« Back
Generated:
Post last updated:
Through a hole in the sky
Some things you can't predict even in retrospect
Permalink Mark Unread

The most important day in human history began, as far as the records of Civilization can tell, almost precisely like every other day that proceeded it. It was not the anniversary of some great event, except insofar as all days could be counted as such given a wide enough view of dath ilan's hidden history, nor did it coincide with any important laws or elections. No storm clouds rumbled on the horizon, no portents heralded its coming, and the prediction markets for p(first contact today) were hovering at a value low enough that a less statistically literate civilization might be inclined to round it down to zero. Indeed, perhaps the biggest news item for the denizens of Schelling Point was that the anticipated 14 hours of uninterrupted summer sunlight would drive the temperature up to nearly 110 standard* and incentivize UV protection for those expecting their lives to take them out of their temperature-controlled environs. 

*About twenty seven degrees Celsius, or 300 Kelvin.

 

 

 

Permalink Mark Unread

At 8:16 AM local time, there's a distortion in the air. A keen observer might analogize it to a heat haze, though in truth the resemblance is more superficial than anything else. 

 It lingers for about thirteen minutes, passively observing its surroundings, and then sets off. In motion, the stealth is significantly less effective, but it still serves the role of disguising just what is doing the moving, and whatever is causing the visual distortion appears bright enough to be careful of the sightlines of passerby and make good use of cover, shadows, and blind corners as it makes its way down unfamiliar streets. Does anything interfere with this?

Permalink Mark Unread

A few dath ilani spot some movement out of the corner of their eyes, but nothing in particular comes of it. The city's cameras get a much better view of things, of course, but there isn't anyone watching their feeds live with enough care to flag it as unusual.

Permalink Mark Unread

The shimmer sticks around for over an hour, though a lot of that time is also spent on stationary observations from better viewpoints. It ranges a few blocks from where it first made its appearance, circles around, and then makes a return to the location it first manifested to disappear completely. By 9:37 AM, there's no sign it was ever there.

Permalink Mark Unread

Absent any information to nudge it off its tracks, the inhabitants of Schelling Point continue to go about their day in the manner they are accustomed to. Those who welcome the warmer weather make their way outside, for lunch if their schedule doesn't otherwise permit it, while others make use of the city's large underground transportation network to avoid its rays. Surge pricing pushes the average cost of chilled drinks and treats up 2%, but the predictability of the change in consumer habits means that most of the increased demand is absorbed by increases in throughput.

Permalink Mark Unread

At 11:23 AM local time, a large marble structure supported by columns appears in the middle of a busy downtown street. The people taking up the space find themselves suddenly elsewhere, and a battalion of armored men on horseback stream out of the structure and into the city proper. No trumpets herald their arrival; the scout didn't mention any nearby military positions, but the best way to minimize their losses is to make the most of the time until that changes, so their fastest elements are set towards making contact with their opposite numbers and running down any isolated detachments.

The local residents will get out of their way, or they will be run over.

 

Permalink Mark Unread

What the superheated toilet paper?

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Earlier and elsewhere:

Permalink Mark Unread

To be a noble of the Saderan Empire is to be an heir to the greatest military legacy the world has ever seen. For seven hundred years, the Saderan dragon has issued forth from the imperial city to spread the Empire's glory, and for seven hundred years, never has there been a defeat they could not expunge. Even now five thousand miles separate its eastern border from its westernmost extent, and those nations beyond its borders deliver regular tribute to ensure that status endures. Every aristocrat's childhood is filled with the tales of those heroes that achieved such victories, and of all the imperial offices, there are few more coveted than the right to command a legion. 

It doesn't usually feel that lucky to Legate Cattaneo, but from the sound of things, today might be the day that that changes.

Permalink Mark Unread

The biggest thing they never tell anyone about being a legate is how hard it is to actually be a conquering hero in this day and age. The other downsides are nearly impossible to miss, from the immense bribes required to get the title to what feels like every other noble in the empire jumping on even the tiniest display of weakness, but somehow he'd always managed to delude himself on this score prior to getting the job. You wouldn't think it from looking at a map, after all; even the least adept cartographers were happy to display a dozen other countries on their maps, and none of them held a candle to the might of the legions, so by all rights they ought to be ripe for the picking. It took a closer and less rose-tinted examination to see the flaws that constantly bedeviled him, and no doubt had done the same to a number of his predecessors. 

Right off the bat, you could cross a full third of them off the list with prejudice. Those countries might have had their own kings or queens, but they were the Emperor's vassals in every way that mattered. Their men wandered the court and senate with impunity, ensuring they would know your plan before you even got to mustering, and the emperor was more than happy to take their lavish gifts in exchange for discouraging any foolish adventurism from his generals. It wasn't even really possible to count on victory to wipe away the stain of disobedience, because their taxes were already flowing into the imperial coffers and even hiking up the rates wouldn't make up for the shortfalls a war would cause. It could still be done, of course, but one might as well set their eyes on a neighboring governor for their trouble, especially since given a hundred years to copy the Empire even lesser nations could figure out the basics of a proper army. That left only the far-flung barbarian kingdoms as real options, and none of them came without strings attached. Marching a Legion three thousand miles across the continent to fight a war was expensive, to say nothing of the difficulties in procuring food, and with how little loot they had to go around you'd have to be able to cover most of the finances out of pocket, all for the glory of conquering some territory nobody in Sadera had ever heard of. There were always exceptions to any rule, but his fellow legates were not in the habit of leaving good invasion targets unmolested for long, and absent a miracle the best you could hope for was to imitate Prince Zorzal and just eat the cost of a ruinously expensive conquest to come out with a win. 

Legate Cattaneo hadn't been expecting to get his hands on a miracle like that, but given the proper motivation his augurs and magi had come through for him in a big way. A divine gateway to another world, one where nobody had heard the first thing about how to deal with imperial dragon knights or a proper tortoise formation? It didn't matter if he could hold it or not, even a sufficiently successful raid on another world could garner him the kind of status none of his peers had managed in almost a century, or else the wealth to parlay into another conquest entirely. He could practically see a marriage into the imperial family on the way, to say nothing of the wealth and senatorial standing, and he'd be damned before he let it slip through his fingers.

Permalink Mark Unread

Fortunately for his ambitions, the gods had truly smiled upon him. The first stroke of good fortune was the location - Alnus hill was only two hundred miles south of Italica, so getting everything he needed into position would be simplicity itself, but it was also far enough away from the imperial capital that he wouldn't raise questions about if he was planning a coup. The second was the sheer size of the aperture in question at its greatest extent; the image brought to mind by 'gateway to another world' was far smaller than what it proved able to manage, to the point that he wouldn't have any issues with getting the wyverns through and the cavalry could ride ten men abreast. It would let him make the most of the element of surprise, especially the first few critical minutes, and would hopefully be enough to prevent any elite detachments from slowing them down by holding a chokepoint. The third stroke of good fortune was that the local rector was a yellow like he was. It was hardly the tightest factional bond, and he had certainly never met the man other than in passing prior, but some of his friends knew their friends and some favor trading was enough to get local support in his preparations.

 

Permalink Mark Unread

And so it was that, on the morning of the 14th day of the 6th month of the 687th imperial year, 17th Duncanica Legion arrayed itself for battle and waited for the return of its scouts. A potent force even in times of relative peace, its numbers had swollen with mercenaries, local auxiliaries, and temporary transfers until it numbered almost half again its usual size. Though as always the it was the heavily armored human infantry that made up the core of the army's strength, they were joined by orcish archers, heavy and light cavalry, three different detachments of wizards, ogre siege companies, and as many dragon knights as the legate could tempt away from their ordinary duties.

All together they made nearly twenty-five thousand heads, which some might call it excessive, but he disagreed. For all that the history of Falmart was littered with countries that had been conquered by less, it was also littered with the corpses of generals that had taken the favor of the gods for granted and not ensured that their victory was sufficiently certain. Their blessings could be fickle at the best of times, so while he made sure sacrifice generously in the days prior he had also made sure to supplement that with careful preparation, from endless drills to the coveted illusionist wizards making their report to him right now. There was always something up to chance, but if Legate Cattaneo had his way this battle would be entirely one sided.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Again, what the superheated toilet paper?

Permalink Mark Unread

There's a cavalry battalion charging out of a weird archway that suddenly appeared in downtown Schelling Point. And if you don't get out of the way, you're going to get run over.

Permalink Mark Unread

...So, a team of aggressive horse-racers wearing primitive protective gear and some kind of... sports equipment just appeared out of thin air and charged into a busy street? That feels incorrect but we have so many overlapping confusions here it's not trivial to disentangle them, even to the point of figuring out how to test the moving parts of that hypothesis. They're very big and moving very recklessly, though, so we're definitely getting out of the way; our insurance injury premiums would go up a little even if theirs pays out for them being obviously at fault, and also it seems like it would hurt. It should be fine, obviously they don't want to hit anyone either.

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Of course not. They're an elite military detachment, here to take down as many defenders as possible before the city has time to rally a proper defense; they don't have time to waste on random passerby. They're just not going to go out of their way to avoid it either, especially not if it means slowing down.

Permalink Mark Unread

The streets aren't so crowded there isn't any room to move out of the way, and further off people making room for the people displaced by other people moving out of the way is just another coordination problem, but a few people still aren't light enough on their feet and get hit by a glancing blow from most of a ton of metal and muscle moving by at speed. Some of those screams definitely imply broken bones.

When you're experiencing events wildly out of agreement with consensus reality, the general suggestion is to loudly announce tsi-imbi and avoid any actions that, if you are hallucinating, might result in you hurting real people. Portals don't actually open up in the middle of busy streets, but people do sometimes experience psychotic breaks that render them unable to distinguish what's really going on. Along the street, usage starts picking up; it's not most people by any means yet, but even the ones who wouldn't go that far are very confused.

(People are still going to go help the people who got injured, though, obviously, and call emergency services.)

Permalink Mark Unread

They don't speak the language, and any attention they have to spare from their task is going towards just how godsdamned weird this city is; humans acting slightly weird doesn't rate in comparison. If it's important, the infantry will have to deal with it.

Permalink Mark Unread

Said infantry are, naturally, the next group through the gateway. Given the emphasis on haste, one would be forgiven for expecting the dragon knights to be next, but such assumptions rest on a fundamental misunderstanding of imperial tactics and ignorance the material reality that underlies them - that wyverns are expensive.

From the small clutch sizes that make it difficult to expand their population to the immense number of calories required to sustain their active metabolism and flight, behind every dragon knight in the legions is a lies a fortune invested over decades prior by some imperial noble house allied with the legate. Compared to such princely sums even maintaining a warhorse begins to seem positively affordable, which is Saderan doctrine has always been to take the utmost care with their use; cautious, measured deployments to favorably balance risk and reward, followed by overwhelming force to break the enemy morale and chase down the scattering survivors. If instead the wyverns went first and were ambushed when going through the gate - grounded, in small numbers, in a city held by the enemy - he could in one stroke cripple his most capable forces and anger his most important allies.

Permalink Mark Unread

And so on the heels of the cavalry legionaires begin to stream into Schelling Point at a steady jog. What resistance do they encounter?

Permalink Mark Unread

It would be an exaggeration to describe any part of today as predictable, but whatever the cause of the sudden street building, it's pretty clear that staying nearby is going to be at least moderately hazardous to your health. Most of the populace has backed off, leaving only a small curious contingent to examine the structure. Even at a closer glance, it still looks like stone, and it's not entirely clear how it was hidden and/or faked. If it's a prank, it's a fairly high effort one of the sort people more often tend to imagine doing than usually pull off.

(A prank is the leading umbrella hypothesis here, with shares on 'yes' already trading at about 70%; while the hows and whats are still up in the air, it's a rare ilani who doesn't understand the appeal of pulling off something seemingly impossible to make someone else's day that much more surreal).

Permalink Mark Unread

I guess that technically counts as resistance.

The civilians can get some nonlethal spear prodding to move them away from the gate; they seem mostly fit enough it'd be a waste to kill them, but the centurion will have their hides if they're dumb enough to start looting and taking captives before the position is secure. Orders say they need a good bit more space before they start setting up the barricades or there won't be enough room for the wyverns to take off, so the gawkers are going to have to move a block or two.

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Superheated - Ow! The jabs don't seem to be aiming for vitals, but nonlethal doesn't mean not painful, and even the ones that aren't drawing blood are going to bruise.

"What's the big idea here?" 

Even for a prank of this magnitude, that's going way too far; he's going to sue their pants off for this nonsense.

Permalink Mark Unread

The barbarians are presumably saying something, but it's just so much noise to imperial ears; even the ones that know some of the regional creoles aren't parsing anything meaningful, and wouldn't be inclined to care if they did.

Permalink Mark Unread

Ow, ow, ow. A number of people nearby do have some level of combat certifications, but when dath ilani drill those skills it's typically self-defense-only or group-safe-subdual courses and neither are predicated around fighting an organized group with weapons while unarmed; the usual advice there is "don't." There are more calls going through to emergency services now, because even without new pertinent details each reporter can still move their internal prediction market about whether this is actually happening, and more bystanders are going to join in on recording. That doesn't seem to be provoking a reaction from whatever this group is, at least, and if you predictably refrain from recording events because other people seem to have it covered then it'll turn out tomorrow that the only people with recording were working with whatever group pulled off the stunt and none of the footage shows anything they didn't want it to.

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Elsewhere in Schelling Point:

In another circumstance, Mylonas would perhaps be willing to admit there was a certain humor in the situation. There were no shortage of ways a city's defenders could make the lives of cavalry hell, and some part of him had been dreading an encounter with foreign magics or battlements of archers or tight ranks of heavy infantry ever since he first learned of his role in the Legate's plan, but never had he expected that the largest roadblock in his efforts would be the vagaries of foreign architecture of all things. If you'd mentioned it to him yesterday, it would never have come to mind as an issue! After the third false start, however, he was forced to face facts - he had absolutely no idea where to even find the local administration. To his untrained eye every building in the city was practically the same, and his efforts to search those that stood out from the pack had thus far turned up a library, an indoor market, and what was presumably some sort of barbarian ritual space he didn't remotely have the context to recognize.

The locals weren't any help  - he and his men could scare them, no problem, but not one among them would admit to knowing a civilized language no matter the pressure. He'd have thought "take me to your leader" wouldn't be hard to grasp from a group of invading soldiers, but they weren't terribly smart either, and even killing a few of them didn't get the rest to wise up. Perhaps a scholar or soothsayer could get something out of the resulting babbling, particularly given the common threads therein, but 'see imbeye' was so much gobbledygook to his ears and the more comprehensible screaming didn't exactly give him new information. The only real positive of the affair was the lack of resistance - if the city did have a standing garrison, it was either well away from the downtown area or asleep at the reins, and both cases meant they could rest relatively easy when it came to retaliation. There would be time to join in on looting the place, at least once they'd done enough searching that they could defend their failure to capture the local magnates.

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Schelling Point emergency services is aware of the problem. It would be an exaggeration to say they understand the situation, but they have a lot more to go on than most of the people on the ground; there are quite literally hundreds of people around the city relaying their observations to the authorities, and they've supplemented this with an emergency protocals that give them access to (almost) all the cameras in the city. Within two minutes of the mysterious building first appearing, the situation was emergency services' top priority; within five, they had already escalated it to exception handling and started roping in keepers. 

The fundemental problem about dealing with it is that it's impossible. Forget the thing it's presenting as being, which is ludicrous on its face; how you'd go about convincingly faking the evidence they're getting is still unclear even having seen it done. They've already done the tests to rule out the worlds where it's an disciplined conspiracy of supercriminals with one good trick; you've got to posit an enormous group of supercriminals of unprecedented organization that also have multiple undiscovered tricks, and even once you posit that being true it doesn't really make them any less confused about what's going on. They're not all keepers, but even the average dath ilani is good enough at cognitive self-reflection to notice the problems there. And while it's typically considered best practices with confusing situations to make small, careful changes to iterate your model until it starts cohering, the 20th percentile guess is that true lives are at stake and the upper plausible limit on the number is alarmingly high.

Permalink Mark Unread

So you're paralyzed with indecision?

Permalink Mark Unread

No, of course not. Even children are capable of figuring out that not deciding on a course of action is usually one of the worst possible ones in a crisis, and emergency services is exceedingly well drilled at avoiding that particular pitfall. What they're explaining is why governance is not currently scrambling an airstrike.

Permalink Mark Unread

By the standards of its technological contemporaries, dath ilan's military is one of the least impressive parts of their civilization. They possess few grand fortresses, can speak of no great glories won in battle, and do not march in grand ranks. Across the entire world, and even including those civilian positions necessary for keeping the machine flowing within their numbers, less than a tenth of a percent of dath ilani are employed by the military at any given time, and even those slated for combat roles have often rather anemic ordinances.

Much of the reason for that is from a lack of need, but that's not the entire story. Certainly dath ilani have all been under one government for longer than recorded history*, so its deployments and procurement need only consider responding to infrequent internal threats, but even those strictly limited and knowable threats could justify a larger force. It's not even a question of money, either; certainly civilization would prefer not to spend resources inefficiently, but the rates at which they will trade their enormous wealth for preserving lives - even stochiastically, for most would not consider it a critical distinction - would stagger belief. Instead the reasoning is rather more structural, in that dath ilan does not in fact want its government to have a monopoly on force. Certainly all else equal they would prefer the armed forces capable of dealing with emergencies, but not at the cost of enabling it to stay in power without the support of the population at large, and the role a hostile military could play there is obvious even to people who phone in their efforts when it comes time to practice overthrowing the government. And since a key part of keeping those counterfactuals strictly counterfactual is ensuring nobody is incentivized to try it, there are an enormous number of checks on the army to limit what it can do, and especially what it can do in a hurry on governmental orders based on fantastical information.

One of the key consequences of this is that it's not exactly trivial to bomb one of their own cities** even if they wanted to. They could manage it once, if everyone involved in the decision making were to have themselves imprisoned pending trial to accomplish it, but - even if everything were exactly as it bafflingly seems, the difference between handling this alien attack optimally or not is conservatively thousands of lives. (There's also some significant concern about whether it would even work out that way - spears and arrows are not a particularly terrifying armament, but an army best modeled by that capability wouldn't appear without warning from a space that absolutely could not fit them with no prior records of their existence).

 

*A significantly less impressive timespan than it might sound, though the planet has indeed been unified for a while.

**With one notable exception, but it's the thorough hope of everyone involved that that particular contingency will never be needed.

Permalink Mark Unread

And so for now the missiles remain unfired, even if not all the planes that could launch them are still on the ground, and a similar forbearance goes for most of their other indiscriminate weaponry. This leaves emergency services with the unenviable problem of time. Civilization does technically have plans for dealing with an alien invasion, but the assumption has always been that by and large such an event was unlikely to occur and beyond their ability to win if it did. Between dath ilan and a civilization already capable of crossing the stars... there's only so much you can do at the other end of a power gap that large, even before you consider the fact that any opponent not confident in their ability to win such a fight could trivially avoid picking it. They're putting together new plans almost as fast as the new information flows in, but they're new plans, and the difficulty of logistics in haste is as always a problem. Everything more complicated than evacuating the city is going to take longer than anyone involved would like.

Permalink Mark Unread

And in the mean time-

Permalink Mark Unread

Yeah. People are going to die. 

Permalink Mark Unread

Just be glad this isn't one of the legions that likes to take skulls as trophies.

Permalink Mark Unread

...They had not been tracking that as one of the ways this could have been worse. Why would anyone do that?

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Tribune Benatus is not, exactly, satisfied with the status of the gate fortifications. It's not that they're bad work, by any means, though he's confident he could have done significantly better if they weren't racing against time - having a ready stockpile of construction materials goes a long way. The problem is the blasted city. Whatever bizarre local concrete they use to pave the streets is the next best thing to impossible to dig through without magical tools, and for some Hardy-damned reason they put it everywhere, limiting how much he'd trust the walls against any siege equipment. He doesn't trust the local buildings they've taken over as hardpoints either, not with how difficult the bigger ones are to properly sweep and the risk of an aerial insertion. It'd be better if they could just block off the staircases, but then anyone who could get there would have free reign to start raining down arrows or pitch or whatever improvised ammunition came to mind down on his people's heads, so he just has to live with the uncomfortably large troop detachments they require.

Still, perfect is the enemy of good, and unless his men missed an invisible mage there's nothing in position to threaten the gate right now. He gives the order to let the dragon riders off their leash, and the steady stream of soldiers and materials into his base camp parts to allow the enormous beasts room.

Permalink Mark Unread

Finally.

Permalink Mark Unread

Wait, no, back up a second here. Are those wings?

Permalink Mark Unread

Yes? How else would they fly, hydrogen sacks?

Permalink Mark Unread

It's not that it's inconceivable, so much as... flying creatures exist under a handful of very tight constraints, and large animals capable of powered flight don't look like that. Dath ilan has fossil evidence of a handful of species in roughly the right ballpark of size, and they all shared key traits by necessity.

Firstly, they need to have large enough wings for their size and a sufficiently aerodynamic body to have enough lift to stay aloft. Something around fifteen to one in lift per drag, in the ideal case, but certainly not less than five. Secondly, they need to be light. Every kilogram of mass in their body is another 10 newtons their muscles need to offset whenever they want to gain height, and flapping your wings is not the most efficient way to supply thrust imaginable. And thirdly, particularly if they do a lot of taking off from ground level, they need enormously powerful wing muscles. These “wyverns” fail all three, even before you consider the fact that they're carrying a rider (!) wearing heavy metal armor (!!) into battle. And you can't just say that it's genetic engineering, either; a modern sailplane can be enormously more efficient than any bird at flight, but the way it does that is by having a very precisely engineered shape, which again does not look like a wyvern.

 

Permalink Mark Unread

That's a bit of an exaggeration. They do make heavy concessions to the rider's weight; much like a horse jockey, the ideal imperial dragon rider is short and slender, and their kit is stripped down as close to the bone as possible. Their armor is made of bespoke plate, ruthlessly optimized to only cover what it must and enchanted for strength so it can be hammered thin without compromising the defense. Their saddle is simple and unornamented, sufficient to allow them to stand in their stirrups and prevent the wyvern's scales from chafing against their clothes, and little more. And the weaponry - oh, there the compromises run tight and dear, much to the dismay of every enterprising legate with the idea of dropping rocks or tar or flaming oil on their foes. This also gives insufficient credit to the muscles the wyverns do have, and the powerful metabolism that fuels them - a wyvern can easily eat an unsuspecting noble family out of house and home.

Permalink Mark Unread

And?

Permalink Mark Unread

And they're the chosen of the sun god Flare, though he rarely bestows his direct favor on any save for true dragons. If you think these are bad, you're in for a rude awakening later.

Permalink Mark Unread

...Noted.

Permalink Mark Unread

By now the surroundings of the gate are clear enough that no actual dath ilani eyes see the arrival of the dragons, but while a number of cameras were smashed this was mostly incidental. It's not immediately certain to the watchers that this is an air force, both because they know enough aerophysics to doubt the wyvern's capabilities and because dath ilan wholly lacks the concept of dragons as a specific alternatephysics animal, but they can see the wings and pull back the two stealth observation drones they've managed to scramble accordingly. The numbers are quite concerning; none of their pilots like the idea of engaging a foe of unknown capabilities, and they'd be doing it at a numerical disadvantage until reinforcements finish re-basing and refueling at local airfields. Additional anti-aircraft weaponry is distributed to the mustering infantry, and the evacuation advisory increases its urgency and starts prioritizing getting people too close to leave the city in time into shelter.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's a little late on that score. Wyverns are, when they feel the need to be, extremely fast. Not by the standards of a fighter jet, certainly, but dogfighting a vtol aircraft isn't impossible as long as it doesn't turn into a race. Once they get oriented they can cross even a city the size of Schelling Point in a matter of minutes, and unlike the cavalry their aerial view is a huge advantage in identifying clusters of people, and in particular which if any are plausible candidates for military organization.

Like, say, emergency services detachments helping coordinate the evacuation.

Permalink Mark Unread

It was always likely that they would prove unable to actually avoid a conflict entirely here, not when the aliens have been acting uniformly hostile to everyone they meet and proven extremely difficult to communicate with. They would still really like to avoid it, but not so much that they're willing to sacrifice this many people to delay it by a bit. 

The soldiers deployed around their approach open fire.

Permalink Mark Unread

The dragons swerve.

It's not that they recognize the guns - Falmart may technically have explosives, but only in the sense that there are some individual people on the continent who dabble in the right kind of magic or alchemy to produce a primitive version of the effect. But their riders do recognize soldiers waiting in ambush, and for all that dath ilani uniforms and armor are strange to their eyes their positioning is unmistakable.

Permalink Mark Unread

That's not going to work like you hope it will. 

One of the biggest factors in ensuring handheld firearms took longer to get adopted than artillery is that early firearms are terrible. They're expensive to supply, their rate of fire is slow, their accuracy is abysmal, and they have a bad tendency to stop working if they get wet. Compared to a mature technology like the longbow that can cripple a man at several hundred yards if it gets past his armor, it leaves much to be desired. Even in pre-screening dath ilan it took some time for people to change over, though they largely had the foresight to prepare for it ahead of time.

These are not early firearms. They fire heavy steel bullets at over twice the speed of sound, several hundred times a minute at full bore, and if their aim is imperfect it's a sight better than any bow or sling on that score. Hitting the riders is going to be a hard ask, at the speeds they're going and with an entire wyvern between them and the guns, but if they take down their ride that's basically as good and those wide wing membranes are an easy target.

Permalink Mark Unread

That's fine, those riders were the ones they were trying to keep safe from the attack in the first place - the wyverns are immune to small arms fire.

Permalink Mark Unread

I don't suppose you can operationalize that?

Permalink Mark Unread

Dath ilani soldiers will observe the bullets connecting with their targets and skittering off, though someone especially keen eyed might see one of them leave a mark occasionally.

Wyvern scales are harder than steel, thick enough that the bullets won't penetrate, and tightly packed around their body that there's no realistic way for a bullet to get through the gaps. They still transfer the kinetic energy, of course, but the scales are large enough to disperse the force, and these bullets have significantly less force behind them than an attack from a fellow wyvern. It's by no means a pleasant experience, but absent a particularly lucky hit sustained small arms fire will mostly only take down a wyvern slowly by attrition. 

Permalink Mark Unread

On Falmart, the going strategy for fighting wyverns when you don't have your own wyverns (as is unfortunately common in the empire's civil wars) is to run away, ideally after they are deployed and before they show up on the battlefield. Where that's not an option, they've learned to cope with aiming for the riders.

 

Permalink Mark Unread

It's not that they're an easy target - they're armored against that, sometimes even with wyvern scales of their own, and riding on the back of an incredibly swift aerial mount! But their armor has gaps, and underneath it is a distressingly mortal body. Missile fire typically rates second under accidental death on the job, but it'd be a different story if everyone had weapons like these barbarians. Their advantages and quick reaction let them avoid the worst of it, but a number of them are sporting bruises and broken bones and a few of them are now casualties.

Wyvern riders don't like the idea of taking casualties. You could say something about their class interests in not being killed by enemies, but it's as much a matter of pride as self preservation, and whenever a nation's archers pull off a particularly successful defense they rarely live to regret it. They're going to come back in for another approach, but smarter this time.

Permalink Mark Unread

The soldiers aren't less ready the second time, and for all they're apparently under-gunned for this scenario they aren't idiots. Their aim is better than it was, or at least more directed at the right targets, and they're more ready for the bizarre creatures' speed and flight patterns. And they still can't let them get to the evacuating civilians.

Permalink Mark Unread

They're not happy about that, and several more of them outright die on the approach despite their own precautions. But then they're close enough to return a little fire of their own, and they intend to replay the favor with gusto. Where dath ilani troops stand alone, teeth and claws and spears tear them to pieces; where they are clustered... their heads rear back as though to spit, and their jaws unhinge to make room as a stream of pressurized liquid makes contact with the oxygen-rich air around. Cones of bright yellow flames wash over hastily-assembled fortifications, and find the makeshift shelters wanting.

 

Permalink Mark Unread

Most of them survive it. It's a simple matter of physics; human bodies are largely water, which takes a truly enormous amount of thermal energy to heat appreciably and renders them pretty resistant to outright burning. Fires usually kill people by making them unable to breathe, largely by toxic chemicals released in the burning process, and for all that it's rather impressively hot the breath just doesn't last long enough for it to be an exception to that rule.

That doesn't mean they're in any position to fight, though, not with the horrific burns and choking lungs and vision issues. Civilization might be able to make protective equipment for this sort of danger, but that doesn't mean their soldiers wear it into battle.

Permalink Mark Unread

The dragon corps will finish them off. These may be barbarians, but they were courageous and fought well; they don't deserve to face the lady below denied even their dignity.

Permalink Mark Unread

This is probably not them intentionally going out of their way to inflict true death as a threat but that doesn't mean Governance is not very unhappy about it. And for all that biological flamethrower CAS is a deeply bizarre way for another civilization's military technology to develop, it's clearly effective enough that refraining from further escalation is also going to get a lot of dath ilani killed. They're still nervous about the unknown unknowns, like this being somehow a horrific misunderstanding or the possibility of the aliens escalating back again and the resulting fight destroying the city, but they're out of good options and the prediction markets think this way is probably better in expectation.

The order is finally given to scramble the fighter jets, and Schelling Point's inbound logistics grid is diverted towards supplying people already on the ground with heavier equipment. 

Permalink Mark Unread

 

Permalink Mark Unread

For ten minutes, the Saderan Dragon Corps has uncontested control of the city's airspace. They don't know that they're on a specific timer, but even if there weren't more of those ?archers? deployed elsewhere in the city that they'd really like to keep from linking up it probably won't take the locals very long to think of hiding in the buildings. And they're very fast, even if they end up losing a bunch of time at every engagement actually finishing off their enemies. Compared to the earlier cavalry scouts or the masses of infantry slowly spiraling away from the gate, it's a difference of night and day.

Permalink Mark Unread

It's a bloody harvest. Their guns are good enough to make the dragon corps pay for it, but not good enough to win or drive them off once the invaders know what they’re dealing with. They can’t just hide and wait out the riders either, because where they don’t find soldiers they go after civilians and they aren’t very careful with the heads.

It would be nice to have some kind of agreement not to go for true-killing or noncombatants, and indeed as a matter of principle Civilization is predictably willing to compensate any enemy who gives up strategic advantage thereby, but they were either insufficiently legible about this or their offer wasn’t predictably generous enough to offset whatever strategic advantage the aliens are getting from it. That’s going to go in the failure analysis somewhere, but it’s not really a surprising outcome that that particular area failed; given how mutually destructive wars are, anyone you can negotiate rules of engagement like that with is probably someone you can just negotiate to not fight with in the first place.

Permalink Mark Unread

Falmart may not have guns, but the idea of the weapon is not beyond their ability to understand. If you told a Saderan general about the existence of a form of missile weapon significantly more capable than slings or arrows, it wouldn't be too much of a leap to realizea thing or two about the effects on warfare, and if they underestimate the extent to which a gun could change warfare they would at least be largely correct about the direction. Having their first introduction to the topic being seeing it in action is rather more of a shock, but it's not a fundemental challenge to their worldview and having seen the results it's not actually that difficult to determine roughly what is going on.

The same cannot be said of other weapon systems. One moment the surroundings are clear, and the next half a dozen wyvern riders are dead and their mounts grievously injured.