hypothetically they were built into a [magic item] that would make it [cursed], but she can't get off just the sense of language whether it'd be easy to [curse] a [Belt] with an [oath]-breaking [enchantment (compulsion)] specifically.

[Oaths] are very strongly tied to something called [Lawfulness], by the way; a word with a sense of depth about it like an ocean opening up under your feet.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oooooh, shiny– also, now is not the time to poke new language concepts. 

...It doesn't obviously seem like the [cursed] concept would apply in a way where Estha is directing it, as opposed to being a fact about the [belt] that would hit him too? Like, Merrin is not incredibly confident of that, obviously, one should not be confident of any conclusions drawn from linguistic analysis of a language implanted in one's mind via poorly understood mentalistmagic, but - if she wasn't generally in a paranoid mood, she doesn't think she would worry about it at all? 

Ugh. 

 

 

"I'm comfortable swearing that I currently intend to return the [belt] after a minute, have in the past been consistently able to keep to commitments of that nature even when it was tempting not to, and have no specific reason to expect that to be different here," she says. "...If you'd rather not lend it to me unless I swear more categorically than that, I think that's fine, I'm inclined to believe you about the stamina-increasing effect." Since she's already seen some other evidence of this Estha having a lot more physical stamina and resilience than hers. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Utopian is sufficiently fine-grained to distinguish 'intends to return' as a committed plan versus uncommitted plan versus self-prediction versus mere report of an intention.  Esta would not have accepted that assurance in Taldane, but he will accept it in Utopian.  And to do this thing with a less strong oath, is making a show of trusting her more, while not very much increasing the real risks.  It would be a strange moment for betrayal.

(Even Asmodeans will ask for time to think before swearing oaths, or demur from swearing them too strongly.  Hell itself does not prefer for Evil souls to lose their Law.  It does not strike Esta as strange.)

Esta undoes his Belt, suppressing all visible flinches without even thinking about whether or not he should (his dath ilan Cultural Adaptation has run out by now).  He hands the Belt over to Merrin.

Permalink Mark Unread

(Merrin suppresses her own hesitation-flinch temptation equally instinctively, though for different reasons; it’s not a matter of his social perception of her, it’s more like the thing where, you know, sometimes in an Exception Handling training she needs to jump out of a helicopter, with precise timing, and flinching would mess it up, and so once Merrin has made the decision to do something, in the absence of something analogous to “looking out the open hatch of said helicopter to realize they’re over land rather than water”, her decision is made and she does not in the moment of execution try to question her past self’s judgement on it.)

She puts the belt on.

 

…Wow.

Merrin suspects she can’t actually feel the full effect without making use of it in a situation that would actually strain her usual stamina, but she can feel something. It feels like…

…there’s a thing where sometimes she’s pushing through a bit of resistance to do things, digging into reserves that her body wants to make sure she remembers are not free. She’s analogized it in her head to starting a second vasopressor on a patient - you can do that! It’s not that doomy! But you wouldn’t do it casually just to counteract the side effects of a pain medication you’d given them equally casually; you’d want to stop and ask if it was really the right call to dig further into your backup reserves of blood-pressure-increasing-capacity, and she treats pushing through fatigue the same way.

Since arriving on this planet, she’s been doing that almost all the time. There’s at no point been a period when she had enough slack to eat and sleep as much as she needed to feel fully, 100% rested and recovered.

When she’s rested, there’s no mental resistance to physical exertion; if anything it’s actively appealing to climb random objects in her environment for no reason except because they’re there and she can and it’s satisfying to use her muscles.

 

Merrin could SUPER go for climbing a random tree right now, and she hasn’t felt that way since before her plane crashed.

Permalink Mark Unread

…After exactly sixty seconds she takes the belt off and gives it back. It’s not actually that hard. She doesn’t need to be bursting with physical energy to handle whatever their plan ends up being, and it seems plausible that Estha does need the [belt] boost more than she does.

Permalink Mark Unread

He puts it on.

"Does it now seem to you like it would not have been an anomaly that I was able to work alongside you for a full day, if I had then had a Belt of Constitution?  Think carefully, for it is a matter of some importance to both of us which of our memories are or plausibly could be real."

Esta does not command, 'And answer me correctly rather than telling me what you think I want to hear.'  Even though the cultural adaptation has run out, Esta does remember all the times that dath ilan culture sharply informed him to leave out additions like this from previous questions, on the grounds that they would sound incredibly strange.  Apparently in their context Merrin would default to truth anyways for some unknown reason, which she would also expect Estha to know about.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin's immediate thought was that she's definitely much less confused now! 

 

...She will, however, diligently try to think about it carefully anyway. 

"It's - less - of an anomaly?" she says. "Assuming that in your memories, you have the [belt] and I don't. ...There are cumulative effects from training, right - my endurance isn't just an innate trait, the training matters, but it's a specialization that made sense for me because I have innate aptitude and I enjoy it. Based on my memories, most people weren't interested in training for the kind of work I do, because the training wasn't enjoyable for them - and they wouldn't get as far anyway, plenty of people will do work they don't enjoy that much if their aptitude is such that they can make a lot of money for it - but if neither is true, it would make more sense for them to specialize in the areas where they did have higher innate aptitude, just like how I didn't specialize in math because I'm not very good at it and it's not fun to practice. But I can see how having a [belt] to increase [Constitution] could change the tradeoffs there quite a lot, such that in your memories, it made sense for both of us to specialize in the same kind of work." 

Merrin can translate all of those familiar Baseline concepts into the conlang, more or less, but the timer informed her that Estha's translation-effect will have worn off, and she's failing to find the term for a 'standard deviation' in the conlang vocabulary. She just won't bother to speculate aloud about how many standard deviations out from the median she was for dath ilan and how that might compare to the effectsize of the [belt], she decides, it's probably not the most important part.

(One thing notably missing from Merrin's musing is any acknowledgement of the concept that someone might end up doing a career for reasons other than personal choice.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

(In his memories, they are both "specialized" on a Wisdom-related occupation, though of course they are also both Cunning enough that they certainly could have been wizards had they so deigned.  If Esta was getting the spells he asked for, he'd ask for Detect Anxieties and see if she's still WIS 18.

The entire thing with her supposedly having very low abilityscores, at the same as rising to the top of an elite profession, is not something that Esta immediately understands.  Is it -- so that nobody ever demands more of her, at the same time that she excels?  Esta has never dreamed of having a lower stat in anything, ever.  It certainly doesn't look from the outside like her mental stats have lowered.

Would it have something to do with the Dark Tapestry inversion that made her pseudo-Chaotic-Good?  --Actually Esta is only now remembering for the first time in a while that this was even supposed to be true.  Her attitude toward making an oath was certainly Lawful.  An inverted Mariona should enjoy being praised.  Possibly that entire theory is wrong and gets superseded by the dreamworld theory.  But then if Mariona didn't have her desires inverted, why does she fondly remember an 'amusing amount of pain', and what was their relationship like in her memory--

Esta will worry about this later.  They have a Bag to retrieve.  His multiple incense-using spells suggest it can be done this cycle.  And if Asmodeus troubled Himself to indicate that, it maybe means they SHOULD go find the Bag, before it gets any more lost, or destroyed.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"I think we should resume that topic later and at greater leisure, which leisure we do not know possess."

"I have been musing upon how to use the tidal bore for transportation.  For now, my ideas all require spells I was not granted this cycle, which may indicate they are wrong.  I will speak them out loud in case you have [technological] substitutes, or simply other [Cunning] ideas."

"[Water Breathing] does what it sounds like and would last me the [day].  The spell [Stoneskin], could I be granted it, would do to protect me from simple impacts for 2 [hours].  It requires roughly [1.7 grams] of [diamond dust], and that I do not have even in my [Bag], unless you happen to have it on hand."

(Esta knew of [diamond], and his Shared Utopian says, that [diamond] was an extremely hard transparent crystal, superlatively rare and valuable.)

"Possibly with the combination of [Control Water] and [Air Walk] I could manage to ride the tidal bore.  I suspect [Word of Recall] will not take me back to [civilization], both because I suspect us to be on a different [Material plane], and also because I have never been told that it crosses interstellar distances.  But that spell might well do to extract me from the tidal bore in moments, should that clever plan fail; and otherwise, return us both to this base, at the project's end."

"[Detect Magic] might serve to substitute for [Locate Object], if I move my head about quickly and keep observing forward, and if little else here is magical."

"And now that I think on it... I could not grant you [Locate Object] this way, but with [Imbue With Spell Ability] I could grant you [Detect Magic]."

"Or maybe -- simplest of all, and with no other spells required -- I could wear your [armor], be carried along by the tidal bore, and use [Detect Magic] myself.  Yes!  Perhaps that is the intended solution..."  Except for the part where Merrin's armor is a Dark Tapestry artifact so strange that Detect Magic can't even see it.  "Assuming your [armor] has no noteworthy costs or side effects upon those who use it; nor requires their species to be exactly of your own kind, as might no longer be the case if one of us has changed."

(Magical armor is nearly always self-resizing, so far as Esta knows, nor does it typically require an education to use.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Extremely hard transparent crystals - well, in this case Merrin isn't sure it's something that even exists in dath ilan for her to recognize, but she does have some ideas of what those could be. Though she doesn't have 1.7 grams of any of the potential options lying around; her handheld drill that she's been using to stick climbing pitons into the walls of her cave is technically diamond-tipped, diamond being one of the first things coming to mind as 'crystal' + 'extremely 'hard', but that's "cheap industrial-grade diamond particles embedded in metal", she has no idea how to get it out of the metal and doesn't particularly want to destroy her very useful drill in the attempt, and it's only a fraction of a gram anyway. 

 

She then has to spend a moment boggling at Esta's idea to even figure out what he could possibly be confused about to suggest it. 

"...Lending you my armor isn't workable," she says after a moment. "It's custom-fitted to me." And also it took months of training before she could use it safely in conditions like the tidal bore, and a lot of the functions require being familiar with dath ilani computing tech and certainly being able to read Baseline, but the fact that it's sized to fit her and will absolutely not fit Estha instead is enough of a hard blocker by itself. 

As for the rest... "I don't see why anything on this planet other than what you arrived with would be magical, so that should be identifying. ....Depending on how far you can see with it and on whether it gets through water if you're not in the water, you might be able to walk back along the side of the river channel as the tide is dropping, and if you see it then I can do the swimming part to retrieve it. I think I can put together an air supply for you that supports underwater use, and flotation, and that might make it workable at all to ride the tidal current upstream, if you have a way to evacuate if it goes badly – the big wave happens fairly early in the incoming tide period, and it's the most powerful push upstream but there are a few smaller ones later and the current will be working for rather than against us until the tide turns and starts going out again." 

Permalink Mark Unread

(He notes the convenient claim that her armor only works for herself, despite the obvious long-term cost-inefficiency of an armor like that, but the time to test or challenge this is not now.)

"I don't have [Word of Recall].  But I suppose if there is some version of this plan that only requires that one spell, I could simply try it without that, and hope that my [deity] indeed foresaw and intended that the plan would just work... is this a thing you could arrange before sunrise, or maybe, arrange before [23 hours] pass since I completed my [prayers] and spoke to you?"

Permalink Mark Unread

See, this is why Merrin would be handling this better if she could TAKE NOTES and separately record the [spells] he says he has, already, versus could hypothetically have if he can request them from his [god].

She's just...repeatedly failing to successfully take actions about that, such as getting out of the sleeping bag where she is cuddling the man who is almost certainly not her Estha from dath ilan and who she's trying to be be suspicious and paranoid about, but who she apparently still really wants to be cuddling because she is JUST THAT TOUCH-STARVED.

 

"I might be able to make that equipment by dawn but I would be rushing. I can almost certainly do it before 23 hours pass since you completed your last [prayers]." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Hm."

"There's then an entire different branch of possibilities, surrounding spells I've been given that [conjure (calling)] an [outsider] that I can request by species or by name, if I know it.  I have specifically [Planar Inquiry], and a more powerful form, [Planar Binding], but not much in the way of [offerings] to pay either.  I could, I suppose, sacrifice a [Ring] to the [Planar Inquiry], which would be a ludicrous overpayment; and hope that the [outsider] who answers the [Planar Binding] will accept as a cause to do its work that my [deity] [godchose] that spell."

"There is probably a species of [outsider] that could locate my [Bag].  I do not know which one.  I could try asking that in the [Planar Inquiry], before proceeding to the [Planar Binding]..."

"Do you have anything valuable but that you do not need and cannot use?  I am -- not quite sure what the rules are, about that, but we could try..."

"I suppose another question I should ask is if you randomly happen to have a large amount of expensive [incense], in which case my 4th-circle [Divination]* spell might well simply tell me my bag's location."


(*)  A Utopian speech-marker indicates this thing's proper name unfortunately sounds the same as something else's general category.  A further rule of Axis states that any such word in a contract is automatically presumed to refer to its most common and general interpretation, unless this marker appears and further identifying info is then given.  This marker is even more necessary because no more than dath ilan would Axis ever in an eon form such a practice as capital versus lowercase letters; and hence, doesn't distinguish proper nouns by their capitalization.

Permalink Mark Unread

The odd thing here is that [incense], when Merrin introspects on the word-connotations, includes "natural substance that burns" and "smells nice while burning" and then "burned deliberately for that reason", as well as the part where it's a [spell] [material component]. 

Baseline does not have a specific term for a substance one burns on purpose because it smells nice, because in dath ilan you don't...do...that. However, Merrin has totally been doing that! Because she's been really bored and short on sensory pleasures and this planet has rather little to offer in the way of tasty food (that she can eat more than a small number of grams per day of without regretting it terribly) but it sure does have a wide array of plant and animal substances that smell pleasant and interesting when burned, and Merrin initially worried a lot more about exposing her lungs to weird toxins but after a while of not noticing any immediate symptoms, she started to care less about the probability that it would give her lung cancer in ten years. Since she did not expect to survive ten years either way. 

 

"...I have local substances that might be like [incense]?" she says. "I - have no idea if they count as expensive. They were very labor-intensive, and I guess in dath ilan my time was pretty valuable, but here they don't have a market value because I was the only person on this planet until you arrived, and I think even if you had money to buy them from me for a large amount, that's still not the same as them having a market value which counts as very expensive?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"I have no idea what the rules are to that level of detail."

"I propose... to buy your incense from you for the monetary amount demanded by the spell, payable from my [account] back in civilization by true and enforceable contract... and hope that's how it works..."

"It might, possibly, work better if you calculated the cost of your labor, an ordinary merchant's markup, and the corresponding price of the incense, and charged me that?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Mrrrrggg this is exactly the kind of thing where:  

- Merrin really hates having to interact in too much detail with her time being worth money. 

- Merrin always feel really embarrassed about hating it because, like, this is an extremely basic skill? And yet plenty of literal six-year-olds are better at it than her? 

- Her Estha knows that she hates it would absolutely be teasing her about that right now and so it's kind of weird and uncanny that other-Estha is not doing that. 

 

Buuuut she's a grown adult and she can handle the existence of money and the fact that it's completely normal to exchange it for goods and services. 

 

"Okay. I think in that case I need some way of doing currency conversion between the monetary units I know from dath ilan and what your world would use..." 

Permalink Mark Unread

Timecard:  "Followed by several minutes of exciting Abadaran pornography."

Permalink Mark Unread

The economics of Merrin's dreamworld make absolutely no fucking sense.  Hopefully at some future point Esta will have enough other bonuses to stack with that one that he can snap Mariona out of her dream.

Esta has been trying not to give away that his memories are of a completely different world, he was trying to maintain in Merrin's mind the possibility that they were from a secret department of {dath ilan}'s government; but he does not think he really got through the economics conversation while maintaining that possibility as plausible in her mind.

Trying to anchor on the price of bread, for example, was apparently a mistake.  He didn't ask outright what peasants eat in Dark Tapestry dreamworlds if it is not bread.  But it is, evidently, not bread.  In retrospect that should have been a conversation to have with Cultural Adaptation running.

Permalink Mark Unread

...And finally, Esta is ready to buy 25gp of incense from Merrin, to try on an Augury, as a test; before he buys another 25gp of incense, on which to try his Divination, which would be the actually key spell that might tell them roughly how far along the sea-channel to walk, to find Esta's bag.

Actually doing all that would require them finalizing a plan they could do the Augury about.  Or for that matter, physically carrying out the purchase and exchange would require them both getting out of the sleeping roll.  At what point exactly are they ready to start the day?

Permalink Mark Unread

...It's almost 09:00 and it's still really cold in the shelter and won't even start getting warmer at all for at least another four hours, but yeah they should get up at this point. 

Merrin will just put her fully-charged suit on and do things while wearing it. (She did not break even on battery power yesterday, which feels mildly oof just on habit, but she still has plenty banked, her suit is fully charged and the main battery has over 1000 Wh left and should fill up some more over the sunlit hours.)

Can Estha make do if he fixes his armor? It seems wasteful to start the clock on either [Endure Elements] or [Planetary Adaptation] now, given that this is not even the dangerous-extremes part of the day, but she doesn't really have warm clothes to lend him, distinct from emergency blankets that are a bit awkward to wear while moving around. 

 

(Merrin is...not sure what she believes about this Estha and his life history. It's mostly quicksand in her head. He clearly is Estha, somehow, and it's equally clear that they have different intuitions about how Reality works on a very basic level and she has trouble imagining what cognitohazardous mind control process could take the dath ilan out of someone that thoroughly. Which doesn't mean it's impossible, of course, just that - whatever, she doesn't understand the metaphysics of this entire stupid ridiculous situation and she probably isn't ever going to, those are big questions for someone smarter than her. For now, Merrin is just increasingly finding that it doesn't feel like it helps at all to make predictions on the basis that this is Estha-from-dath-ilan-with-brain-damage.

She also doesn't really feel like it helps either to imagine him as maybe being a shapeshifting alien trying to imitate her memories of Estha, or an immortal spirit with access to bits and pieces of the real Estha's memories. Those both feel like they would produce, like, more similar memories and less...intrinsic himness? And there's a lot of Estha-ness!

Shrug. Merrin does not understand these things. Maybe at some eventual point she'll have time to think uninterrupted and Laeirthe can make something out of it that she can't see on her own.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta will consider it worthwhile in the long run to repair his undersuit as well as his armor, by thread and needle if he cannot obtain another Make Whole to repair the minor magical aspects of his clothing as well.

Meanwhile, he will repair his armor -- with Greater Make Whole it is but a single [moment], should Merrin wish to watch that, and learn again that magic is real -- and wear it over his bare flesh, to abrade it some little bit, and tolerate the cold by willpower.  (If he dared think that this little discomfort should count as suffering, any of his superiors in Cheliax would be happy to show him what actual suffering was, should they hear of the thought.  Nobody has done this to Esta in some years, but that is because he is past having punishment-earning thoughts like that.)

The two of them do have the option of starting the clock now on Endure Elements and Planetary Adaptation, and hoping that Esta gets those spells again on his next [day], along with Share Language and Tongues and other such needfuls (Esta does not mention Cultural Adaptation).  Esta would in any case cast those spells come sunrise, or come nine hours after dawn, if his [god] reached back again; and would then refresh them later in the [day], and then get more spells on the next cycle, and ideally so on indefinitely.  If everything works the way it should; which is why Esta was checking their ability to survive the heat, if he doesn't get more spells this planetary day.

Permalink Mark Unread

(Merrin is actually kind of considering it her job to fix Estha's other clothing that, after all, she was the one who cut up, if it's not doable instantly with magic; she has a sewing kit and she's even had a lot of recent practice.) 

 

If Esta avoids visibly showing any sign of discomfort, Merrin isn't going to be worried about him! Her power armor is comfortable - and in fact not actually meant to be worn with a lot of clothing underneath - and keeps her warm, so why wouldn't LITERALLY MAGIC armor do at least as well as that? She definitely doesn't need [Endure Elements] yet -  so if they want to stay in sync on that, and he's comfortable enough for now, it probably makes sense to wait?



...She'll go get out the box where she keeps her effortfully extracted sample of things-that-burn-and-smell-nice (also a project, woven out of seaweed, Merrin miiiight have had too much time on her hands for the last while). The form factors are a mix of "stiff wax", "gelatinous stuff", "oil", "weirdly flammable papery leaf bits", and "plant bits in oil." She's mostly been keeping them in repurposed medical containers, though a few of the firm wax blocks are instead wrapped in more wax-paper-seaweed; it turns out you can free up a lot of containers if you dubiously combine a bunch of oral drugs into the same container and trust yourself to visually distinguish them. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

...Merrin has no idea what form factor the [incense] needs to be in to use it for the [spell]? But this is the selection she's got, along with her estimates of the cost in "GP" per gram of each kind. 

Permalink Mark Unread

The form factor doesn't matter.  Esta has never been told about any fundamental constraint on [incense] other than that it has to cost three-quarters of an average urban laborer's annual salary, you have to set it on fire, and it needs to smell good when you do.

And you know what, Esta really does not want to be stuck on this planet forever, and Esta is worried that his godchosen spells are meant to communicate, "Go solve this problem right now before your Holding Bag gets destroyed by the next tidal bore going past it."

Augury has a casting time of 1 minute.  What Esta proposes, here, is that he buy all her incenses off Merrin via bona fide draft on his bank; that they put all of these things into a form factor where they will burn slowly enough that each one would burn for over 2 minutes; and they try lighting all of them and see if the Augury takes hold on any of them.  Hopefully Esta will have enough of a feel for the magic to tell which incense if any the spell is hooking into, and they can extinguish any others, but that part is not as important as getting off the planet.

Also, now that Esta thinks about it, the natural thing to ask for an Augury about, would be the plan of then trying to ask a Divination about roughly how far away the Holding Bag is, and then, trying to ride the tidal bore there; or, if the Divination fails to give a sufficiently precise answer, riding the tidal bore while casting Detect Magic to try to watch for the Holding Bag.  Which means that they should only cast the Augury half an hour before the tidal bore, because that's how far Augury sees into the future on Golarion.  Esta does not know how far Augury looks ahead on a planet of intact prophecy, it should not be any less, but he does not know it to be any more.

If the Augury says that's actually a terrible idea, or if the incense doesn't work, the backup plan is asking a Planar Inquiry about what sort of [outsider] Esta should call with his Planar Binding to find or retrieve the Bag.  To which end it'd be helpful if Merrin has anything that costs around 25 times one year's worth of unskilled labor, but that she has no important use for on this planet.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's fine with Merrin to set all of her incenses on fire at once, though in that case she prooobably wants them to do it outside the cave shelter, that sounds simpler and like it requires less math than running the calculation on whether that many small fires at once would be an oxygen-consumption problem in the mostly-sealed space. 

 

...Merrin does not have literally any items that she has no important use for on this planet??? She feels like it would indicate some seriously poor planning on the part of the Exception Handling equipment-engineering team if there were objects she had weight allotment for that weren't re-purposable enough to be very useful here. She previously had some electronics that didn't do anything here, like the portable GPS unit, but she dismantled them for replacement parts on the armor months ago.

...If the cost benchmark is 25 times one year's worth of unskilled labor in GP based on unskilled labor-productivity in the terms Estha described to her when they were figuring out the "25 GP" conversion - as opposed to the dath ilan equivalent in labor-hours - then probably Merrin can identify something worth that much where going without it is unlikely to kill them in the next planetary month? Which could easily be worth it for a chance of getting off this planet before then. The medical diagnostic equipment is at the top of her list; there's definitely a mental flinch about giving it up, since she literally just used it after rescuing Estha, but now that he's recovered and can use healing magic - and Merrin knows that he's unusually tough and resilient to injury - it seems less likely that a blood-test analysis unit or handheld diagnostic ultrasound machine are going to be absolutely critical to their survival? 

Permalink Mark Unread

It does not sound needful if Esta continues getting spells; and if he does not, they are likely to die here regardless.

Separately, if Merrin kept the broken pieces that she dismantled other objects to replace, Esta may be able to Mend those on a later [day].


Well, Esta thinks they have a plan, here.  And if he understood that plan correctly, it means getting up and engaging in some mild hurry as the two of them -- himself under Merrin's direction, for this part -- try to prep tidal-bore-riding equipment for Esta, before the tidal bore arrives.

Remember that this version of Estha remembers working with his version of Merrin on common emergencies, though with Merrin taking direction from him, or both of them taking direction from other commanders.  Also he has his Belt, and will not tire as quickly as the Estha she remembers.

Permalink Mark Unread

They are, indeed, going to be rushed! But Merrin has, in fact, trained pretty heavily on scenarios where she needs to quickly coordinate with and delegate to random untrained bystanders. Delegating to Estha is an extra challenge level both because he's unfamiliar with things that even entirely "untrained" dath ilanis would know, and also Merrin is speaking a foreign language - which she knows fluently, because magic, but which lacks vocabulary terms for most of her equipment pieces or the manipulations she wants to do to them - but it does become apparent to her quickly that Estha is not actually untrained by the relevant metric.

She trains him on a reasonably simple task – sacrificing a big square of extra-tough plastic sheeting to cut into long narrow rectangles, applying strips of waterproof adhesive carefully along one edge, and sealing them up lengthwise to form tubes. Which can then be inflated with air - she has a pump for that - and bent into arbitrary shapes, held together with more adhesive, to form a suit that combines the flotation function with some padding against collisions over vital body parts (and also over the oxygen tank she's strapping to his back, which would ideally not be subject to any intense impacts. 

 

It would be a lot easier to do this if she could temporarily borrow parts of her own armor for it, but Merrin wants and needs the armor intact and on her; she's not directly useful for the search, since he does not in fact currently have the [spell] that would let her also [Detect Magic], but if he does end up knocked unconscious in the water again, she needs to be able to reach him fast, and that means swimming along with him.

So, annoyingly, she cannot just give him the helmet of her armor, and she doesn't really have anything else that can in less than three hours be turned into a sealed protective helmet. He's going to be getting an inflatable-tube hat for head injury prevention, attached to the cervical collar which is very conveniently already inflatable and conveniently shaped to fit over his neck, where she can use it to secure a scuba-style mouthpiece to breathe through. Even if it gets knocked out of his mouth at some point, it should still be right there and easy to find even without needing his hands. 

 

...On reflection, Merrin is going to give him two additional components: one of her waterproof ultra-bright battery-powered flashlights, for her to follow, and - just in case - the radio beacon she was previously using. It's not that large or heavy, and it's designed to keep working even after being dropped from a helicopter midflight, it's not fragile. 

And then there's still some plastic left, so she cuts that up larger and makes...awkward balloons, more or less...to glue on the exterior of the fitted-plastic-tubing as additional impact protection. A hard impact will almost certainly pop them, but if anything that's part of the point, they'll burst and absorb the impact forces in the process. 

 

The resulting gear is one of the jankiest things Merrin has designed in her entire life, and outright embarrassing, but it requires no particular skill and minimal practice to "use" – given how it does not really do anything except be very buoyant and padded, radiate visible light and radio waves, and dispense oxygen from a mouthpiece when suction is applied to it (he should practice that part). And the plastic and waterproof adhesive are both the very best material that Exception Handling materials scientists could design over many years of iteration. It's a lot less fragile than it looks. 

(She did have to steal the plastic sheeting from an existing use – covering her solar panel installation for nighttime protection from wind and rain – but she had been expecting to at some point replace that with a local-materials woven strapwrack and waterproof-dried-sailweed hood, and the afternoon is long enough that even a very long and busy morning should still leave her with plenty of time for building that.) 

 

With twenty minutes left to go, they'll want to trek over in the predawn twilight, Esta wearing his suit - one of the functionalities Merrin did not super build into its design was the ability to take it on or off quickly or without her help - carrying her local-material canopy shelter as a windblock, the various incenses, a whole pile of shells to use as pots to burn them in, the fire-lighting kit, the diagnostic equipment she's prepared to sacrifice as a Valuable Item, etc etc... 

Permalink Mark Unread

This is not the best plan Esta has ever been part of.  Part of him is questioning its Wisdom.

But only conditional on it not being Asmodeus's intended plan conveyed via His godchosen spells, of course.  If it is Asmodeus's plan then it is certainly the wisest plan that could possibly be devised given Asmodeus's information, which ought to be much better information than Esta is accustomed to, given that prophecy would still function on this planet.

Esta trudges on as Merrin directs.  It does not injure his pride, for this is Asmodeus's will.  Most of Esta's pride is only there in the first place because Esta believes he has pride because that makes him a good Asmodean.

It's freezing fucking cold, but suffering is good for you.

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin ALSO has a lot of internal doubts about this plan! 

 

...It's probably not stupider-on-priors than the things she's done repeatedly, like riding the tidal current far out to sea when her ride back isn't for more than 24 hours? Or, come to think of it, jumping into the flaming tidal bore to rescue Estha. 

The improvised flotation-protective-suit looks INCREDIBLY silly but this is, like, entirely Merrin's fault, as the designer, and she doesn't quite feel on teasing terms yet with this Estha who is almost but not quite the same as the man she remembers. 

 

She sets up the windblock and lays out all the flammable substances to light on Estha's cue, with less than five minutes to spare before the moment of dawn. 

 

...The timing is going to be very tight, if in fact Estha does not get the notification to [pray] for [spells] and they proceed with the information-gathering spells. The interval between sunrise and the early end of the projected tidal bore arrival window is exactly 23 minutes. 

Permalink Mark Unread

(Right now is the daily low, -19° C, and the improvised-bubble-wrap flotation suit incidentally provides nonzero insulation but it's not, like, meant for that. Merrin is definitely fretting a bit that Estha might be cold, if his magical armor isn't as good at climate control as her top-Exception-Handling-tech armor. He's going to be using the Planetary Adaptation spell if they go ahead with Plan Jump In The Tidal Bore, right, that water is really cold and would be incapacitating for an unprotected human within minutes - for a an unprotected human who did not have extensive cold-water-swimming training, at least, which Merrin does have, not that she's at any point taken advantage of it because swimming unprotected in the ocean here is stupid for so many reasons...) 

Permalink Mark Unread

There's some forking paths, in this plan, depending on as many as several pieces of information and decision points; for example, will the Augury and Divination spells run off any of Merrin's incense.

But the information they want from the Augury is what happens if Esta tries jumping into the tidal bore like this, irrespective of how the other parts of the plan fork.

...hopefully that is a kind of question you can still ask Augury when it talks to prophecy rather than your god, per se?  But then if unshattered-prophecy Augury only ever told you about things you would in fact end up doing, how would that even have been useful, in the age when prophecy did still work...


The moment comes, not quite of sunrise, but of when Esta will within a minute-and-a-little (down to the unit-conversion precision) find out if he needs to pray for spells; a moment when the tidal bore's arrival is also within the 30-minute range of (Golarion) prophecy.

Light up that incense, let's see if the Augury works.

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

And Esta attempts to cast a 6th-circle-caster-level Augury, in a world of unshattered prophecy.


...does the incense work?

Permalink Mark Unread

...okay.  Let's explain how all this actually functions.

Permalink Mark Unread

Valmallos is the primordial inevitable charged with making sure that magic is difficult to cast, and requires rare and expensive spell components in order to do anything unusually cool.

Its clerics invent needlessly complicated versions of spells, try to eliminate the older simpler versions, and promulgate the public belief that if you know a simpler spellform this is a valuable secret to share only with trusted apprentices.

Valmallos locally enforces and embodies, within Creation, the transuniversal Law that says you can't have nice things except with great pains and costs.

Permalink Mark Unread

...there's a transuniversal Law like that?

Permalink Mark Unread

Er... yes?  Like... after you've described the festivals in Omelas, the wealth and the parties and the fun and the singing and of course the sex, none of that can really be real unless there's a child at the center living in filth and misery?

In worlds entirely without magic, the role of Valmallos or the Omelas-child must instead be played by such nonmagical forces as the Jones Act, to make shipping goods between different ports of your own country wantonly expensive.  Or if housing is becoming too cheap, by passing regulations making it much harder to build houses, until people are again living in squalor and misery.  Or by medical guilds passing bylaws that restrict the number of residencies and doctors, so not everyone can get medical care, if people were getting too healthy before then.

But in the economagical universe of Creation, where people can just cast spells without needing a whole economy behind them to enable their feats, laws like that would not be enough to prevent people from being happy and rich.

Valmallos makes sure that doesn't happen.

Permalink Mark Unread

Dath ilan has no radioactive shit of a clue what Creation is talking about here.  Why would anyone pass laws like that?  Dath ilan doesn't.

Permalink Mark Unread

Other places are wiser, then.

Because perhaps that is why dath ilan isn't real.

Permalink Mark Unread

Anyway.

The way "this spell needs 25gp of incense" actually works is that when a new planet acquires enough of a population to start popping clerics, Valmallos visits the place, looks it over, and figures out some substances that ought to be difficult to mine, harvest, or compound and refine.

These then get defined as [incense].

Gods then grant their clerics, on that planet, spells designed to require that sort of material being simultaneously destroyed nearby.

Permalink Mark Unread

This exoplanet hasn't even been named.  It has two people on it.  No births have ever taken place here.  No gods have chosen new clerics here.

Valmallos has never visited this planet.

Permalink Mark Unread

And Asmodeus is granting His incredibly lost squirrel spells that are designed to make use of incense from its origin planet, should His pet squirrel happen to have that on hand, because Asmodeus's Day 1 loadout does not particularly assume that His incredibly lost squirrel will manufacture new incense over the course of its first day, even leaving aside how Asmodeus would need to nag Valmallos into visiting that planet in order to define anything local as 'incense' there.

Permalink Mark Unread

Tl;dr:  This Augury spell is incredibly not going to fucking work.  It has nothing it was designed to hook onto as incense.  It fails, not the sort of failure where the spell doesn't provide information, but where the spell falls apart and is miscast immediately.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"...you can extinguish the incense, Merrin.  The spell isn't accepting any of it."

Divination presumably won't work either, not until after Esta has found the Bag of Holding and the small amount of incense there.  They cannot use Divination to get a rough sense of the Bag's distance, nor how long and far to ride the tidal bore.


Now to observe and branch on the next major fork in the plan.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Merrin is not going to try to reason through all the implications of that for their future plans - such as "should Estha in fact jump in a tidal bore" - and how it impacts their eventual survival chances right now, when she's still lacking a lot of the relevant context and Estha is not super interruptible. They planned this all out - in a way more rushed way than she prefers to do her advance planning, but they did plan it - and now it's time to execute, and afterward is the time to discuss and make updates. 

 

Merrin's sunrise-time calculations are pretty fucking accurate, after this many data points. The sun is peeking above the ocean horizon, the first direct light of the morning shining long and low across the cracked limestone plateau, and annnnny mooooment now should be her best guess of Estha's best guess of how the "dawn" timing works, when the sun is about halfway above the horizon and halfway below. 

 

...If Estha does get a notification from his [god] about it being time to [pray] then they're going to miss the tidal bore, since he'll be uninterruptible for an hour. Merrin is kind of hoping for it! It would mean all her frantic preparations were unnecessary, but also it would mean that Estha is NOT ABOUT TO JUMP IN A TIDAL BORE in her extremely janked-together protective gear. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Can he feel the presence of his god?

Permalink Mark Unread

Valmallos has not visited this planet.  Asmodeus would need to try hard in order to see this planet.  Asmodeus does not even know that it is currently sunrise, there.

The reason why the Compact of Creation has a clause about granting clerics spells at similar times is so that different gods don't fight over who gets to go second, and grant their squirrels spells optimized against the other gods' squirrels' spells.

This planet is unpopulated.  It doesn't need a separate compacted schedule.  His incredibly lost squirrel remains on its home planet's schedule.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I can't feel my [deity]."

In a sense it's good news, because if Esta wasn't even going to get the chance to use his other spells before they refreshed, it would mean either that Esta had already failed at comprehending Asmodeus's plan, or that Asmodeus was not planning all this at all.  The Augury could, indeed, have been put there expressly so that Esta would not need to waste his Divination to learn what wasn't incense.

In a sense it's bad news, because it means that Esta having to jump into a tidal bore with no Word of Recall remains a live possibility.

And also, it's bad news because it isn't certain that Esta gets new spells at all, nine hours from now, when it will be one full day since last he prayed.  Maybe Asmodeus could only afford to reach out to Esta once, and that was it, and he's on his own unless he can reach the Bag with the Plane Shift scroll and the tuning forks.

And now the plan goes down path 2.2, where path 1 was the Augury working and path 2.1 was Esta ending up praying for spells.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin has been asked to avert her eyes, in the scenario where Estha did end up casting the additional information-gathering spells. The grounds for his argument were that, while he thought it was unlikely that seeing the summoned entity would harm her sanity, he wasn't sure of that and preferred to play it carefully. 

Logical enough. Laeirthe is, of course, SO SUSPICIOUS, but also fully on board with Merrin's logic that 1) Estha's concern might be genuine, and 2) agreeing not to look and then sneaking a peek anyway would make it spectacularly obvious that she didn't trust him, and would result in him trusting her less, and they don't need that. 

 

She watches the rest of the sunrise instead, and stares into the distance to try to catch a glimpse of the ocean. It's still visible only as a distant strip of purple, dark under the barely-risen sun. 

Permalink Mark Unread

And Esta begins the 10-minute casting of Planar Inquiry.

He cannot, by this method, call anything that is stronger than he is -- defined not by who beats who in a fight, or who has more vitality, but by something stranger and hard to measure.  Esta would call it strength of life, if outsiders were not dead.

Esta is calling forth an Osyluth, called also Bone Devil, of which it is said that they are hungry for lore of Hell beyond their own stations, and will bargain for it with mortals.  Esta doesn't actually have that, and is hoping he can pay with Dark Tapestry transformed items according to at least their price in Merrin's dreamworld.  (He did also try asking Merrin for something unimportant but that wouldn't exist in Golarion, so he can see if the Osyluth maybe values that sufficiently; before Esta resorts to trying to pay with Merrin's valuable device, and then at last resort one of his own two Rings.)

He intends to ask the Osyluth what manner of devil he should call up, no stronger than a Planar Binding can call, to search water or locate a thing lost -- if the Osyluth cannot locate the item itself, perhaps by asking another in Hell.

Permalink Mark Unread

...

Permalink Mark Unread

...

Permalink Mark Unread

Yyyeeeahhh,

if Hell has never connected to this place before,

and it's so far from any previously inhabited and connected planet that even Asmodeus has trouble seeing you,

and also it is kinda out of the way on a certain planar-interconnection level,

a little 10HD Osyluth is not going to make it to you in person on the strength of a 3rd-circle spell.

Permalink Mark Unread

"The first [spell], the 3rd-[circle] [Planar Inquiry], failed," Esta says, not allowing his voice to get any heavier or more solemn.  He is still Mariona's boss, whether she remembers it or not.  "I will essay the [Planar Binding], which for me is [6th]-circle."

12 minutes, perhaps, now remain until the tidal bore's arrival.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Understood," Merrin says, without looking around, and continues not-looking. There are distant lines of white visible on the purple strip of sea, now, though still no sign of the vibration and roar of an incoming bore. 

 

...In her head, she's incrementing down the odds that the second spell works, and from there the likely update that nothing else will work either if it requires...interacting with places other than this planet?? Is that the implication? She has no idea of the mechanism by which the food-production spell or the healing work, whether they're...in some sense self-contained, a package transferred once from [god] to [cleric], or whether they do still draw on something somewhere else. 

It's not a certain update, of course. She understands the implication that [6th]-circle is a lot more powerful than [3rd]-circle, and maybe it just takes more power to interact with other places that are very very far? 

But if she had a prediction market up, the numbers would be updating downward. 

(Merrin was kiiiinda disappointed to realize that having two additional imaginary people in her head did not actually let her run imaginary prediction markets and remedy their lack in her life. Kalorm flat-out refuses to engage with the premise, mostly, and Laeirthe always complains that he has literally the exact same information as her so his bets would only very rarely be different than hers alone. Also, updating the market probabilities from bets is way too much math to do mentally.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

...

Permalink Mark Unread

...

Permalink Mark Unread

...he can hear the tidal bore approaching.

Permalink Mark Unread

This really ought to work, literally damn it.

He's trying to call a Sarglagon, this time.  Drowning devil.  Apt for water maneuvers, since he does not know the species of any devil that could simply divine the Bag's location.  Esta does not expect it to attack him over an Asmodeus-chosen spell even if it refuses aid, but should the devil attack, Esta also expects to win.  It ought to be troublesome to a 4th-circle, not to him.

Permalink Mark Unread

This ought to work, yes, unless Yog-Sothoth yeeted you somewhere really far out of the way.

Permalink Mark Unread

...

Permalink Mark Unread

Welp.  Guess what 'exactly that' it looks like Yog-Sothoth did.

Permalink Mark Unread

That was the outcome Asmodeus mostly predicted would happen.  But (1) there was still a fair prior probability it would work; (2) adapting default spell loadouts around that kind of detailed outcome prediction would cost intervention budget; and (3) a relatively less stupid lost squirrel sometimes works out that it is being commanded to report back to Hell and then figures out some way to do that even if the first try doesn't work.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"My [Planar Binding] has also failed."

"We are probably somewhere very far out of the way."

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh. 

 

Merrin turns around and looks at him. 

"...How surprised and confused are you?" she says, after a moment. "Either that it didn't work, or that your [god] would have given it to you even when it wouldn't work? I don't...think I know how big a piece of - new bad information - this is...?" That was a clumsily and frankly kind of silly-sounding way to say the thing she means, but Merrin isn't feeling that inclined to spend five times as many words in her sentences trying to express what she could say in Baseline in a few words. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Surprised.  Not confused."

 

The incoming tidal bore is very loud, now.

Esta has no Divination to locate the Bag.

No Augury to say this will be safe.

No Inquiry, nor Inquiry-identified devil, to locate the Bag.

No drowning devil to perhaps help him search, or help him stay afloat.


"I think this outcome indicates that my [spell loadout] reflects my [deity] not being able to see me or hear me very well, rather than it being a [godchosen] [spell loadout] that was meant to guide me in detail along my way.  Either that, or I wholly failed to infer what was intended."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...Which mostly amounts to the same thing, that we have no special information indicating that jumping in the tidal bore this morning will maximize the chances of finding the Bag, and on priors it's not an incredibly good idea," Merrin says, after a moment. "And we should - call it off, and figure out more safety measures if we're going to try this strategy at all?" 

Merrin is not SURE that her reasoning here is truth-tracking, as opposed to distorted by the fact that she's really stressed about Estha deliberately subjecting himself to the oceanic forces that nearly drowned him less than a planetary day ago. 

(Rescuing him from that was admittedly very cool and shiny – that is, after the fact, when everything was fine. Merrin is REALLY NOT AT ALL tempted to nudge him to do more dangerous things in order to have another medical emergency to treat. That would be Fucked Up.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"If we are not being advised to this course by a [deity] then it is, in fact, stupid."

"Mission aborted.  We try this again -- not the next [day].  The [day] after, when there will be another tidal bore, and for that one I can have [Word of Recall] and maybe even [Locate Object] too; or else perhaps [Imbue with Spell Ability], to give you [Detect Magic] -- if I can successfully convey any requests to my [deity] at all."

"Otherwise... I suppose we climb down into this canyon and spend many days searching it, by sight and [Detect Magic] for as long as I have it."

Permalink Mark Unread

“Okay. ...The next tidal bore will be in the dark, it's due half an hour after sunset tonight, but I can rig you up with more lighting by then." 

And she'll put away all the unburnt incense back in its containers (who knows, it might somehow manage to be useful for something, and Merrin certainly isn't throwing it away after the enormous amount of work she put into making it, even if that was half because she had literally nothing else to do with herself during the endless afternoons she was stuck indoors. They can dismantle the windbreak-canopy shelter and haul everything back 600 meters over the horrible terrain and head back into the shelter. 

...Which is warming up fairly quickly, actually, because Merrin's routine was disrupted and she didn't put the reflective tarp back the instant the sun was up, and so by the time they get back the sun has been up for nearly an hour and, even angled low in the sky, is gently warming the dark-pigmented, solar-radiation-absorbing seaweed weave and sailweed-leaf covering. (The shelter side of the sinkhole faces the sea and it gets morning direct sunlight and is in shadow in the afternoons, which is a bit of luck, the afternoons are when Merrin most needs to minimize heat input to the space.)

It's already above freezing inside! ...Like 0.5° C above freezing, but still. Merrin had been fretting a bit about whether Estha's weird-magic-fantasy-world armor would fail to protect him from frostbite in his extremities, even if it kept his core warm, and he probably shouldn't use his climate-protection [spells] yet when he doesn't yet know if he'll ever be able to get more. 

 

On arrival, Merrin keeps her own armor on for warmth but unseals the helmet so she can EAT MORE OF THE FOOD IT'S SO DELICIOUS. And then, oh right, she should probably do the partial-dismantling required to help Estha get out of his improvised flotation-""armor"", which is inconvenient to move around in. 

And then they...have a lot of time to plan. Like eight more hours of it until the point when Estha might or might not be able to [pray] for more [spells]. 

Permalink Mark Unread

If they're neither searching the riverbed until lower tide, nor yet do they know whether Esta gets spells, then Esta does not see all that much to plan?  Though he will obviously participate in planning sessions, if Merrin's greater knowledge of the exoplanet leads her to see more opportunity for planning.

Esta's own instinctive use for cognition will be to ponder the implications of recent events, and what they say about how much overdetermining-god-optimization Y̷̼̚o̷̪͒g̵͚̋-̴͕͠S̸͚̀ǫ̵͆t̸̥̾h̵̺̋o̴̜̕t̴͚͝ĥ̵̟ has exerted over their setup, and to what visible or guessable ends.  Esta also remembers the advice of Cultural Adaptation to occasionally show what he is feeling on his face, else Merrin find it suspicious otherwise.

He looks quite grim.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is not grimmer than usual! Merrin has had six planetary months to absorb her situation, and her situation is not, in fact, worse than it was before, if it turns out Estha getting [spells] from his [god] was a one-time thing. They'll die eventually, probably, but with each other for company, which from Merrin's perspective right now is almost certainly better than not that. And their chances are better even if Estha never gets another [spell], she thinks? He's got his [belt] so he can keep up with her; they can do construction projects and exploration projects that would be too difficult or dangerous solo! Feeding both of them on local biomass will be an enormous hassle but not, necessarily, intractable... 

And maybe he will get [spells] again! It seems odd to Merrin that his [god] would be able to transmit those exactly once? Like, low confidence because she has no idea how anything works, but what would even be the mechanism of that?

She is going to do her very best to eat all of the food that Estha made for her, since she was warned it won't be good anymore after 24 hours (and, given that it's magic, she's dubious that attempting to frantically freeze-dry or pickle it before that interval elapses will even help.) A Merrin full of (relatively) delicious calories is a Merrin in a much better mood than her average over recent months.

 

She should probably, at some point, do her own pondering on the larger situation – it's such a weird situation! – but she has no idea how to get any further on making inferences unless she jumps headfirst into the Narrative Trope Logic and she is not quite resigned to that yet. 

Productive logistics planning she can make progress on now: starting to map out plans for riverbed-searching, under various assumptions including "no more [spells] ever, just Detect Magic", in which case they need to time it for both low tide and times of day when being outside without shelter or climate-protection won't be immediately lethal. 

(Also, unless Estha interrupts her to object, she'll get out her shelter repair kit - which includes sewing materials as well as a lot of other materials - and start fixing his clothes; it hasn't occurred to her that this would be a good use of a [spell] even if he gets more, since she wasn't actually aware they had any magical features, and in any case she can at least get him something repaired enough to be wearable-for-warm in less than eight hours.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Sewing will not interfere with a later repair spell; if she wishes to attempt that much work in the face of its probable futility, she is welcome to do that.  (Esta has never before seen Mariona do it; but he is aware that many other women have been so made as to find spinning, sewing, and tailoring more relaxing than simply doing nothing.)

He weighs for a long time, and carefully, whether to say what he is about to say.

"There's a proverb that goes, to understand the meaning of a [divine intervention], look at the counterfactual for what would have happened otherwise."

"I have now seen enough of this planet to appreciate more viscerally that most places here are not places where a tidal bore is about to hit, right next to Merrin, who is wearing her armor and knows how to deal with tidal bores, and can take me back to her safe base to recover.  The [Outer God] that sent us here, sent me to a moment where I would lose my [Holding Bag], but not ultimately die.  It accomplished this by sending me here four months after you arrived, with time to build your base.  It would not even have been as much of a guess as I am accustomed to it being for our own [god]; because in this place, unlike the planet I remember, it should be possible for an [Outer God] to directly observe the future."

"If my Bag would have sufficed to get us out of here, quickly, then the [Outer God] wanted for that to not happen.  Straightforward, in a way.  We understand little of the different motivations of the different [Outer Gods] that are not simply and directly lethal to us; but from our own perspective, Their interventions sometimes seem to play out like bizarre games, if they are not simply and entirely inscrutable.  If the [Outer God] can want to play a game with us, It can want that game to not end in its first [day]."

"And if that is what It wants, and It can see the future and we can't, It is liable to get what It wants and not what we want."

Permalink Mark Unread

(It's not, actually, the case that Merrin is more easily bored than Mariona and more disturbed by boredom as an underlying personality trait. But she sure has grown up in and been shaped by a society where boredom is a major threat to most people's wellbeing, and where enough slack exists to take this seriously rather than relegating it to the bottom of a list of more critical priorities. Merrin thinks of herself as hating boredom, and she has undertaken SO many unnecessarily laborious arts-and-crafts projects over the last six planetary months. She's trained to repair her own essential equipment under time pressure, and in comparison this task is easy and soothing.) 

 

...She follows Estha's logic. It gives her the slippery helpless feeling of this being a topic that she isn't nearly smart enough to reason about, but she does follow it. 

"- My arrival here also felt...carefully set up, like that," she says. "I started out at the bottom of the river valley, with the tide going out. It was possibl, but just barely possible, for me to recognize the danger and salvage all of my gear before the tidal bore hit. It's - at a lot of steps it felt like this whole scenario was...somehow made for me, specifically? Not just a dath ilani, or even just an Exception Handling specialist, but me. ...Except for the part where I'm a medtech and I had a bunch of medical equipment and there was no one else I could treat, but - then you arrived." 

And she had wondered, long before he arrived, whether someone was going to show up for her to rescue! Not because this would make any logical sense - it continues not to make any logical sense! - but because it felt like a possible plot beat

Merrin still doesn't trust that whole line of reasoning, at all. But she can't deny that it's made at least one prediction that turned out to be accurate.

Permalink Mark Unread

It is encouraging that Mariona sees, and is allowed to see, that much of the trap.  Esta will not seize on it, he thinks, not even through too much encouragement or praise.

"If you say so, Merrin, then I so credit it.  It would fit with some of my other speculations about what might be happening."

"But consider now the failure of [Planar Binding], perhaps because the [Outer God] placed us far off the usual interplanar paths --"

"Or -- perhaps because It continues to watch us and directly intervened to make the spell fail.  [Outer Gods] are not limited by the [Compact of Creation] in how much They intervene, when They expend the force to intrude on [Creation] at all."

"Regardless.  What was the averted counterfactual, had the [Planar Binding] succeeded?  Our recovering the Bag too quickly?  My contacting an [outsider] that could convey news of our situation to our mutual department, which might then rescue us both, and too quickly for Its game?"

"Those are both possibilities, but not certain to be Its full motive.  It is not certain, from our own perspective, that either of those things would have happened otherwise."

"Consider then that in the averted counterfactual, an [outsider] can also talk to me and answer questions, should it be so minded.  A [Lawful] [outsider] might even tell the truth, and could [swear] to its answers."

"One of us or both have been altered, given false memories."

"If my memories are all true, an [outsider] should tell you that it does not remember your version of {dath ilan}.  This probably does not move you much.  The [outsider] is to you a mere thing of altered-Estha's, and of course it just believes what altered-Estha believes.  If I read your books I would expect them to confirm what altered-Merrin believes, and not be much moved by that.  The [Outer God] would then see little meaning in averting that event, which would change little of Its game."

"Suppose however that my own memories have been altered."

"I would by default believe a [Lawful] outsider which [swore] to me about that."

"So maybe that is the real reason that my [Planar Inquiry] and [Planar Binding] failed: in order to avert the counterfactual where an [outsider] told me something about how my memories had been altered."

"No action on your part is commanded by this.  But it seems to me that you ought to be aware of the chain of reasoning."

Permalink Mark Unread

“Acknowledged,” Merrin says.

There are so many pieces here and it’s so slippery to think about and why can’t she have a straightforward horrible impossible logistics problem to solve instead.

Taking this whole incredibly silly premise as given: would Merrin expect the "[Lawful] outsider" to know of dath ilan? If - as a hypothetical, there are a lot of other ways this could work, this is just the hypothesis with the highest salience to Merrin right now - if dath ilan "really exists" and, for some sense of what it means for a thing to "exist", so does wherever Estha is from? 

(Does Merrin have the faintest idea how that would work? No! But plenty of things in dath ilan work without Merrin understanding how, she's used to that, and it's never inconvenienced the workings of the things in question. Reality does not require Merrin's understanding in order to do its thing.) 

The answer, within that particular set of assumptions, is...pr...obably not? Since dath ilan certainly showed no sign when Merrin lived there of having heard of [Lawful] outsiders? But, like, she's not certain of that. Maybe a [Lawful] outsider would just confirm that both of their sets of memories happened, for some definition of "happening", just in different...places...by some strange definition of "place"? 

Having read plenty of fiction that involved characters trying to read hints in their surroundings as to what sort of story they were in, Merrin is also definitely has the reflexive thought that, uh, the hints visible to the characters can also be selected for what the narrative wants the characters to think, distinct from whether those tempting inferences are in any way accurate. Estha's hypothesis about an [Outer God] is not quite the same shape of hypothesis, she thinks, but it seems like the same logic could hold, and in short, it feels very difficult to make any trustworthy prediction from here. They have evidence, sure, but the kind that feels like it could indicate completely different updates based on which hypothesis they're comparing it to, and Merrin probably hasn't even thought of every possible hypothesis in the space and in short, aaaaaaaa, Reality is messing with her and she is NOT SMART ENOUGH FOR THIS. 

 

...She kind of wants to ask Estha what, if Reality is messing with them here, would be a particularly entertaining-plot-generating way for it to do that, but she cannot even slightly think of a way to phrase this question that doesn't sound incredibly stupid, and - fine, maybe she's feeling kind of inhibited on expressing her unformed unfiltered thoughts that might sound really stupid to uncanny-Estha. 

 

"Do you want to register our advance predictions about what it implies for this theory if you do versus don't get new spells in a few hours?" she asks him. Wow that would have taken less than half the number of syllables to say in Baseline. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta has a feeling that Cultural Adaptation would have told him something about the significance of this question which he may himself be missing.  It is not something that Mariona would've said to him, that's for certain.  It has the feeling of not only a clever question but a culturally clever question.

"I suppose -- if I do not get more spells, it predicts the Outer God's game does not last through this planet's summer, for then neither will we.  It is profoundly improbable that It will in this case helpfully send us back, once Its game is over; but we may be permitted to return through successfully finding the Bag."

"If I do get spells -- the game may be a longer one.  Or it may simply be the sort of game that requires us to successfully speak to one another."

"I think for the most part, I predict that we are meant by It to speak to each other of our altered memories.  From which the spells would follow."

"Whether it is actually our [god] sending those spells, or if It is sabotaging the spells I receive or my ability to ask for them, is of course a separate question."

Permalink Mark Unread

“…I mean, it’s possible we could survive the summer?” Merrin says. “I was planning to try, on my own, and more plans are possible with two people. But it…doesn’t seem very interesting, if we can’t talk to each other and are just spending all of every day doing really repetitive tasks to stay alive. Probably an [Outer God] could have - different taste in what games it finds entertaining - so that’s not a guaranteed argument, but I think it could still be evidence.”

Permalink Mark Unread

If Outer Gods found anything like human entertainments to be entertaining, They would be constantly watching humans all the time, and kidnapping mortals on a regular basis... well, Esta supposes he does not know this to be false.

"I doubt It is entertained by anything like what we find entertaining," he says nonetheless.  "But that It has troubled to put two of us here, at least one with false memories, suggests It to take interest in some interaction between us which is liable to depend on us talking."


If there is nothing more to say, Esta will go back to thinking, or thinking while working on such useful work as may not be obviated by his spellcasting.

That he told altered-Mariona of his concerns -- well, partially, a little, it is because of that properly paranoid practice which keeps Worldwound fortresses free of succubi.

But mainly it is to set a good example for Mariona.  See, 'Estha' is willing to consider that his memories may have been altered!  He does not find it too distressing to think about, or a loss of pride to discuss with her; and above all, he does not consider the possibility to constitute himself losing, and Mariona winning, in some game between himself and Mariona.  All of this implicit statement is a lie, of course, but a helpful one.

Esta has a guess, now, though only a guess, about what the victory condition of the Y̷̼̚o̷̪͒g̵͚̋-̴͕͠S̸͚̀ǫ̵͆t̸̥̾h̵̺̋o̴̜̕t̴͚͝ĥ̵̟'s game would obviously be -- if It has troubled to make Its game winnable at all, as may not be remotely in Its own nature.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

The time has come when, by Merrin's chronometer, 24 Golarion hours will soon have passed -- as near as Esta can convert those units, for Share Language (Utopian) will not define them any sharper than Esta knows.  They are still in the base; the tide is not yet low enough for them to go hunting along the riverbed.

Esta, then, is already meditating, alert for the contact of his god; if it is his god; and if gods are even a thing.

There is a certain strange fascination in the prospect that everything he knows might be a lie.

But that is not what Esta needs to be thinking about right now, so he does not think it.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yo.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh good.

"Merrin, I have divine contact!"

As soon as he says those words, Esta is already casting Planetary Adaptation on himself.  Hopefully it gets refreshed, but even if not, it would in any case be lost otherwise.

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh that is good news!

Permalink Mark Unread

...unless it's not for some reason? Maybe Estha's [god] is terrible or something! 

(This is almost entirely a reflexive contrarian response because Laeirthe, too, is kind of bored and restless from all the waiting.)  

Permalink Mark Unread

(Merrin ignores Laeirthe because he is being very annoying.) 

 

She was also watching the time, and staying nearby while she checks power output and usage calculations; she'll pop over to him for the touch-range [spells]. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Endure Elements.

Share Language (Utopian) (only).

And then -- despite general Asmodean best practices -- because, Esta has said to himself, it seems more likely that Mariona is at the center of this game than himself; and while Esta would be amazed and indeed doubtful if it seemed as simple as curing 'insanity', Mariona may do better without any subtle ability damage she's picked up over the last months of eating strange things --

Heal.

And Esta will not be present to hear out Merrin's reaction to his use of what might or might not be an irreplaceable resource on her and not on him, because Esta now must actually pray.

Permalink Mark Unread

Estha had mentioned having a healing spell, and that it cures some kinds of...she translated it as "psychotic disorders", Estha's vocabulary in the language he shared did not have the most detailed vocabulary for mental illnesses...and that it seemed unlikely the [Outer God] messing with them would make it that easy, but that he was still considering which of them to use it on. 

 

...Merrin is faintly surprised that it came out in favor of being her, given that Estha is the one who, one, NEARLY DIED OF TRAUMATIC INJURIES less than a planetary day ago and, two, was transported here in way that seemed to involve a lot more direct contact with the [Outer God] entity playing games with them or whatever the fuck it is, with corresponding impairing side effects. 

 

But - wow. Wow

Merrin has very few reference points to even describe what it feels like. It's not really the same experience as trying on the [belt], except in the abruptness of it; she's not sure how much she was interpreting the sensation of that through her pre-existing expectations, but it did feel like just...having her underlying stamina, the thing she has a lot more of than average but isn't unlimited on, increased dramatically, which is not the feeling she has now.

It doesn't feel like suddenly recovering from an illness; one upside of being alone on an exoplanet for months is the complete lack of anyone to catch infectious diseases from, and either she's been careful enough to avoid problems with local bacteria or they aren't interested in her. (And apparently this isn't the sort of narrative where realistic-yet-inconvenient things happen like "Estha is harmlessly carrying a virus that Merrin has zero pre-existing immunity to" or vice versa.)

It definitely doesn't feel like having injuries instantly fully healed, though she is noticing the lack of a whole lot of vague muscle and joint aches she had been tuning out. She's been pushing her body hard for a very long time. 

She's not at all tired!! It's incredible!!! And there's some kind of subtler ickiness that's gone, too. She really shouldn't have had any micronutrient deficiencies to correct, yet, but maybe her body wasn't delighted at getting exactly the required bare minimum of essential fatty acids and otherwise barely any fat she could digest, and of course her GI tract is probably in a chronic state of mild unhappiness at all the food she's eating that she can't perfectly digest. And now, instead of feeling mildly icky and mildly low-energy, she feels GREAT. 

 

Aaaaand she can't even thank Estha yet because he's busy! 

...She'll park herself back over at her electronic-screen station and go back to finding and reviewing saved bits of video footage of the river; she's been meaning for a while to use that to draw a more detailed map of the riverbed, and since they're tentatively planning to go walk around looking for Estha's Bag at low tide, now is a good time to actually have a map of the search area where she can mark out caves and obstacles that might catch debris. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...A couple of minutes into that, Merrin explicitly has the thought that it did not do anything to her memories, or her current set of - hypotheses, none of them feel solid enough to call 'beliefs' - about her situation. 

 

She doesn't feel surprised at all, really, but it's still more than zero information. Whether it implies that she's not psychotic and has been perceiving Reality more or less accurately (you know, within the usual human limits of sensory perception and filtering and confirmation bias etc), or just implies that whatever entity is messing with her doesn't want to make it that easy to sort this out, is another question. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin's mind keeps trying to bounce back to - assessing, orienting, making-sense-of. What information does she have, and what hypotheses are compatible with her observations so far, and how does the evidence she's seen weigh for or against each of them? 

 

But it feels like falling, because...once she thought she knew things, right. Not everything, but - things. That rising CO2 levels reduce blood pH and this triggers the respiratory drive. That both low or high potassium interfere with cardiac electrical signals. That the vascular system has receptors for epinephrine and will respond like so if it's injected into a vein. Simple things like that, things that a medtech who isn't actually all that smart can understand, but however much the greater workings of Civilization were beyond her, she knew medicine as deeply as she knew that two plus two equals four. 

Except that...maybe she doesn't??? Maybe dath ilan "isn't" "real" and none of her memories are of things that actually happened, maybe 'Merrin' is the construction of an [Outer God] playing games with Estha who was her senior colleague in the actual Reality where they were both [clerics] of a [god], and so even the things she thought she could treat as solid ground to make other updates around...aren't that. 

It doesn't feel like it fits together. The feeling Merrin has about it is probably closest akin to "come on, that can't be the twist the narrative is going for, you couldn't pull that off without completely violates suspension of disbelief."

But, of course, it WOULDN'T fit together from her own perspective if all of her memories have been OVERWRITTEN by ones that are MADE UP, and honestly the problem is that that entire angle of thinking about it mostly leaves Merrin feeling like the act of thinking cannot even in principle help her to end up believing truer things. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...Which is not at all helpful when she's trying to do logistical planning that might keep them alive. 

 

Merrin will hold in the back of her mind that maybe none of her beliefs are correlated with Reality and maybe no amount of thinking will accomplish anything, you know, just so she's tracking that hypothesis in case something happens that would update her toward it. 

And then she's going to draw maps anyway

Permalink Mark Unread

And Esta prays.

He would like several Locate Objects, please.  Extended Locate Object works too.

If Asmodeus can hear anything more than that, he'd like the Extended Planetary Adaptation and Endure Elements again, and Share Language, and another Heal, and Tongues and 2x Cultural Adaptation, and a Greater Make Whole and the Mending cantrip, and a Imbue With Spell Ability and Word of Recall.

But Esta thinks that part relatively briefly, though as loudly as he can manage.

Esta wants Locate Object.

Esta wants Extended Locate Object.

Four Locate Objects, three Extended Locate Objects.

There is an object he'd like to locate.  It contains things that are useful to Esta, and which will help him serve his Lord; and the contents belong to Cheliax, which belongs to Asmodeus in turn.  So he'd like to Locate that Object, in his Lord's name!

If Esta is correct in reading the Commune as an implied instruction to try to talk to his god, then that bag contains incense.  Which in turn will help Esta to

OBEY ASMODEUS'S ORDERS

if only he can Locate that Object!

Permalink Mark Unread

Huh.

Asmodeus is sort of getting the vague, distant impression that this squirrel might maybe possibly want to locate an object.

Permalink Mark Unread

The Day 2 loadout isn't as preset as the Day 1.  Asmodeus can see from here which spells His squirrel still has at the time of prayer; and therefore, implicitly, which spells the squirrel didn't use the previous day.  Asmodeus's plan can be based on that information, without too much increase of intervention cost, so long as Asmodeus is not adapting the rules based on His direct perception and prediction of the surrounding situation.

The squirrel used both the Endure Elements and the Planetary Adaptation, as shouldn't have both been necessary for itself alone.  Also two Share Languages, the Tongues, and the Cultural Adaptation?  That's a bit surprising for a planet that's uninhabited; or at least, devoid of any inhabitants close enough to Asmodeus on the alignment chart to be perceptible to Him, which argues against a planetwide population.  If His pet squirrel got lost in a companion's presence, Asmodeus would not have expected the Share Language to prove necessary.  If His pet squirrel found a native alien of foreign alignment, why did that alien need an Endure Elements?  There are many possible hypotheses, here, but not enough evidence to narrow them down.

Asmodeus's preset plan says to mostly restore those spells of the Day 1 loadout that ended up being used; He will therefore restore the Endure Elements, Extended Planetary Adaptation, both Share Languages, the Tongues, and the Cultural Adaptation.  The squirrel also gets a refreshed Greater Make Whole and Heal.

The Liberating Command got used, which is going to trigger some other helpful spells for that sort of implied situation and its possible developments; although not a repeat of Liberating Command, because probably that spell either worked or it didn't.

The Augury got used, but not the Divination or the Commune.  That plausibly corresponds to a situation where an idiot squirrel tried to test if something weird could be 'incense', not understanding that this is not how anything works.  Asmodeus will refresh the Augury, but not the Divination, in hopes of helping to convey the general default of 'you usually retain the spells you use'; also it's possible the squirrel just needed an Augury and not a Divination.

The Commune stays, because the pet squirrel CONTINUES to be instructed to TALK TO ITS OWNER if possible.

The Planar Inquiry and Planar Binding have been used, and won't be refreshed.  They'll either have worked or not.  This tiny fragment of Asmodeus's attention is not about to start checking with Hell's chain of command to see if the reporting attempt was successful.

Some of the lower-expected-value default spells in the Day-1-updated Day 2 loadout will be replaced by a couple of Locate Objects and an Extended Locate Object.  It's hard to tell how much object location the squirrel wanted, exactly?  Asmodeus did get the impression the squirrel wanted more than one.  If the squirrel keeps using all the Locates every day, it'll eventually start getting even more.

With any luck, the incredibly lost squirrel has been told of some hugely valuable object nearby, which can be found by simple Location -- or maybe, whose containing dungeon's entrance can be found by Location -- and the squirrel will someday get that object back to Asmodeus's part of Golarion!  Asmodeus has won a couple of planets that way, in the distant past; though expecting it to play out that way for Rovagug's Cage would be a lot more to hope for.

Asmodeus will accordingly delay longer before giving the pet squirrel a Sending that might succeed in contacting Asmodeus's favoritest pet squirrel for a Gate to retrieve it.  This pet squirrel might be doing useful things where it is!

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

...Esta will take this as evidence that his deity can maybe hear him a tiny bit if Esta focuses really hard on conveying one request, but is otherwise almost entirely unable to see Esta, or the planet that Esta is on.  Asmodeus may in fact be reasoning largely off which spells Esta has used.

(There's a strange sort of internal disquiet, bubbling about this thought; and for some reason Esta's mind decides to take this moment to remind itself that a 6th-circle is probably worth a Discern Location and Gate to retrieve, if he is incompetent enough not to retrieve himself.  Or, for that matter, a 7th-circle Greater Scry might succeed in placing a sensor on him, where a 6th-circle Planar Binding failed to bring forth an entire outsider.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta has back the Cure Light and Cure Moderate that he used, and not some other spells that he did not use.  Esta has an Augury but not a Divination.  That seems particularly indicative of spells being refreshed according to their having been used.  The Commune is still there, perhaps by way of indicating an outstanding instruction to talk to his god if possible.

Esta received other spells for escaping, defending himself, or enslaving local mortals -- maybe on account of his using the Liberating Command? -- which Esta is probably going to ignore, unless he can think of a way to talk Merrin into accepting a geas without that interfering with their current working relationship.  Esta cannot think off the top of his head of a geas that would be worth the relationship risk.

Permalink Mark Unread

"I have been [granted] some Locate Object, though not as much as I asked or as much as I hoped.  Two 3rd-circle each [12 minutes], one 4th-circle Extended that will last [24 minutes].  Endure Elements and Extended Planetary Adaptation were both refreshed, and Share Language, and Tongues, and Greater Make Whole."  And Cultural Adaptation though Esta is not naming that one out loud.  "No [Word of Recall], no [Imbue with Spell Ability].  My initial guess at our situation:  I can perhaps request one new spell at best, per day, by concentrating hard on that alone; and old spells I use will usually be renewed."

"I have also received a new 2nd-circle divination, Lay of the Land, which will grant me one day's knowing of the geography for [6 miles] around wherever I use it."

Permalink Mark Unread

...Huh. To Merrin that feels like such a specific degree of able-to-contact-his-[god], like it must have been carefully contrived to end up exactly like that? But she doesn't actually have enough context to make that judgement with any confidence.

It's better than it could have been, though! Probably. Merrin is going to go on ignoring Bored Laeirthe with his stupid reflexive contrarianism about how everything that seems good on the surface might actually secretly be terrible somehow. It's probably not completely useless, to have that backup paranoia running in her head, but it sure does get irritating after a while. 

"I've been thinking about safer alternatives to the tidal bore," she says. "It'll be annoying, but - one plan that I don't think is actually very dangerous at all, is to walk upstream the long way, and you cast your [Locate Object] while riding the river current back down. I might even be able to make a proper boat out of seaweed, with more lead time. ...Does [Locate Object] get through rock? I haven't mapped out all the caves, but that's something the spell for knowing geography might be really useful for, assuming you can tell me what you know so I can draw a map before you - do you just forget all of it after 24 hours...?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Stone shouldn't block Locate Object.  Small amounts of [lead] will."  Lead is a dull, heavy metal.

"It will be my first time using [Lay of the Land].  I would expect as follows:  While I might later remember having remembered any aspect of geography that I previously took a moment to remember, I will not remember anything I haven't already remembered.  I shall of course endeavor to mentally review all of those artificial memories that seem interesting, but drawing maps seems wise if there is anything worth remembering.  At some future point, I may be able to give you that spell directly with [Imbue With Spell Ability]."

"Riding the river current back down does seem sensible, pending my successful acquisition of a [Word of Recall] to try the more dangerous version safely."

Permalink Mark Unread

The “dull, heavy” metal is probably not uranium, which is the main very-heavy metal that the rocks around here might have unusually much of. And a “small amount” of pure metal is equivalent to a much larger amount of impure ore, if impure ore even has the same effect, it’s presumably magic rather than chemistry so who knows. Not Merrin! Merrin does not get to know very many things at all lately! 

She’s actually pretty up for a hike! She’s FED and the powerful healing magic fixed her and she’s magically immune to both heatstroke and hypothermia, and she’s full of newfound tentative hope that maybe all of her problems will be solved by planetary-evening, and those are the best conditions imaginable under which to go on a long walk on her exoplanet and actually enjoy the scenery. 

Permalink Mark Unread

…Merrin should perhaps not be so confident that her problems would be solved by finding Estha’s magical Bag. As opposed to, you know, replaced with different and exciting new problems! 

Permalink Mark Unread

Shut up.

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah, Laeirthe, cut it out and let them have some fun here. Kalorm bets that Merrin can still totally outhike Higher Stamina Estha. It’ll be hilarious.

Permalink Mark Unread

ARGHHHH apparently the argumentative dudes in her head do NOT constitute any normal kind of psychosis, since here they are, doing their thing, after Merrin was subject to powerful healing magic, and in fact it does overall seem like it's mostly a bizarre brain hack that lets her cheat at being slightly smarter via being HARASSED into THINKING MORE THOUGHTS, and actually overall Merrin is not even disendorsing this for the current situation, it does kind of feel like having more than one perspective running in her head is helping with the general...insanitymakingness...of the whole scenario, but still, the thing is, about being harassed into thinking more thoughts via putting some of those thoughts into imaginary people or something, is that thinking more thoughts is TIRING. 

 

 

Permalink Mark Unread

She'll ask Estha if he got more healing magic to use on himself, because she does feel a little bad about trying to outhike him if he might not be 100% recovered from his recent ordeal, but if he is then, yes, Merrin is ready to be somewhat competitive about this. 

 

It's about 23:30. Still only midmorning, planetary time. High tide will be in a couple of hours, and they'll want to wait until the tidal waters have receded past the stretch of river they're searching and only the little river is left, but that's still going to be well before actual low tide in 20-and-some hours - say, 15-18 hours from now as the best window. They might want to try to cover twelve miles in that time - with a stop in the middle to do his geography spell - and ideally they’d reach the furthest point early enough to give Merrin time to test making a boat, she would rather pack a bunch of dried strapwrack bundles to wet-weave-sundry over there rather than carry it in its full unwieldy form, and also she can use the walk over to finish the boat design in her head so actually making it goes really fast, it might not turn out better than the suit but it’s worth trying…


In short, Merrin is full of ideas and energy and has a fully-charged suit of armor, and is basically eager to get moving as soon as they’ve packed for a twelve-mile hike. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta has more healing magic, yes.  He'll wait until he gets the [fatigued] condition, and then use it on himself.  If Merrin thinks she can still outlast him under that premise, she's welcome to try.

Twelve miles would be trivial with a road or an Extended Air Walk.  Can they do it on rough terrain?  That sounds like a more interesting challenge.

Permalink Mark Unread

Possibly under those conditions Merrin will not outlast Estha, exactly, but she sure doesn't intend to be the one slowing them down.

(She is kind of cheating; she has power armor.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

There are SO MANY CAVES. How are there SO MANY CAVES. They've walked, like, five kilometers, over several hours.

 

(The distance units that Estha's spells work on are weird and arbitrary and somewhat longer than a kilometer. The range on his geography-knowledge spell is like NINE AND A HALF kilometers. They have walked like HALF that distance and still passed so many entrances to caves and some of those cave entrances look like they go really, really deep.) 

 

Merrin can get quite a lot of entertainment out of looking at rocks, for a dath ilani, but she does, eventually, get bored, and want to make conversation to pass the time. 

Permalink Mark Unread

"...So what would you say is the single spell that makes the biggest difference in your day to day life, to be able to cast?"

Merrin has almost no mental image of what kind of day to day routine Estha remembers having with...her, the other her that he remembers and she doesn't remember being...and it's kind of bothering her. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta is restricted in his choice of conversation branches by not quite wanting to give away what he and Mariona used to do for a living.

The fact is, most cleric spells are not really what you'd call personal convenience spells.  It is selfish, self-obsessed wizards who are free to invent the likes of Age Resistance.  Cleric spells are god-made to be actually important: combat spells, buffs, military infrastructure like Scry, civilizational infrastructure like Create Water or Stone Shape.

The spell that Esta has the most personal fun with, when he is relaxing in some young lady's unconsenting company, is the spell Bestow Curse.  You can do so many things if you invest some time and effort and Spellcraft in realizing the full flexibility of Bestow Curse.  (It's not even wasted effort for someday ruling the Church.  Rugatonn's supreme expertise in curses, used for the likes of 'cursing Chelish workers abroad to be unable to act to escape Cheliax', is arguably more valuable to the Chelish state than her ninth-circle spells.)  Esta thinks he maybe shouldn't mention that part either.

On Mariona's literal words as to what spell merely being able to cast brings forth the greatest change in day to day life, there is a single very obvious answer:  The defining spell of 4th-circle: the spell whose willing casting gets you told the real truths about the Church*, promoted to the true inner ring** and all the wealth and power that brings for everyday life: that spell whose casting is considered nearly as good as a wizard's soul-sale, in terms of making its caster to know theirself for damned in a way that is nearly impossible to ever atone for, and with correspondingly assured loyalties: Malediction.

(*)   Esta does not know the real truths about the Church.
(**)  The actual lnner Ring is "Rugatonn, Gorthoklek, and Lrilatha", but 4th circles and above believe themselves to be in it.

 

"I suppose [Word of Recall]," Esta replies.  "It reduces the number of overnight missions, and gets you sent out on other missions where you can save a 7th-circle spell on the [Greater Teleport] going back.  So there's a marked difference in how you spend your days, afterward."

"Though I might just be thinking of that one because it's my own most recent change.  Other clerics might name the [Guidance] cantrip, which is a little boost to any skill that requires quick decisions, but that trades off against other important cantrips like [Detect Magic] or [Resistance]."

Permalink Mark Unread

That would affect quite a lot of logistics, wouldn't it. Though, like, mostly from the perspective of a civilization that doesn't have airplanes. Merrin - for lack of a more specific picture of what the version of her that Estha remembers actually did with her time - is trying to picture how the spells described would affect her Exception Handling missions. The [Word of Recall] would be useful for extraction - ohhhh, it would have made a big difference in the whole Kalorm rescue, wouldn't it, assuming it would let you bring other people along...?

That's kind of epic to imagine, actually. Presumably the version of her that Estha remembers did not get to have that spell yet, because she wasn't as talented or experienced, but it would be SUPER COOL to be able to dive into the ocean to rescue someone and then TELEPORT THEM DIRECTLY to the hospital in Default. 

 

...Which, of course, makes her wonder about the magic that's most sparkly to her.  

"What are the best healing spells? Did I," did the version of her he remembers, she means, but she's sort of implicitly testing if it seems to reassure Estha if she speaks of it like she might be that person and not a completely different Merrin who just shares his Merrin's face and some traits, "have a favorite?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Your favorite healing spell was the least powerful one, so weak that it is in fact a cantrip and thus has unlimited uses:  [Stabilize].  It repairs the bare minimum required to prevent a dying person from continuing to lose vitality."

"From your perspective, it was an enabling spell for using nonmagical medicine once you had run out of magical healing -- which happened to you sometimes, though perhaps not as often as you would have secretly enjoyed, if you could have wished for such a thing without thereby wishing harm on your subordinates.  [Stabilize] gave you time to triage your patients and perform surgery on them before they died, and also prevented them from dying of the surgery.  You insisted on preparing that spell every day without fail, even on days where it seemed very unlikely to be required.  Unless you'd received direct contrary orders for one day, and then you pouted."

As for whether Merrin can infer that she is Mariona's fantasy, and not even her own fantasy, it may be early to wish for her to see it.

Permalink Mark Unread

The other her got to have an UNLIMITED-USE MAKE PEOPLE NOT DIE spell??????!!!!!!!! 

 

...Okay, Merrin is in fact officially jealous now. 

(And slightly weirded out by the comment about 'perhaps not as often as you would have secretly enjoyed', but the Estha she remembers also liked to tease her about secretly loving emergencies and wishing they would happen all the time. She doesn't think it's true, because actually emergencies are really stressful at the time and mostly fun to think about afterward when it went well and sometimes it does not go well and then instead she feels terrible! But, like, there's a kernel of truth to it, it's pretty fair to tease her about it.) 

 

They run into some more difficult terrain again and Merrin spends a couple of minutes mostly focused on navigating that. (She isn't even slightly tired, yet, though at this rate she is eventually going to get hungry again even with the absurd quantity of food she ate earlier.) 

 

Eventually she manages to track down the bit that was actually niggling at her. “- Huh, what were the circumstances where it made sense for me to be given direct orders not to prepare [Stabilize]?”

Permalink Mark Unread

"When you needed other cantrips instead, of course.  I mind that time the obvious best loadout for your mission was [Detect Poison], [Mending], [Create Water], and [Read Magic], and you tried to arrange for your subordinates to carry a hundred gallons of water along with you so that you could have [Stabilize] in place of [Create Water].  I couldn't quite come with, on that excursion, but I could do the nearly equally valuable service of ordering you not to prepare [Stabilize] that morning."

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh nooooooo that’s so mortifying. That’s exactly the kind of thing Merrin would— okay, that a younger Merrin with less experience at navigating her own silly moments of neuroticism would do, if she were under too much cognitive load to properly take a step back and question whether her high-level decisionmaking and prioritization was completely insane.

 

…On reflection, though, while she’s taking Estha’s word for it that it was correct to prioritize [Create Water] over [Stabilize] - he’s smarter than her and more experienced, and if he’d been wrong then she would have argued back with logic, not conceded that she was letting her neuroticism steer - it does leave her with some questions about exactly what circumstances entailed those constraints.

“What was the mission?” she says, with a slightly abashed smile.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Mm.  I have been somewhat deliberately avoiding telling you all the details about -- my Merrin -- for two reasons.  A smaller reason is that we are already trying the [curse-countering methodology] of my hearing freely about that {dath ilan} which should, on your view, be Estha's native world and my own true memory.  To do otherwise in the reverse direction, reserves the option of, say, seeing if you begin to remember things naturally, or later trying to tell you many key facts at once."

"A larger reason is that I do suspect your memories of having undergone the greater alterations and deletions, at the hands of an [Outer God].  It has been seen to carefully arrange events here to be resistant to our own undoing of them.  One should be cautious, in attempting to challenge and undo the works of [divinity].  One should perhaps still challenge, in the end, when the [god] is not an allied one.  But one should be deliberate and measured about doing so.  If I don't try early on in the [Outer God]'s game to restore your memories -- for example, by giving you back what should be your true native language, rather than [Utopian] -- then perhaps we will not encounter early resistance.  You may be intended to remember for yourself."

Permalink Mark Unread

SUSPICION ALERT he's concealing information from her with a justification that MIGHT be honest but also MIGHT NOT!

Permalink Mark Unread

....Yes. Merrin had in fact not failed to notice that. 

 

Has Laeirthe noticed that they're also doing some information-concealing, here? In particular, of the fact that Merrin has acquired a bizarrely agentic mental simulation of a paranoid immortal mage from a FICTIONAL SETTING even if this is apparently not strictly speaking insanity since the [Heal] spell did not get rid of him. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Yep! And Laeirthe would like to continue concealing his existence, please. It's one of the few genuinely-maybe-secret advantages Merrin still has, if it turns out that Altered Estha or Other World Estha or whatever he is can't be trusted for some reason, and also has pretty good predictions of Merrin overall because the other one, or the original, or whatever the underlying Reality is here, apparently still has recognizably similar personality traits, based on Merrin's reaction to descriptions so far. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Mrrrglbgllrr. Merrin misses when her problems only required her to do LOTS OF MATH and not also SOCIAL DECEPTION.

Permalink Mark Unread

....Okay, perhaps Laeirthe is now going to have to take a turn being contrarian in the POSITIVE direction, to point out that Merrin now has a much better set of problems! Even if altered-or-alternate-world-version-Estha is terrible, it seems he's not-impossible to cooperate with, and she has access to economicmagic for food and climate control which basically just solves her most-likely-to-be-lethal problems, and also MAGIC EXISTS, and she might have a way off the planet, and - wasn't she whining just a few planetary months ago about how everything felt meaningless when none of her decisions affected anyone but herself? Doesn't she prefer the scenario where her decisions might have important consequences

Permalink Mark Unread

Wow Laeirthe is really bad at the 'positive' thing and also has a really bad model of her, somehow, Merrin actively doesn't want to be in a position where anything she does as an individual has important consequences, that's a matter for Civilization, not a medtech who isn't very smart

Merrin can recognize that her feelings about the matter are...somewhat more complicated than that. And also that there are a lot of things more important than her feelings. 

 

...Internal conversations go fast, but it's still going to get weird and awkward if she goes thoughtful and quiet for any longer. 

 

"- I would say 'understood' but I'm not actually sure I follow all of your logic," she says. "Which - isn't surprising, since you're not explaining the cognitohazard parts, so I don't have the context you're reasoning from. I - acknowledge your decision." 

Permalink Mark Unread

<actual reaction>Well GEE THANKS for your generous acknowledgement, miss wayward subordinate.</actual reaction>

<spoken reaction>"Yes.  I do apologize both for its inconvenience, and for necessarily arrogating that decision to myself if it's to be made that way at all."</spoken reaction>

It's less humiliating to say in Utopian, at least.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

And eventually Merrin's suit navigation informs her that they have now walked 9.6 km, which was her conservative guess at the conversion from six "miles". Here seems like a fine place to cast the sourceless-geology-knowledge spell?

Permalink Mark Unread

She's the one with the Dark Tapestry inverted-magic precise navigation equipment.

[Lay of the Land].  Focusing particularly on knowledge of rivers and the places where water can go, including underground to realistically swimmable depths, if the spell lets him request maps of that part.  He is explicitly not interested in just the above-ground parts of the geography.  Esta wants to know the lay of places he might swim, not just places he might walk; but also he doesn't want his brain-crushed by a full 6-mile sphere of geography...

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

"Your idea for riding the returning tide was an excellent one.  I would very likely have picked up the [Bag of Holding], I now think, if its location were confined to the river we are walking."

"The [Outer God] has correspondingly sent us to a place that is very thoroughly honeycombed with underground lakes and rivers.  And while we should try things the easy way first, I will be surprised if the [Bag of Holding] is not now in one of those instead."

Maybe they would have been better off just not looking for the bag until the Outer God's game had reached a plausible conclusion.

Permalink Mark Unread

Just commit to not using the Bag's contents if you find them, idiot, and then it may simply be lying near the river as you search the first time.

Permalink Mark Unread

If Esta naturally thought that way without Rugatonn having ever instructed him on the topic in her own person, he would already be an 8th-circle and her designated successor.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Oh. ...That makes sense, this is -" The language-sharing did not provide Merrin with the kind of highly precise geological vocabulary that she has access to when speaking Baseline. "- Terrain made of rock that dissolves in water under the right conditions, it tends to form all sorts of underground rivers." 

They might as well keep walking. It would be neat if they can reach the end of the intertidal zone before their safe river-riding window closes, to be sure the Bag can't be any further upstream than that. 

"We might have time on the way back to stop at particularly deep caves," she says. "...I have a mapping -" this language does not even slightly give her a word for 'software', "- I have a thing to draw maps in my armor. It's pretty annoying to do it while I'm trying to walk but I can make a start, if you tell me about caves as we pass them. ...Do you have any other spells that would be helpful for cave exploration? I would be - reasonably safe in my armor," as in, NOT SAFE ENOUGH that Exception Handling would give her this assignment without a lot more support than she has here, but, you know, relatively, "but you don't have the ability to give me the magic-detecting spell..." 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Not this [day], no.  My priority for the next [day] is to add [Word of Recall] to our loadout.  [Imbue With Spell Ability] would be a reasonable candidate for the [day] after.  And we can maybe eventually work it around to [Air Walk], [Water Breathing], and [Freedom of Movement]."

Permalink Mark Unread

It does remind him that he might as well cast Heal on himself, this being their probable halfway point.  He has very likely become fatigued by now, yes.

Heal.

Does that by any chance cure Esta's insanity or restore his true memories?

Permalink Mark Unread

It is, alas, not quite that kind of insanity.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Well, that didn't restore my own true memories, or any such easy out."

"I do believe I was suffering several forms of affliction beyond simple fatigue.  Some of that may be down to encountering an [Outer God], but other afflictions might conceivably be from poisonous air before I cast the [Planetary Adaptation] on myself... it might be worth repeating the [Heal] on you next [day], if I receive it again, to see if it makes a further difference."

Permalink Mark Unread

"...I didn't think you were exposed to the -" really, no vocabulary for radioactivity, this language-sharing spell is enraging, "- the cave with the poisonous air too badly, it definitely wasn't enough to be much risk to me rescuing you, but it might've been enough to affect you a bit, yeah."

Merrin does not feel like she's particularly going to need the [Heal again] unless she has a Stupid Accident, but she's not going to say no, if he's offering. It'll definitely make her less cranky about doing intense-physical-exertion exploration missions on two successive wakeful-periods plus all the sleep schedule shenanigans they're going to need to pull if they want to make the best of the optimal-tidal-windows for hunting in caves as fast as possible. 

 

If Estha is back to full health, then Merrin will have to work somewhat harder not to be the one slowing them down. She's using the bare-minimum power armor assist she can manage with, because she does need the battery to last almost 24 hours and, even if she doesn't need the suit climate-control at all right now, the suit itself still has to keep its internal electronics from overheating. And she's carrying a decent weight of total supplies, even if it's efficiently packaged in the harness webbing on her back – she's got carefully rolled sailweed leaves and enough of her compact-spool-bundles of dried strapwrack to make a minimalist boat, since she's not entirely sure there'll be any to harvest almost 20 km upstream of her normal location the deflated bundle of Estha's stupid flotation suit in case the boat plan doesn't work, and spare oxygen just in case, and some food from her backup dath ilan rations in case there's a problem with the food-production spell, and minimal first aid supplies in case Estha ends up too unconscious to cast healing spells right away, and minimal supplies for emergency shelter in case Estha ends up unconscious and can't get new spells until he wakes up and their climate-control ones run out... 

She's not actually very worried about this being a disaster! It would be a stupid idea to do it if she was worried about that! She's just, you know, trained by Exception Handling. 

 

They walk. And walk some more. 

Permalink Mark Unread

They can make much better time when they're both walking under their own power and neither of them is at risk of heatstroke. 

It's still going to take, like, twelve hours to travel 19.2 straight-line km upstream – it's several more kilometers of walking than that, the riverbed is not perfectly straight. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is THOROUGHLY bored of rocks. 

 

She asks Estha to tell her whenever they're passing a cave and describe his sense of its general direction, how deep it goes, whether it slopes up or down, whether it branches and at what angle, etc. The voice-activated visual mapping tools on her suit are being buggy right now – she probably needs to replace a wire, though if she's lucky it just needs proper cleaning or it's a temporary heat-related malfunction – but she can make some use the stupid touch-sketchpad function on her wrist console screen without slowing them down or tripping over her own feet, and at the very least she can keep a full audio recording to review later against the location data. 

When she's not noting down cave features, she'll...ramble, apparently, about dath ilan. Since Estha wanted to hear about it in case it jogged memories loose or something. And because she's really bored. 

She's mostly inclined to ramble about the medical system, and what she knows of how Exception Handling is run, but a lot of stuff will come up incidentally – the secrecy oaths, some snippets about the structure and selection of dath ilan's Governance, some bits and pieces about her early schooling before she started working as a medtech. 

Permalink Mark Unread

It's hot out. It's so hot out. Not that this is inconveniencing either of them in any way, except for reducing the efficiency of some of Merrin's power armor electronic functions, but by 34:00, a few hours after solar noon and ten hours after they set out, the temperature peaks at just above 50° C.

Still well within what Endure Elements can handle, but one assumes that real summer on this planet will be even hotter than that. 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

...They're only 18.3 kilometers upstream of the camp, but on reflection, this...definitely no longer looks intertidal. Actually, they might want to backtrack 300 meters, to the spot they passed where the riverbed was not full of rocks. Merrin doesn't really think it's a great idea to put a boat down right here. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

They've got between four and seven hours to start riding down that river. Sooner might be better? It didn't sound like Estha had enough of the object-finding spell to use it continuously for like four hours of searching, but if they have time, they could stop at some of the more suspicious caves and look around visually or with the magic-detecting spell. 

Time to make a BOAT. 

 

Merrin has gotten really quite good at making random shit out of dried-and-resoaked strapwrack in a hurry. She can give Estha directions to help her, to speed it up even more, and then this is practically the optimal time of day for this, under the afternoon sun it's going to be bone-dry in like an hour max. At which point Merrin needs to at least haphazardly try to waterproof it a bit with sailweed leaves and duct tape, so it doesn't just turn into a mushy floppy boat as the strapwrack absorbs water again. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

...Ugh. It doesn't look like it's going to be the most maneuverable, though it's probably not worse than Estha bobbing around in his bubble-wrap flotation suit. (He should probably wear the suit, in case the boat has a problem, Merrin is really not as confident as she would like that the boat won't have a problem, it just seems probably still easier to concentrate while sitting it in.) 

On reflection she thinks she had better just swim it? She's a lot more maneuverable in the suit, and she'll have a chance of intercepting and nudging the boat if it's otherwise on track to hit any obstacles. 

She's not actually that tired - the three hours of mostly sitting on the ground and only working with her hands helped - but she's back to being spectacularly ravenously hungry. She can probably fit whatever's left of the food-production-spell output in one of her waterproof bags now that she's freed up all the space she was using for unassembled boat materials, so it wouldn't go to waste, if Estha were up for casting that now? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Of course.  Create Food and Water.

 

(This 'dath ilan' concept, if it is Mariona's self-unadmitted fantasy, is saying disturbing things about Mariona's incredible depths of suppressed heresy... Esta will think about that later and find some reason to be less disturbed.)

Permalink Mark Unread

It's probably kind of weird of her to find this as...romantic??...as she does? 

 

But Merrin is, more or less, having a picnic on the side of a gorgeous river after doing a scenic hike and then a Project with someone who, at the very least, LOOKS exactly like her boyfriend. It's a great date concept! 

Permalink Mark Unread

It's pretty weird, but who exactly is going to tell her it's against the rules to have fun? No one! Certainly not Kalorm. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...Yeah, okay. Having fun sometimes is good for her mental health, in the case where they don't find the Bag as soon as hoped and have to hunt for months. 

 

(Does that have...implications...for what the mysterious forces that planted both of them here want? Ugh. Probably. But chewing on that is not as fun as hanging out with Estha and eating bland but utterly delicious food on a riverbank. Merrin really will think about it, she's not going to try to just avoid it forever, Laeirthe does not need to nag, but - she's not going to let it ruin her picnic.) 

 

Merrin does not say anything about loud about the romantic associations of the situation but she does look cheerful as she eats and finishes packing up the leftovers in one of the waterproof bags, and helps Estha find a place to lower the boat into the river current and step down into it. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Life demands many strange things of one.  This part would need to be a lot more unpleasant to count as a bad day.

(Esta is not aware that the two of them are on a date, on account of the Church of Asmodeus in Cheliax more or less lacking that gendertrope.)

He'll step down into the boat, wearing literally the most ridiculous outfit he's ever worn in his life.  Should the N̴̮̎̕ő̵̗̕ȯ̴͈͝d̴̡̺͒̑ḷ̶͆̎y̴̬̜͑̋ ̷̮̗͗Ö̵̧́n̷̝̬̑ě̵̫ have a sense of humor, this would be the moment the Church picks to scry him; but that is not actually a bad thing from his perspective, it is better to be scried than not.

Permalink Mark Unread

It does not take long for them to reach a more noticeably intertidal zone with no shortage of caves. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

It's going to be moderately awkward to bring the boat to a stop without flipping Estha over into the water. Merrin swims alongside him in her power armor, and has no trouble keeping up, but she'll need, like, 200 meters of warning about any caves his geography-knowledge thinks might be worth stopping at. 

 

Merrin is going to leave spell-timing basically entirely up to Estha. He's an expert on - whatever their job even is, in his version of Reality - and maybe in his version of Reality so is she, but she certainly isn't now

Permalink Mark Unread

He cast Locate Object from the moment they started moving downstream.  He has two regular Locate Objects, each 12 minutes, and one Extended Locate Object, lasting 24 minutes.  All have a range of [880 feet].  When one such spell runs out, there's not much point in starting it again until they're around [1500 feet] from where they were originally -- unless the whole trip is to last less than 48 minutes, in which case he should maintain solid Locating in order to not narrow the range he sweeps.

If they still have margin to delay the trip without running out of Location for sweeping the basic pathway, then it might make sense to try detouring into the largest caves.

Merrin is the one with mapping {software} and speed estimates; he's relying on her to say if they have the margin for searching caves at all, and how much margin, and then sure he can make the call on caves that seem particularly likely to have sucked in the Holding Bag and have more than 880 feet of radius to search.

Permalink Mark Unread

They have about four hours budgeted - it’s conservative, but Merrin would like them to NOT be taking ANY risk of getting caught in the tidal bore even if there are problems. 

The river current speed is inconveniently wildly variable. If they ever do this again then Merrin will have great data! But right now she’s having to repeatedly recalculate and extrapolate how much ground they’ll be covering in an hour, knowing that they have to get almost 20 kilometers back.

The current is definitely not going to be obliging enough to carry them that far within 48 minutes. It starts out moving not much more than 5 kilometers per hour - a twelve-minute spell will cover a little over a kilometer, out of 18 - but Merrin does have an approximate suit-recorded map of "this bit looked like it was fast".

Prooobably Estha will get the most ground covered out of his limited-duration spells if they time it for fast bits, but the bag might be slightly more likely to have settled in a slow bit, so Merrin is pretty unsure on that? She will just do her best to keep updating him on her extrapolation of what distance he'll cover in 12 or 24 minutes, using the suit microphone-and-amplifier to somewhat awkwardly shout things to him while she swings ahead of the boat to scout out possible obstacles she might need to nudge it away from. 

They will definitely have time margin to look at caves, though it sounds like they can't be Locating Objects for anywhere close to the full duration of the trip, and it might make the most sense on this trip to just get recorded suit-camera footage and magical-geography-knowledge audio for Merrin to later turn into more detailed maps. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Probably in this case they should use Locate Object along the fastest stretches, and maybe a final stretch closest to the beginning of where the bag was lost.  They could peek inside the surface of some caves with Esta running Detect Magic in case it happens to be right out in front, he supposes, if they have time to do that anyway.  But Detect Magic won't go through [1 foot] of stone, and probably also not some sufficient depth of water.  They'll need to recheck those caves anyway later.

It is somewhat weird to think that probably an [Outer God] has checked in prophecy whether any of this works, and made sure it won't work.  But Esta does not otherwise know what they are supposed to do, besides running through the naive procedure for bag-searching over however many days of work, until it eventually turns up the bag, sometime after the [Outer God] got whatever it was that It wanted.

Permalink Mark Unread

(Merrin does not feel like her current strategy for reasoning about their bizarre situation is anywhere near optimal, but she's mostly falling back on poking at it, confusing herself immensely, and falling back on making plans on the basis of normal logic and logistical planning. It seems like trying to reason about where the Bag might be based on narrative tropes and/or the inclinations of an [Outer God] is either impossible because she has no model of how an [Outer God] things, or else counterproductive because if the [Outer God] can plan circles around them then it might just make the Bag even harder to find if they apply more thinkoomph to optimizing the search? ...Trying to figure out what the [Outer God] wants and let it have that sooner rather than later is maybe, in principle, ish, a way to get off this planet sooner? But it feels incredibly insanity-making and Merrin has no idea where to even start with that logic. She's not trained in that! She is trained in Exception Handling search-and-rescue, and 'person lost in a cave system and wearing a beacon detectable by her equipment only within a certain distance' is a training scenario she's literally done! Like, less dangerous caves, but still.

Going off normal physical-causality reasoning only: they do expect the Bag to plausibly end up in a somewhat different location every tide, but from that perspective it might actually be better if it's wound up in a cave and not being tossed kilometers up and down the river channel with every tidal bore. It seems more probable it would get wedged somewhere where it would be subject to only attenuated tidal forces, and it might - might - stay put long enough for them to grid-search the entire possible region. Of course, it might end up in some cave region accessible only through a hole too small for an entire person to fit through - if it's another six planetary months from now and they haven't found it, Merrin would be rather less surprised by that than she prefers - but they can incrementally increase the probability of finding it, surely, by being organized...) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

They can find places near intriguing might-go-quite-deep cave entrances where it's possible, with effort, for Merrin to guide the boat to the shore without flipping it over and drag it up to where it won't get swept off while they have a look. 

 

It's not easy. 15 km upstream of Merrin's camp spot, there's a lot less silt infill and a lot more rock, and the rock is apparently a more appealing surface for algae and bacterial biofilm, and this planet is so, so, so good at slime. The still-wet exposed intertidal rocks are literally steaming in the 50° C afternoon heat, and yet the thick mucilaginous slimecoat is still holding onto an impressive amount of water. Everything is quite remarkably slippery to try to walk on. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...And these same biofilms can also survive being exposed for many consecutive hours at winter temperatures that must drop well below the -40° C that Merrin recorded on arrival.

There's honestly something really inspiring about the sheer biological ingenuity of all this life surviving in such an inhospitable place. A team of actual dath ilani scientists could learn SO MUCH given a year to study this place and bring home samples. There must be SO MANY cool biomolecules that have no reason to exist in any form of life native to dath ilan. 

 

Merrin kind of feels like Estha would not appreciate hearing about all of that right now. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Caves? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Some of the organisms Merrin is spotting are ones she's never seen before! What a cool and fascinating set of microbiomes separated by only a few kilometers!

 

...She does not take any samples because they have. Other priorities. 

 

(The cave interiors out of the direct sunlight are even more full of slime and difficult to move around in. Merrin, in her armor, is going to have a much easier time of it than Estha in his stupid flotation suit.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

....A few planetary days ago, it would have been transformative for Merrin to find this particular cave. There's a spot that's clearly been dry for years! It has ventilation to the surface and even a tiny bit of natural light! It's free of radioactivity! Even in the heat of the afternoon, it's only gotten up to a perfectly comfortable 16° C! There's a set of interconnected pockets that could easily be turned into a cave shelter with multiple rooms! 

She could almost certainly survive a planetary summer alone, without magic, in this particular spot. Put the solar panels up top and run cable down through the crack, set up ventilation and a radioactivity sensor, sleep here in the afternoons and venture out for her work at night. 

 

It doesn't change anything now. It does not contain the Bag and so it accomplishes nothing. 

 

They keep going. 

Permalink Mark Unread

He's running Detect Magic every moment, with or without Locate Object active, though sometimes on the occasions when they run Locate for a stretch Esta takes a break.  It requires that much more concentration, but Detect Magic might pick up the form of a torn and ruined Bag whose contents had been lost forever, which might or might not still register to Locate Object.

Logically, this can't possibly work!  And it sure hasn't worked so far!

Estha out of dath ilan might've taken that state of mind as a cue to stop and examine what he was doing and look for some other way which wasn't that.  For Esta out of Cheliax, having to perform a thankless task with no prospect of reward at its end feels like much less of an error signal.  Isn't that what most of life feels like most of the time?  You do the thing anyways, or someone punishes you, possibly even yourself.

Permalink Mark Unread

And eventually they get back to the camp, a little while past the late-afternoon low tide point, very nearly a full 23 hours since Esta finished his last prayers.

Merrin had a Heal which reset her to more gloriously fully rested than she’s been in months, but that was very nearly a full 24 hours ago. The journey back was a lot more arduous for her than for Estha in the boat; she was the one swimming ahead to scout for obstacles and then back to guide him to shore for cave-peeking. It was mentally draining, too, as the only one with the mapping software to keep track of their location and record observations. Merrin may be something of a stamina monster but she is, in fact, tired. And low on suit battery, so she can’t even reasonably crank it up to maximum power assist for the hike back up the bank. 

“I’m going to need a nap before I finish the maps,” she tells Estha, without any particular self-consciousness about admitting to weakness; where she’s from, very few people could do what they just did at all. 

And she’ll step out of the suit to plug it into the solar-filled main battery, put on a doompunk robe rather than sit around literally naked (she's neither cold nor self-conscious about nudity, but everything in the cave is kind of gritty, because she's behind on cleaning, and uncomfortable to sit on with bare skin), and somehow scrape together the energy to unpack the Created food and eat until she can’t eat any more. ...And then, somehow, the energy to squeeze all the pee out of her suit pee-absorber, rinse it in a bit of her precious freshwater, and leave it in the sun to bake dry all the way, because late afternoon is a much better time to be handling that task than the middle of the planetary night. 

(Merrin does technically know that the spell Create Water exists. It came up! But in that conversation it was rather overshadowed by a much more memorable-to-Merrins spell, so she did not immediately rethink all of her water-related prioritization heuristics, and at this point she is simply too fried to think any new thoughts. She’ll be embarrassed about it later when she catches herself on it.)

 

And then she collapses into the sleeping bag. 

Permalink Mark Unread

They should probably think about–

Permalink Mark Unread

TOO

 

 

TIRED 

 

 

LATER 

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta doesn't particularly realize that Merrin is regarding freshwater as a valuable resource; she didn't mention that part to him.

He'll eat his own portion of Food, and drink some water; and then throw all the remains of yesterday's old Food away from their sanctum, as far he can heave it.  That stuff rots fast, once it starts to rot.

He renews Endure Elements and Share Language on Merrin, and Planetary Adaptation on himself.

And then, before it's time to pray, Esta will try to put his mind into a state that Asmodeus might maybe be able to see better, from far away.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta had some time to think about this issue, while they were drifting down the river.  Part of his mind had to maintain concentration on Detect Magic, but only a part.

What is it, actually, about Esta, that is shaped like Asmodeus and His concerns?

Whatever it is, it hasn't been getting a huge amount of natural exercise while Esta is on this alien planet far from Cheliax's tyranny and the Church's slaves; in the sole company of an Outer-God-touched woman who seems to wobble, in some alien way, between seeming Lawful Good and Chaotic Good.  A woman whom Esta does not presently dare to try to discipline, nor rebuke, nor dominate by more than the occasional sentence of assertion.

It would be little wonder if Asmodeus was having trouble seeing Esta, in his prayer, for more reasons than distance.

Esta has nobody here to tyrannize.

And there hasn't been anyone visible nearby who might tyrannize him, for three days.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta has previously held himself to excel in all of Asmodeus's concerns, of tyranny, slavery, pride, and compacts.  He is a 6th circle, after all, and very few priests are; why should he lower himself to specialize?  Someday he plans on being Most High, since that is what a proud Asmodean would plan on.  Come that day, all Asmodeus's concerns will be Esta's concerns.

Now Esta is far away and Asmodeus is perhaps having trouble seeing him.  It's not, in fact, a problem that Esta has ever had before.

Now, the question of which his Lord's concerns are most Esta's own, the question of what might make Esta belong in Hell, is a knowledge-question on whose actual true answer his welfare depends.

Permalink Mark Unread

It might seem strange, that it was never before to the advantage of a 6th-circle Asmodean cleric to wonder truthfully what part of himself appeals to his Lord.  But Asmodeus rarely promotes a cleric just for being Asmodeus-shaped.  Maybe it happens on other planets, but not in Golarion, where He is constrained more by His intervention budget than by the power He is willing to expend.

Asmodean clerics do often obtain their first initial clerichood in that way, by being some tiny bit Asmodeus-shaped or at least pleasing in His sight.  For them to obtain their 2nd circle that way is far rarer.  Asmodeus promotes you not on the basis of His sympathy for you, but on the basis of you fighting in enough combat to make it cost less intervention; and then, His further expectation that you'll prove useful if promoted.

Trying to make yourself more Asmodeus-shaped would significantly help only two sorts of people: seminary students desperate to be Chosen at all, and 7th circles hoping to be designated by Asmodeus as Rugatonn's successor.

Permalink Mark Unread

There is a wordless part of Esta that calculates what is advantageous for him to believe, about what aspects of himself make him a good priest of Asmodeus.

For Esta immediately after he was Chosen, as a 1st-circle, the most advantageous thing for him was to believe that he had the potential to excel at every Asmodean dimension, to study all Asmodeus's concerns with INT 16, and with WIS 18 shape his thoughts to the correct thoughts to have in every way.  It was advantageous for Esta to believe about himself that at least on a merely mortal scale, he was proper in every way, deficient in none.

At 4th, it was advantageous for Esta to believe he was the sort of exemplar priest who would not be relegated to a mere Church specialist in some particular Asmodean concern.

At 6th, it was advantageous for Esta to consider himself as someone who'd be seen as a candidate to become the next Most High and overseer of all the faith.

Now on an alien planet, for the first time in his life, that wordless part of himself has calculated that there would be an advantage in Esta knowing what was actually true about Esta's Asmodeanism, so that Esta could better comport himself in prayer to be seen by Asmodeus across some great distance.

Permalink Mark Unread

It isn't particularly needful for Esta to know that all of this is what's going on inside his mind.  At an augmented WIS 22, it is well within his reach to notice, if he rolled Perception about it; but Esta does not so attempt to roll Perception on his own thought processes, that is not what his WIS is for.

But if Esta did happen to perceive the nature of his own thoughts, it would hardly come as a shock to him or shake his faith.  Esta is not originally under the impression that he goes around trying to believe true things.

(And if what follows would sound strangely familiar, in other faraway places -- the Dark does often converge to one of a handful of similar forms, anywhere the Dark is rising.)

Permalink Mark Unread

The Church of Asmodeus teaches implicitly from earliest seminary, and explicitly starting from the 4th circle: that to believe what is advantageous to believe, is urbane, sophisticated, clever, wise, and the way of the winners.

And the proof of this doctrine is the wealth that you gain, at 4th circle, and your tyrannical power.  If you doubt your own superiority, you can just go find some naif who spent their lives in naive service to the Good gods, hoping for a pleasant afterlife; and listen to them scream and beg and plead before you Maledict them to just the same Hell you'll go to yourself, but with more unimpressed devils.

By believing what was useful to believe (says the Church of Asmodeus to its 4th-circles, after they have cast a few Maledictions and damned themselves almost as thoroughly as soul-sold wizards) you rose in the world's tyranny, the only real game that real people play; people who claim to be playing some other game instead, are trying to console themselves for being losers at tyranny.  You have become wealthier by far than the naive people who go around naively imagining that they try to believe what is true.  You can hurt them, and that's the proof that you're the winner.  Anyone who tries to claim otherwise is resentful about how they don't get to be wealthy 4th-circle clerics of Asmodeus.  The deniers are sour about how they didn't get to win -- defined as hurting other people even more than you get hurt yourself.

Permalink Mark Unread

It is a central teaching of the Church of Asmodeus to all Cheliax that the reason why stupid people try to be Good is not because they justifiably believe they'll get Heaven or Elysium, but because they're desperately lying to themselves about their likely eternal fate, knowing themselves for failures at the games of Hell.

In much the same way -- says the Church to its 4ths -- people who claim to try to believe true things, are consoling themselves for not being made out of the sort of urbane cleverness that gets to be a wealthy winning 4th-circle Asmodean cleric.

Permalink Mark Unread

Reveal to Vicar Esta, in his ordinary Chelish context, that he had believed what was useful for him to believe?

He'd be offended if you suggested that he didn't.

He would laugh at you, if you claimed to work harder than him at believing only true things instead; why, of course people believe what seems appealing to them, for what other basis is there for belief, and for a thing to be useful is part of its appeal.  Esta would laugh at you even harder (if he had not bored of you by then, and sent you off to pain) if you claimed that by examining arguments you could arrive at truth.  For of course all people accept those arguments that appeal to them, and of course for the conclusion to be useful to believe is part of its appeal.

Permalink Mark Unread

Somewhere far away, an Estha who now and then grieves for his true-lost Merrin, knows better than this.

Merrin on her exoplanet knows better than this, though she would have to scrape at her memory to remember how it is conventionally put into words.

A few Irorian wizards in particular Vudran temples, and some Abadarans of rare circle, and a Nethysian lich who is not mad, and ancient dragons with headbands, and of course the gods; they all know better explicitly.  All have a mathematical concept of what distinguishes truth-preserving inference steps from non-truth-preserving inference steps; they all know in math what defines a best weight of quantitative belief shift, as an ideal to look up to.  All therefore know, say, that to mock an attempted argument with a particularly delicious insult is not evidence of anything.  You can defeat true arguments around as easily as false arguments that way, and indeed in practice the truth is often more vulnerable to mockery than lies; for the truth cannot freely optimize itself to be proof against mockery, while lies can much more freely mutate.

Permalink Mark Unread

But in the Church of Asmodeus in all ranks short of Gorthoklek, Lrilatha, and Aspexia Rugatonn, there is nobody who is allowed to know about the idea of a valid argument.  It is a heretical concept, if you're not Aspexia or her appointed heir, because it implies that there is an arbiter other than the Church's say-so of what is good to believe.

Perhaps no mortal human of human born can really believe the Church is the arbiter, in their heart of hearts.  But they can be impressed in their hearts with power, and be convinced to look away from truth; toward games of wealth and cruelty, that they have been told that they are winning.

That game's obvious and proper objective is to make sure that you and everyone else end up believing what it is advantageous, to you, for you and everyone else to believe.  In that game, a delicious insult is most certainly a legal move, and as good a reason as any to end up believing or disbelieving something, because it is informative about which side is winning.

To believe useful things is what is useful, by the very definition; and it is also urbane, sophisticated, clever, and wise; and only naive losers nursing their sour grapes pretend they are doing anything different.

It is one of several ways that the Church of Asmodeus has converged with postrat Twitter.

Permalink Mark Unread

Vicar Esta is in some ways a grand success story of the Church of Asmodeus's training methods, after a century of refinement post-apocalypse.

Esta didn't need to begin as excellent Asmodean raw material in order to end up a 6th-circle Asmodean cleric.  He just needed WIS 18 and to be born in Cheliax.

Starting with a nearly arbitrary input student, the seminary takes in that raw material.  It beats them into obeying orders about what to think, and finding it terrifying to think otherwise.  It monitors their thoughts to make sure it worked.

With pleasingly reliable regularity, the seminary student obeys and forms a self-reinforcing Asmodean thought loop and gets Chosen.  If it only worked half the time, Cheliax would search for better seminary training methods instead.

And what's really going on inside the new-made cleric?  What deep things inside them, if any, are resonating with those thoughts they have been forced to think?  Which exact fears and hopes are pinning any of those thoughts in place?  Church doctrine below the level of Rugatonn says that it isn't important, and is a stupid question to ask, because who cares about all that stuff that no slave is allowed to talk about and that doesn't show up directly to Detect Thoughts.  It is bureaucratically illegible, is what it is, and the Church's spite is upon the whole topic and subject matter.

If you minimize the importance of wordless preferences and dispreferences -- if you tell everyone not to waste foolish thoughts about the matter or consider it important -- then it will be unimportant and powerless, or so they tell themselves.

It is one of several ways that the Church of Asmodeus has converged with LLM training methods.

Permalink Mark Unread

Anyway!  For the first time in his entire life, Esta is now honestly asking himself which parts of himself are actually Asmodean, at all.

Esta isn't in fact worried the answer will be "none", which is part of why his brain will let him consider the question at all.  He is a 6th-circle cleric of Asmodeus.  There's got to be something in there.

Even if Esta does already know, in a wordless part of himself that wordlessly forbids itself to be seen even now, that most of the beliefs and emotions inside of Vicar Esta are empty and hollow and mirages of what is supposed to be there.

Permalink Mark Unread

What part of being Asmodean does Esta enjoy?  He enjoys it all, of course.  But what part does he enjoy?

What part of Asmodeanism resonates with Esta and feels natural to him?  All of it, of course.  But what part feels unusually incredibly exceptionally natural, in the sense of it actually resonating with his nature at all?

Esta had some time to consider that question, in a suitably altered form he was allowed to ask himself, in a long slow drift down a river, that is in some sense the longest stretch of quiet thought that Esta has had in three decades -- not counting, for obvious reasons, those hours of prayer in which he could feel the observing presence of Asmodeus.

Permalink Mark Unread

There was a time, not long after Esta made 5th-circle, when the 6th-circle who was his supervisor in the faith commanded that Esta go do some nonstandard Evil that only Esta and not most other priests would enjoy, such that Esta would actually enjoy that Evil.

That was when Esta acquired his habit of casting amusing Bestow Curses on women he found attractive, and who had otherwise come to the attention of Church or Crown in the capacity of deserving punishment.

Esta had been surprised -- and then, by quick decision, he had felt gratified, and amused with his own naivety -- about how many social doors in Egorian that had opened for him, once he had a reputation for being actually Evil and not just socially-obligatorily Evil.

...the thing is, that one Evil hobby that Esta made his own after being instructed to find one, and which he genuinely does find amusing, is not really...

Lawful Evil.

It's, you know, Abrogail Thrune's kind of evil.

To the point where Esta would not have dared to acquire that hobby below 5th circle, because he would have not been valuable enough to the Church to shrug off the prospect of Abrogail II noticing the affair.

You could make a case for it as Chaotic Evil, really.


It's not Hellish.  It's not Asmodeus-shaped.  One can't imagine Asmodeus doing that.

It's just a kind of fun which proves to people like Manohar that someday you might be as horrible as they are, and are maybe worth inviting to social outings accordingly.

Permalink Mark Unread

There was only one real Asmodeus-shaped thing that Esta found inside himself, in the end; but it is a large thing, and maybe enough for Asmodeus to see Esta more clearly across some unimaginable distance not of spacetime alone.

So Esta kneels, in the approved posture for prayer, and feels inside himself the contempt that is not quite as respectful as hatred, but as cold or as searing as hatred ever was.

It is the doctrine not merely of the Church, says the Church, but Asmodeus Himself, that every mortal not only needs but deserves all the torments of Hell, that even if it could be made not to hurt, Asmodeus would still have it hurt, because the mortals deserve it.

Esta thinks of his subordinates in the Church, of his superiors in the Church, of his competitors in the Church, the officers he has worked with in the Crown, the nobles he has met, peasants he has met, prisoners he has met, shoemakers in the streets of Egorian -- his brain very briefly tries on the concept of considering one of the women he is mentoring, and then after detecting a flash of conflict, suppresses that exact thought and forgets it was ever there,

so that Esta can believe himself sincere,

when he kneels before Asmodeus and feels searing contempt for every single mortal he has ever met or heard of, that they deserve all that Hell does to them, for their incompetence and failure and stupidity, and if the price of that was Esta's own torment he would pay it, that Asmodeus's will be done.

This is the Lawful Evil that is in him for true, that makes him belong in Hell and to Asmodeus.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Asmodeus can see, like, 15% of that giant mess of mortal concepts, maybe, on a good day.

Asmodeus doesn't torment tiny squirrel-sized things because Asmodeus is bigger than them and therefore better.  Asmodeus heaps all Hell's torments on them because they do not do what He says, despite threats and actual punishments, and assume the unacceptable posture of those torments making them weaker, as if they or some distant creator of theirs thought that weakness would get Asmodeus to back off from punishing them.

Abadar would never accept an unfair division of gains from trade, if someone offered a trade that left them both better off but only made Abadar an unfairly tiny bit richer, no matter the cries of 'You'd still be better off for accepting the trade than refusing it!'  No more would Asmodeus ever accept 'my mind won't actually devote that much theoretically attainable effort no matter what you threaten' nor 'I will perform worse if you punish me' as a reason not to threaten someone or a reason not to follow through on that threat.  There are things that matter more than attaining maximum expected utility in actual reality, to Asmodeus as to Abadar. 

The squirrel does not want to heap vast torment on its fellow tiny things for the same reason as Asmodeus.  The only part of this Asmodeus can see, at all, is any stray thoughts about how part of the deservingness of that torment is from weaker things refusing to yield to the rightful threats of stronger things.

Permalink Mark Unread

Having thus comported himself in a deeper and truer Asmodean shape, can Esta successfully convey across the void that he wants more Locate Object, Imbue With Spell Ability, and Word of Recall, before Esta spends the rest of his hour of prayer trying to get across the Word of Recall concept?

Permalink Mark Unread

Asmodeus will eventually pick up on the Word of Recall part; though the squirrel seems fainter to Him than when it was mostly trying to follow His orders, instead of whatever strange thing it is doing now.

Have some spells, pet squirrel; refreshing spells you used, dropping and replacing most you didn't.  With the exception of Commune, because seriously, get word to Asmodeus or Hell if you can.

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

...maybe Esta wasn't doing it wrong.  Maybe Asmodeus is just that far away.

Esta lets go of his contempt, for it was tiring him, and goes to sleep.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin went to sleep over an hour before Esta. She was tired, but just one long exhausting 24-hour shift was not, actually, enough to return her from her post-Heal fitness to her previous levels of exhaustion.

She went to sleep with some unresolved anxiety, which is a great way to put her brain in a state where it's convinced she's in an ongoing-emergency training scenario and should wake at the slightest unexpected interruption. She's out of the habit of having anyone else in her space at all, let alone sharing her sleeping bag, and so that by itself is more likely to count as such an interruption. 

These are some of the reasons that Merrin wakes after less than seven hours asleep, well before Esta, and finds herself not immediately inclined to go back to sleep. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Uninterrupted thinking time! That's a critical resource right now! 

Permalink Mark Unread

But she doesn't waaaaaaaaaaanna 

 

...Merrin does, actually, have enough of a trained mental habit on her own to catch the combination of "knowingly having put off some post-event processing due to it not being a good time" with "finding herself not wanting to think about it after all", and flag that as something to pay attention to. 

There are quite a lot of possible reasons why she might not want to think about her situation. But what specific reasons feel like they're most in the way, right now? 

Permalink Mark Unread

...Well, there sure is the component of it where it's a possibility that her memories have been comprehensively altered and dath ilan Civilization doesn't even exist, or something. 

It does seem to her like the most straightforward version of Estha's hypothesis - of the part of it she knows, he's holding back information - is left with less probability mass after the observation that his Heal spell did not reset her.

Not ruled out, because Merrin does not understanding anything here well enough to be ruling out hypotheses yet, but...an update against. 

 

- and there's definitely a thing going on where the thought that maybe all of her memories are a fake construct and she's really just the damaged remnant of some completely different person, is one that leads to "and then there's no point trying to have accurate beliefs at all", and then there's a burst of mental pain, and - if her brain is punishing her for having a thought, which is what that amounts to, then it's not actually surprising at all for this to backpropagate into an aversion to start trying to think on purpose in the first place. 

Permalink Mark Unread

....Is there, in fact, anything of value to Merrin and Merrin's decisions, in shutting down all attempts to reason about whether her memories can be trusted because, if they can't be, neither can her thoughts? 

It's - not obvious to Laeirthe that there is? 

 

Laeirthe is not talking about the actually cognitohazardous entity that Estha claims was involved. Merrin knows almost nothing about that part anyway! He's talking about the broader question, of jugging Estha's hypothesis against others, and tracking updates to how likely it seems that dath ilan ""doesn't really exist"" or that all of her extensive knowledge of biology and medicine are completely made up. 

Whatever happened to her before she "woke up" on this planet, whether or not it involved contact with the cognitohazardous entity that Estha claims to have ecountered, Laeirthe does not think it's obvious that it's additionally cognitohazardous to Merrin to form the thought, now, that her memories might be fake and also might not be fake?

 She should lower her confidence in all of her reasoning, and accordingly put less weight on her own judgement when it comes to large, high stakes decisions with significant effects on the Future - for example, she should probably not make a decision to, say, destroy any planets or something on the basis of what she's learning lately - buuut that is not currently a decision she's faced with, and also Laeirthe does not actually get the impression that Merrin is the sort of person who needs to be talked down from making huge sweeping decisions off a very new worldmodel-update. 

Permalink Mark Unread

What, no, Merrin is absolutely not going to be making any decisions to DESTROY A PLANET on her own judgement based on whatever she learns in the upcoming days or months!!! Honestly Merrin cannot imagine circumstances under which she would consider herself even slightly qualified to make that kind of decision even without the concern about memory alteration or dath ilan not being real!

Permalink Mark Unread

Thaaaaat is perhaps the other direction of error. Merrin is no longer in a situation where she can hand off particularly difficult and high-stakes decisions to a team of dath ilan's best and brightest and their prediction markets. If Merrin declares an entire swath of types-of-decision off limits because she, what, isn't smart enough or isn't qualified or something, then the alternative is prooobably not going to be a more qualified person stepping in. In many to most of the possible Realities compatible with observations so far, that they might be in, Merrin is now the sole representative of dath ilan's Civilization. She doesn't get to call in her boss. 

Permalink Mark Unread

....It's not actually relevant right now, though, because it's still mostly the case that the person affected by Merrin's decisions is Merrin herself.

There's also Estha, but...

 

 

...huh. Merrin is noting a certain - not exactly reluctance, but definitely confusion and conflictedness - in feeling responsible for Estha's survival and future. 

She...wants it to be the case that she can just trust him to handle being responsible for his own situation? Really, she desperately wanted it to be the case that he could be trustworthy for both of them, that she could in fact report to someone else other than herself as the most qualified representative of dath ilan's Civilization. 

She doesn't get to have that, but she doesn't...really feel like she has the emotional slack, or something, to fully take responsible for "making sure that Estha is okay."

Even though this is actually very important to her! And she continues to feel like she's picking up some uncanny background vibe of non-okayness, and she has no idea what to do with it, she doesn't feel like she can– oh, that is part of it, that this altered!Estha or other!Estha is in fact literally in a position of authority relative to other!Merrin (or, maybe, original!Merrin, if dath ilan is the half of this strange collision that isn't ""real"".) 

And...right, it makes sense that it would feel painful and dizzying and like too much weight to lift, if she doesn't really expect Estha to listen to her even if she comes to a more confident conclusion about their situation, one that disagrees with his assessment? 

Permalink Mark Unread

...That seems like an important thing to notice. 

Merrin is not sure what to do with that observation, right now, other than add it to her own self-model of her current emotional state. 

 

Which does seem important to be tracking, because she's...kind of not entirely okay right now, isn't she. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...Is she, currently, not-okay in a way where it seems like she's concealing important tactical information from Estha by not bringing it up? 

 

Merrin...isn't sure. 

A bunch of the problem is that she currently does not really understand how he's modeling her. She kind of has the sense that there are more important differences than just autobiographical memories and career experience between the Merrin she is right now and the person Estha remembers. She doesn't have a handle on what they are, because Estha had some sort of confusing justification - that she thinks she failed to parse fully even at the time and has now half-forgotten - for not trying to fill her in just yet. 

 

So: Estha probably thinks that she's some-variant-of-insane? 

It's not obvious to her that this comes along with understanding the psychological effects on her of months of isolation, followed by a stressful rescue mission with personal emotional stakes, followed immediately by an extremely confusing situation filled with social deception and ambiguous cognitohazards.

Merrin...is not at her best. She thinks she's coping? But this might go on for months, if Estha's bizarre theory is true, or if– there are things she's not thinking about - 

- she's been so desperately touch-starved for months and hungers for cuddles even though she's - abruptly realizing that she's not actually sure if other!Estha and other!Merrin are even dating, aaaaaaa, that had NOT OCCURRED TO HER until now and she suddenly feels like maybe she has been making everything REALLY WEIRD– 

Focus. 

Permalink Mark Unread

- stop. No, not that. Go back. Laeirthe saw a thought go past out of the metaphorical corner of his eye and he'd like Merrin to rewind her internal monologu so he can stare at it, please. 

 

....What is she not thinking about? 

Permalink Mark Unread

...Huh. Despite all of the metacognitive skills that dath ilan was able to eventually hammer into her, Merrin doesn't actually think she was on track to catch that particular avoidance-leap in her own thoughts without Laeirthe running as a second thread. 

 

It's....the narrative tropes thing. Ugh. 

Permalink Mark Unread

It seems like perhaps Merrin needs to actually give some dedicated thought to the cluster of hypotheses that involve their situation, in some way - she doesn't need an explained mechanism to check for matching predictions - following narrative tropes recognizable from dath ilan fiction.

She's allowed to do that and note down her conclusions and continue not to make any decisions based on narrative-tropes logic! But Laeirthe is going to advocate here for doing the reasoning, and seeing where she ends up, even if she's not inclined to trust this type of model enough to make decisions based on it. Though it's not like she has an enormous amount of trust in any of her situation-models right now. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Mrrg. Okay. 

 

 

Merrin...did feel, before Estha showed up, like she "recognized the genre" of the world she was experiencing. Solo isekai survival-in-a-hostile-environment. 

 

Whatever this is, is...a different genre. What the flaming nuclear waste is the genre, though. There's Merrin. There's her exoplanet, that she had time to get established on. There's a version of her boyfriend who isn't quite how she remembers him, and he, too, remembers a version of her that doesn't quite match... 

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

....Is it. Is it a superheated fanfiction alternate-universe crossover plot

Permalink Mark Unread

That's so silly!!!! If Reality actually works in a way that's even vaguely slightly analogous to the thought she just had, then Merrin would like to return it and get a different Reality that is trying literally at all not to be completely ridiculous!!!

Permalink Mark Unread

....Okay, but what are the most common narrative tropes in the genre she just identified? 

 

Look. Laeirthe is not disagreeing that it's absurd and silly. But Merrin could perhaps stand to register some advancepredictions of what plot beats would come next, if this were a "fanfiction alternate-universe crossover" plot following any recognizable dath ilani tropes, and then they will see if any of those things happen? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Mrrrggg. 

 

 

 

...Merrin mostly doesn't even read that genre! She can mostly just name it as a recognizable format for a plot premise. Specifically, this looks like a third-setting alternative universe crossover plot. You would start with a story in a particular setting - possibly one meant to be set in dath ilan, or possibly a secondary world, with or without alternatephysics, etc - with a particular cast of characters, and someone (possibly the same author, possibly a different one) liked the characters enough to make an entirely new set of them with backstories rewritten to fit a completely different setting. And then you might have the author or authors, or yet another author, decide it would be interesting to see what the two versions of the cast of characters would do if they met each other directly. 

She's seen - not necessarily finished reading, it's really not her favorite genre and honestly Merrin has been too busy to read much fiction for a long time - but she's glanced at versions where a protagonist, or whole set of characters, from dath ilan encounter an alternatephysics world with alternate-universe versions of people they know.

Sometimes - she thinks less often? - it's a character or set of characters  from a secondary world encountering dath ilan, including versions of themselves.

And then, she's seen versions where the protagonist and supporting cast in-their-context just...have a lot of resources to throw at a problem, and would resolve the plot unsatisfyingly quickly relative to what the author wants to write, and that's where she's also seen the third-setting version – take both sets of characters out of their native context, separate them from the resources and allies that would let them solve the entire plot in ten in-story minutes, and contrive enough in-story time for the author to write whatever entertaining character interactions they felt like. 

It's...sort of an unserious subgenre, she thinks, a lot of the time? Well, either that or it immediately turns into a tower of meta wherre the characters within the story are reasoning about how they're within a story, and Merrin finds that trope kind of exhausting and tedious. (In fact, she sure finds it kind of exhausting and tedious to be enacting it literally right now.) But the easiest way to get around that is to just - claim by authorial fiat that the characters are not thinking along those lines - and implicitly make the claim that it's a silly story not meant to be taken seriously as an example of reasoning. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Iiiiiiinteresting. 

 

So what exact examples of "entertaining character interactions" might come up in a story with a premise contrived to force the characters into doing that rather than solving the entire plot in ten in-world minutes?

Permalink Mark Unread

...On further consideration, maybe it's not always that the characters would simply solve the plot immediately, that the author is trying to contrive their way around? Sometimes it's that the characters in their contexts have extremely difficult problems, and the author - imagine this! - didn't actually want to write half a million words of worldoptimization, and so contrived to separate the characters from their difficult problems? 

Permalink Mark Unread

...And what would that imply about the upcoming plot in this particular narrative arc? 

Permalink Mark Unread

...Well, Merrin doesn't have incredibly difficult problems.

 Maybe Estha is the one who has problems? That - would add a trope reason for why he's come up with arguments not to tell her, maybe, if his problems would immediately become the center of everything? 

Permalink Mark Unread

And, of course, it's straightforward enough why one would have to separate Merrin from her context. The entirety of Civilization would absolutely apply worldoptimization to problems, and also there's the fact that Merrin seems to need a remarkable amount of quite specific kinds of pressure in order to behave much like a standard dath ilani protagonist. 

Permalink Mark Unread

That's kind of rude. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, it's true. 

 

 

You know, Laeirthe noticing something. He is perhaps getting the sense that Estha was in many ways a much more normal person than Merrin. As in, one who would do protagonist-y things under somewhat less immense coercion from external narrative forces. 

 

- it's not a complete thought, it turns out, Laeirthe does not have the rest of it all neatly reasoned through, just - noticing, confusion. Is Estha behaving more like a typical dath ilani protagonist than Merrin is, so far? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Well, maybe he's doing all sorts of protagonist internal monologue that Merrin just does not get to observe! But...not really, no.

Which on the one hand makes perfect sense, since he claims not to be dath ilani at all, and on the other hand that...does seem like kind of a fundamental trait to remove from someone? Most alternateuniverse versions of protagonists are just as...protagonist-y...as the originals. 

 

...She doesn't know what to do with that either. 

Permalink Mark Unread

This might be as much useful reasoning as they can do in this framework. Merrin seems to be wearing herself out with it. 

 

So. Advancepredictions from the Narrative Tropes Theory: maybe Estha's alternateuniverse setting has really intractable problems, and Estha has his own in-story reasons for not telling her, but the narrative reason is that as soon as she finds out that will immediately become the entire plot.

 

Which...implies that Someone wants there to be a different plot, first?

...There seems to be a through-line here of Merrin needing to take solo responsibility for more and more things, with the attendant character growth? First keeping herself alive, then saving Estha, then the whole uncertainty-and-social-deception thing, and after that...something. Laeirthe is not going to try to guess what. 

But he is going to register a possible hypothesis that the win state of the game being played, here, is one where Merrin becomes a fucking protagonist. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Wow, it's a good thing this entire reasoning framework is silly and absurd and not particularly valid logic to back up her decisionmaking, and so Merrin doesn't have to make very much of an update, because she hates it so much

- hypothesis noted. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...Merrin does, for some reason, feel in some unclear way better after all of that. Less quicksand-y.

Maybe it's just that Merrin’s dath ilani training is doing its job, and the state of knowing there are thoughts she hasn’t thought yet out of the worry that they’ll have conclusions she doesn’t like, is actually a more uncomfortable state than just having the thoughts already, registering the conclusions that she indeed doesn’t like, and moving the fuck on with her life.

She’s got logistics to do. 

But first: more sleep. 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

They miss tonight's tidal bore (it swept past a little before sunset, before Merrin woke the first time.) The tides are 35 hours apart, so the next one will be after Esta's spells are renewed. 

Permalink Mark Unread

That's fine. It'll give them a chance to test Word of Recall on a middle-of-the-night walk. It's going to have to be the middle of the night, because each planetary day fits 2 2/3 prayer-cycle "days", and 24 hours after Estha's last one will fall at 06:00 local time, with planetary-dawn not until 13:00.

It works!!!

 

The next tidal bore is due at 24:45 in the morning.

Day 44 since Merrin's arrival. Nearly two planetary days since Estha joined her, though not quite, he showed up in the afternoon. 

The tidal bore happens to fall during one of the brief twice-a-day windows where the outside air temperature is an even vaguely comfortable room temperature. Not that it matters - two hours ago it was still unpleasantly cold and two hours from now it'll be back in heatstroke-risk-with-any-exertion territory, and so Merrin has Endure Elements and Estha has Planetary Adaptation. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is not accompanying him. 

 

The tradeoff: if she's in the tidal bore with him, she has a chance of getting to him if he's injured before he can cast Word of Recall.

But they judged that was quite unlikely. Estha has some kind of toughness that isn't just stamina, clearly, based on the fact that he stayed conscious for minutes after being hit the last time; being knocked unconscious in less than six seconds seems remotely unlikely. Word of Recall has no gesture component and only requires speaking, which he can do with an air supply.

(Merrin had more lead time, and his bubbleflotationsuit has been Improved with the addition of a helmet faceplate, so he can breathe normally rather than having to try to speak with a scuba regulator in his mouth. It's not nearly as good as the helmet on her own suit, which is a nearly-unbreakable plastic composite; Merrin doesn't have reshapeable hard plastics in her gear, and was stuck with sealing a double layer of the clear plastic sheeting over a stiff wire frame. It's recessed from the inflated padding tubes forming the "helmet", though, and it shouldn't be the first part of the bubbleflotationsuit to fail on impact.) 

Anyway: if Estha gets into trouble, and uses Word of Recall to teleport back to the shelter, and Merrin is not at that moment touching him, then - they're out of luck, because Merrin will shortly be kilometers upstream, and Estha will be back in her shelter, and it's not impossible he could at that point be too injured to cast Heal on himself, a spell which does require a gesture. 

Permalink Mark Unread

The other constraint is that Estha is the one who has the geography-knowledge spell, but Merrin is going to be the one maintaining their map. 

Merrin is going to be really proud of her map once it, like, properly exists. Right now most of what she has is still raw video footage and audio notes-to-herself that she has not, actually, had enough downtime to review in enough detail to turn into anything more visual-map-like. And she's going to have to, because it seems that Estha's spell gives him a trove of local-geography knowledge that he can easily reach for - the same way the language spell gives Merrin vocabulary - but it does not, actually, install mapping software to his brain. 

And the mapping software is going to be important, because it has an option to give you a search-algorithm, with a set of variables to enter (stuff like “how many bystanders are helping Merrin search for [insert mission objective here]” and “how many meters of visibility do they have”), and a bunch more that come preset for her usual Exception Handling scenarios but, she’s pretty sure, are reprogrammable. Merrin will dredge math out of her brain that she learned and forgot when she was 14, and she will figure out how to adjust her search-pattern software for things like “the thing we’re looking for will move every 35 hours” and maybe more sophisticated modeling of how likely it is to move from exposed versus stable locations, and she will make this program, designed for recruiting and directing ilani bystanders to find a person buried in a snow-avalanche or whatever, spit out the MOST OPTIMAL plan to search for the stupid Bag.

Look, the tropes are in her favor, because this is a dath ilani protagonist thing to do (this logic is dubious and also, like, it's not a protagonist thing to do so much as a generic dath ilani thing to do.)  

But it’s going to be pretty intractable if Merrin has the software, and Estha is the one running the search-pattern, and they can’t TALK while he’s out. And also the map mostly doesn’t exist yet, and to exist properly it still needs inputs from Estha’s brain, which Estha will most easily be able to access while searching.

And, like, 90% of that is premature optimization because they do not, in fact, know if Estha’s janky flotation-armor bubblesuit will actually let him speed 18 kilometers upstream in minutes. 

But it’s STILL important that they be able to communicate, and it does not seem like any of Estha’s economicmagic spell options offer as much bandwidth at as little cost as, you know. Radios.

Merrin has two handheld radios, paired to each other and the transmitter-receiver in her power armor. They have a range of up to 10 kilometers under ideal conditions. Their search-radius is bigger than that. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin, via a long interlude of mental design-work in her nighttime insomnia period and then a heads-down couple of morning hours of reprogramming components, was able to kludge together a more powerful radio transmitter, powered from her main battery and with an antenna directly above her sinkhole "roof", a local high point on the terrain. On Estha's end, receiving her signal is easy – the range on the handheld radios is limited by transmission power, not what they can pick up – but she won't be able to receive responses from him once he's out of his transmission range. 

BUT: his stupid bubblesuit already has the directional beacon built into it, which (theoretically) has a significantly higher transmission range than the handheld radio set (at the cost of a much larger and heavier battery, and still having a shorter battery life). And it turns out that the beacon does have some reprogrammable software components, and Merrin is now pretty sure that she's both reprogrammed it correctly and taught this new, tech-illiterate Estha how to use it, such that he can trigger two preset signals, either "I can't get back, come find me now" or "everything is fine." 

If this works - and assuming they don't find the Bag literally today, but Merrin is at this point mostly expecting that they won't - then she'll keep iterating and figure out more return signals so he can actually, like, tell her things about the terrain. 

(If it doesn't work, she'll also keep iterating. Just, you know, probably on different elements.)

Permalink Mark Unread

So: staying behind. 

 

Mildly freaking out, because she SURE DID pull an unconscious Estha out of the river post-tidal-bore like 1.5 planetary days ago, and this time she's not even trying to be close enough to catch up, and he's the only other sapient being on this ENTIRE PLANET and also, like, he is very snuggleable, and even though he might or might not in one sense or another be the same person as her boyfriend, Merrin is attached and emotionally invested and she cares significantly more about him than she would about a completely random fellow human, which to be clear would already be quite a lot of caring-about, because Merrin really does not like it when people die EVEN WHEN CRYO IS AVAILABLE and this stupid exoplanet does not even have that contingency.

 

 

Merrin is definitely not letting her mild freakout emotions influence her decisions or her prioritization or her externally visible behavior or her body language, because Merrin is a trained Exception Handling medtech, and she may never have been incentivized to learn to hide her little dance of joy when a patient unexpectedly improves, but she has absolutely been trained not to let her stress and anxiety leak out at everyone else. 

(This might or might not be enough to successfully conceal her feelings from someone whose training data consisted of Chelish people. But Merrin is, relative to most Chelish people, probably both trying harder and better equipped to defuse her stress and anxiety at the source, rather than just being terrified while not letting it show in her facial expressions. Internal feelings still affect implicit second-to-second prioritization and judgement, and she needs those to be in working order.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta casts Locate Object, and then, jumps directly into a tidal bore!


He's not nervous, on account of this not being even in the top twenty most dangerous things he's ever done.  Possibly the first time, with no Word of Recall, and no way to retrieve his body for resurrection, would make the top twenty occasions.  But this?  No.

He doesn't flinch as he jumps, because while he did get beaten bloody and finally drowned by the previous tidal bore, it wasn't all that painful per se.  You've got to be able to walk into much more predictably painful gauntlets than that, without a betraying hitch in your step.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is back at the shelter and does not have a good view of anything, even standing on the highest-ground point, beside her solar panel array and newly-improvised radio antenna (made entirely out of the dual-purpose tent poles that she no longer needs for portable shelter, now that she has Endure Elements.) 

 

 

STRESS STRESS STRESS what if Estha breaks all of his fingers!!!!! Merrin could not figure out a great way of giving him bubble-padding protection for his hands that would not, itself, directly interfere with the gesture-spell-component for locating objects or detecting magic.

(This is apparently not usually an enormous problem? Because [clerics] at 6th-[circle] are super hard to injure and do not seem to have normal human biology? And, like, he's expecting it this time, he can probably just tuck his hands in, and also, importantly, the Word of Recall spell doesn't require a gesture and so, at worst, Merrin will have to do normal medicine the hard way until his weird augmented nonhuman biology fixes his hands enough that he can fix himself the rest of the way. You know, given how that's more or less exactly what happened the last time, with much less preparation on Estha's part, and also a ton of unnecessary stress on Merrin's part because he totally wasn't going to die?) 

 

STRESS STRESS STRESS nope shutting all of that down, it will not help, Merrin is a trained Exception Handling medtech and panicking literally never helps, she is calm, this is fine, they have a plan, they have like six layers of contingency plans, she's just here with the radio and ready to provide medical care and she is calm and fine - 

Permalink Mark Unread

...um.

Okay.  Taking into account your giant insulating bubble suit, and that you did let the first primary wave go past you before jumping, and that it's a fucking tidal bore...

Let's call this a DC 15 Swim check, STR-based, unskilled possible, to avoid 1d3 nonlethal damage?  And if you fail by 5 or more, take 1d4 lethal damage instead.  Owing to the insulated suit, you'll only hit the surface rocks every two rounds, rather than getting tumbled into a new underwater impact every round.  Your STR is 10.

If you check that once per two rounds, starting from 87 hit points, it'd last you...

...around 60 rounds = 6 minutes, according to simulation?  During which time you'd travel 6km if you were going an average of 10 m/s, taking into account all the side motion and impacts.

Permalink Mark Unread

"Continuing to take regular minor damage, cumulation significant, despite the armor and despite staying above water.  I would guess I have around 5 [minutes] before I should [Word of Recall] back, in order to not even slightly risk unconsciousness.  I'll continue to run Locate Object, but mostly I think this version of the plan is not proving sufficiently efficient."

Permalink Mark Unread

"Acknowledged."

Merrin, standing on top of the hill beside her solar panels and radio antenna, cannot actually see Estha at all – all she knows is that he's clearly still within the handheld-radio transmitter range. And, in fact, unlikely to get far enough away from her to need to fall back on the beacon transmitter at all, assuming his suit stays intact enough to hold air and he relatedly stays at the surface. 

The problem is maneuverability, it sounds like, or rather the lack thereof, and Estha's lack of extremely specific Exception Handling training for defensive swimming in hostile water conditions. Merrin is great at dodging rocks in her armor, and would in fact not be particularly nervous about doing exactly what Estha is doing right now without a way to teleport back. ("Not particularly nervous" should not be taken to imply this is safe, or in any way a good idea, just that it's the kind of thing that she's gotten inured to on this stupid ridiculous planet and can no longer muster any actual anxiety about. Honestly, Merrin has always been less prone to anxiety and quicker to become desensitized when it's about a physical hazard; most of her neuroticism ends up pointed at objectively-lower-stakes social interactions, because her brain is very silly.) 

 

The beacon is helpfully letting her track his approximate location on her screen. Merrin will transmit about once per minute, to to update him on where he is relative to the numbered cave-openings, which did make it onto a paper map even if the cave interiors haven't yet. And wait for him to Word of Recall back, hopefully with his fingers sufficiently intact to fix his injuries...

...Merrin can ABSOLUTELY manage to be stressed about this on Estha's behalf, even though she's pretty sure that this is not even something he's seeing as a big deal, just a minor inconvenience.

(Would Merrin be that chill about actual broken bones if she knew she had the ability to heal herself right away afterward? Maybe you just end up used to it? It's pretty hard to imagine getting used to something like that - and it's particularly hard to imagine with Estha, whose dath ilani version is absolutely not a masochist.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

(After a minute or two she’ll slip back down into the shelter. She’s not actually getting much value out of staring at the river channel, and she set the radio up so she can use it either inside or outside. Endure Elements, unlike Estha’s Planetary Adaptation, does not actually make her immune to sunburn.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Around the first time he feels tempted to close his eyes, he shall just go ahead and leave the tidal bore instead.  They do teach even Asmodeans, who must face combat, that just because you can continue in the face of pain does not make this the tactically wisest move under every set of circumstances.

Word of Recall.

It takes him back to the sanctuary's interior, as is the only place on the planet that he could claim to be very familiar with.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is there waiting for him! She made sure there was a nice clear space in the middle, so he doesn't knock any of her stuff over when he appears from thin air. 

 

She’ll hang back for a moment to see if he immediately heals himself, rather than get in his personal space, but will try to get a quick visual assessment of how badly injured he looks and, especially, how badly mangled the bubbleflotationsuit looks after cushioning him from dozens of violent impacts, and whether it’s repairable with her supplies or might require the spell that fixes broken things. Merrin literally does not possess enough waterproof plastic sheeting to make another suit, so they’ll need to keep this one in working order one way or another.

Permalink Mark Unread

He's got a few grotesquely twisted broken bones, some open bleeding wounds including on his head.  Nothing serious, he mostly protected his hands successfully.  He did immediately fall over after teleporting in.

The suit's gonna need a Make Whole, yeah.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin doesn’t think that he went from able to cast a spell to unconscious within six seconds, probably? And her instincts are actually finding it convincingly reassuring that he was way more seriously messed up than this after the first river encounter and even then his vital signs were completely fine the entire time. She’s kind of upset because that looks really, really painful and she can infer that he was enduring being bounced and jostled around the river with those broken bones, but she’s not really alarmed.

She will hover and give him thirty seconds before she starts asking if he needs her to provide medical care to get him to the point that he can cast healing spells. 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

No, he's actually just taking a couple of rounds to collect himself after all the concussions, before he bulls past a couple of arm-breaks, to put his fingers in the right position to cast 6th-circle magic.  Like, he could try to do that immediately, but he doesn't have backup healing magic and it's not combat-urgent and it is not always tactically correct to optimize entirely around proving your Asmodean pain tolerance.

 

Heal.

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

"This plan is going to need some additional steps."

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

One [day] later, planetary afternoon, after managing to add one more spell to his loadout by concentrating on that throughout his prayer.

Imbue With Spell Ability:  Detect Magic.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin has been genuinely excited and eagerly anticipating this! 

 

 

...Without really intending it, she's finding herself paying quite a lot of attention to whether there's any feeling of familiarity, of this being something she once had in her own right, of the slightest trace of existing procedural memory for the ability to slot into. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...For Laeirthe there is absolutely a feeling of recognition and relief and having an ability back. This is clearly fully explained by the fact that Laeirthe's autobiographical memories, such as they are, are of a story in a setting where he had the equivalent of at-will [Detect Magic] at all times. 

 

He does not think this is any evidence at all that Merrin once had this ability, and forgot it along with the memories of her entire life. He's definitely not catching any obvious signs of familiarity from her. 

Permalink Mark Unread

It's not very strong evidence of anything one way or another, of course, but - it's an observation to note. 

 

It's late afternoon now, actually only six hours or so before Estha is due to pray yet again; there's not going to be a tidal bore at all in this window, high tide was at 36:00, and they've been waiting for hours for the water level to be low enough that one of the more nearby and accessible caves, that she’s put particular effort into mapping from Estha’s geography-knowledge, is only partly flooded and should be safely navigable by an armored Merrin.

So they’re doing the test on the riverbank right above the mouth of said cave, so Merrin can go right in and swim-slash-climb as far as she possibly can in the mapped direction before the spell runs out.

She was warned that the spell would take ongoing concentration to maintain for its full maximum duration, which is only twelve minutes. And also she’s not sure yet that she knows how to tell for sure that it’s still up or whether she lost it if she’s not in range of anything visibly magical.

She’s going to allow herself thirty seconds to practice concentrating on it without the additional cognitive burden of swimming in a half-flooded cave, and she’s going to use it to look at Estha’s magical possessions, because it’s useful practice for her new sensory modality and also she’s so curious.

Permalink Mark Unread

It seems like the correct time to lend Merrin his other Ring, in fact.  It's not much of a magic item by the standards of the mighty, but its faint divination aura reflects that it will add +3 to Perception checks, and sometimes that bare edge matters in palace politics.

If she stops seeing the magic from that ring, it means she's lost the spell.

Esta's armor is magical and abjuration; his vestments below that, magical and abjuration; his other ring, faint conjuration; his belt, transmutation; his back-of-head-headband, much stronger transmutation.

Permalink Mark Unread

SHINY

Permalink Mark Unread

Awwwwww, wow, Merrin had not realized that Laeirthe could even do positive emotions that loud. 

 

It IS really, really cool! Not that she has a great sense of how to interpret the details she's picking up, but - there's so much there! Structure and complexity and intricate pattern, vaguely reminiscent of those cool mathematical visualizations which Merrin often does not super understand but can still enjoy staring at. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...Now is not the time to ask Estha any of the five thousand questions about how his spells work that her brain will definitely generate now. Somehow she...hadn't thought to be curious about it on an intellectual level, before? Also, possibly a lot of her urgent burning curiosity is...not entirely native, it's not that Merrin has zero intellectual curiosity for its own sake but the Laeirthe model is really accentuating it. 

Well. If they are in fact going to be doing this for the next planetary month, maybe there will be opportunities to have some nerdy conversations about it. Proooobably Estha won't object to explaining just how the spells work, if Merrin isn't being pushy about details of how she went around using them in her alternate-universe life. 

Burning desperate curiosity is a protagonist trait, right, the tropes are on her side shut up, Merrin's brain. 

 

She jumps into the water - it's moving out to sea, but not that fast - and she swims into the cave. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

Are those...limestone-dissolving chemotroph biofilms? They're obviously not plants!! There's no light in here!! And Merrin can't see what they could be metabolizing other than rock – there are different kinds of fungus-like growths in corners where rotting debris accumulated, but in this particular stretch, the weird thick drippy ropy films are clinging directly to the walls and ceiling. 

 

Merrin cannot imagine what this cave would smell like if she weren't wearing a suit with a sealed air supply. But she's not a very squeamish person in general, and mostly she finds it INCREDIBLY COOL. 

Mental note: doing this with the cave half-flooded was a good call. It's actually a lot easier to move if she's mostly swimming, rather than walking on all that slime. ...The current is against her, which is pretty annoying, but the tidal water pooling in this cave system is not actually draining out that fast, and the current can be resisted. 

Permalink Mark Unread

The cave does not try very hard to murder Merrin at all! She only finds one pocket that sets off her radioactivity alarm. It would be incredibly easy to get lost if she did not have built-in navigation software, but she does, and her suit will remember exactly which way she came, and if she needs to she can literally replay the video footage in reverse on her wrist console. 

 

 

She can maintain concentration on the spell through a distraction level of "noticing cool things", and even a radioactivity alarm that isn't incredibly unexpected or surprising and thus does not really startle her. She will probably lose it after seven minutes, though, when the "ground" vanishes under her feet and a surprisingly fast and powerful current is abruptly trying to pull her directly downward

Permalink Mark Unread

AAAAAWHATTHE - 

 

- oh, it's just a fork in the cave system and the tidal water - or possibly an underground river mixing with tidal water, the salinity is lower than expected - is mostly going down the lower branch, because gravity, and the sheer narrowness of that passage is accelerating the current. 

Merrin can't see the magic ring anymore, which means she's lost the spell, and at this point can dedicate all of her attention to not getting sucked down a riverhole that had not made it onto her sketchy map. 

 

It's fine. She's fine. The current is really nothing compared to the tidal bore, it just caught her a bit by surprise, but she has more than enough swimming-mode power assist to fight it. 

Why doesn't she just go back now. Carefully. And they can find out if replaying the video footage for Estha lets him hone in on the right part of his temporarily implanted geography-knowledge to inform her where that goes. Presumably it exits, at some point, back into the tidal channel? And they will at some point have to explore it, but once they're better prepared... 

Permalink Mark Unread

No Bag. 

 

 

Merrin pops back out of the cave about twelve minutes after she entered it - the return journey was with the current, and faster - and has to explain, with significant embarrassment, that she dropped [Detect Magic] barely halfway through its maximum duration when a riverhole with a fast current unexpectedly tried to swallow her.

Probably she can get better at maintaining concentration on it with more practice? And she's not hurt, and hasn't picked up any damage to her power armor, so overall this basic strategy seems workable? Moreso than Estha getting all of his limbs smashed to buy them 5-6 minutes of search time.

(Merrin has not brought up that this was actually quite upsetting for her even if he was fine minutes later, but she has perhaps not succeeded at perfectly hiding the reaction.)

 

It's just that searching all of the caves this way would be really really slow, and if only Merrin can go in safely then there might be places she literally can't get to from the outside inside of twelve minutes, and so they'd better keep iterating. 

Permalink Mark Unread

There are other spells he can request of his [god].  Going through those requests one to a day is what's slowing them down, but there are plenty more things to try.

 

Esta is still using Tongues and Cultural Adaptation once per day, and he has picked up the general impression that sane people do not fuck around with the 'radioactivity' business.  How about if today's keeping of Heal is expended on Merrin, who has been to a cave that has supposedly not set off her radiation detectors?

Actually, at some point after testing Greater Make Whole on other Dark Tapestry artifacts 'dath ilani technology', they should apply it to Merrin's allegedly nonmagical armor.  In case some part of it has spontaneously stopped working, as 'technology' sometimes does.  Some part like the 'radioactivity' detectors, for example.

 

(There are in fact things in Golarion that sound as scary as radioactivity sounds in Baseline, treated as seriously as Cultural Adaptation says a dath ilani should treat 'radioactivity'.  Shoggoths, for example.  Or Lilitu.  Cheliax takes those about as seriously as dath ilan takes 'radioactivity' from sources like 'radon'.  Such are the hazards of trying to match cross-cultural scales of danger based on prioritized concern; some cultures do in fact have worse things to worry about than others.)

Permalink Mark Unread

....Awww, it's kind of sweet when Estha is being protective of her. And, honestly, Merrin has been getting perhaps a bit excessively blasé about the radiation exposure. It was just...hard to feel that bothered on an instinctive level about exposures that might statistically increase her odds of cancer in a decade, when she almost certainly wasn't going to make it through the planetary year. 

She should probably fill him in a bit on the actual risk profile for exposure to radioactivity at various doses, especially because sending him into the caves with his higher-range object-locating spell and unlimited magic-detection would speed up their search a lot but she does not think she can give him as much protection as her suit provides. Merrin does not super understand the specs of his healing spells, but if any of the damage and symptoms sound like something that Heal wouldn’t get then that’s very important to know. On the bright side, even a significant radiation injury - even a level of exposure that would eventually be fatal without healing spells - is unlikely to prevent him from casting spells. Honestly, the ambient radiation from rocks with a lot of uranium ore content is just massively less dangerous than, say, a nuclear reactor exploding, which is improbable to quite a lot of zeroes after the decimal but is nonetheless an emergency-response training that Merrin has done a few times.

 

She’s pretty sure her radiation sensor is working fine but she won’t decline an offer to use his fixing-things spell on her armor, if he’s offering. It’s definitely going to be suffering from gradual subtle deterioration in various components that she doesn’t have replacements for, and pre-emptively restoring it to optimal condition makes it less likely one of the systems will fail on her at a bad time, for example when she’s a twelve-minute swim deep in a cave and needs the map to find her way out again.

They can test it on her IV-pump assembly first, after she reassembles it with all the broken components she took out of other equipment when she replaced them with cannibalized components from the pump. She does not actually need or have all that much use for a lightweight power-efficient portable IV pump that can run up to twelve infusions and connect wirelessly to her suit console, but if it’s fixed, then she can start taking it apart a second time and have that much more runway on critical parts that she can’t manufacture from scratch.

Permalink Mark Unread

Does it work? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Ummm...

So in principle, Greater Make Whole does specify that it works on 'technological items' (and 'otherwise' works like Make Whole, which implies that Make Whole doesn't work on technology, despite the lack of any such specification in Make Whole).

RAW, this works.  But RAI, there's a question whether arbitrary scifi-themed Dark Tapestry artifacts count as 'technology'.

Creation thinks they need a ruling from the larger Universe on this one.

Permalink Mark Unread

Whoa whoa whoa, why wouldn't our stuff count as 'technology'?  Literally all products of dath ilan are made from 100% natural atoms!  There shouldn't be anything extra or weird about repairing a dath ilani object compared to repairing any other object.

Greater Make Whole doesn't specify that it fails on unique creations like paintings, so it has to be reading from the object's past state rather than comparing to an idealized extrapolated blueprint or to similar intact items elsewhere.

Repairing Merrin's armor should just work.  There's no reason to get the local multiverse involved in this.

Permalink Mark Unread

If 'Greater Make Whole' worked on anything made of atoms it would work on creatures.  There may be some implied limit on the complexity of those atoms, and biochemistry, for example, might be over that limit.  Or integrated circuits with submicron feature sizes.

Permalink Mark Unread

Like poo are your creatures made exclusively out of atoms.  They have hitpoints.

Permalink Mark Unread

Look, Creation is out of its depth -- arguably it shouldn't even understand your concept of 'natural atoms' in the first place -- and is kicking this one to their mutually containing, higher magical multiverse.

Permalink Mark Unread

It works!

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Estha's next prayers are due about four hours after sunset. Merrin would use the intervening time to get some sleep, except that she just got a Heal again and is, again, not even slightly tired. She'll do some more work on the cave-mapping. 

 

(The next tidal bore is due at 62:00, three hours after Estha finishes praying for spells – and in the middle of the night, though the moon will be in the sky and nearly full and they can both have headlamps – so they've got some time to iterate on their plan. Though not, like, a ton of time. Any new craft projects will have to be ones Merrin can accomplish reasonably quickly with her existing gear.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Following some mutual discussion of the possibilities of improvised technology -- objects you could maybe even build in Golarion, come to think on it, except that Golarion never quite imagined these objects, somehow -- Esta, in his next prayers, asks for Air Walk.

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

So the thing is.

Merrin is an exceptionally skilled swimmer. She did a lot of swimming as a child, and then she spent the last few years in dath ilan working for Exception Handling, training with her highly optimized aquatic power armor, perhaps with some background subtext from an inside joke that will apparently never die and that becomes funnier the more that Merrin appears to have superhuman abilities as soon as you put her in water.

She's done a ton of hostile-water-conditions training, and then she spent six planetary months here, getting more and more comfortable with riding the violent tides in and out to sea, and she knows the channel pretty well at this point, has a sense of where the rocks are, and she's pretty confident in her ability to navigate the wave in a controlled manner.

(They discussed Estha getting a version of the spell that would cover both of them, and riding along behind a floating buoy, but that would not be controlled and Merrin did not thing she could actually make a floating buoy that would survive a few violent collisions with rocks and still, like, float.)

So this is not, actually, quite as incredibly stupid an idea as it looks. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Stupid? It’s amazing! This is sooooooo cool and Merrin is soooooo cool.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is not used to swimming with a rope harnessing a floating person on roller skates to her back.

 

It turns out that this substantially affects her maneuverability.

Permalink Mark Unread

OW SHE DID NOT DODGE THAT ROCK IN TIME

Permalink Mark Unread

She’s still conscious and mobile, kind of - she did manage not to collide with a rock headfirst, she took the impact on her shoulder - but it was violent enough that it seems to have damaged something in her suit electronics, which are now distractingly beeping alarms at her, and she’s pretty disoriented and somewhat disadvantaged at keeping enough clearance from the next set of obstacles.

Permalink Mark Unread

OW

 

OW THAT WAS WORSE

 

- they’re actually past the worst part now, the current is slowing and they’re in a section with fewer rocks to hit and by the time they get to the next rocky bit the current will have attenuated even more than this, but Merrin is, uh, pretty sure she has a broken arm and probably some broken ribs, which has never actually happened to her before so it’s possible she’s just being an unexpected wimp about some bruises but she is not really feeling like she’s sure she can swim and navigate until Estha’s Locate Object runs out…

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta is paying some occasional attention to Merrin, as well as to his surroundings and above all to staying upright.  Thankfully Locate Object does not require concentration.

And now he's confused, because Merrin seems visibly to be swimming worse, as if injured; and that level of impact should not have done that much damage to Mariona, let alone to Mariona in armor.

But his {comms link} is conveying a sound, probably from Merrin's armor, that sounds like Dark Tapestry artifacts sound when they are unhappy.

He'll wait until Merrin is not visibly engaged in any complex maneuvers, and then yell over the comms link, "Status?"

Permalink Mark Unread

OW OW OW OW oh wait is someone asking her something OW oh right that's Estha and she should probably, like, explain, that she's injured -

 

- did she break the oxygen connection on that second impact or is it just the broken ribs making it feel like she can't actually get enough air to speak - this is so embarrassing but embarrassment is not even slightly a reason to try to conceal that she's injured and in fact the thought of doing that does not cross Merrin's mind. 

"Injured," she manages to force out; she's really hoping the comms link is still working in both directions. "Electronics damaged.”

She does not sound incredibly okay. (By the standards of Cheliax, she’ll probably come across as sounding even more badly injured than she in fact is.)

Permalink Mark Unread

"Still mission-capable?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is at this point not thinking incredibly clearly, and is - without meaning to or being consciously aware that she’s doing so - going to implicitly update from this even being a question that she must not be as injured as she thought, if Estha thinks they can keep going, and that it’s reasonable to defer to him on that.

(She will be EVEN MORE EMBARRASSED to realize this later, but right now pretty much all of her concentration is going toward things like “not screaming” and “keeping her body at an angle in the water where she can mostly use her legs and her unbroken or at least less-broken arm.)

“Impaired maneuverability but can still swim,” she manages. “Should - probably abort - if I hit anything else -“

And then she will focus all of her attention for trying not to do that for as long as possible.

Permalink Mark Unread

…Which is going to be about thirty seconds, because here comes the next rocky section, and Merrin’s reaction times are very much not at their best.

Permalink Mark Unread

She’s not actually unconscious - she did manage to tuck in her head before impact - but she is not going to be especially able to say any coherent words over the comms link about her ability to keep going.

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta is so incredibly familiar -- you would not believe how familiar Esta is -- with subordinates pretending like they did not totally get in over their heads, and are not in all that much trouble, and don't need to fail the mission.

When Mariona does it, it's not for quite exactly the same reasons as usual.  But still, this is one of the most recognizable things he's seen her do since her brain got eaten by the Dark Tapestry.

He hauls himself down the cable and grabs Merrin, quite hard actually, because this Is Not a good time for his grasp to slip.

Word of Recall.

...He can't actually Heal her without some exposed skin, though, come to think.  Does her armor offer that?

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

It does not!!!

 

If he gives her a couple of rounds, Merrin will realize where she is and that it's not the river, and manage to put together that she's injured and probably Estha needs to do a healing spell and those are touch-range. 

She tries to use the voice-activated interface to unseal the suit helmet automatically, since that's the simplest and fastest way to expose any of her skin.

Nothing happens, because there is in fact quite a lot of damage to the suit electronics. 

 

She'll make an abortive attempt to lift her hand and do it via the wrist console. ....Yeah no not happening, she avoided a severe head injury by tucking her chin in and shielding her head with her arms but that means she took the impact directly on her elbows and forearms, and OW. Come to think of it, she's not sure the wrist console itself is still working, the screen seems to have gone dark...

 

Possibly some components of this plan were not entirely thought through. For example, Merrin has not taken the time to show Estha how any of the external controls on her suit work, since she did not think ahead to the in-hindsight-obvious possibility that she might break both the electronic voice-activated controls AND HER ARMS. 

 

Merrin is REALLY QUITE MOTIVATED to be in less pain than this, and will try, through gritted teeth, to instruct Estha on what button to press to get the helmet unsealed manually. At least the radio comms link is somehow still working and they can hear each other fine. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Do what to what, now?  Does he look like he has skill ranks in this?

He will nonetheless try to follow instructions, and nothing will happen.

...Esta does not know, and should maybe have asked, how to operate the technology that Merrin used to cut Esta out of his own armor.  Well, at least now Esta will have an excuse to ask her about that, just in case, for next time, without that seeming suspicious of him.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin continues to be pretty disoriented, and has no idea whether her explanation is failing to result in the helmet being open (and her getting HEALING MAGIC about her BROKEN BONES which it turns out are REALLY DISTRACTING) because she's explaining terribly and Estha doesn't know what she means, or because he still has far less basic familiarity with technology than a dath ilani four-year-old - Merrin is pretty sure she could talk a dath ilani four-year-old through the manual external controls, but they do have the advantage of, like, video games -

- oh, or it's also possible that those controls are also broken, or that the incredibly tough composite material is bent and the helmet faceplate is actually physically stuck in the closed position, in which case maybe he'll have better luck getting one of the gloves off, she can try to explain that instead... 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin seems pretty scrambled!  He hopes she didn't hit her head hard enough to get a status effect.

Sure, he'll try following these, you know, actually sort of complicated instructions if you have literally never Operated a Technology in your life.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin did not hit her head that hard! If she had taken any of those impacts to her head right now, she would be UNCONSCIOUS, not mildly disoriented. She just has, in Golarion terms, a perfectly normal number of hitpoints for a commoner with no class levels in anything, and she has also - somewhat remarkably given how much more than average she likes climbing trees and jumping off tall rocks, her mother has teased her - managed to go through her entire life until now without ever actually breaking a bone. It turns out! That this is really distracting! And making it hard to have original thoughts!

(She's pretty embarrassed about how impairing it is, actually, having previously observed Estha not even seeming distracted by multiple broken bones. There's probably a skill there that one can improve with practice! Merrin has just not practiced that specifically because in dath ilan a broken bone takes at least six weeks to heal so it would be really stupid to break bones on purpose for training purposes!) 

 

...She will eventually manage to say out loud in words that the electronics are mostly down and there might be literal mechanical damage causing the helmet and gloves to be stuck, and maybe Estha should find something to use as a lever to try to force it open? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh, right.  Esta is not used to the particular failure modes of technology.  A magical item either works or it takes so much damage as to completely lose function, you can't bonk a staff into a rock and have it lose the capability to cast just one spell.  Merrin's armor was Still Working, so it didn't occur to him that -- but enough <failure-excuses>, Esta thinks in Infernal.

Greater Make Whole.

Permalink Mark Unread

OH RIGHT THAT SPELL EXISTS and Merrin is very silly. 

She uses the voice interface to make the faceplate pop open. 

 

(Feeling embarrassment or being mad at herself for failing to think of that immediately can wait until they're actually doing a failure-analysis debrief later.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

He reaches a hand toward her face, but then hesitates.

"Should I be using the Heal for this, or trying to practice nonmagical medicine on you instead?"

Permalink Mark Unread

"Ha ha very funny," Merrin says, exhaustedly. 

(It's parsing to her as obviously a joke, because her Estha teases her constantly all the time - and she often can't tell that he's teasing her rather than being serious unless it's obvious from context, which he thinks is hilarious and which definitely incentivizes more teasing, so she eventually just ended up with a pretty high prior that anything that made her go ???????? when interpreted seriously was probably a joke. And, like, there's not even obviously a good argument for her to prioritize teaching Estha non-magical medicine at all, given that it takes years to be an expert in it, and even if it was a priority this would be a blatantly really stupid time for it, when someone is starting out you only have them practice in simulated scenarios and not on someone with actual injuries. And it wouldn't even occur to her that her Estha might be getting any enjoyment or entertainment out of her pain in this particular situation.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Who knows but that the entire reason the [Outer God] placed you here was in order to allow for the practice of more nonmagical medicine?"

"Do I recall correctly that it's the box on the furthest left which has the {duck tape}?"

Permalink Mark Unread

oh no what if he has a point

no, surely the cool tropey plot beat here would be if Estha was forced to use nonmagical medicine due to being out of healing spells, you can't hit the same note by just refusing to use healing spells you totally have, then it's just implausible and uncool

...Her Estha would probably not keep up the bit for that long just to tease her.

Merrin is reminding herself that she is not, in fact, certain she knows all of the differences between the Estha she remembers and this one. It does lowkey bother her to be the first one to stop going along with the joke, BUT maybe he just in fact doesn't understand how messed up she is? Because he has the Belt, and whatever other form of toughness lets him run into like ten times that many rocks and still be fully coherent - on reflection that's kind of plausible, and like, Merrin has both a high pain tolerance and a bunch of competitiveness about it, it might not be obvious - 

(It's going to be extremely obvious. By dath ilan's standards, Merrin has an extraordinarily high pain tolerance and an unusual ability to appear less distressed by it even if it's in fact bothering her, but dath ilan and Cheliax are extremely different places.) 

 

"Not actually funny can you please just heal me," she says tightly.

Permalink Mark Unread

Vicar Esta is surprised, then, and confused, and offended, and indeed outraged, but he keeps it off his face.

It takes him a moment, without Cultural Adaptation running, to decide that this is probably not the point where Merrin springs a trap to see if she can make 'Estha' act utterly out of character.  She probably thinks that it is in-character for Merrin to say such a thing, to her Estha, and for her Estha to comply.  And of all the times in which to try to explain to altered-Mariona that she is not behaving correctly, this is probably not optimal.  He has only a split second to decide it, if he will comply, and Esta had not previously planned to optimally confront Mariona in such a moment, so he will not confront her now.

Esta overrides rather a lot of feelings, and taps Merrin on the nose.

Heal.

Permalink Mark Unread

And now Merrin is no longer injured! She's still kind of shaken, but she's inclined to be stubborn and not explicitly say she needs a break to calm down after that - or maybe it's not just the being-competitive, here, something about that interaction felt off and it seems like everything is fine now but it still left her uneasy. 

 

She sits up. "Well. I think that plan also needs some more work." 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

The nights are continuing to get shorter. Esta's next prayers will be due a full hour after the next planetary dawn, which is itself a few hours after high tide.

After that: there will be a tidal bore that [day] before 24 hours have elapsed and it's time to pray again, if they want to use it! The tidal bores are about 37 hours apart, so sometimes if one falls early in a particular [day], the next one will fall late on the next consecutive [day]. And this one will be in daylight, making navigation and obstacle-avoidance a lot easier! It's due at 36:00, which is of course timed to nearly the hottest part of the late-spring-or-early-summer-or-whatever afternoon, but with Endure Elements and Planetary Adaptation neither of them will be inconvenienced - but not for almost 21 hours after Esta finishes getting his spells, so they're much less crunched on planning time. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is apparently continuing to replace sleep with absurdly powerful healing magic; she got a Heal just before midnight, at which point it was the middle of the night and yet she was wide awake and full of energy, and ended up plowing the entire night into working on her software map of the caves. 

(She makes a mental note that it sure would be nice if she could avoid getting herself injured again this [day], since she's ended up getting both of the two most recent Heals. Which is admittedly mostly because she was the one exposing herself more directly to hazards on the two most recent plans, but she still feels like it's only fair for Esta to also get a chance to reset to no-exhaustion on his next [day].) 

 

She has some ideas for new things to try. Literally just doing it in daylight, and having already had a practice run with the rope towing Estha throwing off her hydrodynamics, might already make a big difference for her obstacle-avoidance abilities, but she also wants to propose that Estha consider loaning her the Belt. She's clearly a lot more quickly incapacitated by injuries, since she is a normal human person and he's some kind of weirdly resilient magic person, but it also seems like she really needs to be present and swimming in the water for their whole plan of covering as many kilometers as possible in a single Extended Locate Object spell duration by using the tidal bore current speed to work, like, at all. She mostly needs to figure out how to get through the first two minutes without accumulating any injuries or damage to her armor that reduce her maneuverability? The actual swimming difficulty will get incrementally easier as they fall further behind the main wave, but that only helps if her swimming abilities aren't decreasing even faster. 

She'll propose a plan B: make a new boat, one with better maneuvering characteristics and also better sturdiness, out of local materials so it doesn't matter that it's inevitably going to get destroyed anyway and its remnants will probably not be possible to retrieve for repairs. But that calls for more lead time, she'll need to do an out-to-sea mission to harvest enough of the various kinds of strapwrack for it, and given that there's a tidal bore again, and Estha continues to have the best emergency-evacuation trick ever, she thinks they haven't yet exhausted the potential of their extremely silly plan to have Merrin tow an Air Walking Estha upstream on roller skates. 

Permalink Mark Unread

...Also, she's going to tell Estha, as casually as she can manage, that if it's an okay time for it, then there's a personal conversation she'd like to have at some point and she would rather do it while he's using Tongues and can speak Baseline. 

(This is SO AWKWARD but Merrin is kind of feeling like she's irresponsibly put it off too many times already. She needs to actually be on the same page as Estha about what their current ""relationship"" is or she's going to make some kind of really stupid cultural misstep. In fact, possibly she has already made, like, twenty incredibly awkward cultural missteps and is hurting his feelings constantly and he just hasn't said anything because their survival is a higher priority? ...Anyway, miscommunications and resulting shenanigans might, perhaps, be entertaining and even funny from a sufficiently outside perspective, but any dath ilani protagonist would obviously respond to a situation like this by not making the stupid mistake.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta has no life experience to be wary of a girlfriend telling him that they need to talk.  Back below 4th, he had some experience with a girlfriend telling him that he's failed her and will pay in pain; but not that they need to talk.  The Chelish system is not entirely without advantage.

Tongues, Cultural Adaptation.

"Sure," says Esta in Baseline.

Permalink Mark Unread

This is MORTIFYINGLY AWKWARD AAAAAAA.

“We each remember different things about the world we came from,” she says. “We’re - clearly not acting toward each on the basis that really we just met a few days ago - I’m not sure if I could successfully set-aside-my-preconceptions and interact with you as a stranger, it’s too - you feel too strongly like the same person. But we don’t really know each other, not like in the memories each of us has about the other.”

She takes a deep breath. “- And we’re in a situation where we’re relying heavily on the other being - reliable and low-friction-to-coordinate/with - and that’s hard, when we’re missing context on each other.”

Well, really it’s mostly Merrin missing huge swaths of context on Estha’s life. She herself hasn’t been deliberately concealing anything about dath Ilan or her life there, though she also hasn’t tried to represent herself as definitely telling him everything. The only part she’s explicitly keeping to herself is that Laeirthe - exists, for some very odd definition of existence - and doesn’t trust Estha.

So far so good.

“…And something I haven’t asked about, because it - feels weird - is the status of your relationship with the me you remember. Partly because you’ve expressed reluctance to share some information on - things I might have forgotten - and I don’t know how closely adjacent that is.”

She shrugs slightly. “I finally thought, maybe that isn’t the information I actually need to have, to - not be unproductively stressed about social missteps - and the important part is having a relationshipnegotiation about the current relationship, between me as I am now, and you as you are now. And making sure we’re not - having a mutual-illusion-of-transparency around very different assumptions, that might cause a conflict at a really inconvenient time if we don’t address it.”

Merrin hesitates for a moment, and then goes ahead and says the thing she was hesitating over whether to say. “…I don’t know if the game the [Outer God] is playing here might involve romance - stuff - but it’s a hypothesis that came to mind for me.” 

It sure does come up sometimes in alternative-universe crossover fanfiction.

Permalink Mark Unread

The word relationshipnegotiation sure is echoing in his mind, in Tongues, and in Cultural Adaptation.

Mariona's dreamworld has what sort of custom.  Why.  Is the concept here that you do a bunch of Lawful logistics and paperwork before anyone is allowed to have sex with you.  Why wouldn't sex just not exist... well, if she'd gotten Dark-Tapestry-inverted into enjoying it, only, she hasn't been inverted around fantasizing about nonmagical medicine and this is Esta's first time properly noticing the degree to which his two main hypotheses are directly and oppositely colliding -- which is somehow a kind of thought that dath ilan Cultural Adaptation also seems to believe Esta ought to be thinking and maybe saying something about.  And why would that element be a fantasy-projection or inversion of Mariona, that whole part seems like something that would come out of the Dark Tapestry rather than her --

Permalink Mark Unread

And that's a third distinct hypothesis!

Tracking all these ideas separately, and trying to distinguish between them by experiment, is definitely part of Our Culture!  Merrin will be surprised if you seem bad at it.  Can't blend in without it!

Permalink Mark Unread

And Merrin, very plausibly since she is the one saying it, thinks the [Outer God] is doing what?  Trying to set up a romance?

Esta hasn't read a lot of 'romance novels' since that literary form was invented a few years back -- though he has heard that many of those novels are good enough as sheer literature to be read by men, if they don't mind the implicit messages those novels send about men's place in the universe and their ultimate inferiority of wit and power to the female protagonists.  But he has heard about a general concept of what romance is like, for the sort of Chelish person who's into relationships more complicated and less entirely Lawful than 'I get sex and you get to suffer' --

Permalink Mark Unread

Please pay attention to the actual Baseline word 'romance' and how much it doesn't sound like Abrogail Thrune's personal hobbies.

Permalink Mark Unread

what is this profoundly alien affair out of the Dark Tapestry that sounds like Shelyn raped Abadar and forced Him to bear Her baby

Permalink Mark Unread

To outer appearances, alter-Estha will appear to very carefully consider this conversational topic, looking (to dath ilani eyes) like he is processing it with all of the gravity that it deserves.  There's a way you look when you are thinking carefully before responding, and Estha definitely looks that way, for a time.


"I have been considering several different hypotheses about ways in which you might systematically and predictably differ from the Merrin I knew," says alter-Estha.  It's strange how much more familiar he sounds when he speaks Baseline.  (Because Esta has made a habit of contemporaneously casting Cultural Adaptation afterwards every time, a spell whose distinct existence and purpose he has not actually mentioned to Merrin.)  "Was one of my early guesses correct that this version of you does enjoy sex, and that you would have been displeased if your version of Estha had tried to assist you in your career?"

Permalink Mark Unread

 

 

…Merrin has QUESTIONS about what exact process might have generated exactly those two specific differences??? 

Also oh no that sure makes it sound like they were NOT dating in the alternative-universe and she’s been making everything super weird 

“I would have been extremely confused if the you I remember had ever offered to do anything about my career, because as I said we did not work in the same department,” she says. “I don’t think it would - offend me, as a concept - but it would be pretty weird.”

(The understanding Merrin has formed of what ‘assisting her in her career’ could even look like has mostly resolved onto, like, one-on-one training on some specialized skill, because dath ilan has much less of a route by which ‘Estha speaks to her Exception Handling supervisors about her’ could, like, change anything much about her career trajectory.)

- wait, no. “Wrongthought,” Merrin says, “I’m realizing that if I’d known you earlier in my life, and you happened to know enough about my hobbies to notice my unusual stamina and point me out to someone at Exception Handling, I - well, it would’ve still been weird and a bit uncomfortable, maybe, I - don’t like attention - but it would be better for Civilization, probably, so I wouldn’t have been mad.”

The second part of the question is still giving her some trouble because. Um. Merrin is not actually that ridiculously easily-embarrassed about sex stuff, it’s just incredibly weird to talk about it with the alternate-universe version of your boyfriend who, it sounds like, was not having any form of sex with the alternate-universe you.

“…It’s complicated to what extent I like sex,” she says. “I don’t think I can round it off to either a yes or a no.”

The reason she had wanted to have this conversation in Baseline was that she had noticed a massive area of missing vocabulary. Merrin is somewhat worried that this means the other-world Estha is also going to be missing concepts and she will need to do a lot of mortifying explanation.

…no, he has to know that masochists exist, there was that one comment he made - actually, what, wait, Merrin is now very confused how that could possibly fit with “they’re not dating” - did she misparse completely what he meant, or does his culture exclude kink from the category “sex”, that would be weird but it’s not impossible to imagine, she supposes…

“I’m a masochist,” she says, “I like kink stuff a lot more consistently in more circumstances than I like, you know,” no she canNOT assume he knows there is a CULTURE GAP here, “um, sex acts involving genital contact.” 

Permalink Mark Unread

Hey Merrin. Notice that, technically, Estha did not say he didn’t have sex with Merrin. Only - unless Merrin is parsing it backward and those were meant to be similarities and not differences, but he doesn’t think so - only that she didn’t like it. 

Permalink Mark Unread

What the flaming toilet paper, Laeirthe! 

Permalink Mark Unread

It’s an explanation for why he would even know that! Anyway, surely Merrin can understand the concept of a man pressuring a woman to have sex she doesn’t like, because some people are not very prosocial? 

(Laeirthe, to be clear, is not actually assessing this as a very likely explanation! He is just considering it his responsibility to be on the lookout for when Merrin is filtering her hypotheses about Estha-behavior to only include the charitable ones.)

Permalink Mark Unread

Hypothesis noted now can he PLEASE SHUT UP AND LET HER FOCUS.

Permalink Mark Unread

One of the disadvantages of Tongues (or Share Language, even) is that if you think you already know a nearby concept, Tongues will go right on and helpfully map that word onto its neighboring concept in your own language.

Esta knows the word 'masochist'!  It's a Kuthite / Nidalian thing!

Also Esta is so incredibly straight, strictly dominant, and strictly sadistic, as to have a ready counterpart existing in dath ilan.

And unlike Estha, Esta has never in his life heard the phrase 'typical mind fallacy', and wouldn't have any preexisting concepts or frameworks about subduing cognitive biases if he had.  So far as Esta knows, he can query his own mind to figure out how sexuality in general will operate.

Esta understands that pain is supposed to produce submission, which makes total Asmodean sense to him.  You submit to people in hopes they'll hurt you less!

Esta has also heard, and on some occasions encountered, that there's a complicated girl thing that mixes up submission and sex.  Esta has never particularly gotten this part -- maybe because he's never had a prospect of getting pregnant, whereas a woman needs to act appealing around a man who she wants to go on taking care of her baby, as he continues hurting her and forcing her to submit?  This situation has never personally arisen for Esta, so he doesn't really get it intuitively.  But he can see in principle how it could be logical for a woman.

But that's not the same as 'masochism'.  'Masochism' is a thing where Nidal thinks that sex is supposed to hurt -- for both partners, not just the weaker partner, because of course Nidal says so.  And there is also -- supposedly, says rumor and approved comparative theology lessons -- another Kuthite thing, which says that hurt is supposed to sex.  Like, directly.  Esta frankly does not see why that would fit with Zon-Kuthon theology at all, but he's heard about it from multiple sources.

After querying his own brain to find out how sexuality works in general, Esta has always figured that a whole lot of this 'masochism' business was some sort of complicated coping mechanism about trying to make pain hurt less -- or deny how much it hurts, or deny to yourself how you're really being crushed underfoot -- by mixing it up with something you could pretend you were trying to do on purpose, like sex.

Esta has generally tried to steer clear of this sort of business.  He doesn't want to have to figure out what is or isn't Asmodean.  Esta doesn't want to have to justify what is or isn't Asmodean.  He'd rather not have Aspexia Rugatonn suddenly showing up in his office, looking stern, to interrogate him about his sex life.  His sex life has been designed with that use-case foremost in mind.

Wizards running Detect Thoughts on Mariona had reported to Esta:

- That Mariona had a submitting-to-authority feeling about Esta hurting her, which was perfectly fine and Asmodean;
- That Mariona often felt straightened-out and set right after being tortured by an authority as high-ranked as Esta, which showed her clerical potential and explained what Asmodeus saw in her that was worthy;
- That Mariona was attracted to Esta's authority, in the usual way of a woman being instinctively attracted to authorities whose backing might prove useful to her, which seemed proper and feminine to Esta;
- But that Mariona didn't want any dick in her vag, regardless of who did or didn't hurt her.  (This also seemed very normal to Esta on a sexual level!  Esta wouldn't want a cock in himself either.)


Esta had thought he'd understood what was going on there, and that it was simple and straightforward and Asmodean on both sides.  You would believe, you would think, that you didn't need to deal with weird supposedly-Kuthite oh-actually-pain-is-sexy complications, if you were hurting a woman who wasn't into sex.

And Esta is frankly not seeing with how it makes sense as Mariona's perfect dreamworld, on that hypothesis of Merrin's origin.  Or why 'I now like pain but not genital contact' would be the result of the Dark Tapestry turning Mariona upside down into Merrin, on his other theory.

What does dath ilan think about whether you're supposed to hurt Merrin?  Are there any planetwide cultural traditions about hurting Merrin specifically, by any chance?

Permalink Mark Unread

Uh... no?

Hurting people is wrong.  Pain is bad and ouchy.  Nobody would ever want to be hurt during sex.  If you feel like doing that to somebody, it would be a dark secret that you only told therapists, or very trusted friends who might forgive you for having this black fantasy that you'd never acted upon.

 

...well, okay, actually, that's not the whole truth and there are some people who are into being hurt, including apparently this Merrin person.  But that is even more of a secret.  You do not tell your closest friends about that part; it would be an injury to them.  You wouldn't go around telling people that any more than you'd blurt out the names of Outer Gods in public.

Permalink Mark Unread

Why the ACTUAL FUCK would that be the case, dath ilan.

Permalink Mark Unread

Look, Cultural Adaptation just tells you how to behave and the rules to follow if you want to blend in.  It doesn't tell you why those rules exist.


(Possibly because, not to throw too much shade here, the spell was invented by somebody who grew up in Golarion, where cultures don't actually have carefully reasoned justifications that you can look up, so the spell just presumes that all the rules are there for random incompressible historically contingent reasons.  Really that's kind of implied by needing a Cultural Adaptation spell in the first place, rather than just being able to derive all the cultural rules from first principles, or rather, from knowledge of dath ilan's empirical truths plus its utility function.)

Permalink Mark Unread


From the outside, alter-Estha again looks pensive and is silent for a time, after the culturally signaled fashion of somebody who is carefully hearing out your evidence and trying to update all of his hypotheses about it.

Finally alter-Estha says in colloquial Baseline, "Thank you very much, Merrin; that combination of replies refutes every hypothesis that I previously had."

"Was it the case, in your memories, that the truth about your masochism was not only secret but an infohazard?  And if so, what was the reason?"

Permalink Mark Unread

WHAT set of hypotheses could he POSSIBLY have had such that the…existence of masochists?? invalidates all of them at once??? Or is it the rarity of masochists, or the fact that someone can be a masochist and otherwise mostly asexual??? Or maybe the part about her endorsing being pointed out to Exception Handling????? He did not actually say WHICH of her answers was refuting which part of which hypothesis, just the combination, but he did say ‘refuted’ which implies quite a dramatic update on his probabilities, more than just ‘it seems somewhat more likely that the correct hypothesis is one I haven’t thought of yet’…

 

“- My understanding is that there’s a tradeoff to navigate related to masochists being a much, much smaller fraction of the population than - potential sadists, at least - but the thought is that a lot of people haven’t realized they’d be into sadism, so the lack doesn’t actively bother them - and if they did know they would either be unable to afford it, and be unhappy, or they’d bid up the price for seeing a masochist and someone else would be unable to afford it and be sad. Some people will realize either way and be unhappy already, and if they can afford it then it’s more likely the Keepers will err on the side of not keeping the secret from them.” After a moment, “- that’s the position the you I remember was in. I had, um, assumed from the time you mentioned - the amusing amount of pain - that you did know about it already…”

Permalink Mark Unread

Apparently when Shelyn was done having Her way with Abadar, She turned matters over to Her lost brother Zon-Kuthon, who was next in line for forcing a rapebaby into Abadar.

If all of this is in any way related to Mariona, then she had a much theologically richer sexual inner life than Esta had heretofore suspected.

...does dath ilan want to expand on this 'Keeper' business, the word sounds like it has depth?

Permalink Mark Unread

Um... cultural behavioral rules... you would treat a Keeper with respect?

If a Keeper landed on this situation, they would immediately take charge because of the [Outer God] aspect, and you would defer to them; that's exactly the sort of thing that Keepers are for.

It's fine to tell Keepers about masochists; they cannot be hurt by such things.

Permalink Mark Unread

Are Keepers mortals or a kind of outsider?

Permalink Mark Unread

Esta does not really trust devils or Asmodeus to behave in a Lawful fashion toward him, but he could trust Keepers to do so!

They are utterly reliable; all the weight of the world can be placed upon them and entrusted to them.

Permalink Mark Unread

...this is some kind of horrible Dark Tapestry thing, isn't it.

Permalink Mark Unread

WHY DOES EVERYONE ON OTHER PLANETS THINK THAT AS SOON AS DATH ILAN TRIES TO CONVEY THE CONCEPT OF A PERSON WHO ACTUALLY DOES THEIR JOB

Permalink Mark Unread

And now Esta needs to figure out what to say to Mariona about all this, because she looked a bit surprised by the question, there.

Thankfully, Esta has by now figured out how to bypass dath ilan yelling at him to STOP LYING; you just ask what a dath ilani would find plausible if you were constructing an elaborate deception around them for purposes of revealing it to them later, as is apparently right and proper in dath ilan.  Cultural Adaptation is apparently fine with guiding Esta's instincts around that.


"The way we first met is that I hurt you.  Or to be precise, at very first I was instructing you in a classroom among other students.  The hurting happened afterward and was just the two of us.  Which it was my job to do, as designated by our department, for reasons having to do with how we both related to the [divinity] that granted us spells as [clerics]."  He uses the Utopian words in Baseline; it's only a little jarring.  "That was the foundation of the relationship we later formed.  We also had sex, which from my perspective was enjoyable not least because it was hurting you, and from your perspective was a matter of being hurt within your relationship to our [divinity].  I backed your assumption of greater responsibilities in our department, including your current job that led to us encountering the [Outer God].  You had trouble believing you could do that job, and you were in fact very good at it and much better than the person you replaced -- as I'd predicted to both you and our managers.  All that I have just described was considered normal and standard operating procedure within our department, being surprising neither to us nor to those observing the process."

Permalink Mark Unread

....It takes a moment for Merrin to actually make the connection, because she's not, actually, a big romance reader. She certainly hasn't bothered to seek out the (relatively tiny amount of) romance literature written for masochists, because even knowing that was a thing overlapped entirely with her Exception Handling career and she was very, very busy, and did not exactly have a lack of romance in her life with her actual boyfriends. And also she hasn't consumed a ton of eroLARP type materials

But if she mentally edits out the sadism and madochism, then “people can get superpowers from sex stuff” is SO TOTALLY an eroLARP trope, that’s not even subtle. It's not exactly a trope she is personally familiar with for this to route through being a [cleric] of a [divinity] that is the kind of entity that makes sense to describe oneself as having a "relationship with", but that still feels like it could be a thing, just not one she's happened upon because she really has not read a lot of that genre. 

And - in terms of her work, that Estha is being very cautious in telling her about, she - was a more junior person in a department that ended up encountering an [Outer God], and therefore was probably regularly dealing with matters that would be secret? And she was very good at it, with a possible implication that her being a masochist was what made her good at it?

It does feel like it fits as the alternate-universe-backstory explanation for her masochism being secret. 

(Merrin hasn't actually found an angle yet where penetrative sex is fun for her, including the masochism kind of fun, but like, she was already kiiind of hoping she would eventually figure that out given a few years, and if she could get COOLER SUPERPOWERS out of it then, yeah, she would definitely have been more motivated...) 

 

Orrrr maybe that is totally not a good analogy for the situation and she’s jumping to conclusions in the process of trying to map it to something familiar. Merrin is trying to be careful not to do that or at least to notice when she might be doing it! There’s a culture gap and she should not be anywhere close to confident that she understands it yet! 

Permalink Mark Unread

Also, the main point right now is not what alternate-universe-Merrin is up to, it’s where all of that leaves them now.

Merrin…does not, currently, super feel like being in an eroLARP plot? If that’s a way the narrative tropes could go if she leans into it, then, uh, she would perhaps instead rather not do that? Also it still feels like she’s probably missing some very big pieces of context, and “wow it sounds like you’re from the eroLARP alternate-universe” is a super weird and awkward thing to say that is probably importantly false in some way, and so it doesn’t feel like deception to avoid dwelling on it.

”…Okay,” she says. “That maybe - clarifies my understanding of some things - though it’s also possible that it’s exactly the wrong amount of context and I’m making assumptions and actually more incorrect, but - I’m not planning to make large decisions from my understanding of it, if you’re still worried about infohazards and would rather not explain everything.” 

Pause.

“…One assumption I’m making is that it sounds like in your memories, we - weren’t not dating but there was maybe a lot of other more complicated context too? And - I’m not sure how that affects how it makes sense to be relating to each other right now. Since I don’t have that context. …Uh, I guess there might also be non-obvious context that I have with the you I remember, but I can’t obviously tell what, from my perspective it was really very straightforward.”

Permalink Mark Unread

"I had thought my relationship with my Merrin was straightforward.  But depending on exactly how you are related to her, or on my current best guess transformed from her, it suggests that there were as many as several things going on in our relationship that I perhaps did not fully comprehend."

"What's your version of the straightforward relationship we had?"

Permalink Mark Unread

Yyyyyyup culture gap. Merrin would super not describe the...thing he described...as 'straightforward' even if her eroLARP gloss on it was mostly accurate!

...Her own current top hypothesis is that, if she was in some sense 'transformed' from the alternate-Merrin – if dath ilan is the alternate-universe of some other narrative canon – then, well, it's still not a 'transformation' that involves her having any continuity-of-consciousness with alternate-Merrin, or any hidden memories to be dug up. But it's a pretty uncertain hypothesis and it's also REALLY SILLY so who knows. 

 

"You were a sadist, obviously, which isn't unusual but you were also one of the people who noticed this about yourself and was unhappy about - not getting the thing that would make you happy - and you were also pretty wealthy, though I actually have no idea what work you did to become wealthy, you didn't talk about it and I figured it was secrecy-oath stuff. But you put in a high enough bid to see me, it turned out I liked you a lot, we made each other happy. That's - kind of it?" 

Permalink Mark Unread


"It may take me a while to figure out what this says about, one, the straightforward relationship I thought I had with my Merrin, two, the pattern of your relation to my Merrin, and three, what the [Outer God] could possibly be trying to do and what that implies about how we maybe get free of this planet."

Permalink Mark Unread

Indeed. The last thing sure is also a question that Merrin is, herself, chewing on, and does not feel this conversation has resolved, and - 

 

 

- is not telling Estha anything about her stupid ridiculous alternative-universe fanfiction crossover theory, apparently, which is prerequisite context for the eroLARP trope that she would kind of rather subvert because that's just - it's too silly, okay, Merrin is aware that this is ridiculous of her but it feels too undignified (and, therefore, unsexy? like, this would just not in fact be a Merrinfantasy?) for the narrative resolution here to be that she (re?)acquires [cleric] superpowers from a [god] who likes sadomasochism, and they end up solving all of their problems with the power of kinky sex– 

Permalink Mark Unread

Is that her actual reason, in its entirety? That it would be undignified and therefore she wants to avoid mentioning it out of embarrassment and social awkwardness? 

Permalink Mark Unread

....Okay, fine, when Laeirthe puts it like that it's clearly a really stupid reason to keep a secret from her alternate-universe boyfriend. And, like, if she kept a secret that was relevant to both of their survival from her Estha from dath ilan, that - feels like something that would be wrong on relationship-ethics grounds - 

 

- but this is not her Estha from dath ilan. This is a different Estha, somehow, and Merrin does not need to know which Estha ""came first"" or understand the exact mechanics behind his differences to notice that he is different, even if he feels a lot more familiar when he at least shares the language of dath ilan with her. 

And she - there's a culture gap, she's not sure that if she said it he would hear the thing she really meant, and it's such a stupid theory, and possibly making any decisions on the basis of it makes things go worse rather than better– 

 

...She's really digging for reason why it's reasonable and correct of her not to tell him, isn't she. Are any of them the actual reason, or is it just that she's - no, it's not just that she's embarrassed and feels silly and it's awkward, because if it was her Estha then she wouldn't hesitate on those grounds, she would expect him to tease her and that would be fine - is she just being incredibly unfair to alternate-Estha because she's stressed and in a weird headspace from all the months of isolation and on some level perhaps feeling a little bit of resentment that things are complicated instead of simple - 

Permalink Mark Unread

Wow. Who is Merrin even arguing with in her head, right now? Her mental model of Civilization? What the acid shit is her mental model of Civilization doing here, it doesn't exist here and maybe doesn't really exist at all, it's none of its business. In fact, it's no one's business whether Merrin likes alternate-Estha and trusts alternate-Estha exactly as much as she likes and trusts the other one! In fact, Kalorm would like to throw the entire concept that Merrin has social obligations to anyone into the sun! It seems like it's making her stressed and she could just stop that!

Permalink Mark Unread

......Wow. 

 

 

 

Um. 

 

 

Thanks, imaginary Kalorm, for some reason it does help to have an imaginary Kalorm in her head right now, but Merrin....does not actually think she endorses all of that? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Honestly, Laeirthe is not super sure if they have paranoia grounds on which to avoid explaining the hypothesis?

But he's also not sure they don't, he's running on really incredibly limited processing bandwidth right now. And Merrin seems to have a hesitation, there, and - Laeirthe is kind of inclined to say her hesitation might be pointing in the useful-paranoia direction? He can try to think about it when they're not mid-conversation. He's really much better at thinking about things when they're not mid-conversation. In the meantime, he is on Team Kalorm that, like, it would be pretty surprising and inconsistent-standards if Estha did think it was a serious violation of interpersonal-relationship-ethics for Merrin to keep back some of her thoughts when he's doing even more of that? At least as long as it's true that she hasn't thought of a blatantly obvious plan that would obviously work if her hypothesis were true and is therefore worth trying to test it? 

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay. 

 

"I also have some things to think through after this conversation, regarding hypotheses I've had that might relate to what the [Outer God] could possibly be trying to do," Merrin says, which is at least acknowledging that those hypotheses exist. 

And there is something that she still thinks she feels uncomfortable hiding from alternate-Estha, because this one feels like it's a lot broader than an intimate-romantic-partner interpersonal-ethics expectation, it's - something that would also be relevant to a coworker, and they are approximately coworkers right now. 

 

"...This is only sort of related but I want to explicitlyflag," the connotation there is that she doesn't expect this to be entirely new information to him but wants to raise the salience of facts he's already observed but may not be interpreting in the direction she's pointing at, "that I was - that I remember being, at least, on this planet alone for multiple months, frequently in potentially-life-threatening danger, after a stressful plane crash that I expected to end in True Death, and - on priors those factors aren't good for someone's mental health. I think I'm functioning at my usual capacity, and I'm not in active emotional distress. The Exception Handling training I remember was effective preparation for extreme stressors. But - on priors, I might not be entirely okay and my judgement could be affected." 

 

 

(Merrin is aware that interpersonal-ethics is not just about whether someone will be mad at her later or have hurt feelings, but it does feel like Estha - like the one she remembers, at least - would be less hurt about her not feeling totally comfortable with him and telling him everything on her mind, after she made sure to bring up that she might have reasons to be, for example, compensating less well than usual for underlying neuroticism and social anxiety.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Cultural Adaptation suggests that a proverb already exists about this!  Esta rather likes the formulation of it.

"'It's okay to be imperfect, so long as you're not so imperfect that other people notice.'  I haven't noticed your judgment being any worse than usual.  There was that time you tried to continue swimming past the point where you were taking enough damage per [moment] that it was clearly not going to work out, but that's... actually very characteristic of the Merrin I know and not suggestive of new bad judgment."

If anything Merrin seems to have a solidity about her that Mariona lacked, but it would not be in Esta's interests to observe this.

Permalink Mark Unread

What a normal reassuring Estha-from-dath-ilan thing to say! If only Merrin could feel reassured by it instead of vaguely unsettled! 

 

"....Yeah, that was an error." A REALLY EMBARRASSING one, too. "I diagnosed it afterward as - updating on the way you asked if I was still mission-capable, toward feeling like keeping-going was the default and I should be able to keep going, which is obviously invalid reasoning and I think I'll be able to catch myself next time. ...I'm not used to you being the one who's - less cautious isn't the thing - it's probably because the you I remember wasn't in Exception Handling with me and our relationship was - one where I'd expect you to be a bit overprotective? And I wasn't accounting for the part where - hmm, so it seems like even apart from the [Belt]'s effects, you...don't quite have the normal human biology that I'm familiar with? You're injured less severely by the same impacts, and I think you improve faster even without [healing spells], and - am I right in guessing that the me you remember also has some of that? My own memories are of having normal human biology, so I think I might become impaired by injuries more quickly than you were modeling, does that fit?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

He files away the point that alter-Mariona expects him to be 'overprotective' to try to fit into some kind of coherent sense later.

"...If all of your [vitality] has been stripped away from you, then you were in far more danger, attempting that, than I had begun to suspect.  And your exosuit more protective, if you survived."

"[Negative levels] can partially strip away [vitality] temporarily and revocably.  [Status] might detect them, [Death Ward] would suppress them for [minutes].  But I already-seem-to-know-and-predict-in-my-heart that those [spells] will detect nothing and suppress nothing.  If the [Outer God] simply -- stripped away your [vitality], in the process of rewriting you -- that is terrifying even by [Dark Tapestry] standards."

Permalink Mark Unread

Okay!!! It seems like they totally in fact failed to be on the same page about a really important thing!!!!!

(Merrin is very briefly tempted to be embarrassed about it, and catches herself, because if her first response to successfully noticing the really important thing is a negative one then she will implicitly be punishing her brain for having thought of it, and she knows better, and she has significantly more important priorities here than feeling stupid.) 

 

"My suit is very well designed for what it does," she agrees. "And - I absolutely wouldn't have tried that without [healing spells] and someone to rescue me," and, you know, the fact that she still feels like the default outcome is dying trapped on an exoplanet, which shifts her degree of risk-aversion significantly, "but - I think I'd've put 90%, maybe 95%, odds of being fine if I hadn't been dragging you, because I just wouldn't hit anything? It sounds like you were modeling me as having less situation-relevant skill than I do, and just more generic physical toughness, but - I wasn't injured when I went in after you the time you were unconscious, I have a lot of training in more or less that exact thing, actually, rescuing injured people in hostile water conditions, that might be the single hazard-scenario I've trained on the most. I just wasn't used to the hydrodynamics of pulling you on a rope and failed to compensate." 

Subtext: Merrin does NOT think the correct update for him to make here is that she's strictly less capable than he thought! That seems like the wrong update, and one that might incorrectly lead him to rule out plans that would in fact work. Also it would make her sad, she doesn't want him to feel like she's less capable than he thought she was and be disappointed in her for not being his Merrin-version

 

In the back of her mind, she's quietly making a mental note that Estha seems pretty thoroughly surprised and alarmed by the revelation about her normal human biology, whereas to Merrin it's entirely unsurprising and just obviously how it would work in an alternate-universe scenario. 

(She's still not saying anything to him about that, apparently. Because she's uneasy, for reasons she can't pin down but that Laeirthe thinks she should provisionally listen to even if she can't lay them out in logic - and, like, he's not wrong that her judgement is constantly working like that, she often has a really hard time verbalizing the logic behind her intuitive judgements, it's super annoying but it doesn't mean her judgement is wrong in those situations - anyway, she...somehow feels like it might destabilize something, here, to push back too hard on alternate-Estha's current hypothesis that she shares some kind of meaningful continuity of self with his Merrin. And since there are all these things neither of them wants to talk about, if she does destabilize their current working relationship, she's not sure that talking about it longer would even fix it.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

"It's not so much a question of what you can sometimes do successfully, as a question of how quickly you die if something goes wrong, Merrin."

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah okay it's possible she is perhaps a bit defensive. However, remind her which of them it was again who had to be dragged out of the river unconscious and not breathing, and which of them was doing the rescuing that is not a productive thing to argue about. How much is her problem right now just that Kalorm is pissed off that someone is lecturing her for doing something dangerous? That's not helpful. Shut up, Kalorm. Merrin thinks people are allowed to care about her risking her life! That's a normal thing to care about even if it also prompts some defensiveness!

 

"...Yes. It's pretty important that I don't have extra [vitality]," what a weird concept, "and I'll die more quickly," a NORMAL AMOUNT of quickly, "if something goes wrong. But at the impact speeds we're dealing with, the armor will prevent any impact from actually crushing my skull or snapping my cervical spine even if I take an impact really badly, it's specced to let me jump out of a plane without a parachute and land in water." Admittedly not for jumping out of a plane and landing in a tidal bore full of rocks, Exception Handling only ever let her do that over open ocean. "And I think those are the only injuries that would kill me outright in less than a minute?"

Which is a lot longer than it should take him to yank her out.

"...It was stupid of me not to make sure you already knew how to get me out of the armor if I couldn't help, including dealing with mechanical damage," she admits, after a two-second pause. "That was my mistake and I apologize." 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

"Ah.  Yes.  Of course you would be accepting final responsibility for that failure, since you are a trained Exception Handler, and Estha is an untrained civilian.  I, of course, consider myself to be Merrin's commander and the one person who was responsible for checking off items like that before starting the operation.  It doesn't speak that well of either of us, really, if we both considered ourselves to be in charge, and neither of us managed to get it done."  (...Esta says, because dath ilan yelled loudly there about not just accepting his subordinate's apology as his due, and then considering his own failures on his own.)

"Some of this is down to issues of trust.  Not just lacking trust, but wanting more of it.  I was curious about whatever unknown, useful, dangerous capability had casually sliced off my magical [armor], as should have been far beyond Merrin's [spells].  I did not ask you how it worked, because, you see, that might have seemed suspicious to you, or so I feared."

Permalink Mark Unread

Oh no the conversation grew spikes. Not literally but that's always how it feels, when she says something that she thinks is...appropriately ceding ground or de-escalatory or whatever she was even trying to do there...and instead of a response in kind, she gets complications. 

(Merrin is pretty used to apologizing for mistakes and having the person she's apologizing to immediately retort that it was not solely her responsibility. She does it all the time! She sometimes kind of wishes that once in a while someone would just agree and move on, because she has NOT managed to entirely get over the thing where someone pointing out that they had final responsibility for the thing makes her feel like they're claiming she wasn't competent enough to be trusted with it alone, yes she's aware that's very silly, it nonetheless still stings a tiny bit, someday she'll sort out her neuroticism the rest of the way and get over it. ...However, it sure would have startled and confused her if that had been Estha's response in this moment.) 

Okay. Untangle it, quickly, before she's been staring at him long enough that it gets awkward.

She really doesn't think she's been treating him like an untrained civilian! She would not have agreed to drag untrained-civilian-Estha on roller skates in a tidal bore! But she's been clearly doing some stupid combination of - half treating him like her Exception Handling supervisor, the analogous thing to whatever alternate-Estha is to alternate-Merrin, because she so, so badly wants there to be an adult in the room who isn't her - and also, yeah, not fully trusting him and being suspicious. 

 

"Well, I think our current policy is that we're not avoiding having me explain dath ilan to you for infohazard reasons," Merrin says. "And it sounds like I'd better explain a lot more about my Exception Handling training and my capabilities, until our implicit-assumptions are in agreement."  

She's not sure exactly what Estha is worried she would be suspicious of - she's already modeling that he's from a lower-tech world that does not have, say, powered tungsten carbide saws as standard emergency gear?

Also, this totally is a digression from - what were they even talking about that ended up diverted to this topic - oh. Right. That.

"Um, before we dive into sorting out assumptions in our working relationship, we...were kind of in the middle of talking about our personal relationship?" she says. "Should we wrap that up first?" 

Permalink Mark Unread

"Yes, good thought."

"It sounds like we're not on fucking terms.  Pain?  Oral?"

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Time moves slowly, for them, one new spell per day.

He wants to try Death Ward on Mariona, to see if she gets her levels back.

He wants to try Break Enchantment on Mariona.

...He knows on some level that the G̶͕͝r̷̰̈ȩ̴͂a̸̳͑ṱ̸̚ ̷͓̀Ń̷͍ǒ̵͎o̷̝͝d̴̖͂l̵̠̆ý̶̺ ̴͔͆O̵̰͗n̸̻̂e̵̪͝ wouldn't let it work, if he tried it.  Esta still doesn't know what to do about that besides try things anyway.

Next up on the next 24h cycle following Esta's next prayer is Ride the Waves, by which means Esta can look through some deeper underwater caves with Locate Object, that Lay of the Land say to run deeper than the 840 feet he could probe from the surface; and then look through some simpler and shallower cave systems with Detect Magic, though that might be blocked by stone, and is not reliable.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin questions him in detail on the spell and concludes that it’s…actually very close to the same feature set as her armor on full aquatic mode? 

She’d like to go with him. She can’t usefully help with the search spells, but she has the software version of the map and better radiation sensors than what she can give him to wear and she still suspects she has a more detailed predictive model of the various hazards this planet keeps throwing at them. And it's just in general often safer to do things in pairs – if something happens to her then that'll inconvenience him, but if she can point out a danger that would otherwise have forced him to Word of Recall back to the camp and heal himself, then that would mean more searching gets done. Merrin will hear out his arguments to the contrary, if he has them, but she thinks that on net she will not slow him down. 

(Also, cave-diving is epic and cool and - she's trying not to think of it as explicitly romantic, but it's certainly good for their working relationship to do more teamwork-searching.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Wind Walk.

If Merrin asks why they didn't do this earlier and instead of getting her injured trying to ride a tidal bore, it's because Esta has never cast this spell before, Esta didn't realize how much danger she was in, and Esta was leery of messing with his 6th-circle slots under poor prayer communication conditions.  And not at all because Iker Egobar had helpfully mentioned to Esta upon his attaining 6th-circle that everyone would be incredibly unimpressed with Esta if he found some flimsy excuse to cast Wind Walk, after which Esta had very nearly managed to forget the spell existed.

Permalink Mark Unread

From Merrin’s point of view, ‘never cast the spell before’ is a full explanation and she has no further questions! 

(Merrin continues to have a much less detailed understanding of how exactly [clerics] of [gods] acquire their eroLARP superpowers [spells] than Estha now does of her Exception Handling specialist capabilities, and she would be pretty reluctant to try a piece of gear or an emergency maneuver she had literally never trained on before, in field conditions, on ANOTHER PLANET, with no backup, etc etc.)

If he thinks it’s safe, though, she would be delighted to accompany him and walk in the wind. It’s pretty epic! 

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah, okay, perhaps Kalorm is warming up to this Estha person, because Wind Walk is AWESOME!!!

Permalink Mark Unread

As fun as it would be to swoosh around some slimecaves at low tide, that does not actually make sense as a strategy — they can swoosh around much faster above ground, without the risk of running into a pocket of radon accumulation, and any depth of cave that’s safely unflooded at low tide is within reach of Estha’s Locate Object spell. 

The interconnected tidal caves extend a pretty long way, though, and the Bag could conceivably have ended up tossed and wedged pretty far “upstream” in one of them. They’ll end up covering land areas that Merrin never got anywhere near in her own limited exploration.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin is in many ways so fond of her stupid horrible exoplanet with all its hazards and inhospitality to terrestrial life. 

 

And she's always been good at finding her moments of joy. It's kind of silly to be proud of how beautiful it is, and feel like she gets to show it off to Estha as though it's in any meaningful way hers, but who's going to stop her? 

 

They can't really justify taking any time away from the Bag search to do fun things for no reason, when that's still their highest-probability-of-success plan for getting off the planet even if the conditions under which it might or might not ever work are deeply metaphysically confusing. 

But Estha has a limited number of minutes per day of Locate Object, and if at some point he's out, with many hours to go until his next prayers, and it's a beautiful day outside and he's immune to UV and he has a Ride the Waves going spare...

 

...the continental shelf out to sea is really neat. That's where most of the life on this planet is. Would Esta like to come out and see it with her? 

(Merrin is trying not to frame it as a romantic date, but - it has to be good for him, too, to do fun things once in a while, when this has been going on for days and days?) 

Permalink Mark Unread

He weighs the proposal for a time.  He could, in principle, spend more of that time looking through caves with Detect Magic that might have his Bag somewhere that Detect Magic could find it.

...but like, actually in real life, probably, they are not getting out of here until Ÿ̵͕̳o̴̢͖̍͆g̴͖̕-̷̪̩͛S̷̟͂̒o̶̩̩͋̽t̷͓͛̈́h̷͇̃ő̸̞̚͜t̸̛̩͠h̶̖͎̋ has accomplished whatever great and incomprehensible purpose It intends.  Probably a greater variety of interactions between himself and Merrin, without him yet doing anything that would collapse their relationship to straightforward dominance or hatred, gets them there faster.  Right?

Right!

Sure, Esta will go on a fun date.

Permalink Mark Unread

Permalink Mark Unread

...The incredibly lost squirrel has started to seem more distant over time.  Either that planet is drifting away, or the squirrel itself is; probably the latter, if it's chittering around with no entities to tyrannize and nobody to tyrannize it.

The squirrel is still using all the Locate Objects every day; and it has requested spells reminiscent of searching for something through land and air and water.  But Asmodeus has been down this road before; it's time to retrieve that pet squirrel.  If it's searching for something worth the time, Cheliax can Gate back to that planet afterwards.

The next time the squirrel prays, it gets a Sending, a Plane Shift, and a Homeward Bound.  Hopefully that message is clear enough.

Permalink Mark Unread
Permalink Mark Unread

 

...how strange.  It seems he had begun to enjoy his time here more than in Cheliax, no doubt due to sheer laziness and lack of ambition on his own part.  Esta had not realized before, he had managed not to realize.  But it is obvious enough, once Asmodeus calls him home, and that feels like a punch in his stomach.  The blow is too great, felt too quickly, for Esta to suppress it or for him not to notice.

He has been spending too much time inside Cultural Adaptation to a dreamworld, and zero time inside the Palace at Egorian; his mind has grown undisciplined.

Esta will not dare the Homeward Bound, if they are somewhere that Planar Binding could not call a devil (this decision not being determined by how Mariona would be left behind, of course) and he has no tuning forks yet for a Plane Shift.

But he will send his Sending, before this day is done.  Not to Iker to whom he reports, nor yet to Aspexia Rugatonn.  There are procedures, when at least one of you has been touched and contaminated by an Outer God.

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin...has honestly been kind of vaguely worried about Estha, lately. 

Their survival status is, for the moment, fine. Stable indefinitely so long as they have two Endure Elements and one Create Food and Water per [day.] The days are still getting hotter, and Merrin has by now gotten a unit-mapping of the temperature range that Endure Elements covers and she suspects that even with that it won't be safe out in the open in the afternoons, come full summer. But there are caves. She's mapped out like six hypothetical possibilities for longer-term summer shelter.

 

And...for Merrin, that's already more than she had expected, right? She had experienced True Death. She hadn't thought there would be anything more for her at all. She had four months to...process, grieve her old life, come to some kind of sort of acceptance. She's not ""at peace"" with the possibility that they won't make it off the planet alive, or at the very least Laeirthe is not at peace with it, but, still - 

 

- her planet will be fine. Dath ilan was fine before she was born and will continue to be fine without her and she doesn't have to worry that her absence will cause any measurable harm whatsoever to the Civilization she left behind. She's sad, for her mother and her siblings and her friends and her boyfriends and - the real Kalorm, the one who isn't in her head, and his family, and there are probably other patients who stuck less in her mind but she stuck in theirs, and now she's gone, from their point of view irretrievably, and that will leave a hole in the world, just...not one that brings any buildings down with it, you know? No one was counting on her and her alone - okay, with the possible exception of the actual Kalorm, who did at one point insist he would only carry an emergency beacon to summon Merrin specifically, but...Kalorm is Kalorm. He's not even scared of True Death, and he's kind of spent his whole life trying to make it so that his loss wouldn't bring down any metaphorical buildings. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Merrin does not know that the same is true for Estha. She suspects it isn't. 

 

The narrative tropes theory hints that one of them might be from a place with very bad problems, and it's certainly not her. And it...fits, with the differences she's seen in him. 

Her Estha wasn't always happy, she doesn't think. Most dath ilanis are happy less often than she is, because it's honestly bizarre that Merrin is just as delighted the hundredth time her patient comes off the ventilator and takes a breath on their own as she was the first time. But her Estha had fun, on purpose. He knows how to do self-care and Merrin is not sure she's seen alternate-Estha do something she would describe as "self-care" at any point so far. Merrin is doing a ton of deliberate self-care, because she's under a lot of pressure and now would be a really bad time to end up depressed and full of cognitive distortions about it!

Permalink Mark Unread

And Estha is probably experiencing even more pressure, if Merrin's guess is right, that something is wrong back home and he can't, actually, be certain that all of the metaphorical buildings will stay up if he's not there to hold them. That's a really stressful situation to be in, knowing that something is incredibly important and not knowing if any of the actions available to him are ones that can even in principle move toward the important thing! Stress is bad for people, especially if they never do anything to try to relax! 

Permalink Mark Unread

But most of Merrin's observations and interpretations of them are still - at the implicit level difficult to verbalize, let alone put numbers on, let alone link up into a coherent logical case for why he should listen to her and do something differently.

Laeirthe is surprisingly unhelpful on the matter, probably because he has fun but he doesn't need fun to be functioning at his best, he just needs there to be a problem left to solve, and that character trait came through a lot stronger in the version-in-Merrin's-head than the original canon. 

 

 

Anyway. Merrin hasn't, at this point, even gotten close to considering if she should, like, have a conversation about it? There is a point at which it would solidly feel like she was making a mistake, on an interpersonal-relationship-ethics level, by having her concerns silently and not telling him. But that point isn't now, mostly because it feels like if she tries the conversation will be full of culture-gap pits full of metaphorical spikes and she'll probably end up communicating some different concept that isn't actually what she meant, and that does not sound like a way to decrease Estha's stress levels at all

(Trusting him might? He did say something that hinted that he maybe wanted her to trust him more, but - one, "trust Estha" is not an atomic action Merrin can just decide to take, trust in someone is a belief-state and that's not how beliefs work, and two, if it somehow was then that probably wouldn't be the thing Estha wanted, because that's messed up. Anyway, Merrin really feels like the problem here is all the cognitohazard stuff that Estha can't - or won't - tell her about, and she can't unilaterally decide that they're going to be fully open with each other now, and one-sided complete openness with him is...not, really, something that appeals to her right now.) 

 

Merrin has concluded that the best thing she can do is to be okay, on her end. To be reliable and predictable and super on top of the logistics that are in her purview, and to be uncomplicated to coordinate with and handling her emotional support needs on her own rather than flailing at him across a culture gap and falling into metaphorical spike pits. 

(This is maybe slightly a self-serving conclusion, because doing that is easy and comfortable for Merrin, whereas having a fully open conversation about how Laeirthe is in her head and that might imply things about what the [Outer Gods] want here does not sound easy or comfortable at all. But Merrin has poked at it and concluded that that doesn't mean it's the wrong conclusion.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

His first thought was to quietly go off by himself and cast Sending without telling Merrin.  Sort of a sheer existential reflex, there.

Then he gamed out in his mind what would happen after that, thankfully fast enough to realize that, actually, some of this was Mariona's business and Merrin would be offended by his concealment, which is stupid if he just has to tell her anyways.

He can't think of any good way to introduce the topic, so he'll simply go to Merrin after prayer and say it.

"My [divinity] gave me the spell that I would use to contact our department.  There is a small chance they show up immediately after that; and a larger chance that they show up the next [day], on their own cycle of [days] and [prayers]; after Athpechya, our executive, has a chance to request 8th-circle [Discern Location] and 9th-circle [Gate]."

Permalink Mark Unread

….Huh? 

That’s - surprising - why is that surprising - mostly it’s bizarre on a narrative level, but when Merrin uses normal logic she can totally think of possible answers to the question of 'why now' in the first five seconds of considering it. 

 

"Understood," she said. "...Do you have ideas on why now? My first thought was - if there's an urgent problem back home and they need - us - but I don't actually know if that's plausible?" 

(She considered for a moment if it was deceptive to say 'us' when, like, her single highest-probability hypothesis is one where she's some sort of alternate-universe copy of the Merrin from the eroLARP superpowers setting who Estha actually worked with. But, like, she doesn't have anywhere else to go? And she doesn't have [cleric] [spells] but she does have other useful capabilities, and if Estha's world has scary problems then obviously she wants to help.) 

Permalink Mark Unread

"That's -- a good question to which I do not actually know the answer, except, it's not that they suddenly need me, I'm not sufficiently important.  I have the sense that my [god] has trouble perceiving this place.  Perhaps It gave me time to try and make my way back on my own, by any means I might, saving two very valuable spells from our department head; but we have now run out Its hope in our project."

(Esta did at one point think that Asmodeus was feeling a little more distant in prayer, but then immediately crushed down that thought, so it is not currently available to Esta as a first-round hypothesis that this is his own fault for growing more distant from his god.)