She has inexplicably tidy handwriting - inexplicably has handwriting at all; inexplicably can spell fifteen words in twenty instead of zero - which she uses, rather a lot. She makes a list of things that are food and magnetizes it to the fridge for reference, adding to it when she locates more things that are food, and when she is trying to tackle complex books she takes notes on who all the characters are so she doesn't have to page backward to remind herself, and she discovers journaling, even though she doesn't have that many events to record.
One day, the event she has to record is: Chris says to morrow she wil go to the DMV and shud not have us ther becas it may take six ours. We wil be baybe sat. If I hav ben baybe sat be for I do not remembre it.
She is curious about the imminent babysitter, and is up bright and early on the day when same may be expected.
"You can't hear them normally but you can hear them if you use this thing." She addresses Virginia. "Can I listen to your heart?"
"Part of what a babysitter does is make sure you're safe," she explains. "Whatever the reason is why you don't have a heartbeat, it means that you don't work the way most people do, and not knowing anything about that means I might not be able to do my job. So if Chris knows, it would be irresponsible of her not to tell me."
The list of unfamiliar words contains mostly nouns, and while many of them are relatively advanced - or archaic, given the source material - words, some of them aren't especially. She had to look up "aneurysm" and "Mormon", but she also had to look up "blood" and "cigar".
"Blood" is certainly the weirdest gap in Katie's vocabulary, but she was also pretty thoroughly devoid of knowledge of geography, apparently. She made a confused note about "hunting for food" - nothing Katie eats runs away and she hasn't seen anyone's carnivore entrées in a motile state - and she also had to look up "married" and "horse".
"Short version," says Chris, "when people breathe, we get oxygen from the air, which is something our bodies need to have all over the place in order to keep working, and we have blood to take the oxygen from the lungs all the way around to everywhere else, and the heart is the thing that pumps the blood to keep it going around, and the thumping is the sound it makes when it does that."
"There's ways," says Chris. "I'd consider these a sign." She shows Katie the blue veins on the insides of her wrists. "They are veins. They contain blood. It's red when it has oxygen in it, blue when it doesn't. Let's have a look at your arms and see if we can find any."
"No veins," she concludes. "But they could still be there; I don't think everybody's veins are the same amount of visible. Other ways to tell... well, under normal conditions people's blood stays inside of them, but if something pokes a hole in our skin, we leak."
"Evidence seems to loosely suggest that you're a plant, because those don't have heartbeats and do leak sweet flowery stuff if you poke holes in them. But I have no idea what that would even mean, because as far as I know, plants aren't the kinds of things that get up and walk around, or think or talk or come in people-like shapes."
On another level, it seems like obvious nonsense that she could be a plant.
But it's also obvious nonsense that she has no heartbeat and bleeds sugar water, and at least that nonsense and the plant nonsense fit together in an obvious way. The fact that it's a silly explanation doesn't mean it's not the best explanation.
So... until she comes up with a better one, Katie is apparently a plant.