with Max (Benedict)
with Earth and Lightning (kappa)
with Ann and Sabrina (kuuskytkolme)
The first thing he notices is that Brenda's has installed a new floor. This is weird, he reasons, because he would expect a complete floor remodeling to take some construction time and not be flawlessly installed overnight. He lifts his eyes from the floor to look around for signs of construction having been hastily cleaned up.
...Well, all this has nothing to do with that hypothesis at all. The windows are different, that's odd, there's new tables and chairs and a new bar and, come to think of it, a new floor plan, and new interior dimensions, and also new exterior scenery and oh boy this is not new decoration at ALL, is it. He must have walked into the wrong... no, no, that's... the street outside, to the best of his recollection, looked really nothing like exploding stars at all, whereas the view from this Wrong Brenda's... differs substantially in that respect.
He is standing in the doorway looking back and forth between the street and the inside of this entirely different coffee shop. Perhaps he thinks that if he looks between them enough times, everything will suddenly begin to make sense.
"Yeah, odd- is that- those- not fireworks, the-"
He steps outside, notes that it is a bright and sunny morning and the sky is not full of exploding stars, and steps back in.
"The outside is different from this outside. The outsides don't match. How can outsides not match?!"
There is noticeable dejection in his voice when he turns to her and says "If it's a TV, it's a 3D TV with head-tracking and higher definition than anything I've ever seen."
"So... okay, seriously. What's... there's something... what do you think happened here? This looks... a few different kinds of impossible. Where did Brenda's go?"
But first...
"What do you mean you weren't going anywhere called- where'd you end up here from? Huh?"
There are a couple obvious possibilities. One possibility, the stupid one, is the one where she is actually a Pokémon trainer. The other possibility is that he's talking to someone who's suffered some severe mental something-or-other and has lost the ability to distinguish between reality and fantasy. Neither is reassuring.
"What..." he begins, "do Pokémon have to do with..." he fails to continue.
Max screams and recoils from the bar, failing to read what's written. "WHERE DID THAT COME FROM?! What IS that?! HOW?!"
He stares at the "It's called Milliways" napkin, in the absence of anything else that suggests investigation. Alarm is not receding, but mounting as more seconds tick by without any explanation clicking into place.
"What's going on?! Where's Brenda's? What did you do?!"
He ignores the thing about being able to return home. The universe contains magic door-stealing talking bars, which is orders of magnitude more important than whatever he had planned for that that. And the way these napkins are talking, he's going to have to work at getting any answers.
"What do you mean you couldn't begin to tell us? Where did you come from, then? Who installed the magic talking napkin bar, huh?"
"So there's the door thing, and there's you, and you're separate, and you do napkins and beverages, and somebody else - invites people over to partake?" says the girl.
That's about the size of it. I can produce things other than beverages, though.
Her, please.
"At her," corrects the girl. "Things other than beverages like what?"
Virtually any medium-sized nonmagical object, although I do have to charge your tab appropriately.
He snatches the new napkin from the counter.
"Our TAB?! Any- nonmagical?! As opposed to- as opposed to...!!!"
Max would like to get properly riled up about the magic thing, but for some reason he's stuck on the possibility that he might be charged for being here.
"She's being nice so you shouldn't be mean," corrects the girl. "So I could get my Pokéballs and Potions here?" she asks the bar.
Yes, although I cannot guarantee that I can offer them at a competitive price depending on whether your usual establishment is having a sale or offers other discounts.
"What, really? You weren't just randomly being a jerk, you actually don't know what Pokémon are?" says the girl. She pulls one of the Pokéballs off her belt, expands it to full apple size, and bounces it on the floor. It opens, there is a flash of red light, it closes and bounces back to her hand, and where it struck is a creature.
The girl puts the creature's Pokéball on her belt again, then picks the animal up and puts it on her lap. It curls up there happily and nuzzles her under the chin. "He used to be a Zigzagoon but now he's evolved," she says. "I thought you didn't think Pokémon were real, how did you even get that close?"
There's got to be a connection, somehow. He should have paid more attention to his kid's yammering about it... no, no, he shouldn't have, that wouldn't have been a reasonable decision given what he knew at the time. Still...
"Pokemon is... its a video game, my kid used to play it, it was... you caught monsters and they fought each other, or something, trying to get batches of something. Supposedly completely fiction! Not a physically possible thing! This... has that in common with that thing. The bar thing, also impossible. There probably aren't multiple kinds of impossible coincidentally happening at the same time. So... connection! What is it?!"
"You do NOT lie to me! Do NOT tell me lies right now!"
Different worlds, that's... even in the face of the windows, and the napkins, and the thing that isn't a Zigzagoon, this... isn't right. Not if different worlds can mean things like... like that. Something else has to be going on here.
He's this close to demanding to see the manager. He has not, so far, considered the question of whether the staff have a policy on ejecting rowdy guests.
"Can my 'mon get free first drinks too?" wonders the girl, still transcribing napkins.
I don't see why not.
"Okay, can I get a aspear smoothie for me and qualot juice for Zag?"
A cup for her and a bowl for her Pokémon appear. The Linoone starts slurping up his juice happily.
He drops his hands and takes a seat at the bar.
"...I'll have a coffee. Lot of cream and sugar. Please."
He sips the coffee. It's good.
"I'm sure you're great at, whatever this is, the serving drinks- but clearly whatever whoever made you was optimizing for... was something they didn't think you would optimize for if you knew about it."
The girl's transcription is starting to catch up to the current napkin. "How often does the door thing happen? I've never heard of it."
Some people get doors routinely, some even more or less on demand. Others get them only rarely or once, and many people never find Milliways within their lifetimes.
He sips his coffee again. It's suspiciously good coffee.
"...so it wants something from people. Wants them to be comfortable but not knowledgeable, wants them to accept their situation and do something with incomplete information. It puts in a polite talking bar, to give you anything you want as long as it's not too powerful or dangerous."
Manipulation. There's manipulation happening here. But to what end?
I don't sell living things, except insofar as things like yeast count, says Bar. And I have some discretion in avoiding selling, for instance, weapons, to people likely to misuse them. The door tends to avoid people who will cause large quantities of trouble while they're here, but not necessarily people who could if they chose, as yourself.
Something should be happening, right now or soon. To take advantage of reciprocity, of course. Something the bar's going to ask him to do...
But there's the door. He could leave whenever he wanted. What is this place playing at?
"Ooh -" The girl flips back in her transcription. "And we go back to the time the door took us from, right? So basically they can put in work and go back home without having wasted any time?"
Under normal circumstances, yes. Your universe will not wait for you if you are not in fact ever going to return to it, or if you cannot do so until conditions requiring the passage of time in your universe are met.
The next napkin reminds Max about the universes thing.
"Okay okay okay HOLD on a second. Universes. I wasn't dealing with that until just now, that's the big thing. What do you mean universes, what- how are universes different from each other? How many are there? Are there other places they connect? What- how can there be Pokémon?"
"Do people who pick up Security jobs get doors more often so they can show up to work?" wonders the girl.
That sometimes happens, but it is not a guarantee.
"Is this your game? You play dumb to get me to call you a liar, so that when it's time for you to really lie I'm too embarrassed to call you out on it? I know a thing or two about the... quantum thing, and I know that infinite universes doesn't mean 'sometimes there's Pokémon!' What's really going on, here?"
"Don't be a jerk to the nice bar," says the girl. "There's no 'mon in your entire world? That sounds... super different. Huh." She scritches her critter. The critter makes noises.
He sputters for a bit, trying to find words.
"No, this- this implies that my foundational assumptions don't even work locally! I... I'm a human being, and my world's foundational assumptions predict that our existence should be extremely unlikely given starting conditions, and our fiction even more unlikely than that... but a completely different set of foundational assumptions taken from a random alternate universe, the kind that enable that thing-" - he points at the Linoone- "also produced human beings?!" - gesturing at the girl.
"There's... are most visitors here human? Did the door just select us from our universes because our dominant lifeforms were so unusually similar? What- how could there be a match like this?!"
"Have you considered the possibility that somebody learned about Pokémon here or something, and then went home and made a video game about them because they're cool?" inquires the girl.
Unless...
"Unless... you said there were an infinite number of universes, but the door... we know the door discriminates about where to open itself. Humans... may still be improbable under a wide set of possible... physics-s, but the door ignores the universes that don't contain... things that it understands, humans or things close enough to human that this bar would make sense. Am I close?"
If nothing else, says the bar, it does tend to limit itself to sorts of people who can interact sensibly with the dimensions and furnishings of this environment. Humans are still more commonplace than, for instance, elves, and I could not begin to speculate on why.
There's that manipulation at play again. Silicon-based hive-mind aliens with inhuman psychologies, less likely to be manipulated in the usual ways. Bring in people you can understand, who you can control...
But that comes back around the the same question- he mutters it under his breath- "why?" Why the bar, why the door, with the power to open doors to anywhere... what could they be after that they couldn't take for themselves?
His question is "can I get another coffee", because that was a good coffee, but... it's only the first one that's free, isn't it? If there's a trap, it's here. He asks a different question.
"What would another coffee cost?"
...he discreetly double-checks his wallet anyway.
"So... what am I supposed to do, here? What do people usually do, besides order drinks?"
"Ooh," says the girl. "How much are rooms?"
They vary by size but begin at ¥1500/subjective day spent within Milliways, in your currency.
"That's a steal for a hotel room," whistles the girl, "if they're at all nice."
Unlike hotel rooms they do not come with amenities beyond basic furnishings, although they do all have ensuite bathrooms.
"I... suppose I can afford one day here, to investigate. If time is frozen out there, I'm at least going to want to get my biorhythms in order so I don't start getting tired early."
He pulls a debit card from his wallet. "Do you have... a card reader, or something, or do you just... magically scan it?"
As an aside, he asks the bar if Milliways has compatible power outlets- he's going to want to take notes on his laptop, and it's low on battery.
He looks around for a napkin on the subject of power outlets. If the bar's aesthetic is a product of the home culture of its owners, presumably some sort of human, he predicts that if there are power outlets, they'd be some common Earth type.
Or, no, scratch that, he predicts they're probably magic and conform to the power interface requirements of whoever's using them, because they can do that kind of thing apparently. Or they're not there to discourage loitering.
"I have a Pokétch app. And a guild ID, for intraguild transactions. I don't think I've ever seen a 'mon working for a bank except as a security guard."
"So... buying things that aren't drinks, anything nonmagical. What are... the limits on how much you know about an order? If an alien walked in and asked for a znorfblarg, please, would you just know what that was? Would they have to describe it to you, would you have trouble fabricating something unusual?"
In the first case, it'd imply some magic inferential or oracular power whose limits could bear further testing. In the second case, the cultural vocabulary of the bar's creators could be triangulated by investigating the bar's menu. He has a good feeling about this avenue.
"And you- what's a Po-catch?"
"It's this," the girl says, pointing at her watch, which on closer inspection is some kind of smart watch. "It does lots of things, including my bank account."
"So, hold on. Real thing? There's an infinite number of universes, supposedly- so somewhere out there has to be something called a znorfblarg. It's definitely a real thing, I just don't have any idea what it is because I'm not from a universe with znorfblargs. If I asked you for a znorfblarg, I assume you wouldn't know what I meant and be unable to produce one. But... if someone came in from a universe you've never met anyone from before, and they ordered a znorfblarg... the only difference would be that they would know what a znorfblarg was. Do you... read minds, or is the system more complicated?"
I do not read minds, but the translation mechanism in place that is, for example allowing you and she to both read the same napkins and speak to each other also works for me, and it does not simultaneously inform me of all the homophones in the multiverse every time you utter a word.
He looks at the girl, trying to find writing somewhere on her clothing that he could confirm as an alien language.
If you take the napkins home, you will find they are in your language. If she takes them home they will be in hers. If you write something she will be able to read it here but not at home, and vice versa.
"I'm speaking Islandish," supplies the girl. "I probably have a pretty generic Sinnoh accent?"
"So, hold on. Does the text on the napkins change when I bring them home, or does the translation effect just persist on the napkin itself? If I took a napkin, left the bar, came back with the same napkin, and gave it to her, and she took it home to her world, would she find it written incomprehensibly in my language?"
He... realizes he can't imagine how knowing one way or the other would be useful, but he finds himself asking anyway. He invents himself a reason- if it's a persistent enchantment, he may be able to bring it home and get someone to study or reverse-engineer the magic. Yes. Good. Practical thinking. He awards himself a gold star in his head.
"How does this place handle ambiguous sorts of translations?" wonders the girl.
Very effectively, I find, considering the magnitude of the problem.
...No, wait.
"So, you can only order nonmagical things, but... you said you could sell her Pokéballs, right? Those things are as good as magic in my world, but presumably in hers they're ordinary technology. Is 'nonmagical' relative to the magic saturation level of the customer's universe, or something?"
"If you're about to ask if you can borrow a 'mon," says the girl, putting her Linoone back in his Pokéball, "the answer is no."
Now, hold on a minute.
"So- hold on, the door- how hard is it to catch a pokemon? In my kid's game, he could get something in like, a minute... if you went to catch a pokemon, and I held the door to the bar, would it stay open to your- I mean, bar, would it stay open to her world?"
If you are holding the door, the door will lead to your world, not hers, says a napkin.
Oh! Max remembers how he got on all this. Nonmagicalness, enchantments, translation, homophones... knowing about znorfblargs.
"So... back to the item-ordering thing... the translation mechanism is what translates my English into whatever you hear it as? That's... leaving aside how a fully general perfect language learning enchantment could be... psychologically invasive, what happens if I ask for a real thing whose name I know, but which I don't know anything about the details of? Say I visit some science lab, and ask someone to name an esoteric piece of equipment for me, and then come here... without knowing what it is, would I be able to order it by name?"
The sum of money for the Pokédex sounds exorbitant. In fact...
"And while I'm at it, how does pricing work? If someone lives in a universe where, say, batteries are extremely uncommon and expensive, and someone else comes from a place where you can get them for a couple bucks at the convenience store, do you quote them two separate prices? What's with that?"
"You don't need a list and you don't read minds- 'speaking English' isn't enough to know how to build a- a- a whatever complicated thing, just from its name! And- and the other thing, currency has nothing to do with it! If someone comes in and asks for batteries, and you base the price on how much they cost in their world, and they can't afford it... and then someone else from another world shows up, do they... do you see what I'm getting at? If I came from a world where they handed Pokedexes out like candy, wouldn't that price you gave be unfair?"
"Cause them to appear?! Wha- that's not how- what are you talking about?! What does that mean? Where does the information that tells you to make the one thing as opposed to the other even- there's- there's no free lunch!"
this bar is either stupid or lying or the fundamental mechanics of information theory are broken ohhh no no no no
Max, in unsurprising contrast to the bar's patience, is losing his cool, if he ever had it. How can this thing- how can she really not understand why this is strange?
"Right. Previous concepts. So..."- he puts his hands to his head- "You know, effectively, the definition of, and enough technical knowledge to synthesize rather than make a nonfunctional replica of, any medium-sized object anyone who speaks any language or dialect has a word for?"
That is... there are frightening implications, here.
Nonmagical objects, clarifies the bar. And there is some fuzz around the borders of constructed langauges and codes, some of which give me some trouble, and of course if you refer to something strictly fictional which cannot be made to work without magic I can't necessarily figure out how to make it for you.
Because that would be too easy.
"Ooh, but you can do arbitrary books that have been published?"
Of course.
"Are those borrowable? Are you a library?"
I am a bar, but I can loan you books.
Max's frustration and suspicion evaporates, and his jaw hangs open. This is probably what a religious experience is like, he thinks.
The girl laughs at him and names a book that she would like to borrow. The bar gives it to her, and she takes it and goes to sit by the fireplace. She releases a Pokémon to sit on her lap and be petted while she reads.
He has just under 24 hours to soak up as much lucrative knowledge as possible before paying another sixty-five dollars or leaving. Going straight for the big guns.
The girl finishes her much shorter book, orders an omelette and sandwich and food for all six of her Pokémon, asks for a handbook on working Security, reads it, signs on for a job, goes to sit in the Security office, comes back after a four-hour half-shift during which a few people who seem to be regulars and just want to eat come in and go out and don't make any trouble, gets a couple other things to read and reads them, and then departs the bar.
The elf, meanwhile, is slowly scanning the environs of the bar; she is apparently captivated by the window.
"Yeah, I- I didn't think I'd need her name, whatever- she signed up for your Security thing, right? What'd she put down on the form? And- no, wait, that's not the point, the point is why can she be the same person but a different species, this is a new kind of weird!"
The elf approaches the bar. Observing that Max has been talking to it, she says, "It would be good to know of your courtesy what manner of place this is."
She gets a napkin, which she reads with interest.
"Now- hold on, the same sort of... I have to assume, by the probability of this person appearing here, now, that... this isn't just, you have customers from an infinite number of universes and logically some of them are going to be similar. They're common enough for you to have a name for them."
He shakes his head.
"The question is, are alts a Thing, some sort of common template that proliferates more commonly than chance in a mere countably infinite set of universes, implying that they are significant in and of themselves without reference to this bar... or are they just... an artifact of which universes the door chooses to open to? It would imply... not that they're selecting for humanness necessarily, but that they're searching for universes that contain specific people- people close enough to some idea of who-they're-looking-for, that they decide to open the door to them, and not to, say, a random location on the Plane Of Infinite Featureless Jell-O Pudding."
Max is not optimistic about the chances of the bar having a particular interest in these questions of metaphysics. From what he's been able to gather, she just wants to serve drinks, and is only answering his questions to be polite.
I don't think every possible universe exists, at least not yet, but I couldn't say for sure. You might have to be more specific about how often you'd expect any of these things to occur 'by chance'. Although I will mention that a plane like the one you just made up would be unlikely to contain doors or people to open them.
The alternative is a deeper level of weird than he's willing to contemplate right now.
It is indeed a long napkin - the elf has unfolded it - but she is coming up on the end of it. "I would like some tea," she tells the bar, "if you don't mind."
The bar supplies her a teapot and teacup. She pours. She sips.
"This is, I think, the finest tea it has ever been my pleasure to drink."
"Elves have autumn blends? They- and you have tea, okay, and humanoid physiology and okay that was a useless observation."
...Elves, while presumably being one of many types of people in this bar's multiverse he doesn't know about, are the thing-he-doesn't-know-about that have a representative sitting right next to him.
"So... elves! What... actually, I don't know how to begin asking how you're different from humans, since you don't... do you have humans?"
He stops.
"...I'd like to know, but don't demand a response about, whether I'm right about questions having special syntax in your language. In the language that I'm really speaking, questions are... basically like what you're saying, stating the desire to know something, followed by a description of the thing, except the desire-to-know is indicated with like... it flips the subject and the verb, and there's a little inflection at the end, and that's it. Ingrained as a normal part of language. I mean... I should get Anna in here sometime, she's a linguist, she'd get like ten different research papers out of this."
"A-HA! Oh, that's good. That's something. I just said, in that language I don't know how to speak... well, what you just said, but in a different language from my own. So, the translation here... it doesn't preserve those differences. But... it could have had something to do with how I did know the meaning of those words. I wonder if..."
He spins around.
"Bar, could I borrow a... one of those guidebooks that translate phrases into English for tourists, like... let's say Russian, I don't know a word of Russian, a Russian to English pocket dictionary?"
"Okay, this can still work! I... well, maybe. Uh, Bar, does... if I take this book and sort of... lean out the door, so the book is outside, in my world, and read it from there, or... if I hold it open with my foot and stand out there and... question is, what's the limit of the translation effect?"
He walks up to the door and covers the English half of one page, then holds the book out the door and... oh. Right. Russian uses a different alphabet. He sits down and pores over the pronunciation guide for a minute, then selects a different random word.
He strolls back up to the bar and declares "картофель!"
"Potato," he repeats. "So this place translates whether or not anyone in it actually knows the meaning of the word. But," he continues, "If I say-" he rattles off a string of gibberish- "- then it's not going to mean anything, even though somewhere in some universe it probably sounds like something in their language. So it knew "potato", it knew that was Russian, because..."
"I suppose this would be interesting if you hoped to exploit the environment to evade large amounts of difficult translation work," says the elf. "It seems unlikely to matter for the purposes of casual conversation; it is a highly effective utility and cannot be brought home, so..."
"No, you don't understand! This... it means something's watching, it can infer things from context! There was no Russian-knowing mind here, just like there's no gibberish-knowing mind to translate the gibberish- but it knew anyway! There's just the dictionary- it can see, oh, he was using a Russian dictionary, so he spoke something in Russian... Bar, I'm assuming you don't handle the translation yourself?"
"...hm. Yes. I mean... well, you... you're also presumably a gibberish-knowing mind, right? Some species of alien or alternate human from one of those infinite universes probably has a word that sounds like- um, what was it, a znorfblarg or whatever I said. They're just not here. So... does it... does it pull all the languages from the world a customer comes from, or... did you learn Russian when you materialized that dictionary?"
Mumble grumble flawed experimental design grumble hrumble.
Max makes a weary noise and slumps back in his chair.
(And subsequently realizes it's a barstool, and struggles to regain his balance.)
"So, yes. A kindness, heh. If there's someone powerful enough to cross between universes, build consciousnesses, universally translate, and create anything they like on the spot... whatever this is, it's intentional. There has to be a reason for this beyond... some kind of benevolent whim. Nobody goes to the trouble of getting that kind of power just to do something like this."
"I'm not taking her word for anything. I just don't have enough information to figure out what she's more than likely lying to cover up. All I've got to go by is what these napkins say, and these napkins say she's got shadowy superiors who don't tell her anything. Not like I have leverage to make her stop feigning ignorance if she is."
"Oh, I guarantee participating in its sinister agenda would be more interesting than anything I could have planned for the afternoon. I just want it to happen already instead of keeping me in suspense! Driving me crazy, waiting around... well, waiting around reading an extremely interesting physics textbook, but... waiting."
He sighs and turns to the bar.
"Where's that room I bought? Think I'd like to take a look around."
Wait why is the view very nice, what happened to the exploding stars, what in the hell-
Max runs over and opens the window- and too late wonders whether the scenery might be an illusion and whether opening the window would suck him into the vacuum of space- but by all appearances, outside the window seems to lie a pristine wilderness with a perfectly ordinary sky. He waves his hand around outside a bit before turning and dashing back downstairs.
"What's that- up there, out the window?!" he shouts, the moment he steps foot on the first floor. "There's a lake! What happened to the stars?!"
That's a remarkably good point, actually.
"You... but, that is a noticeably atypical outside, I'm sure you... or... most universes, they do have continuous..."
How do you ask a sentient location about... their familiarity with...
"Just... what do you know about the outside, besides that half of it is stars and half of it is... whatever you said, lake and forest and so on?"
Rules about violence are relaxed in the back yard, the lake contains a giant squid, attempts to depart the area of the yard result in wrapping back around on the other side, the building extends laterally and vertically enough to prevent going around it, and people do not visit the area out front in person.